My husband and I, along with two friends just returned from a 13 day ring road trip around the country of Iceland. Iceland is Stunning. I read this book front to back over the summer and then we brought it with us on our trip. It was a huge help, we basically planned our entire trip off this book and then used it while in Iceland to help narrow down where to eat and shop. It is well organized and easy to use. The maps in each section also were a great highlight and reference for quick checks while we were driving. We used lots of sticky notes to help map out our trip.
No travel book can be perfect, however, as a lot of the important sights can be opinion based. These were the few things I felt the book missed.
-Gjain: This place was barely mentioned in the book, it was a small paragraph noting it as a small oasis and Game of Thrones filming location. The only reason we stopped here was because it was within walking distance of Stöng (viking ruins). Gjain was gorgeous, it was unlike any of the other waterfall places we had been (and there are A LOT in Iceland) you can do a full 360 and have waterfalls in every view. It was also one of the most plant and tree heavy places we went (and we drove around the entire country).
-Driving: This was probably this biggest frustration I had with this book. I felt like I couldn't get clear answers on where I could and couldn't drive with a 4x4. Sometimes the book said it was required, other times the book said even a 4x4 couldn't get you there and you need to hire a guide (for the same location). I ended up having to read a couple blogs and travel question sites to get a clear answer on this. It also did not prepare us for the nasty roads into the West Fjords: Hair pin turns on gravel roads, steep grades, at one point it was a 16% incline & 15% decline, the roads are narrow and you may have to pull over for the local truck drivers, and it's all on cliffs with no guard rails. Not a fun surprise.
-Weather: There is very little information about the weather in Iceland. Part of this I am sure is because of how unpredictable and quick it is to change, but this book offers barely anything.
-Shops: Some of the places that are rated highly to visit, just ended up being a disappointment for us. My best example was in Akureyri. The book lists the Geysir souvenir shop as a highly rated spot to stop. We stopped in the city specifically for this, and were extremely disappointed. It was mostly a clothing store with an emphasis on leather and wool goods that were extremely expensive. There is also a larger store in Reykjavik, which should have been a comment. This also happened in Borgarnes with another shop for us as well. Expectation is the root of all disappointment I guess.
I will note that this book was written in 2014, and advertised for 2015, and we went in 2016. For most places this probably isn't that big of a deal, but Iceland's tourism is rapidly increasing and there for so are the accommodations for tourists. Some of the information was a little outdated.
What I did really like about the book is the historical or relevant information that was included with most sights, as well as resources and links to find more information.
The book did not lead us astray on the food places it recommended. It also listed some sights that were not really advertised that ended up being some of our favorite spots, Landmannalaugar being one of our treasures, the arctic fox center, and several of the geothermal pools.
Overall this book was worth every penny and I would highly recommend to anyone travelling to Iceland, with the disclaimer of doing some extra research on the side. Reading blogs of other travels was very helpful.