Stuart Olyott has, and continues, to be a huge influence to me, personally and in ministry. One of the most significant sermons I've ever heard was a gospel sermon he preached at very short notice from Romans 10, and also another mighty sermon that changed my whole perspective was on Acts 17, Paul in Athens. Both of those messages he preached at The Banner of Truth Minister's Conference years ago. Now, Iinvariably give 5 stars to his books. But I've given 4 stars to this commentary on Romans (Well, 3 stars initially but I think that was too strong). Why only 4 stars? He takes the view that 'Israel' in Romans 9-11 refers (bottom line) to the Church. In other words, that God has finished with ethnic Israel. Unfortunately, his position on this is very public, as I've known people who quote him on this. And we're in the strange position as evangelical Christians today in which the historic (and I'd say, Biblical) position is looked on as unorthodox, almost suspicious. And yet, the historic (and biblical) position of countless reformed evangelicals, has been that God's promises to ethnic Israel have not, and cannot, fail. God cannot revoke His promises to Israel. Indeed, I would have to engage in scriptural gymnastics to argue that 'Israel' in Romans 1v16-17, and chapters 9,10, and 11 is not referring to ethnic Israel. I feel I'm in good company, with the Puritans eg Oliver Cromwell, John Owen, etc, and McCheyne, the Bonars, Charles Simeon (notably), Charles Hodge, Prof. John Murray, DM Lloyd-Jones, RC Sproul, etc. The most challenging view on this came from William Hendriksen, but DM Lloyd-Jones utterly, and effectively, dismantles Hendriksen's interpretation biblically, in his sermons on Romans ch. 11 (Banner of Truth series ).
So, I very, very cautiously beg to differ with my enormously respected mentor Stuart Olyott on this point. But all of his books are up there at 5 stars for me. #respect