The Chasm by Bronwyn Hall
Synopsis /
Every town needs somewhere to hide their secrets. Andy King knew she should never return to Stonefield. Ten years ago, her boyfriend Will Hoffman disappeared without a trace and most people in the town thought she was to blame. But a decade is a long time to be homesick, and she isn't technically going back there. Only to Taplin, a small town in the neighbouring valley, far enough away from Stonefield she can stay under the radar, but close enough to the mountains that she can feel their pulse and breathe their special brand of oxygen. And it's only for four weeks, after all. But Andy didn't bargain on running into those who are still looking for Will, the ones who have the most to lose if he is ever found. Andy will go to her grave before she reveals what had happened back then, but when she realises that those same people have other secrets hidden in the mountains, it's clear she's once again in their way. And this time sending her to her grave is exactly their intention.
My Thoughts /
3.5 rounded up to 4 ⭐
I absolutely adored Hall's debut novel, Gone to Ground. A fast-paced novel with a military theme, full of suspense and danger, military tactics and drama, with just a 'smidge' of romance - all set deep in the jungle of the Democratic Republic of the Congo. I can remember it like yesterday.
To say I had high expectations going into her second novel, well, you wouldn't be wrong, and that's where it all fell apart.
The Chasm is a slooooow burn, so if you don't mind being trickle fed, then the pace of this novel won't be an issue. The first half seems to be dedicated to 'setting the scene'. Hall introduces us to Andy King. Andy works as a locum vet taking short term appointments to cover for things like annual leave, maternity leave, and illness. We meet Andy after she arrives to fill a locum position in Taplin - a small country town nestled in the Victorian mountains. Her duties are all fairly routine jobs for a country vet and included travelling out to properties to provide general veterinary services. One of the callouts was to Ethan Landers property - here Andy was tasked to check all their cows to determine if they were pregnant. And yes, Andy and Ethan become attracted to one another. But that's where the story became a little lost for me.
We learn that this is not Andy's first-time visiting Taplin. Andy grew up in the town of Stonefield, which is next door to Taplin, but she left over ten years ago under a cloud. Andy's best friend Will Hoffman had disappeared, believed murdered, and, despite there being no body or evidence to suggest this, rumour was that Andy, and her father were both involved.
Hall trickle feeds us clues and snippets about the disappearance while continuing with the thread in the present day. And it's here that I became confused as to whether this was a 'romance' novel or a 'mystery crime thriller'. It seemed to me that Hall was devoting equal time to both and for me, the romance element was an irritating distraction.
Despite this criticism, there were moments of ingenuity which reminded me of why I enjoyed Hall's previous novel. Most of the characters were endearing, the plot was plausible and easily read. I'm just not sure that the two stories were suited to the one book.
I finished reading this about nine days ago now and have been sitting on my thoughts before putting fingers to the keyboard.
My review will sit somewhere in outlier land, but that's okay; and I'm looking forward to what Hall will serve us up next.