What do you think?
Rate this book
Ellis Island #2
Annie's Stories
The year is 1901, the literary sensation The Wonderful Wizard of Oz is taking New York City by storm, and everyone wonders where the next great book will come from. But to Annie Gallagher, stories are more than entertainment—they’re a sweet reminder of her storyteller father. After his death, Annie fled Ireland for the land of dreams, finding work at Hawkins House.
But when a fellow boarder with something to hide is accused of misconduct and authorities threaten to shut down the boardinghouse, Annie fears she may lose her new friends, her housekeeping job . . . and her means of funding her dream: a memorial library to honor her father. Furthermore, the friendly postman shows a little too much interest in Annie—and in her father’s unpublished stories. In fact, he suspects these tales may hold a grand secret.
Though the postman’s intentions seem pure, Annie wants to share her father’s stories on her own terms. Determined to prove herself, Annie must forge her own path to aid her friend and create the future she’s always envisioned . . . where dreams really do come true.
But when a fellow boarder with something to hide is accused of misconduct and authorities threaten to shut down the boardinghouse, Annie fears she may lose her new friends, her housekeeping job . . . and her means of funding her dream: a memorial library to honor her father. Furthermore, the friendly postman shows a little too much interest in Annie—and in her father’s unpublished stories. In fact, he suspects these tales may hold a grand secret.
Though the postman’s intentions seem pure, Annie wants to share her father’s stories on her own terms. Determined to prove herself, Annie must forge her own path to aid her friend and create the future she’s always envisioned . . . where dreams really do come true.
417 pages, Kindle Edition
First published July 1, 2014
18 people are currently reading
808 people want to read
About the author
Cindy Thomson
22 books145 followersCindy Thomson is the author of both fiction and nonfiction, including her newest novel, Enya’s Son, third in the Daughters of Ireland series based on ancient legends. Being a genealogy enthusiast, she has also written articles for Internet Genealogy and Your Genealogy Today magazines, and children’s short stories for Clubhouse Magazine. She has also co-authored a baseball biography. Most everything she writes reflects her belief that history has stories to teach. Cindy and her husband live in central Ohio near their three grown sons and their families.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 76 reviews
June 20, 2014
Annie’s Stories is a perfect example why Cindy Thomson is such a talented writer. This is book two of the Ellis Island series. Right from the start, I could not stop turning the pages. Cindy captures how early nineteenth century New York City was with so many different cultures and immigrants. Of course, being of Irish descent, I enjoyed Annie being an Irish immigrant and learning more of the Irish culture. I loved how Grace from the first book of series, Grace’s Pictures makes many appearances. I loved catching up with her and still continue with her story, as well. I really thought using The Wonderful Wizard of Oz as a theme of the story to be quite interesting and refreshing. This book is rich in historical detail. Many of the details I did not know before. I, also, loved how there was an addition of mystery and suspense that kept me reading and not want to put it down. There are many twists and turns that I did not see coming.
Great Book! Well done, Cindy Thomson, you really have outdone yourself this time.
5 stars and up.
Great Book! Well done, Cindy Thomson, you really have outdone yourself this time.
5 stars and up.
August 20, 2014
About this book:
“The year is 1901, the literary sensation The Wonderful Wizard of Oz is taking New York City by storm, and everyone wonders where the next great book will come from. But to Annie Gallagher, stories are more than entertainment—they’re a sweet reminder of her storyteller father. After his death, Annie fled Ireland for the land of dreams, finding work at Hawkins House.
But when a fellow boarder with something to hide is accused of misconduct and authorities threaten to shut down the boardinghouse, Annie fears she may lose her new friends, her housekeeping job . . . and her means of funding her dream: a memorial library to honor her father. Furthermore, the friendly postman shows a little too much interest in Annie—and in her father’s unpublished stories. In fact, he suspects these tales may hold a grand secret.
Though the postman’s intentions seem pure, Annie wants to share her father’s stories on her own terms. Determined to prove herself, Annie must forge her own path to aid her friend and create the future she’s always envisioned . . . where dreams really do come true.”
Series: Book #2 in the “Ellis Island” series {You can see my review of book #1, “Grace’s Pictures”, Here!}
Spiritual Content- Annie thinks God can’t be bothered, that He abandoned her and that “If God was not with the president, then how could Annie ever expect he would protect her?” (*Spoiler* She becomes stronger her in Faith at the end. *End of Spoiler*); Father Weldon helped Annie a lot & talks about God to her; Stephen has a firm Faith; Church going; Many Scriptures & Psalms are quoted; A hymn is sung; a “for the love of St. Michael”; Many Talks about God.
Negative Content- Minor Cussing including: two ‘stupid’, two ‘idiot’s, two ‘what the devil’s, two ‘get a backbone’; Stephan calls his cowlick hair ‘cursed’; Suicide is mentioned (how the man did it, nothing else); Cigar smoking (not-detailed, not the main characters); Annie has nightmares/flashbacks of her time at Magdalene Laundry.
Sexual Content- A flashback to Annie at Magdalene Laundry and a boy kissing her & a doctor lingers while giving her a check-up (just how she felt, not-detailed/semi-detailed); A 2nd character tells Annie that she tempted a man, that he forced himself on her, violated her (she calls herself soiled) and *Spoiler* she has a miscarriage after all that. *End of Spoiler*; a hint about a girl who was raped (no detailed); Love & Falling in love.
-Annie Gallagher
-Stephen Adams
P.O.V. switches between them.
Set in 1901
382 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star (and a half)
Early High School Teens- Two Stars
Older High School Teens- Three Stars
My personal Rating- Three Stars
{Because of the Magdalene Laundry and what Annie went through there = lower ratings}
I really liked how “The Wonderful Wizard of Oz” played such a major role and how Annie really grew in her Faith. I also liked how both characters loved books. This quote made me crack up!
‘He was an average-looking, hard working fellow who was more comfortable reading about people in books than socializing with them.’
Link to review:
http://booksforchristiangirls.blogspo...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher (Tyndale House Publishers) for this review.
“The year is 1901, the literary sensation The Wonderful Wizard of Oz is taking New York City by storm, and everyone wonders where the next great book will come from. But to Annie Gallagher, stories are more than entertainment—they’re a sweet reminder of her storyteller father. After his death, Annie fled Ireland for the land of dreams, finding work at Hawkins House.
But when a fellow boarder with something to hide is accused of misconduct and authorities threaten to shut down the boardinghouse, Annie fears she may lose her new friends, her housekeeping job . . . and her means of funding her dream: a memorial library to honor her father. Furthermore, the friendly postman shows a little too much interest in Annie—and in her father’s unpublished stories. In fact, he suspects these tales may hold a grand secret.
Though the postman’s intentions seem pure, Annie wants to share her father’s stories on her own terms. Determined to prove herself, Annie must forge her own path to aid her friend and create the future she’s always envisioned . . . where dreams really do come true.”
Series: Book #2 in the “Ellis Island” series {You can see my review of book #1, “Grace’s Pictures”, Here!}
Spiritual Content- Annie thinks God can’t be bothered, that He abandoned her and that “If God was not with the president, then how could Annie ever expect he would protect her?” (*Spoiler* She becomes stronger her in Faith at the end. *End of Spoiler*); Father Weldon helped Annie a lot & talks about God to her; Stephen has a firm Faith; Church going; Many Scriptures & Psalms are quoted; A hymn is sung; a “for the love of St. Michael”; Many Talks about God.
Negative Content- Minor Cussing including: two ‘stupid’, two ‘idiot’s, two ‘what the devil’s, two ‘get a backbone’; Stephan calls his cowlick hair ‘cursed’; Suicide is mentioned (how the man did it, nothing else); Cigar smoking (not-detailed, not the main characters); Annie has nightmares/flashbacks of her time at Magdalene Laundry.
Sexual Content- A flashback to Annie at Magdalene Laundry and a boy kissing her & a doctor lingers while giving her a check-up (just how she felt, not-detailed/semi-detailed); A 2nd character tells Annie that she tempted a man, that he forced himself on her, violated her (she calls herself soiled) and *Spoiler* she has a miscarriage after all that. *End of Spoiler*; a hint about a girl who was raped (no detailed); Love & Falling in love.
-Annie Gallagher
-Stephen Adams
P.O.V. switches between them.
Set in 1901
382 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star (and a half)
Early High School Teens- Two Stars
Older High School Teens- Three Stars
My personal Rating- Three Stars
{Because of the Magdalene Laundry and what Annie went through there = lower ratings}
I really liked how “The Wonderful Wizard of Oz” played such a major role and how Annie really grew in her Faith. I also liked how both characters loved books. This quote made me crack up!
‘He was an average-looking, hard working fellow who was more comfortable reading about people in books than socializing with them.’
Link to review:
http://booksforchristiangirls.blogspo...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher (Tyndale House Publishers) for this review.
July 9, 2014
Seriously -- you say Irish and story in one sentence and I swoon so it was a shoe-in that I'd want to read this book. And, since I've read Thomson's first book, Grace's Pictures, I knew I was going to love this sequel. Be still my heart -- Irish storytelling and children's literature are at the heart of this intriguing read.
Thomson has done a marvellous job of portraying immigrant life in early twentieth century New York City. The good, the bad and the ugly. So many people bent on beginning a new life as they leave the past (and all its secrets) behind. Annie struggles to replace bitter memories with new ones, but unresolved issues keep sucking her back to a dark time. She grapples with trust and finds it hard to picture God in the midst of her tribulations. This is a story of redemption -- not only for Annie, but for other characters as well.
Like Stephen. An erstwhile hero if ever there was one. A heart of gold, but the impulses of an ox. :-) He wants to help everyone he sees and does so with reckless abandon that often leads to unexpected results, not all of them happy. I wanted to smack him upside the head at one particular point in the story. So like a man to want to act before asking. It's the whole Neanderthal must-fix-everything-so-woman-can-be-happy gene at work in an out of control way. Argh!
Needless to say there's heartache and sorrow within these pages but the thread of hope grows stronger as the story progresses. A truly amazing read.
My thanks to the publisher and Net Galley for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
Thomson has done a marvellous job of portraying immigrant life in early twentieth century New York City. The good, the bad and the ugly. So many people bent on beginning a new life as they leave the past (and all its secrets) behind. Annie struggles to replace bitter memories with new ones, but unresolved issues keep sucking her back to a dark time. She grapples with trust and finds it hard to picture God in the midst of her tribulations. This is a story of redemption -- not only for Annie, but for other characters as well.
Like Stephen. An erstwhile hero if ever there was one. A heart of gold, but the impulses of an ox. :-) He wants to help everyone he sees and does so with reckless abandon that often leads to unexpected results, not all of them happy. I wanted to smack him upside the head at one particular point in the story. So like a man to want to act before asking. It's the whole Neanderthal must-fix-everything-so-woman-can-be-happy gene at work in an out of control way. Argh!
Needless to say there's heartache and sorrow within these pages but the thread of hope grows stronger as the story progresses. A truly amazing read.
My thanks to the publisher and Net Galley for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
August 8, 2014
This book was just a wonder to me as I saw the thirst for books and the written word portrayed in such a unique way. It made me wish people were as hungry for good literature now. I often see a lot of hunger for fantasy and cheap literature instead. Int his book, you see how people longed for well written books, and it was this time period many of the classics we love and cherish still today were written.
There were several hard topics covered in this sweet story with a very light romantic bent to it. It addresses some of the abuse that young women suffered at the hands of people that believed they were following the Lord. Women were blamed for rape, forced kisses and other indignities, and locked away like they committed a crime. One young woman was locked away for marrying a man of the wrong religion.
Annie is somewhat damaged, she lost her father, her uncle had her locked away and stole from her and when she is making a new life in America, she is mistrustful and wary. The mystery that is skillfully woven throughout, involving immigrants, the Pinkerton’s, and the US Postal Service, I found especially fascinating.
While this book covers some hard topics, it is an easy read. It is not something that will depress you or be too much info for a mature teen. It will for sure give you some topics for discussion, that would be for sure!
This book was provided for me for review by NetGalley. The opinions contained herein are my own.
There were several hard topics covered in this sweet story with a very light romantic bent to it. It addresses some of the abuse that young women suffered at the hands of people that believed they were following the Lord. Women were blamed for rape, forced kisses and other indignities, and locked away like they committed a crime. One young woman was locked away for marrying a man of the wrong religion.
Annie is somewhat damaged, she lost her father, her uncle had her locked away and stole from her and when she is making a new life in America, she is mistrustful and wary. The mystery that is skillfully woven throughout, involving immigrants, the Pinkerton’s, and the US Postal Service, I found especially fascinating.
While this book covers some hard topics, it is an easy read. It is not something that will depress you or be too much info for a mature teen. It will for sure give you some topics for discussion, that would be for sure!
This book was provided for me for review by NetGalley. The opinions contained herein are my own.
August 4, 2016
My personal reading preference just did not care for this story. I found it quite boring; but it has really good ratings so this is just my opinion. I think all reviews can be helpful even negative ones. Mrs. Hawkins drove me batty calling every one "love." Stephen and Annie's reflective thoughts were very repetitive; we continuously read of their hardships over and over again. It was somewhat stale for me; just not enough going on. On the positive side I prefer my historical reads to be without all the love fanfare and this book was low romance and I liked that aspect. This was just not a keeper for me.
January 20, 2020
There are some interesting plot ideas in Annie's Stories. The romance is rather non-existent, however.
December 27, 2014
This was the second book that I read by Cindy Thomson, the first being Grace's Pictures, and I really enjoyed continuing the Ellis Island adventure! While I think that Grace's Pictures is my favorite of the two novels, I did enjoyed Annie's Stories and really enjoyed getting to meet Annie as well as see how Grace was doing after her story came to a temporary close in Grace's Pictures.
While there are many similarities between Grace's Pictures and Annie's Stories (book one and two in the Ellis Island series), they are both stand-alone novels that don't have to be read in order. While it's nice to know Grace's background from reading the first book, it's completely optional, and not necessary in order to enjoy Annie's Stories.
The Ellis Island novels focus on Irish immigrants who have recently traveled to Ellis Island in hopes of a better life, and Annie Gallagher is no exception. Following these young women's journey in this new land, it highlights their joys and trials experienced while living in a new place. In Annie's case, there is some "baggage" from her past in Ireland that she has to deal with and heal from, and seeing that journey unfold on the pages was very inspiring. As a woman who unjustly suffered abuse in her past, the healing process is very detailed and tedious, but when she meets a fellow boarder who is going through the same trials, she is able to offer an understanding hand brought up by experience, and is able to make a difference. While there is a bit of sensitive content in this portion of the book, I don't think it ever got inappropriate, and was handled well. However I did wish to mention it so readers are aware of this before diving into the story.
The Wizard of Oz, which was really becoming quite popular during this time that the story takes place, in the early 1900s, had a big role in this story as Annie read it and related with a lot of the themes. I always love books based on characters who also share a love for books, or those that have a thread of books themselves in the novel, and really felt like there was a lot of The Wizard of Oz in this novel, which I loved!
One of the things I love about this author is the writing style that often reminds me of Janette Oke in the simplicity of a slow romance that is very clean and doesn't clog up the story-line. The main story-line focuses on Annie's story in Ellis Island, so her budding romance with the mailman wasn't the main focus. That makes for a good book choice for those who don't like as much romance in their reading material, however on the flip side, it probably wouldn't be the first choice for those who like lots of romance and a suspenseful story. Unlike a lot of novels, this book focuses on Annie and her journey in a new land and her relationships with her friends, versus a romance. But the down side to this is the fact that often times I felt like this novel was slow, and while it never really bothered me all that much, it was still something I noticed. The story-line was very good and interesting but I felt like it was somewhat dragged out at times.
In all, I really enjoyed this heart-felt novel following one Irish immigrant's journey to healing. While sometimes a bit dragged out, it was still a very pleasant read, and is on my bookshelf of novels that I am definitely keeping despite space restrictions. Fans of Grace's Pictures should read this second installment in the Ellis Island novels!
D I S C L A I M E R :: I received a free copy of Annie's Stories through the publisher for the sole purpose of this review. I was not paid to write this review, and all thoughts expressed are my own, completely honest and unbiased.
While there are many similarities between Grace's Pictures and Annie's Stories (book one and two in the Ellis Island series), they are both stand-alone novels that don't have to be read in order. While it's nice to know Grace's background from reading the first book, it's completely optional, and not necessary in order to enjoy Annie's Stories.
The Ellis Island novels focus on Irish immigrants who have recently traveled to Ellis Island in hopes of a better life, and Annie Gallagher is no exception. Following these young women's journey in this new land, it highlights their joys and trials experienced while living in a new place. In Annie's case, there is some "baggage" from her past in Ireland that she has to deal with and heal from, and seeing that journey unfold on the pages was very inspiring. As a woman who unjustly suffered abuse in her past, the healing process is very detailed and tedious, but when she meets a fellow boarder who is going through the same trials, she is able to offer an understanding hand brought up by experience, and is able to make a difference. While there is a bit of sensitive content in this portion of the book, I don't think it ever got inappropriate, and was handled well. However I did wish to mention it so readers are aware of this before diving into the story.
The Wizard of Oz, which was really becoming quite popular during this time that the story takes place, in the early 1900s, had a big role in this story as Annie read it and related with a lot of the themes. I always love books based on characters who also share a love for books, or those that have a thread of books themselves in the novel, and really felt like there was a lot of The Wizard of Oz in this novel, which I loved!
One of the things I love about this author is the writing style that often reminds me of Janette Oke in the simplicity of a slow romance that is very clean and doesn't clog up the story-line. The main story-line focuses on Annie's story in Ellis Island, so her budding romance with the mailman wasn't the main focus. That makes for a good book choice for those who don't like as much romance in their reading material, however on the flip side, it probably wouldn't be the first choice for those who like lots of romance and a suspenseful story. Unlike a lot of novels, this book focuses on Annie and her journey in a new land and her relationships with her friends, versus a romance. But the down side to this is the fact that often times I felt like this novel was slow, and while it never really bothered me all that much, it was still something I noticed. The story-line was very good and interesting but I felt like it was somewhat dragged out at times.
In all, I really enjoyed this heart-felt novel following one Irish immigrant's journey to healing. While sometimes a bit dragged out, it was still a very pleasant read, and is on my bookshelf of novels that I am definitely keeping despite space restrictions. Fans of Grace's Pictures should read this second installment in the Ellis Island novels!
D I S C L A I M E R :: I received a free copy of Annie's Stories through the publisher for the sole purpose of this review. I was not paid to write this review, and all thoughts expressed are my own, completely honest and unbiased.
November 1, 2014
Annie Gallagher is a young Irish woman who immigrated to New York around the turn of the twentieth century. She leaves behind a volatile extended family situation and some traumatic experiences, but does manage to hold onto her beloved father's stash of children's stories. He was a hedge school master, who used to try to make a living traveling around, teaching under his own terms in the great outdoors for barter. Annie lives at a boarding house run by the loving Mrs Hawkins, who treats all the young women beneath her roof as if she's their mother.
Stephen Adams is the friendly postman, who has lost everything, including his family, but still tries to stay optimistic. He finds himself in a bind when his landlord, who is also a publisher and a bit of an opportunist, threatens to kick him out for his debt, unless Stephen can find a great children's manuscript for him to publish. Given the title of this book, it's not difficult to predict where the story is heading.
A great chunk of Annie's back story jams up the first few chapters, making me wonder if there's a prequel. It turns out there is (I haven't read it), but not necessarily the sort I would have expected. It's about Grace, one of the other girls who lives in the boarding house, and I don't know how much of Annie's story is revealed in it. I just finished wading through her back story, when another great block, this time her friend, Kirsten's, is introduced in the next chapter! It all made the movement grind off to a slow start, deferring the start of this novel's plot.
I never really got over this feeling of dragging, even though the premises of the story were so good. We have the backdrop of interesting, early 1900s America, and the sensation the publication of L. Frank Baum's 'The Wizard of Oz' was making. There's also Annie's dream of building a library to bless and cheer poor folk like herself. Maybe it's because the plot seemed to move like clockwork in several ways, with things falling into place, reminding me of a High School drama performance. I couldn't get over the feeling that an author was pulling the strings for these characters.
I did appreciate the evidence of Annie's wounds from her past, which she found hard to shake off. Post Traumatic Stress Disorder wouldn't have been named in 1901, but it was happening. Even though Annie had been rescued from the trauma of her past, she was still grappling with the memories of betrayal and dread feelings. I looked up Magdalene Laundry, and discovered that such a horrible place really existed under that name. How human, to be insecure and worried that something awful might happen again, even in new and cheerful surroundings.
Overall, though I wanted to love this book with its appealing blurb and cover, it wasn't really my cup of tea.
I received a copy from Net Galley and Tyndale House in return for an honest review.
Stephen Adams is the friendly postman, who has lost everything, including his family, but still tries to stay optimistic. He finds himself in a bind when his landlord, who is also a publisher and a bit of an opportunist, threatens to kick him out for his debt, unless Stephen can find a great children's manuscript for him to publish. Given the title of this book, it's not difficult to predict where the story is heading.
A great chunk of Annie's back story jams up the first few chapters, making me wonder if there's a prequel. It turns out there is (I haven't read it), but not necessarily the sort I would have expected. It's about Grace, one of the other girls who lives in the boarding house, and I don't know how much of Annie's story is revealed in it. I just finished wading through her back story, when another great block, this time her friend, Kirsten's, is introduced in the next chapter! It all made the movement grind off to a slow start, deferring the start of this novel's plot.
I never really got over this feeling of dragging, even though the premises of the story were so good. We have the backdrop of interesting, early 1900s America, and the sensation the publication of L. Frank Baum's 'The Wizard of Oz' was making. There's also Annie's dream of building a library to bless and cheer poor folk like herself. Maybe it's because the plot seemed to move like clockwork in several ways, with things falling into place, reminding me of a High School drama performance. I couldn't get over the feeling that an author was pulling the strings for these characters.
I did appreciate the evidence of Annie's wounds from her past, which she found hard to shake off. Post Traumatic Stress Disorder wouldn't have been named in 1901, but it was happening. Even though Annie had been rescued from the trauma of her past, she was still grappling with the memories of betrayal and dread feelings. I looked up Magdalene Laundry, and discovered that such a horrible place really existed under that name. How human, to be insecure and worried that something awful might happen again, even in new and cheerful surroundings.
Overall, though I wanted to love this book with its appealing blurb and cover, it wasn't really my cup of tea.
I received a copy from Net Galley and Tyndale House in return for an honest review.
June 13, 2014
I enjoy stories written by Cindy Thomson. I loved Grace's Pictures. And Annie's Stories is in somewhat.of.the.same. venue but yet, it's its own story.
Annie must find work. She finds a rather good job in the housekeeping area at a boarding house, Hawkins House. But when one of the tenants is accused of wrong doing and the authorities threaten to shut the House down Annie knows she may have to find another job. Not an easy task. Then there's the "over friendly" postman who show way to much interest in Annie. Annie knows her father's unpublished stories may hold a secret...does the postman know? Are some secrets worth holding onto? And is her father's secret worth enough to hold onto. Annie only knows this is her way to make a tribute to her father.
Annie only knows that she must help her friend who is accused of wrongdoing. Stories that have a moral and a christian theme that show integrity and kindness are few and far between...that's why this is such a great read! Loved this great story! Mystery and history . . . what a way to spend a summer afternoon reading about lives of past ages! A great read for mystery and history fans!
*(This review is based upon a copy of this book which was provided free of charge from Tyndale House Publishers. These opinions are my own; I was not required to write a positive review, nor was I compensated for this review.)*
October 15, 2014
What a wonderful story! This book is proceeded by Grace’s Pictures but stands alone as well. It has mystery, romance and history all in one book. I loved the characters and how real they seemed! At one point Mrs. Hawkins, aka The Hawk, says, “Some people think Shakespeare is just for the university types, but just because a woman hasn’t been to university doesn’t mean she can't read, love.”
Annie is a new immigrant to the United States and has been hired as housekeeper at a boarding house. Mrs. Hawkins, the owner, treats her as a daughter. But will the Pinkerton detectives shut the house down for the supposed illicit activities of one of the boarders? And what secret is Mrs. Hawkins keeping? Annie’s stories are the stories her dead dad has left her and pose quite a problem for Annie – should she seek to get them published or keep them for herself? After all, with the publishing of The Wizard of Oz, which everyone seems to be reading, there is a demand for children’s stories. But Annie is not the only one with a dilemma – Andrew, the mailman, does not seem to ever be able to pay his debts and ends up in a bad situation, making very poor financial decisions. But both learn to listen to God’s still voice and learn from their mistakes. It was also very enlightening to learn about times that morality seemed so very high, yet so many abuses occurred by people who ought to be trusted, with the truth then kept very quiet. Very good book and I really enjoyed it. I received this book from TBCN in return for my honest opinion.
Annie is a new immigrant to the United States and has been hired as housekeeper at a boarding house. Mrs. Hawkins, the owner, treats her as a daughter. But will the Pinkerton detectives shut the house down for the supposed illicit activities of one of the boarders? And what secret is Mrs. Hawkins keeping? Annie’s stories are the stories her dead dad has left her and pose quite a problem for Annie – should she seek to get them published or keep them for herself? After all, with the publishing of The Wizard of Oz, which everyone seems to be reading, there is a demand for children’s stories. But Annie is not the only one with a dilemma – Andrew, the mailman, does not seem to ever be able to pay his debts and ends up in a bad situation, making very poor financial decisions. But both learn to listen to God’s still voice and learn from their mistakes. It was also very enlightening to learn about times that morality seemed so very high, yet so many abuses occurred by people who ought to be trusted, with the truth then kept very quiet. Very good book and I really enjoyed it. I received this book from TBCN in return for my honest opinion.
July 19, 2016
http://pagebypagebookbybook.blogspot....
Cindy Thomson writes excellent historical fiction. The second in her Ellis Island series (preceded by Grace’s Pictures), Annie’s Stories once again ventures into New York City life at the turn of the century, and at every point within the story, I felt immersed in the cultural and social reality of the day. Thomson touches on many prominent historical aspects and their effects – some with which I was previously unfamiliar – including Magdalene Laundries, Ellis Island inspections, the assassination of President McKinley, the Post Office Department. I especially enjoyed the prominence of The Wonderful Wizard of Oz throughout the storyline, as Thomson uses its plot points to reflect character growth and development. I had not realized what a cultural phenomenon this book was when first published, but I feel like I need to go read it now.
Overall, Annie’s Stories is a sweet story with flawed but lovable characters and bits of romance, mystery and drama. I recommend it for fans of historical fiction. (It is not necessary to first read Grace’s Pictures. Both novels are able to be read on their own.) It’s an entertaining and enlightening read, and I can’t wait to read more from Cindy Thomson. I thank Tyndale BlogNetwork for providing me with a complimentary copy of this novel in exchange for my honest review.
Cindy Thomson writes excellent historical fiction. The second in her Ellis Island series (preceded by Grace’s Pictures), Annie’s Stories once again ventures into New York City life at the turn of the century, and at every point within the story, I felt immersed in the cultural and social reality of the day. Thomson touches on many prominent historical aspects and their effects – some with which I was previously unfamiliar – including Magdalene Laundries, Ellis Island inspections, the assassination of President McKinley, the Post Office Department. I especially enjoyed the prominence of The Wonderful Wizard of Oz throughout the storyline, as Thomson uses its plot points to reflect character growth and development. I had not realized what a cultural phenomenon this book was when first published, but I feel like I need to go read it now.
Overall, Annie’s Stories is a sweet story with flawed but lovable characters and bits of romance, mystery and drama. I recommend it for fans of historical fiction. (It is not necessary to first read Grace’s Pictures. Both novels are able to be read on their own.) It’s an entertaining and enlightening read, and I can’t wait to read more from Cindy Thomson. I thank Tyndale BlogNetwork for providing me with a complimentary copy of this novel in exchange for my honest review.
July 24, 2014
I won this book on goodreads.
Annie's Father has died and she moved to
America from Ireland. Annie lives at Mrs. Hawkins home
as a housekeeper, lives with Grace and Kirsten and Aileen her cousin.
Mr. Adams is the postal worker who delivers mail and has a tragic past.
This book is a historical Christian with mild romance.
It was pretty good a little slow at points but not bad.
I enjoyed the book and the ending.
Thanks for the opportunity.
Annie's Father has died and she moved to
America from Ireland. Annie lives at Mrs. Hawkins home
as a housekeeper, lives with Grace and Kirsten and Aileen her cousin.
Mr. Adams is the postal worker who delivers mail and has a tragic past.
This book is a historical Christian with mild romance.
It was pretty good a little slow at points but not bad.
I enjoyed the book and the ending.
Thanks for the opportunity.
July 1, 2017
What a wonderful story this was! The characters were positively delightful! And the dialogue was beautiful. The women were ladies and the men were gentlemen. There is Scripture quoted throughout the story, so it is told from a Christian perspective.
I would highly recommend this book. I enjoyed it immensely.
I received an e-copy of this book from Net Galley in exchange for an honest review.
I would highly recommend this book. I enjoyed it immensely.
I received an e-copy of this book from Net Galley in exchange for an honest review.
April 18, 2015
Really enjoyed this book. I loved that she referenced books that were current at the time the story takes place. The characters were interesting and I loved that Annie had dreams of owning her own library.
March 15, 2023
I love reading and stories and writing and I usually really enjoy books about reading. Annie's father is a story teller and after his death, Annie leaves Ireland for America. She has her father's stories, and wants to honor him with a library. She meets Stephen, a young postman who lives above a publisher. He reads one of her father's stories and gives it to the publisher without Annie's knowledge.
The life of these early immigrants was difficult and often horrifying. There were many plot points and characterizations and the novel gives a terrific glimpse of life in early 20th century New York. I liked Annie, I found myself frustrated with Stephen. But the story is compelling and the literary aspect is delightful.
Second in the Ellis Island series, I haven't read the others and the story stood alone just fine.
The life of these early immigrants was difficult and often horrifying. There were many plot points and characterizations and the novel gives a terrific glimpse of life in early 20th century New York. I liked Annie, I found myself frustrated with Stephen. But the story is compelling and the literary aspect is delightful.
Second in the Ellis Island series, I haven't read the others and the story stood alone just fine.
February 13, 2018
Annie's Stories is a fun little story from the turn of the century. Since it takes place in New York City and focuses on an Irish immigrant, it reminded me of Brooklyn. But it has it's own unique style. I really enjoyed the tie in with The Wonderful Wizard of Oz, showing the response of readers when it first came out. I look forward to reading the other books in the series.
August 12, 2017
A sweet novel set in 1900 NYC, based around new Irish Immigrant Annie Gallagher, who has arrived in America after the death of her father. Annie wants to put her traumatic past behind her, but she's not sure if she can do it, alone and in a new country.
October 19, 2021
The hidden Story
Wow! What a book! If you like a story with lots of twists and turns, read this one! I think both Annie and Stephen learned lessons that we need to keep in mind today. Very well done!
Wow! What a book! If you like a story with lots of twists and turns, read this one! I think both Annie and Stephen learned lessons that we need to keep in mind today. Very well done!
July 9, 2023
An excellent book. I wish there were more Ellis Island novels to read, whether Irish immigrants or assorted nationalities.
Learning about the hardships and difficulties to be overcome is fascinating, even with all the help Annie had.
Everyone has a story, many are intriguing.
Learning about the hardships and difficulties to be overcome is fascinating, even with all the help Annie had.
Everyone has a story, many are intriguing.
April 12, 2018
Very interesting story. From family history to life adventures, this story takes the reader on a journey of turmoil, devotion, love, faith and courage. Great read.
June 27, 2023
Great story with very likable characters.
April 14, 2024
will have to look for more by this author
March 12, 2017
A Visit With My Ancestors
The introduction to Annie, Mrs. Hawkins and the other Irish ladies was like riding through the serene tunnel of a roller coaster and being lulled in by the gentle banter among them. Then the climb up each step of the storyline that would soon plunge into a free fall of loops and twists you could not have seen coming. And what a fun and exhilarating ride it was. As a McCall, I now know more about my Irish heritage and truly want to learn even more. The magical story of Annie's beloved father's stories was masterfully woven in with the lessons of one of the great classics. I look forward to backing up a little to the first book in the Ellis Island series. Highly recommended reading, regardless of your family history.
The introduction to Annie, Mrs. Hawkins and the other Irish ladies was like riding through the serene tunnel of a roller coaster and being lulled in by the gentle banter among them. Then the climb up each step of the storyline that would soon plunge into a free fall of loops and twists you could not have seen coming. And what a fun and exhilarating ride it was. As a McCall, I now know more about my Irish heritage and truly want to learn even more. The magical story of Annie's beloved father's stories was masterfully woven in with the lessons of one of the great classics. I look forward to backing up a little to the first book in the Ellis Island series. Highly recommended reading, regardless of your family history.
August 26, 2014
Annie's Stories
is a tale of young lives struggling to overcome tragic pasts in a young Manhattan neighborhood. For Annie, who emigrated from Ireland four years ago, literally rescued by a warm-hearted British priest from cruel incarceration in what is historically known as the Magdalene Laundries, a reformatory type system that took in unwanted scraps of human life, forcing them into labor all in the name of charity, there was trauma and loss to overcome. Right after her father's funeral, her heartless uncle spurred on by the false accusations of wrongdoing by her young cousin Aileen, sent her away to endless labor at one of those infamous laundries. Fortunately, she was now safely ensconced in the priest's sister's loving care in New York. Annie's one great joy in life was being in possession of a writing desk fill with pages of stories written down for her by her beloved "da"--stories he made up especially for her. He called them Annie's stories.
For Stephen, his difficult past included his father's abandonment of his wife and sons when life got too difficult. In a fit of despair, the man had hung himself, leaving family members to fend for themselves. Stephen's mother died of cancer and his brother passed away after a tragic construction accident. Stephen was left with the bills to pay for all those funerals and now the undertaker was threatening him. While he had a great job as a walking route mailman, the rent took most of his paychecks. But he fought against despair because he didn't want to become like his father. He had his faith in God's love and care, and he prayed when things became overwhelming.
The author intertwines some fascinating history from the world of the early 1900's into the fabric of this story. Not only are Annie's flashbacks of her time in the Magdalene Laundry based on true stories told by survivors of the institutions, she included the event of President McKinley's assassination, tidbits of intrigue about the early postal system and its investigations into mail fraud, early financial scams perpetrated on innocent citizens, especially upon immigrants who had come to America expecting to amass wealth for themselves, and the role of the Pinkerton detective agency in tracking down criminals of all kinds. In those early days, some agents abused their authority to get information through intimidation.
Another element I liked in this book was the use of the book The Wonderful Wizard of Oz by Frank Baum as a metaphor. The book had just been published in the time frame of this story and had taken the world by storm. Everyone was talking about the story of Dorothy Gale. Dorothy's search for a way home seems parallel to Annie's journey in life for meaning and love. Annie was trying to gain her footing in her new country, seeking purpose, to belong.
Annie and Stephen's personal struggles fleshed out the characters and drew me to them effectively. However, I had difficulty with Stephen's character. His bumbling was adorable and his intentions were honorable, and he did catch himself when he stepped over the line and tried to make decisions for Annie before she was ready for him to do that, but for some reason he didn't resonate with me. I wanted to be in his corner rooting for him to make the relationship with Annie work, but I couldn't get enthused over their future. I think I would have liked to have seen the two together more often, working out the dynamics together. Instead, the book focused on their separate issues, and only brought them together at the very end.
It is still a lovely story; the history and intrigue were great additions to the plot. I would recommend this to someone who enjoys historical fiction with a light touch of romance.
I am reading and reviewing this book for the Tyndale House Publishers, Inc. summer reading program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
For Stephen, his difficult past included his father's abandonment of his wife and sons when life got too difficult. In a fit of despair, the man had hung himself, leaving family members to fend for themselves. Stephen's mother died of cancer and his brother passed away after a tragic construction accident. Stephen was left with the bills to pay for all those funerals and now the undertaker was threatening him. While he had a great job as a walking route mailman, the rent took most of his paychecks. But he fought against despair because he didn't want to become like his father. He had his faith in God's love and care, and he prayed when things became overwhelming.
The author intertwines some fascinating history from the world of the early 1900's into the fabric of this story. Not only are Annie's flashbacks of her time in the Magdalene Laundry based on true stories told by survivors of the institutions, she included the event of President McKinley's assassination, tidbits of intrigue about the early postal system and its investigations into mail fraud, early financial scams perpetrated on innocent citizens, especially upon immigrants who had come to America expecting to amass wealth for themselves, and the role of the Pinkerton detective agency in tracking down criminals of all kinds. In those early days, some agents abused their authority to get information through intimidation.
Another element I liked in this book was the use of the book The Wonderful Wizard of Oz by Frank Baum as a metaphor. The book had just been published in the time frame of this story and had taken the world by storm. Everyone was talking about the story of Dorothy Gale. Dorothy's search for a way home seems parallel to Annie's journey in life for meaning and love. Annie was trying to gain her footing in her new country, seeking purpose, to belong.
Annie and Stephen's personal struggles fleshed out the characters and drew me to them effectively. However, I had difficulty with Stephen's character. His bumbling was adorable and his intentions were honorable, and he did catch himself when he stepped over the line and tried to make decisions for Annie before she was ready for him to do that, but for some reason he didn't resonate with me. I wanted to be in his corner rooting for him to make the relationship with Annie work, but I couldn't get enthused over their future. I think I would have liked to have seen the two together more often, working out the dynamics together. Instead, the book focused on their separate issues, and only brought them together at the very end.
It is still a lovely story; the history and intrigue were great additions to the plot. I would recommend this to someone who enjoys historical fiction with a light touch of romance.
I am reading and reviewing this book for the Tyndale House Publishers, Inc. summer reading program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
June 29, 2014
Saturday, June 28, 2014
Annie's Stories by Cindy Thomson, © 2014 ~*an Ellis Island novel*~
Stand at the crossroads and look; ask for the ancient paths, ask where the good way is, and walk in it, and you will find rest for your souls.~Jeremiah 6:16 NIV
Annie's Stories by Cindy Thomson is a thoughtfully written story of needs all generations have ~ to be accepted and protected, to be loved and cherished, and to find our way home.
And I will give thee the treasures of darkness, and hidden riches of secret places, that thou mayest know that I, the LORD, which call thee by thy name, am the God of Israel.
--Isaiah 45:3 KJV
Annie Gallagher has been rescued from a life of bondage and sent to America from Ireland, coming through Ellis Island. She becomes a housekeeper at Hawkins House, a boardinghouse for women in Lower Manhattan. Along with her memories, Annie brings handwritten tales her father wrote out for her when he was ill before passing, of the stories he told her as a little girl.
One of my favorite characters throughout was the postman, Stephen Adams. He has a good heart and is kind to the families on his mail route. One thing that surprised me was the post office was more like a messenger transit service, delivering mail more than once a day should parcels or letters come later in the day, rather than collecting and delivering it the next day. When Stephen would come to the Hawkins House, he especially hoped Annie Gallagher would answer his ring at the door. He is unsure of his acceptances by young lasses and it is comical to find what his approach is. He finds out Annie does like his neighbor's sugary dough delights he brings to her. Hoping to find Annie at the Irish dances, he instead comes away with Irish tunes he whistles as he approaches the boardinghouse.
Annie Gallagher longs for the days of storytelling by her da. Independent, to take care of herself, she wants to share these stories with other girls and boys. She is dismayed when she finds Stephen is interested too ~ in her, or solely in her da's stories? Guarded, Annie puts a line around her heart, as she determines direction she is to take in having her da's stories published for reading by others. Stephen lives above a publishing office, which doesn't help matters of the heart to distinguish Stephen's intent in a finder's fee or caring for her protection in their printings.
Interesting as you read Annie's Stories, you may pick up on characteristics of Mr. Baum's Oz roles within; Dorothy, Tin Woodman, the Scarecrow, and the Lion. Leaving oppression behind and realizing forgiveness; being released from bondage frees enabling the present and future to be lived beyond the past circumstances in life that no longer then can have a hold against God's intention for us.
As mysteries unfold for a new boarder and a parcel she receives, Stephen tries to track it down since it involves the United States Post Office Department and his mail route deliveries to the Lower Manhattan neighborhood. The Hawkins House has many visitors intent on discovering the whereabouts of the package too.
I liked how everyone in the house worked together despite their differences. They come to rely on each other and respect and trust develops. I am looking forward to the next novel by Cindy Thomson.
***Thank you to author Cindy Thomson for inviting me to be a part of the release team for her novel Annie's Stories, and for having the review print copy of Annie's Stories sent to me from Tyndale House. Book 2 in her Ellis Island novels, following Grace's Pictures, I am fond of these especially because my ancestors came through Ellis Island. Come along as these immigrants settle in America in her stories, visiting some of the characters from Book 1. This review was written in my own words. No other compensation was received.***
No matter how dreary and gray our homes are, we people
of flesh and blood would rather live there than in any other
country, be it ever so beautiful. There is no place like home.
L. FRANK BAUM, THE WONDERFUL WIZARD OF OZ
Annie's Stories by Cindy Thomson, © 2014 ~*an Ellis Island novel*~
Stand at the crossroads and look; ask for the ancient paths, ask where the good way is, and walk in it, and you will find rest for your souls.~Jeremiah 6:16 NIV
Annie's Stories by Cindy Thomson is a thoughtfully written story of needs all generations have ~ to be accepted and protected, to be loved and cherished, and to find our way home.
And I will give thee the treasures of darkness, and hidden riches of secret places, that thou mayest know that I, the LORD, which call thee by thy name, am the God of Israel.
--Isaiah 45:3 KJV
Annie Gallagher has been rescued from a life of bondage and sent to America from Ireland, coming through Ellis Island. She becomes a housekeeper at Hawkins House, a boardinghouse for women in Lower Manhattan. Along with her memories, Annie brings handwritten tales her father wrote out for her when he was ill before passing, of the stories he told her as a little girl.
One of my favorite characters throughout was the postman, Stephen Adams. He has a good heart and is kind to the families on his mail route. One thing that surprised me was the post office was more like a messenger transit service, delivering mail more than once a day should parcels or letters come later in the day, rather than collecting and delivering it the next day. When Stephen would come to the Hawkins House, he especially hoped Annie Gallagher would answer his ring at the door. He is unsure of his acceptances by young lasses and it is comical to find what his approach is. He finds out Annie does like his neighbor's sugary dough delights he brings to her. Hoping to find Annie at the Irish dances, he instead comes away with Irish tunes he whistles as he approaches the boardinghouse.
Annie Gallagher longs for the days of storytelling by her da. Independent, to take care of herself, she wants to share these stories with other girls and boys. She is dismayed when she finds Stephen is interested too ~ in her, or solely in her da's stories? Guarded, Annie puts a line around her heart, as she determines direction she is to take in having her da's stories published for reading by others. Stephen lives above a publishing office, which doesn't help matters of the heart to distinguish Stephen's intent in a finder's fee or caring for her protection in their printings.
Interesting as you read Annie's Stories, you may pick up on characteristics of Mr. Baum's Oz roles within; Dorothy, Tin Woodman, the Scarecrow, and the Lion. Leaving oppression behind and realizing forgiveness; being released from bondage frees enabling the present and future to be lived beyond the past circumstances in life that no longer then can have a hold against God's intention for us.
As mysteries unfold for a new boarder and a parcel she receives, Stephen tries to track it down since it involves the United States Post Office Department and his mail route deliveries to the Lower Manhattan neighborhood. The Hawkins House has many visitors intent on discovering the whereabouts of the package too.
I liked how everyone in the house worked together despite their differences. They come to rely on each other and respect and trust develops. I am looking forward to the next novel by Cindy Thomson.
***Thank you to author Cindy Thomson for inviting me to be a part of the release team for her novel Annie's Stories, and for having the review print copy of Annie's Stories sent to me from Tyndale House. Book 2 in her Ellis Island novels, following Grace's Pictures, I am fond of these especially because my ancestors came through Ellis Island. Come along as these immigrants settle in America in her stories, visiting some of the characters from Book 1. This review was written in my own words. No other compensation was received.***
No matter how dreary and gray our homes are, we people
of flesh and blood would rather live there than in any other
country, be it ever so beautiful. There is no place like home.
L. FRANK BAUM, THE WONDERFUL WIZARD OF OZ
October 2, 2014
When I first saw the cover of this book, for whatever reason, Anne of Green Gables came to mind. Then I looked closer and noticed that the girl on the cover is reading The Wizard of Oz. While I’ve never read the book, I’ve been enchanted with the movie. These two things together made me pick up the book. As I started reading, some of the characters felt familiar–like old friends. I soon realized that this is a sequel in a series. The first being a novel called Grace’s Pictures. I remembered reading that one, and I really enjoyed it. I’m always pleased when I find a book that is a sequel to one I already enjoyed or an author I loved reading.
Annie’s Stories is a novel that explores how we find home.
From Amazon:
The year is 1901, the literary sensation The Wonderful Wizard of Oz is taking New York City by storm, and everyone wonders where the next great book will come from. But to Annie Gallagher, stories are more than entertainment—they’re a sweet reminder of her storyteller father. After his death, Annie fled Ireland for the land of dreams, finding work at Hawkins House.
But when a fellow boarder with something to hide is accused of misconduct and authorities threaten to shut down the boardinghouse, Annie fears she may lose her new friends, her housekeeping job . . . and her means of funding her dream: a memorial library to honor her father. Furthermore, the friendly postman shows a little too much interest in Annie—and in her father’s unpublished stories. In fact, he suspects these tales may hold a grand secret.
Though the postman’s intentions seem pure, Annie wants to share her father’s stories on her own terms. Determined to prove herself, Annie must forge her own path to aid her friend and create the future she’s always envisioned . . . where dreams really do come true.
While the book felt a bit slow at times, and I got frustrated with characters, I did really enjoy this book. The message of the book is encouraging. So many times, what people, especially our loved ones, do can have such strong repercussions. Both the main characters have to come to terms with things their respective fathers had done. Both are haunted by something in their pasts that they need to come to grips with.
Thomson does a wonderful job of dropping hints about the story from early on. The reader won’t even notice until it becomes relevant. Her use of the Wizard of Oz and home is a wonderful metaphor for this whole story.
One of the enjoyable aspects of historical fiction is getting a look into a snapshot of history. For me, the excitement surrounding The Wizard of Oz was a strong appeal in this novel. Living in a culture so inundated with L. Frank Baum’s classic, it is easy to overlook the magic of the story. But it did have an impact on literature, especially children’s stories. Seeing the character’s enjoy this popular story for the first time was wonderful (I even enjoyed reading the snippets of it that Thomson placed in her novel- I have to admit I have not read The Wizard of Oz).
If you read and enjoyed Grace’s Pictures, then I am sure you will enjoy this book as well. Especially since the story of Grace and Owen is continued (in the background of course). If you haven’t read it, don’t worry- this book can be read as a stand-alone novel.
**I received a free copy of this book from Tyndale Publishing and NetGalley in exchange for my honest review**
Annie’s Stories is a novel that explores how we find home.
From Amazon:
The year is 1901, the literary sensation The Wonderful Wizard of Oz is taking New York City by storm, and everyone wonders where the next great book will come from. But to Annie Gallagher, stories are more than entertainment—they’re a sweet reminder of her storyteller father. After his death, Annie fled Ireland for the land of dreams, finding work at Hawkins House.
But when a fellow boarder with something to hide is accused of misconduct and authorities threaten to shut down the boardinghouse, Annie fears she may lose her new friends, her housekeeping job . . . and her means of funding her dream: a memorial library to honor her father. Furthermore, the friendly postman shows a little too much interest in Annie—and in her father’s unpublished stories. In fact, he suspects these tales may hold a grand secret.
Though the postman’s intentions seem pure, Annie wants to share her father’s stories on her own terms. Determined to prove herself, Annie must forge her own path to aid her friend and create the future she’s always envisioned . . . where dreams really do come true.
While the book felt a bit slow at times, and I got frustrated with characters, I did really enjoy this book. The message of the book is encouraging. So many times, what people, especially our loved ones, do can have such strong repercussions. Both the main characters have to come to terms with things their respective fathers had done. Both are haunted by something in their pasts that they need to come to grips with.
Thomson does a wonderful job of dropping hints about the story from early on. The reader won’t even notice until it becomes relevant. Her use of the Wizard of Oz and home is a wonderful metaphor for this whole story.
One of the enjoyable aspects of historical fiction is getting a look into a snapshot of history. For me, the excitement surrounding The Wizard of Oz was a strong appeal in this novel. Living in a culture so inundated with L. Frank Baum’s classic, it is easy to overlook the magic of the story. But it did have an impact on literature, especially children’s stories. Seeing the character’s enjoy this popular story for the first time was wonderful (I even enjoyed reading the snippets of it that Thomson placed in her novel- I have to admit I have not read The Wizard of Oz).
If you read and enjoyed Grace’s Pictures, then I am sure you will enjoy this book as well. Especially since the story of Grace and Owen is continued (in the background of course). If you haven’t read it, don’t worry- this book can be read as a stand-alone novel.
**I received a free copy of this book from Tyndale Publishing and NetGalley in exchange for my honest review**
July 1, 2014
Cindy Thomson's Ellis Island series began with Grace's Pictures, about a young Irish immigrant who comes to New York City at the turn of the 20th century. She finds work as a nanny for a family and a room at a boarding house run by a kind Christian woman, and becomes enthralled by photography.
The second book in the series is Annie's Stories, about another young Irish immigrant who lives in the same boarding house. Annie is the housekeeper at Mrs. Hawkins' boarding house. She was raised by her father, a storyteller called a seanchaithe, in Ireland. When her father died and Annie went to live with her an uncle, who treated her poorly.
Her uncle shipped her off to the Magdalene Laundries, a horrible place for girls who are abandoned by their families. Many of the girls were pregnant and gave birth to babies there. (The Magdalene Laundries have been in the news over the last year, and the Oscar-nominated movie Philomena dealt with this issue as well.)
Eventually Annie was sent to New York to live. Annie's father left her with a small writing desk, filled with children's stories he created for Annie. She treasured these stories, and reading them gave her great comfort.
The local postman, Stephen, has a crush on Annie, but he hasn't worked up the courage to tell her. They both enjoy reading, and Stephen suggests that they read the hottest book in publishing, The Wizard of Oz, so that they could discuss it together.
As someone who loves to read, I really enjoyed the role that books and the publishing industry played in the story. Stephen lives above a publisher's offices, and we get to glimpse how publishing worked in the early 1900s.
Thomson does a great deal of research for her books, and because of that, the reader feels dropped right into the middle of this fascinating era in New York City. There is a subplot that involves the Pinkerton Detectives and another boarder, and the steely resolve that Mrs. Hawkins shows in dealing with an unpleasant situation is impressive.
Annie's faith is a very important part of her life, and it informs everything she does. Mrs. Hawkins is a deeply religious woman as well, and their strength of faith is inspirational to readers.
I so enjoyed catching up with Grace as they all prepare for her wedding to Sgt. McNulty, a policeman. Perhaps we might see another wedding in a future Ellis Island book?
Anyone who wants to add to their reading list will have some new suggestions too, from Jules Verne's Facing the Flag to H.G. Wells First Man on the Moon and of course, Frank L. Baum's The Wizard of Oz, which plays such a big role.
If you enjoy historical fiction and Christian fiction, Annie's Stories is a must-read for you. I felt like I was catching up with old friends, and made some new ones that I hope to meet up with again the near future.
The second book in the series is Annie's Stories, about another young Irish immigrant who lives in the same boarding house. Annie is the housekeeper at Mrs. Hawkins' boarding house. She was raised by her father, a storyteller called a seanchaithe, in Ireland. When her father died and Annie went to live with her an uncle, who treated her poorly.
Her uncle shipped her off to the Magdalene Laundries, a horrible place for girls who are abandoned by their families. Many of the girls were pregnant and gave birth to babies there. (The Magdalene Laundries have been in the news over the last year, and the Oscar-nominated movie Philomena dealt with this issue as well.)
Eventually Annie was sent to New York to live. Annie's father left her with a small writing desk, filled with children's stories he created for Annie. She treasured these stories, and reading them gave her great comfort.
The local postman, Stephen, has a crush on Annie, but he hasn't worked up the courage to tell her. They both enjoy reading, and Stephen suggests that they read the hottest book in publishing, The Wizard of Oz, so that they could discuss it together.
As someone who loves to read, I really enjoyed the role that books and the publishing industry played in the story. Stephen lives above a publisher's offices, and we get to glimpse how publishing worked in the early 1900s.
Thomson does a great deal of research for her books, and because of that, the reader feels dropped right into the middle of this fascinating era in New York City. There is a subplot that involves the Pinkerton Detectives and another boarder, and the steely resolve that Mrs. Hawkins shows in dealing with an unpleasant situation is impressive.
Annie's faith is a very important part of her life, and it informs everything she does. Mrs. Hawkins is a deeply religious woman as well, and their strength of faith is inspirational to readers.
I so enjoyed catching up with Grace as they all prepare for her wedding to Sgt. McNulty, a policeman. Perhaps we might see another wedding in a future Ellis Island book?
Anyone who wants to add to their reading list will have some new suggestions too, from Jules Verne's Facing the Flag to H.G. Wells First Man on the Moon and of course, Frank L. Baum's The Wizard of Oz, which plays such a big role.
If you enjoy historical fiction and Christian fiction, Annie's Stories is a must-read for you. I felt like I was catching up with old friends, and made some new ones that I hope to meet up with again the near future.
August 17, 2014
Dreams of a Better Life
This is the second book in the Ellis Island collection by Cindy Thomson. It can be read as a stand-alone novel. Set in New York during the early 1900's, the book tells the story of Annie Gallagher, an Irish immigrant who has come to America to begin a new life.
Annie has terrible memories of her life in Ireland. All was well in her life until her father died. After his death, Annie lived with an uncle who sent her to the Magdalene Laundry, a horrible prison-like institution for unwanted girls. The primary reason she was sent away was because her cousin made false accusations against her. When Annie is finally rescued from the laundry, she arrives in America with only her father's writing desk and the treasured stories he wrote during his lifetime. Annie feels alone and abandoned by God.
Annie moves to a boardinghouse run by Mrs. Hawkins. She is a kind woman and treats Annie well. Still, Annie feels that nobody truly cares about her and she dreams of moving on and opening her own library one day. When Annie's cousin arrives from Ireland, she moves into Mrs. Hawkins' house and Annie is faced with old memories from her past. Memories she wishes to forget. She can never forgive her cousin for the misery she caused Annie back in Ireland. Where can Annie turn for love and support? She has friends, but longs for a deeper relationship.
Stephen Adams is a postal carrier who delivers mail to Mrs. Hawkins' house. He is quite attracted to Annie, but is also quite shy. Stephen loves books, as does Annie, and that seems to be the way Stephen can get closer to Annie. Stephen longs for a family, but he is deep in debt and has nothing to offer a woman. He also has issues from his past which he struggles to rise above. Annie and Stephen are both reading "The Wizard of Oz" which is very popular at that time. They enjoy discussing the book with each other. However, Stephen still has a difficult time winning Annie's affection.
While Annie is trying to rebuild her life, the boardinghouse is suddenly being investigated due to the behavior of another boarder. If Mrs. Hawkins' house is shut down, what will become of Annie? Will she realize the dream of having her own library? Circumstances seem to forever defeat Annie. Her father's stories seem to be the only things left to Annie. Could they be the key to fulfilling Annie's dreams? How can she overcome her troubles? Will she finally turn to God and find the hope and peace she seeks?
"Annie's Stories" is a book filled with history, mystery, and suspense. It is also a story about second chances and forgiveness. I enjoyed it very much!
I received a copy of this book from the publisher, through The Book Club Network (bookfun.org) in exchange for my honest review.
This is the second book in the Ellis Island collection by Cindy Thomson. It can be read as a stand-alone novel. Set in New York during the early 1900's, the book tells the story of Annie Gallagher, an Irish immigrant who has come to America to begin a new life.
Annie has terrible memories of her life in Ireland. All was well in her life until her father died. After his death, Annie lived with an uncle who sent her to the Magdalene Laundry, a horrible prison-like institution for unwanted girls. The primary reason she was sent away was because her cousin made false accusations against her. When Annie is finally rescued from the laundry, she arrives in America with only her father's writing desk and the treasured stories he wrote during his lifetime. Annie feels alone and abandoned by God.
Annie moves to a boardinghouse run by Mrs. Hawkins. She is a kind woman and treats Annie well. Still, Annie feels that nobody truly cares about her and she dreams of moving on and opening her own library one day. When Annie's cousin arrives from Ireland, she moves into Mrs. Hawkins' house and Annie is faced with old memories from her past. Memories she wishes to forget. She can never forgive her cousin for the misery she caused Annie back in Ireland. Where can Annie turn for love and support? She has friends, but longs for a deeper relationship.
Stephen Adams is a postal carrier who delivers mail to Mrs. Hawkins' house. He is quite attracted to Annie, but is also quite shy. Stephen loves books, as does Annie, and that seems to be the way Stephen can get closer to Annie. Stephen longs for a family, but he is deep in debt and has nothing to offer a woman. He also has issues from his past which he struggles to rise above. Annie and Stephen are both reading "The Wizard of Oz" which is very popular at that time. They enjoy discussing the book with each other. However, Stephen still has a difficult time winning Annie's affection.
While Annie is trying to rebuild her life, the boardinghouse is suddenly being investigated due to the behavior of another boarder. If Mrs. Hawkins' house is shut down, what will become of Annie? Will she realize the dream of having her own library? Circumstances seem to forever defeat Annie. Her father's stories seem to be the only things left to Annie. Could they be the key to fulfilling Annie's dreams? How can she overcome her troubles? Will she finally turn to God and find the hope and peace she seeks?
"Annie's Stories" is a book filled with history, mystery, and suspense. It is also a story about second chances and forgiveness. I enjoyed it very much!
I received a copy of this book from the publisher, through The Book Club Network (bookfun.org) in exchange for my honest review.
July 16, 2014
Annie's Stories An Ellis Island Novel by Cindy Thomson is a wonderful historical fiction book. Annie is the housekeeper at Hawkins House where she was brought after being rescued from the Magdalene Laundries in Ireland. Her mother died when she was a baby and her father, with Annie, would travel around Ireland because her father was a storyteller. When he died Annie had no one but a mean Uncle who did not want her and when her cousin Aileen tells a lie her Uncle sends Annie to the laundry.
Annie gets a second chance when she is rescued from the laundry and sent to live with Mrs. Hawkins at the Hawkins House. She only has her stories her father left her of her past life with him and the rest of her past she wants to forget.
This book is Annie's story of second chances and finding her strength to move on and she is determined not to depend on anyone but herself. Can Annie move past the hurts and memories that haunt her from the laundry? Will she ever be able to make her dreams reality? Most of all will she find that she is not unloved and forgotten by God? Will she find Love again for God, herself and a man to love her like the postman Stephen?
I loved this book. I love how Cindy Thomson makes books, reading and especially the book The Wizard Of OZ by Frank Braum an important part to Annie's story. I love how strong and independent Annie is and the heart for others she has. Annie grows as a person throughout the book and you find yourself caught up right along with her. You begin to feel a part of this story too and it is written where you can just feel Annie, Mrs Hawkins , Stephen and all the other characters could be people you know. This book is a book about second chances, moving on from the past hurts and holding on to the good memories, about love and learning to rely on Faith and God. You see with Annie that she has to come to realize that God can love her and that God never left her but was always with her. She has to love herself and realize she is lovable before she can become whole and achieve what she wants to in the future. Very uplifting and wonderful book.
This book combines the love of books, reading with history of family, books, publishing and the time period. If you are a lover of books, history, genealogy and good historical fiction then I believe you will love this book. I would recommend this book to all it is well worth the read.
If you want more information about this book, the Ellis Island Novels or the author visit her website at
http://cindythomson.blogspot.com/
I was given a free copy of this book from Tyndale Publishing in exchange for my honest review of the book
Annie gets a second chance when she is rescued from the laundry and sent to live with Mrs. Hawkins at the Hawkins House. She only has her stories her father left her of her past life with him and the rest of her past she wants to forget.
This book is Annie's story of second chances and finding her strength to move on and she is determined not to depend on anyone but herself. Can Annie move past the hurts and memories that haunt her from the laundry? Will she ever be able to make her dreams reality? Most of all will she find that she is not unloved and forgotten by God? Will she find Love again for God, herself and a man to love her like the postman Stephen?
I loved this book. I love how Cindy Thomson makes books, reading and especially the book The Wizard Of OZ by Frank Braum an important part to Annie's story. I love how strong and independent Annie is and the heart for others she has. Annie grows as a person throughout the book and you find yourself caught up right along with her. You begin to feel a part of this story too and it is written where you can just feel Annie, Mrs Hawkins , Stephen and all the other characters could be people you know. This book is a book about second chances, moving on from the past hurts and holding on to the good memories, about love and learning to rely on Faith and God. You see with Annie that she has to come to realize that God can love her and that God never left her but was always with her. She has to love herself and realize she is lovable before she can become whole and achieve what she wants to in the future. Very uplifting and wonderful book.
This book combines the love of books, reading with history of family, books, publishing and the time period. If you are a lover of books, history, genealogy and good historical fiction then I believe you will love this book. I would recommend this book to all it is well worth the read.
If you want more information about this book, the Ellis Island Novels or the author visit her website at
http://cindythomson.blogspot.com/
I was given a free copy of this book from Tyndale Publishing in exchange for my honest review of the book
April 10, 2016
Historic details behind the book are both fascinating and horrifying. The Magdalene Laundry in Ireland in which Annie was imprisoned was originally a ministry to provide alternate work for prostitutes, but by the late 1800's was little more than a prison for any woman accused of indiscretion, where they were forced into unpaid labor with little hope of escape. Atrocities like this are generally glossed over or ignored in schools, but they are important pieces of history from which we need to learn. I was also interested to learn the reputation the post office had for scaring off criminals, and that they were more feared than police or Pinkerton agents.
Stephen is a great guy, willing to give away his only pair of mittens when he doesn't have the money for a new pair. It is no wonder his generous heart and gentle demeanor attract Annie. However, he is a fool when it comes to money, and his good intentions aren't worth a cent. I realize this is how people end up deep in debt - they forget to pay their bills, spend money on luxuries rather than necessities, trust the wrong people, fall for scams, and so on. It is frustrating to see, though, and I cringed every time he puts his trust in questionable people. Besides learning to use money wisely, he has other faults and struggles, making him a very human but endearing character. While he generally has good intentions for everything he does, he has a habit of landing in trouble. And as it reiterates in the Bible, obedience is more important to God than sacrifice and good intentions.
Since her father's death, Annie's life has been extremely difficult and painful, and she has utterly given up on the idea that God sees and wants her, taking to heart the lies that say she is a sinner of the worst kind. We live in a fallen world, and bad things happen; it can be hard to see God's hand in the midst of trials, but as Annie learns, He is there, whether we recognize it or not.
Thomson's story is filled with energy, reflecting the hope of immigrants for a new life, despite their poverty and oppression. There is a strong feeling of progress: women control their own business, German immigrants live with Irish, Americans frequent the kitchens of Italians and Jews - the melting pot is in action! Her story has many points to ponder, and it is a great glimpse of turn-of-the-century America.
Thank you Tyndale House and NetGalley for providing a free e-copy for the purpose of review; I was not required to make it positive, and all opinions are my own.
Stephen is a great guy, willing to give away his only pair of mittens when he doesn't have the money for a new pair. It is no wonder his generous heart and gentle demeanor attract Annie. However, he is a fool when it comes to money, and his good intentions aren't worth a cent. I realize this is how people end up deep in debt - they forget to pay their bills, spend money on luxuries rather than necessities, trust the wrong people, fall for scams, and so on. It is frustrating to see, though, and I cringed every time he puts his trust in questionable people. Besides learning to use money wisely, he has other faults and struggles, making him a very human but endearing character. While he generally has good intentions for everything he does, he has a habit of landing in trouble. And as it reiterates in the Bible, obedience is more important to God than sacrifice and good intentions.
Since her father's death, Annie's life has been extremely difficult and painful, and she has utterly given up on the idea that God sees and wants her, taking to heart the lies that say she is a sinner of the worst kind. We live in a fallen world, and bad things happen; it can be hard to see God's hand in the midst of trials, but as Annie learns, He is there, whether we recognize it or not.
Thomson's story is filled with energy, reflecting the hope of immigrants for a new life, despite their poverty and oppression. There is a strong feeling of progress: women control their own business, German immigrants live with Irish, Americans frequent the kitchens of Italians and Jews - the melting pot is in action! Her story has many points to ponder, and it is a great glimpse of turn-of-the-century America.
Thank you Tyndale House and NetGalley for providing a free e-copy for the purpose of review; I was not required to make it positive, and all opinions are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 76 reviews