What do you think?
Rate this book
She Who Knows #2
One Way Witch
Set in the universe Africanfuturist luminary Nnedi Okorafor first introduced in the World Fantasy Award-winning Who Fears Death, One Way Witch is the second in the She Who Knows trilogy
The world has forgotten Onyesonwu.
As a teen, Najeeba learned to become the beast of wind, fire and the kponyungo. When that took too much from her, including the life of her father, she let it all go, and for a time, she was happy — until only a few years later, when the small, normal life she’d built was violently destroyed.
Now in her forties and years beyond the death of her second husband, Najeeba has just lost her beloved daughter. Onyesonwu saved the world. Najeeba knows this well, but the world does not. This is how the juju her daughter evoked works. One other person who remembers is Onyesonwu’s teacher Aro, a harsh and hard-headed sorcerer. Najeeba has decided to ask him to teach her the Mystic Points, the powerful heart of sorcery. There is something awful Najeeba needs to kill and the Mystic Points are the only way. Najeeba is truly her daughter’s mother.
When Aro agrees to help, Najeeba is at last ready to forge her future. But first, she must confront her past — for certain memories cannot lie in unmarked graves.
The world has forgotten Onyesonwu.
As a teen, Najeeba learned to become the beast of wind, fire and the kponyungo. When that took too much from her, including the life of her father, she let it all go, and for a time, she was happy — until only a few years later, when the small, normal life she’d built was violently destroyed.
Now in her forties and years beyond the death of her second husband, Najeeba has just lost her beloved daughter. Onyesonwu saved the world. Najeeba knows this well, but the world does not. This is how the juju her daughter evoked works. One other person who remembers is Onyesonwu’s teacher Aro, a harsh and hard-headed sorcerer. Najeeba has decided to ask him to teach her the Mystic Points, the powerful heart of sorcery. There is something awful Najeeba needs to kill and the Mystic Points are the only way. Najeeba is truly her daughter’s mother.
When Aro agrees to help, Najeeba is at last ready to forge her future. But first, she must confront her past — for certain memories cannot lie in unmarked graves.
159 pages, Kindle Edition
First published April 29, 2025
68 people are currently reading
2420 people want to read
About the author
Nnedi Okorafor
77 books17.8k followersNnedi Okorafor is a New York Times Bestselling writer of science fiction and fantasy for both children and adults. The more specific terms for her works are africanfuturism and africanjujuism, both terms she coined and defined. Born in the United States to two Nigerian (Igbo) immigrant parents and visiting family in Nigeria since she was a child, the foundation and inspiration of Nnedi’s work is rooted in this part of Africa. Her many works include Who Fears Death (winner of the World Fantasy Award and in development at HBO as a TV series), the Nebula and Hugo award winning novella trilogy Binti (in development as a TV series), the Lodestar and Locus Award winning Nsibidi Scripts Series, LaGuardia (winner of a Hugo and Eisner awards for Best Graphic Novel) and her most recent novella Remote Control. Her debut novel Zahrah the Windseeker won the prestigious Wole Soyinka Prize for Literature. She lives with her daughter Anyaugo in Phoenix, AZ. Learn more about Nnedi at Nnedi.com and follow Nnedi on twitter (as @Nnedi), Facebook and Instagram.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 105 reviews
September 8, 2025
I walked into the desert, in the opposite direction my daughter would soon walk and never return from. I wasn't afraid to be alone. Onyesonwu held me to this world. Without her, I was nothing. I clung to the weight of her. If only to be there for her if she somehow needed me. And so I walked into the desert to unlock something I'd put away long ago.
One Way Witch shows Najeeba's perspective of the time immediately before and after her daughter's remaking of the world, which story is told in Who Fears Death. This book acts as a bridge for Najeeba from these events to the role she knows she has to play in the future of the new world.
Though Nnedi Okorafor's writing is as evocative as ever of the pain and anguish experienced by the protagonists, this book is essentially some time off for Najeeba as she studies magic and processes her feelings to move on - and the slow story arc reflects this break. Her character arc remains strong as she actively journeys to where she wants to be in her life.
The book on the whole is still recommended for anyone who wants to follow the series and keep tabs on the world-building. The strengths of the book, and the series, are definitely the writing and the character arcs.
Thanks to NetGalley, Nnedi Okorafor and the publishers DAW for the advanced copy of this book for an honest review.
🌟🌟🌟
[3/4 stars for the premise and the whole book; Half a star for the writing; Half a star for the world-building; Half a star for the story arc; 3/4 stars for the characters - Three stars in total].
One Way Witch shows Najeeba's perspective of the time immediately before and after her daughter's remaking of the world, which story is told in Who Fears Death. This book acts as a bridge for Najeeba from these events to the role she knows she has to play in the future of the new world.
Though Nnedi Okorafor's writing is as evocative as ever of the pain and anguish experienced by the protagonists, this book is essentially some time off for Najeeba as she studies magic and processes her feelings to move on - and the slow story arc reflects this break. Her character arc remains strong as she actively journeys to where she wants to be in her life.
The book on the whole is still recommended for anyone who wants to follow the series and keep tabs on the world-building. The strengths of the book, and the series, are definitely the writing and the character arcs.
Thanks to NetGalley, Nnedi Okorafor and the publishers DAW for the advanced copy of this book for an honest review.
🌟🌟🌟
[3/4 stars for the premise and the whole book; Half a star for the writing; Half a star for the world-building; Half a star for the story arc; 3/4 stars for the characters - Three stars in total].
February 26, 2025
One thing to note, is you really need to read Who Fears Death before picking up the second novella in the series! One Way Witch begins during the events of that novel and mostly occurs after Onyesonwu, the daughter of Najeeba, had changed the world.
This novella is about a woman in middle-age finding herself in a new way, healing from the past, and stepping into her power and who she might become. It explores how the body carries memories of trauma, even when the mind doesn't remember the details, and how art can be a form of healing and catharsis. I don't know what it is, but across both novellas I have found Najeeba and her story to be so very compelling. I liked Who Fears Death for what it's doing, but these novellas have both hit me in a different way. Loved it. I received a copy of this book for review via NetGalley, all opinions are my own.
This novella is about a woman in middle-age finding herself in a new way, healing from the past, and stepping into her power and who she might become. It explores how the body carries memories of trauma, even when the mind doesn't remember the details, and how art can be a form of healing and catharsis. I don't know what it is, but across both novellas I have found Najeeba and her story to be so very compelling. I liked Who Fears Death for what it's doing, but these novellas have both hit me in a different way. Loved it. I received a copy of this book for review via NetGalley, all opinions are my own.
April 29, 2025
🔥 HAPPY PUB DAY - 4/29/25 🔥
Black History Month 2025 #1
I read SHE WHO KNOWS for a book club I didn't end up attending. I loved it. Though short, it packed a punch. This is also short. It packs no punches. I found myself so bored with the continuation of Najeeba's story. She has grown into a rather staid adult. There are reasons for this, but as I zoned in and out of this book, I won't go into them.
📱 Thank you to NetGalley and DAW
Black History Month 2025 #1
I read SHE WHO KNOWS for a book club I didn't end up attending. I loved it. Though short, it packed a punch. This is also short. It packs no punches. I found myself so bored with the continuation of Najeeba's story. She has grown into a rather staid adult. There are reasons for this, but as I zoned in and out of this book, I won't go into them.
📱 Thank you to NetGalley and DAW
April 27, 2025
Argh, no resolution! However, that means we get more of Najeeba’s story in another installment, so I’m okay with that.
Nnedi Okorafor is a brilliant author. I love this world she created, and I love reading about her characters as they come to life on the page.
Okorafor does include a brief summary of a previous book at the beginning, but it is very bare bones, and she recommends that you read “Who Fears Death” first, which is about Najeeba’s daughter, Onyesonwu. I read the novella about Najeeba’s childhood, “She Who Knows”, but I haven’t yet read “Who Fears Death.” Just know that you will get some spoilers in both novellas.
Highly recommended, and Okorafor is an auto-read author for me. She’s amazing.
Thank you to NetGalley and DAW for the eARC. All opinions are my own.
Nnedi Okorafor is a brilliant author. I love this world she created, and I love reading about her characters as they come to life on the page.
Okorafor does include a brief summary of a previous book at the beginning, but it is very bare bones, and she recommends that you read “Who Fears Death” first, which is about Najeeba’s daughter, Onyesonwu. I read the novella about Najeeba’s childhood, “She Who Knows”, but I haven’t yet read “Who Fears Death.” Just know that you will get some spoilers in both novellas.
Highly recommended, and Okorafor is an auto-read author for me. She’s amazing.
Thank you to NetGalley and DAW for the eARC. All opinions are my own.
July 25, 2025
While Nnedi Okorafor's writing still vividly captures the pain and struggles of the main characters, this book mainly serves as a period of rest for Najeeba, giving her time to learn magic and work through her emotions from what happened in the first book, giving this a slower plot. Despite this lull, her character development remains compelling as she persistently works toward her goals and sets up nicely for the final third book
December 28, 2024
I received an advance copy from the publisher via Netgalley for review purposes; this in no way influences my review.
I’ve seen Nnedi Okorafor’s books around for a while, but it wasn’t until I happened across She Who Knows that I finally broke the seal, and I’m so glad I did. I made sure to read Who Fears Death before starting One-Way Witch and I absolutely recommend reading WFD before Najeeba’s series, but especially before this novella. There is so much that happens with Onyesonwu that creates so much of the reality for One-Way Witch, especially understanding the Before. I love Nnedi’s writing and storytelling, and these characters are so complicated and flawed. I can’t wait to see the conclusion of Najeeba’s story and more about the Cleanser.
I’ve seen Nnedi Okorafor’s books around for a while, but it wasn’t until I happened across She Who Knows that I finally broke the seal, and I’m so glad I did. I made sure to read Who Fears Death before starting One-Way Witch and I absolutely recommend reading WFD before Najeeba’s series, but especially before this novella. There is so much that happens with Onyesonwu that creates so much of the reality for One-Way Witch, especially understanding the Before. I love Nnedi’s writing and storytelling, and these characters are so complicated and flawed. I can’t wait to see the conclusion of Najeeba’s story and more about the Cleanser.
April 18, 2025
Thanks to DAW and Netgalley for this ARC.
I loved the first two books in this series, She who knows and Who Fears Death. The Afrofuturist genre of Okorafor's writing is so unique and gritty. I had first read Who Fears Death for one of my University Literary courses and devoured it. I had never read a book with female rage, sci Fi and African culture mixed into one. Najeeba and Onyesonwu's mother daughter relationship is both intense and enduring. The way Okorafor includes modern day genocide, racism and weaponized rape was heartbreaking.
One Way Witch continues Najeeba's storyline from Who Fears Death. She searches out her daughters teacher Aro to become a sorcerer, and looks to take out the mysterious Cleanser. This felt like an extended epilogue to the ending of this series. It didn't have the same strong story telling as the first two but wraps up a few key points of Najeeba's storyline. The world building is expanded and I do enjoy the magic system in this series. I just wish this had a bit of the same strong direction as the previous two installments.
I look forward to reading more of Okorafor's writing.
Rating: 3.5 ⭐
release date: April 29
I loved the first two books in this series, She who knows and Who Fears Death. The Afrofuturist genre of Okorafor's writing is so unique and gritty. I had first read Who Fears Death for one of my University Literary courses and devoured it. I had never read a book with female rage, sci Fi and African culture mixed into one. Najeeba and Onyesonwu's mother daughter relationship is both intense and enduring. The way Okorafor includes modern day genocide, racism and weaponized rape was heartbreaking.
One Way Witch continues Najeeba's storyline from Who Fears Death. She searches out her daughters teacher Aro to become a sorcerer, and looks to take out the mysterious Cleanser. This felt like an extended epilogue to the ending of this series. It didn't have the same strong story telling as the first two but wraps up a few key points of Najeeba's storyline. The world building is expanded and I do enjoy the magic system in this series. I just wish this had a bit of the same strong direction as the previous two installments.
I look forward to reading more of Okorafor's writing.
Rating: 3.5 ⭐
release date: April 29
June 22, 2025
3.5 stars
December 1, 2025
Well written, but my experience suffered from how long it's been since I read Who Fears Death. I know I lost much of the significance.
February 5, 2025
One Way Witch follows Najeeba, a woman with natural abilities as a sorcerer, as she trains in these abilities with the intention of going after a threat stalks and takes people from the village she grew up in. It occurs after Najeeba’s daughter has left and changed the world, and Najeeba is mourning both the loss of her husband and her daughter, processing grief. I didn’t love this as much as She Who Knows – it did feel a bit ‘middle book’ in that a lot of it is backstory as well as anticipatory of what will be the plot of the final book – but Okorafor’s writing is impactful and beautiful as always and the character development of Najeeba is really effective. I will certainly pick up the final installment and finish this trilogy.
This is a sequel to the novella She Who Knows; I strongly discourage reading this one first as key elements of the backstory of the characters would be missing. These books are also set in the same universe as Who Fears Death, which follows Onyesonwu, Najeeba’s daughter, and chronologically falls mostly between these two novellas; I have not read this book but can still easily make sense of these novellas (though they refer to – and no doubt contain spoilers – for the novel).
Thank you to DAW and NetGalley for providing me an ARC to review.
Content warnings: rape, sexual assault, violence, slavery (as having occurred prior to the plot of this story), animal cruelty, animal death
This is a sequel to the novella She Who Knows; I strongly discourage reading this one first as key elements of the backstory of the characters would be missing. These books are also set in the same universe as Who Fears Death, which follows Onyesonwu, Najeeba’s daughter, and chronologically falls mostly between these two novellas; I have not read this book but can still easily make sense of these novellas (though they refer to – and no doubt contain spoilers – for the novel).
Thank you to DAW and NetGalley for providing me an ARC to review.
Content warnings: rape, sexual assault, violence, slavery (as having occurred prior to the plot of this story), animal cruelty, animal death
October 6, 2025
Najeeba is grieving—her daughter Onyewusu is gone on her mission. And then she changed the world.
Najeeba is one of the few who knows what the world was like before, and it’s jarring, but she slowly acclimatizes. One night, when she is flying in her kponyungo, she sees the Cleanser in her old village Adora 5 taking a young woman. Najeeba is furious, and decides she will kill the Cleanser. But, before she can do that, she must learn how to use her power, and goes to Aro, who taught Onyewusu, how to be a sorcerer.
Though he thinks Najeeba is reckless, he begins her training. She goes through successive trials, and when not training, she continues to sell cactus candy in her shop, and becomes involved with Devdan, a glassmaker from the West, whom Najeeba deduces was formerly a slave. He no longer remembers this, but feels something of the pain of his former life, intriguingly.
The story ends with Najeeba in a position to take on her biggest challenge, the Cleanser.
This was not quite as good as book one, but I still enjoyed this quite a lot. Najeeba the 40-year-old is tough, warm and driven. No matter how terrifying or hard the challenge he, she keeps moving forward with her plan to take on the Cleanser. (I wish I better understood what the Cleanser is, other than possibly malevolent, definitely disruptive and likely murderous.)
I am eager to get to book three of this trilogy.
Thank you to Netgalley and DAW for this ARC in exchange for my review.
Najeeba is one of the few who knows what the world was like before, and it’s jarring, but she slowly acclimatizes. One night, when she is flying in her kponyungo, she sees the Cleanser in her old village Adora 5 taking a young woman. Najeeba is furious, and decides she will kill the Cleanser. But, before she can do that, she must learn how to use her power, and goes to Aro, who taught Onyewusu, how to be a sorcerer.
Though he thinks Najeeba is reckless, he begins her training. She goes through successive trials, and when not training, she continues to sell cactus candy in her shop, and becomes involved with Devdan, a glassmaker from the West, whom Najeeba deduces was formerly a slave. He no longer remembers this, but feels something of the pain of his former life, intriguingly.
The story ends with Najeeba in a position to take on her biggest challenge, the Cleanser.
This was not quite as good as book one, but I still enjoyed this quite a lot. Najeeba the 40-year-old is tough, warm and driven. No matter how terrifying or hard the challenge he, she keeps moving forward with her plan to take on the Cleanser. (I wish I better understood what the Cleanser is, other than possibly malevolent, definitely disruptive and likely murderous.)
I am eager to get to book three of this trilogy.
Thank you to Netgalley and DAW for this ARC in exchange for my review.
October 17, 2025
* I really should have reread the previous book before this one; I found myself a teeny bit lost at times [as an aside, I HIGHLY recommend that you do not read this as a standalone and that you read ALL the previous books before this or you will be more than just a teeny bit lost].
* The wait to get this audiobook was insane [$17+ for a 6hr audiobook is ALSO insane but I digress...] - thankfully it was absolutely worth it. I adore the narrator [Yetide Badaki] of these books and once again, they did not disappoint. I am so grateful for excellent narration.
* Najeeba's story is a complex one and I thought this was going to be more of the very complex storytelling I've come to know and love from this author. What I got was much more relaxed storytelling as Najeeba takes a break [so-to-speak] to train/study magic, hone/discover her powers more, and *AHEM* enjoy some "adult" activities [even though she is constantly warned against this by her teacher]. As much as I enjoyed this [and I did - it was still a very good read], I do know that there were several moments where I said to myself, "this is the LONGEST short book I have read in a long time".
This was still an excellent read for me and sets us all up for book 3 very nicely and I am really looking forward to reading that book as well!!
Thank you to NetGalley, Nnedi Okorafor, and DAW for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
* The wait to get this audiobook was insane [$17+ for a 6hr audiobook is ALSO insane but I digress...] - thankfully it was absolutely worth it. I adore the narrator [Yetide Badaki] of these books and once again, they did not disappoint. I am so grateful for excellent narration.
* Najeeba's story is a complex one and I thought this was going to be more of the very complex storytelling I've come to know and love from this author. What I got was much more relaxed storytelling as Najeeba takes a break [so-to-speak] to train/study magic, hone/discover her powers more, and *AHEM* enjoy some "adult" activities [even though she is constantly warned against this by her teacher]. As much as I enjoyed this [and I did - it was still a very good read], I do know that there were several moments where I said to myself, "this is the LONGEST short book I have read in a long time".
This was still an excellent read for me and sets us all up for book 3 very nicely and I am really looking forward to reading that book as well!!
Thank you to NetGalley, Nnedi Okorafor, and DAW for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
January 15, 2025
This is the sequel to she who knows and set in the same world of who fears death. Like her previous books, this one is well written and uses Nigerian mythology for the story. I’m not really sure how much to say about this one for a summary since it’s a spinoff series and a sequel. Plus it’s so short. I think the most I can say is that I really enjoyed it, the world building was well done and Nnedi Okorafor’s writing is getting better with each book. My only issue is that it’s a novella. I rarely give out 5 stars to novella’s since I want more time with the story and characters.
**thank you netgalley and Daw for the free e-arc in exchange for an honest review**.
**thank you netgalley and Daw for the free e-arc in exchange for an honest review**.
May 27, 2025
I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, I’m a big fan of Nnedi Okorafor’s writing. I love the characters she creates and the worlds she build. The “One Way Witch” will lead you wanting more and I can’t wait until the next installment arrives. Do yourself a favor and pick up any of Okorafor’s books.
April 20, 2025
3.5 stars-Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC of this book, releasing April 29th!
I had to give less than four stars because I didn't like this one quite as much as She Who Knows, the prequel in this series. This one picks back up with Najeeba quite a while after the events of the first book (this occurs after the events of Who Fears Death-I read that one but quite a while ago and don't remember specifics, but there's a foreword that covers what you need to know included with this volume). This definitely felt like the middle book in a trilogy-the plot is pretty slow-moving and building and covers Najeeba's time training to harness her power and become a sorcerer. Partly due to this it didn't have the same pull as the first volume, although I still love Najeeba as a character and did finish it in a few days. I think the next steps are definitely intriguing enough for me to want to finish the series even if this one didn't grab me the same way as She Who Knows.
I had to give less than four stars because I didn't like this one quite as much as She Who Knows, the prequel in this series. This one picks back up with Najeeba quite a while after the events of the first book (this occurs after the events of Who Fears Death-I read that one but quite a while ago and don't remember specifics, but there's a foreword that covers what you need to know included with this volume). This definitely felt like the middle book in a trilogy-the plot is pretty slow-moving and building and covers Najeeba's time training to harness her power and become a sorcerer. Partly due to this it didn't have the same pull as the first volume, although I still love Najeeba as a character and did finish it in a few days. I think the next steps are definitely intriguing enough for me to want to finish the series even if this one didn't grab me the same way as She Who Knows.
September 13, 2025
4,5 rounded up. Love a woman coming into her power
December 30, 2025
3.5 This felt like middle book syndrome. I am curious about book 3 though!
January 20, 2025
One Way Witch is the sequel that She Who Knows deserves, drawing you further into Najeeba's story and the world of Who Fears Death. I enjoyed Who Fears Death, but I find myself utterly engrossed in Najeeba's novellas. Okorafor's character work is some of the best in the business, creating a Science Fiction stunner in One Way Witch. Okorafor blends Africanfuturistic genre devices and settings with a plot that makes you just want to keep on reading. One of my favourites by Okorafor to date!
Thank you to NetGalley for the advanced copy! ✨️
Thank you to NetGalley for the advanced copy! ✨️
August 23, 2025
ended right at a good part. love books like this.
April 18, 2025
What more can I say?Yetide Badaki knocks it out of the park with her narration here again. Really made my ears happy even if the content could get tough at times.
Thanks to NetGalley for the audio arc :)
Thanks to NetGalley for the audio arc :)
May 9, 2025
Najeeba’s name means “She Who Knows” and she is the One Way Witch of this novella trilogy. Which is both a prequel and a sequel to Who Fears Death, as is totally utterly fitting because Onyesonwu, the “who fears death” protagonist of that novel, is her daughter.
Was her daughter.
Past and present tenses get knocked a bit off-kilter in the second book of Najeeba’s story, as Who Fears Death happened between the first book of the trilogy, She Who Knows, and this second one.
But Onyesonwu didn’t merely die at the end of her story, she sacrificed herself in order to change the world, to kick the universe – or at least Earth’s little corner of it – onto an entirely different track. She literally changed the world and everyone in it, wiping out their history, their actions, even their memories, healing a whole lot that was toxic and wrong and erasing her own existence.
Najeeba remembers everything, both the ‘Before’ that only other sorcerers remember, and the ‘Now’ that everyone else believes has always been.
One Way Witch is the story of Najeeba’s reconciliation between the dark and painful past that already was – at least for her – with the ‘Now’ that moves forward into the future. The only way out is through, and it’s a ‘one way’ trip that demands that she move into the future with it – otherwise her powers will destroy not merely herself but everyone around her as well as a peace that is more fragile than she first imagined.
Escape Rating A-: As a reader who has not yet managed to get back and read Who Fears Death (so many books, so little time, so many shiny new adventures on the horizon), this second novella in the trilogy worked better for me because it is about Najeeba’s world as it now is. The story is moving forward, even though of course Najeeba looks back at the daughter she misses.
At the same time, the plot device that powers the story is a familiar one, both from SF and fantasy but also from fanfiction that deals with those genres. One Way Witch is a story about reconciliation, not so much between people or even countries as it is between the past one remembers and the crimes that were committed in it, and the new future that one has sacrificed so much to bring about.
Najeeba is surrounded by people who bullied and mistreated her daughter in the past that has been literally wiped away. She remembers how truly awful some of them were, but the people they are now aren’t actually guilty of anything. At the same time, the circumstances that created some of her deepest adult friendships also didn’t happen, so she’s forced to let those friendships go because they never were.
Every silver lining has a cloud, after all.
Just because people don’t remember the world her daughter wiped away, that doesn’t mean that the trauma that they suffered in that alternate history doesn’t linger in their subconscious. Or their collective memory. Or their souls. The world is reshaping itself as people who were slaves in the old past can’t bear to stay where they were shackled – even if they no longer remember any of it.
The world – or at least the people in it, are on the move, trying to find the places that their hearts call home – even if they don’t know why. The new peace is fragile because people are fragile, and it’s breaking.
(Something that I expect to be part of the final book in the trilogy.)
Unlike so many middle books in trilogies, One Way Witch is not a descent into deep darkness and despair – and it’s lovely to see a story break that pattern. Instead, this story feels like it’s a restart of Najeeba’s story. Not in the sense that she can’t remember the past, but rather that her past and THE past were defined by her trauma, and that this story is about reconciling with her own past and finding her own ‘one way’ into the future.
This reader is looking forward to a future where the final book in the trilogy will be available. Najeeba has plenty of journey and adventure yet to come, and I can’t wait to read it.
Originally published at Reading Reality
Was her daughter.
Past and present tenses get knocked a bit off-kilter in the second book of Najeeba’s story, as Who Fears Death happened between the first book of the trilogy, She Who Knows, and this second one.
But Onyesonwu didn’t merely die at the end of her story, she sacrificed herself in order to change the world, to kick the universe – or at least Earth’s little corner of it – onto an entirely different track. She literally changed the world and everyone in it, wiping out their history, their actions, even their memories, healing a whole lot that was toxic and wrong and erasing her own existence.
Najeeba remembers everything, both the ‘Before’ that only other sorcerers remember, and the ‘Now’ that everyone else believes has always been.
One Way Witch is the story of Najeeba’s reconciliation between the dark and painful past that already was – at least for her – with the ‘Now’ that moves forward into the future. The only way out is through, and it’s a ‘one way’ trip that demands that she move into the future with it – otherwise her powers will destroy not merely herself but everyone around her as well as a peace that is more fragile than she first imagined.
Escape Rating A-: As a reader who has not yet managed to get back and read Who Fears Death (so many books, so little time, so many shiny new adventures on the horizon), this second novella in the trilogy worked better for me because it is about Najeeba’s world as it now is. The story is moving forward, even though of course Najeeba looks back at the daughter she misses.
At the same time, the plot device that powers the story is a familiar one, both from SF and fantasy but also from fanfiction that deals with those genres. One Way Witch is a story about reconciliation, not so much between people or even countries as it is between the past one remembers and the crimes that were committed in it, and the new future that one has sacrificed so much to bring about.
Najeeba is surrounded by people who bullied and mistreated her daughter in the past that has been literally wiped away. She remembers how truly awful some of them were, but the people they are now aren’t actually guilty of anything. At the same time, the circumstances that created some of her deepest adult friendships also didn’t happen, so she’s forced to let those friendships go because they never were.
Every silver lining has a cloud, after all.
Just because people don’t remember the world her daughter wiped away, that doesn’t mean that the trauma that they suffered in that alternate history doesn’t linger in their subconscious. Or their collective memory. Or their souls. The world is reshaping itself as people who were slaves in the old past can’t bear to stay where they were shackled – even if they no longer remember any of it.
The world – or at least the people in it, are on the move, trying to find the places that their hearts call home – even if they don’t know why. The new peace is fragile because people are fragile, and it’s breaking.
(Something that I expect to be part of the final book in the trilogy.)
Unlike so many middle books in trilogies, One Way Witch is not a descent into deep darkness and despair – and it’s lovely to see a story break that pattern. Instead, this story feels like it’s a restart of Najeeba’s story. Not in the sense that she can’t remember the past, but rather that her past and THE past were defined by her trauma, and that this story is about reconciling with her own past and finding her own ‘one way’ into the future.
This reader is looking forward to a future where the final book in the trilogy will be available. Najeeba has plenty of journey and adventure yet to come, and I can’t wait to read it.
Originally published at Reading Reality
Read
April 17, 2025Book Review: One Way Witch (She Who Knows #2) by Nnedi Okorafor
Nnedi Okorafor’s One Way Witch, the second book in the She Who Knows series, continues to showcase her signature blend of Africanfuturism and rich storytelling. This installment follows the journey of the protagonist, a young witch named Sunny Nwazue, as she navigates a world filled with magical realism, cultural depth, and personal growth amidst the complexities of her heritage.
Overview and Structure
One Way Witch is structured as a continuation of Sunny’s adventures, picking up from the significant events of the first book. Okorafor effectively balances character development with a fast-paced plot that engages readers from the outset. The narrative unfolds through a combination of vivid descriptions, dynamic dialogue, and an intricate portrayal of Sunny’s internal conflicts. Each chapter builds upon the last, establishing a sense of urgency and tension that propels the story forward.
Thematic Exploration
A central theme in One Way Witch is the exploration of identity and self-discovery. Sunny grapples with her dual heritage—navigating the expectations placed upon her by her family and society while striving to forge her own path as a witch. Okorafor delves into issues of belonging, cultural responsibility, and the power of personal agency, inviting readers to reflect on their own identities within a broader cultural context.
The novel also addresses the theme of environmentalism, intertwining magical elements with ecological consciousness. Okorafor’s portrayal of the natural world emphasizes the interconnectedness of all living beings, highlighting the need for respect and harmony with nature. This theme resonates powerfully in today’s context of climate crisis and environmental degradation, making Sunny’s journey both timely and relevant.
Characterization and Writing Style
Okorafor excels in her characterization, crafting a diverse cast of figures that reflect a wide range of experiences and backgrounds. Sunny’s growth throughout the narrative is both believable and emotionally resonant, as she faces external challenges while confronting her inner fears and aspirations. The supporting characters are equally well-developed, each contributing to the richness of the story and providing insight into different aspects of the world Okorafor has created.
The author’s writing style is vibrant and evocative, with a lyrical quality that draws readers into the narrative. Okorafor’s use of cultural references and folklore enhances the authenticity of the setting and provides a deeper understanding of the characters’ motivations. Her ability to blend the fantastical with the mundane allows the reader to experience the magic of Sunny’s world in a compelling and relatable way.
Conclusion
In conclusion, One Way Witch by Nnedi Okorafor is a powerful continuation of the She Who Knows series, effectively weaving together themes of identity, environmentalism, and personal growth within a richly imagined narrative. Okorafor’s masterful storytelling and dynamic characterization captivate readers and invite them to ponder the complexities of life in a culturally rich context. This novel is highly recommended for fans of speculative fiction and those seeking stories that explore the intersections of magic, identity, and the human experience. With its thought-provoking themes and engaging prose, One Way Witch is an important contribution to contemporary literature, further establishing Okorafor as a leading voice in the genre.
Nnedi Okorafor’s One Way Witch, the second book in the She Who Knows series, continues to showcase her signature blend of Africanfuturism and rich storytelling. This installment follows the journey of the protagonist, a young witch named Sunny Nwazue, as she navigates a world filled with magical realism, cultural depth, and personal growth amidst the complexities of her heritage.
Overview and Structure
One Way Witch is structured as a continuation of Sunny’s adventures, picking up from the significant events of the first book. Okorafor effectively balances character development with a fast-paced plot that engages readers from the outset. The narrative unfolds through a combination of vivid descriptions, dynamic dialogue, and an intricate portrayal of Sunny’s internal conflicts. Each chapter builds upon the last, establishing a sense of urgency and tension that propels the story forward.
Thematic Exploration
A central theme in One Way Witch is the exploration of identity and self-discovery. Sunny grapples with her dual heritage—navigating the expectations placed upon her by her family and society while striving to forge her own path as a witch. Okorafor delves into issues of belonging, cultural responsibility, and the power of personal agency, inviting readers to reflect on their own identities within a broader cultural context.
The novel also addresses the theme of environmentalism, intertwining magical elements with ecological consciousness. Okorafor’s portrayal of the natural world emphasizes the interconnectedness of all living beings, highlighting the need for respect and harmony with nature. This theme resonates powerfully in today’s context of climate crisis and environmental degradation, making Sunny’s journey both timely and relevant.
Characterization and Writing Style
Okorafor excels in her characterization, crafting a diverse cast of figures that reflect a wide range of experiences and backgrounds. Sunny’s growth throughout the narrative is both believable and emotionally resonant, as she faces external challenges while confronting her inner fears and aspirations. The supporting characters are equally well-developed, each contributing to the richness of the story and providing insight into different aspects of the world Okorafor has created.
The author’s writing style is vibrant and evocative, with a lyrical quality that draws readers into the narrative. Okorafor’s use of cultural references and folklore enhances the authenticity of the setting and provides a deeper understanding of the characters’ motivations. Her ability to blend the fantastical with the mundane allows the reader to experience the magic of Sunny’s world in a compelling and relatable way.
Conclusion
In conclusion, One Way Witch by Nnedi Okorafor is a powerful continuation of the She Who Knows series, effectively weaving together themes of identity, environmentalism, and personal growth within a richly imagined narrative. Okorafor’s masterful storytelling and dynamic characterization captivate readers and invite them to ponder the complexities of life in a culturally rich context. This novel is highly recommended for fans of speculative fiction and those seeking stories that explore the intersections of magic, identity, and the human experience. With its thought-provoking themes and engaging prose, One Way Witch is an important contribution to contemporary literature, further establishing Okorafor as a leading voice in the genre.
January 1, 2025
2 stars, Metaphorosis reviews
Summary
Najeeba is a witch who can transform to a spirit creature of flame and wind. Her daughter formed by rape is a sorceress who remade the entire world. But Najeeba wants more - to understand the Mystic Points of power in the world, and become a full sorceress herself.
Review
I said in my review of Firespitter that DAW didn’t seem to know what it was doing with the book, and this sequel hasn’t changed my mind. This book has even less going on than the previous one – it’s largely a description of the fact that the narrator is training in sorcery; not even really how she trains, beyond some vague, muddled description. It really made me lose patience with this series, and perhaps even with how Okorafor tells a story.
Okorafor starts with a defensive, ‘I can’t explain what my previous book was about, but here’s my [fairly useless] summary’. It refers to Who Fears Death, and seems to suggest this book and Firespitter are really just backstory for that novel, which I have not read. If so, that may explain why these books are so formless and opaque. It begins to feel as if many of Okorafor’s books are connected, and I just don’t have the right grounding, not having read the right set in the right order. However it may be, I found this book not only dull, but downright irritating. I’m taking a big step back from, ‘Okorafor is a very interesting writer new to me’ and toward ‘Okorafor’s books are occasionally interesting, but overall muddled’.
Very little happens in this book. Najeeba learns sorcery, but a) she was already a magician, and b) it all just sort of happens and she tells us it did. In a sense, we see the learning experience, but it’s so opaque that it’s hard to make sense of until she tells us the effect it apparently had. To make matters worse, she never accomplishes the one goal she set out for herself. Instead, a completely different and unheralded resolution worms its way in. I found the book boring, and was never invested in the characters. It’s a short book, but even so, I was never eager to pick it up, feeling more that it was a chore I had to accomplish. It feels like the middle of a novel, but not an interesting one.
In a way, it’s impressive that one book can me me reevaluate the author quite so much. But frankly, it’s really only the Binti trilogy that drew me in, and the other Okorafor books I’ve read have been disappointing. I’m willing to class this one as bad, more because it’s so muddled and flat than because there’s anything egregious in it. I haven’t read Who Fears Death, no longer want to, and am not interested to follow this backstory series any further. And that’s from someone who hates to quit something they’ve started.
I received this book for free in exchange for an honest review.
Summary
Najeeba is a witch who can transform to a spirit creature of flame and wind. Her daughter formed by rape is a sorceress who remade the entire world. But Najeeba wants more - to understand the Mystic Points of power in the world, and become a full sorceress herself.
Review
I said in my review of Firespitter that DAW didn’t seem to know what it was doing with the book, and this sequel hasn’t changed my mind. This book has even less going on than the previous one – it’s largely a description of the fact that the narrator is training in sorcery; not even really how she trains, beyond some vague, muddled description. It really made me lose patience with this series, and perhaps even with how Okorafor tells a story.
Okorafor starts with a defensive, ‘I can’t explain what my previous book was about, but here’s my [fairly useless] summary’. It refers to Who Fears Death, and seems to suggest this book and Firespitter are really just backstory for that novel, which I have not read. If so, that may explain why these books are so formless and opaque. It begins to feel as if many of Okorafor’s books are connected, and I just don’t have the right grounding, not having read the right set in the right order. However it may be, I found this book not only dull, but downright irritating. I’m taking a big step back from, ‘Okorafor is a very interesting writer new to me’ and toward ‘Okorafor’s books are occasionally interesting, but overall muddled’.
Very little happens in this book. Najeeba learns sorcery, but a) she was already a magician, and b) it all just sort of happens and she tells us it did. In a sense, we see the learning experience, but it’s so opaque that it’s hard to make sense of until she tells us the effect it apparently had. To make matters worse, she never accomplishes the one goal she set out for herself. Instead, a completely different and unheralded resolution worms its way in. I found the book boring, and was never invested in the characters. It’s a short book, but even so, I was never eager to pick it up, feeling more that it was a chore I had to accomplish. It feels like the middle of a novel, but not an interesting one.
In a way, it’s impressive that one book can me me reevaluate the author quite so much. But frankly, it’s really only the Binti trilogy that drew me in, and the other Okorafor books I’ve read have been disappointing. I’m willing to class this one as bad, more because it’s so muddled and flat than because there’s anything egregious in it. I haven’t read Who Fears Death, no longer want to, and am not interested to follow this backstory series any further. And that’s from someone who hates to quit something they’ve started.
I received this book for free in exchange for an honest review.
February 4, 2025
Thanks to NetGalley and DAW for providing a DRC in exchange for an hones review.
3.75 out of 5 stars
After reading She Who Knows, I could immediately tell someone what the book was about in its entirety. With One Way Witch, I feel like the author meandered through the storyline, circling back on parts, taking the scenic route, getting lost along the way. I wonder if it is because I didn't realize I should have read Who Fears Death before I read either of these.
OWW takes places decades after SWK. Najeeba has left her first husband after a tragic ordeal, lives in Jwahir, and her second husband has passed on. Her daughter has saved the world, and in doing so, unwrote her own birth. Najeeba remembers the Before. But most don't. Instead, they feel themselves with almost-memories they can't quite grasp, and a lot of people come untethered to the lives they were living in the Before. The Nurus no longer enslave the Okeke in this new world, but the echoes of hate are still there.
Najeeba, in the interim decades, has sold cactus candy at her shop, has not gone witching, has not become the kponyungo. Now, though, she embraces those things she has long left behind. She also goes to the sorcerer, Aro, who taught her daughter, and asks him to teach her so that she can go back to the village of her birth and rid the world of The Cleanser.
Meanwhile, Dedan, an Okeke slave from Before, wanders until he comes to Jwahir. He opens up a glass shop. When he goes to Najeeba's candy store, there's an immediate connection. Dedan also begins building a glass house. Najeeba calls it a passion project, but in reality, it seems as though Dedan is compelled to build it.
As Najeeba gets further in her studies of sorcery, she finds that there is a history beyond even the history of Before, and it threatens to break her, and when someone from her past finds her in Jwahir, all her anger and rage beg for release.
Don't get me wrong. OWW was still a mesmerizing, captivating book. I don't think Okorafor has the capability of writing something that doesn't hypnotize the reader. It just felt a little...all over the place for me. Again, that might because I have not read Who Fears Death. I've only begun reading Okorafor in the last month, and this is my third book by her.
Regardless, I cannot wait for the third book in this trilogy to see where this is all going.
3.75 out of 5 stars
After reading She Who Knows, I could immediately tell someone what the book was about in its entirety. With One Way Witch, I feel like the author meandered through the storyline, circling back on parts, taking the scenic route, getting lost along the way. I wonder if it is because I didn't realize I should have read Who Fears Death before I read either of these.
OWW takes places decades after SWK. Najeeba has left her first husband after a tragic ordeal, lives in Jwahir, and her second husband has passed on. Her daughter has saved the world, and in doing so, unwrote her own birth. Najeeba remembers the Before. But most don't. Instead, they feel themselves with almost-memories they can't quite grasp, and a lot of people come untethered to the lives they were living in the Before. The Nurus no longer enslave the Okeke in this new world, but the echoes of hate are still there.
Najeeba, in the interim decades, has sold cactus candy at her shop, has not gone witching, has not become the kponyungo. Now, though, she embraces those things she has long left behind. She also goes to the sorcerer, Aro, who taught her daughter, and asks him to teach her so that she can go back to the village of her birth and rid the world of The Cleanser.
Meanwhile, Dedan, an Okeke slave from Before, wanders until he comes to Jwahir. He opens up a glass shop. When he goes to Najeeba's candy store, there's an immediate connection. Dedan also begins building a glass house. Najeeba calls it a passion project, but in reality, it seems as though Dedan is compelled to build it.
As Najeeba gets further in her studies of sorcery, she finds that there is a history beyond even the history of Before, and it threatens to break her, and when someone from her past finds her in Jwahir, all her anger and rage beg for release.
Don't get me wrong. OWW was still a mesmerizing, captivating book. I don't think Okorafor has the capability of writing something that doesn't hypnotize the reader. It just felt a little...all over the place for me. Again, that might because I have not read Who Fears Death. I've only begun reading Okorafor in the last month, and this is my third book by her.
Regardless, I cannot wait for the third book in this trilogy to see where this is all going.
April 29, 2025
Ahoy there me mateys! This book is the second in a trilogy. This novella overlaps slightly and continues after the book Who Fears Death. According to the author's foreword for this story, it should not be read without knowledge of that novel. Unlike the first book, this middle novella is lighter on action and is much more reflective. The main character, Najeeba, is training to be a sorcerer and is dealing with the trauma of the past.
What I really found fascinating wasn't Najeeba's training (as cool as it was) but the themes of memory and trauma. Najeeba's daughter, Onyesonwu, had Changed the world for the better. The problem is that people don't remember the world as it was with the exception of Najeeba and a few others. Najeeba has the memories of the Before and the Now. She has sorrow because Onyesonwu saved the world and no one remembers her. She misses her deceased husband. She misses the friends that no longer remember their prior bond. She chooses to keep going and have a greater goal rather than give up on life. Najeeba becomes better acquainted with her own power and who she wants to be. She might still make mistakes based on her trauma but she is growing and maturing in how she handles those issues.
However, just because the world became better didn't mean that all evil had left the world. Those with no memories of the Before still have residual effects from the trauma in their pasts. A person finds themselves wanting to leave a spouse or move to a new town seemingly out of the blue. This is because the trauma leaves a mark on the being. I loved the juxtaposition of Najeeba dealing with her two sets of memories and the stories and consequences of the Change on regular folk.
The other aspect that I loved was how these novellas about Najeeba wrap around and comment on Onyesonwu's story. I don't normally need the Before and Now after the saving the world but in this case how they intertwine and cause the reader to reevaluate the original novel is just so thought-provoking and wonderful. Najeeba gets to learn about her daughter on multiple levels. She even shares the same teacher. I cannot wait for the final book in the trilogy and seeing how Najeeba continues to fight evil in her past and follow Onyesonwu's legacy into the future. Arrrr!
What I really found fascinating wasn't Najeeba's training (as cool as it was) but the themes of memory and trauma. Najeeba's daughter, Onyesonwu, had Changed the world for the better. The problem is that people don't remember the world as it was with the exception of Najeeba and a few others. Najeeba has the memories of the Before and the Now. She has sorrow because Onyesonwu saved the world and no one remembers her. She misses her deceased husband. She misses the friends that no longer remember their prior bond. She chooses to keep going and have a greater goal rather than give up on life. Najeeba becomes better acquainted with her own power and who she wants to be. She might still make mistakes based on her trauma but she is growing and maturing in how she handles those issues.
However, just because the world became better didn't mean that all evil had left the world. Those with no memories of the Before still have residual effects from the trauma in their pasts. A person finds themselves wanting to leave a spouse or move to a new town seemingly out of the blue. This is because the trauma leaves a mark on the being. I loved the juxtaposition of Najeeba dealing with her two sets of memories and the stories and consequences of the Change on regular folk.
The other aspect that I loved was how these novellas about Najeeba wrap around and comment on Onyesonwu's story. I don't normally need the Before and Now after the saving the world but in this case how they intertwine and cause the reader to reevaluate the original novel is just so thought-provoking and wonderful. Najeeba gets to learn about her daughter on multiple levels. She even shares the same teacher. I cannot wait for the final book in the trilogy and seeing how Najeeba continues to fight evil in her past and follow Onyesonwu's legacy into the future. Arrrr!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 8, 2024
This novella is a fresh feel for me, a novel perspective from what I’m used to reading in the fantasy genre. The plot is a strong concept, a follow-on story from a previous novel, in which the mother of the previous main character is learning to awaken her magical powers in the way her daughter did. My favorite part of the book was these segments in which she’s fully realizing her strength and doing something fantastical, to great effect in her environment or on her life.
The writing style at times was not quite my thing, but I want to leave room for other’s tastes, so a few things I will go over that won’t affect my scoring. Read on to see if this sounds like something you’re interested in.
I could see this as a triggering text, as there is a lot of misogyny and discussion of rape. It’s pretty much the central thread of the plot. I understand it is describing a different culture, however, and the sexual mores of this culture are just different than what I’m used to. It’s not really the fact that there are characters that act agist and misogynistic exist in the book, so much as the fact that those types of interactions are the bulk of the book, so there’s nothing to balance it out. Many of the characters are rude, arrogant, and authoritarian, which can be harsh to read.
Even with the main character being this incredibly powerful woman sorceress, her entire life and essence is being talked down to by men, serving them, being used and abused by them. They fear her, put her down, make demands of her. It’s just hard to watch. Even the one man in her life who’s supposed to be decent, all she does is cook for him and sleep with him. The last 1/3 improves in this regard since it becomes more heavily plot focused and less relationships with people.
Overall, if you read and liked the main novel this was based on, I would imagine this would be something you would like to pick up. Rating this on the world building, magic system, and novelty, 3.5 stars, check it out.
*An uncorrected proof of this book was provided by the publisher at the reviewer’s request in exchange for a fair and uncompromising review.
The writing style at times was not quite my thing, but I want to leave room for other’s tastes, so a few things I will go over that won’t affect my scoring. Read on to see if this sounds like something you’re interested in.
I could see this as a triggering text, as there is a lot of misogyny and discussion of rape. It’s pretty much the central thread of the plot. I understand it is describing a different culture, however, and the sexual mores of this culture are just different than what I’m used to. It’s not really the fact that there are characters that act agist and misogynistic exist in the book, so much as the fact that those types of interactions are the bulk of the book, so there’s nothing to balance it out. Many of the characters are rude, arrogant, and authoritarian, which can be harsh to read.
Even with the main character being this incredibly powerful woman sorceress, her entire life and essence is being talked down to by men, serving them, being used and abused by them. They fear her, put her down, make demands of her. It’s just hard to watch. Even the one man in her life who’s supposed to be decent, all she does is cook for him and sleep with him. The last 1/3 improves in this regard since it becomes more heavily plot focused and less relationships with people.
Overall, if you read and liked the main novel this was based on, I would imagine this would be something you would like to pick up. Rating this on the world building, magic system, and novelty, 3.5 stars, check it out.
*An uncorrected proof of this book was provided by the publisher at the reviewer’s request in exchange for a fair and uncompromising review.
March 24, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC.
I enjoyed book 1, and as such I thought I was going to enjoy book 2. I was wrong. I am honestly not quite sure how that even happened. The drop off in writing from book 1 to 2 was extremely steep, or perhaps I didn't notice the quality in book 1 because the plot was intriguing. In book 2, the plot (what little there was) was not nearly as eye catching as the first book.
Najeeba (after a lot happens which is glossed over in a short forward/summary that made me only more confused) attempts to become a sorceress. The narration of it feels more like a script than a book, which is likely why my opinion was so low. Moreover, up until about halfway through the book, nothing really happens. She 'studies' but we aren't exactly told how.
The one major plotline was motivating but, in the end, fell flat. It did not end how the tone of the story made it seem like it would. Not even in a "ah-ah" kind of way, or a even a "twist". I'm fine with forgiveness and all that, but even after doing so, it doesn't feel like Najeeba was fine with ti, which was... strange, to say the least.
This book, as others have said, feels like set up for book 3. A bridge of sorts. It would have served better being longer, or far shorter. The plot (or at least what I assume will be the plot) for next book is to take out a specific person. This is a person that is mentioned twice throughout the book, once in the first half, once in the second, and both times with great amounts of hatred. So much hatred that they should have been a larger part of this book.
All in all, the pacing at least was good enough to turn the pages, and I did finish this one rather quickly, I think in three days or so. I know this is a complimentary series to another of Okorafor's series, but after this one, I unfortunately don't have any interest in checking them out.
I enjoyed book 1, and as such I thought I was going to enjoy book 2. I was wrong. I am honestly not quite sure how that even happened. The drop off in writing from book 1 to 2 was extremely steep, or perhaps I didn't notice the quality in book 1 because the plot was intriguing. In book 2, the plot (what little there was) was not nearly as eye catching as the first book.
Najeeba (after a lot happens which is glossed over in a short forward/summary that made me only more confused) attempts to become a sorceress. The narration of it feels more like a script than a book, which is likely why my opinion was so low. Moreover, up until about halfway through the book, nothing really happens. She 'studies' but we aren't exactly told how.
The one major plotline was motivating but, in the end, fell flat. It did not end how the tone of the story made it seem like it would. Not even in a "ah-ah" kind of way, or a even a "twist". I'm fine with forgiveness and all that, but even after doing so, it doesn't feel like Najeeba was fine with ti, which was... strange, to say the least.
This book, as others have said, feels like set up for book 3. A bridge of sorts. It would have served better being longer, or far shorter. The plot (or at least what I assume will be the plot) for next book is to take out a specific person. This is a person that is mentioned twice throughout the book, once in the first half, once in the second, and both times with great amounts of hatred. So much hatred that they should have been a larger part of this book.
All in all, the pacing at least was good enough to turn the pages, and I did finish this one rather quickly, I think in three days or so. I know this is a complimentary series to another of Okorafor's series, but after this one, I unfortunately don't have any interest in checking them out.
April 18, 2025
This is a riveting adventure through magic and time, led by a matriarch and mother of the woman who saved the world.
Let me start by what struck me here. Our hero is an older woman, not old per se, but older than most adventurers and on top of that, mother to the protagonist and heroine of the previous novel. Rather than continue with Onyesonwu's arch, we access a new story centred on her mother. Not only that, but Najeeba's future, rather than the past. And Najeeba still has much to learn.
This is a coming-of-age novel in a lot of ways, despite the age of the protagonist. This is a second life story. Najeeba embarks on an adventure to become a sorcerer, at least on the surface. Her adventure ends with a deeper dive into her psyche and the greatest personal challenge she might ever need to face in her personal history.
It's this point that I really didn't like. I hate that the obstacle women and genderful folk face is almost always sexual violence of some kind. But the story was already writ, I suppose, and a retcon may have felt evasive. The way Okorafor handles this battle is new and compelling. What if you had the power to heal all wounds?
Part of what I loved about this adventure was the wanton, no-holds-barred flight of our heroine. She experiences it all! She defies her stuffy mentor, defies societal expectations, and loves freely (if you know what I mean). All the while she grapples with her selfishness and making amends for that selfishness, even while taking good care of herself and never losing sight of her value.
The narration by Yetide Badaki was superb. Frankly, Badaki elevated Okorafor's already compelling prose.
Thank you to NetGalley and Brilliance Publishing | Brilliance Audio for the advance copy of the audiobook.
Let me start by what struck me here. Our hero is an older woman, not old per se, but older than most adventurers and on top of that, mother to the protagonist and heroine of the previous novel. Rather than continue with Onyesonwu's arch, we access a new story centred on her mother. Not only that, but Najeeba's future, rather than the past. And Najeeba still has much to learn.
This is a coming-of-age novel in a lot of ways, despite the age of the protagonist. This is a second life story. Najeeba embarks on an adventure to become a sorcerer, at least on the surface. Her adventure ends with a deeper dive into her psyche and the greatest personal challenge she might ever need to face in her personal history.
It's this point that I really didn't like. I hate that the obstacle women and genderful folk face is almost always sexual violence of some kind. But the story was already writ, I suppose, and a retcon may have felt evasive. The way Okorafor handles this battle is new and compelling. What if you had the power to heal all wounds?
Part of what I loved about this adventure was the wanton, no-holds-barred flight of our heroine. She experiences it all! She defies her stuffy mentor, defies societal expectations, and loves freely (if you know what I mean). All the while she grapples with her selfishness and making amends for that selfishness, even while taking good care of herself and never losing sight of her value.
The narration by Yetide Badaki was superb. Frankly, Badaki elevated Okorafor's already compelling prose.
Thank you to NetGalley and Brilliance Publishing | Brilliance Audio for the advance copy of the audiobook.
April 28, 2025
It's possible that if I'd read the other, related series, this would have hit harder. I really do recommend reading this in conjunction with "Who Fears Death." I had hoped that just because I'd read book 1 of this series, I'd be able to follow everything. There were notes at the beginning that helped, so I didn't feel entirely lost, but there were some things that were a bit hard to follow without context. (My own fault, of course, but I'm just suggesting that you might want to be wiser than I was.)
I really enjoy Najeeba as a character---"She Who Knows" was quite enjoyable, but I really appreciated that this book follows her as an older woman starting over. I believe she's about fifty in this book, and she's coming back into her own power after a series of devastating losses that happen off-page in this series, but which I believe are detailed in the related books. I don't see a lot of books about older female protagonists, though there have been more coming out recently, and seeing a character whose personal journey is ongoing makes me feel... hopeful, I suppose. The Najeeba of this story makes very different choices than she made in book 1, in part because of her trauma, but also because she's matured and knows herself better than she did when she was younger. At the same time, Najeeba makes different mistakes than before, often based on her fears around her prior traumas and losses.
I look forward to seeing how this series ends, especially with the hints this book provides re: future events. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC. I plan to go back and read the related books before the final installment of this series releases!
I really enjoy Najeeba as a character---"She Who Knows" was quite enjoyable, but I really appreciated that this book follows her as an older woman starting over. I believe she's about fifty in this book, and she's coming back into her own power after a series of devastating losses that happen off-page in this series, but which I believe are detailed in the related books. I don't see a lot of books about older female protagonists, though there have been more coming out recently, and seeing a character whose personal journey is ongoing makes me feel... hopeful, I suppose. The Najeeba of this story makes very different choices than she made in book 1, in part because of her trauma, but also because she's matured and knows herself better than she did when she was younger. At the same time, Najeeba makes different mistakes than before, often based on her fears around her prior traumas and losses.
I look forward to seeing how this series ends, especially with the hints this book provides re: future events. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC. I plan to go back and read the related books before the final installment of this series releases!
March 1, 2025
Nnedi Okorafor does it again!! After reading She Who Knows, I immediately fell in love with Nnedi’s writing. This sequel was no different. Not only was the writing absolutely gorgeous, but I just love being able to escape into new fantasy worlds, which this author supports you in doing. It’s just a mesmerizing and somewhat confusing (in a good way) experience as a reader.
Overall, I really enjoyed exploring more of Najeeba’s story, especially as we see her her struggle with letting go of control, mourn her ex husband and forgive people from her past, embrace agency and find love. Older Black women characters deserve all the love in fantasy stories, too. I also loved the magic and sorcery in this book, especially her training scenes. I found the bickering between the two entertaining and her reflection with the camel one of the most memorable scenes in the book. I also just love Nnedi’s refusal to fit into any boxes while writing, which made the story unique. I think people reading her work think too hard, not that they shouldn’t, but if you go into it expecting something “traditional” and stale, you’ll have no idea how to handle this story.
I do wish I understood this book’s connection to Who Fears Death because I haven’t read that one yet. At times I was confused because some of the events described in this book obviously took place in the Who Fears Death book. I only had the previous book, She Who Knows, and the prologue to lean on. Either way, I’m really looking forward to the third book in the series and hope we get to spend more time with Najeeba.
Overall, I really enjoyed exploring more of Najeeba’s story, especially as we see her her struggle with letting go of control, mourn her ex husband and forgive people from her past, embrace agency and find love. Older Black women characters deserve all the love in fantasy stories, too. I also loved the magic and sorcery in this book, especially her training scenes. I found the bickering between the two entertaining and her reflection with the camel one of the most memorable scenes in the book. I also just love Nnedi’s refusal to fit into any boxes while writing, which made the story unique. I think people reading her work think too hard, not that they shouldn’t, but if you go into it expecting something “traditional” and stale, you’ll have no idea how to handle this story.
I do wish I understood this book’s connection to Who Fears Death because I haven’t read that one yet. At times I was confused because some of the events described in this book obviously took place in the Who Fears Death book. I only had the previous book, She Who Knows, and the prologue to lean on. Either way, I’m really looking forward to the third book in the series and hope we get to spend more time with Najeeba.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 105 reviews