What do you think?
Rate this book
A Plain Man
Bestselling author Mary Ellis offers an engaging new standalone Amish romance about a prodigal seeking to find his way home. Though Caleb Beachy lived in the Englisch world for some years, he is a Plain man at heart. When he decides to return to the Amish lifestyle, he moves back home and goes to work for his father. Soon these two strong-willed men find themselves at odds. Caleb discovers there’s more to embracing his faith and reconnecting with the community than merely driving a horse and buggy and giving up Levis. Josie Yoder was just a girl when he left. All grown up now, she gives Caleb hope for the future. She soothes his frayed temper and is determined to remind him that while his faith may have wavered, God never left his side. Caleb is tempted to return Josie’s feelings, but the choices he made while away are a heavy burden on his conscience. Will past mistakes end up destroying their fledgling romance? Or will she be able to break through the wall around his heart? A Plain Man is more than just a sweet romance centered in Amish beliefs. It’s the ever-fresh story of a wounded heart finding joy, health, and healing in God’s infinite grace.
306 pages, Kindle Edition
First published April 1, 2014
32 people are currently reading
507 people want to read
About the author
Mary Ellis
36 books271 followersMary Ellis is a former schoolteacher turned USA Today bestselling author who’s written twenty-six novels including Amish fiction, historical romance, and suspense. Her first mystery, Midnight on the Mississippi, was a finalist for the RT Magazine’s Reviewer’s Choice Award and a finalist for the Daphne du Maurier Award. Her latest book is One for the Road from the Bourbon Tour Mysteries from Severn House. One Hundred Proof Murder releases August 31, 2021. Her latest Amish novella is Missing at Amazon Kindle. She enjoys gardening and bicycling and lives in Ohio with her husband and dog. www.maryellis.net or www.facebook.com/Mary.Ellis.Author
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 50 reviews
November 26, 2022
Caleb has lived 5 years, long years in the English world.
When his sister Sarah tracks him down and asks him to return, he does. But it’s a hard road back to repentance and his return to the Amish life. He rekindles his friendship with a young woman named Josie. They spend a lot of time walking, talking and rebuilding their common interests.
I appreciate an Amish theme that has a unique twist in the plot. I just recently found Mary Ellis, and I am working my way through her titles.
This was a library book.
When his sister Sarah tracks him down and asks him to return, he does. But it’s a hard road back to repentance and his return to the Amish life. He rekindles his friendship with a young woman named Josie. They spend a lot of time walking, talking and rebuilding their common interests.
I appreciate an Amish theme that has a unique twist in the plot. I just recently found Mary Ellis, and I am working my way through her titles.
This was a library book.
March 12, 2015
Hold on to your hats...
Caleb Beachy has finally returned - after five long years - to the Amish community!
But does he find it easy? Nope.
...especially with a sister like Rebekah! Oh boy, what a stinker(someone needs a smack).
His dat is the bishop, and he’s not about to make things easy on Caleb, especially since he thinks his son will give up and return to his Englisch life.
A Plain Man is a story of forgiveness… Caleb’s dat needs to forgive him for leaving, but Caleb also needs to forgive himself for all the mistakes he made while on his rumspringe - and that’s the hardest thing he’s found to do.
I admit, I felt he was being silly for the way he goes about it... and his dat isn’t pleased either - he thinks Caleb is holding on too tightly to his Englisch ways. But in many ways, I could identify... because the hardest person for me to forgive - is me.
Will Caleb be able to forgive himself and find the peace he’s looking for?
I have to mention how much I loved being continually reminded of a favorite hymn, "Come, thou fount of every blessing, tune my heart to sing thy grace...
Mary Ellis surpasses everything I expected in this book - the way Caleb thinks and acts, as well as his family and friends; it all seems much more than just believable - it's amazing!
A most excellent book! I hope you have an opportunity to read it.
September 10, 2016
Not a Plain Read! Mary Ellis is a new Author to my collection. This book is written from a different prospective. Normally Amish fiction is written from an Amish young lady or Frau's point of view. Mary chose to travel a different path and follow our hero Caleb's life choices. Caleb was/is Amish who went on an extended Rumspringa and had to find himself in his own way and time. Caleb has to decide English or Amish, Sweet Josie the Amish sweetheart or the Englisher Kristen, follow Amish rules when working or convenience of English technology, and then there is honoring the parents. Caleb's life choices and guilt takes him on a rollercoaster of emotions and keeps you reading and rooting for him and the love of his life. Don't miss this wonderful book of Faith's journey with Caleb and the Beachy family. Thanks Mary Ellis.
December 12, 2013
Sweet & Wholesome
A wholesome love story that follows the path of an Amish family. Insightful into the tribulations all families face and how with God’s help love and relationships can be restored. Well written with in-depth characters. Rocky challenges are faced and friendships are built while the romances blossom. Enjoy! NetGalley and Harvest House Publishers provided an advanced review copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
A wholesome love story that follows the path of an Amish family. Insightful into the tribulations all families face and how with God’s help love and relationships can be restored. Well written with in-depth characters. Rocky challenges are faced and friendships are built while the romances blossom. Enjoy! NetGalley and Harvest House Publishers provided an advanced review copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
March 19, 2023
What a frustrating book. Dnf
May 2, 2014
About the Book:
Bestselling author Mary Ellis offers an engaging new standalone Amish romance about a prodigal seeking to find his way home.
Though Caleb Beachy lived in the Englisch world for some years, he is a Plain man at heart. When he decides to return to the Amish lifestyle, he moves back home and goes to work for his father. Soon these two strong-willed men find themselves at odds. Caleb discovers there's more to embracing his faith and reconnecting with the community than merely driving a horse and buggy and giving up Levis.
Josie Yoder was just a girl when he left. All grown up now, she gives Caleb hope for the future. She soothes his frayed temper and is determined to remind him that while his faith may have wavered, God never left his side. Caleb is tempted to return Josie's feelings, but the choices he made while away are a heavy burden on his conscience. Will past mistakes end up destroying their fledgling romance? Or will she be able to break through the wall around his heart?
A Plain Man is more than just a sweet romance centered in Amish beliefs. It's the ever-fresh story of a wounded heart finding joy, health, and healing in God's infinite grace.
About the Author:
Mary Ellis grew up close to the Amish where she loved their peaceful agrarian lifestyle and strong sense of Christian community. She and her husband now live by the largest population of Old Order in the country where they take weekend trips to research her books. Mary enjoys reading, traveling, gardening, bicycling and swimming. Before "retiring" to write full-time, Mary taught Middle School and worked as a sales rep for Hershey Chocolate--a job with amazingly sweet fringe benefits.
My Review:
Mary Ellis, can always be counted on for her fresh outlook on Amish fiction, her latest, "A Plain Man" is no different. In this stand alone novel she introduces us to Caleb Beachy, a man returning to the Amish lifestyle trying to find out where he belongs in the world. He returns to work for his father only to learn that it won't be as easy an adjustment than anticipated, partly because he and his father don't quite see eye to eye.
Soon Caleb finds his heart entangled in feelings that he has for Josie Yoder, it makes him believe that he too, will find a forever romance that will lead to marriage. He is so worried that when she sees his past her feelings will flounder and he will lose her forever. But Josie reminds him that God has never left Him and doesn't plan to now.
**Disclosure** This book was sent to me free of charge for my honest review from the publisher.
Bestselling author Mary Ellis offers an engaging new standalone Amish romance about a prodigal seeking to find his way home.
Though Caleb Beachy lived in the Englisch world for some years, he is a Plain man at heart. When he decides to return to the Amish lifestyle, he moves back home and goes to work for his father. Soon these two strong-willed men find themselves at odds. Caleb discovers there's more to embracing his faith and reconnecting with the community than merely driving a horse and buggy and giving up Levis.
Josie Yoder was just a girl when he left. All grown up now, she gives Caleb hope for the future. She soothes his frayed temper and is determined to remind him that while his faith may have wavered, God never left his side. Caleb is tempted to return Josie's feelings, but the choices he made while away are a heavy burden on his conscience. Will past mistakes end up destroying their fledgling romance? Or will she be able to break through the wall around his heart?
A Plain Man is more than just a sweet romance centered in Amish beliefs. It's the ever-fresh story of a wounded heart finding joy, health, and healing in God's infinite grace.
About the Author:
Mary Ellis grew up close to the Amish where she loved their peaceful agrarian lifestyle and strong sense of Christian community. She and her husband now live by the largest population of Old Order in the country where they take weekend trips to research her books. Mary enjoys reading, traveling, gardening, bicycling and swimming. Before "retiring" to write full-time, Mary taught Middle School and worked as a sales rep for Hershey Chocolate--a job with amazingly sweet fringe benefits.
My Review:
Mary Ellis, can always be counted on for her fresh outlook on Amish fiction, her latest, "A Plain Man" is no different. In this stand alone novel she introduces us to Caleb Beachy, a man returning to the Amish lifestyle trying to find out where he belongs in the world. He returns to work for his father only to learn that it won't be as easy an adjustment than anticipated, partly because he and his father don't quite see eye to eye.
Soon Caleb finds his heart entangled in feelings that he has for Josie Yoder, it makes him believe that he too, will find a forever romance that will lead to marriage. He is so worried that when she sees his past her feelings will flounder and he will lose her forever. But Josie reminds him that God has never left Him and doesn't plan to now.
**Disclosure** This book was sent to me free of charge for my honest review from the publisher.
May 9, 2014
Title: A PLAIN MAN
Author: Mary Ellis
Publisher: Harvest House
April 2014
ISBN: 978-0736949804
Genre: Amish
The prodigal comes home
Though Caleb Beachy lived in the Englisch world for some years, he is a Plain man at heart. When he decides to return to the Amish lifestyle, he moves back home and goes to work for his father. Soon these two strong-willed men find themselves at odds. Caleb discovers there's more to embracing his faith and reconnecting with the community than merely driving a horse and buggy and giving up Levis.
Josie Yoder was just a girl when he left. All grown up now, she gives Caleb hope for the future. She soothes his frayed temper and is determined to remind him that while his faith may have wavered, God never left his side. Caleb is tempted to return Josie's feelings, but the choices he made while away are a heavy burden on his conscience. Will past mistakes end up destroying their fledgling romance? Or will she be able to break through the wall around his heart?
A PLAIN MAN is more than just a sweet romance centered in Amish beliefs. It's the ever-fresh story of a wounded heart finding joy, health, and healing in God's infinite grace.
Bestselling author Mary Ellis offers an engaging new standalone Amish romance about a prodigal seeking to find his way home.
A PLAIN MAN is Ms. Ellis’ most recent book. Caleb is returning to his Amish roots after five years away and he’s struggling. He feels like a boy in a man’s body when he’s at home, he’s angry and resentful at the way things turned out, and his daed seems to always be angry at him. Caleb has made some mistakes in the Englisch world, things that can’t be erased so easily.
Josie’s parents have forbidden her to get involved with Caleb—he’s a bad boy and they no longer trust him. It’s worst when some of his past sins come to light. Will the Amish community be able to forgive him for what he did during his rumspringe, or will he be forever treated with distrust?
I enjoyed reading about Caleb’s and Josie’s struggles as these two people discover each other. I hoped Caleb would get over his anger issues, stop treading his daed with disrespect, and that his daed would recognize that his belligerent son just needs love and acceptance. A good read for those who love Amish fiction. $13.99. 304 pages.
Author: Mary Ellis
Publisher: Harvest House
April 2014
ISBN: 978-0736949804
Genre: Amish
The prodigal comes home
Though Caleb Beachy lived in the Englisch world for some years, he is a Plain man at heart. When he decides to return to the Amish lifestyle, he moves back home and goes to work for his father. Soon these two strong-willed men find themselves at odds. Caleb discovers there's more to embracing his faith and reconnecting with the community than merely driving a horse and buggy and giving up Levis.
Josie Yoder was just a girl when he left. All grown up now, she gives Caleb hope for the future. She soothes his frayed temper and is determined to remind him that while his faith may have wavered, God never left his side. Caleb is tempted to return Josie's feelings, but the choices he made while away are a heavy burden on his conscience. Will past mistakes end up destroying their fledgling romance? Or will she be able to break through the wall around his heart?
A PLAIN MAN is more than just a sweet romance centered in Amish beliefs. It's the ever-fresh story of a wounded heart finding joy, health, and healing in God's infinite grace.
Bestselling author Mary Ellis offers an engaging new standalone Amish romance about a prodigal seeking to find his way home.
A PLAIN MAN is Ms. Ellis’ most recent book. Caleb is returning to his Amish roots after five years away and he’s struggling. He feels like a boy in a man’s body when he’s at home, he’s angry and resentful at the way things turned out, and his daed seems to always be angry at him. Caleb has made some mistakes in the Englisch world, things that can’t be erased so easily.
Josie’s parents have forbidden her to get involved with Caleb—he’s a bad boy and they no longer trust him. It’s worst when some of his past sins come to light. Will the Amish community be able to forgive him for what he did during his rumspringe, or will he be forever treated with distrust?
I enjoyed reading about Caleb’s and Josie’s struggles as these two people discover each other. I hoped Caleb would get over his anger issues, stop treading his daed with disrespect, and that his daed would recognize that his belligerent son just needs love and acceptance. A good read for those who love Amish fiction. $13.99. 304 pages.
March 22, 2014
Any book I’ve read by Mary Ellis makes me stop and think while enjoying a wonderful storyline and feeling like I want to be friends with the characters she has created. A Plain Man surpassed the rest of her stories by drawing me in and I found I didn’t want to leave as I turned the last page.
Not only was the storyline terrific but the subtle lessons she offered on grace and forgiveness left me thinking deeply about not only my own life but how I can extend grace to others around me. I was especially moved by Elizabeth’s speech to her husband - reminding him that even though he is the Bishop, he needs to think less about what others in the community will think about him and more about the very personal needs of his first-born son.
I love how Ms. Ellis has a gift of crafting four-dimensional people on a piece of paper. There are no cookie cutter characters in her books. She is able to write in such a way that you love each and every one of them for different reasons. They are all so unique and attractive in their own way. She makes them come alive on the page to where I imagine I can reach out and physically touch them. I can’t tell you who I fell in love with more - Caleb with his soul searching, Josie for her love of life, Sarah for her kindness, Adam for his self-consciousness, or Elizabeth for her love of family and womanly wisdom. Ms. Ellis has a gift even with the characters who are harder to love, such as Eli, Rebekah, and John. She is able to show a blend of vulnerability and humanness despite the words that they spoke.
As I said before, I love all of Ms. Ellis’ work but this book touched me deeply. She was able to accurately demonstrate the struggle I can only imagine an Amish man would feel when transitioning back into his culture after having been exposed to the English world, a position most Amish people would never put themselves in or can relate to.
I can’t wait to read Ms. Ellis’ next book. To have her gift of weaving a story with characters so real I want to be their friends is genuinely a blessing. I’ve already been spreading the word that this is a book for your must-read pile.
Not only was the storyline terrific but the subtle lessons she offered on grace and forgiveness left me thinking deeply about not only my own life but how I can extend grace to others around me. I was especially moved by Elizabeth’s speech to her husband - reminding him that even though he is the Bishop, he needs to think less about what others in the community will think about him and more about the very personal needs of his first-born son.
I love how Ms. Ellis has a gift of crafting four-dimensional people on a piece of paper. There are no cookie cutter characters in her books. She is able to write in such a way that you love each and every one of them for different reasons. They are all so unique and attractive in their own way. She makes them come alive on the page to where I imagine I can reach out and physically touch them. I can’t tell you who I fell in love with more - Caleb with his soul searching, Josie for her love of life, Sarah for her kindness, Adam for his self-consciousness, or Elizabeth for her love of family and womanly wisdom. Ms. Ellis has a gift even with the characters who are harder to love, such as Eli, Rebekah, and John. She is able to show a blend of vulnerability and humanness despite the words that they spoke.
As I said before, I love all of Ms. Ellis’ work but this book touched me deeply. She was able to accurately demonstrate the struggle I can only imagine an Amish man would feel when transitioning back into his culture after having been exposed to the English world, a position most Amish people would never put themselves in or can relate to.
I can’t wait to read Ms. Ellis’ next book. To have her gift of weaving a story with characters so real I want to be their friends is genuinely a blessing. I’ve already been spreading the word that this is a book for your must-read pile.
April 26, 2014
Let me preface this review by confessing that I don't typically choose to read Amish romances. If it weren't for the publisher mailing me a review copy, I would have skipped over A Plain Man. But receiving books through the mail is like opening a gift, meant to be savored and enjoyed. So that's what I did.
For me, the book started a bit slow because it took so long to meet the main characters, and I thought Caleb acted a bit immature through his father, Eli's, eyes, which was probably the author's intention. Eventually, I warmed to the characters and enjoyed the story: a man embarks on a journey to discover who he is emotionally and spiritually.
After living in the English world for five years, Caleb Beachy finally returned home to his Amish family. At twenty-four, he struggles with the restrictions of the Amish world and his overbearing father, who's also the district's bishop. With a floundering faith, he's unable to forgive himself for the worldly things he did while on rumschpinge. Even the budding relationship with sweet Josie Yoder does little to keep him from feeling suspended between two worlds, never quite belonging to either.
At least, he used to be spirited. Now he just seemed sad.
What was it like to not fit in anywhere? ~Josie, musing on Caleb.
A Plain Man is a story of finding oneself. It's about maintaining difficult relationships within our family and our community because we're all on this journey together. It's about forgiveness, and trusting that God's love is enough to cover the dark stains in our life, no matter how deep or how painful or how awful we think they are. When Caleb stopped focusing on himself and began to bless others, he discovered who he was and found his place in his community. I wouldn't pick up A Plain Man for the romance, but I would definitely read it again for the journey.
Disclaimer: Sending a big thank you to the author, Mary Ellis, and Harvest House Publishers, for providing me with a copy of A Plain Man in exchange for my fair and unbiased review. This opinion is my own, and I received no compensation.
For me, the book started a bit slow because it took so long to meet the main characters, and I thought Caleb acted a bit immature through his father, Eli's, eyes, which was probably the author's intention. Eventually, I warmed to the characters and enjoyed the story: a man embarks on a journey to discover who he is emotionally and spiritually.
After living in the English world for five years, Caleb Beachy finally returned home to his Amish family. At twenty-four, he struggles with the restrictions of the Amish world and his overbearing father, who's also the district's bishop. With a floundering faith, he's unable to forgive himself for the worldly things he did while on rumschpinge. Even the budding relationship with sweet Josie Yoder does little to keep him from feeling suspended between two worlds, never quite belonging to either.
At least, he used to be spirited. Now he just seemed sad.
What was it like to not fit in anywhere? ~Josie, musing on Caleb.
A Plain Man is a story of finding oneself. It's about maintaining difficult relationships within our family and our community because we're all on this journey together. It's about forgiveness, and trusting that God's love is enough to cover the dark stains in our life, no matter how deep or how painful or how awful we think they are. When Caleb stopped focusing on himself and began to bless others, he discovered who he was and found his place in his community. I wouldn't pick up A Plain Man for the romance, but I would definitely read it again for the journey.
Disclaimer: Sending a big thank you to the author, Mary Ellis, and Harvest House Publishers, for providing me with a copy of A Plain Man in exchange for my fair and unbiased review. This opinion is my own, and I received no compensation.
August 18, 2014
I was intrigued by the cover of A Plain Man by Mary Ellis. A straw hat and suspenders, a woman in a short white cap hanging clothes on a clothesline. These were not the makings of the world I know. And as I delved into the pages of the book, I was soon introduced to the Amish. The author paints a picture of Caleb Beachy, a man—not a boy—struggling to reconcile his past experiences with the rules and regulations of his Amish world, a world where he was raised and loved, a world he turned his back on for five years. Anyone who has left home, for whatever reason, knows how difficult it can be to patch the gaps. Caleb’s reconciliation comes with turmoil and yearnings. In the midst of this daily strain fall the sibling rivalries of his sisters, the constant war to understand his father, the gentle love and encouragement of his mother, and the beginnings of romantic interest with an Amish woman, Josie Yoder.
Five years in the outside world has taught Caleb enough to be an insidious thorn to his father. Can Caleb let go of his past and embrace his Amish future? Will it be enough to resort to the simple ways of his birth and family? Can he love and respect an Amish woman and not yearn for the lavish, intoxicating ways of city life? These questions form the focus of this book. I loved the author’s use of German to paint the dichotomy between the Englisch and the Amish. The simple daed and mamm and fraa evoked such a presence that, mixed with the lovely descriptions of farming life, told me so much about this culture. That lifestyle, coupled with the ongoing tension of Caleb’s unresolved dilemmas, made for a very enjoyable story.
This was first foray into Mary Ellis’s writing. I look forward to reading many more of her books.
I received this book from the Goodreads contest in exchange for an honest review.
Five years in the outside world has taught Caleb enough to be an insidious thorn to his father. Can Caleb let go of his past and embrace his Amish future? Will it be enough to resort to the simple ways of his birth and family? Can he love and respect an Amish woman and not yearn for the lavish, intoxicating ways of city life? These questions form the focus of this book. I loved the author’s use of German to paint the dichotomy between the Englisch and the Amish. The simple daed and mamm and fraa evoked such a presence that, mixed with the lovely descriptions of farming life, told me so much about this culture. That lifestyle, coupled with the ongoing tension of Caleb’s unresolved dilemmas, made for a very enjoyable story.
This was first foray into Mary Ellis’s writing. I look forward to reading many more of her books.
I received this book from the Goodreads contest in exchange for an honest review.
October 24, 2020
Holy cow, this book is incredible. I laughed, cried, laughed again, lost 15 pounds, and then cried again. I have never read an Amish romance novel before, but if there are more like this then sign me up.
Let's start with the cover image, which by itself is worth the price of the book. A hunky, aloof, and distant man stands with his face turned towards an Amish woman hanging laundry. This hunk is none other than Caleb Beachy, who is our main character in the story. After a 5-year rumspringa in the city with some regrettable decisions and lifestyle choices, Cal has turned away from city-life and is attempting to return home. Notice on the cover that his back is turned to the reader and his face is set towards an Amish community: deeply symbolic. However, he is standing at a distance. Because of the sinful and destructive life he lived in the city, he wonders if he can be forgiven by his Amish community, himself, and God.
When we follow his gaze on the cover, we see he is eyeing up none other than the wonderful, charming, and kind Josie Yoder. A respectable woman of great fortitude, Josie begins to set her hooks into Caleb with her personality, natural charm, and four-bean salad (the recipe is in the back of the book! to the ladies and fellas out there trying to impress someone, TAKE NOTE!)
Will Caleb be welcomed back into his Amish community? Will the allure of life in the city draw him back into sin? Will he find forgiveness from others? Forgiveness from God? Forgiveness from himself? Will he end up courting and marrying Josie Yoder? WILL HE EVER GET MORE OF HER FOUR-BEAN SALAD?! These questions and many more will be addressed in the pages of 'A Plain Man'.
This book is a tour de force for Amish Romance, and will leave readers in awe of the power of forgiveness and rejuvenate readers to believe again in the power of love (and four-bean salad).
Let's start with the cover image, which by itself is worth the price of the book. A hunky, aloof, and distant man stands with his face turned towards an Amish woman hanging laundry. This hunk is none other than Caleb Beachy, who is our main character in the story. After a 5-year rumspringa in the city with some regrettable decisions and lifestyle choices, Cal has turned away from city-life and is attempting to return home. Notice on the cover that his back is turned to the reader and his face is set towards an Amish community: deeply symbolic. However, he is standing at a distance. Because of the sinful and destructive life he lived in the city, he wonders if he can be forgiven by his Amish community, himself, and God.
When we follow his gaze on the cover, we see he is eyeing up none other than the wonderful, charming, and kind Josie Yoder. A respectable woman of great fortitude, Josie begins to set her hooks into Caleb with her personality, natural charm, and four-bean salad (the recipe is in the back of the book! to the ladies and fellas out there trying to impress someone, TAKE NOTE!)
Will Caleb be welcomed back into his Amish community? Will the allure of life in the city draw him back into sin? Will he find forgiveness from others? Forgiveness from God? Forgiveness from himself? Will he end up courting and marrying Josie Yoder? WILL HE EVER GET MORE OF HER FOUR-BEAN SALAD?! These questions and many more will be addressed in the pages of 'A Plain Man'.
This book is a tour de force for Amish Romance, and will leave readers in awe of the power of forgiveness and rejuvenate readers to believe again in the power of love (and four-bean salad).
April 25, 2014
Okay, I have a confession. This is the first time I've ever read an Amish novel. I still can't claim to be a fan of Amish fiction, although, I enjoyed reading about Caleb's struggle---one that most young people deal with no matter the background.
This isn't a typical Christian romance. In fact, the romance really doesn't begin until quite a bit into the book, and then it's secondary. Even though Caleb's love interest plays an important role in helping him discover where he stands with God, his family, and his past, this is a story about a young man (he's 24) who goes astray, then must convince himself and a whole community that he's changed. It's really a story about growing up and fitting in. It's a family story.
While I assumed which world he would eventually choose, the author did a good job of keeping that grain of doubt rubbing against my confidence. Would he remain Amish or go back to his Englisch life a changed and better man? And would Josie agree to live with that horrible tattoo?
Even if you're not a reader of Amish fiction, I'm sure you'll find something to relate to in this novel about finding God's grace and forgiveness, whether you're Englisch or A Plain Man.
Disclosure of Material Connection: This book came to me free from the author, Mary Ellis, and the publisher, Harvest House, with the hope that I would mention it on this blog. There was no requirement for me to write a positive review and the opinions I have expressed above are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
This isn't a typical Christian romance. In fact, the romance really doesn't begin until quite a bit into the book, and then it's secondary. Even though Caleb's love interest plays an important role in helping him discover where he stands with God, his family, and his past, this is a story about a young man (he's 24) who goes astray, then must convince himself and a whole community that he's changed. It's really a story about growing up and fitting in. It's a family story.
While I assumed which world he would eventually choose, the author did a good job of keeping that grain of doubt rubbing against my confidence. Would he remain Amish or go back to his Englisch life a changed and better man? And would Josie agree to live with that horrible tattoo?
Even if you're not a reader of Amish fiction, I'm sure you'll find something to relate to in this novel about finding God's grace and forgiveness, whether you're Englisch or A Plain Man.
Disclosure of Material Connection: This book came to me free from the author, Mary Ellis, and the publisher, Harvest House, with the hope that I would mention it on this blog. There was no requirement for me to write a positive review and the opinions I have expressed above are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
April 11, 2014
"Come, Thou Fount of every blessing, Tune my heart to sing Thy grace.....Caleb slouched down against a post. 'Plenty at first, when I had wheels and a good job. But money management didn't turn out to be my strong suit.' His friend's confusion only seemed to deepen. Caleb didn't know how much to reveal about his past. Could he admit he'd hung out in bars until closing time and bought drinks for people he'd never met before? Should he talk about sleeping with women who were little more than acquaintances? How about the fact that he'd attended church only once during his entire time in Cleveland?"......
Caleb turned to the Englisch world for several years but he has returned to his Amish family and desires nothing more than to live an upright life and marry Josie. His father doesn't trust that he won't return to the Englisch world. I have long believed that the Amish forgive and forget a person's sins if they have not joined the Amish church yet, but Caleb's father gives him a very hard time. This book is full of love and forgiveness. We all need a heavy dose of that in our lives. This is a 5 star work of Amish fiction. I have certainly had my share of mistakes and long for forgiveness for those mistakes. I could feel the emotional pain of the characters as I read. I was left with a feeling of hope and renewal when I read the last line of this book.
I was given a kindle version of this book from netgalley in exchange for my honest review.
Caleb turned to the Englisch world for several years but he has returned to his Amish family and desires nothing more than to live an upright life and marry Josie. His father doesn't trust that he won't return to the Englisch world. I have long believed that the Amish forgive and forget a person's sins if they have not joined the Amish church yet, but Caleb's father gives him a very hard time. This book is full of love and forgiveness. We all need a heavy dose of that in our lives. This is a 5 star work of Amish fiction. I have certainly had my share of mistakes and long for forgiveness for those mistakes. I could feel the emotional pain of the characters as I read. I was left with a feeling of hope and renewal when I read the last line of this book.
I was given a kindle version of this book from netgalley in exchange for my honest review.
October 5, 2014
A Plain Man is a great story of forgiving oneself, even though God and others have already forgiven you. This story struck a chord with me, because I myself know, that the hardest person for me to forgive, is also my own self.
Caleb Beachy went on his Rumspringa years and pretty much fell away from his safe Amish background. His sister, Sarah, somehow manages to convince him to return to the fold. He finds it hard to fit in to his old Amish ways and the adjustment isn't as easy or natural as he would have thought.
He reconnects with Josie Yoder, but the sins of his past haunt him and he doesn't know how she will respond to the truth and should he tell her all? With his father serving as the Bishop of their Amish congregation, this adds to his difficulties as to how to again assimilate into his old lifestyle.
Will he be able to forgive himself and will he find the peace he is looking for in his life as he carries a permanent reminder of his past on his arm.
I felt there were many feelings that were well thought through and probably something that returning Amish would truly have to deal with. Feelings of guilt and impurity as their culture would expect of them.
Will he find a way to restore himself in the good graces of God, family and himself or will he not be able to find the pathway home?
An excellent book which I hope you will all have an opportunity to read. Mary Ellis captures the feelings of many prodigal children, I am certain!
Caleb Beachy went on his Rumspringa years and pretty much fell away from his safe Amish background. His sister, Sarah, somehow manages to convince him to return to the fold. He finds it hard to fit in to his old Amish ways and the adjustment isn't as easy or natural as he would have thought.
He reconnects with Josie Yoder, but the sins of his past haunt him and he doesn't know how she will respond to the truth and should he tell her all? With his father serving as the Bishop of their Amish congregation, this adds to his difficulties as to how to again assimilate into his old lifestyle.
Will he be able to forgive himself and will he find the peace he is looking for in his life as he carries a permanent reminder of his past on his arm.
I felt there were many feelings that were well thought through and probably something that returning Amish would truly have to deal with. Feelings of guilt and impurity as their culture would expect of them.
Will he find a way to restore himself in the good graces of God, family and himself or will he not be able to find the pathway home?
An excellent book which I hope you will all have an opportunity to read. Mary Ellis captures the feelings of many prodigal children, I am certain!
April 6, 2014
I feel I need to make a disclaimer. I’ve never read an Amish book before. I wasn’t really interested because I like books with adventure, and I assumed an Amish novel wouldn’t keep my attention. But when I was asked to read this Amish novel and I saw it was a retelling of the Prodigal Son, I decided to give it a try. I love stories that use the Prodigal Son theme of redemption. So I started reading it without high expectations.
I don’t know if this is a typical Amish novel or if others would hold my attention as well. I only know that I could not put A Plain Man down. I loved the characters and gained a greater understanding of the Amish culture. My favorite parts were the underlying themes of redemption and forgiveness.
I loved how the author didn’t make it easy for Caleb to return to the Amish society, but instead showed the difficulties he would have faced. He wrestled with guilt from his past as well as changing his mentality back to Amish way. His father dealt with fear of accepting his return because he was afraid his son might leave again. When Caleb had romance in his life, he dealt with trust since he violated trust so easily. There are so many subplots and nuances to the story.
I loved this novel. It’s been awhile since a novel touched me the way this one did. Even for those resisting Amish fiction, I highly recommend it.
I don’t know if this is a typical Amish novel or if others would hold my attention as well. I only know that I could not put A Plain Man down. I loved the characters and gained a greater understanding of the Amish culture. My favorite parts were the underlying themes of redemption and forgiveness.
I loved how the author didn’t make it easy for Caleb to return to the Amish society, but instead showed the difficulties he would have faced. He wrestled with guilt from his past as well as changing his mentality back to Amish way. His father dealt with fear of accepting his return because he was afraid his son might leave again. When Caleb had romance in his life, he dealt with trust since he violated trust so easily. There are so many subplots and nuances to the story.
I loved this novel. It’s been awhile since a novel touched me the way this one did. Even for those resisting Amish fiction, I highly recommend it.
August 16, 2014
Recently I read Mary Ellis’s Civil War romance “The Quaker and the Rebel” and was immediately hooked on Civil War romances!
If I were not already a fan of Amish fiction, “A Plain Man” would make me one. It’s no wonder Mary Ellis is such a popular author!
WOW!
Mary Ellis is one of those authors that simply refuses to take the easy way – she refuses to steer clear of touchy subjects, instead meeting them head-on with wit and wisdom – showing us God’s love in a world very much in need of it!
She refuses to write simple characters, instead presenting us with REAL people – with flaws and weaknesses and real, true emotion!
And she refuses to give us an easy course, instead showing that the way of life is not always easy. Sometimes we stumble, sometimes we fall – but God is always there to pick us back up!
AMAZING!
Now, of course, I’m determined to go hunt down every single book she’s written so I can read and enjoy them all!
Some authors are content to tell a story – Mary Ellis will make you experience… EVERYTHING!
Don’t miss this book! And don’t miss her others either! Her Amish fiction is JUST as wonderful as her Civil War fiction! I know it seems a little backward that I would say it that way since she wrote Amish first… but to be fair, I started with the Civil War so…
I received this book free in exchange for an honest review.
If I were not already a fan of Amish fiction, “A Plain Man” would make me one. It’s no wonder Mary Ellis is such a popular author!
WOW!
Mary Ellis is one of those authors that simply refuses to take the easy way – she refuses to steer clear of touchy subjects, instead meeting them head-on with wit and wisdom – showing us God’s love in a world very much in need of it!
She refuses to write simple characters, instead presenting us with REAL people – with flaws and weaknesses and real, true emotion!
And she refuses to give us an easy course, instead showing that the way of life is not always easy. Sometimes we stumble, sometimes we fall – but God is always there to pick us back up!
AMAZING!
Now, of course, I’m determined to go hunt down every single book she’s written so I can read and enjoy them all!
Some authors are content to tell a story – Mary Ellis will make you experience… EVERYTHING!
Don’t miss this book! And don’t miss her others either! Her Amish fiction is JUST as wonderful as her Civil War fiction! I know it seems a little backward that I would say it that way since she wrote Amish first… but to be fair, I started with the Civil War so…
I received this book free in exchange for an honest review.
March 15, 2014
A Plain Man is the story of a man who has lived in both worlds, English and Amish. He now wants to become a full Amish man, but is dealing with some of the repercussions from some of the decisions he made living in the English world.
Caleb Beachy was gone longer than most men, when they leave their community, but after five years, has decided he want to return. Can he and his community accept his decision? Can he forgive himself of the sins he committed while live in the English world? Will he be able to conform into the person his faith requires of him?
He also has some romance on the horizon, but can Josie Yoder's family forgive him for leaving and living worldly for so long? As the Amish grapevine whispers about him, will he be able to hold his head high and finish his required classes?
Come and absorb yourself in the Amish Community, spend time at the Preaching Sunday. Enjoy the fellowship and the great meals afterward. You'll love some of the bantering that goes on. Some sibling rivalry, and family disagreements, just likes the rest of us. I so enjoyed my visit here, and hope there will be more to return to!
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publish Harvest House, and was not required to give a positive review.
Caleb Beachy was gone longer than most men, when they leave their community, but after five years, has decided he want to return. Can he and his community accept his decision? Can he forgive himself of the sins he committed while live in the English world? Will he be able to conform into the person his faith requires of him?
He also has some romance on the horizon, but can Josie Yoder's family forgive him for leaving and living worldly for so long? As the Amish grapevine whispers about him, will he be able to hold his head high and finish his required classes?
Come and absorb yourself in the Amish Community, spend time at the Preaching Sunday. Enjoy the fellowship and the great meals afterward. You'll love some of the bantering that goes on. Some sibling rivalry, and family disagreements, just likes the rest of us. I so enjoyed my visit here, and hope there will be more to return to!
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publish Harvest House, and was not required to give a positive review.
March 2, 2017
Caleb left the Amish life to be a carpenter but now has to return home because he can't find work. The people welcome him but distrust him at the same time, fearing that he has been tainted by the outside world and will not fit back in to the community.
The characters are well described and vary from a lovely young lady who would make a fine match, to the authoritarian father starting to feel his age and awkwardly, who is in charge of the building crew that Caleb joins. Poor Caleb has to give away his top of the line tools and even his work jacket. They aren't Plain. His city friends come to call and make a fine contrast in the big Amish kitchen. Caleb's sister is used to the Englisch as she helps in a local guesthouse but she does not want to lose her brother again and urges him to fit in as best he can.
We can see all points of view gradually through the story and the hand-intensive work does mean that more labourers are required from farming to barn raising, while the European breeds of draught horse working there are a valuable reservoir of genetic stock for the Belgian and Haflinger breeds. I did enjoy this lengthy book as an interesting story and a much understated romance.
The characters are well described and vary from a lovely young lady who would make a fine match, to the authoritarian father starting to feel his age and awkwardly, who is in charge of the building crew that Caleb joins. Poor Caleb has to give away his top of the line tools and even his work jacket. They aren't Plain. His city friends come to call and make a fine contrast in the big Amish kitchen. Caleb's sister is used to the Englisch as she helps in a local guesthouse but she does not want to lose her brother again and urges him to fit in as best he can.
We can see all points of view gradually through the story and the hand-intensive work does mean that more labourers are required from farming to barn raising, while the European breeds of draught horse working there are a valuable reservoir of genetic stock for the Belgian and Haflinger breeds. I did enjoy this lengthy book as an interesting story and a much understated romance.
August 21, 2014
I really enjoyed this refreshing Amish story with a strong male point of view. I haven't often seen stories about Amish people who leave for quite a few years and then return and it was interesting how Caleb had to adjust back to the Amish way of doing things after living as an Englishman for so long. He had really strayed from the straight and narrow while away, so seeing how all of his baggage affected his choices and relationships was tough. It's a good reminder that we may be forgiven, but there are always consequences. The romance was cute and I really liked the banter Caleb and Josie had with each other. Josie was such a fun, spunky character! I enjoyed both her and his sister, Sarah's, viewpoints, too. I thought what Caleb decided to do was unique when he was struggling with all of the sins of his past, but wondered how it could really fit with his Amish faith. I was pretty frustrated with his father and how stubborn and almost mean he could be when his children disagreed with him, especially since he was the bishop. Caleb's other sister was a piece of work, too! I liked most of the characters, though, and would definitely recommend this story to Amish fiction lovers!
I received this book free from Harvest House Publishers in exchange for an honest review.
I received this book free from Harvest House Publishers in exchange for an honest review.
June 15, 2016
A Plain Man written by Mary Ellis is a heartwarming book about forgiveness, love, and faith. When Caleb Beachy returns home after 5 years living in Cleveland, Ohio he finds he is welcomed by some and practically shunned by others. Caleb knows he has his work cut out for him to prove he has returned to the Amish faith for good.
While Caleb's friends have accepted him back his daed, who is also the Bishop, is keeping a close eye on him. Caleb is determined to win his father's trust back, but will taking a job working for his daed be the way to do it? Will he cause more harm than good?
When Caleb meets up with Josie Yoder after his time away will she accept him back into her life? Will Caleb be able to prove himself worthy of Josie's trust? What secret is Caleb hiding from Josie that could split them up for good?
I did not receive a complimentary copy of this book but I felt compelled to submit my honest review! I highly recommend this book to all those who love to read the Amish genre and love heartwarming stories of love and forgiveness. I also rated A Plain Man with 5 stars for a well written story. I will be watching for Mary Ellis to publish her next book.
While Caleb's friends have accepted him back his daed, who is also the Bishop, is keeping a close eye on him. Caleb is determined to win his father's trust back, but will taking a job working for his daed be the way to do it? Will he cause more harm than good?
When Caleb meets up with Josie Yoder after his time away will she accept him back into her life? Will Caleb be able to prove himself worthy of Josie's trust? What secret is Caleb hiding from Josie that could split them up for good?
I did not receive a complimentary copy of this book but I felt compelled to submit my honest review! I highly recommend this book to all those who love to read the Amish genre and love heartwarming stories of love and forgiveness. I also rated A Plain Man with 5 stars for a well written story. I will be watching for Mary Ellis to publish her next book.
September 2, 2016
Totally enjoyed this book. Caleb has returned from five years "among the English" filled with I wish I had not done almost everything I did.
He receives love from his family although his father, the bishop, watches him carefully. But not for the reasons Caleb thinks -- Eli is afraid he will lose his much loved son again. He even finds love from an Amish girl, who is now very much a woman.
What I especially liked about this book was how the author dealt with the struggles that Caleb goes through. As well as his father who must walk the line between fatherhood and being the bishop. Some writers make the transfer from living in the English world back to Amish too easy. They miss stuff like electricity, cars, even music -- but they seldom seem to deal with their past of that English life. This book did.
Of course, I'd love to turn Rebekah, Caleb's youngest sister, over my knee and ... or ground her to her room ... stand in the corner ... any number of things her attitude would summon. You'll find out as you read the book ...
He receives love from his family although his father, the bishop, watches him carefully. But not for the reasons Caleb thinks -- Eli is afraid he will lose his much loved son again. He even finds love from an Amish girl, who is now very much a woman.
What I especially liked about this book was how the author dealt with the struggles that Caleb goes through. As well as his father who must walk the line between fatherhood and being the bishop. Some writers make the transfer from living in the English world back to Amish too easy. They miss stuff like electricity, cars, even music -- but they seldom seem to deal with their past of that English life. This book did.
Of course, I'd love to turn Rebekah, Caleb's youngest sister, over my knee and ... or ground her to her room ... stand in the corner ... any number of things her attitude would summon. You'll find out as you read the book ...
January 3, 2018
I enjoyed this book and found it well written. The book shows us a story of a young mans struggle to find his way back home to the Amish world. Very much a prodigal son's coming home this store is.
The characters are well developed and could be someone that you know or have meet. They could be someone living next door to you. I came to cheering Caleb the main character on is his struggle to fit back into the Amish community. He is not sure everyone is ready to welcome him back. Caleb's father is one of them.
Caleb's father loves his son but struggle with if his son is ready to come but to the plain life. Both men are strong will and butt heads on what is right to them. Caleb's father worries that he could loose his son again to the English world. We watch as Caleb struggle with his faith and trying to win over the girl he loves.
Can Caleb find his way back and show his father that he belongs and win the girl he loves.
The characters are well developed and could be someone that you know or have meet. They could be someone living next door to you. I came to cheering Caleb the main character on is his struggle to fit back into the Amish community. He is not sure everyone is ready to welcome him back. Caleb's father is one of them.
Caleb's father loves his son but struggle with if his son is ready to come but to the plain life. Both men are strong will and butt heads on what is right to them. Caleb's father worries that he could loose his son again to the English world. We watch as Caleb struggle with his faith and trying to win over the girl he loves.
Can Caleb find his way back and show his father that he belongs and win the girl he loves.
April 10, 2014
Caleb Beachy left his Amish home for the Englisch world, where he squandered his money on women and beer. He returns home in shame.
His father is the bishop of their district. He treats Caleb as a boy whom he doesn’t trust to stay.
Caleb resents the treatment. Matters don’t improve when Caleb joins his dad’s construction crew. His mother mediates between them, and eventually his dad realizes he may have been the cause for Caleb leaving home in the first place.
Caleb is smitten with Josie Yoder, but will she, a proper Amish young lady, want a man with “Kristen” tattooed on his arm? They’re heading toward marriage, but Caleb breaks up because he doesn’t feel good enough for her. Then Josie gets an idea that may help him, even though their parents think it’s nonsense.
This is one of Mary Ellis’ best works yet.
His father is the bishop of their district. He treats Caleb as a boy whom he doesn’t trust to stay.
Caleb resents the treatment. Matters don’t improve when Caleb joins his dad’s construction crew. His mother mediates between them, and eventually his dad realizes he may have been the cause for Caleb leaving home in the first place.
Caleb is smitten with Josie Yoder, but will she, a proper Amish young lady, want a man with “Kristen” tattooed on his arm? They’re heading toward marriage, but Caleb breaks up because he doesn’t feel good enough for her. Then Josie gets an idea that may help him, even though their parents think it’s nonsense.
This is one of Mary Ellis’ best works yet.
June 25, 2014
A Plain Man
Mary Ellis
Copyright 2014
Hello Fellow Readers would you like to journey with me to Ohio? Just pick up A Plain Man by Mary Ellis and off we go.
Sarah is relieved when her brother comes back to there Amish community after five years for part of that time he was on his Rumpspringa. Caleb still has friends from his time in the Englisch world and finds it hard to let some things in the life he had before he came back to the Amish world.
Csleb is happy to be back home especially happy to reunite with his teenage love Josie Yoder.
Will Caleb be able to stay with his plain lifestyle or will he ho back to the Englisch world he was part of for five years?
Will Caleb and Josie Yoder get married and live happily ever after?
Five out of five stars for an amazing book.
Happy Reading Friends
Michelle
Mary Ellis
Copyright 2014
Hello Fellow Readers would you like to journey with me to Ohio? Just pick up A Plain Man by Mary Ellis and off we go.
Sarah is relieved when her brother comes back to there Amish community after five years for part of that time he was on his Rumpspringa. Caleb still has friends from his time in the Englisch world and finds it hard to let some things in the life he had before he came back to the Amish world.
Csleb is happy to be back home especially happy to reunite with his teenage love Josie Yoder.
Will Caleb be able to stay with his plain lifestyle or will he ho back to the Englisch world he was part of for five years?
Will Caleb and Josie Yoder get married and live happily ever after?
Five out of five stars for an amazing book.
Happy Reading Friends
Michelle
May 1, 2014
I've long enjoyed Mary Ellis's books, and A Plain Man is no different. Caleb's story is a touching story of a wayward son coming home. Except it's not an easy transition. With a little help from his sister's best friend, Josie, Caleb discovers some things about himself that threaten his future. I hate spoilers, so I won't tell you more; you'll have to read it to find out the good stuff.
A Plain Man is a quick look into the life of an Amish man who stepped away from his upbringing and has much to regret about his life. Upon returning to his roots, he is determined to do the right thing.
***I received this book from the publisher/author for the purpose of review. The above is my honest opinion.***
A Plain Man is a quick look into the life of an Amish man who stepped away from his upbringing and has much to regret about his life. Upon returning to his roots, he is determined to do the right thing.
***I received this book from the publisher/author for the purpose of review. The above is my honest opinion.***
April 30, 2014
I thoroughly enjoyed every minute of reading this book!! It was a beautiful story of love, humor, anger and forgiveness. The book is about a young Amish man who returns home to his family after living in the English world for 5 years. Not everyone is willing to accept him and many are skeptical about his intentions. I felt like I almost knew this family after reading this book! I couldn't put it down! The song lyrics that are shared throughout the book are a great comfort and addition. I highly recommend this book! Mary Ellis has done another fantastic job!!!
March 19, 2014
Caleb has returned to his Amish family after being away for 5 years. After a difficult homecoming, even his father has forgiven him. Can Caleb forgive himself? Will the girl he once longed for still love him?
I loved this book. There was one twist that I did not enjoy so much, but I will not spoil it for the readers. Overall, I thought the characters were well laid-out. The plot was relatable. This is a book to read and recommend.
I loved this book. There was one twist that I did not enjoy so much, but I will not spoil it for the readers. Overall, I thought the characters were well laid-out. The plot was relatable. This is a book to read and recommend.
August 13, 2016
Caleb Beachy has come back home after 5 years of trying to be English. Can he go back to being Amish? Will his father ever trust him again? Can he win back his first love?
October 14, 2019
Excellent Story
This is sn excellent story. I look forward to reading the next one. Mary Ellis is an excellent author. I love her Amish books. 🙂
This is sn excellent story. I look forward to reading the next one. Mary Ellis is an excellent author. I love her Amish books. 🙂
October 13, 2022
A Plain Man is a wonderful story about a young man, Caleb, that left the Amish, but after five years has returned and decided to commit to the Amish lifestyle. He meets up with Josie, a neighbor he hasn't seen in five years, but they get reacquainted. he is nervous because he was a terrible person while he was gone, and he doesn't know if it will be a problem with her in the future and he doesn't know how to put his past behind him. A well written, wonderful, clean story I loved!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 50 reviews