I LOVED this book! I was fortunate enough to get an ARC from the author and once I started reading, I couldn't put it down. I think by page 17 I was already hooked and knew this was going to be a good one. The summary up top does a good job so I won't repeat it here, but I give this book all of the stars possible and highly recommend you grab a copy when it comes out in August 2024!
Editing my review here because I think there's a few things that could use some clarity. I've seen a few reviews about how it's not a "realistic" portrayal of a victim of SA, how the "rules" of time travel aren't spelled out/followed/questions are left unanswered, how the religious element didn't hit right etc. and I wanted to explain how I can still LOVE this book and speak nothing but good things about it.
I'm one of those readers who just loves a good story. It doesn't have to make 100% perfect sense, be 100% accurate to reality, answer every single question I can come up with, or let me be able to expound upon it in a way that impresses those around me with how well-rounded/educated/informed/etc I am. No offense to those who want their stories to do all of this, of course. I just love to read, to escape into a different world. No author can answer every question my brain will conjure and if a character isn't true to life, oh well. That's the joy of fiction! (And maybe they just aren't true to the people I've met in my life - who's to say they aren't accurate to other people in life?)
I can understand the commentary on how having s*x to overcome trauma doesn't feel like a realistic portrayal of someone who has been assaulted, but not everything has to be realistic. Sometimes an easy solution like that is what we WANT to be able to have happen, not necessarily something that DOES happen. Who wouldn't want to be able to fix their trauma just by getting back on the horse, as it were? Or how people are frustrated that women who time travel are always subject to s*xual assault or (g)rape. If you want realism, I think that's pretty much it. We know how prevalent violence toward women is today and we know that culturally it was even worse throughout history, so I think it's actually very realistic to have women who travel to the past have to deal with this situation. Same with falling in love with "anyone who crosses their path". We are human, we're social creatures. Can you imagine being thrown into a time not your own, a culture not your own, and having to survive? Of course you would cleave on to someone, anyone who would be kind and understanding, and I think that is a form of love.
I love that we see so much of the training and the build up before the time travel - even in movies I'll find myself watching the training/build up scenes over and over and then not caring as much about the final battle or whatever it is. It's the growth of the character that happens during those training/building sessions that draws me in.
The 'rules of time travel' issue though.....It's freakin' time travel. There are no rules! I adored how the time travel in this book worked and that some of the questions asked can be left up to the imagination of the reader. Personally, I think that if time travel was possible and we could make drastic changes like this, God or whatever higher power you hold sacred would have already planned this out so that when humanity makes changes, people don't disappear and such. Kind of like how in Outlander, Claire heals so many people and thinks about all the lives she's changed - but who's to say that she wasn't already accounted for. She thought that by killing Jack Randall her husband in modern times wouldn't exist, only to find out that the actual ancestor was Jack's brother.
The religious angle/piece hit home so hard for me. Not only the commentary that I "heard" from the author on the duty we have to care for our earth (which, interestingly enough was a theme I've spoken about with more religious family members before), but also the use of what historically was a very strong dependence on the church to effect positive change.
Overall, still a million stars for this book because I couldn't put it down, I still think about it when people ask me if I have any recommendations (which they do a lot because I own a bookstore), and I want to read the stories of the 22 Heroes that came before Sloan - all of which are signs of a fantastic story that stuck with me and made me want more from this author :)