What do you think?
Rate this book
Return to the Canadian West #1
Kam zavolá odvaha
Jej odvahu a srdce čakajú skúšky, s akými nerátala…
Beth Thatcherová strávila celý život v bezpečnom a pohodlnom svete rodiny, priateľov a spoločenských podujatí, ktorý jej zaručilo otcovo bohatstvo. Na prekvapenie všetkých však prijme miesto učiteľky v drsnom podhorí západnej Kanady. Inšpirovaná svojou tetou Elizabeth, ktorá pred rokmi odišla učiť na západ, a za povzbudzovania svojho otca sa Beth rozhodne dôverovať Bohu a zvládnuť všetky prekážky, ktoré sa jej postavia do cesty.
Podmienky v Uhoľnom údolí sú však ešte horšie, než sa obávala. Nedávne banské nešťastie zanechalo mestečko, kde všetko ovláda ťažobná spoločnosť, ponorené v zármutku. Predchádzajúci učiteľ poskytol tamojším deťom veľmi chabé základy a mnohí z miestnych obyvateľov ani nehovoria po anglicky. Nie je tam dokonca ani škola. Beth navyše rieši aj citový problém, jej srdce je rozpoltené medzi dvoma mladými mužmi. Obaja slúžia v horskej polícii: jedného pozná prakticky odmalička, druhého stretla až v Uhoľnom údolí – je to láskavý, mierny muž, ktorý jej vždy ochotne podal pomocnú ruku.
Napriek prekážkam je Beth odhodlaná zmeniť zapadnuté horské mestečko k lepšiemu. Keď ju však príde z východu navštíviť sestra, pripomenie jej luxus, ktorého sa svojím rozhodnutím odísť na západ Beth vzdala. Vráti sa po skončení školského roka k privilegovanému životu v kruhu svojej rodiny?
Beth Thatcherová strávila celý život v bezpečnom a pohodlnom svete rodiny, priateľov a spoločenských podujatí, ktorý jej zaručilo otcovo bohatstvo. Na prekvapenie všetkých však prijme miesto učiteľky v drsnom podhorí západnej Kanady. Inšpirovaná svojou tetou Elizabeth, ktorá pred rokmi odišla učiť na západ, a za povzbudzovania svojho otca sa Beth rozhodne dôverovať Bohu a zvládnuť všetky prekážky, ktoré sa jej postavia do cesty.
Podmienky v Uhoľnom údolí sú však ešte horšie, než sa obávala. Nedávne banské nešťastie zanechalo mestečko, kde všetko ovláda ťažobná spoločnosť, ponorené v zármutku. Predchádzajúci učiteľ poskytol tamojším deťom veľmi chabé základy a mnohí z miestnych obyvateľov ani nehovoria po anglicky. Nie je tam dokonca ani škola. Beth navyše rieši aj citový problém, jej srdce je rozpoltené medzi dvoma mladými mužmi. Obaja slúžia v horskej polícii: jedného pozná prakticky odmalička, druhého stretla až v Uhoľnom údolí – je to láskavý, mierny muž, ktorý jej vždy ochotne podal pomocnú ruku.
Napriek prekážkam je Beth odhodlaná zmeniť zapadnuté horské mestečko k lepšiemu. Keď ju však príde z východu navštíviť sestra, pripomenie jej luxus, ktorého sa svojím rozhodnutím odísť na západ Beth vzdala. Vráti sa po skončení školského roka k privilegovanému životu v kruhu svojej rodiny?
328 pages, Paperback
First published February 4, 2014
998 people are currently reading
4072 people want to read
About the author
Janette Oke
347 books3,448 followersJanette Oke is a Canadian author known for her inspirational fiction, often set in a pioneer era and focused on female protagonists. Her debut novel, Love Comes Softly (1979), became the foundation for a successful series, followed by over 75 other novels. The first book in her Canadian West series, When Calls the Heart (1983), inspired the popular television series of the same name.
Born in Champion, Alberta, to farmers Fred and Amy (née Ruggles) Steeves during the Great Depression, Oke went on to graduate from Mountain View Bible College in Didsbury, Alberta, where she met her future husband, Edward Oke, who later became the president of the college. The couple has four children, including a daughter who has collaborated with Janette on several books.
A committed Evangelical Christian, Oke has authored numerous works exploring themes of faith. She has received various accolades for her contributions to Christian fiction, including the 1992 President's Award from the Evangelical Christian Publishers Association and the 1999 CBA Life Impact Award.
Born in Champion, Alberta, to farmers Fred and Amy (née Ruggles) Steeves during the Great Depression, Oke went on to graduate from Mountain View Bible College in Didsbury, Alberta, where she met her future husband, Edward Oke, who later became the president of the college. The couple has four children, including a daughter who has collaborated with Janette on several books.
A committed Evangelical Christian, Oke has authored numerous works exploring themes of faith. She has received various accolades for her contributions to Christian fiction, including the 1992 President's Award from the Evangelical Christian Publishers Association and the 1999 CBA Life Impact Award.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 405 reviews
January 1, 2018
There is nothing like a good Janette Oke book. Like I've mentioned before, hers is an older style of writing, so you either love it or not love it. I enjoyed the setting thoroughly and me being musical and a teacher, I appreciated those elements greatly.
What I appreciated most was the strong spiritual thread. Wow. From pretty much page one, there was a decided spiritual thread. Beth and the other characters had a lot of things they went through, and through it all, they sought the Lord and tried to do what was right Biblically. It was one of those inspiring reads.
There was the backdrop of romance in this book--I suppose the set-up for more to come in books two and three, but overall, it wasn't a strong romance thread.
What I appreciated most was the strong spiritual thread. Wow. From pretty much page one, there was a decided spiritual thread. Beth and the other characters had a lot of things they went through, and through it all, they sought the Lord and tried to do what was right Biblically. It was one of those inspiring reads.
There was the backdrop of romance in this book--I suppose the set-up for more to come in books two and three, but overall, it wasn't a strong romance thread.
January 31, 2014
My love for Christian fiction was inspired by Frank Peretti, Michael Phillips and Janette Oke. I think I’ve read every book Janette Oke has ever published. She effectively created Christian prairie fiction with the Love Comes Softly series. She introduced me to Canada and inspired an enduring respect for the hardworking settlers and the Mounties with When Calls the Heart.
When Courage Calls is co-authored by Janette and her daughter, Laurel Oke Logan, and it’s just as good as the early books. It features Beth Thatcher, a young relative of Elizabeth (from When Calls the Heart), and Beth is following her aunt’s footsteps by leaving the security of her well-to-do Toronto home to take a job teaching in the West—Coal Valley, a mining town, in the 1920’s.
It’s not a romance (although there are romantic elements). It’s the story of a young woman from a privileged upbringing who finds herself serving in a small town with no conveniences (no shops—not even indoor plumbing). As the story progresses, she is challenged by people and circumstances, and learns to rely on God for guidance in times of difficulty. It’s reminiscent of the story of Elizabeth Thatcher, but it’s also entirely Beth’s own story.
Recommended for all Janette Oke fans. If you’ve read and enjoyed the When Calls the Heart books, you’ll enjoy this. It is a standalone novel, as there are only passing references to the earlier books and locations, and this is set in a new time and place. So if you haven’t read When Calls the Heart, you can still enjoy When Courage Calls.
Thanks to Bethany House and NetGalley for providing a free ebook for review.
When Courage Calls is co-authored by Janette and her daughter, Laurel Oke Logan, and it’s just as good as the early books. It features Beth Thatcher, a young relative of Elizabeth (from When Calls the Heart), and Beth is following her aunt’s footsteps by leaving the security of her well-to-do Toronto home to take a job teaching in the West—Coal Valley, a mining town, in the 1920’s.
It’s not a romance (although there are romantic elements). It’s the story of a young woman from a privileged upbringing who finds herself serving in a small town with no conveniences (no shops—not even indoor plumbing). As the story progresses, she is challenged by people and circumstances, and learns to rely on God for guidance in times of difficulty. It’s reminiscent of the story of Elizabeth Thatcher, but it’s also entirely Beth’s own story.
Recommended for all Janette Oke fans. If you’ve read and enjoyed the When Calls the Heart books, you’ll enjoy this. It is a standalone novel, as there are only passing references to the earlier books and locations, and this is set in a new time and place. So if you haven’t read When Calls the Heart, you can still enjoy When Courage Calls.
Thanks to Bethany House and NetGalley for providing a free ebook for review.
February 12, 2014
Age Appropriate For: 11 and up for reading level and mildly scary scenes
Best for Ages: 15 and up
It has been far too long since I have read any book by Janette Oke. I read her entire Love Comes Softly series, Seasons of the Heart series, The Canadian West series, and a couple others of her stand-alone books. However, over the past few years I haven’t read any of them. I had forgotten how much I had loved her books.
This story was a refreshing change from the books I have been reading. Beth was neither shy or submissive to a fault, or so strong and boyish as to lose her femininity. Beth was sweet, but was also courageous. She wanted to teach despite her mother’s protests, without hating her parents. She wanted to have a job, without thinking that homemaking was stupid. She wasn’t a stereotype character.
The story itself was a slower pace than many I have read lately. There isn’t any heavy romance, or heart-stopping action. It is about the day-to-day struggle of Beth trying to teach in primitive situations, and help a mining town that has been devastated by a recent cave-in. There isn’t much action, yet the story pulled at my heartstrings and kept me turning the pages.
The cast of characters was rich and diverse. From the kind hearted, Italian miner, to the kind and wise woman who runs the boarding house, to the children in the class room; the characters were so real.
I really enjoyed that the romance, although a part of the story, wasn’t the main element of the book. As much as I love a good romance, it is nice to have some books that are not all about passion and romance.
I highly recommend this book for readers who love Jennet Oke, light romance, and stories of courageous women.
I received this book from Bethany House in exchange for my honest review. I was under no obligation to write a positive review. The opinions in this review are entirely my own.
Why no voting buttons? We don't let custo
Best for Ages: 15 and up
It has been far too long since I have read any book by Janette Oke. I read her entire Love Comes Softly series, Seasons of the Heart series, The Canadian West series, and a couple others of her stand-alone books. However, over the past few years I haven’t read any of them. I had forgotten how much I had loved her books.
This story was a refreshing change from the books I have been reading. Beth was neither shy or submissive to a fault, or so strong and boyish as to lose her femininity. Beth was sweet, but was also courageous. She wanted to teach despite her mother’s protests, without hating her parents. She wanted to have a job, without thinking that homemaking was stupid. She wasn’t a stereotype character.
The story itself was a slower pace than many I have read lately. There isn’t any heavy romance, or heart-stopping action. It is about the day-to-day struggle of Beth trying to teach in primitive situations, and help a mining town that has been devastated by a recent cave-in. There isn’t much action, yet the story pulled at my heartstrings and kept me turning the pages.
The cast of characters was rich and diverse. From the kind hearted, Italian miner, to the kind and wise woman who runs the boarding house, to the children in the class room; the characters were so real.
I really enjoyed that the romance, although a part of the story, wasn’t the main element of the book. As much as I love a good romance, it is nice to have some books that are not all about passion and romance.
I highly recommend this book for readers who love Jennet Oke, light romance, and stories of courageous women.
I received this book from Bethany House in exchange for my honest review. I was under no obligation to write a positive review. The opinions in this review are entirely my own.
Why no voting buttons? We don't let custo
February 23, 2016
About this book:
“Her courage and her heart will be tested in ways she never expected...
Beth Thatcher has spent her entire life in the safe, comfortable world of her family, her friends, and the social outings her father's wealth provides. But Beth is about to leave it all behind to accept a teaching position in the rugged foothills of western Canada. Inspired by her aunt Elizabeth, who went west to teach school several years ago, and gently encouraged by her father, Beth resolves to put her trust in God and bravely face any challenge that comes her way.
But the conditions in Coal Valley are even worse than she'd feared. A recent mining accident has left the town grieving and at the mercy of the mining company. The children have had very little prior education, and many of the locals don't even speak English. There isn't even a proper schoolhouse. In addition, Beth's heart is torn between two young men--both Mounties, one a lifelong friend and the other a kind, quiet man who comes to her aid more than once.
Despite the many challenges, Beth is determined to make a difference in the rustic frontier town. But when her sister visits from the East, reminding her of all the luxuries she's had to give up, will Beth decide to return to her privileged life as soon as the school year is over?
A special companion story to Hallmark Channel's "When Calls the Heart" TV series.”
Series: Book #1 in the “Return to the Canadian West” series. {There is another series that follows Beth’s aunt, Elizabeth, called the “Canadian West” series. Read Reviews of #1 Here, #2 Here, #3 Here, #4 Here, #5 Here, and #6 Here. You do not have to read the first series to understand this one, but it’s a great series to read. :) }
Spiritual Content- Many, many Prayers; Many, many Talks about God, the Bible & Witnessing; ‘H’s are capital when referring to God; Scriptures are quoted, read & mentioned; Mentions of those in the Bible; Church going & Hymns are sung; Bible studies & plays; Christmas, carols & a play.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘blamed’, and a ‘who the blazes’; Mentions of curses said but not written; A mention of a dead deer (barely-above-not-detailed); A couple mentions of spankings; Mentions of gambling, liquor & drinking.
Sexual Content- A gossip that miners have two wives; Mentions of flirting; A bit of noticing & the emotions.
-Beth Thatcher
P.O.V. of Beth
Set in the 1920s (I believe)
329 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- Two Stars
New Teens- Four Stars
Early High School Teens- Five Stars
Older High School Teens- Four Stars
My personal Rating- Four Stars
My goodness! I’m trying not to compare it to the TV show, but though they are very different, I really, really enjoyed “Where Courage Calls”. Not really anything like the TV show (which I wasn’t expecting it to be) but it was still great.
Link to review:
http://booksforchristiangirls.blogspo...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
“Her courage and her heart will be tested in ways she never expected...
Beth Thatcher has spent her entire life in the safe, comfortable world of her family, her friends, and the social outings her father's wealth provides. But Beth is about to leave it all behind to accept a teaching position in the rugged foothills of western Canada. Inspired by her aunt Elizabeth, who went west to teach school several years ago, and gently encouraged by her father, Beth resolves to put her trust in God and bravely face any challenge that comes her way.
But the conditions in Coal Valley are even worse than she'd feared. A recent mining accident has left the town grieving and at the mercy of the mining company. The children have had very little prior education, and many of the locals don't even speak English. There isn't even a proper schoolhouse. In addition, Beth's heart is torn between two young men--both Mounties, one a lifelong friend and the other a kind, quiet man who comes to her aid more than once.
Despite the many challenges, Beth is determined to make a difference in the rustic frontier town. But when her sister visits from the East, reminding her of all the luxuries she's had to give up, will Beth decide to return to her privileged life as soon as the school year is over?
A special companion story to Hallmark Channel's "When Calls the Heart" TV series.”
Series: Book #1 in the “Return to the Canadian West” series. {There is another series that follows Beth’s aunt, Elizabeth, called the “Canadian West” series. Read Reviews of #1 Here, #2 Here, #3 Here, #4 Here, #5 Here, and #6 Here. You do not have to read the first series to understand this one, but it’s a great series to read. :) }
Spiritual Content- Many, many Prayers; Many, many Talks about God, the Bible & Witnessing; ‘H’s are capital when referring to God; Scriptures are quoted, read & mentioned; Mentions of those in the Bible; Church going & Hymns are sung; Bible studies & plays; Christmas, carols & a play.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘blamed’, and a ‘who the blazes’; Mentions of curses said but not written; A mention of a dead deer (barely-above-not-detailed); A couple mentions of spankings; Mentions of gambling, liquor & drinking.
Sexual Content- A gossip that miners have two wives; Mentions of flirting; A bit of noticing & the emotions.
-Beth Thatcher
P.O.V. of Beth
Set in the 1920s (I believe)
329 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- Two Stars
New Teens- Four Stars
Early High School Teens- Five Stars
Older High School Teens- Four Stars
My personal Rating- Four Stars
My goodness! I’m trying not to compare it to the TV show, but though they are very different, I really, really enjoyed “Where Courage Calls”. Not really anything like the TV show (which I wasn’t expecting it to be) but it was still great.
Link to review:
http://booksforchristiangirls.blogspo...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
April 24, 2023
Another great book by Janette Oke! I have read so many of her books and loved them. Beth is beginning a new chapter in her life in Coal Valley, where she will teach the children. However, she soon learns this town and the people are nothing like what she has grown up with and accustomed to all her life. This book was filled with moments of faith, laughter, and learning. Anyone who has seen the Hallmark show “ When Calls the Heart” would enjoy this book.
April 6, 2015
I love Janette Oke’s books, and her newest release was no exception! It took me about 70 pages to really get into this book but, after that, I flew through it.
The characters were really nice to read about, and I really liked all of them–Frank Russo being my favorite. The character development was set at a realistic pace, and it was prominent. So many books that I have read show very little character development which is frustrating. I love it when the main character learns something and it changes them–be it for the good or bad–by the end of the novel.
If you’re looking for a romance-based novel, I don’t think you’ll find it here. A love triangle is there, but it doesn’t completely take over the storyline. This novel is more about Beth learning to follow God’s leading and how to make wise decisions in difficult situations.
Where Courage Calls, is a breath of fresh air, and I can’t wait to continue on with the series. I’m going to give this novel 5/5 stars because I highly enjoyed it!
*I was not sent this for review by the publisher or author. All opinions are my own. I was in no way compensated for this review.
The characters were really nice to read about, and I really liked all of them–Frank Russo being my favorite. The character development was set at a realistic pace, and it was prominent. So many books that I have read show very little character development which is frustrating. I love it when the main character learns something and it changes them–be it for the good or bad–by the end of the novel.
If you’re looking for a romance-based novel, I don’t think you’ll find it here. A love triangle is there, but it doesn’t completely take over the storyline. This novel is more about Beth learning to follow God’s leading and how to make wise decisions in difficult situations.
Where Courage Calls, is a breath of fresh air, and I can’t wait to continue on with the series. I’m going to give this novel 5/5 stars because I highly enjoyed it!
*I was not sent this for review by the publisher or author. All opinions are my own. I was in no way compensated for this review.
January 10, 2016
Qui l'eut cru ? Mais j'ai beaucoup beaucoup aimé ... une romance inspirationnelle.
Bon, j'avoue que peut être le charme de la série tv a fonctionné et que grâce à cela les moments où j'ai levé les yeux au ciel à cause du côté très religieux, ont moins compté! En même temps, j'ai grandit en regardant La petite maison dans la prairie et ensuite, plus grande, j'ai révassé devant Docteur Quinn, on est clairement dans le même genre.
"Bondieuseries" mises à part, j'ai apprécié ici que l'histoire soit plus âpres, moins facile pour Elizabeth "Beth". Coal Valley est moins idyllique, plus rude et pauvre mais les habitants tout aussi chaleureux. ET même si on ne retrouve pas les personnages auxquels on est habitué, on s'attache à tous ces hommes et femmes pauvres mais dignes et bien plus humains.
Et l'histoire d'amour alors? Il n'y en a pas ... Enfin, elle pointe le bout de son nez tout doucement. C'est clairement une histoire qui se fera sur plusieurs tomes. L'intrigue commence au même point que le téléfilm pilote. Le cavalier de la police montée mis en avant est Edward. Et petit à petit, il laisse sa place à Jack. Le passage de témoin est moins abrupte qu'à la tv.
Bref, le charme a fonctionné. J'aime Coal Valley, Elizabeth et Jack! Et j'y retournerai!!!!
Bon, j'avoue que peut être le charme de la série tv a fonctionné et que grâce à cela les moments où j'ai levé les yeux au ciel à cause du côté très religieux, ont moins compté! En même temps, j'ai grandit en regardant La petite maison dans la prairie et ensuite, plus grande, j'ai révassé devant Docteur Quinn, on est clairement dans le même genre.
"Bondieuseries" mises à part, j'ai apprécié ici que l'histoire soit plus âpres, moins facile pour Elizabeth "Beth". Coal Valley est moins idyllique, plus rude et pauvre mais les habitants tout aussi chaleureux. ET même si on ne retrouve pas les personnages auxquels on est habitué, on s'attache à tous ces hommes et femmes pauvres mais dignes et bien plus humains.
Et l'histoire d'amour alors? Il n'y en a pas ... Enfin, elle pointe le bout de son nez tout doucement. C'est clairement une histoire qui se fera sur plusieurs tomes. L'intrigue commence au même point que le téléfilm pilote. Le cavalier de la police montée mis en avant est Edward. Et petit à petit, il laisse sa place à Jack. Le passage de témoin est moins abrupte qu'à la tv.
Bref, le charme a fonctionné. J'aime Coal Valley, Elizabeth et Jack! Et j'y retournerai!!!!
December 24, 2013
Janette Oke has long been considered an influential author within the Christian fiction publishing industry, so I was excited to have the opportunity to read and review her latest book. Where Courage Calls, was co-written with her daughter Laurel Oke Logan, and is scheduled to be released in February 2014. It is described as a prairie romance, and is set in the Canadian west during the early twentieth century.
The story’s heroine, Beth Thatcher is a pampered daughter from a wealthy family from Toronto, and has accepted a year-long teaching position in a humble coal mining town far from the comforts of home. She believes she is following God’s will for her life and is determined to prove to her overly protective mother that she is equal to the task, even after the conditions in the town prove more challenging and potentially dangerous than she had anticipated. Her luggage is stolen in her travels, and she arrives to find that modern conveniences like plumbing and electricity are unavailable. Nevertheless, she is determined to persevere.
The story is inspiring in that Beth adapts to her circumstances, continually seeks God’s will for her life, and ultimately makes a huge difference in the lives of her students and in the community. Christians looking for a safe and comfortable read, exploring the joys of leading a Godly life will find much to like in this sequel to When Calls the Heart.
That said, I was not as impressed with this story as I had hoped I might be, given the author’s reputation. I found the heroine hard to relate to. Her continual self-sacrifice and nobility made her come across more as a caricature or an ideal to be aspired to than as a real person. She is painted as selfless to the point where I’m not sure I could identify anything she wants for herself, with the possible exception of being out from under her mother’s thumb. Most of her desires seem to be for a better life for her students and to be able to better help her new friends and neighbors. Laudable, to be sure, but realistic? I’m not so sure.
The story started out slowly, with a lot of introspection and reflection on the heroine’s childhood as she traveled to her new home. Her day to day life in the mining town, and the details of what her life and career there turned out to be were very well developed and interesting. However, for a book described as a romance, the romantic element seemed lacking. I thought that Beth’s relationships with each of the potential suitors felt underdeveloped and her interactions with each of them limited, to the extent that I wasn’t sure who the hero would turn out to be until the book was nearly over. Even then, the outcome felt contrived, because it did not hinge on her relationship with either suitor, but rather on an outside circumstance introduced at the last minute, seemingly to tidy things up.
Overall, Where Courage Calls was a thoroughly sweet and innocent story and a pleasant enough read. Fans of historical fiction will appreciate the historical detail, and Christians seeking a clean and uplifting story about the good that can be accomplished by someone persevering in God’s will, need look no further. This is your story. Additionally, fans of Janette Oke's Canadian West series or the Hallmark Channel's new When Calls the Heart TV series, will likely want to give this book a read. Just don’t go into this story expecting a great deal of emphasis on the romance, or you may be disappointed.
I would like to thank the publisher, Bethany House, for providing me with a free electronic copy of this book through NetGalley for my review.
Discussion Questions are available on my blog at http://karencollier.com/book-review-w...
The story’s heroine, Beth Thatcher is a pampered daughter from a wealthy family from Toronto, and has accepted a year-long teaching position in a humble coal mining town far from the comforts of home. She believes she is following God’s will for her life and is determined to prove to her overly protective mother that she is equal to the task, even after the conditions in the town prove more challenging and potentially dangerous than she had anticipated. Her luggage is stolen in her travels, and she arrives to find that modern conveniences like plumbing and electricity are unavailable. Nevertheless, she is determined to persevere.
The story is inspiring in that Beth adapts to her circumstances, continually seeks God’s will for her life, and ultimately makes a huge difference in the lives of her students and in the community. Christians looking for a safe and comfortable read, exploring the joys of leading a Godly life will find much to like in this sequel to When Calls the Heart.
That said, I was not as impressed with this story as I had hoped I might be, given the author’s reputation. I found the heroine hard to relate to. Her continual self-sacrifice and nobility made her come across more as a caricature or an ideal to be aspired to than as a real person. She is painted as selfless to the point where I’m not sure I could identify anything she wants for herself, with the possible exception of being out from under her mother’s thumb. Most of her desires seem to be for a better life for her students and to be able to better help her new friends and neighbors. Laudable, to be sure, but realistic? I’m not so sure.
The story started out slowly, with a lot of introspection and reflection on the heroine’s childhood as she traveled to her new home. Her day to day life in the mining town, and the details of what her life and career there turned out to be were very well developed and interesting. However, for a book described as a romance, the romantic element seemed lacking. I thought that Beth’s relationships with each of the potential suitors felt underdeveloped and her interactions with each of them limited, to the extent that I wasn’t sure who the hero would turn out to be until the book was nearly over. Even then, the outcome felt contrived, because it did not hinge on her relationship with either suitor, but rather on an outside circumstance introduced at the last minute, seemingly to tidy things up.
Overall, Where Courage Calls was a thoroughly sweet and innocent story and a pleasant enough read. Fans of historical fiction will appreciate the historical detail, and Christians seeking a clean and uplifting story about the good that can be accomplished by someone persevering in God’s will, need look no further. This is your story. Additionally, fans of Janette Oke's Canadian West series or the Hallmark Channel's new When Calls the Heart TV series, will likely want to give this book a read. Just don’t go into this story expecting a great deal of emphasis on the romance, or you may be disappointed.
I would like to thank the publisher, Bethany House, for providing me with a free electronic copy of this book through NetGalley for my review.
Discussion Questions are available on my blog at http://karencollier.com/book-review-w...
September 3, 2022
I enjoyed this gentle story of Beth and her adventures in teaching and pulling a mining community together. The description of everyday mundane details slowed the pace, but immersed the reader in the lives of the characters. The children are a big part of the story, and romance was definitely on the back burner. I didn't realize that Beth's story continues through the whole trilogy, so it looks like her relationship with Jarrick will deepen in the next book. There is some danger in the mountains which comes to a head in the climax of the story, changing the dynamics of the little town for the better. Beth undergoes growth through her experiences and matures in her perspective and faith.
Disclosure statement: A complimentary copy of this book was provided from a tour group, publisher, publicist, or author, including NetGalley, OR was borrowed from the library, including OverDrive, OR borrowed from Kindle Unlimited, OR purchased. A review was not required and all views and opinions expressed are unbiased and my own.
Disclosure statement: A complimentary copy of this book was provided from a tour group, publisher, publicist, or author, including NetGalley, OR was borrowed from the library, including OverDrive, OR borrowed from Kindle Unlimited, OR purchased. A review was not required and all views and opinions expressed are unbiased and my own.
January 5, 2025
review to follow
December 27, 2014
This new companion novel to the When Calls The Heart Hallmark movie and T.V. series, is sure to be a delightful read for any Janette Oke fans, as well as fans of the movie adaptions of her books. Filled with lots of prairie close-knit family together-ness and courage to boot, join Beth Thatcher on an unforgettable journey where she learns to trust God in every situation, knowing He is working all things out for good.
This was a very nice novel, which I greatly enjoyed reading during the time when the T.V. series based on Janette Oke's book Where Calls The Heart, was airing each Saturday evening. I had already come to love the T.V. series and fallen in love with the characters, so I was very enthusiastic to read the book that inspired the series. Since this book is the companion novel to the series, it was neat getting to "read" more of the T.V. series, so to speak, and see what the movie episodes were based on. I've always been a fan of Janette Oke's Love Comes Softly series and movies, so I wasn't surprised to love this novel just as much as the Love Comes Softly saga!
This book is full of Janette Oke's classic writing style that often features a hard working prairie family setting, a soft and clean romance as well as lots of strong Christian values and morals throughout. I was not surprised to end up enjoying this novel so much, and it reminded me in a way of her Love Comes Softly novels, though of course in a different setting. This novel focuses on main character Beth Thatcher's journey into the wild west to become a school teacher to the poor children of Coal Valley, who recently lost their fathers in a mining accident when the coal mine exploded, leaving shattered children and helpless widows. Accustomed to luxuries of indoor plumbing, electricity and plenty of money at her disposal, Beth is unaware that primitive Coal Valley and her new teaching position are both going to test her in more ways than one; and reveal who she really is underneath her family's wealth and fame to the person God has called her heart to be, and the life purpose He has for her.
Among the many pros I found in this book, the biggest one was how big the emphasis on how your money doesn't define who you are as a person, and how everyone is important, was played out in the story. I loved Beth as she was a very humble character who willingly went to help poor people in a primitive town with few luxuries, when all she'd ever known was wealth and prosperity. I also loved her character. She was such a strong young lady and really aimed towards truly helping the people of Coal Valley and sharing Christ's love with others, no matter what their current situation was. I just loved being able to see how Beth connected with the people of Coal Valley despite their vast differences, and shared hope with them. At the end of the story I truly felt like she had truly reformed the town and left it better off than she found it; and I loved her example of how one person truly can make a difference for the Lord and bless others.
While I did find the events that took place while Beth was in Coal Valley completely different than the events played out in the T.V. series, I found it uniquely interesting getting "more" of the events of this town while Beth was teacher. While some people may see this as a con since the book is so different than the movie, I didn't feel like it lessened the book, and actually thoughts it was interesting to continue the story with the same characters you already knew and loved from the T.V. episodes.
Overall, I'd highly encourage all fans of Janette Oke's books and movie adaptions to read this book. It's filled with Christian values and a very sturdy life changing character, with an overall uplifting storyline, and sure to not disappoint!
D I S C L A I M E R :: I received a free copy of Where Courage Calls from the publisher through Litfuse Publicity for the purpose of this review. I was not paid in any way to write this review, or promote this book. All thoughts expressed in my review are completely my own, honest and unbiased.
This was a very nice novel, which I greatly enjoyed reading during the time when the T.V. series based on Janette Oke's book Where Calls The Heart, was airing each Saturday evening. I had already come to love the T.V. series and fallen in love with the characters, so I was very enthusiastic to read the book that inspired the series. Since this book is the companion novel to the series, it was neat getting to "read" more of the T.V. series, so to speak, and see what the movie episodes were based on. I've always been a fan of Janette Oke's Love Comes Softly series and movies, so I wasn't surprised to love this novel just as much as the Love Comes Softly saga!
This book is full of Janette Oke's classic writing style that often features a hard working prairie family setting, a soft and clean romance as well as lots of strong Christian values and morals throughout. I was not surprised to end up enjoying this novel so much, and it reminded me in a way of her Love Comes Softly novels, though of course in a different setting. This novel focuses on main character Beth Thatcher's journey into the wild west to become a school teacher to the poor children of Coal Valley, who recently lost their fathers in a mining accident when the coal mine exploded, leaving shattered children and helpless widows. Accustomed to luxuries of indoor plumbing, electricity and plenty of money at her disposal, Beth is unaware that primitive Coal Valley and her new teaching position are both going to test her in more ways than one; and reveal who she really is underneath her family's wealth and fame to the person God has called her heart to be, and the life purpose He has for her.
Among the many pros I found in this book, the biggest one was how big the emphasis on how your money doesn't define who you are as a person, and how everyone is important, was played out in the story. I loved Beth as she was a very humble character who willingly went to help poor people in a primitive town with few luxuries, when all she'd ever known was wealth and prosperity. I also loved her character. She was such a strong young lady and really aimed towards truly helping the people of Coal Valley and sharing Christ's love with others, no matter what their current situation was. I just loved being able to see how Beth connected with the people of Coal Valley despite their vast differences, and shared hope with them. At the end of the story I truly felt like she had truly reformed the town and left it better off than she found it; and I loved her example of how one person truly can make a difference for the Lord and bless others.
While I did find the events that took place while Beth was in Coal Valley completely different than the events played out in the T.V. series, I found it uniquely interesting getting "more" of the events of this town while Beth was teacher. While some people may see this as a con since the book is so different than the movie, I didn't feel like it lessened the book, and actually thoughts it was interesting to continue the story with the same characters you already knew and loved from the T.V. episodes.
Overall, I'd highly encourage all fans of Janette Oke's books and movie adaptions to read this book. It's filled with Christian values and a very sturdy life changing character, with an overall uplifting storyline, and sure to not disappoint!
D I S C L A I M E R :: I received a free copy of Where Courage Calls from the publisher through Litfuse Publicity for the purpose of this review. I was not paid in any way to write this review, or promote this book. All thoughts expressed in my review are completely my own, honest and unbiased.
July 12, 2021
A beautiful, faith-filled story! I loved coming back to the west with Beth and it was so wonderful to see her grow in faith and resilience throughout the novel.
I loved Coal Valley, and all the wonderful people she met, particularly Molly and Frank. The way that Beth was touched so many lives around her greatly encouraged and challenged me personally.
Although it was rather slow-paced, I enjoyed every minute of it, and I can't wait to read the rest of the series!
I loved Coal Valley, and all the wonderful people she met, particularly Molly and Frank. The way that Beth was touched so many lives around her greatly encouraged and challenged me personally.
Although it was rather slow-paced, I enjoyed every minute of it, and I can't wait to read the rest of the series!
November 10, 2014
The story is nice but very superficial. There is way too much religion in this book compared to her earlier books. The love comes softly series was a well-written series and the preaching didn't come til near the end. This one is a preachy book all the way thru.
June 3, 2019
I really enjoyed reading this book and would definitely like to read it again some day!
July 28, 2019
This book was the basis of the Hallmark series When Calls the Heart. I’ve been of fan of Oke’s earlier books since discovering them. This book main character grew up in luxury and there was quit a bit of focus on that aspect of her life.
Elizabeth (Beth) Thatcher traveled west to teach in a mining town in Canada as her aunt had done many years prior. She was shocked by the situation of the struggling families trying to make it after a mine had collapsed and killed most of the men. Beth adapts and brings about changes but at a cost to some. She found a friend in handsome Royal Canadian Mounted Police Jarrick Thornton, who was assigned to the area as there was an on going investigation. There were some unexpected events that brought intense action to the story.
I borrowed this book from a friend who had purchased it at used library sale, thus a review was not required.
Elizabeth (Beth) Thatcher traveled west to teach in a mining town in Canada as her aunt had done many years prior. She was shocked by the situation of the struggling families trying to make it after a mine had collapsed and killed most of the men. Beth adapts and brings about changes but at a cost to some. She found a friend in handsome Royal Canadian Mounted Police Jarrick Thornton, who was assigned to the area as there was an on going investigation. There were some unexpected events that brought intense action to the story.
I borrowed this book from a friend who had purchased it at used library sale, thus a review was not required.
November 4, 2025
I didn’t really enjoy this one. I went into it thinking it was a continuation of the original Canadian West series, but it turned out to be more of a retelling of When Calls the Heart—just with some characters from the TV show mixed in. The story felt confusing because it blurred the lines between the book and TV versions, making it hard to tell what was supposed to be new or different. The romance didn’t draw me in the way Janette Oke’s books usually do, and the writing didn’t have quite the same warmth or depth that makes her stories so special. That said, it’s a clean, sweet, and innocent story that would be perfectly fine for readers 14 and up.
February 15, 2014
First, I must say that Where Courage Calls is definitely better than the new television adaptation of When Calls The Heart might lead you to believe. That is if you were one of those who'd read the original books and found the adaptation ridiculous and/or frustrating. The heroine, Beth Thatcher, is a young cousin of the original Elizabeth Thatcher. Beth's father is one of Elizabeth's uncles. None of Elizabeth's uncles (or aunts) were ever mentioned in the original series, so this is all new. Though because that Elizabeth is a ten or so years older, she is "Aunt Elizabeth" to her cousins. (That is one of the things you just have to go with.) Here is the best news. There is NO RIDICULOUS DIARY. "Aunt Elizabeth" has not vanished into thin air. Her fate is not unknown. She has not thrown over her family or been cast aside by her family. Elizabeth did go west to teach; she did get married and go west once more. But readers don't have to put up with Beth discovering her aunt's story through embarrassing diary entries.
Also gone is the pathetic stage-coach portion from the movie. Since "Aunt Elizabeth" went west circa 1910, it only makes sense that her YOUNG cousin a decade or so later travels by train and then automobile to her place out west. True, the book still has Beth losing all of her possessions, but it is because Edward gave them to a porter at the train station who turned out to be a thief. There was no hold-up of the stage coach!
While the movie makes much of Edward, the book Edward is rarely around for better or worse. Beth has a long standing dislike for Edward. She realizes that her mother's greatest hope is for her to marry Edward, but, she sees Edward as not being worthy of her love and respect. He seems immature and irresponsible. Beth IS rude to him in many places, though she counsels herself after each occurrence that she isn't behaving like a proper Christian girl when she treats Edward like she does.
It soon becomes clear to readers that Edward is not the one being built up as the OBVIOUS romantic choice for her to make by the end of the book. Another man fills that role. Like Edward, he is a Mountie. Unlike Edward, he earns her respect and friendship almost immediately. NOT that she falls head over heels in love with him, like Elizabeth fell for Wynn. Where Courage Calls is not about instant love.
Where Courage Calls makes a good attempt or effort to be about a whole community, about Beth finding her place within that community, about her finding inner strength and making a big difference when it matters most. Readers meet adults and children alike, and, there are several stories to be told. (One story line was about prohibition. Another about Italian miners facing discrimination in town.)
While When Calls the Heart was focused almost solely on ROMANCE, Where Courage Calls is focused more on history and community relationships. Yes, there is a question asked of Beth before the last page is turned, but, the book was always about more than that.
I loved the original series, especially the first two books. This one did not work for me in the same way. But. It was encouraging to see the author make something positive come from the dreadful movie.
Where Courage Calls could easily be compared to Christy by Catherine Marshall. In my opinion, Christy is the better book, the more charming, the more memorable. But I have read it dozens of times, so it may be that Where Courage Calls is too new to be loved like that.
Also gone is the pathetic stage-coach portion from the movie. Since "Aunt Elizabeth" went west circa 1910, it only makes sense that her YOUNG cousin a decade or so later travels by train and then automobile to her place out west. True, the book still has Beth losing all of her possessions, but it is because Edward gave them to a porter at the train station who turned out to be a thief. There was no hold-up of the stage coach!
While the movie makes much of Edward, the book Edward is rarely around for better or worse. Beth has a long standing dislike for Edward. She realizes that her mother's greatest hope is for her to marry Edward, but, she sees Edward as not being worthy of her love and respect. He seems immature and irresponsible. Beth IS rude to him in many places, though she counsels herself after each occurrence that she isn't behaving like a proper Christian girl when she treats Edward like she does.
It soon becomes clear to readers that Edward is not the one being built up as the OBVIOUS romantic choice for her to make by the end of the book. Another man fills that role. Like Edward, he is a Mountie. Unlike Edward, he earns her respect and friendship almost immediately. NOT that she falls head over heels in love with him, like Elizabeth fell for Wynn. Where Courage Calls is not about instant love.
Where Courage Calls makes a good attempt or effort to be about a whole community, about Beth finding her place within that community, about her finding inner strength and making a big difference when it matters most. Readers meet adults and children alike, and, there are several stories to be told. (One story line was about prohibition. Another about Italian miners facing discrimination in town.)
While When Calls the Heart was focused almost solely on ROMANCE, Where Courage Calls is focused more on history and community relationships. Yes, there is a question asked of Beth before the last page is turned, but, the book was always about more than that.
I loved the original series, especially the first two books. This one did not work for me in the same way. But. It was encouraging to see the author make something positive come from the dreadful movie.
Where Courage Calls could easily be compared to Christy by Catherine Marshall. In my opinion, Christy is the better book, the more charming, the more memorable. But I have read it dozens of times, so it may be that Where Courage Calls is too new to be loved like that.
May 20, 2022
I simply LOVED this book, such a sweet story and so full of faith guidance and truth. Just loved each moment and it was my dearest pleasure to bring this book into portuguese language for the first time.
March 3, 2014
I knew right away that I would like this book better than the movie that was made about Where Calls the Heart. And it’s not at all a surprise.
Books are almost always better than movies – not to mention, the movie was actually the story Janette and her daughter have written here - when the storyline was supposed to be about Elizabeth and Wynn.
In the movie, Elizabeth’s niece – Beth was reading about her aunt’s story as she embarked on an adventure of her own. I don’t know if the movie was always meant to be a gateway into a series for Hallmark (if it was – I would have thought they’d cast the people they intended to stay through the series…) or not but that’s how it turned out.
I don't know if Janette Oke ever envisioned her stories being made into movies but I can not imagine that she truly had "that" picture in her head when she wrote the wonderful stories that Hollywood has twisted into their very own versions.
Either way, this book is a masterful retelling of what was, in my humble opinion, a somewhat mediocre movie. Personally I don’t care for some of the things that were added into the movie and I am thrilled to see that Janette and her daughter did not put them into this new novel. But that’s not surprising either. Janette Oke is, and has always been, a superb writer. She writes each story so well, you feel as if you’re right there with the characters.
I can remember listening to my mother as she read the Love Comes Softly series to us as young children. Janette painted such a beautiful picture through her wonderfully vivid descriptions and the truly realistic plots. Each book was a treasure-trove of intrigue and adventure.
I think Janette Oke was the first writer who inspired my own stories. She made it all sound like a wonderful fairy tale while also making it feel like you were listening to a story about one of your own ancestors – passed down through the generations.
This story is no different. She hasn’t lost a bit of her touch and I’m thinking that it also bodes well that he daughter collaborated with her on this latest novel. The story is so much like her others, it feels less like a collaboration than a true meeting of the minds.
BRAVO Janette and Laurel!
I hope we see many more stories from the two of you!
Disclaimer: I received this book free in exchange for an honest review
Books are almost always better than movies – not to mention, the movie was actually the story Janette and her daughter have written here - when the storyline was supposed to be about Elizabeth and Wynn.
In the movie, Elizabeth’s niece – Beth was reading about her aunt’s story as she embarked on an adventure of her own. I don’t know if the movie was always meant to be a gateway into a series for Hallmark (if it was – I would have thought they’d cast the people they intended to stay through the series…) or not but that’s how it turned out.
I don't know if Janette Oke ever envisioned her stories being made into movies but I can not imagine that she truly had "that" picture in her head when she wrote the wonderful stories that Hollywood has twisted into their very own versions.
Either way, this book is a masterful retelling of what was, in my humble opinion, a somewhat mediocre movie. Personally I don’t care for some of the things that were added into the movie and I am thrilled to see that Janette and her daughter did not put them into this new novel. But that’s not surprising either. Janette Oke is, and has always been, a superb writer. She writes each story so well, you feel as if you’re right there with the characters.
I can remember listening to my mother as she read the Love Comes Softly series to us as young children. Janette painted such a beautiful picture through her wonderfully vivid descriptions and the truly realistic plots. Each book was a treasure-trove of intrigue and adventure.
I think Janette Oke was the first writer who inspired my own stories. She made it all sound like a wonderful fairy tale while also making it feel like you were listening to a story about one of your own ancestors – passed down through the generations.
This story is no different. She hasn’t lost a bit of her touch and I’m thinking that it also bodes well that he daughter collaborated with her on this latest novel. The story is so much like her others, it feels less like a collaboration than a true meeting of the minds.
BRAVO Janette and Laurel!
I hope we see many more stories from the two of you!
Disclaimer: I received this book free in exchange for an honest review
May 31, 2024
I loved this book! It's the book based on the TV series based on the book about a teacher in Coal Valley and how she learns about and becomes a part of the community and how the community finds hope partly through her positive influence. This is an uplifting book filled with faith and goodness. Here are some of my favorite quotes:
"For one with a gentle spirit and acute sensitivity, it was overwhelming. Beth felt she would smother if she were not allowed some space--some quiet, some fresh air--if only for a few minutes, until she was able to calm her heartbeat and ease the pulsing in her temples. If only she could slip away (p. 7)."
"'I want you to have it. I know you've always loved it.'... Father's compass had been special to Beth since she was a little girl, enamored by anything that had to do with her father's work at sea... it had been a symbol to them both of his love and guidance to his daughter (p. 17)."
"'Charlie remembers things the way he wants to remember them. I suppose we all do... And then we spend the rest of our lives basing the way we think about our families on what we thought happened--instead of what really did' (p. 23)."
"'The compass needle tells the truth, Beth, even in a storm' (p. 25)."
"All her other books except her Bible had been packed in the trunks that had been checked--The trunks! Would they have been sent to the wrong train? Beth's mind whirled in panic (p. 32)."
"'Your father requested that I accompany you during your travels--see you safely through to Coal Valley' (p. 38)."
"'Only the devil at the door would be worse than Edward Montclair!'... she wanted to hide form him... even as she knew she was being childish and nonsensical... I thought I was well rid of him! (p. 39)"
"No doubt Mother is intrigued by the 'nobility' of the family (p. 41)."
"'Please help me to be respectful tomorrow. Even if I don't desire his company, I don't want to dishonor You' (p. 42)."
"'You promised that Your mercies are new every morning. Thank You for that. I need those mercies tonight. And tomorrow' (p. 43)."
"'It's precisely the same sky that covers everything' (p. 45)."
"'I believe You called me to this job and this place. If my attitudes are wrong, please help me understand so I can change them. But please, please, Father, give me the strength I need to do whatever it is that You're asking me to do. That's what I want. To please You--not to displease my mother' (p. 49)."
"All her clothes were gone. But more than that, her books and teaching materials. Oh no--my violin! Tears spilled over as she remembered that her most cherished possession of all--Father's compass--had been taken as well (p. 56)."
"'These things will happen. You must choose to persist' (p. 59)."
"Beth felt her heart drop. She wasn't even there yet, and she already felt isolated and confined (p. 63)."
"'This tavern... is to be our schoolroom?' (p. 67)"
"'Had he been schooled, who knows what else might'a been. So we can't let the mine get the rest, Miss Beth. We gotta find a way to give 'em more. Can you help us do that, ya think?' (p. 75)"
"She wondered if she would have consented to come had she realized the extent of the primitive living conditions (p. 76)."
"'Marnie, how many students attended your last school?'... 'Don't know, Miss Thatcher... Me and Teddy Boy, we didn't go to school... Our daddy... didn't make us. Said it wasn't gonna help us none' (p. 83)."
"The children had grouped themselves rather naturally by age (p. 86)."
"Just as Beth was about to dismiss the students for lunch, a long whistle blast sounded from the direction of the mine. She had noticed piercing noise the previous day at what seemed to be random times, but Beth now thought it must indicate the workers' breaks or changes of shifts. Apparently the sound would serve as a signal for school lunchtime as well. Clearly her students were attuned to it (p. 86)."
"It came as no surprise that she encountered a wide range of ability among the students (p. 88)."
"'Lord, help me, please, she prayed, to know how to help them' (p. 91)."
"Beth's heart ached to express itself in music--and the memory of the violin she would never play again dampened her spirits further (p. 93)."
"Beth was growing frustrated at the rather frivolous nature of Mother's selections (p. 96)."
"She chose the simplest of the dresses and held it up, scrutinizing herself carefully. It was still uncomfortably excessive. But perhaps something could be done (p. 99)."
"'David's momma is mad at Miles's momma on account'a Miles's dad owed money--an' now he's dead, an' Miles's momma can't pay it' (p. 106)."
"Determined as she was to fulfill her commitment to the full year, she did not truly consider such an option, yet the very contemplation had brought a gloomy cloud of discontent over her (p. 109)."
"'I work because I wish to educate children and improve their opportunities in life' (p. 110)."
"What if it were actually possible to find a way for Paolo to teach English to some of the other miners? Wouldn't that benefit all? (p. 111)"
"At last it was Coal Valley's turn for the arrival of the traveling preacher, and there would be a proper serve to attend. She felt as if her soul had been starving for food and now was beginning to salivate at the chance to dine again (p. 112)."
"'Mrs. McFarland, this is my friend Jack Thornton... Jack, I'd like you to meet Mrs. Molly McFarland. And this is Marnie, and Teddy, and Miss Thatcher--to whom I had the pleasure of being introduced just this morning' (p. 115)."
"'Miss Thatcher has just begun important work here in Coal Valley. It would be a tragedy for them to lose her now. Let's give her a chance to see what God has in store for her here' (p. 117)."
"'These children--they need so much love right now, and it will require someone who can be with them often to reach out to them' (p. 117)."
"'Oh mercy, I may have offered you some chalk dust with my handshake... It's something that goes with being a schoolteacher' (p. 129)."
"Jarrick quickly reached for her and held her up, then led her to a nearby chair and crouched down beside her. No longer aware of anything else, Beth dropped her head against his shoulder and sobbed... 'I'm so sorry I became emotional. It's just--it was my father's--and it's so special to us, to me.'... 'I thought perhaps it was a gift... from Edward.' 'Oh no. My father' (p. 131)."
"She had never wandered so far alone. Caution and daring battled within her, yet she pressed on--always a little farther--exhilarating in the sense that she was the first to enter such a pristine wood (p. 134)."
"Lifting her gaze again to the mountains around her took Beth's breath away--all this magnificent scenery surrounded her every day (p. 136)."
"'The foreign men, they're not welcome in'a town' (p. 141)."
"'I can only tell you that if God is calling you to become involved in some way, then He'll provide the means for it to happen. And if there's any way I can help, I promise I'll do what I can' (p. 147)."
"She wondered what it would be like to live so close to a town and yet be entirely excluded from it (p. 150)."
"Already they have taken on responsible tasks as the eldest in their homes. Will they soon be called away from the schoolroom and required to take on some sort of occupation (p. 152)?"
"In Beth's mind, the biggest need for the entire area and the one thing that would bring them together was a shared faith. But what could she do? She was just one person--and a woman. She felt helpless (p. 153)."
"'I know that speaking English won't change everything, but I'm convinced it will help... I want them to be able to share in the church services with the rest of us. It's so important that they know about God and how much He loves us all' (p. 161)."
"'That's right, Marnie. We all have sinned sometimes. And so do those miners. But God loves them, and Jesus died to save them too--at the very same time He died to save all of us in this room' (p. 170)."
"Beth was struggling to phrase these thoughts well, but she could see that the children were wrestling with what seemed to be conflicting information. She now understood that it was a lot simpler to teach prejudice. Children could grasp much more easily characterizations that were simply all good or all bad (p. 171)."
"'Suppose the other men who don't know English are like Mr. Russo--kind and good, but when you don't know someone, you have to use discretion--that means good judgment, wisdom. You have to get to know people and learn which ones you can trust' (p. 172)."
"'I hope this letter finds you well. I have searched for some time to recover your violin. Many of my fellow officers throughout the province have aided in my search, and with God's help, I know, I was able to locate it in a pawn shop.'... She could only imagine the effort it had cost him (p. 178)."
"'Elizabeth... I never heard anybody play like that. Bet you even made God smile' (p. 183)."
"'Truly He taught us to love one another: His law is love and His gospel is peace' (p. 185)."
IT was God to whom he was giving praise--not to Beth and her violin. She took a deep breath and a few steps backward, thanking God for the gift of music that was able to convey the wonder of His greatest Gift to these villagers of Coal Valley... What she realized they were actually grateful for was hope (p. 186)."
"She added a prayer for the young man seated next to her, for his family and the Christmas celebrations that would occur so far from him this year (p. 191)."
"In all directions were miners enjoying the warmth and welcome of the resources that the town hall had to offer... 'It could have never happened if God had not intervened' (p. 199)."
"Molly suitably fussed over Beth in the days that followed, mumbling about taking more seriously the illness that had stolen away so many in the flu epidemic of 1918--still vivid in Molly's memory--and chastising Beth for having gone out into the wintry air without even having the sense to put on a coat (p. 202)."
"On December the twenty-third, Jarrick surprised them with a visit, chatting amiably during the short break he was able to spare from his responsibilities (p. 203)."
"What do I feel where Edward is concerned? Beth couldn't sort out her emotions--at least not right then (p. 208)."
"'You have so many wonderful talents, Elizabeth. I'm convinced there is nothing you could not accomplish if you try. I will cherish this gift as a tribute to what an amazing woman you are, and on frosty winter evenings I'll find some way to tuck it under my tunic' (p. 211)."
"'Please try to take care of yourself--I shall pray for your safety' (p. 212)."
"Beth tried not to meddle, but the idea that any of her children did not have enough to eat brought serious concern (p. 222)."
"'How about if we see they get a good breakfast? Many schools have done that much. And it's one of the cheapest meals to provide' (p. 223)."
"Each time in the coming days when she felt worry return, she did her best to place it back into God's hands through prayer (p. 228)."
"God's answer had been so much more efficient and effective than what she could have even imagined. She prayed her gratitude (p. 233)."
"'Sometimes God answers before we even know what to ask' (p. 244)."
"It seemed to come as a sobering realization that Beth was working much harder, with more creativity and energy, than Julie had ever envisioned (p. 266)."
"'Philip is a handsome, educated, gracious man. What more could you possibly be looking for in a husband?' (p. 283)"
"'What I'm doing here is important to me. It's what I've studied hard to accomplish--and I believe God is using me. So I'm not looking for a life partner until I feel God is leading me in that direction' (p. 285)."
"'We all share in the good and the bad together' (p. 288)."
"'What's important to me... is that I believe right now I'm supposed to be here in Coal Valley teaching children to read and write--ones who likely wouldn't be learning these things if I hadn't come. At least, I hope I'm effective in that task--I want to make a difference in their futures--and in this town' (p. 290)."
"Beth was astounded. She had never guessed that so much criminal activity was happening around her (p. 299)."
"Did I get done what You wanted me to do, Lord? (p. 311)"
"'We all been talkin' 'bout what ya done for our town. An' I 'preciate it all--along with the rest a' the town. Ya brought a lot to us--to our children. But to me ya brought more than what ya done. Ya brought back hope--an' faith--things I didn't know I lost. I'd stopped going' to church. I'd stopped prayin'--right when I needed it most. An' then when my kids got excited 'bout those little Bible plays, I decided to go along with 'em' (p. 312)."
"'God leads--it is up to us to follow' (p. 317)."
"It was in God's hands. As much as her heart beat faster at the thought of the one man from whom her heart had hoped to receive attention, she would not need to do anything about it (p. 318)."
"'I think you'll be back... At least, that's what I'm gonna tell myself' (p. 322)."
"'You mean a great deal to them, Beth... You've had a good year... Are you looking forward to getting back to the city--to civilization?'... 'Well, I'm ready to see my family again. I've missed them very much' (p. 323)."
"'That day we spent together--taking Willie Coolidge to the hospital--I was going to ask you if you might be open to having a gentleman caller' (p. 324)."
"'I've seen you giving of yourself and striving to serve in ways that few others would. I've seen you pouring out your love on the children you taught and making a great difference in their lives. I've seen you being honest in difficult moments, and patient and wise. And I've seen you rise to the occasion to defend those you love. I have to tell you, Beth, I've come to admire you greatly. You are what I would see as the best of women, and any man would be blessed to share his life with you... I have no right to ask for your permission in a formal way--there being no assurance you'll return again. But I hoped at least to express my admiration and my wish that if God brings you back to us, that you... might consider... my request at that time' (p. 326)."
"Beth was surprised when he asked if he could say a short prayer (p. 328)."
"'Father... I know You are in charge of my future. I can see Your hand in everything that has happened over the past several months. Truly You have been my strength--just as my father said You would... Dear Lord... if it fits Your plans, please... I would so love to come back here' (p. 329)."
"For one with a gentle spirit and acute sensitivity, it was overwhelming. Beth felt she would smother if she were not allowed some space--some quiet, some fresh air--if only for a few minutes, until she was able to calm her heartbeat and ease the pulsing in her temples. If only she could slip away (p. 7)."
"'I want you to have it. I know you've always loved it.'... Father's compass had been special to Beth since she was a little girl, enamored by anything that had to do with her father's work at sea... it had been a symbol to them both of his love and guidance to his daughter (p. 17)."
"'Charlie remembers things the way he wants to remember them. I suppose we all do... And then we spend the rest of our lives basing the way we think about our families on what we thought happened--instead of what really did' (p. 23)."
"'The compass needle tells the truth, Beth, even in a storm' (p. 25)."
"All her other books except her Bible had been packed in the trunks that had been checked--The trunks! Would they have been sent to the wrong train? Beth's mind whirled in panic (p. 32)."
"'Your father requested that I accompany you during your travels--see you safely through to Coal Valley' (p. 38)."
"'Only the devil at the door would be worse than Edward Montclair!'... she wanted to hide form him... even as she knew she was being childish and nonsensical... I thought I was well rid of him! (p. 39)"
"No doubt Mother is intrigued by the 'nobility' of the family (p. 41)."
"'Please help me to be respectful tomorrow. Even if I don't desire his company, I don't want to dishonor You' (p. 42)."
"'You promised that Your mercies are new every morning. Thank You for that. I need those mercies tonight. And tomorrow' (p. 43)."
"'It's precisely the same sky that covers everything' (p. 45)."
"'I believe You called me to this job and this place. If my attitudes are wrong, please help me understand so I can change them. But please, please, Father, give me the strength I need to do whatever it is that You're asking me to do. That's what I want. To please You--not to displease my mother' (p. 49)."
"All her clothes were gone. But more than that, her books and teaching materials. Oh no--my violin! Tears spilled over as she remembered that her most cherished possession of all--Father's compass--had been taken as well (p. 56)."
"'These things will happen. You must choose to persist' (p. 59)."
"Beth felt her heart drop. She wasn't even there yet, and she already felt isolated and confined (p. 63)."
"'This tavern... is to be our schoolroom?' (p. 67)"
"'Had he been schooled, who knows what else might'a been. So we can't let the mine get the rest, Miss Beth. We gotta find a way to give 'em more. Can you help us do that, ya think?' (p. 75)"
"She wondered if she would have consented to come had she realized the extent of the primitive living conditions (p. 76)."
"'Marnie, how many students attended your last school?'... 'Don't know, Miss Thatcher... Me and Teddy Boy, we didn't go to school... Our daddy... didn't make us. Said it wasn't gonna help us none' (p. 83)."
"The children had grouped themselves rather naturally by age (p. 86)."
"Just as Beth was about to dismiss the students for lunch, a long whistle blast sounded from the direction of the mine. She had noticed piercing noise the previous day at what seemed to be random times, but Beth now thought it must indicate the workers' breaks or changes of shifts. Apparently the sound would serve as a signal for school lunchtime as well. Clearly her students were attuned to it (p. 86)."
"It came as no surprise that she encountered a wide range of ability among the students (p. 88)."
"'Lord, help me, please, she prayed, to know how to help them' (p. 91)."
"Beth's heart ached to express itself in music--and the memory of the violin she would never play again dampened her spirits further (p. 93)."
"Beth was growing frustrated at the rather frivolous nature of Mother's selections (p. 96)."
"She chose the simplest of the dresses and held it up, scrutinizing herself carefully. It was still uncomfortably excessive. But perhaps something could be done (p. 99)."
"'David's momma is mad at Miles's momma on account'a Miles's dad owed money--an' now he's dead, an' Miles's momma can't pay it' (p. 106)."
"Determined as she was to fulfill her commitment to the full year, she did not truly consider such an option, yet the very contemplation had brought a gloomy cloud of discontent over her (p. 109)."
"'I work because I wish to educate children and improve their opportunities in life' (p. 110)."
"What if it were actually possible to find a way for Paolo to teach English to some of the other miners? Wouldn't that benefit all? (p. 111)"
"At last it was Coal Valley's turn for the arrival of the traveling preacher, and there would be a proper serve to attend. She felt as if her soul had been starving for food and now was beginning to salivate at the chance to dine again (p. 112)."
"'Mrs. McFarland, this is my friend Jack Thornton... Jack, I'd like you to meet Mrs. Molly McFarland. And this is Marnie, and Teddy, and Miss Thatcher--to whom I had the pleasure of being introduced just this morning' (p. 115)."
"'Miss Thatcher has just begun important work here in Coal Valley. It would be a tragedy for them to lose her now. Let's give her a chance to see what God has in store for her here' (p. 117)."
"'These children--they need so much love right now, and it will require someone who can be with them often to reach out to them' (p. 117)."
"'Oh mercy, I may have offered you some chalk dust with my handshake... It's something that goes with being a schoolteacher' (p. 129)."
"Jarrick quickly reached for her and held her up, then led her to a nearby chair and crouched down beside her. No longer aware of anything else, Beth dropped her head against his shoulder and sobbed... 'I'm so sorry I became emotional. It's just--it was my father's--and it's so special to us, to me.'... 'I thought perhaps it was a gift... from Edward.' 'Oh no. My father' (p. 131)."
"She had never wandered so far alone. Caution and daring battled within her, yet she pressed on--always a little farther--exhilarating in the sense that she was the first to enter such a pristine wood (p. 134)."
"Lifting her gaze again to the mountains around her took Beth's breath away--all this magnificent scenery surrounded her every day (p. 136)."
"'The foreign men, they're not welcome in'a town' (p. 141)."
"'I can only tell you that if God is calling you to become involved in some way, then He'll provide the means for it to happen. And if there's any way I can help, I promise I'll do what I can' (p. 147)."
"She wondered what it would be like to live so close to a town and yet be entirely excluded from it (p. 150)."
"Already they have taken on responsible tasks as the eldest in their homes. Will they soon be called away from the schoolroom and required to take on some sort of occupation (p. 152)?"
"In Beth's mind, the biggest need for the entire area and the one thing that would bring them together was a shared faith. But what could she do? She was just one person--and a woman. She felt helpless (p. 153)."
"'I know that speaking English won't change everything, but I'm convinced it will help... I want them to be able to share in the church services with the rest of us. It's so important that they know about God and how much He loves us all' (p. 161)."
"'That's right, Marnie. We all have sinned sometimes. And so do those miners. But God loves them, and Jesus died to save them too--at the very same time He died to save all of us in this room' (p. 170)."
"Beth was struggling to phrase these thoughts well, but she could see that the children were wrestling with what seemed to be conflicting information. She now understood that it was a lot simpler to teach prejudice. Children could grasp much more easily characterizations that were simply all good or all bad (p. 171)."
"'Suppose the other men who don't know English are like Mr. Russo--kind and good, but when you don't know someone, you have to use discretion--that means good judgment, wisdom. You have to get to know people and learn which ones you can trust' (p. 172)."
"'I hope this letter finds you well. I have searched for some time to recover your violin. Many of my fellow officers throughout the province have aided in my search, and with God's help, I know, I was able to locate it in a pawn shop.'... She could only imagine the effort it had cost him (p. 178)."
"'Elizabeth... I never heard anybody play like that. Bet you even made God smile' (p. 183)."
"'Truly He taught us to love one another: His law is love and His gospel is peace' (p. 185)."
IT was God to whom he was giving praise--not to Beth and her violin. She took a deep breath and a few steps backward, thanking God for the gift of music that was able to convey the wonder of His greatest Gift to these villagers of Coal Valley... What she realized they were actually grateful for was hope (p. 186)."
"She added a prayer for the young man seated next to her, for his family and the Christmas celebrations that would occur so far from him this year (p. 191)."
"In all directions were miners enjoying the warmth and welcome of the resources that the town hall had to offer... 'It could have never happened if God had not intervened' (p. 199)."
"Molly suitably fussed over Beth in the days that followed, mumbling about taking more seriously the illness that had stolen away so many in the flu epidemic of 1918--still vivid in Molly's memory--and chastising Beth for having gone out into the wintry air without even having the sense to put on a coat (p. 202)."
"On December the twenty-third, Jarrick surprised them with a visit, chatting amiably during the short break he was able to spare from his responsibilities (p. 203)."
"What do I feel where Edward is concerned? Beth couldn't sort out her emotions--at least not right then (p. 208)."
"'You have so many wonderful talents, Elizabeth. I'm convinced there is nothing you could not accomplish if you try. I will cherish this gift as a tribute to what an amazing woman you are, and on frosty winter evenings I'll find some way to tuck it under my tunic' (p. 211)."
"'Please try to take care of yourself--I shall pray for your safety' (p. 212)."
"Beth tried not to meddle, but the idea that any of her children did not have enough to eat brought serious concern (p. 222)."
"'How about if we see they get a good breakfast? Many schools have done that much. And it's one of the cheapest meals to provide' (p. 223)."
"Each time in the coming days when she felt worry return, she did her best to place it back into God's hands through prayer (p. 228)."
"God's answer had been so much more efficient and effective than what she could have even imagined. She prayed her gratitude (p. 233)."
"'Sometimes God answers before we even know what to ask' (p. 244)."
"It seemed to come as a sobering realization that Beth was working much harder, with more creativity and energy, than Julie had ever envisioned (p. 266)."
"'Philip is a handsome, educated, gracious man. What more could you possibly be looking for in a husband?' (p. 283)"
"'What I'm doing here is important to me. It's what I've studied hard to accomplish--and I believe God is using me. So I'm not looking for a life partner until I feel God is leading me in that direction' (p. 285)."
"'We all share in the good and the bad together' (p. 288)."
"'What's important to me... is that I believe right now I'm supposed to be here in Coal Valley teaching children to read and write--ones who likely wouldn't be learning these things if I hadn't come. At least, I hope I'm effective in that task--I want to make a difference in their futures--and in this town' (p. 290)."
"Beth was astounded. She had never guessed that so much criminal activity was happening around her (p. 299)."
"Did I get done what You wanted me to do, Lord? (p. 311)"
"'We all been talkin' 'bout what ya done for our town. An' I 'preciate it all--along with the rest a' the town. Ya brought a lot to us--to our children. But to me ya brought more than what ya done. Ya brought back hope--an' faith--things I didn't know I lost. I'd stopped going' to church. I'd stopped prayin'--right when I needed it most. An' then when my kids got excited 'bout those little Bible plays, I decided to go along with 'em' (p. 312)."
"'God leads--it is up to us to follow' (p. 317)."
"It was in God's hands. As much as her heart beat faster at the thought of the one man from whom her heart had hoped to receive attention, she would not need to do anything about it (p. 318)."
"'I think you'll be back... At least, that's what I'm gonna tell myself' (p. 322)."
"'You mean a great deal to them, Beth... You've had a good year... Are you looking forward to getting back to the city--to civilization?'... 'Well, I'm ready to see my family again. I've missed them very much' (p. 323)."
"'That day we spent together--taking Willie Coolidge to the hospital--I was going to ask you if you might be open to having a gentleman caller' (p. 324)."
"'I've seen you giving of yourself and striving to serve in ways that few others would. I've seen you pouring out your love on the children you taught and making a great difference in their lives. I've seen you being honest in difficult moments, and patient and wise. And I've seen you rise to the occasion to defend those you love. I have to tell you, Beth, I've come to admire you greatly. You are what I would see as the best of women, and any man would be blessed to share his life with you... I have no right to ask for your permission in a formal way--there being no assurance you'll return again. But I hoped at least to express my admiration and my wish that if God brings you back to us, that you... might consider... my request at that time' (p. 326)."
"Beth was surprised when he asked if he could say a short prayer (p. 328)."
"'Father... I know You are in charge of my future. I can see Your hand in everything that has happened over the past several months. Truly You have been my strength--just as my father said You would... Dear Lord... if it fits Your plans, please... I would so love to come back here' (p. 329)."
September 11, 2016
One of my favorite books is When Calls the Heart. I've read numerous books by Janette Oke over the years, but that particular series is my favorite. So I was looking forward to reading this book. Unfortunately, I think my expectations from were too high from the beginning. First, I saw the first (or maybe it was the second) in the series on Hallmark. I wasn't really pulled in or intrigued to watch another episode. But I blame that on me. I thought I was watching the series version of When Calls the Heart!
So when I selected the book Where Courage Calls, I had one scene already in my head that was not in the book. I don't see how the two can be considered companion pieces, when scenes in the book are drastically different from the book. In the tv series, there is a stagecoach robbery. In the book, there is no mention of such, rather a theft of a different nature.
But putting all that aside, my overall reaction to the book is disappointment. I thought it moved along very slowly, parts of it delightful, but other parts I kept waiting for something to happen. It's almost as though the writers were told, let's make this one book into a second part, now drag it along.
The characters I didn't really get to know, other than the main character. Her "love" interests, I never got to know, I had no sort of affinity for them. The drama of the book didn't captivate me, because it almost seemed trite. And the event at the end, again, I didn't feel any sort of clues or dramatic event to lead up to it. The most disappointment was the ending of the story. It leaves too much of it open ended.
Overall, it's an okay book. Written well, but lacking in areas. It was a book I could set down and have no urgent interest in finishing it, but I did finish it.
I received this book from Bethany House Publishers for my honest review. I did not receive any other compensation and all thoughts and opinions are strictly my own.
So when I selected the book Where Courage Calls, I had one scene already in my head that was not in the book. I don't see how the two can be considered companion pieces, when scenes in the book are drastically different from the book. In the tv series, there is a stagecoach robbery. In the book, there is no mention of such, rather a theft of a different nature.
But putting all that aside, my overall reaction to the book is disappointment. I thought it moved along very slowly, parts of it delightful, but other parts I kept waiting for something to happen. It's almost as though the writers were told, let's make this one book into a second part, now drag it along.
The characters I didn't really get to know, other than the main character. Her "love" interests, I never got to know, I had no sort of affinity for them. The drama of the book didn't captivate me, because it almost seemed trite. And the event at the end, again, I didn't feel any sort of clues or dramatic event to lead up to it. The most disappointment was the ending of the story. It leaves too much of it open ended.
Overall, it's an okay book. Written well, but lacking in areas. It was a book I could set down and have no urgent interest in finishing it, but I did finish it.
I received this book from Bethany House Publishers for my honest review. I did not receive any other compensation and all thoughts and opinions are strictly my own.
April 2, 2014
A great book. An offshoot of the Canadian West series that she wrote many years ago.
This time Beth is going west to teach in a small school, following in the steps of her Aunt Elizabeth. She finds the area primitive but the people loving, accepting of her, real and trying to make the way better for their children. There is a mystery, conflict, problems to be solved and of course a little romance.
Favorite quotes from this book...
“'Brothers and sisters,' he implored them, wiping a handkerchief across his glistening forehead, 'I know that this world holds suffering—and hardship—and sometimes despair. But our God has a gift—a hope and a future for each of us. If only we accept the manner in which it comes: the surrender of our will to His—in faith and obedience.'
“Amen,' Beth whispered. 'Amen.' And in her heart she prayed for greater faith to heed God's voice more fully.” (pg 113)
“'Now, dearie, ya gotta take care. That word should, it's a slip'ry one. Who gets ta measure shoulds? Only God gets ta say. If He says ya should, then ya mind Him. If folks say ya should—ya jest go back an' ask God. Don't need more'n that to measure up to.' She smiled to herself and reached for the next plate. 'Good thing 'bout getting old—ya don't think so much 'bout what folks think of ya—what they say ya should do. Ya spend more time wond'rin' what you still can do. Wish I could go back over my own life and not bother with all the silly things folks said I should. Sure woulda make life more simple—less confusin'.'” (pg 265)
The book was left open ended and I hope that means more books to come for this series. I love Janette Oke's writing and have a new book to add to my want list on Amazon as I own most of Janette Oke's books and want to keep my collection complete.
This time Beth is going west to teach in a small school, following in the steps of her Aunt Elizabeth. She finds the area primitive but the people loving, accepting of her, real and trying to make the way better for their children. There is a mystery, conflict, problems to be solved and of course a little romance.
Favorite quotes from this book...
“'Brothers and sisters,' he implored them, wiping a handkerchief across his glistening forehead, 'I know that this world holds suffering—and hardship—and sometimes despair. But our God has a gift—a hope and a future for each of us. If only we accept the manner in which it comes: the surrender of our will to His—in faith and obedience.'
“Amen,' Beth whispered. 'Amen.' And in her heart she prayed for greater faith to heed God's voice more fully.” (pg 113)
“'Now, dearie, ya gotta take care. That word should, it's a slip'ry one. Who gets ta measure shoulds? Only God gets ta say. If He says ya should, then ya mind Him. If folks say ya should—ya jest go back an' ask God. Don't need more'n that to measure up to.' She smiled to herself and reached for the next plate. 'Good thing 'bout getting old—ya don't think so much 'bout what folks think of ya—what they say ya should do. Ya spend more time wond'rin' what you still can do. Wish I could go back over my own life and not bother with all the silly things folks said I should. Sure woulda make life more simple—less confusin'.'” (pg 265)
The book was left open ended and I hope that means more books to come for this series. I love Janette Oke's writing and have a new book to add to my want list on Amazon as I own most of Janette Oke's books and want to keep my collection complete.
March 3, 2014
Janette Oke's books hold a special place in my heart. Her books introduced me to Christian historical fiction. I have read all of her previous books and I still look forward to her new books. So, it was safe to say I was thrilled when I saw Janette Oke and her daughter Laurel Oke Logan were releasing a new novel, Where Courage Calls, part of When Calls the Heart.
It was enjoyable to dive back into the When Calls the Heart stories. Instead of continuing with the original characters, we are introduced to newer characters. We did see Beth briefly in the original series, but as a little girl. Here, Beth has grown and made it through college and is ready to put her knowledge to use, just like her aunt, in the wilds of the Canadian frontier.
It was a delight experiencing the quiet, but busy life Beth had as a teacher in a small coal mining town. Beth faces many challenges, but she does her best to push through with her intelligence and with her faith. She is also quick to make friends and as she becomes accustomed to the town, this small town starts to become her home.
There is a small romance that buds in these pages, but it isn't the main focus of the story. I saw this story as Beth finding out who she is and who God wants her to be. She has been led by her mother to be certain ways, but here in Coal Valley away from her mother's nudging, Beth is able to discover what her own strengths are. I liked how Beth was finding out who she was before pursuing a relationship. That shows a wonderful strength in her.
The story was left open to possibly continue, I hope it does, I would like to see where Beth's story takes her.
Thank you to Litfuse Publicity and Bethany House, I received a copy of this book for free in exchange for an honest review.
It was enjoyable to dive back into the When Calls the Heart stories. Instead of continuing with the original characters, we are introduced to newer characters. We did see Beth briefly in the original series, but as a little girl. Here, Beth has grown and made it through college and is ready to put her knowledge to use, just like her aunt, in the wilds of the Canadian frontier.
It was a delight experiencing the quiet, but busy life Beth had as a teacher in a small coal mining town. Beth faces many challenges, but she does her best to push through with her intelligence and with her faith. She is also quick to make friends and as she becomes accustomed to the town, this small town starts to become her home.
There is a small romance that buds in these pages, but it isn't the main focus of the story. I saw this story as Beth finding out who she is and who God wants her to be. She has been led by her mother to be certain ways, but here in Coal Valley away from her mother's nudging, Beth is able to discover what her own strengths are. I liked how Beth was finding out who she was before pursuing a relationship. That shows a wonderful strength in her.
The story was left open to possibly continue, I hope it does, I would like to see where Beth's story takes her.
Thank you to Litfuse Publicity and Bethany House, I received a copy of this book for free in exchange for an honest review.
January 29, 2014
When I saw that one of my all time favorite author had a new book out, co-authored by her Daughter Laurel Oke Logan, I knew I had to read it. Again, I was not disappointed.
In this book we have Elizabeth's niece Beth. Beth comes from a well to do family, and has always had a delicate health. When she decides to take a teaching job out West in Coal Town. Her Mother doesn't want her to go, but her father prevails and Beth is off on a new adventure in her life.
Long time family friend Edward, meets her as she gets off the train, he has been there on the train with her all along. He precedes to help Beth getting to her hotel, and hires a man to take her things there. I find this quite a funny part of the story, as Edward is in his Royal Mounted Police uniform, and pays the guy....who steals everything.
What a start to a new life?? Arriving in a new town as the teacher, with no clothes or books, or anything...no underwear! Now this is a small, small town, you cannot go out and buy what you need. Thank goodness Mom comes to the rescue.
Through out all of her stay here, she finds a new family. The people make her feel so welcome, and Beth keeps coming up with new ways to help these miners and their families. I can see God's hand in a lot of what happens here. He seems to answer a lot of prayers.
We will sympathize with the plight of the families here, and hope something can be done for them. Beth sure is trying!
You will wonder if there is a bit of romance in the air, and I see at least three possibilities. Will any of them work out?
I hope that there will be more stories coming, I feel like I need to know what is going to happen next! Enjoy!
I received this book through Litfuse Publicity Book Tours, and was not required to give a positive review.
In this book we have Elizabeth's niece Beth. Beth comes from a well to do family, and has always had a delicate health. When she decides to take a teaching job out West in Coal Town. Her Mother doesn't want her to go, but her father prevails and Beth is off on a new adventure in her life.
Long time family friend Edward, meets her as she gets off the train, he has been there on the train with her all along. He precedes to help Beth getting to her hotel, and hires a man to take her things there. I find this quite a funny part of the story, as Edward is in his Royal Mounted Police uniform, and pays the guy....who steals everything.
What a start to a new life?? Arriving in a new town as the teacher, with no clothes or books, or anything...no underwear! Now this is a small, small town, you cannot go out and buy what you need. Thank goodness Mom comes to the rescue.
Through out all of her stay here, she finds a new family. The people make her feel so welcome, and Beth keeps coming up with new ways to help these miners and their families. I can see God's hand in a lot of what happens here. He seems to answer a lot of prayers.
We will sympathize with the plight of the families here, and hope something can be done for them. Beth sure is trying!
You will wonder if there is a bit of romance in the air, and I see at least three possibilities. Will any of them work out?
I hope that there will be more stories coming, I feel like I need to know what is going to happen next! Enjoy!
I received this book through Litfuse Publicity Book Tours, and was not required to give a positive review.
February 21, 2014
Beth Thatcher is determined to beat the odds and prove to her family that she can survive on her own as a teacher in a small coal mining town. Will her faith pull her through even when she has two very different men vying for her heart?
Where Courage Calls is a well written story, with classic values and an admirable heroine. Everything one could hope for from an Oke novel. I loved the timeless quality to the story, and writing which to me just confirms why Janette Oke has long been a household name in Christian Fiction and Romance.
One of my favorite things about this book was Beth's growing faith, and trust in God through the tough times, when it would have been easy to take things into her own hands.
This is an engaging tale from start to finish, and if you think that you don't need to read this book because you saw the movie, think again! The movie leaves off at what is only about 15% of the way through the book, so if you want to find out what happens...
Overall this was a terrific read, with a godly love story that I hope will continue in future books. I liked how the ending was both open and satisfying, so that even if there aren't any more new books for a while I won't die, but left me wanting more just the same! Reading this book brought me back to my younger years when all I read were Janette Oke books, with its classic coming of age tale mixed with sweet romance. I think it is so awesome that Ms. Oke's daughter is helping her to continue the legacy of great stories for all ages!
Where Courage Calls is a well written story, with classic values and an admirable heroine. Everything one could hope for from an Oke novel. I loved the timeless quality to the story, and writing which to me just confirms why Janette Oke has long been a household name in Christian Fiction and Romance.
One of my favorite things about this book was Beth's growing faith, and trust in God through the tough times, when it would have been easy to take things into her own hands.
This is an engaging tale from start to finish, and if you think that you don't need to read this book because you saw the movie, think again! The movie leaves off at what is only about 15% of the way through the book, so if you want to find out what happens...
Overall this was a terrific read, with a godly love story that I hope will continue in future books. I liked how the ending was both open and satisfying, so that even if there aren't any more new books for a while I won't die, but left me wanting more just the same! Reading this book brought me back to my younger years when all I read were Janette Oke books, with its classic coming of age tale mixed with sweet romance. I think it is so awesome that Ms. Oke's daughter is helping her to continue the legacy of great stories for all ages!
June 23, 2015
There is a television series on Hallmark, When Calls the Heart. It is over the top cheesy goodness to which I am addicted through 2 seasons. The title comes from a Janette Oke series of the same name, but the characters are based on this book series - a follow up series of which this is book 1. This is one case where I like the show much better than the book. I enjoy the story a lot. A young, wealthy schoolteacher goes into the Canadian wild west to teach in a small mining town. Think adult Little House on the Prairie in Canada. The show follows some of this book's plot through season 1, but don't expect all the characters or plot points. In one big difference, I liked the book's portrayal of Jack Thornton better than the show. He is older (30), more established as a Mountie, and more direct in his courtship of Elizabeth.
Oke's writing style is hard for me to take. It is a removed first person with almost no humor, a lot of naivete, and some self-righteousness. It's distinctive. As much as I've liked some of her books, i.e. the Love Comes Softly series, the style grates on me.
Oke's writing style is hard for me to take. It is a removed first person with almost no humor, a lot of naivete, and some self-righteousness. It's distinctive. As much as I've liked some of her books, i.e. the Love Comes Softly series, the style grates on me.
January 3, 2016
Real Rating: 4.5 stars
Where Courage Calls is the newest release from Janette Oke and her daughter Laurel. Janette's books have a very special place in my heart. I grew up reading her books and I have read most if not all of Janette's novels.
Where Courage Calls is no exception from her previous works. It is an absolutely beautiful novel full of romance and adventure. It is perfect for the reader who is a Historical romance junkie. This one is a keeper.
Where Courage Calls is the newest release from Janette Oke and her daughter Laurel. Janette's books have a very special place in my heart. I grew up reading her books and I have read most if not all of Janette's novels.
Where Courage Calls is no exception from her previous works. It is an absolutely beautiful novel full of romance and adventure. It is perfect for the reader who is a Historical romance junkie. This one is a keeper.
June 19, 2017
I read the large print version, so I need to find that one.
This had mentioned characters from the tv show, When Calls the Heart and I fangirled a lot!
It's pretty cool! :D
Anyways, I stink at writing reviews so don't waste your time with this one. ;)
This had mentioned characters from the tv show, When Calls the Heart and I fangirled a lot!
It's pretty cool! :D
Anyways, I stink at writing reviews so don't waste your time with this one. ;)
April 27, 2017
This is my third time reading this book. Didn't love it quite as much as the first two times, but still liked it a lot. I just wish Jack would shave that horrid mustache of his.
And you know, I noticed the first time I read Where Courage Calls that the story is extremely similar to Christy by Catherine Marshall. Anyone else notice that??
And you know, I noticed the first time I read Where Courage Calls that the story is extremely similar to Christy by Catherine Marshall. Anyone else notice that??
June 4, 2024
2024 reread thoughts: (Spoilers Ahead)
Where do I begin? Honestly, I really love this book. The plot ties up nicely enough that you don't have to read the next books in the series, which I'm personally a fan of. As someone who is a fan of the When Calls the Heart tv show, I have to mentally separate the book from the tv show because to me they are two different things. The Elizabeth of the book isn't stubborn for thinking that women can do anything, instead she is resolute in following where she believes God has called her. I had forgotten how much faith content there was in this book, but it was really refreshing compared to a lot of Christian, historical romance books I've read.
I think the one thing that bothered me was the whole Edward plot-line. Elizabeth doesn't like him, and then the next moment she is waiting to hear from him. She tells Jarrick at dinner, that she describes as seeming as almost romantic, how nice Edward is for recovering her possessions. She is then confused why Jarrick seems withdrawn after. Girl, read the room.
I forgot about Philip entirely for some reason. I honestly wouldn't have minded if he was the love interest. But I feel like that is a controversial opinion that I'm not entirely ready to defend.
Anyways, I enjoyed reading this book again. Now I have to pull out season 1 of the show and start a rewatch... 4.5 Stars
Where do I begin? Honestly, I really love this book. The plot ties up nicely enough that you don't have to read the next books in the series, which I'm personally a fan of. As someone who is a fan of the When Calls the Heart tv show, I have to mentally separate the book from the tv show because to me they are two different things. The Elizabeth of the book isn't stubborn for thinking that women can do anything, instead she is resolute in following where she believes God has called her. I had forgotten how much faith content there was in this book, but it was really refreshing compared to a lot of Christian, historical romance books I've read.
I think the one thing that bothered me was the whole Edward plot-line. Elizabeth doesn't like him, and then the next moment she is waiting to hear from him. She tells Jarrick at dinner, that she describes as seeming as almost romantic, how nice Edward is for recovering her possessions. She is then confused why Jarrick seems withdrawn after. Girl, read the room.
I forgot about Philip entirely for some reason. I honestly wouldn't have minded if he was the love interest. But I feel like that is a controversial opinion that I'm not entirely ready to defend.
Anyways, I enjoyed reading this book again. Now I have to pull out season 1 of the show and start a rewatch... 4.5 Stars
Displaying 1 - 30 of 405 reviews