I couldn't wait to start reading this book, I loved The Puzzling Brain of Martha Tidberry so much. I liked the early chapters; I have either experienced the problem, know someone who has, or seen it explored on television or read about it in a newspaper. It was fascinating to see each character develop as their "take" on memory loss, or some other childhood experience, affected them. Doubts arose with Mildred, for two reasons. She was ashamed of being abused. Maybe abused women do feel shame: the feeling they admit to, if they ever reveal the abuse, is guilt they are so convinced they deserved to be treated badly. The second reason is that Mildred, understandably, is afraid of her husband, yet she makes notes to aid memory he could find, including one to make a doctor's appointment she wants to keep secret. What he does take from her, catching her in a lie for which he will punish her, is the doctor's report. That made a sort of sense. Adam, the first character introduced, gripped me from the start and his story, intermingled with those who try to help him, is brilliant. Not quite a five star, but a fascinating, if rather difficult, book to read: very thought provoking