Nikki Jewell does it again and delivers yet another hit with The Penalty! It’s the fourth installment in her Lakeview Lightning series. This college hockey romance has everything fans love: heart, humor, and a perfect blend of tension and spice. The story kicks off with Devlin ("Dev"), a college hockey player, meeting Cecilia ("Cece") at Comic Con. 🤓Their shared passion quickly turns a casual weekend hangout into something more meaningful, but they agree to leave it at that. However, fate intervenes when Cece transfers to Lakeview for her final year to be closer to her twin brother, Beau—who, as it turns out, is also Dev's best friend. The romance that ensues is filled with secret dates and the thrill of hiding their relationship.
Dev and Cece's dynamic is irresistibly charming. Dev is reserved, with a vulnerable side stemming from a difficult past, while Cece's warmth and strength are a perfect counterbalance. Their chemistry is electric from their first meeting, and their secret relationship makes for plenty of delicious tension. Dev stands out as an unforgettable MMC—flawed, vulnerable, and genuine, which only makes him more endearing. Cece's journey, facing her own challenges, adds a layer of depth to her character, making her equally lovable.
Oh my goodness, I absolutely LOVED this book! Nikki Jewell has such an incredible talent for breathing life into her characters—it's not just the swoon-worthy romance that gets you hooked but also the rich themes of found family, personal growth, and deep, genuine friendships. The way she crafts her supporting characters adds so much humor, heart, and warmth to the story, making Lakeview feel like a world you never want to leave. And don't even get me started on the perfect mix of college hockey culture and geeky Comic Con vibes—it's the most delightful, refreshing combination. The emotional depth and chemistry between the characters just took my breath away. I couldn’t get enough of it! This book was an absolute joy from start to finish. I don’t even know if I can pick a fave from the series! They are all too good!
If you’re into college sports romances, the "brother’s best friend" trope, or the grumpy/sunshine dynamic, this book is a must-read. The heat level is high, though be prepared for a few cringey phrases in the spicy scenes. Overall, The Penalty is another slam dunk (or rather, a perfect goal) by Nikki Jewell—she never disappoints!