The opening of the book was really well done, and I think would be a great springboard to a substantial book club discussion, comparing our young lives with Karen's, and possibly exploring the differences because of most of us being 10 years older than she. But then, as it went on , it became less creative, and more mundane, esp. with the drinking college days, and the sorority/fraternity college stories. More than halfway in it spent a lot of time on mom's health, which made it a tough read for me (losing two very important relatives in a matter of a couple of months this year). Finally, I missed a high point and a good sound ending that would send the reader off with some good themes to learn from the book. One huge plus, though, is the connections most readers can make in the book. Because I was a teacher, the opening stories in the classroom reminded me of my kindergarten and early school days, and I enjoyed those parts. Those are the reasons for my score of 3 out of 5.