Rating: 4.5 stars
Yup, this is my favourite of the series so far. It has everything you've come to expect from the Nevermore Bookshop series, but just... more of it. More heart, more spice, more mystery, more murder and more moments that properly pull you in. And yet, it didn't quite go in the direction I expected, so it had some nice surprises for me too!
First thing's first, I defy anyone to read this book and NOT picture Andrew Scott and Benderdink Crumplesnack as Morrie and Sherlock. If you're a fan of their iterations on the telly, then you'll LOVE this. The imagery is... *mind wanders*... sorry, I got distracted 😂. What makes it for me is seeing Morrie shed his facade and show his vulnerability and goodness, while still somehow retaining the veneer of the criminal mastermind he is. His character development has been rather on the back burner for the last couple of books, with only hints of real change, but boy does it come to the fore here. The man he is at the end is the same and yet so totally different, and it feels like the relationship not just between him and Mina, but between all of our main characters is going to be far stronger and more settled for it.
The standalone plot of this book was good, and I really enjoyed the fact that it was set in the world of fandom and cosplay. However, there are so many different plot threads in this book, both as standalones and for the wider series arc, that it perhaps didn't get quite the amount of attention it deserved. Nevertheless, it was a clever yarn and a great reveal! And, if I'm being completely honest, the fact that this book was more about the characters than the underlying plot is probably a reason I enjoyed it so much!
Equally though, we got some proper moments in here relating to the bigger mystery of Nevermore, which definitely up the ante and make you wonder just what's in store! And some of the other wider storylines, like the introduction of Mina's new guide dog pup, Oscar, just make you smile wider and your heart melt just a bit more. But there's still a serious undertone to it all, despite the madness - Mina facing discrimination because of her loss of sight, and the portrayal of the 'old boys club' of a tech firm and the disgusting nature of certain men who have a position of power over a woman; it all adds up to a wonderfully pitched piece of writing that makes you laugh and think at the same time.
My only reservations with this book, and the only reason it doesn't get five stars, is down to what I found to be a bit of a muddled timeline. There are moments that feel important that I don't recall reading about in previous books, but that are clearly being laid down as the key to an important plot point (and the issue in question refers to Christmas). I'm sure at one point there's a mention of Halloween, like it's October, and then a few chapters later it's stated that it's February. And yet this book follows immediately on from the last, and each of the books previous to that seem to only have short gaps between them. Likewise, in the last book Mina was only considering getting a guide dog, but in this one she's already spoken with the organisation, applied and been accepted. Now, I can forgive all of this because the story is fabulous and, in the grand scheme of things, it doesn't make a whole lot of difference. But if I'm picking these things up with my 'passenger princess' style of reading, I suspect someone more analytical may get frustrated. I am absolutely happy be proven wrong here, so if anyone does want to walk me through it, I'd be most grateful!!!
Oh, and there are a few more non-Britishisms in here; dollars instead of pounds, blocks instead of streets etc. These do grate on my nerves just a smidge, particularly when it's Heathcliff, the bit of Yorkshire rough, using them.
But that ending! Your heart does a happy dance, then plummets to the floor in dread... I'm heading straight into book 6 because I cannot wait to see what happens next!