What do you think?
Rate this book
Dr. Julia Lewis #2
A Slash of Emerald
In a riveting new novel in a Victorian-set mystery series brimming with authentic atmosphere, Doctor Julia Lewis, Scotland Yard’s first female medical examiner, and her partner, Detective Inspector Richard Tennant, investigate a string of murders in the art world.
London, 1867: Among the genteel young ladies of London society, painting is a perfectly acceptable pastime—but a woman who dares to pursue art as a profession is another prospect, indeed. Dr. Julia Lewis, familiar with the disrespect afforded women in untraditional careers, is hardly surprised when Scotland Yard shows little interest in complaints made by her friend, Mary Allingham, about a break-in at her art studio. Mary is just one of many “lady painters” being targeted by vandals.
Painters’ sitters are vanishing, too—women viewed by some as dispensable outcasts. Inspector Richard Tennant, however, takes the attacks seriously, suspecting they’re linked to the poison-pen letters received by additional members of the Allingham family. For Julia, the issue is complicated by Tennant’s previous relationship with Mary’s sister-in-law, Louisa, and by her own surprising reaction to that entanglement.
But when someone close to them commits suicide and a young woman turns up dead, the case can no longer be so easily ignored by ‘respectable’ society. Layer after layer, Julia and Tennant scrape away the facts of the case like paint from a canvas. What emerges is a somber picture of vice, depravity, and deception stretching from London’s East End to the Far East—with a killer at its center, determined to get away with one last, grisly murder . . .
London, 1867: Among the genteel young ladies of London society, painting is a perfectly acceptable pastime—but a woman who dares to pursue art as a profession is another prospect, indeed. Dr. Julia Lewis, familiar with the disrespect afforded women in untraditional careers, is hardly surprised when Scotland Yard shows little interest in complaints made by her friend, Mary Allingham, about a break-in at her art studio. Mary is just one of many “lady painters” being targeted by vandals.
Painters’ sitters are vanishing, too—women viewed by some as dispensable outcasts. Inspector Richard Tennant, however, takes the attacks seriously, suspecting they’re linked to the poison-pen letters received by additional members of the Allingham family. For Julia, the issue is complicated by Tennant’s previous relationship with Mary’s sister-in-law, Louisa, and by her own surprising reaction to that entanglement.
But when someone close to them commits suicide and a young woman turns up dead, the case can no longer be so easily ignored by ‘respectable’ society. Layer after layer, Julia and Tennant scrape away the facts of the case like paint from a canvas. What emerges is a somber picture of vice, depravity, and deception stretching from London’s East End to the Far East—with a killer at its center, determined to get away with one last, grisly murder . . .
336 pages, Hardcover
Published February 25, 2025
135 people are currently reading
3761 people want to read
About the author
Patrice McDonough
5 books165 followersPatrice McDonough is the author of the Dr. Julia Lewis Mystery series set in Victorian England. MURDER BY LAMPLIGHT and A SLASH OF EMERALD are the first two books in the series. She is a native of the Garden State, has a master’s degree in history from Rutgers University/NJIT. She taught history and served as Department Chair at Immaculate Heart Academy in Washington Township, NJ, a college preparatory high school for girls, was named an Outstanding Educator by the Archdiocese of Newark in 1995, and is a member of the Historical Writers of America, the Mystery Writers of America, and the Historical Novels Society. She spends her leisure time traveling, sailing, missing puts on the golf course, and reading the histories, mysteries, and historical novels piled high on her night table.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 128 reviews
February 9, 2025
A Slash of Emerald
by Patrice McDonough, the second book in the Dr. Julia Lewis historical mystery series, picks up soon after the first book in the series. Set in Victorian London in 1867, it features Detective Inspector Richard Tennant of Scotland Yard and Dr. Julia Lewis, one of Britain’s first female physicians. Julia has recently been named Scotland Yard’s first female medical examiner, which adds to her workload running a medical clinic.
While painting is considered an acceptable pastime for women, it is not viewed as acceptable by most to pursue art as a profession. When Mary Allingham complains about a break-in at her art studio, Scotland Yard doesn’t want to pursue it. However, Mary is just one of the woman painters who are being targeted by vandals. Additionally, painters’ sitters are disappearing. Richard takes the attacks seriously and suspects they’re related to the poison-pen letters received by other members of the Allingham household. Julia and Richard join forces to investigate with help from Sergeant O’Malley.
Julia is candid, self-sufficient, intelligent, curious, and wants to be listened to; not just seen. She doesn’t hold back on her opinions. Richard is dour, aloof, guarded, has a steely resolve, and isn’t easy to know. He’s well-educated and doesn’t like tight spaces. Their characters gain depth as the story progresses. The author created characters with believable relationships that made them come to life.
Two main plotlines make this a twisty and absorbing story that is atmospheric and felt true to the times. I learned something about the Victorian art world. Many of the painters mentioned in the novel were real, not fictional. Imagine meeting Whistler and his contemporaries! It also incorporates some real-world issues into the story that still exist today. This adds depth to the narrative and provides food-for-thought. The worldbuilding was well-done and included cultural, societal, and political aspects for the story. While many parts of the story were wrapped up, a couple of key items were not sufficiently brought to a satisfactory conclusion for me. However, they will hopefully be resolved in book three.
Overall, this dark, gritty, and engaging book has great characterization with likeable main characters, excellent worldbuilding, and a solid mystery. Readers who appreciate historical mystery stories will likely enjoy this novel. I’m looking forward to the next book in the series.
Kensington Publishing and Patrice McDonough provided a complimentary digital ARC of this novel via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own. Publication date is currently set for February 25, 2025.
-------------------------------------------
My 4.14 rounded to 4 stars review is coming soon.
While painting is considered an acceptable pastime for women, it is not viewed as acceptable by most to pursue art as a profession. When Mary Allingham complains about a break-in at her art studio, Scotland Yard doesn’t want to pursue it. However, Mary is just one of the woman painters who are being targeted by vandals. Additionally, painters’ sitters are disappearing. Richard takes the attacks seriously and suspects they’re related to the poison-pen letters received by other members of the Allingham household. Julia and Richard join forces to investigate with help from Sergeant O’Malley.
Julia is candid, self-sufficient, intelligent, curious, and wants to be listened to; not just seen. She doesn’t hold back on her opinions. Richard is dour, aloof, guarded, has a steely resolve, and isn’t easy to know. He’s well-educated and doesn’t like tight spaces. Their characters gain depth as the story progresses. The author created characters with believable relationships that made them come to life.
Two main plotlines make this a twisty and absorbing story that is atmospheric and felt true to the times. I learned something about the Victorian art world. Many of the painters mentioned in the novel were real, not fictional. Imagine meeting Whistler and his contemporaries! It also incorporates some real-world issues into the story that still exist today. This adds depth to the narrative and provides food-for-thought. The worldbuilding was well-done and included cultural, societal, and political aspects for the story. While many parts of the story were wrapped up, a couple of key items were not sufficiently brought to a satisfactory conclusion for me. However, they will hopefully be resolved in book three.
Overall, this dark, gritty, and engaging book has great characterization with likeable main characters, excellent worldbuilding, and a solid mystery. Readers who appreciate historical mystery stories will likely enjoy this novel. I’m looking forward to the next book in the series.
Kensington Publishing and Patrice McDonough provided a complimentary digital ARC of this novel via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own. Publication date is currently set for February 25, 2025.
-------------------------------------------
My 4.14 rounded to 4 stars review is coming soon.
March 3, 2025
The book summary introduces the primary storyline of women artists being harassed and threatened and their models being killed or “disappearing”. Some of these women were being targeted for a purpose so horrible, while their deaths and disappearances were being ignored and blamed on the women instead of the rich, evil and despicable men who were behind it all. I enjoyed this book from the beginning until the end. High recommend.
February 6, 2025
It was nice catching up with Dr. Julia and Inspector Tennant in this new installment. I enjoy a good historical fiction story every now and then; it’s a nice break from all the police procedurals and crime thrillers that I read so much about. However, this is no cozy mystery, both installments have shown the dark and dangerous and seamy side of London and especially for Dr Julia (who was almost killed in the last book), as the first female doctor in London as well as Scotland Yard. I especially like historical fiction stories that have bold, brave, strong, smart and unconventional FMC’s, like Dr Julia. In other words, the original feminists who fought the battles and paved the way for the feminists of today who are still fighting some of the same battles.
The book summary introduces the primary storyline of women artists being harassed and threatened and their models being killed or “disappearing”. What the book summary doesn’t mention is that some of these women were being targeted for a purpose so horrible, while their deaths and disappearances were being ignored and blamed on the women instead of the rich, evil and despicable men who were behind it all.
There is also a secondary storyline of Dr Julia’s and Inspector Tennant’s growing affections and attraction towards each other. With Dr Julia returning to her family’s clinic after having recuperated from almost being killed in the last installment, she is diving back in full speed ahead. With Inspector Tennant entrenched in the “Yard” as well as dealing with a difficult superior, they both have no time for courting and are so pitifully awkward in the romance department. At this point, I’m thinking if this goes on much longer, it’s going to become painful to watch. Lots of eye-rolling and snickering during these parts.
Most of the story revolves around the threats, murders and disappearances of the female artists and models. As the clues and leads came in along with more dead bodies, my armchair detective was all over the place trying to decide who the real monster was, but did start to zero in on someone after a while. WOW!!! Was I ever wrong! The ending was so shocking, intense and kind of disturbing! However, it was the final scene that had my eyes becoming just a little moist and the whisper of a “oh no” for Dr Julia. I don’t know what’s going on, whether it’s just me being a little too invested in my characters and their fate or if it’s just the last few installments for some of my fave series have all just had sad endings. I’d like to think it’s the latter, but it’s probably a little of both.
The continuing character development for Dr Julia and Inspector Tennant was well done. It will be interesting to see what McDonough has in store for them. The pacing was steady and the storyline very interesting. I really enjoyed the Author Notes at the end that included some additional history and info on the art world and artists of that time. The writing was also well done and on par for the series so far. McDonough has definitely done a lot of research and portrays in a realistic manner. I’m looking at an overall rating of 4.3 that I will be rounding down to a 4star review. I want to thank NetGalley and Kensington Publishing for sending me this eARC in exchange for my honest review.
#NetGalley #KensingtonPublishing #ASlashofEmerald
The book summary introduces the primary storyline of women artists being harassed and threatened and their models being killed or “disappearing”. What the book summary doesn’t mention is that some of these women were being targeted for a purpose so horrible, while their deaths and disappearances were being ignored and blamed on the women instead of the rich, evil and despicable men who were behind it all.
There is also a secondary storyline of Dr Julia’s and Inspector Tennant’s growing affections and attraction towards each other. With Dr Julia returning to her family’s clinic after having recuperated from almost being killed in the last installment, she is diving back in full speed ahead. With Inspector Tennant entrenched in the “Yard” as well as dealing with a difficult superior, they both have no time for courting and are so pitifully awkward in the romance department. At this point, I’m thinking if this goes on much longer, it’s going to become painful to watch. Lots of eye-rolling and snickering during these parts.
Most of the story revolves around the threats, murders and disappearances of the female artists and models. As the clues and leads came in along with more dead bodies, my armchair detective was all over the place trying to decide who the real monster was, but did start to zero in on someone after a while. WOW!!! Was I ever wrong! The ending was so shocking, intense and kind of disturbing! However, it was the final scene that had my eyes becoming just a little moist and the whisper of a “oh no” for Dr Julia. I don’t know what’s going on, whether it’s just me being a little too invested in my characters and their fate or if it’s just the last few installments for some of my fave series have all just had sad endings. I’d like to think it’s the latter, but it’s probably a little of both.
The continuing character development for Dr Julia and Inspector Tennant was well done. It will be interesting to see what McDonough has in store for them. The pacing was steady and the storyline very interesting. I really enjoyed the Author Notes at the end that included some additional history and info on the art world and artists of that time. The writing was also well done and on par for the series so far. McDonough has definitely done a lot of research and portrays in a realistic manner. I’m looking at an overall rating of 4.3 that I will be rounding down to a 4star review. I want to thank NetGalley and Kensington Publishing for sending me this eARC in exchange for my honest review.
#NetGalley #KensingtonPublishing #ASlashofEmerald
May 18, 2025
4 very strong stars!
I really enjoyed the first book featuring Dr. Julia Lewis. However, this second book was much stronger: smoother writing, better plot elements , more devolped characters.
I loved the art world setting of London in 1867. Female artists are struggling to have their work exhibited for the Royal Academy' major art show as well as facing harassment at their own gallery show. The plot kicked off with Mary Allingham, one of these female professional artists, complaining to the police about a break-in at her art studio. This is followed by artists' models being attacked or vanishing. And when one of those models turned up dead, her body dumped in the street, Inspector Richard Tennant of Scotland Yard became very interested in learning more.
I loved watching the growing relationship between Julia and Richard--no insta-love here. This is very slow burn and the better for it. I also appreciated all of the non-mystery scenes, especially the dinners with Julia's grandfather and aunt and their various guests.
The murder mystery was clever, though I did identify the murderer before the big reveal. The secondary mystery involving human trafficking, and high-end pornography publishing was interesting as it crossed paths with the murders.
As a bonus, the ending gave us hope for another book. I'll be waiting, eager to read it whenever it comes out.
I really enjoyed the first book featuring Dr. Julia Lewis. However, this second book was much stronger: smoother writing, better plot elements , more devolped characters.
I loved the art world setting of London in 1867. Female artists are struggling to have their work exhibited for the Royal Academy' major art show as well as facing harassment at their own gallery show. The plot kicked off with Mary Allingham, one of these female professional artists, complaining to the police about a break-in at her art studio. This is followed by artists' models being attacked or vanishing. And when one of those models turned up dead, her body dumped in the street, Inspector Richard Tennant of Scotland Yard became very interested in learning more.
I loved watching the growing relationship between Julia and Richard--no insta-love here. This is very slow burn and the better for it. I also appreciated all of the non-mystery scenes, especially the dinners with Julia's grandfather and aunt and their various guests.
The murder mystery was clever, though I did identify the murderer before the big reveal. The secondary mystery involving human trafficking, and high-end pornography publishing was interesting as it crossed paths with the murders.
As a bonus, the ending gave us hope for another book. I'll be waiting, eager to read it whenever it comes out.
February 27, 2025
Dr. Julia Lewis once more finds herself embroiled in murder.
Inspector Richard Tennant, of Scotland Yard, calls on Julia where he can to act as the coroner In his inquiries
This time he does it out of deference to a young woman’s feelings who’s been brought in under the Contagious Diseases Act, as she’d been walking home from her work via St James’s Park, a dodgy part of London at night, and near to the barracks. Annie O’Neil is a hat maker who’s also been working as an artist’s model. However neither the Act nor the constabulary in this time of 1867 discern between everyday workers and prostitutes.
A doctor is needed to examine Annie to determine if she’s a prostitute. Julia is livid with the law. Her opinion is that, “forced examinations are medical rape.”
This is just the opening barrage in the murder of some respected members of society, apparently united until now, the puzzling disappearance and murder of young and respectable working women, threats being made against women painters who are holding a major exhibition, and the recovery of traumatized young Chinese girls who’d thought they were being sent to North America as brides, but ended up in London in brothels.
There’s more than one thread of occurrences but are they in anyway linked?
Another intriguing mystery from Mcdonough, one to get your teeth into!
A Kensington ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
Please note: Quotes taken from an advanced reading copy maybe subject to change
Inspector Richard Tennant, of Scotland Yard, calls on Julia where he can to act as the coroner In his inquiries
This time he does it out of deference to a young woman’s feelings who’s been brought in under the Contagious Diseases Act, as she’d been walking home from her work via St James’s Park, a dodgy part of London at night, and near to the barracks. Annie O’Neil is a hat maker who’s also been working as an artist’s model. However neither the Act nor the constabulary in this time of 1867 discern between everyday workers and prostitutes.
A doctor is needed to examine Annie to determine if she’s a prostitute. Julia is livid with the law. Her opinion is that, “forced examinations are medical rape.”
This is just the opening barrage in the murder of some respected members of society, apparently united until now, the puzzling disappearance and murder of young and respectable working women, threats being made against women painters who are holding a major exhibition, and the recovery of traumatized young Chinese girls who’d thought they were being sent to North America as brides, but ended up in London in brothels.
There’s more than one thread of occurrences but are they in anyway linked?
Another intriguing mystery from Mcdonough, one to get your teeth into!
A Kensington ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
Please note: Quotes taken from an advanced reading copy maybe subject to change
March 31, 2025
I enjoyed this historical mystery so very much! This is a dark, gritty, and highly engaging book. The main characters are likable and intelligent, and it features truly excellent worldbuilding, with a well plotted mystery.
With two main plotlines and a twisty story set against the atmospheric backdrop of Victorian London, the story is vividly portrayed. Learning about the Victorian art world was surprisingly intriguing.
Readers who love a great historical mystery are a perfect fit for this book. Getting to know Inspector Richard Tennant & Dr. Julia Lewis, as this series progresses, has been a joy. I'm definitely looking forward to more of them both in this series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are my own.
With two main plotlines and a twisty story set against the atmospheric backdrop of Victorian London, the story is vividly portrayed. Learning about the Victorian art world was surprisingly intriguing.
Readers who love a great historical mystery are a perfect fit for this book. Getting to know Inspector Richard Tennant & Dr. Julia Lewis, as this series progresses, has been a joy. I'm definitely looking forward to more of them both in this series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are my own.
March 10, 2025
This was a fantastic read filled with some interesting history [while trafficking is still very prevalent today, it was fascinating to view it through the lends of 1867 and how little they had to work with and little resources as well] that really fleshed out the story [art and murder anyone?], and an excellent mystery that kept me guessing until the well-done reveal that I NEVER EVER saw coming and left me sad, but also wishing for more, or at least another book to dive into. ;-)
If you love really good historical mysteries, then this series is for you; I am so very glad I took a chance on it.
Very well done.
Thank you to NetGalley, Patrice McDonough, and Kensington Publishing/Kensington for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
If you love really good historical mysteries, then this series is for you; I am so very glad I took a chance on it.
Very well done.
Thank you to NetGalley, Patrice McDonough, and Kensington Publishing/Kensington for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
November 9, 2025
I really liked this book. It continues nicely from the first one, and I found myself getting pulled back into the story quite easily. The pacing felt good, the characters more developed, and the writing had a nice rhythm that made it easy to keep reading.
And then that ending — such a cliffhanger. I finished it and immediately wanted to know what happens next.
Overall, A Slash of Emerald was a solid follow-up. It kept the tone and style I liked from the first one but added more tension and emotion. I’m definitely curious to see where the story goes from here.
And then that ending — such a cliffhanger. I finished it and immediately wanted to know what happens next.
Overall, A Slash of Emerald was a solid follow-up. It kept the tone and style I liked from the first one but added more tension and emotion. I’m definitely curious to see where the story goes from here.
September 29, 2024
Another solid entry in this series. I like how brisk they are. No need to record every encounter and interview here - just stick to the meat and potatoes of the investigation. This avoids a lot of plot cliches, too, and I appreciate that. These are never going to be bestsellers, but they’re well written, and I hope they continue to be engaging reads.
April 16, 2025
A fantastic follow-up/continuation of Murder by Lamplight! Lies and murder abound in the Victorian artworld, leaving Detective Tennant and Dr. Lewis to sort out yet another mess together. I think I enjoyed this book even more than the first one! A great read!
March 17, 2025
Looking forward to book number 3.
November 7, 2024
The second book in this very promising series set in Victorian London is a well-plotted and enjoyable read. Dr, Julia Lewis is back and again working with the very open-minded Inspector we met in the first book in the series. This can be read as a standalone, although I’d recommend reading the first just because it’s also a good read. This time the mystery centers on murders and other crimes in the art world and specifically among artists’ models. As with the first book, this one gives good historical detail and context without becoming merely descriptive. We learn more about some of the characters’ pasts, and the mystery itself is well done. My only real quibble is one of personal preference, which is that I really dislike cliffhanger endings. That said, I’m looking forward to seeing how this one resolves. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an advance copy. All views are entirely my own and offered voluntarily.
January 28, 2025
Another fun outing in this series!
We previously met Dr. Julia Lewis and Inspector Richard Tennant in Murder by Lamplight, and A Slash of Emerald takes place shortly thereafter, with Richard having gotten Julia's name on Scotland Yard's official list of medical examiners. I quite enjoy the burgeoning connection between Julia and Richard, and if there's anyone else out there who, like me, rage-quit Miss Scarlet and the Duke when they wrote the Duke off, this series might help fill that small hole in your heart.
This second book in the series sees Julia and Richard investigating a series of crimes connected to a group of female painters. Why are the female artists receiving nasty poisoned pen letters, and how does it connect to another string of crimes? Once again, this mystery does address some heavy topics, so content warning for .
I enjoyed how the mystery unfolded and was quite satisfied when we found out who was behind it all. Just like with the first book in the series, I did guess who the killer was, but I was excited about being proven correct. The clues were clever, the motive compelling, and it was satisfying when all came to light in the end. The mystery also features cameos from real Victorian-era artists and the author's note at the end about what was real and what was fictional taught me some interesting facts I didn't know.
There was a whiff of Julia and Richard's growing feelings for each other, and I like their nice slow-burn. I do wish we got a bit more of Richard's backstory in this - I thought his PTSD from Crimea would be explored more than it was, and I don't think it was necessary to make one of the characters in the book, Louisa, his former girlfriend. One, , and two, it didn't have much impact on the story, other than Julia briefly feeling jealous one time.
Overall, enjoyable second entry. I hope there will be a third in the series.
Thank you to the publisher, Kensington, for providing me with my copy via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
We previously met Dr. Julia Lewis and Inspector Richard Tennant in Murder by Lamplight, and A Slash of Emerald takes place shortly thereafter, with Richard having gotten Julia's name on Scotland Yard's official list of medical examiners. I quite enjoy the burgeoning connection between Julia and Richard, and if there's anyone else out there who, like me, rage-quit Miss Scarlet and the Duke when they wrote the Duke off, this series might help fill that small hole in your heart.
This second book in the series sees Julia and Richard investigating a series of crimes connected to a group of female painters. Why are the female artists receiving nasty poisoned pen letters, and how does it connect to another string of crimes? Once again, this mystery does address some heavy topics, so content warning for .
I enjoyed how the mystery unfolded and was quite satisfied when we found out who was behind it all. Just like with the first book in the series, I did guess who the killer was, but I was excited about being proven correct. The clues were clever, the motive compelling, and it was satisfying when all came to light in the end. The mystery also features cameos from real Victorian-era artists and the author's note at the end about what was real and what was fictional taught me some interesting facts I didn't know.
There was a whiff of Julia and Richard's growing feelings for each other, and I like their nice slow-burn. I do wish we got a bit more of Richard's backstory in this - I thought his PTSD from Crimea would be explored more than it was, and I don't think it was necessary to make one of the characters in the book, Louisa, his former girlfriend. One, , and two, it didn't have much impact on the story, other than Julia briefly feeling jealous one time.
Overall, enjoyable second entry. I hope there will be a third in the series.
Thank you to the publisher, Kensington, for providing me with my copy via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
October 2, 2024
Thank you to Kensington and NetGalley for providing an advance copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. The book will be published on February 25th, 2025.
This Victorian London mystery really grew on me with its abundance of female characters pursuing professions and activities still unusual at the time (1867). Julia Lewis is a doctor and medical examiner who is called on to do post-mortems on women and to inspect suspected prostitutes for venereal disease (!) I love the historical note that Julia — trained in the US — is able to practice medicine in Britain (where medical schools do not admit women) though a loophole: Parliament added doctors with foreign degrees to the medical register in 1858 without specifying that they had to be men. Absolutely delightful piece of (real world) trivia! She is paired with the rather open-minded Inspector Tennant in this second installment of the Dr. Julia Lewis Mysteries.
This episode centers on the art world of Victorian England, the narrative flowing between competition for the Royal Academy's annual exhibition and the frustrations of the female artists who wish to pursue art as a profession, rather than a genteel pastime. I enjoyed the fully fleshed out setting which opened an entire world of models, studios, galleries, technique, and inspiration with just enough well-researched detail. I particularly enjoyed the comment of one artist who pointed out that the best models were actresses who were able to channel the painter’s intention while posing.
Decent writing, strong women characters, and full marks for an historical setting that is detailed, interesting, and accurate. I’m going back to read book number one!
This Victorian London mystery really grew on me with its abundance of female characters pursuing professions and activities still unusual at the time (1867). Julia Lewis is a doctor and medical examiner who is called on to do post-mortems on women and to inspect suspected prostitutes for venereal disease (!) I love the historical note that Julia — trained in the US — is able to practice medicine in Britain (where medical schools do not admit women) though a loophole: Parliament added doctors with foreign degrees to the medical register in 1858 without specifying that they had to be men. Absolutely delightful piece of (real world) trivia! She is paired with the rather open-minded Inspector Tennant in this second installment of the Dr. Julia Lewis Mysteries.
This episode centers on the art world of Victorian England, the narrative flowing between competition for the Royal Academy's annual exhibition and the frustrations of the female artists who wish to pursue art as a profession, rather than a genteel pastime. I enjoyed the fully fleshed out setting which opened an entire world of models, studios, galleries, technique, and inspiration with just enough well-researched detail. I particularly enjoyed the comment of one artist who pointed out that the best models were actresses who were able to channel the painter’s intention while posing.
Decent writing, strong women characters, and full marks for an historical setting that is detailed, interesting, and accurate. I’m going back to read book number one!
January 30, 2025
We are dropped right into London is 1867 when Dr. Julia Grey is called to a police station to examine a woman who has been arrested for prostitution by her friend Inspector Tennant. Just passing by an Army base is enough for any woman to be arrested. In this case, the young hatter has been on a legitimate errand and is let go. The blatant sexism of the time is something that winds its way throughout the plot of this story.
Not only did Julia get onto the registry of doctors through a loophole but she has to face all sorts of prejudice from most men who can't believe that a woman can be a doctor. When she is instrumental in rescuing a man from ice breaking while skating, he doesn't let her examine him leaving his sister Mary concerned about his welfare.
Mary Allingham is facing prejudice of her own as she is trying to make her name as a female artist. Richard Tennant is concerned about these female artists because there have been blackmail letters and other threatening letters sent to many female artists and many artists' models have been disappearing.
Tennant is looking into the death of a young artists' model whose body was thrown from a speeding carriage. And shortly after, he also has the case of a famous artists' model who has had her throat cut. Margot Miller was frequently the subject of both male and female artists.
Tennant's investigation leads him into the world of pornography and trafficking which is partially wrapped into the art world. Mary's brother who is a wealthy printer and publisher is a suspect in both the trafficking and pornography until he is found dead in an apparent suicide.
Julia and Richard are both involved in the investigation and have different sources of information. I liked the way the mystery unfolded. I also liked the way Julia and Richard's slow-burn romance is progressing. The story had great historical details.
Not only did Julia get onto the registry of doctors through a loophole but she has to face all sorts of prejudice from most men who can't believe that a woman can be a doctor. When she is instrumental in rescuing a man from ice breaking while skating, he doesn't let her examine him leaving his sister Mary concerned about his welfare.
Mary Allingham is facing prejudice of her own as she is trying to make her name as a female artist. Richard Tennant is concerned about these female artists because there have been blackmail letters and other threatening letters sent to many female artists and many artists' models have been disappearing.
Tennant is looking into the death of a young artists' model whose body was thrown from a speeding carriage. And shortly after, he also has the case of a famous artists' model who has had her throat cut. Margot Miller was frequently the subject of both male and female artists.
Tennant's investigation leads him into the world of pornography and trafficking which is partially wrapped into the art world. Mary's brother who is a wealthy printer and publisher is a suspect in both the trafficking and pornography until he is found dead in an apparent suicide.
Julia and Richard are both involved in the investigation and have different sources of information. I liked the way the mystery unfolded. I also liked the way Julia and Richard's slow-burn romance is progressing. The story had great historical details.
February 17, 2025
Thank you to Patrice McDonough and Kensington Publishing (through Netgalley) for a digital ARC in exchange for my honest review!
On the dark streets of London, 1867, Inspector Richard Tennant & Dr. Julia Lewis are once again pulled together to solve a growing case involving the rich and poor alike. If you enjoy clever historical mysteries then look no further.
I thoroughly enjoyed my time with Tennant and Lewis as they expertly navigate another case together. Lewis is compassionate and diligent in her work as a doctor, especially in a time not prone to accepting women who choose their careers over all else. Tennant is a hound when it comes to sniffing out dishonesty and pursuing all avenues, even when they appear to be a dead end. Together they're an evenly matched team.
Patrice McDonough is an expert at writing mystery novels that immerse the reader in the intricacies and politics of Victorian England. She doesn't romanticize London. She lays it out plainly as a playground for depravity. No one is safe, and as the case unfolds it becomes clear that there are no limits to what people are willing to do to get what they want.
If you're looking for a mystery novel that has an abundance of history meshed in, then a Dr. Julia Lewis Mystery is for you. A Slash of Emerald is dark, dry, and all business.
Available February 25th, 2025.
On the dark streets of London, 1867, Inspector Richard Tennant & Dr. Julia Lewis are once again pulled together to solve a growing case involving the rich and poor alike. If you enjoy clever historical mysteries then look no further.
I thoroughly enjoyed my time with Tennant and Lewis as they expertly navigate another case together. Lewis is compassionate and diligent in her work as a doctor, especially in a time not prone to accepting women who choose their careers over all else. Tennant is a hound when it comes to sniffing out dishonesty and pursuing all avenues, even when they appear to be a dead end. Together they're an evenly matched team.
Patrice McDonough is an expert at writing mystery novels that immerse the reader in the intricacies and politics of Victorian England. She doesn't romanticize London. She lays it out plainly as a playground for depravity. No one is safe, and as the case unfolds it becomes clear that there are no limits to what people are willing to do to get what they want.
If you're looking for a mystery novel that has an abundance of history meshed in, then a Dr. Julia Lewis Mystery is for you. A Slash of Emerald is dark, dry, and all business.
Available February 25th, 2025.
January 10, 2025
A Slash of Emerald by Patrice Mcdonough is a great historical fiction and mystery which is the is the second book in the Dr. Julia Lewis Mystery series.
I really enjoyed the first book in this series, and this was a nice follow up. This series is a bit more dark and gritty than other “cozy mystery” series, but so far, it seems to fit.
The murder/mystery plot was intricate and kept me engaged, however I could have used a bit more of Julia…jmo.
I will definitely continue to read to see how this goes.
4/5 stars
Thank you NG and Kensington Publishing | Kensington for this wonderful arc and in return I am submitting my unbiased and voluntary review and opinion.
I am posting this review to my GR and Bookbub accounts immediately and will post it to my Amazon, Instagram, and B&N accounts upon publication on 2/25/25.
I really enjoyed the first book in this series, and this was a nice follow up. This series is a bit more dark and gritty than other “cozy mystery” series, but so far, it seems to fit.
The murder/mystery plot was intricate and kept me engaged, however I could have used a bit more of Julia…jmo.
I will definitely continue to read to see how this goes.
4/5 stars
Thank you NG and Kensington Publishing | Kensington for this wonderful arc and in return I am submitting my unbiased and voluntary review and opinion.
I am posting this review to my GR and Bookbub accounts immediately and will post it to my Amazon, Instagram, and B&N accounts upon publication on 2/25/25.
November 7, 2024
3.5 stars for another entertaining read in the Dr Julia Lewis series. I’m wholly invested in where this series is going, and can’t wait for the next. The middle of the book sagged somewhat, and at one point I struggled with all the names and how they were all connected, but it came together nicely in the end. (Must brag that I did guess the murderer much before the reveal.)
(Review copy from NetGalley)
(Review copy from NetGalley)
February 19, 2025
Both the world of Victorian London, and the characters, stand out in this new installment.
May 24, 2025
The second book in the Dr. Julia Lewis and Richard Tennant series. I book looks at the steamy side of Victoria England. A good read with interesting characters
July 27, 2025
Good series?
October 21, 2025
Very good follow-up to the previous book.
I would have preferred a more definite conclusion but it seems things are set up for a new book.
I would have preferred a more definite conclusion but it seems things are set up for a new book.
June 6, 2025
Dr J Lewis should explain why the girlfriend of the art reviewer was able to get pregnant for him without contracting Syphilis but his wife had previously had three miscarriages because she was infected with Syphilis by him. The man had never been cured and had a rash and sores.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 26, 2025
Historical mystery but not a cozy. Read PamG s review.
May 4, 2025
A Slash of Emerald is the second in a Victorian Mystery series starring Dr. Julia Lewis. I normally find female forensic detectives to be the best stories. This was a little bit bland. It may be that not having read the first book in the series, I was missing some background. But this particular mystery was not very challenging. All of the perpetrators either committed suicide or escaped the country except for a few lackeys doing the dirty work. The murderer wasn’t difficult to figure out due to the consistent victimization they received from all three people murdered. The story dealt with women in the art world and freedom to paint, either life studies (nudes) or the right to be hung with male painters in the Royal Academy. It was not very passionate on the part of the characters. The other half of the story involved pornography and a form of human trafficking occurring with young working women and young girls who were kidnapped and put to work in brothels. The murders stem from a wealthy families association with both worlds. The major abusers of these women were not pursued because of standing and wealth and the murderer killed the other people involved and then killed themself to avoid justice. Very unsatisfying. I like surprise and a little meat to my mysteries.
Technically, the writing style is well done and Dr. Julia has potential. I hope this is brought to bear in future novels.
3⭐️
Technically, the writing style is well done and Dr. Julia has potential. I hope this is brought to bear in future novels.
3⭐️
February 27, 2025
Thank you to Kensington Publishing for the ARC!
In A Slash of Emerald, the second installment in the Dr. Julia Lewis Mystery series, Patrice McDonough delivers another gripping, atmospheric historical mystery set in the shadowed alleys and grand salons of Victorian London. With meticulous attention to detail, McDonough immerses readers in a world where art and ambition collide with danger, and women who dare to defy societal norms face peril at every turn.
A Dark and Intriguing Mystery
Dr. Julia Lewis, Scotland Yard’s first female medical examiner, once again finds herself entangled in a sinister case, this time alongside the steadfast Inspector Richard Tennant. When her friend, Mary Allingham, reports a break-in at her art studio, the authorities dismiss it as a minor nuisance. But as more female artists become targets of vandalism and their sitters begin disappearing, it becomes clear that something far more insidious is at play.
Tennant, already investigating a series of poison-pen letters aimed at the Allingham family, starts to see connections between these seemingly unrelated events. As the bodies begin to surface, Julia and Tennant must navigate a treacherous path of secrets and lies, peeling back layers of deception like paint from a canvas. From the opulent homes of the wealthy to the grim realities of London’s East End, the mystery deepens, revealing a chilling conspiracy that stretches across continents.
What Makes This Book Stand Out
✅ Authentic Historical Detail –McDonough masterfully recreates the Victorian era, from its societal constraints to the art world’s struggles. Real-life painters make cameo appearances, adding richness to the narrative.
✅ Compelling Female Lead – Julia is sharp, determined, and unafraid to push boundaries. Her resilience in a male-dominated field makes her an inspiring protagonist.
✅ Intricate, Twisting Plot – The blend of murder, missing women, and a deeper, more horrifying crime kept me turning pages late into the night.
✅ Subtle but Engaging Romance – The slow-burn relationship between Julia and Tennant adds an emotional depth without detracting from the main mystery.
✅ A Gritty, Realistic View of the Times – This is no cozy mystery; McDonough doesn’t shy away from the dark realities of 19th-century London, making the stakes feel all the more urgent.
TROPES & THEMES:
Strong Female Protagonist 💪 – Julia is a pioneer in her field and refuses to be sidelined.
Historical Mystery 📜 – A richly detailed look at the Victorian art scene, crime, and society.
Slow-Burn Romance 💕 – Julia and Tennant’s evolving dynamic is filled with tension and unspoken emotions.
Secrets & Deception 🎭 – Hidden motives and shocking revelations make for an unpredictable read.
>Social Commentary ✍️ – The book highlights real struggles women faced in Victorian times, many of which remain relevant today.
A Few Quibbles
⚠️ Unresolved Threads – A few plotlines felt like they needed a more conclusive wrap-up, likely setting up the next book.
⚠️ That Cliffhanger! – The ending left me craving the next installment immediately, which is both a compliment and a mild frustration.
Final Verdict ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
A Slash of Emerald is a dark, thought-provoking, and engrossing historical mystery that seamlessly blends fact with fiction. With compelling characters, a suspenseful plot, and a setting that feels vividly real, McDonough cements her place as a must-read author for historical mystery lovers. If you enjoy books with strong heroines, intricate investigations, and a dash of romance, this one is for you!
I can’t wait to see where Julia and Tennant’s journey takes them next. Bring on book three!
In A Slash of Emerald, the second installment in the Dr. Julia Lewis Mystery series, Patrice McDonough delivers another gripping, atmospheric historical mystery set in the shadowed alleys and grand salons of Victorian London. With meticulous attention to detail, McDonough immerses readers in a world where art and ambition collide with danger, and women who dare to defy societal norms face peril at every turn.
A Dark and Intriguing Mystery
Dr. Julia Lewis, Scotland Yard’s first female medical examiner, once again finds herself entangled in a sinister case, this time alongside the steadfast Inspector Richard Tennant. When her friend, Mary Allingham, reports a break-in at her art studio, the authorities dismiss it as a minor nuisance. But as more female artists become targets of vandalism and their sitters begin disappearing, it becomes clear that something far more insidious is at play.
Tennant, already investigating a series of poison-pen letters aimed at the Allingham family, starts to see connections between these seemingly unrelated events. As the bodies begin to surface, Julia and Tennant must navigate a treacherous path of secrets and lies, peeling back layers of deception like paint from a canvas. From the opulent homes of the wealthy to the grim realities of London’s East End, the mystery deepens, revealing a chilling conspiracy that stretches across continents.
What Makes This Book Stand Out
✅ Authentic Historical Detail –McDonough masterfully recreates the Victorian era, from its societal constraints to the art world’s struggles. Real-life painters make cameo appearances, adding richness to the narrative.
✅ Compelling Female Lead – Julia is sharp, determined, and unafraid to push boundaries. Her resilience in a male-dominated field makes her an inspiring protagonist.
✅ Intricate, Twisting Plot – The blend of murder, missing women, and a deeper, more horrifying crime kept me turning pages late into the night.
✅ Subtle but Engaging Romance – The slow-burn relationship between Julia and Tennant adds an emotional depth without detracting from the main mystery.
✅ A Gritty, Realistic View of the Times – This is no cozy mystery; McDonough doesn’t shy away from the dark realities of 19th-century London, making the stakes feel all the more urgent.
TROPES & THEMES:
Strong Female Protagonist 💪 – Julia is a pioneer in her field and refuses to be sidelined.
Historical Mystery 📜 – A richly detailed look at the Victorian art scene, crime, and society.
Slow-Burn Romance 💕 – Julia and Tennant’s evolving dynamic is filled with tension and unspoken emotions.
Secrets & Deception 🎭 – Hidden motives and shocking revelations make for an unpredictable read.
>Social Commentary ✍️ – The book highlights real struggles women faced in Victorian times, many of which remain relevant today.
A Few Quibbles
⚠️ Unresolved Threads – A few plotlines felt like they needed a more conclusive wrap-up, likely setting up the next book.
⚠️ That Cliffhanger! – The ending left me craving the next installment immediately, which is both a compliment and a mild frustration.
Final Verdict ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
A Slash of Emerald is a dark, thought-provoking, and engrossing historical mystery that seamlessly blends fact with fiction. With compelling characters, a suspenseful plot, and a setting that feels vividly real, McDonough cements her place as a must-read author for historical mystery lovers. If you enjoy books with strong heroines, intricate investigations, and a dash of romance, this one is for you!
I can’t wait to see where Julia and Tennant’s journey takes them next. Bring on book three!
March 5, 2025
Originally posted on my blog Nonstop Reader.
A Slash of Emerald is the second historical mystery featuring Dr. Julia Lewis, by Patrice McDonough. Released 25th Feb 2025 by Kensington, it's 336 pages and is available in hardcover, audio, and ebook formats. It's worth noting that the ebook format has a handy interactive table of contents as well as interactive links and references throughout.
A well crafted thoroughly researched historical novel featuring an intelligent and driven young female physician in London in 1866. She's fully licensed (having used a legal loophole to join the register of practicing physicians after finishing her studies in the USA), and has joined her grandfather's practice. She has a very keen eye for detail, and employs critical reasoning and observation to also help the police with inquiries.
It's not really a cozy cozy, there are some gruesome descriptions, but overall, the violence occurs chiefly off-page, so it's not truly horrifying. The author also doesn't shy away from the historically accurate but distressing sexism, racism, xenophobia, homophobia, crushing poverty, and other unsavory details. Speaking of detail, the book is written around a framework of actual historical events and people, and interwoven with a lot of interesting real political and social movements of the time period. Ms. McDonough has definitely done her homework.
The characterizations are impressive, and they're three dimensional and believable, with their own motivations and agendas. There's some slow-burn development/potential romance between Julia and Richard, but it's definitely sloooow (2 books in, and there are only glimmers of romance, nothing concrete). This volume works well enough as a standalone mystery, but there are some interpersonal developments between the returning characters which will be spoiled if read out of order.
The unabridged audiobook version has a run time of 9 hours and 15 minutes and is capably read by series narrator Henrietta Meire. She has a light RP English accent, but does a credible job with the varied London accents both male and female. Sound and production quality are high throughout the read.
Worth a look for readers of historical mystery and very well written. Readers who enjoy Deanna Raybourn, Anna Lee Huber, Tasha Alexander, et. al., will likely enjoy this book.
Four and a half stars.
Disclosure: I received an ARC at no cost from the author/publisher for review purposes.
A Slash of Emerald is the second historical mystery featuring Dr. Julia Lewis, by Patrice McDonough. Released 25th Feb 2025 by Kensington, it's 336 pages and is available in hardcover, audio, and ebook formats. It's worth noting that the ebook format has a handy interactive table of contents as well as interactive links and references throughout.
A well crafted thoroughly researched historical novel featuring an intelligent and driven young female physician in London in 1866. She's fully licensed (having used a legal loophole to join the register of practicing physicians after finishing her studies in the USA), and has joined her grandfather's practice. She has a very keen eye for detail, and employs critical reasoning and observation to also help the police with inquiries.
It's not really a cozy cozy, there are some gruesome descriptions, but overall, the violence occurs chiefly off-page, so it's not truly horrifying. The author also doesn't shy away from the historically accurate but distressing sexism, racism, xenophobia, homophobia, crushing poverty, and other unsavory details. Speaking of detail, the book is written around a framework of actual historical events and people, and interwoven with a lot of interesting real political and social movements of the time period. Ms. McDonough has definitely done her homework.
The characterizations are impressive, and they're three dimensional and believable, with their own motivations and agendas. There's some slow-burn development/potential romance between Julia and Richard, but it's definitely sloooow (2 books in, and there are only glimmers of romance, nothing concrete). This volume works well enough as a standalone mystery, but there are some interpersonal developments between the returning characters which will be spoiled if read out of order.
The unabridged audiobook version has a run time of 9 hours and 15 minutes and is capably read by series narrator Henrietta Meire. She has a light RP English accent, but does a credible job with the varied London accents both male and female. Sound and production quality are high throughout the read.
Worth a look for readers of historical mystery and very well written. Readers who enjoy Deanna Raybourn, Anna Lee Huber, Tasha Alexander, et. al., will likely enjoy this book.
Four and a half stars.
Disclosure: I received an ARC at no cost from the author/publisher for review purposes.
February 20, 2025
🌟 A Slash of Emerald by Patrice McDonough is the second book in the Dr. Julia Lewis Mysteries series, and it’s a dark and atmospheric historical mystery set in Victorian London 🏙️. Dr. Julia Lewis is back, and this time, she’s working with the ever-so-determined Inspector Richard Tennant 🔍. The plot is a whirlwind of intrigue, art, and suspense, with an emphasis on strong, daring women fighting against the odds 💪.
What I Liked:
• Historical Richness: McDonough does an amazing job capturing the gritty, dangerous side of Victorian London 🎨💀. The art world, filled with ambitious female artists, is beautifully explored 👩🎨.
• Strong Female Characters: Dr. Julia is a force to be reckoned with! A doctor and Scotland Yard's first female medical examiner, she’s independent, smart, and unafraid to speak her mind 👩⚕️🔥.
• Compelling Mystery: The art world is under attack, with models going missing and mysterious murders taking place 🎭💔. The mystery kept me on the edge of my seat!
• Chemistry Between Characters: Julia and Inspector Tennant’s slow-burn romance is awkward and adorable, though I’m dying to see how it resolves 🥰🔒.
• Surprising Twists: The ending was a jaw-dropper! 😱 The suspense builds beautifully, and the final revelations left me speechless.
TROPES:
• Strong Female Protagonist: Dr. Julia is the original feminist! 💁♀️
• Historical Mystery: A dark, atmospheric look at Victorian London’s art world and its secrets 🖼️.
• Slow-Burn Romance: Julia and Tennant’s sweet, awkward moments made me smile and roll my eyes 😂💘.
• Twists and Turns: The mystery was full of surprises, and I was left shook by the ending! 😳
The Not-So-Great:
• Unresolved Plot Threads: A couple of mysteries weren’t fully tied up for me 😕. I’m hoping they’ll be wrapped up in the next book 📚.
• Cliffhanger Ending: The ending was intense, but I’m a bit mad about that cliffhanger! 😫
Final Thoughts:
This dark, gritty historical mystery is an absolute must-read for fans of strong female characters and intricate plots. The world-building is top-notch 🌍, the mystery kept me hooked 🎣, and the characters were so well-developed. If you love historical mysteries with a twist and lots of heart ❤️, this one’s for you!
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4.3/5)
What I Liked:
• Historical Richness: McDonough does an amazing job capturing the gritty, dangerous side of Victorian London 🎨💀. The art world, filled with ambitious female artists, is beautifully explored 👩🎨.
• Strong Female Characters: Dr. Julia is a force to be reckoned with! A doctor and Scotland Yard's first female medical examiner, she’s independent, smart, and unafraid to speak her mind 👩⚕️🔥.
• Compelling Mystery: The art world is under attack, with models going missing and mysterious murders taking place 🎭💔. The mystery kept me on the edge of my seat!
• Chemistry Between Characters: Julia and Inspector Tennant’s slow-burn romance is awkward and adorable, though I’m dying to see how it resolves 🥰🔒.
• Surprising Twists: The ending was a jaw-dropper! 😱 The suspense builds beautifully, and the final revelations left me speechless.
TROPES:
• Strong Female Protagonist: Dr. Julia is the original feminist! 💁♀️
• Historical Mystery: A dark, atmospheric look at Victorian London’s art world and its secrets 🖼️.
• Slow-Burn Romance: Julia and Tennant’s sweet, awkward moments made me smile and roll my eyes 😂💘.
• Twists and Turns: The mystery was full of surprises, and I was left shook by the ending! 😳
The Not-So-Great:
• Unresolved Plot Threads: A couple of mysteries weren’t fully tied up for me 😕. I’m hoping they’ll be wrapped up in the next book 📚.
• Cliffhanger Ending: The ending was intense, but I’m a bit mad about that cliffhanger! 😫
Final Thoughts:
This dark, gritty historical mystery is an absolute must-read for fans of strong female characters and intricate plots. The world-building is top-notch 🌍, the mystery kept me hooked 🎣, and the characters were so well-developed. If you love historical mysteries with a twist and lots of heart ❤️, this one’s for you!
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4.3/5)
April 11, 2025
London, 1867. Dr. Julia Lewis and Inspector Richard Tennant are back in a second historical mystery. This time the focus is on the artistic community and links to pornography and other illicit trade "goods."
While it is perfectly acceptable for Victorian women to dabble in watercolors and painting as an innocent pastime, women who try to make a living as an artist face ridicule and worse. And the women who pose for artists (male or female)? They're even worse. Julia is called to examine a young woman suspected of prostitution (to make sure she's not spreading disease) even though the girl insists that she's a shop girl and an artist's model at times. The police only became involved because two men were harassing her--though it's obvious they think she attracted their attention on purpose. Then, a new artistic friend of Julia's, Mary Allingham, suffers a break-in the studio on the grounds of her home. A large "W" (for whore) in emerald green paint is left behind. Local officers aren't too keen to investigate the "goings-on" at an art studio, but Julia asks Richard to speak with her friend about other incidents in the female art world.
When young female models become the target of a killer, both Richard and Julia are sure there's more behind this than just spite against females who don't know their place. Mary's brother Charles, an admirer of all sorts of art, has also died of poison. It looks like and is ruled a suicide, but then the family doctor and a member of Charles's club also dies of poison. The club has been tied to another line of investigation involving young girls--are the two threads connected? And if so, how?
McDonough has provided another absorbing Victorian mystery (one of my favorite historical periods). We learn more about Julia and Richard and we get to watch them learn about each other. The supporting characters are also interesting and given depth--even those who aren't on stage long. I enjoyed the look at the artistic world of the 1800s and McDonough deftly weaves real artists into the story in a very believable way. Like Richard Tennant, I wasn't happy that justice wasn't served up to all of the deserving. At the end of the book he takes a leave of absence from the force and is off to France in search of one of those responsible. I hope he catches them...but since the official justice system isn't interested, I do wonder what he's going to do when he does find them.
First posted on my blog My Reader's Block.
While it is perfectly acceptable for Victorian women to dabble in watercolors and painting as an innocent pastime, women who try to make a living as an artist face ridicule and worse. And the women who pose for artists (male or female)? They're even worse. Julia is called to examine a young woman suspected of prostitution (to make sure she's not spreading disease) even though the girl insists that she's a shop girl and an artist's model at times. The police only became involved because two men were harassing her--though it's obvious they think she attracted their attention on purpose. Then, a new artistic friend of Julia's, Mary Allingham, suffers a break-in the studio on the grounds of her home. A large "W" (for whore) in emerald green paint is left behind. Local officers aren't too keen to investigate the "goings-on" at an art studio, but Julia asks Richard to speak with her friend about other incidents in the female art world.
When young female models become the target of a killer, both Richard and Julia are sure there's more behind this than just spite against females who don't know their place. Mary's brother Charles, an admirer of all sorts of art, has also died of poison. It looks like and is ruled a suicide, but then the family doctor and a member of Charles's club also dies of poison. The club has been tied to another line of investigation involving young girls--are the two threads connected? And if so, how?
McDonough has provided another absorbing Victorian mystery (one of my favorite historical periods). We learn more about Julia and Richard and we get to watch them learn about each other. The supporting characters are also interesting and given depth--even those who aren't on stage long. I enjoyed the look at the artistic world of the 1800s and McDonough deftly weaves real artists into the story in a very believable way. Like Richard Tennant, I wasn't happy that justice wasn't served up to all of the deserving. At the end of the book he takes a leave of absence from the force and is off to France in search of one of those responsible. I hope he catches them...but since the official justice system isn't interested, I do wonder what he's going to do when he does find them.
First posted on my blog My Reader's Block.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 6, 2025
I really enjoy this new series featuring a female doctor in Victorian England. Dr. Julia Lewis began the first book called out on a police case, and now the police have adjusted to the fact that she’s female and tend to call on her with more frequency. She also has a regular practice, of course, but the focus of the books is her work with the police, specifically one very attractive yet damaged Inspector.
While I loved the first book, it was jam packed. This one has a more focused plot, to the benefit of the book. As the story opens, Dr. Julia is called in to perform a pelvic exam on a woman who was walking close to an army barracks and assaulted. Under British law at the time, the woman was required to be examined for infectious disease, not the man. Inspector Tennant asks Julia to perform the exam, thinking it will be a gentler iteration than one performed by a man. She agrees.
The other kick off event is a massive skating accident on a frozen pond as Regent’s Park. Among those who went into the frozen water is a man whose sister is a friend of Julia’s, and being on the scene, she’s pressed into an exam. This draws Julia into the story of the Allingham family. The man who went in the water is an important art critic and publisher; his sister, recently home from Paris, is a painter; and the man’s wife is mourning several miscarriages. When the man dies by his own hand shortly after the accident, apparently having put poisonous green paint in his drink (green paint at the time was loaded with arsenic).
The sister asks Julia to investigate, because of the successful resolution of the last case where she helped the police. As Julia and Inspector Tennant are now friends, she has a smoother path forward. This investigation takes Tennant and Julia through the London art world, an extremely lively one at the time, when artists like Turner and Whistler reigned supreme. As a woman, Mary Allingham, the dead man’s sister, has a bit of a tougher path.
Both books to date have had a strong theme of women’s agency and place in society. This one looks at the lives of prostitutes as well as the lives of female artists. As Tennant and Julia uncover a nefarious scheme of what we would now call human trafficking, McDonough demonstrates her narrative chops. These books are expertly paced and the characters the series is built upon – Julia and Tennant – are interesting and sturdy, and should easily be able to shoulder a long lived series.
The look at the art world at the time, from small timers to members of the Royal Academy, is also a fascinating one, and there’s an especially vivid scene set as the annual Academy show is about to open and the artists visit the gallery on “varnishing” day to put final touches on their work, which are already hanging on gallery walls. These books are the whole package: setting, tight plot, wonderful characters. Book three really cannot come soon enough.
While I loved the first book, it was jam packed. This one has a more focused plot, to the benefit of the book. As the story opens, Dr. Julia is called in to perform a pelvic exam on a woman who was walking close to an army barracks and assaulted. Under British law at the time, the woman was required to be examined for infectious disease, not the man. Inspector Tennant asks Julia to perform the exam, thinking it will be a gentler iteration than one performed by a man. She agrees.
The other kick off event is a massive skating accident on a frozen pond as Regent’s Park. Among those who went into the frozen water is a man whose sister is a friend of Julia’s, and being on the scene, she’s pressed into an exam. This draws Julia into the story of the Allingham family. The man who went in the water is an important art critic and publisher; his sister, recently home from Paris, is a painter; and the man’s wife is mourning several miscarriages. When the man dies by his own hand shortly after the accident, apparently having put poisonous green paint in his drink (green paint at the time was loaded with arsenic).
The sister asks Julia to investigate, because of the successful resolution of the last case where she helped the police. As Julia and Inspector Tennant are now friends, she has a smoother path forward. This investigation takes Tennant and Julia through the London art world, an extremely lively one at the time, when artists like Turner and Whistler reigned supreme. As a woman, Mary Allingham, the dead man’s sister, has a bit of a tougher path.
Both books to date have had a strong theme of women’s agency and place in society. This one looks at the lives of prostitutes as well as the lives of female artists. As Tennant and Julia uncover a nefarious scheme of what we would now call human trafficking, McDonough demonstrates her narrative chops. These books are expertly paced and the characters the series is built upon – Julia and Tennant – are interesting and sturdy, and should easily be able to shoulder a long lived series.
The look at the art world at the time, from small timers to members of the Royal Academy, is also a fascinating one, and there’s an especially vivid scene set as the annual Academy show is about to open and the artists visit the gallery on “varnishing” day to put final touches on their work, which are already hanging on gallery walls. These books are the whole package: setting, tight plot, wonderful characters. Book three really cannot come soon enough.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 128 reviews