OHaS is a standalone novel but part of a connected series of retellings and is a New Adult Fantasy Romance.
Book Cover: /* - Okiedokie, this book has been through a cover change recently, and when I bought this book it had one of the protagonists centered on the cover, but now it is a important animal in the book. Both are pretty, but I honestly can't figure out a final score for this part of the review, so I'll leave this part be.
Summary/Tagline: 4* - I go back and forth being intrigued by the stone heart thing, but also confused because the book is dual pov, so the synopsis sounds like we are only following one of the protagonists instead of 2. However, still intrigued so let's go.
Characters: 3* - Alrighty, so we follow 2 protagonists, Eirwen, an elf who has the Snow White physical details, is in charge of mining magical ores for the dwarves, is a mechanic, but is also anti dresses, romances, and feminine things in general. To me, she was written to be the I'm not like other girls trope, and to be honest, a lot of that is just hate girlie things now. Florian is the other protagonist, the fourth son to his King, trapped in a family where he is forced to fight, mocked, abused for baking, caring for animals, and not at all willing to kill. The role of Snow White is split in two characters, one who complains about dealing with sexism, but we never see them, and Florian, who's name means flower, is dealing with panic attacks and ptsd. These two are supposed to be love interests for each other, but Eirwen isn't around when he's going through that, and when they are together, it's mostly taunts, taunts,taunts, oogle each other's bodies because Florian is so hot and look at those muscles and Eirwen is beautiful, but terrifyingly or fiercely beautiful, only to go back to taunting each other some more until over halfway into the book. Unfortunately, I didn't buy their romance, especially when the romance focuses only on the physical and rarely, if ever, on the emotional. So, I ended up feeling numb when the 2 are together, unlike Florian though, super nice guy while also trying to figure himself while baking and gaining a friendship with Mogrik and Dalbreath. They are two out of a bunch of side characters in this book. I forgot most of the other names. Florian's family sucks though, just trust me on that. So yeah, moving on.
World Building: 5* - Now, besides the sudden and slightly confusing second Prologue, I found the world and lore unique and I like what the author did by splitting Snow White into two characters and creating a thrilling magic system out of it using Eirwen's stone heart and a interesting idea/use of both Norse Mythology, Celtic Mythology, and setting it in WWII like fantasy setting. It was interesting, fun, and unique. The author also chose to use the comb from the original tale! I rarely see people use the comb in a Snow White retelling. I like that lol. However, this book gender essentializes, constantly being reminded who is male and who is female, although it isn't as bad as some books that go as far as female hands and a voice so male, but it was annoying to read nonetheless.
Story: 4* - Okiedokie, I will do my best here. Eirwen has many, MANY foster siblings, but their missing ore quotas for the king which will spell bad things for her town if they can't figure out what to do against the tyrant, slave driving King. Florian is commanded by his father to find someone called the Black Witch and bring her to the castle to find more magical ores for them. Being forced to be proven to be a man, he doesn't question the mission and goes after finding a group to go with him through the Cursed Forest to find her. A traumatic journey later, the two meet, threats were made, even though Florian was ready to die right then and there, they learn that things will get worse and the two must try and work together to save the dwarves, stop Florian's family, while trying not to die by their own family's hands. I went back and forth for not feeling much for a while, and like I said, I never bought the romance in this book, but I really enjoyed following Florian's journey to finally stand up against his family. Afterwards I just wanted to wrap him in a blanket, hold him, and tell him everything will finally be ok. So, yeah.
Over All: 4* - In the end, this story wasn't bad. It was unique and thrilling, and I do wish I liked both protagonists instead of one of them, which is a step up from my last Snow White retelling I read. In the end, I wanna try more books from this author, hopefully I like the other ones more.