The first chapter of this book had me so excited. A mysterious narrator waits outside of a house, watching. There’s someone inside who shouldn’t be, and a woman is in there with them and in danger. The narrator rushes into the house, and fade to black…. So good! I was on the edge of my seat and couldn’t wait to see how we got here and what happened next. The book then goes back to two days ago as we spend time in the POVs of the new owner of the house, her daughter, the husband she’s leaving, as well as two of the previous occupants: the ne’er-do-well son who has no intention of leaving the house his family has sold out from under him and his stepmother.
Based on that, did you expect this to be about incels, domestic violence, child abuse, corrupt church leaders, neo-nazis, prostitution, and social media scandals? All with a large dose of religion thrown in? Yeah no, me either. Apologies if that description counts as a spoiler, but I’d have included them as content warnings anyway. I also want to note that while that opening chapter may have you expecting lots of thrills, this was very much domestic suspense, and light on the suspense until the very end.
I’ve read two other Kaira Rouda books (Best Day Ever (which I loved) and The Favorite Daughter) and in both of those my favorite part was that Rouda was able to create deliciously evil, over the top, love-to-hate characters. Here, I just hated nearly everyone. And not in a fun way. In an “I can’t wait to put this down and get away from these people” way. This simply wasn’t
fun
in the way I’ve come to expect from this author. I do have to give credit though for the last 20% or so really sucking me in. My pulse was pounding and I did enjoy the callback to the opening scene once we got there. I truly disliked a lot of the resolution and how preachy the whole thing felt, but some of those issues come down to personal taste and beliefs.
Other reviews are much more positive, so make sure to check out those as well for a balanced look at this title. I *may* give the author another try because I did enjoy the first two books I read quite a bit, but I skipped her last and wish I’d skipped this one too. I’ll be waiting for reviews next time to see if she’s gotten her devious character spark back.
Expected publication date: January 18, 2022.
Many thanks to NetGalley and Thomas & Mercer for an advance copy of this title for review.