What do you think?
Rate this book
The Root of the Matter
She’s terrified.
Time travel. The North Atlantic in winter. Which is worse?
Geneva Fielding is a researcher in the Archives of the Applied History department, prepping time travelers for their destinations. She loves the smell of old paper and chocolate croissants.
One day, a Traveler fails an important test and cannot go. Instead of canceling the Trip, the dean appoints Geneva and her friend Peter Donatelli, a physicist, to take his place. They have three days to prepare to Travel to 1630s New England.
Geneva’s always wanted to know more about John Winthrop. Maybe she can even get a dissertation topic from the Trip. But the truth is, she’s scared stiff. No one knows her private struggles. And she’s not about to tell.
Geneva and Peter are dumped into an early, struggling Massachusetts, the Puritan inhabitants having escaped the persecution of the Crown only to face a howling wilderness. Roger Williams’s arrival sends shockwaves through the frail colony.
Can the Bay Colony afford to allow a critic of the king to dwell among them?
And what will Geneva do when she discovers Peter’s secret?
Time travel. The North Atlantic in winter. Which is worse?
Geneva Fielding is a researcher in the Archives of the Applied History department, prepping time travelers for their destinations. She loves the smell of old paper and chocolate croissants.
One day, a Traveler fails an important test and cannot go. Instead of canceling the Trip, the dean appoints Geneva and her friend Peter Donatelli, a physicist, to take his place. They have three days to prepare to Travel to 1630s New England.
Geneva’s always wanted to know more about John Winthrop. Maybe she can even get a dissertation topic from the Trip. But the truth is, she’s scared stiff. No one knows her private struggles. And she’s not about to tell.
Geneva and Peter are dumped into an early, struggling Massachusetts, the Puritan inhabitants having escaped the persecution of the Crown only to face a howling wilderness. Roger Williams’s arrival sends shockwaves through the frail colony.
Can the Bay Colony afford to allow a critic of the king to dwell among them?
And what will Geneva do when she discovers Peter’s secret?
312 pages, Kindle Edition
First published July 1, 2024
About the author
Lynne Basham Tagawa
11 books227 followersLynne Tagawa got her start in writing when a small school needed a Texas history curriculum. Later she branched out into historical fiction. She loves to write about both the spiritual and cultural heritage of our country, and this inspired the 18th century series, the Russells. She's a wife, mother, and grandmother in sunny south Texas.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 32 reviews
February 27, 2025
This was SUCH a different book for me, but I absolutely LOVED it! The history and the thought provoking faith content were both exceptional😍
I wasn’t aware this was a dystopian story …of sorts…it’s kind of a mix between that genre, time travel, and history fiction. So different, but so enjoyable…
I was super impressed with the research this author put in. I grew up in Christian school, so I was familiar with many of the individuals from the “past” part of this story. I really think that helped me follow some of the deeper dialogues/situations. It was still really intriguing though and I learned a lot more about the Puritans. Now I want to get some biographies to learn more❤️ (Note: the author mentions a few at the end!)
As for the fictional characters, I loved them! The story is told from Geneva’s perspective in first person (with some correspondence between Peter and a coworker sprinkled throughout—those fit perfectly and added much to the story.) I never found the first person hard to read. The characters live in a time sometime in the unknown future where government is trying to control everything. I think it would help to add something explaining that at the beginning… I got confused at times until I finally figured out it MUST be in the future. It would have been helpful to say “Boston 2060 or something…”. I didn’t dock my review though because I really did love the story and finally figured out that aspect. I never ever found it slow!
This is not a love story, though there is a budding romance that was perfectly sweet and clean, not even a kiss.
I won’t give away the plot 😉 I’ll simply finish by saying, I think this book is best for adult readers (not due to questionable content, just deeper convos, and themes would prob be appreciated more by mature readers). I believe other Christians will enjoy this book too for its rich history, the intriguing questions it poses, and relatable/likable characters—not to mention the adventure and a tad bit of suspense.
I can’t wait for book two 😍
* I recieved an ARC copy of this book from the author—thank you so much!— and wasn’t required to leave a positive review.
**Note: An unmarried couple poses as married while “undercover” in the past and have to share a bed at times. BUT I did think the author handled this possible scenario exceptionally well. It wasn’t added for drama. The characters both made effort to be above board and honorable. Nothing immoral happens. This story is super clean. Thanks to the author for keeping it that way! (I mention this because it could be an issue for some or parents may want to be aware for older teens-I don’t know that younger teens would find this book as enjoyable).
I wasn’t aware this was a dystopian story …of sorts…it’s kind of a mix between that genre, time travel, and history fiction. So different, but so enjoyable…
I was super impressed with the research this author put in. I grew up in Christian school, so I was familiar with many of the individuals from the “past” part of this story. I really think that helped me follow some of the deeper dialogues/situations. It was still really intriguing though and I learned a lot more about the Puritans. Now I want to get some biographies to learn more❤️ (Note: the author mentions a few at the end!)
As for the fictional characters, I loved them! The story is told from Geneva’s perspective in first person (with some correspondence between Peter and a coworker sprinkled throughout—those fit perfectly and added much to the story.) I never found the first person hard to read. The characters live in a time sometime in the unknown future where government is trying to control everything. I think it would help to add something explaining that at the beginning… I got confused at times until I finally figured out it MUST be in the future. It would have been helpful to say “Boston 2060 or something…”. I didn’t dock my review though because I really did love the story and finally figured out that aspect. I never ever found it slow!
This is not a love story, though there is a budding romance that was perfectly sweet and clean, not even a kiss.
I won’t give away the plot 😉 I’ll simply finish by saying, I think this book is best for adult readers (not due to questionable content, just deeper convos, and themes would prob be appreciated more by mature readers). I believe other Christians will enjoy this book too for its rich history, the intriguing questions it poses, and relatable/likable characters—not to mention the adventure and a tad bit of suspense.
I can’t wait for book two 😍
* I recieved an ARC copy of this book from the author—thank you so much!— and wasn’t required to leave a positive review.
**Note: An unmarried couple poses as married while “undercover” in the past and have to share a bed at times. BUT I did think the author handled this possible scenario exceptionally well. It wasn’t added for drama. The characters both made effort to be above board and honorable. Nothing immoral happens. This story is super clean. Thanks to the author for keeping it that way! (I mention this because it could be an issue for some or parents may want to be aware for older teens-I don’t know that younger teens would find this book as enjoyable).
August 11, 2024
Two timelines:
Future - not sure when, but religion is outlawed, everything is monitored and scheduled for individuals, even procreation, and AI watches everyone. Plus science has progressed so much that a government group does research on history by actually traveling there.
Past - 1633, Massachusetts Bay, a new colony lead by John Winthrop.
I didn’t know much about Roger Williams nor John Winthrop when I started this book. But Ms. Tagawa's vast historical knowledge (and research) was clearly evident, and her book so readable.
The two main characters, Geneva Fielding, and Peter Donatelli were sent to the past to study what actually happened with Roger Williams who was exiled from the colony because of his separatist beliefs.
Geneva and Peter traveled from England to America with Roger Williams and Thomas Dudley (future governor of the colony they were to study). John Winthrop was the governor when they landed.
This all sounds a bit dry, and at times the historical bits were, but there was so much more to this story. One character was a believer, but religion was outlawed, and believers, once thy admit it, were either "re-educated", or punished, possibly leading to death.
This was theological and fascinating. Loved all the reasoning the characters did to work through the concept of God being real and that He saved them from "their sins" (a foreign concept) by grace.
This ended as sort of a cliffhanger, but I didn’t mind. The reader knows where this is going. I plan to get the next book as Lynne Basham Tagawa is one amazing author!
Oh, and seldom do I say I will probably reread a book. But… this is definitely a book I’m going to reread. I breezed through it far too quickly. This needs to be savored.
Future - not sure when, but religion is outlawed, everything is monitored and scheduled for individuals, even procreation, and AI watches everyone. Plus science has progressed so much that a government group does research on history by actually traveling there.
Past - 1633, Massachusetts Bay, a new colony lead by John Winthrop.
I didn’t know much about Roger Williams nor John Winthrop when I started this book. But Ms. Tagawa's vast historical knowledge (and research) was clearly evident, and her book so readable.
The two main characters, Geneva Fielding, and Peter Donatelli were sent to the past to study what actually happened with Roger Williams who was exiled from the colony because of his separatist beliefs.
Geneva and Peter traveled from England to America with Roger Williams and Thomas Dudley (future governor of the colony they were to study). John Winthrop was the governor when they landed.
This all sounds a bit dry, and at times the historical bits were, but there was so much more to this story. One character was a believer, but religion was outlawed, and believers, once thy admit it, were either "re-educated", or punished, possibly leading to death.
This was theological and fascinating. Loved all the reasoning the characters did to work through the concept of God being real and that He saved them from "their sins" (a foreign concept) by grace.
This ended as sort of a cliffhanger, but I didn’t mind. The reader knows where this is going. I plan to get the next book as Lynne Basham Tagawa is one amazing author!
Oh, and seldom do I say I will probably reread a book. But… this is definitely a book I’m going to reread. I breezed through it far too quickly. This needs to be savored.
July 14, 2024
From the moment I learned the premise of The Root of the Matter by Lynne Basham Tagawa, I knew I wanted to read this book. A whole department of time travelers? The heroine’s job is prepping them, courtesy of research, for their travel destinations? Something happens that has her stepping in for her first time travel, filling in for someone else, paired up for the journey with her male friend/colleague (yep, that sound is my romance-loving antennae whirring to full alert). Yes please! To all of it.
And then, once I did start reading this novel, I found a wealth of other layers that I wasn’t expecting but loved for the rich complexities they added to the story. For instance, the time from which Gen and Peter are traveling – the ‘present day’, so to speak – is set at some point in a dystopian future later in the 21st century. A world monitored by AI under the guise of making life easier but also where the words you speak, the food you eat, the people you spend time with, etc can be reported to the authorities if anything is a trigger within the government’s control parameters. Yet Gen and Peter are traveling to 1630s New England to learn more about the Puritans and their theological differences, a paradox I found really fascinating and one which precipitates Gen’s intelligent & tender journey toward Jesus. There are a lot more of those layers I could mention but I don’t want to spoil the discoveries for you.
Speaking of our hero and heroine, I loved both of their personalities (Peter’s steady integrity and quiet courage, Gen’s kind heart and relatability), and I was completely a fan of their ‘disguise’ as a married couple in a kind of forced proximity that’s unlike most we get to read about. Their friendship moving toward a romance isn’t a major focus of the story, though, and while I always enjoy a lot of sparks and kisses in this case I enjoyed watching them slowly begin to show readers their feelings (even if they don’t show each other). There’s something very sweet and innocent about it, and given the volatile times they live in and travel to, the pace makes sense. I look forward to seeing how it develops, though, as the series continues (because of course I do. None of you are surprised by this). Also…I need more of their friend Scott who came out of nowhere to become one of my fave supporting characters.
Bottom Line: The Root of the Matter by Lynne Basham Tagawa is an intriguing blend of dystopian/science fiction, time travel, and historical fiction with a dash of romance, poignant faith threads and complex layers. Real life figures from the earliest settlements in America intersect with the author’s imagination, and watching Gen & Peter navigate 1630s New England as time travelers kept me engaged just as much as watching them start to fall in love. Tagawa thought of details that I wouldn’t have and incorporated them creatively into the plot, including how to let Gen indulge in her chocolate cravings. I was fascinated by each element that came together to make this a uniquely compelling story, and I am already imagining what will happen in book two!
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower
And then, once I did start reading this novel, I found a wealth of other layers that I wasn’t expecting but loved for the rich complexities they added to the story. For instance, the time from which Gen and Peter are traveling – the ‘present day’, so to speak – is set at some point in a dystopian future later in the 21st century. A world monitored by AI under the guise of making life easier but also where the words you speak, the food you eat, the people you spend time with, etc can be reported to the authorities if anything is a trigger within the government’s control parameters. Yet Gen and Peter are traveling to 1630s New England to learn more about the Puritans and their theological differences, a paradox I found really fascinating and one which precipitates Gen’s intelligent & tender journey toward Jesus. There are a lot more of those layers I could mention but I don’t want to spoil the discoveries for you.
Speaking of our hero and heroine, I loved both of their personalities (Peter’s steady integrity and quiet courage, Gen’s kind heart and relatability), and I was completely a fan of their ‘disguise’ as a married couple in a kind of forced proximity that’s unlike most we get to read about. Their friendship moving toward a romance isn’t a major focus of the story, though, and while I always enjoy a lot of sparks and kisses in this case I enjoyed watching them slowly begin to show readers their feelings (even if they don’t show each other). There’s something very sweet and innocent about it, and given the volatile times they live in and travel to, the pace makes sense. I look forward to seeing how it develops, though, as the series continues (because of course I do. None of you are surprised by this). Also…I need more of their friend Scott who came out of nowhere to become one of my fave supporting characters.
Bottom Line: The Root of the Matter by Lynne Basham Tagawa is an intriguing blend of dystopian/science fiction, time travel, and historical fiction with a dash of romance, poignant faith threads and complex layers. Real life figures from the earliest settlements in America intersect with the author’s imagination, and watching Gen & Peter navigate 1630s New England as time travelers kept me engaged just as much as watching them start to fall in love. Tagawa thought of details that I wouldn’t have and incorporated them creatively into the plot, including how to let Gen indulge in her chocolate cravings. I was fascinated by each element that came together to make this a uniquely compelling story, and I am already imagining what will happen in book two!
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower
June 5, 2024
The Root of the Matter is a wonderfully written book about the life and theology of John Winthrop and Roger Williams who had differing opinions in 1601 New England. Geneva Fielding and Peter Donatelli take a time travel trip to 1631 to investigate.
The characters are exciting and are well fleshed out. The combination of historical details and time travel made for an amazing read. I was engrossed from the first chapter and couldn't put it down. I can't wait for the next book in the series. This book is highly recommended.
I received a complimentary copy from the author. A positive review is not required, and all opinions are my own.
The characters are exciting and are well fleshed out. The combination of historical details and time travel made for an amazing read. I was engrossed from the first chapter and couldn't put it down. I can't wait for the next book in the series. This book is highly recommended.
I received a complimentary copy from the author. A positive review is not required, and all opinions are my own.
June 2, 2024
Travel along with Gen and Peter as a fellow time traveler within the pages of the creative and well written book, The Root of the Matter. Author Lynne Tagawa has combined many creative story elements and woven another exciting book series with great historical research combined with great fiction.
Characters Gen and Peter are transported back in time as specialists with assignments to discover more about Puritans, Roger Williams and associates, and understand motives; choices they made. The team must “become” an authentic community member observe and learn as they travel back and forth in time documenting information. They become fully acquainted with dress, religion, and colony living. The team, keeping their identities hidden, face the dangers of the 17th century with local Indians, climate, foods, societal expectations and new freedom of religion while dealing with loyalists to the Mother land.The poignant characters are strong and resilient adjusting to present and past learning about themselves, God and their feelings for one another in the process.
I didn’t want to put the book down and cannot wait for the next one.
Joni G
Characters Gen and Peter are transported back in time as specialists with assignments to discover more about Puritans, Roger Williams and associates, and understand motives; choices they made. The team must “become” an authentic community member observe and learn as they travel back and forth in time documenting information. They become fully acquainted with dress, religion, and colony living. The team, keeping their identities hidden, face the dangers of the 17th century with local Indians, climate, foods, societal expectations and new freedom of religion while dealing with loyalists to the Mother land.The poignant characters are strong and resilient adjusting to present and past learning about themselves, God and their feelings for one another in the process.
I didn’t want to put the book down and cannot wait for the next one.
Joni G
June 4, 2024
4.5 stars!
This was extremely unexpected. In a marvelous way. I really hadn’t the slightest idea of what I was getting into, but my goodness it was quite the read! The story hooked me from the first paragraph, the theological theme was intriguing and the history was not something I could pass by. I love being submerged into the unknown (well, not physically of course–I’m not quite that brave) so that made this book a truly splendid adventure.
For the first quarter, I had an extremely difficult time connecting with the characters. Geneva most of all. I simply couldn’t get a grasp on her and struggled for some context on her life… However, the entire premise was so enthralling that I seriously could not put it down.
Eventually, I did connect with her, got more of her background, and rooted for her–no pun intended. The futuristic setting was intriguing–and terrifying–and I was dying to know more. Geneva’s journey to Christ was beautiful, powerfully underlined by the immense cost she is paying. It’s so important to be grateful for our freedom and remember those who have suffered for that freedom! This book spectacularly portrays that in both time periods… which brings us to the time travel!
Ok, I have read a good number of time travel fiction and romance, and seriously Tagawa executed it perfectly. None of it felt cheesy or far fetched, very plausible and natural. In fact, NONE of this book felt cheesy. Something about it had a refreshing quality, like a cold drink of water on a roasting day. I can’t quite place my finger on it.
Delving deeper into the characters… As I said earlier, Genever was difficult to flesh out in the beginning, but that changed. She made me laugh and maybe even cry? I adored Peter, he was so steady and oh to have that man’s courage!!!!!
Also, can we talk about Scott for a moment? We NEED more Scott. Please.
Sorry, Scott needed his own tiny paragraph 😂 Anywayyyyy *clears throat* Ok, the historical characters, they felt just as vivid and palpable as the modern ones, and while there were times when I would get a little lost with all the names, it was truly a delight to experience that window of history and be immersed in the lives of these people that shaped our country. I also immensely enjoyed the Native American portrayals since that has always been of great interest to me and is rarely portrayed in the Christian genre!! The theology was enthralling to me and it spurred me to do my own research which was wonderful!
All that to say, despite wishing for a deeper initial character connection and sometimes feeling overwhelmed with all the names and figuring out who said what—this was a beautiful book and I am going to slowly die every day until the next book is out! The fact that I gobbled this story up in two days should be proof enough of my fascination.
I received a copy from the author and was not required to write a positive review.
This was extremely unexpected. In a marvelous way. I really hadn’t the slightest idea of what I was getting into, but my goodness it was quite the read! The story hooked me from the first paragraph, the theological theme was intriguing and the history was not something I could pass by. I love being submerged into the unknown (well, not physically of course–I’m not quite that brave) so that made this book a truly splendid adventure.
For the first quarter, I had an extremely difficult time connecting with the characters. Geneva most of all. I simply couldn’t get a grasp on her and struggled for some context on her life… However, the entire premise was so enthralling that I seriously could not put it down.
Eventually, I did connect with her, got more of her background, and rooted for her–no pun intended. The futuristic setting was intriguing–and terrifying–and I was dying to know more. Geneva’s journey to Christ was beautiful, powerfully underlined by the immense cost she is paying. It’s so important to be grateful for our freedom and remember those who have suffered for that freedom! This book spectacularly portrays that in both time periods… which brings us to the time travel!
Ok, I have read a good number of time travel fiction and romance, and seriously Tagawa executed it perfectly. None of it felt cheesy or far fetched, very plausible and natural. In fact, NONE of this book felt cheesy. Something about it had a refreshing quality, like a cold drink of water on a roasting day. I can’t quite place my finger on it.
Delving deeper into the characters… As I said earlier, Genever was difficult to flesh out in the beginning, but that changed. She made me laugh and maybe even cry? I adored Peter, he was so steady and oh to have that man’s courage!!!!!
Also, can we talk about Scott for a moment? We NEED more Scott. Please.
Sorry, Scott needed his own tiny paragraph 😂 Anywayyyyy *clears throat* Ok, the historical characters, they felt just as vivid and palpable as the modern ones, and while there were times when I would get a little lost with all the names, it was truly a delight to experience that window of history and be immersed in the lives of these people that shaped our country. I also immensely enjoyed the Native American portrayals since that has always been of great interest to me and is rarely portrayed in the Christian genre!! The theology was enthralling to me and it spurred me to do my own research which was wonderful!
All that to say, despite wishing for a deeper initial character connection and sometimes feeling overwhelmed with all the names and figuring out who said what—this was a beautiful book and I am going to slowly die every day until the next book is out! The fact that I gobbled this story up in two days should be proof enough of my fascination.
I received a copy from the author and was not required to write a positive review.
August 18, 2024
I regularly enjoy reading Historical fiction and I’m always looking for well-done Time Travel fiction. When I realized that the author had combined the historical and time travel fiction genres with solid Biblical faith, I couldn’t purchase the book fast enough.
I have to say, for me, this was the BEST book from Lynne Tagawa I have read to date. I’ve enjoyed her other books, but they have at times suffered from a plethora of characters that are hard to track and a plot that jumps around, which leads to a lack of connectedness. This book has none of those previous issues. I just sailed through the book. I was engaged and enthused every minute of my read. I found the historical detail and theological insights, convincingly added to my enjoyment. Having grown up around seminarians and professors, the discussions were familiar. It was easy to keep centered on the two main characters, Geneva and Peter, all other characters interacted with one or both of them. The debt we owe to those who came to this country in those early days was great, this book depicts their stark privations. How could any of my hardships measure up to what they experienced? I could sympathize with Geneva over her sea sickness. I can still remember a tortuous English channel voyage, I thought would never end. The cramped quarters of the Lyon with the slight food offerings, storms, dangers, and sickness were chilling. But when compared to what they would endure once on land…
It was also inspiring to see how Geneva acquiesced to her changed circumstances, from a researcher in the Archives of the Applied History department to a quasi-wife and housekeeper. In the Applied History department, she prepared time-travelers for their chosen destinations, but one day when a traveler bound for 1630 Massachusetts failed the required theology test, a test that prepared the traveler for seamless entry into the 1630 Puritan community, Geneva and Peter are selected to step in as time-travelers. This meant, they would collect the needed information on John Winthrop, the Puritan community, and discover interactions with Roger Williams and his changing opinions.
In the process of her time travel, Geneva goes from a knowledge of theology and Bible truths, to a heart understanding; she becomes a believer in the Lord Jesus Christ. She understands and accepts that her journey could be as difficult as the one the Puritan’s faced, albeit in a different way. In her time, the near future: Bibles are outlawed, churches are just antique architecture, faith isn’t spoken of, and Christians can’t officially gather for worship.
Quote that Cleverly becomes the Titles:
• Page 297, Geneva asks Peter, “What is the ‘root of the matter’?” She notes that Winthrop used those words about Williams. “He said he was sound in the root of the matter.” Peter responded, “He knew the Lord. He preached a sound—an orthodox—gospel.”
This book delivers on so many fronts and I highly recommend it.
I have to say, for me, this was the BEST book from Lynne Tagawa I have read to date. I’ve enjoyed her other books, but they have at times suffered from a plethora of characters that are hard to track and a plot that jumps around, which leads to a lack of connectedness. This book has none of those previous issues. I just sailed through the book. I was engaged and enthused every minute of my read. I found the historical detail and theological insights, convincingly added to my enjoyment. Having grown up around seminarians and professors, the discussions were familiar. It was easy to keep centered on the two main characters, Geneva and Peter, all other characters interacted with one or both of them. The debt we owe to those who came to this country in those early days was great, this book depicts their stark privations. How could any of my hardships measure up to what they experienced? I could sympathize with Geneva over her sea sickness. I can still remember a tortuous English channel voyage, I thought would never end. The cramped quarters of the Lyon with the slight food offerings, storms, dangers, and sickness were chilling. But when compared to what they would endure once on land…
It was also inspiring to see how Geneva acquiesced to her changed circumstances, from a researcher in the Archives of the Applied History department to a quasi-wife and housekeeper. In the Applied History department, she prepared time-travelers for their chosen destinations, but one day when a traveler bound for 1630 Massachusetts failed the required theology test, a test that prepared the traveler for seamless entry into the 1630 Puritan community, Geneva and Peter are selected to step in as time-travelers. This meant, they would collect the needed information on John Winthrop, the Puritan community, and discover interactions with Roger Williams and his changing opinions.
In the process of her time travel, Geneva goes from a knowledge of theology and Bible truths, to a heart understanding; she becomes a believer in the Lord Jesus Christ. She understands and accepts that her journey could be as difficult as the one the Puritan’s faced, albeit in a different way. In her time, the near future: Bibles are outlawed, churches are just antique architecture, faith isn’t spoken of, and Christians can’t officially gather for worship.
Quote that Cleverly becomes the Titles:
• Page 297, Geneva asks Peter, “What is the ‘root of the matter’?” She notes that Winthrop used those words about Williams. “He said he was sound in the root of the matter.” Peter responded, “He knew the Lord. He preached a sound—an orthodox—gospel.”
This book delivers on so many fronts and I highly recommend it.
June 13, 2024
Amazing!
"The Root of the Matter" is an amazing book!
The unique telling of both future events and past events (while the same main character told the story in both eras) was well done, and allowed for a smooth development of the characters and story.
I was pulled into the book, and didn't want it to end! As I read, I learned about the theology (and politics) of the Puritans who came to America in the 1600's. I also learned about their travel, food and dress, homes, customs, speech, work, and living conditions. I was being educated, while it felt like I was being entertained!
I was given the opportunity to 'meet' men like John Winthrop, Roger Williams, John Cotton and more. I was challenged by their lives and by the lives of the main characters in the story.
The 'future' part of the story had just enough 'light' moments to amuse, while providing much to give serious thought to - futuristic, yet believable - as well as disquieting.
Once again I learned from and was inspired by the author's use of significant quotations at the beginning of each chapter.
Thank you, Lynne Basham Tagawa!
[I received a complimentary copy and these are my voluntary and honest opinions. I was not required to leave a positive review.]
"The Root of the Matter" is an amazing book!
The unique telling of both future events and past events (while the same main character told the story in both eras) was well done, and allowed for a smooth development of the characters and story.
I was pulled into the book, and didn't want it to end! As I read, I learned about the theology (and politics) of the Puritans who came to America in the 1600's. I also learned about their travel, food and dress, homes, customs, speech, work, and living conditions. I was being educated, while it felt like I was being entertained!
I was given the opportunity to 'meet' men like John Winthrop, Roger Williams, John Cotton and more. I was challenged by their lives and by the lives of the main characters in the story.
The 'future' part of the story had just enough 'light' moments to amuse, while providing much to give serious thought to - futuristic, yet believable - as well as disquieting.
Once again I learned from and was inspired by the author's use of significant quotations at the beginning of each chapter.
Thank you, Lynne Basham Tagawa!
[I received a complimentary copy and these are my voluntary and honest opinions. I was not required to leave a positive review.]
Read
July 3, 2024Lynne Basham Tagawa’s The Root of the Matter: The American Puritans Book One explores time travel between pre-colonial American religious development–featuring major figures of the American Puritan movement–and a near future America where Christianity is forbidden. The novel examines both the physical and spiritual struggles of America’s earliest settlers as well as the modern intellectual concerns of academia, including promotion, publish or perish, and the ever important–but often difficult to develop–research question. Sprinkle in a budding romance, and readers have a thought-provoking, well researched examination of spiritual conscience. While its authentic depiction of historical characters from early American history that we’ve all read about–Bradford, Williams, Winthrop, and Cotton, among others–makes these people come alive, it’s the future dystopian possibility of punishment for a profession of Christian faith that will keep readers thinking about this novel long after they’ve finished it.
June 12, 2024
I’m in love with this book! The characters were amazing and the setting was beautiful. The premise was fantastic and the historical research was stellar! As I read, I was just as enamored with the futuristic/dystopian aspect as I was with the historic/Puritan portions. This was a time-travel novel handled expertly.
The ensemble of characters were fascinating to get to know and the future angst as well as the past investigations had me invested in both time-periods with equal gusto. I loved the growth displayed by Geneva and just her all-around personality throughout the story. And Peter was a loveable hero in every way!
This book absolutely took my breath away and I’m firmly hooked! I knew that this author’s previous works were incredible, but I still found myself blown away by The Root of the Matter and am looking forward, with much anticipation, to the next in The American Puritans series!
The ensemble of characters were fascinating to get to know and the future angst as well as the past investigations had me invested in both time-periods with equal gusto. I loved the growth displayed by Geneva and just her all-around personality throughout the story. And Peter was a loveable hero in every way!
This book absolutely took my breath away and I’m firmly hooked! I knew that this author’s previous works were incredible, but I still found myself blown away by The Root of the Matter and am looking forward, with much anticipation, to the next in The American Puritans series!
June 8, 2024
Thought-provoking and heart-searching
The historical content is amazing within these pages; I felt transported back in time just like Gen and Peter with the descriptions of landscapes and interactions with people. The history of my country and faith has always intrigued me.
As the thoughts, views, and opinions of men like Roger Williams and John Winthrop were discussed, I was reminded about the foundation of my faith. The root is the matter is having Christ as your Saviour and being willing, after counting the cost for following Him, to continue to follow Him forever.
This genre of futuristic time travel is not my normal one, but I’m so glad that I read this one. It has made me stop and think and solidify some areas of life. I received a complimentary copy and these are my voluntary and honest opinions. I was not required to leave a positive review.
The historical content is amazing within these pages; I felt transported back in time just like Gen and Peter with the descriptions of landscapes and interactions with people. The history of my country and faith has always intrigued me.
As the thoughts, views, and opinions of men like Roger Williams and John Winthrop were discussed, I was reminded about the foundation of my faith. The root is the matter is having Christ as your Saviour and being willing, after counting the cost for following Him, to continue to follow Him forever.
This genre of futuristic time travel is not my normal one, but I’m so glad that I read this one. It has made me stop and think and solidify some areas of life. I received a complimentary copy and these are my voluntary and honest opinions. I was not required to leave a positive review.
June 2, 2024
This is the first book in Tagawa’s new series, The American Puritans. Since I’ve really enjoyed Tagawa’s American Revolution series The Russells, I was eager to read this one. It is very different, but still, VERY GOOD! The added spice of time travel from a future full of synthetics back to the 1600s Puritan settlements had me chuckling over and over as the main female character has to suddenly learn how to cook real food, keep clean (self and house), and interact with those around her in proper cultural ways.
I love learning about history through books like this, and Tagawa has done a great job. I can’t wait for book 2!
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher and was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.
I love learning about history through books like this, and Tagawa has done a great job. I can’t wait for book 2!
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher and was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.
August 16, 2024
This book was fun, a challenge to the imagination, historically interesting, and a touch of romance. I love time travel books and this was very well written and an enjoyable read. It was also spiritually challenging. It recorded the difficulties of Christians in the past and possible persecution in the future. Makes one thankful for the relative freedom we have now. The only drawback is that it didn't turn out to be a stand-alone. I was disappointed because I cannot afford to purchase the other books. So this is a warning if you are like me: there are loose ends that leave you wanting more.
May 31, 2024
First of all I am an ARC reader and this is an honest review.
I must say this is the most intriguing book about the Puritans I have ever read. Being a native Rhode Islander it was so wonderful to read about Roger Williams. Time travel is one of my favorite genres. I never see too much in books regarding Rhode Island history, to read it with the time travel surprises in it I was captivated.
I have read a few of Lynne's books and I have never been disappointed. She is a marvelous story teller and gives readers a lot to think about as far as the subject matter goes.
I must say this is the most intriguing book about the Puritans I have ever read. Being a native Rhode Islander it was so wonderful to read about Roger Williams. Time travel is one of my favorite genres. I never see too much in books regarding Rhode Island history, to read it with the time travel surprises in it I was captivated.
I have read a few of Lynne's books and I have never been disappointed. She is a marvelous story teller and gives readers a lot to think about as far as the subject matter goes.
July 15, 2024
I was honored to help with the early beta reading process of this historical time travel book written by my friend Lynne Tagawa. It was great fun, and I loved both the characters and the premise. She did a lot of work ironing out the behind-the-scenes preparations for the time travel, which I found fascinating (particularly when it involved Tollers the robot!), and also appreciated that she chose 17th century Puritans for the focus, as they tend to get underrated compared to figures from the previous or following centuries. I recommend y'all put it on your summer reading list!
August 15, 2024
Crisis of Belief
This Sci-Fi historical fiction retelling of some key Puritans in New England as they wrestled with how much control the authority at the time, the king of England, should have in the church. It was creatively told, with lots of quotes from the key figures themselves. This is a great book for lovers of historical fiction as well as those who want insight into our country's founding.
This Sci-Fi historical fiction retelling of some key Puritans in New England as they wrestled with how much control the authority at the time, the king of England, should have in the church. It was creatively told, with lots of quotes from the key figures themselves. This is a great book for lovers of historical fiction as well as those who want insight into our country's founding.
January 6, 2025
I liked the mix of history and future, time travel, dystopian, AI, faith. Very unique. The only issues I had were not understanding why the government in the future goes back in time to learn more about different time periods and I felt I personally didn't understand enough of the time period to fully get what all was taking place. Regardless I enjoyed learning more about the time of the Puritans and the characters. Looking forward to a sequel to find out what happens to the main characters!
June 27, 2025
Odd, eery, FANTASTIC!
What a bizarre blend of futuristic AI and science fiction and historical fiction and biblical theology!!! This was a fun novel that hooked me quickly. Lynne Tagawa does a great job dropping pieces of the structure of her tale in this fanciful setting. Her AI component may not be all that imaginative, considering our technologically advancing age. Well done!
What a bizarre blend of futuristic AI and science fiction and historical fiction and biblical theology!!! This was a fun novel that hooked me quickly. Lynne Tagawa does a great job dropping pieces of the structure of her tale in this fanciful setting. Her AI component may not be all that imaginative, considering our technologically advancing age. Well done!
June 4, 2024
I was an ARC reader. A window between futuristic present and the past. Historical facts of 1600’s I never knew. A love story between man and woman, for friends, and most importantly for our Lord and Savior. An interesting read.
September 21, 2024
Interesting, historical take on the beginning of America. It also combines futuristic possibilities.
I liked learning about some of the founding fathers and the reasons behind their actions. Enjoyed the characters and their stories, as well.
I liked learning about some of the founding fathers and the reasons behind their actions. Enjoyed the characters and their stories, as well.
January 18, 2025
Great adventure
Different insight into time travel in a very regulated society. Good glimpses into the early history of Puritan society in the 1630s. Insights into AI in society.
Different insight into time travel in a very regulated society. Good glimpses into the early history of Puritan society in the 1630s. Insights into AI in society.
May 15, 2025
window into American history
So appreciate a glimpse into the life and times of our forbearers…. The new insights of struggles between civil and church influence was enlightening….
So appreciate a glimpse into the life and times of our forbearers…. The new insights of struggles between civil and church influence was enlightening….
June 26, 2025
The writing style was so clunky and unappealing that I felt no urge to finish it.
July 9, 2025
This book has it all - Puritan history, Reformed theology, time travel, slow and clean romance, science fiction, and futuristic dystopian society! The only problem is the sequel isn't out yet!
February 4, 2026
3.5 Stars
March 8, 2026
Five stars for all the amazing research that went into this, the creativity in presenting both time periods (past and future), and for such an original time travel story.
July 13, 2024
The Root of the Matter
Lynne Basham Tagawa
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Geneva Fielding works as a researcher helping to prepare time travelers for their historical destinations. When a Traveler fails an important test just days before an assignment, Geneva and physicist Peter Donatelli are tasked with making the trip themselves. The pair have a mere three days to prepare for a journey to 1630s New England.
Geneva is terrified by the prospect of crossing the Atlantic by ship and immersing herself in a Puritan community, but she's long been intrigued by the life of John Winthrop. This assignment could help her answer questions about Winthrop and even come up with a topic worthy of a dissertation.
This story held just enough historical record and futuristic fantasy to engage both of us as readers. The beginning groundwork was a bit difficult to get through, but then we were caught up in the story of these two time travelers. We rooted for Geneva and Peter as their old-fashioned love story bloomed between time periods.
We gladly rejoiced when Geneva understood not only what the root of the matter was but also accepted it personally into her life, the gospel of Jesus Christ. This story perfectly illustrated the stark difference between knowing and believing. One thing is for certain. Tagawa knows how to bait readers into a follow-up story. We were left with far too many questions and look forward to reading more about Geneva and Peter.
We received an advance copy from the author. This is our honest review
Lynne Basham Tagawa
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Geneva Fielding works as a researcher helping to prepare time travelers for their historical destinations. When a Traveler fails an important test just days before an assignment, Geneva and physicist Peter Donatelli are tasked with making the trip themselves. The pair have a mere three days to prepare for a journey to 1630s New England.
Geneva is terrified by the prospect of crossing the Atlantic by ship and immersing herself in a Puritan community, but she's long been intrigued by the life of John Winthrop. This assignment could help her answer questions about Winthrop and even come up with a topic worthy of a dissertation.
This story held just enough historical record and futuristic fantasy to engage both of us as readers. The beginning groundwork was a bit difficult to get through, but then we were caught up in the story of these two time travelers. We rooted for Geneva and Peter as their old-fashioned love story bloomed between time periods.
We gladly rejoiced when Geneva understood not only what the root of the matter was but also accepted it personally into her life, the gospel of Jesus Christ. This story perfectly illustrated the stark difference between knowing and believing. One thing is for certain. Tagawa knows how to bait readers into a follow-up story. We were left with far too many questions and look forward to reading more about Geneva and Peter.
We received an advance copy from the author. This is our honest review
August 2, 2024
Loved this book! I am a huge fan of historical fiction and this book, The Root of the Matter. I normally don't read time travel books but this was so interesting! The back and forth of time periods trying to figure out certain specific aspects that cause events was a really fun and interesting way to explore that time period. Can't wait for her next book!
Read it, you won't be diappointed!
Read it, you won't be diappointed!
September 13, 2025
I truly loved this book and was so fascinated by the concept! Time travel from the near-off future to the colonial days?! The author beautifully explained the culture shock of the directional travel, nailed the experiences and nuances of the colonial era, and kept me guessing about the "current" time frame. The spiritual engagement of both eras also was fascinating - entertaining both our history and our future, and how orthodox Christianity and belief is influenced by the times. So many surprises and intrigues left me on the edge of my seat. Now I keep stalking Goodreads to look for the next installment!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 32 reviews