It is important to understand what you are getting here: this is an oral history of the production of Terrence Malick’s films, not any kind of analysis of the finished product. Malick himself is famously reclusive, and so he did not contribute to this book, while those who did contribute can only guess at “what Malick’s films mean”. The book is based on interviews with a number of Malick’s collaborators from his first film Badlands (1973) to The Tree of Life; while it was known to the editors that it had shot To the Wonder, that film came too late to be considered herein.
The interviews with the cinematographers for Malick’s films, with his longtime crew like production designer Jack Fisk and casting agent Diane Crittenden, and with editor Billy Weber give a great deal of insight into how actors were cast, how weather conditions and the terrain determined shots, and how the mountain of footage shot was gradually sculpted into a finished film. Impressively, the editors were even able to get input from most of Malick’s actors, even though some of them are big Hollywood stars.
For me, one of the most interesting things about this book is how it deconstructs the “myth of the auteur”. While each film can definitely be seen as Malick’s own personal expression simply because he oversaw the final edit, he played no part in many day-to-day aspects of moviemaking: sometimes a hired coach trained the actors for weeks before they briefly appeared in front of the camera, and each film had a second camera unit that made various shots on their own and only sent them on to Malick for approval.
The downside of the oral-history format of the book is that sometimes, when pressed to comment on Malick himself and his aims, the interviewees can only resort to platitudes. And sometimes multiple interviewees make the same comments, which leads to repetition. Still, I found this worthwhile for better understanding Malick’s films and how they came to be.