5 stars. I finished reading one of the Newbery books I've most anticipated "The Moved Outers" by Florence Cranall Means. While it didn't disappoint, I'm still in digestion mode. The book was published in 1946 and was an Honor Book in 1947 - which may be the most remarkable thing about it. Why? Because it's the story of an American family (kids Tad, Amy, Susie, Kim) living in CA .It begins 5 Dec 1941 and covers a bit more than a year in their lives as they go from proud Americans to being the enemy and being placed in first a holding facility (the horse stalls at Santa Anita) and then the internment camp Amache in CO..... All because they're the children of nisei and the bear the names Tadeo, Emiko, Sumiko, and Kimio. Relevance for today? Hell. Yes I finished reading one of the Newbery books I've most anticipated "The Moved Outers" by Florence Cranall Means. While it didn't disappoint, I'm still in digestion mode. The book was published in 1946 and was an Honor Book in 1947 - which may be the most remarkable thing about it. Why? Because it's the story of an American family (kids Tad, Amy, Susie, Kim) living in CA .It begins 5 Dec 1941 and covers a bit more than a year in their lives as they go from proud Americans to being the enemy and being placed in first a holding facility (the horse stalls at Santa Anita) and then the internment camp Amache in CO..... All because they're the children of nisei and the bear the names Tadeo, Emiko, Sumiko, and Kimio. Relevance for today? Hell. Yes. Reason for digestion: Means is not of Japanese descent and I want to read George Takei's graphic novel and also Farewell to Manzanar. I read this for my 2019 Reading Challenge and my Newbery Challenge (Honor Book 1947).
ETA: I finished Manzanar a few days after reading this. Means' book holds up and is especially strong given the time in which it was written (Manzanar dates from the early 1970s). Differences: (1) the age of the central character (Houston was 10 when she was interned, Sumiko was 17-19) which made the experience somewhat different - interestingly both came from white areas prior to internment, (2) the effect the internment had on the fathers - Houston's father was a broken man, Means' fictionalized father was merely aged, and 3) post-internment Houston's family spread across the US with the CA contingents supported by her mother, and Means' fictionalized family (which also spread) seemed to be able to mostly pick back up from where it had been due to community/church support.