A Sudden Light is a sublimely written novel that demands your full attention, it's not something to be rushed, and in return it reveals it's magic to you, the reader. I had seen very mixed reviews of this book so went in to it quite open minded, often that way is best.
The book has some simply incredible scenes and moments in it that capture the imagination and stir the emotions. On the other hand it also has some rather dull and drawn out moments that inspire a touch of boredom, those were however, not that often thankfully. But this is not a rapid page turner, rather a piece of fiction to delve into, coming up for air now and then, then diving back in for more.
In the summer of 1990, fourteen-year-old Trevor Riddell gets his first glimpse of Riddell House. Built from the spoils of a massive timber fortune, the legendary family mansion is constructed of giant, whole trees, and is set on a huge estate overlooking Puget Sound. Trevor’s bankrupt parents have begun a trial separation, and his father, Jones Riddell, has brought Trevor to Riddell House with a goal: to join forces with his sister, Serena, dispatch Grandpa Samuel—who is flickering in and out of dementia—to a graduated living facility, sell off the house and property for development into “tract housing for millionaires,” divide up the profits, and live happily ever after.
Trevor, is 14 going on 21, some may argue that he thinks and talks like an adult, this could somewhat be because a lot of the book is written from the adult version of Trevor remembering these years and times. I like to think that he is just a clever young man, a man who seeks truth and sees things others don't, not a frivolous boy. A serious young man. By golly, I liked him a huge amount as a character. Brilliantly done.
His parents have "separated" although nobody is calling it that and his mother is in London, whilst he travels to the home of his father's upbringing and family ancestors. A rambling, huge home with a history that speaks from the very walls themselves.
But it's a manipulative purpose, Trevor's father has teamed up with his sister Serena (I will get to her in a minute) to try to "encourage" Grandpa Samuel to hand over power of attorney, the end goal being to sell of this house and it's history to developers wanting to whack modern housing on it. Grandpa Samuel is not going down without a fight. He's a brilliant old man portrayed in the grip of Alzheimer's, but with moments of such lucid brilliance, you can't help but like him. Young Trevor quickly connects and cares for Grandpa Samuel.
Serena!, where do we start with Serena. What a character I loved to hate. Vile, manipulative and cruel one moment, then cloying, seductive and demonstrative the next. I seriously began to wonder if she has a personality disorder (or three). BUT, very cleverly written, she sheds a dark shadow over this house with her eyes cast on selling it off, no matter what Grandpa Samuel wants and making a lot of money. Hideous woman. What a very special flawed and well written character however, even if you don't like her.
There are some ghostly encounters in the house, young Trevor explores the house and finds things in secret places, hidden journals and sees the ghosts that his Grandpa Samuel also sees, like that of his Grandmother, dancing at night in the ballroom. Ghosts? The dead? Do they see them or do they not? It's not clear. But don't be fooled into thinking this is a creepy ghost story, that is not what it's about ultimately, this is a very clever piece of fiction tackling the complexities and dynamics of family and relationships.
Trevor believes if he helps his father convince Grandpa to sign over power of attorney that he will be rich and therefore his mother will come back and all will be well. He is like any young child facing this situation, he's thinking of the happy ever after, the reality is kept from him unfortunately which feeds his fantasies of a whole family. God bless you Trevor, you deserved better.
The magic of this book is in the writing, the clever interactions between family members, the very subtle reveals that make you gasp as they sneak up on you, then it makes so much sense. There is questions of proper relationship between brother and sister, the historical truth of family members that were homosexual in an era when it had to be hidden at all costs, there are lies, manipulations and deep, dark secrets. Young Trevor uncovers much of the darkness and shines light on the dark places.
The plot is slow, almost lulled me to sleep a bit in the middle, especially the flashbacks to times long ago, but I could not stop reading, you have to keep going, it had a magical lilt to it, a way of weaving words into my imagination, I was right there in that huge house, seeing the characters and watching their subtle interactions that carried a million mixed messages.
The book leads to a dramatic and highly unexpected conclusion, nothing I saw coming from the beginning and it left me feeling quite numb, then I felt good, then I felt sad. I pondered a bit on all of that. Sometimes you have to read a book and not look for thrills, chills and pace, sometimes you have to read a book that has you look carefully at what is being said, finding the message in the book. I can't describe it fully, but it's as though the words in this novel weaved around me like a fine mist. Too theatrical? Yeah, probably. It was cleverly written and I liked it. There, better?
There are huge environmental and historical reasons why Grandpa Samuel doesn't want this grand, but decaying home sold, bulldozed and modern housing built on the land. The book takes you on that historical journey through the eyes of Trevor and his discoveries about his ancestors and their story.
I am on the team that likes this book, I think many will not, it might be whether you get it or not, or even if you simply have the patience for it. I found it fascinating because I find human beings very interesting and love seeing complex dynamics at work in my books. It's a challenge. You may like it too for reasons of your own. Enjoy the clever reveals and truths as they surface, decide yourself if you like the characters or not (I wanted Grandpa Samuel to be MY grandpa). It's up to you now.
Sigh. Wistful sigh. A pleasing book that took me on a fascinating and special journey. For that, I am thankful. I give this book 3.5 stars, rounded up to 4.
I received a copy of this book thanks to the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.