An intriguing and well-written novel, but one where the ending undoes a little of the book’s elegance (4.5/5, rounded down to 4 stars).
The Closing Days follows American university student Alex on his travels to Austria. He meets and falls for local girl Johanna, who finds him some work with her grandfather Heinrich. When Heinrich asks Alex to stalk an old acquaintance, it’s unclear whether he should trust his employer or if something concerning is going on…
First off, the good. Alex is extremely believable and relatable as a character. As so much of the story is told from his perspective, Alex’s character feeing real is a huge strength. The prose is another highlight - it’s clear and elegant, with a great sense of place. The novel tackles some interesting ideas too: the burden of history (especially complicated, painful or regrettable pasts), whether it’s always worth facing difficult history, and the extent to which culture unites or divides.
While the ending delivered on the plot, the final 30-40 pages leave the reader in no doubt about the author’s views on the novel’s themes. I couldn’t shake the feeling that some of the characters were talking for the author at times. I think The Closing Days would have been more successful if the author had left more space for readers to reach their own conclusion.
There were also a few aspects of the book that felt a bit forced. For instance, Alex has deep knowledge of cameras, which is first mentioned when a camera becomes useful for the stalking he has been sent to do. At very least this could have been foreshadowed more, otherwise it feels like the plot is driving the characters rather than the other way around.
Still, on the whole The Closing Days was a very enjoyable read. It (mostly) delivered on plot, ideas, prose and characters, and books that do that are not common.
One final thought is that having read the book, I wasn’t surprised to learn that the author spent time in Vienna. Parts of Alex’s explorations and homesickness have a slight travelogue feel to them. I’d be very keen to read Kovach’s next book, and in particular to see what we can do when the setting and subject matter are a little less personally familiar.
The Closing Days is recommended for those who like a good mix of plot, characters and themes and aren’t afraid to read about difficult topics. I probably wouldn’t recommend it for those who want a lot of action from page one, or for those looking for a bit of thematic ambiguity.
Thank you to Netgalley, Isaac Kovach and Parallel Grey Press for a free review copy of The Closing Days, provided in exchange for an honest review.