4.5 Stars.
It is 1397, and a peasant 'gleeman' (a wandering bard/orator) Mottyr Naked, recounts the tale of the destruction of his home to its ultimate destroyers. With total commitment to its style, this book is delivered as one vitriolic monologue in 'Auld English'.
As the book twists and winds, the expectation is of one massive, cathartic reveal. Instead Brown breaks down the story, and each twist that a lesser writer would have made the central 'punch', is one in a stage of many. The identity of Mottyr, of the fell wraith Annie, the lingering presence of Pearl Eye and the Mercers, are all slowly teased out and revealed, bringing new questions. The structure is superlative, where the information given to the audience, embedded and reader, is expertly controlled and unveiled.
Further, the ideas of the text are also incredibly enticing, appealing to the reader's sense of justice and delivering a very satisfying ending. The notions of medieval class, with its hierarchical ordering, and the interaction of faith and vassalhood, is stretched and drawn out throughout the book with a seething awareness of the injustice it perpetuates. Mother Naked is not just the story of one man's cunning revenge, and transmogrification from 'mysterious stranger' to 'avenging son', but of a class hatred and scrabble for justice.
To go from the scant springboard of the historical recorded performance of 'Mottyr Naked' in 1433-4, to this story, is stunning.