I do love a good high school romance, but I really enjoy a great one. This one is the latter, clearly, but it absolutely comes down to how messy these kids are allowed to be some times.
This volume kind of stuffs its major plot, such as it is, into the back chapters. The rest is mostly slice of life, with a flashback and a bunch of goofing off. It’s almost cozy and I think this handles the sick girl trope way better than a lot of stories.
It has such a great eye for framing its pages too. I loved the chapter where parts are presented as excerpts from a scrapbook and, while the flashback chapter is a little confusing, it has a great full spread of the astronomy club at the end.
One of the biggest plots this time is the astronomy club and their apparent inability to get new members. This serves as an exploration of Yui (the arcade manager)’s backstory and her estrangement from her family. It’s both sad and enjoyable in equal measure.
There’s also the ongoing issue of Ganta trying to have the slightest bit of optimism about anything. I have to say that the way this plays out is all rather sweet and affirming. He’s the classic character who gets stuck in his own bad thoughts way too much and no I don’t relate, why do you ask?
The back part of the book is where real life and high school life start crashing into one another. Ganta’s big plan is to become a nurse so he can take care of Magari, but he gets dressed down by his teacher for not thinking this through. Which he isn’t; he’s a kid.
We also see a couple times this volume that Ganta’s father is far from reliable and it’s no wonder the poor kid has no confidence in himself with so little guidance. Ganta’s got a goal, but it seems like his real passion is elsewhere and he’s doing this just for Magari. Sweet, but not entirely reasonable.
I love Magari’s perspective on things and it comes back to give Ganta some real insight on, well, life. As she points out, nobody knows when she might die. And nobody knows when he will either. Her blunt words that if he begins to see her as a burden they’re done are the perfect antidote to Ganta’s ideas. She has such a great outlook on her limitations and what she wants from life.
Which is all a little heavy, but it’s surrounded by this delightful examination of youth and young love. There’s not just the inherent depression of chronic illness, it focuses on living a life despite that and living it well. There are so many joyous moments to be found here.
This is probably too sedate for some people. It lumbers along at its own pace and is often just doing its thing, which is being laid back and then also doing some dramatic punching to the reader. For me, who loves seeing these two together, it’s always pure reading pleasure.
4.5 stars - rounded up because I’d watch these two eat soup and enjoy every minute of it.