"This biography attempts to show Catherine neither as a saint nor a sinner, but rather as a woman of her time, living in an era of immense scientific, global and social change, who had a profound impact on the world around her."
4,5/5!
Catherine of Braganza is mostly remembered as the long-suffering, childless wife of the Merry Monarch, Charles II. In this wonderful biography, Sophie Shorland shines a light on this often overlooked queen and explores her life before, during and after her marriage to Charles, painting a vivid picture of a woman who was so much more than just that one queen who never had kids and had to tolerate her randy husband's copious affairs.
Catherine of Braganza was a fascinating woman. I knew bits and bobs about her life before and after Charles II, so I knew she had a much larger role in politics of the time then people usually give her credit for, but this book still opened my eyes and made me appreciate her even more. Shorland's detailed and wonderfully written book paints such a complex portrait of this woman, while also providing the reader with historical background regarding events, ideologies, political debates and social changes contemporary to her which helps the reader to place her in the larger context of her time. Shorland's writing is easy to grasp and she conveys difficult topics with such ease, never dumbing anything down, just making sure everyone can understand what is going on. The author's humour also shines through every now and then, making the book funnier than you'd expect a biography of a historical queen to perhaps be.
Shorland approaches Catherine not just a queen of England, but also, above all, a Portugese princess. Throughout her life, Catherine was devoted to her home and, after her husband's death, she wrote to her brother, hoping "– to be united with You, Your Wife & daughter, & at the same time to see my Home land on whose behalf I have been Exil'd from it for six-and-twenty years always longing to be there with you". I think it does her a disservice if she is only ever described as a Queen of England – she'd hate that! I found her devotion to her home and her aching homesickness to be really moving. Catherine is a great example of a royal pawn, someone who is used to build bridges and establish alliances between nations, whose whole purpose is to help rule one country while making sure the country she came from is viewed positively and aided. It was super interesting exploring this dual identity she has going on, even after she returned to Portugal as a widow (it was sad but also a bit funny how odd she found Portugal after decades away, and how she insisted Portugal had changed, not her). As someone who is not at all familiar with Portugese royal history, I enjoyed getting to know her family and all their wild shenanigans – her dad became king after a brief and bloodless revolution where the Spanish Habsburgs were kicked out, her mom was an ambitious power played behind the scenes, her mom ended up the regent for her teen son and held on to power so long they had to kick her off the throne, her brother Pedro hooked up with their other brother Afonso's queen Marie Françoise and together they overthrew Afonso and so much more. They had some real royal soap opera drama going on back in Lisbon.
Shorland manages to capture Catherine's personality really vividly. You get a strong image of a woman who was both prone to fits of depression and immense joy. She liked a good party, enjoyed gate-crashing parties in disguise (once her disguise was so good her own attendants didn't recognise her and she had to make her way back to the palace on her own), loved playing cards, dabbled in crossdressing and was, in many ways, a great fit for her husband's notoriously fun-loving court. But she was also deeply pious, a devout Catholic, surprisingly minimalist in her style and always dignified, despite the embarrassments her husband put her through and the genuine danger her religion put her in. She was a hypochondriac who liked trying out new medical treatments so much her doctors worried she might like being sick and treated a bit too much. It's unfortunate she is so often depicted as this mousy, quiet, sad wife of Charles, when in reality she was fun to be around and immensely liked. Even when the Catholic persecution and panic was at its worst, people liked her and defended her. I had to respect her unerring politeness and how she was able to seemingly get on with anyone, even making friends with her husband's mistresses – it seems even the infamous Barbara Palmer made friends with the queen after their, to put it mildly, rocky start. She was a great queen in so many ways – she upheld social harmony, corresponded with foreign monarchs and played a major role in diplomacy (her circles, held in her private rooms, became integral spaces for people to meet and talk with the royal family) – so it is sad she is only remembered for not being able to have kids and thus "failing" in her role as queen.
Shorland challenges commonly held beliefs about Catherine. For example, instead of taking the easy route and parroting the idea that she and Charles were unhappy and that their first big row over Barbara Palmer ruined any chance of happiness for them, she focuses on them as two complex individuals who had a complex dynamic. Sure, it was an arranged marriage and Charles married her in part because she was pretty, in part because it was a smart political move and in part because the Spanish ambassador told him not to do it and he didn't like being told what to do. But despite their occasional disagreements and Charles's rampant adultery (even on the era's standards), they were partners. Her role in politics suggests Charles had faith in her, he always defended her from public slander and though it seems he was tempted for a while to divorce her, he stood by her side and refused to abandon her, saying it would be horrid to abandon her after all he has put her through. There are stories of them waking up at 5 AM to go fishing together, bonding over their shared interest in science (they stayed up for three nights hoping to see a comet) and of Charles being openly affectionate towards her and spending more time with his wife than was normal for a king. When Catherine's physician was found not guilty of Catholic treason (thus also saving Catherine from being further targeted and implicated in this false Popish Plot), Charles apparently cried in relief. When he died, she mourned intensely and with such raw emotion people worried for her. It took her three months to be able to visit the new Queen, even though she was a close friend to her. I appreciated Shorland for highlighting the multifaceted nature of their partnership and allowing it to be messy and difficult and not trying to push them into any strict category.
Alongside learning about Catherine's remarkable life, this book also taught me a a lot about the Restoration court and the time period as a whole. I knew the court was a wild place, but learning that apparently the balls were so busy and loud that one of Catherine's ladies in waiting gave birth in the middle of the hall without anyone noticing made me appreciate, on a whole new level, just how noisy and busy it would've been. Shorland also does a great job at showcasing how, though Charles's reign was fun and steamy, it was also a period of severe unrest. The capital was struck first by plague and then, not long after, by the Great Fire – two hellish, cataclysmic events. There was also severe political unrest, with paranoia against this imagined plot of the Catholics going as far as to result in executions, violence, mob hysteria and accusations against the queen and the king's brother. I knew the religious debates of the time were wild, but I had no idea just how close Catherine came to losing her throne and James to being, by parliament, cut off the succession. This book also made me appreciate just how loudly people demanded Charles divorce Catherine. Her reign was full of tumult and fear, and it is no wonder, considering the attacks against the faith she held so dear, people trying to get her hubby to dump her and her inability to have kids, that she suffered from anxiety and depression.
One of the most intriguing sections of the book for me was everything that followed Charles's death. I knew Catherine went back to Portugal, but I didn't know it took her until after the Glorious Revolution to get there. I had no idea she was there when James II took the throne and began his deeply unpopular (but to my eyes, quite respectable) campaign for religious freedom. It was baffling to read about how so many suspected Mary of Modena somehow faking giving birth to a son and how common stories like "the baby was delivered to the room, where multiple people (including Catherine) watched the queen give birth, in a bedpan and then Mary faked labor" were. I had no idea Catherine begged James for the Duke of Monmouth's life to be spared (to no avail) or that, after Mary and William took over, Jacobites met at her house (somehow she still remained on good terms with her "nieces"). Her later life in Portugal was interesting, and a great study in what female power looks like when the woman in question is no longer directly linked to a man. As a widow, Catherine had her own funds and more liberty than ever. Her officially apolitical role (until she became her ill brother's regent, during the War of Spanish Succession, and had to oversee both the government and army) is also a wonderful example of so-called soft power: she met with diplomats, hosted big wigs, remained an integral link between England and Portugal and took over the education of her brother's children when his wife died.
It would be easy to assume that Catherine's life didn't have that big an impact on the world, but oh boy it did, for better or worse. She popularised tea-drinking in England (it is amusing to me that one of the most quintessentially British things was made popular by a foreigner Queen), she introduced baroque style and music to England, and she created an alliance between England and Portugal that has remained quite strong ever since. The alliance she oversaw and made possible was referenced by Churchill during WWII when he petitioned for Portugal's help. Her dowry included Bombay, which made the colonisation of India possible. The New York area of Queens was named after her: New York, conquered by James, was named after him, and what is now Brooklyn was called Kings County after Charles. She helped bring modern fashion to Portugal, changing court life there. For the Portuguese, she was a heroine and a saviour, the woman who brought them the allies that made winning the war for independence possible. She shaped her world, and it is important that we remember that, even if not all she left behind was positive.
This is exactly what I hoped a biography of Catherine would be. I would recommend this book enthusiastically for anyone interested in Catherine's life, the Restoration era and Charles II's merry reign. There is also plenty here for those intrigued by history of religion.
Some interesting facts I learned:
- All of Catherine's family loved music (and arts in general – her mom Luisa was a painter). It is possible her dad, King João composed the melody of O Come All Ye Faithful.
- João was offered the throne of Portugal multiple times but he refused, until, it seems, his wife convinced him to take it.
- The Portugese have a long tradition of giving their monarchs nicknames. Catherine's dad was João the Restorer, while Catherine's nephew, João was refererred to as the Portuguese Sun King and the Visitor of Convents (one of his main msitresses was a nun).
- A marriage between Charles and Catherine was first discussed when he was 14 and she was 5. The Civil War in England put a stop to those negotiations.
- When they got engaged, Charles sent Catherine English clothes. She tried high heels for the first time then and strained her ankle doing so.
- Charles I's nephew Rupert, a royalist legendary military leader, became a privateer and a pirate after the Civil War. He caused a ruckus in Portugal and João almost ended up in a conflict with the Protectorate over him.
- Charles was crowned king of England before Catherine arrived so a catholic queen didn't have to undergo a protestant ceremony.
- When Catherine left Portugal, her brother Afonso sailed incognito on a barge to serenade her on her way out of the harbor.
- Charles couldn't have sex with Catherine on their wedding night cause she was on her period. He wrote to his sister Henriette, saying "The curse that followed our family is fallen upon me", referring to Henriette having had the same issue on her wedding night with Philippe. It also seems Henriette and Charles gossiped in their letters about Henriette's husband not being great in bed which is just all sorts of amusing.
- Wilmot, Earl of Rochester, wrote that Barbara Palmer "has swallowed more pricks than the nation has land", which says pretty much everything about her reputation and his sense of humour.
- During the plague, a rumour began circulating that syphilis gave you immunity, which led to masses of desperate people visiting sex workers. This, of course, didn't work.
- Around 70 000 to 80 000 people were made homeless by the Great Fire of London.
- It was suspected that Henriette, Charles's sister, was poisoned by her husband's lover Chevalier de Lorraine, but the autopsy didn't show any signs of poison.
- James smuggled a Catholic priest in secrecy to his brother's deathbed.
- Charles's mom Henrietta Maria was a crucial ally and friend to Catherine. She was also good friends with James II's queen, Mary of Modena.
- Catherine asked to be buried next to her brother Teodósio who died when they were teens. He had been only 19, a "perfect prince". 52 years later, his sister was laid to rest next to him.
- In her will, Catherine left money to free slaves and debtors, to religious organisations and for her servants.