Uneven but Worth a Read During Spooky Season
Reading the Benjamin Oris Collection as a whole is a very complicated experience. Carrie Rubin delivers a blend of medical suspense, folklore, and supernatural horror with levity but the execution across the three books is uneven.
Book 1 (The Bone Curse) introduces Ben as a deeply flawed protagonist a skeptic so unwilling to accept what’s right in front of him that two women die and many are hurt as a result of his arrogance. His privilege and refusal to trust others makes him a hard character to root for, and the women in the story, Laurette and Sophia especially, are used too often as devices to further his arc.
Book 2 (The Bone Hunger) is the weakest of the trilogy. Overstuffed with characters and side plots, it skimps on meaningful development and continues to lean too heavily on the trope of women suffering to advance Ben’s journey. Sophia, who already endured illness and trauma, is dragged through further pain, and Laurette once again is forced into Ben’s orbit romantically in a way that feels both forced and unsettling.
Book 3 (The Bone Elixir) redeems the trilogy in many ways. It’s tighter, better paced, and gives more autonomy to its women characters. Harmony, Laurette, and Sophia are the ones who hold the story together, correcting Ben’s missteps and carrying the means for final resolution. Harmony and her brother’s subplot provides genuine warmth, and while Ben is still frustrating as always. Well at least he moves from reluctant skepticism toward cautious belief in the supernatural.
Overall, the trilogy is frustrating but fascinating. Rubin writing in Book 1 & 3 keep the pages turning, but her reliance on sidelining women as martyrs or props for Ben undermines the otherwise strong storytelling. If you want the essentials, you could read Book 3 on its own for the clearest and most rewarding story, then circle back to Book 1 as a “prequel” after the fact to fill in background. I’d recommend skipping Book 2 entirely, unless you don’t totally hate Ben after book 1 as it drags the series down, confused the reader, and hurts a truly amazing character. All in all i recommend it for spooky season reading especially book 3!