What do you think?
Rate this book
Their Shadows Deep
The author of Nothing Is Forgotten takes a dark look at power gone too far, imagining the connection between JFK’s presidential campaign and an ex-cop’s investigation into her husband’s murder.
In 1960, Senator John F. Kennedy makes a historic run for the White House. Despite concerns about his Catholicism, Kennedy’s outward charm is winning the country over, but his inner demons are putting his candidacy in danger and risk destroying his political career.
That same year, Caitlin Russo, a former cop turned reporter, is devoting her skills to finding her husband’s killer. His job as a CIA operative posed its fair share of risks, but when Caitlin discovers his notes about the case that led to his death, she knows there’s more to the story than simple tragedy.
As Caitlin and Kennedy search for the people responsible for upending their lives, some ugly truths about American politics and foreign affairs come to light, and Caitlin finds herself in a web of deceit and shattered hopes, realizing that heroes aren’t always who they seem.
In 1960, Senator John F. Kennedy makes a historic run for the White House. Despite concerns about his Catholicism, Kennedy’s outward charm is winning the country over, but his inner demons are putting his candidacy in danger and risk destroying his political career.
That same year, Caitlin Russo, a former cop turned reporter, is devoting her skills to finding her husband’s killer. His job as a CIA operative posed its fair share of risks, but when Caitlin discovers his notes about the case that led to his death, she knows there’s more to the story than simple tragedy.
As Caitlin and Kennedy search for the people responsible for upending their lives, some ugly truths about American politics and foreign affairs come to light, and Caitlin finds herself in a web of deceit and shattered hopes, realizing that heroes aren’t always who they seem.
373 pages, Kindle Edition
First published February 1, 2025
4340 people are currently reading
5998 people want to read
About the author
Peter Golden
23 books130 followersPeter Golden is an award-winning journalist, historian, and novelist who has written nine books and interviewed Presidents Nixon, Ford, Reagan, and Bush (41); Secretaries of State Kissinger, Haig, Shultz, and Eagleburger; Israeli Prime Ministers Rabin, Peres, and Shamir; and Soviet President Gorbachev. His first novel, Comeback Love, was praised by the novelist and reviewer Caroline Leavitt as an “extraordinary debut.” Wherever There Is Light, his second novel, was featured in New York Magazine’s Fall Preview issue, widely reviewed, and selected by the New Jersey Star-Ledger as one of the best books of 2016. His third novel, Nothing Is Forgotten, which explores the connection between the Holocaust and the Cold War, was published on April 10, 2018. New York Times bestselling author Lisa Wingate praised the novel as "the sort of book you won’t soon forget…Cold War Europe, lingering Nazi secrets, and the tragic history faced by millions of families not only bring this tale to life but will keep you turning the pages.”
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 219 reviews
Read
January 16, 2025Since it hasn't been published yet, I obviously can't write a review, but in the 1960s women made up about 1% of police departments, let alone actual acting cops, and were just beginning to be accepted as real reporters (as opposed to Dear Abby and covering social events). That being said, the premise sounds more than a bit shaky, in fact, highly unlikely. I love historical fiction, but it has to be true to the period; otherwise, IMHO it's not worth reading.
March 30, 2025
Their Shadows Deep by Peter Golden is an okay book. I must admit that I was a bit let down since I was eager to read a book that had JFK as a main character investigating a murder. That part of the book was the one I liked the best. I was not equally fond of the storyline with Caitlin Russo; I just didn't find her believable. I think she's way too modern for the era. At least that's how I felt. I did like her interactions with Jackie Kennedy, and the ending was good.
I want to thank the publisher for providing me with a free copy through NetGalley for an honest review!
I want to thank the publisher for providing me with a free copy through NetGalley for an honest review!
January 22, 2025
I don’t know. This was ok. I enjoyed some elements of the story: Jack’s health problems, the imaginary musings with Kit. Jackie. But there were a lot of elements that didn’t make any sense to me at all:
1. We all could have seen who the bad guy was from a mile away, and yet Cait meets with him anyway, not telling anyone what she knows, and then confronts the killer of her husband. I mean.. how dumb is that? It was the most anticlimactic stand off I’ve read in a long time. The old “well, before I shoot you I’m going to tell you everything” routine is so blah.
2. I don’t know what the focus of the story was. Are we supposed to care about Jack or Cait? The POV switch didn’t work for me. Also, Cait is always the hero but Jack is… also a hero? And antihero? I don’t get the point.
3. How is Cait the only one to find Clara?!? And how does a woman who is supposedly so smart (Clara) decide “Oh! I think I’ll mail the one piece of evidence — a sex tape with THE PRESIDENT— to a lady I just met one time in hopes that she will keep her vague promise to keep me protected..”What?
I could go on about the silliness I saw, but it wasn’t a bad read. I learned some history I didn’t know, and it mostly kept my attention.
1. We all could have seen who the bad guy was from a mile away, and yet Cait meets with him anyway, not telling anyone what she knows, and then confronts the killer of her husband. I mean.. how dumb is that? It was the most anticlimactic stand off I’ve read in a long time. The old “well, before I shoot you I’m going to tell you everything” routine is so blah.
2. I don’t know what the focus of the story was. Are we supposed to care about Jack or Cait? The POV switch didn’t work for me. Also, Cait is always the hero but Jack is… also a hero? And antihero? I don’t get the point.
3. How is Cait the only one to find Clara?!? And how does a woman who is supposedly so smart (Clara) decide “Oh! I think I’ll mail the one piece of evidence — a sex tape with THE PRESIDENT— to a lady I just met one time in hopes that she will keep her vague promise to keep me protected..”What?
I could go on about the silliness I saw, but it wasn’t a bad read. I learned some history I didn’t know, and it mostly kept my attention.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 4, 2025
Historical fiction based on life when I was a kid.
January 6, 2025
dnf - too much going on
January 16, 2025
Some insight on JFK
I've read a fair amount about JFK , and while his character was more of a subplot , I gleaned a little more about his life and insight into potential assassins and a little more about his demons. The main character Caitlin is well written and interesting. She is trying to investigate the shooting of her husband and becomes embroiled in the workings of the CIA and the mafia. The book wasn't as dark as I imagined it would be , Kennedy is treated sympathetically and there's an interesting structural device which uses imagined conversations with his dead sister Kick to shed light on his character. There is a grim underbelly to the novel. I'm glad I read the afterword which explained a little more of the significance of the missing film which may or may not have existed . I did guess who the 'baddie ' was but not straight away. This wasn't a book I galloped through, it wasn't compelling as such, but I'll probably check out other works by Golden. It was well written though.
I've read a fair amount about JFK , and while his character was more of a subplot , I gleaned a little more about his life and insight into potential assassins and a little more about his demons. The main character Caitlin is well written and interesting. She is trying to investigate the shooting of her husband and becomes embroiled in the workings of the CIA and the mafia. The book wasn't as dark as I imagined it would be , Kennedy is treated sympathetically and there's an interesting structural device which uses imagined conversations with his dead sister Kick to shed light on his character. There is a grim underbelly to the novel. I'm glad I read the afterword which explained a little more of the significance of the missing film which may or may not have existed . I did guess who the 'baddie ' was but not straight away. This wasn't a book I galloped through, it wasn't compelling as such, but I'll probably check out other works by Golden. It was well written though.
January 4, 2025
Fascinating glimpse into JFKs story - told as a novel
If even half of the shenanigans depicted in the story behind the story of the run-up to JFKs election as President are based on the truth, they depict levels of corruption and scheming that make modern day politics look tame.
A gripping read which spins stories around the cast of CIA, FBI, journalists and other influencers in one of the closest run elections ever. Hard to put down and with a twist I hadn't seen coming, this book is pacy, well written and intriguing.
If even half of the shenanigans depicted in the story behind the story of the run-up to JFKs election as President are based on the truth, they depict levels of corruption and scheming that make modern day politics look tame.
A gripping read which spins stories around the cast of CIA, FBI, journalists and other influencers in one of the closest run elections ever. Hard to put down and with a twist I hadn't seen coming, this book is pacy, well written and intriguing.
April 2, 2025
This dual POV story follows JFK as he prepares to run for the presidency, while a mutual friend prepares to hunt down her husband's killer.
Their Shadows Deep is a historical fiction thriller standalone by award-winning Peter Golden.
The book follows the presidential campaign of John F. Kennedy and how his path crosses with a former cop who is investigating her husband’s murder. Set in the 1960s, readers are presented with two compelling stories where both characters want answers and will do anything to get them, even if it means sacrificing their livelihoods.
I think it would be fair to say that I struggled with staying focused on this book; the first part — the book is split into four parts — was definitely the most engaging, but it quickly became too much. The constant switch in POV and story made it hard to follow. I usually struggle with these sorts of things in books, but figured I would give it a go regardless because I was intrigued by the premise.
Besides some of the flaws, I certainly enjoyed the storytelling aspect of the book. I liked how headstrong Cait was, and I liked how charismatic Jack was. One of the main strengths of the book was how the characters were developed and how much they had to offer. The overall story was easy to follow and understand at first because the two MCs' paths crossed pretty early on, but sadly that was lost as the book progressed.
As someone who enjoys learning about history, the historical aspects of the plot, especially anecdotes that readers hadn’t been introduced to before, definitely contributed to my rating of this book. It was easy to get confused quickly, which was a shame because I thought that following John F. Kennedy's journey into the White House had so much potential.
Sadly, I didn't enjoy this one but definitely give it a go if you are experienced with historial fiction.
I received a copy of Their Shadows Deep via Amazon’s First Reads Programme.
Their Shadows Deep is a historical fiction thriller standalone by award-winning Peter Golden.
The book follows the presidential campaign of John F. Kennedy and how his path crosses with a former cop who is investigating her husband’s murder. Set in the 1960s, readers are presented with two compelling stories where both characters want answers and will do anything to get them, even if it means sacrificing their livelihoods.
I think it would be fair to say that I struggled with staying focused on this book; the first part — the book is split into four parts — was definitely the most engaging, but it quickly became too much. The constant switch in POV and story made it hard to follow. I usually struggle with these sorts of things in books, but figured I would give it a go regardless because I was intrigued by the premise.
Besides some of the flaws, I certainly enjoyed the storytelling aspect of the book. I liked how headstrong Cait was, and I liked how charismatic Jack was. One of the main strengths of the book was how the characters were developed and how much they had to offer. The overall story was easy to follow and understand at first because the two MCs' paths crossed pretty early on, but sadly that was lost as the book progressed.
As someone who enjoys learning about history, the historical aspects of the plot, especially anecdotes that readers hadn’t been introduced to before, definitely contributed to my rating of this book. It was easy to get confused quickly, which was a shame because I thought that following John F. Kennedy's journey into the White House had so much potential.
Sadly, I didn't enjoy this one but definitely give it a go if you are experienced with historial fiction.
I received a copy of Their Shadows Deep via Amazon’s First Reads Programme.
January 7, 2025
A decent read that is based during Cuba's early years under Castro and Kennedy running for president. It was a nice read and had extra subplots with names familiar to the Kennedy assassination. It was before the assassination and a somewhat interesting story. The main character didn't seem all that real as a female moving around so easily in the 1950s made me question based on the times. But Golden picked a nice story in an era of interest.
January 14, 2025
My second Kindle First choice of this month.....and I loved it !! I'm a massive JFK buff, whether in fiction or non-fiction or a bit of both, as we have here. It was sooooooo interesting. I read up on the author as he's a new one to me and see he's written in a similar vein before. A couple of others I read books by do the same and I do get a kick (pun intended) out of what might or might not have been said or done.
I'm so pleased he didn't go into all the needless stuff about Cuba and the CIA as I'd have been glazing over. He kept it really interesting and I really liked how he did this.
My only gripe was he capitalised black, in the new PC-for-this-year way authors have started doing, YET he doesn't capitalise French, Danish or Kelly....(which I was always going to spot) !! And let's face it, this book is set in 1960 so it wouldn't have been capitalised full-stop, so I don't think he should have done it. Oh, and he wrote broach not brooch, although I have seen it written thus before and think it was an old-fashioned way of spelling it....
Mentions of Jack's infidelities and of Caitlin's pal Viola I highlighted as a little repetitive but other than these things it was super, just super. One other thing he did was to mention Joe Kennedy pushing Rose Kennedy around in a wheelchair when it really needed to be the other way around. He maybe had his reasons for choosing to do it this way but it's wrong, so he shouldn't have, in my humble opinion !!
I loved the mention of purchasing cigarettes after-hours at a local police station as we used to do that as kids here as well, since it was the only place open with a vending machine a lot of the time....I hadn't thought glue-sniffing was a thing back in the 1950s so googled and was shocked it originated in that decade. I thought it came into being in the 1980s !! The whole new verb for JFK's proclivities, girling, was terrific, too....
There were some very shocking incidents I didn't expect in this that made me gasp and some very heartfelt little passages as well. The ending left me with a truly bittersweet taste.....but it was perfectly done. I'm highly recommending this......I really liked it a great deal.
I'm so pleased he didn't go into all the needless stuff about Cuba and the CIA as I'd have been glazing over. He kept it really interesting and I really liked how he did this.
My only gripe was he capitalised black, in the new PC-for-this-year way authors have started doing, YET he doesn't capitalise French, Danish or Kelly....(which I was always going to spot) !! And let's face it, this book is set in 1960 so it wouldn't have been capitalised full-stop, so I don't think he should have done it. Oh, and he wrote broach not brooch, although I have seen it written thus before and think it was an old-fashioned way of spelling it....
Mentions of Jack's infidelities and of Caitlin's pal Viola I highlighted as a little repetitive but other than these things it was super, just super. One other thing he did was to mention Joe Kennedy pushing Rose Kennedy around in a wheelchair when it really needed to be the other way around. He maybe had his reasons for choosing to do it this way but it's wrong, so he shouldn't have, in my humble opinion !!
I loved the mention of purchasing cigarettes after-hours at a local police station as we used to do that as kids here as well, since it was the only place open with a vending machine a lot of the time....I hadn't thought glue-sniffing was a thing back in the 1950s so googled and was shocked it originated in that decade. I thought it came into being in the 1980s !! The whole new verb for JFK's proclivities, girling, was terrific, too....
There were some very shocking incidents I didn't expect in this that made me gasp and some very heartfelt little passages as well. The ending left me with a truly bittersweet taste.....but it was perfectly done. I'm highly recommending this......I really liked it a great deal.
February 28, 2025
Thank you to Peter Golden, Brilliance Publishing and NetGalley for an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
4 ⭐️! I am a huge lover of all things to do with JFK and the conspiracies surrounding his murder. Getting a different perspective surrounding what his life could have been like before his election to office was so fun to read! It gave us glimpses into his life during the war in which he was injured and how this had a ripple effect on how he was perceived before becoming president as well as glimpses into what his relationship with Jackie may have been like behind closed doors.
The mystery theme of this book was also very intriguing! The combination of these two and how they were woven together was enough to keep me coming back for more not wanting to put this one down.
Highly recommend to anyone who loves the historical fiction genre and/or anything to do with JFK!
4 ⭐️! I am a huge lover of all things to do with JFK and the conspiracies surrounding his murder. Getting a different perspective surrounding what his life could have been like before his election to office was so fun to read! It gave us glimpses into his life during the war in which he was injured and how this had a ripple effect on how he was perceived before becoming president as well as glimpses into what his relationship with Jackie may have been like behind closed doors.
The mystery theme of this book was also very intriguing! The combination of these two and how they were woven together was enough to keep me coming back for more not wanting to put this one down.
Highly recommend to anyone who loves the historical fiction genre and/or anything to do with JFK!
July 22, 2025
A good read from the 1960s
I grew up in this age and although I realize a lot of this book is made up, there is enough factual information that brings back memories, good and bad,of a time when America had hope.
I grew up in this age and although I realize a lot of this book is made up, there is enough factual information that brings back memories, good and bad,of a time when America had hope.
February 3, 2025
This was a pretty good book. I like the characters. Some things were slightly far fetched but still a good book.
February 5, 2025
3.5⭐️ Never read about JFK before so that was an interesting theme and marks another historical fiction complete🤞🏼
March 8, 2025
The CIA. Romance. JFK. The mob. Lots of intense things in this book. Had to text my dad a few times for a US world history refresher. Good, not amazing.
April 13, 2025
A kindle Goodreads giveaway win. I am so glad I won it! A great story about JFK prior to him becoming president and a newspaper reporter who is trying to find out who murdered her husband. JFK knew both of them. A thriller murder mystery full of twists and turns in every chapter, including Cuba and Castro and many other interesting character. So much going on, but not hard to follow.
July 23, 2025
Historical fiction on the road to the presidency of John F. Kennedy. Lots of shockers in there for me at least.
July 27, 2025
What a great book. Mr. Golden can make you believe that he is writing a historical book. But I think this is more historical fiction. It is believable because of our knowledge of JFK. He did seem to be addicted to sex.
Now add to this a secret sex tape, the mafia, and the murders of Catlin's friends. There are many twists and turns that can be confusing, but fear not, it will all come together by the end of the book.
Fun read.
As I have seen from other readers, I am not a paid reviewer nor do I have a vlog, podcast, or website.
Now add to this a secret sex tape, the mafia, and the murders of Catlin's friends. There are many twists and turns that can be confusing, but fear not, it will all come together by the end of the book.
Fun read.
As I have seen from other readers, I am not a paid reviewer nor do I have a vlog, podcast, or website.
August 23, 2025
Thought provoking
January 18, 2025
Historical fiction, my favorite genre, is usually a lot of fiction but interspersed with history from a specific era. This book although admittedly mostly from the imagination of the author, does provide insight into John F. Kennedy the Senator and Democratic Presidential nominee in 1960 along with the culture of the Country at that time. I found it very interesting and worth reading. 3.5 stars is a more accurate rating.
Read
January 21, 2025This was a great historical fiction read. Based on true events this book spins a tale of deceit and mystery as you find the killer hiding in plain sight.
January 16, 2025
Boring. Took me 3 days to get thru 20 % and I have no interest in finishing this
January 5, 2025
Ok
So many minor players, it was difficult to keep them all straight and matched up to the appropriate character's personality. Lots going on in this book, maybe too much...
So many minor players, it was difficult to keep them all straight and matched up to the appropriate character's personality. Lots going on in this book, maybe too much...
February 21, 2025
Peter Golden's latest novel, "Their Shadows Deep," masterfully combines historical fiction with noir mystery elements to create a riveting narrative set against the backdrop of John F. Kennedy's historic 1960 presidential campaign. Following his successful novels "Nothing Is Forgotten," "Wherever There Is Light," and "Comeback Love," Golden once again demonstrates his expertise in weaving together personal narratives with significant historical moments.
Plot and Narrative Structure
The story unfolds through two parallel narratives that eventually intersect in unexpected ways. The first follows Caitlin Russo, a former police officer turned journalist, investigating her CIA operative husband's murder. The second thread traces JFK's presidential campaign as he navigates both public scrutiny and private demons that threaten to derail his political ambitions.
Golden's narrative structure is particularly effective in building tension. The alternating perspectives between Caitlin's investigation and Kennedy's campaign create a rhythm that keeps readers engaged while gradually revealing how these seemingly separate stories connect.
Character Development
Caitlin Russo
The protagonist emerges as one of the novel's greatest strengths. Golden crafts a complex character whose grief and determination drive the narrative forward. As a former cop, Caitlin brings both professional skills and emotional depth to her investigation, making her journey both believable and compelling. Her transformation from grieving widow to determined investigator is masterfully portrayed.
John F. Kennedy
Golden's portrayal of JFK deserves special mention. Rather than settling for a one-dimensional historical figure, the author presents Kennedy as a complicated man struggling with personal demons while maintaining a carefully crafted public image. The internal dialogues between Kennedy and his deceased sister Kick are particularly poignant, offering intimate glimpses into his psyche.
Historical Accuracy and Research
One of the novel's most impressive aspects is Golden's attention to historical detail. His recreation of 1960s America feels authentic, from the political landscape to the social dynamics of the era. The author's extensive research is evident in everything from the description of campaign stops to the intricate details of CIA operations during the Cold War.
Writing Style and Prose
Golden's prose is sharp and evocative, striking a balance between noir-style detective fiction and historical narrative. His dialogue rings true whether it's between political operatives or underworld figures. The author particularly excels in creating atmosphere, whether describing the smoky backrooms of political dealings or the tension-filled streets of Greenwich Village.
Critique and Areas for Improvement
While the novel is largely successful, there are a few areas where it could be stronger:
- The pacing occasionally slows in the middle sections, particularly during some of the political campaign sequences
- Some secondary characters could have been more fully developed
- A few plot threads, particularly regarding international intrigue, might be challenging for readers to follow without some background knowledge of the era
Major Themes
The novel explores several compelling themes:
- The price of power and ambition
- The complex relationship between public image and private reality
- The role of truth and deception in both personal relationships and politics
- The impact of grief and loss on personal identity
- The moral ambiguity of Cold War politics
Notable Elements
Setting and Atmosphere
Golden excels at creating a vivid sense of time and place. His description of 1960s New York, particularly Greenwich Village, is masterfully done. The political atmosphere of the era, with its tensions between Catholics and Protestants, and the looming threat of the Cold War, is expertly captured.
Historical Integration
The way Golden weaves historical figures and events into the narrative deserves special mention. Real historical figures like Allen Dulles, Eleanor Roosevelt, and various political operatives appear naturally within the story, adding authenticity without overwhelming the narrative.
Technical Elements
Structure
The book is divided into four parts, with chapters alternating between Caitlin's investigation and Kennedy's campaign. This structure works effectively to build tension and show how the two narratives gradually converge.
Pacing
The pacing is generally well-managed, though some readers might find the middle section slightly slower. However, the final third of the book moves at a breakneck pace as various plot threads come together.
Impact and Relevance
The novel's themes of political power, personal integrity, and the cost of ambition remain remarkably relevant to contemporary readers. Golden's exploration of how personal lives intersect with historical events offers valuable insights into both past and present.
Conclusion
"Their Shadows Deep" is a remarkable achievement that successfully combines historical fiction with elements of noir mystery. While not without its minor flaws, the novel's strengths far outweigh its weaknesses. Golden's careful attention to historical detail, complex characterization, and skilled plotting create a compelling narrative that will satisfy both history buffs and mystery fans.
Plot and Narrative Structure
The story unfolds through two parallel narratives that eventually intersect in unexpected ways. The first follows Caitlin Russo, a former police officer turned journalist, investigating her CIA operative husband's murder. The second thread traces JFK's presidential campaign as he navigates both public scrutiny and private demons that threaten to derail his political ambitions.
Golden's narrative structure is particularly effective in building tension. The alternating perspectives between Caitlin's investigation and Kennedy's campaign create a rhythm that keeps readers engaged while gradually revealing how these seemingly separate stories connect.
Character Development
Caitlin Russo
The protagonist emerges as one of the novel's greatest strengths. Golden crafts a complex character whose grief and determination drive the narrative forward. As a former cop, Caitlin brings both professional skills and emotional depth to her investigation, making her journey both believable and compelling. Her transformation from grieving widow to determined investigator is masterfully portrayed.
John F. Kennedy
Golden's portrayal of JFK deserves special mention. Rather than settling for a one-dimensional historical figure, the author presents Kennedy as a complicated man struggling with personal demons while maintaining a carefully crafted public image. The internal dialogues between Kennedy and his deceased sister Kick are particularly poignant, offering intimate glimpses into his psyche.
Historical Accuracy and Research
One of the novel's most impressive aspects is Golden's attention to historical detail. His recreation of 1960s America feels authentic, from the political landscape to the social dynamics of the era. The author's extensive research is evident in everything from the description of campaign stops to the intricate details of CIA operations during the Cold War.
Writing Style and Prose
Golden's prose is sharp and evocative, striking a balance between noir-style detective fiction and historical narrative. His dialogue rings true whether it's between political operatives or underworld figures. The author particularly excels in creating atmosphere, whether describing the smoky backrooms of political dealings or the tension-filled streets of Greenwich Village.
Critique and Areas for Improvement
While the novel is largely successful, there are a few areas where it could be stronger:
- The pacing occasionally slows in the middle sections, particularly during some of the political campaign sequences
- Some secondary characters could have been more fully developed
- A few plot threads, particularly regarding international intrigue, might be challenging for readers to follow without some background knowledge of the era
Major Themes
The novel explores several compelling themes:
- The price of power and ambition
- The complex relationship between public image and private reality
- The role of truth and deception in both personal relationships and politics
- The impact of grief and loss on personal identity
- The moral ambiguity of Cold War politics
Notable Elements
Setting and Atmosphere
Golden excels at creating a vivid sense of time and place. His description of 1960s New York, particularly Greenwich Village, is masterfully done. The political atmosphere of the era, with its tensions between Catholics and Protestants, and the looming threat of the Cold War, is expertly captured.
Historical Integration
The way Golden weaves historical figures and events into the narrative deserves special mention. Real historical figures like Allen Dulles, Eleanor Roosevelt, and various political operatives appear naturally within the story, adding authenticity without overwhelming the narrative.
Technical Elements
Structure
The book is divided into four parts, with chapters alternating between Caitlin's investigation and Kennedy's campaign. This structure works effectively to build tension and show how the two narratives gradually converge.
Pacing
The pacing is generally well-managed, though some readers might find the middle section slightly slower. However, the final third of the book moves at a breakneck pace as various plot threads come together.
Impact and Relevance
The novel's themes of political power, personal integrity, and the cost of ambition remain remarkably relevant to contemporary readers. Golden's exploration of how personal lives intersect with historical events offers valuable insights into both past and present.
Conclusion
"Their Shadows Deep" is a remarkable achievement that successfully combines historical fiction with elements of noir mystery. While not without its minor flaws, the novel's strengths far outweigh its weaknesses. Golden's careful attention to historical detail, complex characterization, and skilled plotting create a compelling narrative that will satisfy both history buffs and mystery fans.
February 21, 2025
Golden combines real historical detail with plausible speculation on what might not appear in the record and a firm grasp of character.
Caitlin Russo put her career as a police officer aside to pursue her dream of journalism and—hopefully—motherhood. However, when her husband Gabe is gunned down in the street and the police find no leads, she dusts off her old skills. As evidence mounts that her husband’s job was a CIA cover, it looks more and more like international espionage killed him. However, her husband’s long-standing acquaintance with Senator John F Kennedy, who is just starting his run for the US Presidency, raises the possibility this was domestic politics.
The novel opens in 1960 as Kennedy begins his campaign for his party’s nomination, and features many famous people and events of the time. These portrayals are consistent with public record. However, Golden goes beyond hypothesising private conversations and off-the-record happenings, inventing whole characters and supposing that a plot that officially didn’t happen actually did. Further, the majority of the plot is focused on the life of one of these invented characters. Thus, the novel falls on the side of historical fiction rather than speculative history.
Caitlin’s search for answers after her husband’s death contains a good balance of progress, twists, and obstacles and unfolds plausibly when measured against real world espionage plots and political machinations.
The secondary plot of Kennedy seeking to secure the nomination avoids both excusing Kennedy’s vices in service of the golden idol and wallowing in his mistakes in service of secular iconoclasm; the result is a tale of a man who is great but perhaps not good. Golden is also skilled at picking which moments to narrate in detail, keeping the tension over specifics even though the overall outcome of Kennedy becoming President is well known.
Golden’s starting stitch to tie these two narratives together is a friendship that arose between Kennedy and Gabe while posted to the same place during World War 2. While the harshest of eyes might squint at this being close enough that Caitlin and Gabe are semi-intimates of Kennedy nearly twenty years later yet distant enough not to be part of the historical record, it is a more than plausible enough convenience for what is fiction.
The denouement of the novel draws the various threads to a close in a manner that readers are likely to find both satisfying and consistent with historical record (or rather the absence of the fictional events from historical record). The hopefulness of this victory is given poignancy by the reader’s knowledge that Kennedy will not get two terms to institute his reforms.
Caitlin is a highly sympathetic protagonist, possessed of useful skills without having had a past the conveniently fits her for every challenge she faces. While her intimate connection to the investigation pervades her actions and thoughts, instilling biases and ambivalences, her emotions fuel her investigation rather than diluting it and so they add richness and complexity to her actions.
Golden’s portrayal of famous (and semi-famous) people is balanced, neither reducing them to stereotypes of what is most known about them nor inventing extensive unrecorded nuances merely to avoid it. This smooths away the edges between real and invented characters, making the cast a smooth whole rather than two separate sets.
The invented supporting cast display a depth and internal conflict that both makes them feel like real people and supports the sense of secrets and uncertainty that pervades the plot.
Overall, I enjoyed this novel. I recommend it to readers seeking a political thriller that is based in solid historical detail without being fixated on it.
Caitlin Russo put her career as a police officer aside to pursue her dream of journalism and—hopefully—motherhood. However, when her husband Gabe is gunned down in the street and the police find no leads, she dusts off her old skills. As evidence mounts that her husband’s job was a CIA cover, it looks more and more like international espionage killed him. However, her husband’s long-standing acquaintance with Senator John F Kennedy, who is just starting his run for the US Presidency, raises the possibility this was domestic politics.
The novel opens in 1960 as Kennedy begins his campaign for his party’s nomination, and features many famous people and events of the time. These portrayals are consistent with public record. However, Golden goes beyond hypothesising private conversations and off-the-record happenings, inventing whole characters and supposing that a plot that officially didn’t happen actually did. Further, the majority of the plot is focused on the life of one of these invented characters. Thus, the novel falls on the side of historical fiction rather than speculative history.
Caitlin’s search for answers after her husband’s death contains a good balance of progress, twists, and obstacles and unfolds plausibly when measured against real world espionage plots and political machinations.
The secondary plot of Kennedy seeking to secure the nomination avoids both excusing Kennedy’s vices in service of the golden idol and wallowing in his mistakes in service of secular iconoclasm; the result is a tale of a man who is great but perhaps not good. Golden is also skilled at picking which moments to narrate in detail, keeping the tension over specifics even though the overall outcome of Kennedy becoming President is well known.
Golden’s starting stitch to tie these two narratives together is a friendship that arose between Kennedy and Gabe while posted to the same place during World War 2. While the harshest of eyes might squint at this being close enough that Caitlin and Gabe are semi-intimates of Kennedy nearly twenty years later yet distant enough not to be part of the historical record, it is a more than plausible enough convenience for what is fiction.
The denouement of the novel draws the various threads to a close in a manner that readers are likely to find both satisfying and consistent with historical record (or rather the absence of the fictional events from historical record). The hopefulness of this victory is given poignancy by the reader’s knowledge that Kennedy will not get two terms to institute his reforms.
Caitlin is a highly sympathetic protagonist, possessed of useful skills without having had a past the conveniently fits her for every challenge she faces. While her intimate connection to the investigation pervades her actions and thoughts, instilling biases and ambivalences, her emotions fuel her investigation rather than diluting it and so they add richness and complexity to her actions.
Golden’s portrayal of famous (and semi-famous) people is balanced, neither reducing them to stereotypes of what is most known about them nor inventing extensive unrecorded nuances merely to avoid it. This smooths away the edges between real and invented characters, making the cast a smooth whole rather than two separate sets.
The invented supporting cast display a depth and internal conflict that both makes them feel like real people and supports the sense of secrets and uncertainty that pervades the plot.
Overall, I enjoyed this novel. I recommend it to readers seeking a political thriller that is based in solid historical detail without being fixated on it.
May 29, 2025
Their Shadows Deep should have been the perfect book for my taste. The Kennedy conspiracy theories (about JFK) is the overarching thread of the plot. I’ve been hooked on those since I sat in my 8th grade U.S. History course, watching a film about the Lincoln assassination, and received the news about the motorcade in Dallas. In truth, the mystery as to why certain murders are taking place prove generally satisfying, as well. Yet, Peter Golden inexplicably opted for a female protagonist who is only tangentially inside the loop and who manages to make incredible (in every sense) progress which the professionals are unable to do. The protagonist kept me from being able to suspend my disbelief enough to enjoy Their Shadows Deep as much as I should have.
It is clear that Peter Golden has done his research. His details regarding the period are spot-on (though how much can an 8th-grader at the time objectively remember?). His speculative insights on the inner shadows of the Jack and Jackie Kennedy of our U.S. “Camelot” seem probable. I loved lines such as the conversation where a character says:
“like Jack says, ‘He’s got ideals but no illusions.’” Julian startled the Kennedys by chuckling. ‘Which means he’ll know the right thing to do but won’t do it?’ (p. 38) It also seems right later when he responds to Eleanor Roosevelt’s plea to embrace more idealism with a negative response, saying: “’Because I don’t believe realism is a curse word.’” (p. 255)
Knowing JFK’s penchant for James Bond novels, there is an interesting scene where the would-be president (most of the novel takes place prior to the 1960 election) engages Ian Fleming in light dinner conversation by asking what Fleming would do to remove Fidel Castro’s influence. So, “…with the disdain that Brits had reserved for Americans ever since the Sons of Liberty had dumped their tea into Boston Harbor. Turning to Jack, he said, “I suggest a disinformation campaign. Have your embassy disseminate mock reprints of scientific articles that claim fallout from American atomic testing collects in beards and renders men unable to function sexually. Castro and his gangsters would trample each other to get to their razors and walking around without beards is disgraceful for Cuban revolutionaries.” (p. 95) Yes, it’s humorous in tone, but plausible given Fleming’s idea of his accomplishments in intelligence.
At another point, informed that he was running behind Nixon in the polls, Kennedy responds: “Polls are like fog. Thick before dawn, gone by breakfast.” (p. 249) The line reminded me of Hosea 6:4 where the prophet says that Israel’s faithfulness is as unreliable as the morning dew. And the two lines which effervesced with literary style (IMHO) were: “The lobby was redolent with Broadway’s version of frankincense and myrrh, an indigo haze of tobacco smoke sweetened by Chanel No. 5.” (p.131) and “Usually his dreams are as drab as charcoal sketches, …” (p. 319).
So, there were moments that I enjoyed Their Shadows Deep immensely, but there were just too many times when I was thrown out of my “suspended disbelief” to give it a higher recommendation, It was one of those times when I enjoyed a book, but kept saying, “This could be so much better.”
It is clear that Peter Golden has done his research. His details regarding the period are spot-on (though how much can an 8th-grader at the time objectively remember?). His speculative insights on the inner shadows of the Jack and Jackie Kennedy of our U.S. “Camelot” seem probable. I loved lines such as the conversation where a character says:
“like Jack says, ‘He’s got ideals but no illusions.’” Julian startled the Kennedys by chuckling. ‘Which means he’ll know the right thing to do but won’t do it?’ (p. 38) It also seems right later when he responds to Eleanor Roosevelt’s plea to embrace more idealism with a negative response, saying: “’Because I don’t believe realism is a curse word.’” (p. 255)
Knowing JFK’s penchant for James Bond novels, there is an interesting scene where the would-be president (most of the novel takes place prior to the 1960 election) engages Ian Fleming in light dinner conversation by asking what Fleming would do to remove Fidel Castro’s influence. So, “…with the disdain that Brits had reserved for Americans ever since the Sons of Liberty had dumped their tea into Boston Harbor. Turning to Jack, he said, “I suggest a disinformation campaign. Have your embassy disseminate mock reprints of scientific articles that claim fallout from American atomic testing collects in beards and renders men unable to function sexually. Castro and his gangsters would trample each other to get to their razors and walking around without beards is disgraceful for Cuban revolutionaries.” (p. 95) Yes, it’s humorous in tone, but plausible given Fleming’s idea of his accomplishments in intelligence.
At another point, informed that he was running behind Nixon in the polls, Kennedy responds: “Polls are like fog. Thick before dawn, gone by breakfast.” (p. 249) The line reminded me of Hosea 6:4 where the prophet says that Israel’s faithfulness is as unreliable as the morning dew. And the two lines which effervesced with literary style (IMHO) were: “The lobby was redolent with Broadway’s version of frankincense and myrrh, an indigo haze of tobacco smoke sweetened by Chanel No. 5.” (p.131) and “Usually his dreams are as drab as charcoal sketches, …” (p. 319).
So, there were moments that I enjoyed Their Shadows Deep immensely, but there were just too many times when I was thrown out of my “suspended disbelief” to give it a higher recommendation, It was one of those times when I enjoyed a book, but kept saying, “This could be so much better.”
March 18, 2025
An amazing juxtaposition between historical fiction and the politics and world surrounding JFK!
The novel Their Shadows Deep was an excellent read! I came across this book when selecting a book for Prime First Reads. I was fascinated by the premise of this book: an ex-cop turned journalist is investigating the death of her husband and, along the way, discovers a possible connection to JFK's presidential campaign. I was interested in seeing how an author handles a fictional view of a prominent historical hero. I was pleasantly surprised to discover that Peter Golden did an excellent job of writing a detective story with an exceptionally well-researched and accurate portrayal of the life and times of JFK.
I was a child attending a Catholic elementary school during JFK's run for the presidency. I remember his heroism during the war and the "sanctity" of his presidential campaign espoused by Catholic pulpits nationwide. To a six-year-old Catholic girl, handsome JFK and his gorgeous society debutant wife, Jackie, were Catholic American royalty! It was much later in my college years that I learned that there was a dark side to the JFK legacy. Peter Golden writes this story like an investigative journalist, which his main character, Caitlin, is becoming. The juxtaposition between fiction and the historical world of 1959- 1960s was well-researched and well-written. The fictional JFK, as well as many of the other historical figures in this novel, were accurately aligned with the real people.
Peter Golden's masterful tale transported me back to my early childhood! Peter Golden, obviously, was a citizen of the 60s, as his description of the time setting, events, and politics was close to how I remembered it. He mentions popular plays, music, and books of the time. I was captivated by the references to the pop culture of the '60s, quotes from famous individuals, and events I recognized from newscasts woven into the story.
I was especially impressed with the depth Mr. Golden went into JFK's possible inner world. Peter Gordon extensively detailed JFK's challenge with pain and reaction to numerous medical conditions he suffered through the years. Golden's use of JFK's conversations with the ghosts of Joe and his sister Kick, to illustrate his inner thoughts and relationships with members of his family, was marvelous.
My only complaint was that the pace of opening scenes seemed to drag. It was so slow I almost skipped a few chapters hoping to get to the "meat of the story". Unfortunately, those "set-up chapters were critical to understanding the mystery that the main character, Caitlin was exploring. My advice to readers is be patient, and keep your mind open to information that will be important to solving the mystery later.
Their Shadows Deep was a delight to read, and a well-written detective novel with a thoroughly researched historical background. I am so glad I chose to read this novel.
The novel Their Shadows Deep was an excellent read! I came across this book when selecting a book for Prime First Reads. I was fascinated by the premise of this book: an ex-cop turned journalist is investigating the death of her husband and, along the way, discovers a possible connection to JFK's presidential campaign. I was interested in seeing how an author handles a fictional view of a prominent historical hero. I was pleasantly surprised to discover that Peter Golden did an excellent job of writing a detective story with an exceptionally well-researched and accurate portrayal of the life and times of JFK.
I was a child attending a Catholic elementary school during JFK's run for the presidency. I remember his heroism during the war and the "sanctity" of his presidential campaign espoused by Catholic pulpits nationwide. To a six-year-old Catholic girl, handsome JFK and his gorgeous society debutant wife, Jackie, were Catholic American royalty! It was much later in my college years that I learned that there was a dark side to the JFK legacy. Peter Golden writes this story like an investigative journalist, which his main character, Caitlin, is becoming. The juxtaposition between fiction and the historical world of 1959- 1960s was well-researched and well-written. The fictional JFK, as well as many of the other historical figures in this novel, were accurately aligned with the real people.
Peter Golden's masterful tale transported me back to my early childhood! Peter Golden, obviously, was a citizen of the 60s, as his description of the time setting, events, and politics was close to how I remembered it. He mentions popular plays, music, and books of the time. I was captivated by the references to the pop culture of the '60s, quotes from famous individuals, and events I recognized from newscasts woven into the story.
I was especially impressed with the depth Mr. Golden went into JFK's possible inner world. Peter Gordon extensively detailed JFK's challenge with pain and reaction to numerous medical conditions he suffered through the years. Golden's use of JFK's conversations with the ghosts of Joe and his sister Kick, to illustrate his inner thoughts and relationships with members of his family, was marvelous.
My only complaint was that the pace of opening scenes seemed to drag. It was so slow I almost skipped a few chapters hoping to get to the "meat of the story". Unfortunately, those "set-up chapters were critical to understanding the mystery that the main character, Caitlin was exploring. My advice to readers is be patient, and keep your mind open to information that will be important to solving the mystery later.
Their Shadows Deep was a delight to read, and a well-written detective novel with a thoroughly researched historical background. I am so glad I chose to read this novel.
January 15, 2025
3.5 stars
I enjoyed this book, one of my two Kindle First Reads for January 2025.
Two plots are braided together. One is a thriller involving Russian and Cuban mobsters, New Yorkers, cops, call girls, criminals, writers, and a suspicious "home movie" of JFK and a prostitute.
There's the wife of a young American man mixed up in all this business, . A former cop, she plays a big role in trying to determine who killed her husband, and why.
It's 1960, and JFK is running for president. He knows this young couple. We also get to see his personal life, his inner demons, and the excruciating pain he suffered all his life. While we readers already know the election's outcome, we get to see the inner workings of the campaign, the deals, the lengths people went to to garner votes, and what the politicians thought of each other.
(I was too young to remember the election, but I do remember how large JFK loomed in American life and culture, even after he died.)
Oh, and JFK's deceased brother and sister visit him at a few points, to offer suggestions, support him, and just act like annoying siblings.
The whole crime gang story was a bit complex, and didn't come clear to me till the end. I don't know if that was most readers' experience, or just mine. That said, I much preferred the JFK side of the story. It's clearly fiction, as the author states at the end of the book. It was interesting to read a rendering of life on the inside of politics, especially after having lived through the recent 2024 presidential election. How some things have changed...how so much has not.
So, a fairly entertaining read, and something different for me. Not bad.
I enjoyed this book, one of my two Kindle First Reads for January 2025.
Two plots are braided together. One is a thriller involving Russian and Cuban mobsters, New Yorkers, cops, call girls, criminals, writers, and a suspicious "home movie" of JFK and a prostitute.
There's the wife of a young American man mixed up in all this business, . A former cop, she plays a big role in trying to determine who killed her husband, and why.
It's 1960, and JFK is running for president. He knows this young couple. We also get to see his personal life, his inner demons, and the excruciating pain he suffered all his life. While we readers already know the election's outcome, we get to see the inner workings of the campaign, the deals, the lengths people went to to garner votes, and what the politicians thought of each other.
(I was too young to remember the election, but I do remember how large JFK loomed in American life and culture, even after he died.)
Oh, and JFK's deceased brother and sister visit him at a few points, to offer suggestions, support him, and just act like annoying siblings.
The whole crime gang story was a bit complex, and didn't come clear to me till the end. I don't know if that was most readers' experience, or just mine. That said, I much preferred the JFK side of the story. It's clearly fiction, as the author states at the end of the book. It was interesting to read a rendering of life on the inside of politics, especially after having lived through the recent 2024 presidential election. How some things have changed...how so much has not.
So, a fairly entertaining read, and something different for me. Not bad.
February 8, 2025
For this and other book reviews, visit www.bargain-sleuth.com
Thanks to NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing and Brilliance Publishing for the digital copy of this book and audiobook; I am leaving this review voluntarily.
As someone who reads anything involving the Kennedys, this selection, which was also an Amazon First Reads selection last month, should have been my first choice. Alas, I had already selected my free read when I read the synopsis o f this book, and luckily got the book and audiobook from NetGalley.
I’m a big fan of different POV for books when done well. However, I felt that in the case of Their Shadows Deep, the constant switching back and forth between Cait and John Kennedy made this a more disjointed story. I definitely was interested in the Kennedy aspect of the book, and I was also interested in the Cait parts, but it really didn’t feel like they went together, even though Cait and Jack crossed paths early in the book. It made for a disjointed story and one that I couldn’t fully embrace despite my interest in both stories.
There are some tidbits about JFK in the book that I hadn’t heard of before despite my reading of many biographies. I appreciated the author’s end notes citing the sources he used. I will definitely be doing my own research into some of the events that occurred throughout this book. And the story is good, I just felt that Cait’s life trajectory was a bit implausible in 1960.
The narrator, Laura Darrell, did an admirable job of bringing these characters to life. I would definitely listen to more books narrated by her.
This Cold War thriller is a solid three stars for me, but it wasn’t a home run.
Thanks to NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing and Brilliance Publishing for the digital copy of this book and audiobook; I am leaving this review voluntarily.
As someone who reads anything involving the Kennedys, this selection, which was also an Amazon First Reads selection last month, should have been my first choice. Alas, I had already selected my free read when I read the synopsis o f this book, and luckily got the book and audiobook from NetGalley.
I’m a big fan of different POV for books when done well. However, I felt that in the case of Their Shadows Deep, the constant switching back and forth between Cait and John Kennedy made this a more disjointed story. I definitely was interested in the Kennedy aspect of the book, and I was also interested in the Cait parts, but it really didn’t feel like they went together, even though Cait and Jack crossed paths early in the book. It made for a disjointed story and one that I couldn’t fully embrace despite my interest in both stories.
There are some tidbits about JFK in the book that I hadn’t heard of before despite my reading of many biographies. I appreciated the author’s end notes citing the sources he used. I will definitely be doing my own research into some of the events that occurred throughout this book. And the story is good, I just felt that Cait’s life trajectory was a bit implausible in 1960.
The narrator, Laura Darrell, did an admirable job of bringing these characters to life. I would definitely listen to more books narrated by her.
This Cold War thriller is a solid three stars for me, but it wasn’t a home run.
March 3, 2025
This was an Amazon First Reads selection for January 2025.
This wavered between a two- and a three-star book for me. I think a bunch of that is just me... I don't really enjoy reading historical fiction about the Post-WWII era, a lesson I continue to learn the hard way. President Kennedy is a major player in this book, and I just don't feel the mystique or nostalgia for the '50s into 1960 the way that I feel many political junkies do. Dulles, Hoover, McCarthy, MacArthur, whoever whoever whoever... it's just a bunch of people I don't really care to read about in a fiction or nonfiction setting even though I recognize how important and consequential they were. This book has a handful of those characters and I just do not care. I'd rather read books that take place during the war.
Beside that, though, I didn't care about the purely fictional members of the cast. Caitlin was this drop-dead gorgeous ex-police officer who made every man fall in love with her in some capacity. Her husband Gabe's death was the catalyst for the bulk of the plot and I just didn't care enough about their relationship to feel bad for her or to mourn him. They were trying to recover a JFK sex tape. Cuba was involved, somehow. There were lots of characters to keep track of, none of them meaningfully different than the others in personality. The mystery was not enticing. It felt like a chore to read.
I do think that senator Kennedy's conversations with his late sister Kick were worth reading, but they didn't feel natural to the plot. I would not recommend this book because the content wasn't compelling enough to me personally and the writing style and pacing did it zero favors.
This wavered between a two- and a three-star book for me. I think a bunch of that is just me... I don't really enjoy reading historical fiction about the Post-WWII era, a lesson I continue to learn the hard way. President Kennedy is a major player in this book, and I just don't feel the mystique or nostalgia for the '50s into 1960 the way that I feel many political junkies do. Dulles, Hoover, McCarthy, MacArthur, whoever whoever whoever... it's just a bunch of people I don't really care to read about in a fiction or nonfiction setting even though I recognize how important and consequential they were. This book has a handful of those characters and I just do not care. I'd rather read books that take place during the war.
Beside that, though, I didn't care about the purely fictional members of the cast. Caitlin was this drop-dead gorgeous ex-police officer who made every man fall in love with her in some capacity. Her husband Gabe's death was the catalyst for the bulk of the plot and I just didn't care enough about their relationship to feel bad for her or to mourn him. They were trying to recover a JFK sex tape. Cuba was involved, somehow. There were lots of characters to keep track of, none of them meaningfully different than the others in personality. The mystery was not enticing. It felt like a chore to read.
I do think that senator Kennedy's conversations with his late sister Kick were worth reading, but they didn't feel natural to the plot. I would not recommend this book because the content wasn't compelling enough to me personally and the writing style and pacing did it zero favors.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 219 reviews