What do you think?
Rate this book
The Lamplight Murder Mysteries #3
Murder on Hunter's Eve
A werewolf terrorizes the city of Lamplight!
It's the week of Hunter's Eve, a yearly celebration of monsters, ghosts, and things that go bump in the night. But for Huntress Isabeau Agarwal, the event is a stark reminder that in her line of work, there is never a day's rest.
Murders rock the city, and Isabeau is charged with solving them before the killer strikes again. One, a macabre accident during a dangerous magician's trick gone awry. The other, a slain politician, his disfigured body displayed atop Lamplight's most memorable landmark.
The deaths are seemingly unrelated, until Isabeau learns both magician and politician belong to the same mysterious social club filled with powerful paragons of the city, each with their own hidden agendas—each with a reason to kill.
And during it all, a werewolf stalks the streets, bounding from rooftop to rooftop and claiming the lives of innocent citizens. As Isabeau uncovers the city's secrets, complications arise: the monster and the murders may be connected.
The magician. The police chief. The Ethereal Maiden. The professor. The criminal kingpin. The industrialist.
One may be a killer. One may be a werewolf. All are hiding something.
It's the week of Hunter's Eve, a yearly celebration of monsters, ghosts, and things that go bump in the night. But for Huntress Isabeau Agarwal, the event is a stark reminder that in her line of work, there is never a day's rest.
Murders rock the city, and Isabeau is charged with solving them before the killer strikes again. One, a macabre accident during a dangerous magician's trick gone awry. The other, a slain politician, his disfigured body displayed atop Lamplight's most memorable landmark.
The deaths are seemingly unrelated, until Isabeau learns both magician and politician belong to the same mysterious social club filled with powerful paragons of the city, each with their own hidden agendas—each with a reason to kill.
And during it all, a werewolf stalks the streets, bounding from rooftop to rooftop and claiming the lives of innocent citizens. As Isabeau uncovers the city's secrets, complications arise: the monster and the murders may be connected.
The magician. The police chief. The Ethereal Maiden. The professor. The criminal kingpin. The industrialist.
One may be a killer. One may be a werewolf. All are hiding something.
378 pages, Kindle Edition
Published July 11, 2024
76 people are currently reading
540 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 113 reviews
October 6, 2025
Actual rating: 4.85648993215 stars
This has to be one of the most underrated fantasy/steampunk/horror/mystery/take-your-pick series published in recent years.
I mean, the world is a) refreshingly original and b) pretty fantastic. It's not your basic, boring steampunk fare, that's for sure.
The cast of characters is one of the most scrumptious ever. (I think I want to marry Mr Holmes. Or maybe Penny? Then again, Izzie and/or Evie wouldn't be a bad choice either. What the fish, I'll just move to Utah and marry them all!)
It's ALL fun, ALL the time. Non-stop action, tons of surprises, a very entertaining whodunit-type-thingie, and oh bloody shrimping hell, that twist!
Also, we've got HAHAHAHAHAHAHA aplenty. And monsters! Those monsters! I mean, a creature with the body of a well-muscled bat and the enormous head of a snarling dog? I want one for Christmas! (Oh, and by the way, I think we need a Witch's Compendium of Monsters crossover. NOW.)
We've also got dog bowls full of cheap whiskey (always a plus) and lady mutton shunters (don't ask). There is a notable lack of chapter thirteen, but there are crustaceans that clip off human limbs, so YAY! Many-armed men abound, some characters sometimes struggle with the frustrating rabbit within (don't you hate it when that happens?), and there are portable heads (👋 waves at Soulcatcher 👋).
But you know one of the things I loved most about this installment? I learned so many interesting, useful words while reading it! Ostrobogulous is my favorite. I mean, how could you not LOVE a word that describes something unusual, bizarre, risqué, or indecent? Then there's to inveigle (to persuade someone to do something by means of deception or flattery), which I'd never come across before but is something Iunknowingly practiced for many years back in my nefarious crustacean breeding days.
Evie's one-word-a-day novelty calendar is so packed with new, helpful vocab, I'd love to get my hands on it! Who would have thought this book would prove to be such a fantastic source of knowledge? Goes to show that whoever said that fantasy fiction is not valuable reading and a complete waste of a reader's time is completely full of fish.
And on that note:
[Pre-review nonsense]
Oh my shrimp, this was SO GOOD!
➽ Review to come and stuff.
· Book 1: Murder at Spindle Manor ★★★★
· Book 2: Murder on the Lamplight Express ★★★★
This has to be one of the most underrated fantasy/steampunk/horror/mystery/take-your-pick series published in recent years.
I mean, the world is a) refreshingly original and b) pretty fantastic. It's not your basic
The cast of characters is one of the most scrumptious ever. (I think I want to marry Mr Holmes. Or maybe Penny? Then again, Izzie and/or Evie wouldn't be a bad choice either. What the fish, I'll just move to Utah and marry them all!)
It's ALL fun, ALL the time. Non-stop action, tons of surprises, a very entertaining whodunit-type-thingie, and oh bloody shrimping hell, that twist!
Also, we've got HAHAHAHAHAHAHA aplenty. And monsters! Those monsters! I mean, a creature with the body of a well-muscled bat and the enormous head of a snarling dog? I want one for Christmas! (Oh, and by the way, I think we need a Witch's Compendium of Monsters crossover. NOW.)
We've also got dog bowls full of cheap whiskey (always a plus) and lady mutton shunters (don't ask). There is a notable lack of chapter thirteen, but there are crustaceans that clip off human limbs, so YAY! Many-armed men abound, some characters sometimes struggle with the frustrating rabbit within (don't you hate it when that happens?), and there are portable heads (👋 waves at Soulcatcher 👋).
But you know one of the things I loved most about this installment? I learned so many interesting, useful words while reading it! Ostrobogulous is my favorite. I mean, how could you not LOVE a word that describes something unusual, bizarre, risqué, or indecent? Then there's to inveigle (to persuade someone to do something by means of deception or flattery), which I'd never come across before but is something I
Evie's one-word-a-day novelty calendar is so packed with new, helpful vocab, I'd love to get my hands on it! Who would have thought this book would prove to be such a fantastic source of knowledge? Goes to show that whoever said that fantasy fiction is not valuable reading and a complete waste of a reader's time is completely full of fish.
And on that note:
[Pre-review nonsense]
Oh my shrimp, this was SO GOOD!
➽ Review to come and stuff.
· Book 1: Murder at Spindle Manor ★★★★
· Book 2: Murder on the Lamplight Express ★★★★
July 14, 2024
4.5/5
Stang’s The Lamplight Murder Mysteries series is awesome. It remains fun, creative, and full of twists and nods to literary tradition. The story starts with Isabeau and Ivie witnessing the magician act gone wrong. Guillotines are dangerous, you see. And then another dead body appears, this one with slit throat and a note promising tt won’t be the last victim during the week of Hunter’s Eve.
So, if you hoped Izzie and Evie would get a break and a chance to rest, forget about it. No rest for the wicked, as they say, and if you remember the ominous prophecy from the pages of Murder on the Lamplight Express, then you know what to expect.
The investigation reveals two cases tie to the same mysterious social club filled with powerful and rich, including the police chief, criminal kingpin and the wealthy industrialist. And to make things even more interesting, there’s a werewolf on the streets, jumping from building to building, tearing people to pieces.
Contrary to the previous two books set in closed spaces (a manor, and a train respectively), this one is set in the city, and we finally get a larger look at the world of Lamplight. And it’s interesting, with a Victorian vibe, constant bad weather, and technology slowly transforming the society and police work.
The characters are quirky and while Stang isn’t afraid to go hardcore with horror moments, dark humor and heartfelt interactions between protagonists balance it out. Stang writes charming, skillful, and intriguing characters who are easy to like.
The blend of classic mystery and horror tropes with playful tone works well for me. I also enjoyed piecing the puzzles, but failed miserably. Again. Anyway, the pace is brisk but with more slow moments than in two previous books. It made me let my guard down and then, BOOM, the first big twist made me sit up straight. And the things that happen afterwards? Pure awesomeness.
I love this series, and it’s only getting better. With that said, readers who prefer their mysteries unapologetically dark and gritty might find the occasionally light-hearted approach a bit jarring. And while quirky characters add to the story’s charm for me, I recognize other readers may find them over-the-top.
Murder on Hunter’s Eve is a delightful book with humor and a playful tone that sets it apart from more traditional mysteries and horror/murder mystery hybrids. The big reveals set the stage for more exciting (and self-contained) adventures I can’t wait to read! Well done, Mr Stang. Excellent work.
Stang’s The Lamplight Murder Mysteries series is awesome. It remains fun, creative, and full of twists and nods to literary tradition. The story starts with Isabeau and Ivie witnessing the magician act gone wrong. Guillotines are dangerous, you see. And then another dead body appears, this one with slit throat and a note promising tt won’t be the last victim during the week of Hunter’s Eve.
So, if you hoped Izzie and Evie would get a break and a chance to rest, forget about it. No rest for the wicked, as they say, and if you remember the ominous prophecy from the pages of Murder on the Lamplight Express, then you know what to expect.
The investigation reveals two cases tie to the same mysterious social club filled with powerful and rich, including the police chief, criminal kingpin and the wealthy industrialist. And to make things even more interesting, there’s a werewolf on the streets, jumping from building to building, tearing people to pieces.
Contrary to the previous two books set in closed spaces (a manor, and a train respectively), this one is set in the city, and we finally get a larger look at the world of Lamplight. And it’s interesting, with a Victorian vibe, constant bad weather, and technology slowly transforming the society and police work.
The characters are quirky and while Stang isn’t afraid to go hardcore with horror moments, dark humor and heartfelt interactions between protagonists balance it out. Stang writes charming, skillful, and intriguing characters who are easy to like.
The blend of classic mystery and horror tropes with playful tone works well for me. I also enjoyed piecing the puzzles, but failed miserably. Again. Anyway, the pace is brisk but with more slow moments than in two previous books. It made me let my guard down and then, BOOM, the first big twist made me sit up straight. And the things that happen afterwards? Pure awesomeness.
I love this series, and it’s only getting better. With that said, readers who prefer their mysteries unapologetically dark and gritty might find the occasionally light-hearted approach a bit jarring. And while quirky characters add to the story’s charm for me, I recognize other readers may find them over-the-top.
Murder on Hunter’s Eve is a delightful book with humor and a playful tone that sets it apart from more traditional mysteries and horror/murder mystery hybrids. The big reveals set the stage for more exciting (and self-contained) adventures I can’t wait to read! Well done, Mr Stang. Excellent work.
January 1, 2026
Starting the year with a 5 is like doing a line of coke for people who don't do coke
July 18, 2024
Possibly the best of the series! Certainly has the biggest “whoa wtf” moments. The first two acts are the most restrained of the series, feeling like a classic procedural — only to unveil moment after shocking moment in act 3 that changes the trajectory of the entire series.
The mysteries are both straightforward and complex, as Stang excels in dropping red herrings everywhere, yet also once again leaving enough clues and evidence for the reader to put it together themselves. I had some theories realized, but this was the toughest to tie together by a good margin.
I imagine Stang’s plotting process akin to that Always Sunny Charlie .GIF where he’s standing in front of a cork board, connecting dozens of items with yarn, looking anxious and half-mad.
Similar to the previous entries, I recommend going into this one blind. It’s notable that the setting is much larger than the previous one-location Lamplight books, and the story takes advantage by furthering the lore, history, and various oddities in the city and beyond.
This is an incredibly fun, engaging, and rewarding series, combining supernatural gas lamp mysteries with humor and horror. Highly recommended.
The mysteries are both straightforward and complex, as Stang excels in dropping red herrings everywhere, yet also once again leaving enough clues and evidence for the reader to put it together themselves. I had some theories realized, but this was the toughest to tie together by a good margin.
I imagine Stang’s plotting process akin to that Always Sunny Charlie .GIF where he’s standing in front of a cork board, connecting dozens of items with yarn, looking anxious and half-mad.
Similar to the previous entries, I recommend going into this one blind. It’s notable that the setting is much larger than the previous one-location Lamplight books, and the story takes advantage by furthering the lore, history, and various oddities in the city and beyond.
This is an incredibly fun, engaging, and rewarding series, combining supernatural gas lamp mysteries with humor and horror. Highly recommended.
February 8, 2025
Czy przeczytałam 70% książki za jednym posiedzeniem? Tak!
Ten tom w odróżnieniu od pozostałych już od samego początku rzuca nas w wir śledztwa, a pod koniec drugiego rozdziału mamy już dwa morderstwa a nie jedno do rozwiązania. Nie zapominajmy też o przerażającym wilkołaku zastraszającym miasto!
Świetna lektura dla uważnego czytelnika, gdzie wszystkie informacje mamy podane przez autorkę i razem z Izzie i Evie możemy rozwiązywać zagadkę. Mnóstwo podejrzanych, zwroty akcji, intrygująca zagadka, jedyny w swoim rodzaju świat - w tej książce nie brakuje niczego! I nie zapominajmy o potworach w tym świecie, które są naprawdę przerażające! Zdecydowanie polecam całą serię i czekam na więcej!
Make monsters scary again! 👹🤌
August 23, 2024
Murder at Spindle Manor ★★★★
Murder on the Lamplight Express ★★★★ 1/2
Murder on Hunter's Eve ★★★★ 1/2
It’s funny how a series I never had much interest in has become one of my most eagerly awaited reads of the year! This latest entry was a bit different from the others, but it still delivered in a big way. Stang continues to excel in keeping the series fresh and engaging.
The book kicks off with a magical performance, providing our heroes a break from their usual murder investigations. After a period without any new mysteries, they find themselves inadvertently tangled in two cases that might be linked.
As always, the writing is top-notch. If you enjoyed the previous installments, this one won’t disappoint. The familiar formula of short chapters is maintained, and the writing balances humor with fantasy, though it also delves into darker territory. The suspense is palpable, keeping you guessing until the very end.
There are two notable changes from the last book. First, Evie takes on a more prominent role in this story, which becomes clear as the plot unfolds. Isabeau, Penny, and Mr. Homes are still around, with Isabeau also playing a key role. New characters are introduced, each a potential suspect, and they add an intriguing dynamic to the story. Familiar faces from previous books make appearances too, which is always a nice touch.
The second major change, acknowledged by the author in the book’s conclusion, is the shift in setting. Unlike the closed environments of earlier books, this one features more open settings. While I wasn’t a fan of this change at first, I grew to appreciate it by the end. It allowed for more world-building, and since the author hints that future books may return to closed settings, I’m not too concerned.
As for the plot, it starts off slow and seems to lack some of the charm of the earlier books, but everything shifts dramatically after a certain chapter—if you’ve read it, you know which one I mean. That chapter sets off a whirlwind of events that make the book nearly impossible to put down.
In summary, while this book diverges from the previous ones, Stang’s gamble pays off spectacularly by the end. With each new book, I’m continually impressed by Stang’s ability to weave everything together. I’m a big fan of the series and eagerly anticipate the next installment(s).
Murder on the Lamplight Express ★★★★ 1/2
Murder on Hunter's Eve ★★★★ 1/2
It’s funny how a series I never had much interest in has become one of my most eagerly awaited reads of the year! This latest entry was a bit different from the others, but it still delivered in a big way. Stang continues to excel in keeping the series fresh and engaging.
The book kicks off with a magical performance, providing our heroes a break from their usual murder investigations. After a period without any new mysteries, they find themselves inadvertently tangled in two cases that might be linked.
As always, the writing is top-notch. If you enjoyed the previous installments, this one won’t disappoint. The familiar formula of short chapters is maintained, and the writing balances humor with fantasy, though it also delves into darker territory. The suspense is palpable, keeping you guessing until the very end.
There are two notable changes from the last book. First, Evie takes on a more prominent role in this story, which becomes clear as the plot unfolds. Isabeau, Penny, and Mr. Homes are still around, with Isabeau also playing a key role. New characters are introduced, each a potential suspect, and they add an intriguing dynamic to the story. Familiar faces from previous books make appearances too, which is always a nice touch.
The second major change, acknowledged by the author in the book’s conclusion, is the shift in setting. Unlike the closed environments of earlier books, this one features more open settings. While I wasn’t a fan of this change at first, I grew to appreciate it by the end. It allowed for more world-building, and since the author hints that future books may return to closed settings, I’m not too concerned.
As for the plot, it starts off slow and seems to lack some of the charm of the earlier books, but everything shifts dramatically after a certain chapter—if you’ve read it, you know which one I mean. That chapter sets off a whirlwind of events that make the book nearly impossible to put down.
In summary, while this book diverges from the previous ones, Stang’s gamble pays off spectacularly by the end. With each new book, I’m continually impressed by Stang’s ability to weave everything together. I’m a big fan of the series and eagerly anticipate the next installment(s).
December 14, 2025
This book made me feel things I haven’t felt from a book in I don’t know how long. Absolutely without a doubt the best entry in this series so far. The way Morgan Stang builds a world needs to be studied. The character work in this series is also insane. The mysteries are so clever and the clues are right in front of your face but somehow completely transparent until they’re pointed out. I laughed out loud, I got chills, my heart was in my throat, I can’t handle how good this series is.
Do yourself a favor and READ IT.
Do yourself a favor and READ IT.
July 15, 2025
4.2/5 ⭐️
Okay this third book really elevated this already enjoyable series for me. The world building was phenomenal, this multi fantastical, supernatural, metropolitan city that the author has built is so complex and interesting. It’s like dipping into a period piece and the future at the same time.
The character development is so much fun and also the relationships the characters are solidifying amongst each other.
I also think the digs at our capitalist societal structure and the self destructive nature of the human race is well done.
I do feel there will be a fourth book and I am excited to carry on this journey. I want to dive into their shadow- esque government more.
Last but not least, the normalized queerness, love me some gay gals. 🤘🏽
Okay this third book really elevated this already enjoyable series for me. The world building was phenomenal, this multi fantastical, supernatural, metropolitan city that the author has built is so complex and interesting. It’s like dipping into a period piece and the future at the same time.
The character development is so much fun and also the relationships the characters are solidifying amongst each other.
I also think the digs at our capitalist societal structure and the self destructive nature of the human race is well done.
I do feel there will be a fourth book and I am excited to carry on this journey. I want to dive into their shadow- esque government more.
Last but not least, the normalized queerness, love me some gay gals. 🤘🏽
July 12, 2024
Yay, Huntress Isabel Arsgwal, her sidekick Evie, living doll Penny and Coachman Homes are back for their 3rd monster murder mystery.
This time we get to see more of the wider world as the setting this time is in the city of Lamplight (like Ye Olde Victorian suburbs but with zepplins in the sky).
A 3 day festival is on for the upcoming Hunter's Eve party but a Werewolf is on the loose terrifying residents. Whilst Hunters are busy hunting it down, a couple of murders occur and it's discovered that the victims have a certain club in common.
Isabel and Co soon learn there may be a connection between the Werewolf and these murders so using all their unique abilities they're determined to find out the who and the why.
Strang has added more background and intrigue to our main players in this installment and I for one can't wait for book 4.
This time we get to see more of the wider world as the setting this time is in the city of Lamplight (like Ye Olde Victorian suburbs but with zepplins in the sky).
A 3 day festival is on for the upcoming Hunter's Eve party but a Werewolf is on the loose terrifying residents. Whilst Hunters are busy hunting it down, a couple of murders occur and it's discovered that the victims have a certain club in common.
Isabel and Co soon learn there may be a connection between the Werewolf and these murders so using all their unique abilities they're determined to find out the who and the why.
Strang has added more background and intrigue to our main players in this installment and I for one can't wait for book 4.
January 9, 2025
Another excellent entry into the Lamplight Mystery series, we see Huntress Isabeau and Warwick Yard Detective Evie take on another case of the paranormal - this one taking place across an entire city, rather than a single manor or train.
There are werewolves, ghosts, and all manner of unnamed horrors (especially in the final quarter, where things take a definite Resident Evil/Bloodborne-esque turn), and the central mystery revolves around two (almost) simultaneous murders.
As with the previous books, I did not piece anything together until Evie or Izzie reveals the puzzle pieces, and everything fit perfectly. I’m always in awe of authors who can write convincing mysteries where you have an “oh of course” revelation rather than feeling like things are too convenient.
There are also some familiar faces and callbacks from the first books and some expansions on the lore from Spindle Manor, which were lovely.
Penny and Mr Homes are back, providing much needed support to our duo as they have an ever more threatening suspect list to work through.
Throughout this book there is growing threat, like a lengthening shadow, nipping at the heels of our principle characters. It keeps the pacing ticking along at a healthy speed while also giving a few pauses to breathe and think.
A brilliant series if you want a victorian-esque murder mystery that isn’t afraid to tap into the horrors lurking in the shadows.
There are werewolves, ghosts, and all manner of unnamed horrors (especially in the final quarter, where things take a definite Resident Evil/Bloodborne-esque turn), and the central mystery revolves around two (almost) simultaneous murders.
As with the previous books, I did not piece anything together until Evie or Izzie reveals the puzzle pieces, and everything fit perfectly. I’m always in awe of authors who can write convincing mysteries where you have an “oh of course” revelation rather than feeling like things are too convenient.
There are also some familiar faces and callbacks from the first books and some expansions on the lore from Spindle Manor, which were lovely.
Penny and Mr Homes are back, providing much needed support to our duo as they have an ever more threatening suspect list to work through.
Throughout this book there is growing threat, like a lengthening shadow, nipping at the heels of our principle characters. It keeps the pacing ticking along at a healthy speed while also giving a few pauses to breathe and think.
A brilliant series if you want a victorian-esque murder mystery that isn’t afraid to tap into the horrors lurking in the shadows.
July 22, 2025
8.5 / 10
With Murder on Hunter's Eve, the 3rd book in the Lamplight Murder mysteries, Morgan Stang hit the hat-trick with another amazingly fun and super enjoyable book!
I suppose that since you're reading a review for the 3rd book, no introduction is needed for the style of the book nor its main characters. The steampunk fantasy mystery thriller setting works perfectly for our main duo of Hunter & Detective (plus their two crazy sidekicks!).
Truth be told, I was initially hesitant to pick up this book. The reason? The more open-world setting (a whole city this time) that was in contrast to the two previous books that took place entirely in a tightly closed location. I wasn't sure if it would work. You see, it's way much easier for a closed location to have a strong "character" and flavor than a whole city. Instead, we are treated to a much wider cast of secondary characters, a faster pace and more importantly much more unpredictability! Plot reveals and twists come a-plenty and a lot of crazy things happen when least expected. Sometimes they even border to incredulous... but (and here's the thing) it's not a problem because the whole setting, style and history allows and promotes a high level of suspension of disbelief. This is not a historically accurate book, it's not a serious or grim fantasy. Adjusting expectations is the key here.
In summary, if you liked the previous two books, you are going to love this one. Much deeper and more diverse characters, an insane plot, lots of enjoyable scenes and a fast pace that's easy to read make this an easy recommendation! Thank you Morgan Stand, and please, bring on the next one soon please!
8.5 / 10
With Murder on Hunter's Eve, the 3rd book in the Lamplight Murder mysteries, Morgan Stang hit the hat-trick with another amazingly fun and super enjoyable book!
I suppose that since you're reading a review for the 3rd book, no introduction is needed for the style of the book nor its main characters. The steampunk fantasy mystery thriller setting works perfectly for our main duo of Hunter & Detective (plus their two crazy sidekicks!).
Truth be told, I was initially hesitant to pick up this book. The reason? The more open-world setting (a whole city this time) that was in contrast to the two previous books that took place entirely in a tightly closed location. I wasn't sure if it would work. You see, it's way much easier for a closed location to have a strong "character" and flavor than a whole city. Instead, we are treated to a much wider cast of secondary characters, a faster pace and more importantly much more unpredictability! Plot reveals and twists come a-plenty and a lot of crazy things happen when least expected. Sometimes they even border to incredulous... but (and here's the thing) it's not a problem because the whole setting, style and history allows and promotes a high level of suspension of disbelief. This is not a historically accurate book, it's not a serious or grim fantasy. Adjusting expectations is the key here.
In summary, if you liked the previous two books, you are going to love this one. Much deeper and more diverse characters, an insane plot, lots of enjoyable scenes and a fast pace that's easy to read make this an easy recommendation! Thank you Morgan Stand, and please, bring on the next one soon please!
8.5 / 10
November 1, 2025
I don't even know what to say, except that this was amazing and I need book 4 NOW, please!
June 11, 2025
4.5 stars rounded up. I enjoy the heck out of the detecting exploits of Izzy and Evie. I must admit to a bit a waning enthusiasm as I started this third book though. The first two books were locked room mysteries (a personal favorite of mine) and the beginning of this book seemed to meander all around the city of Lamplight as the two detectives stacked up bodies and mysteries everywhere they stopped. I was curious but not 100 percent focused. Then, BAM. I could not put this book down. Somewhere around the 50 percent mark the story really took off and I was locked in. I quit being productive for the rest of the day because I had to know all the answers. I did figure out a couple things before the big reveal at the end but there were still surprises enough to make the end really satisfying and thrilling. The characters are growing — in their friendship, their backstories, and their skills at crime fighting. Plus, Mr. Homes regularly makes me laugh out loud. I look forward to more episodes. I will keep buying them.
August 4, 2024
4.5 stars
April 5, 2025
This brings some changes to the series. It has left behinds it's svelte roots -- the first book was 250 pages -- becoming yet another 400 page fantasy book, which is a bit disappointing. We've also left behind the confined spaces of hotels and trains; this one sprawls across an entire city offering a bit broader perspective on the world. We (finally) get a bit more of Evie, which was a welcome change. The resolution relied on a complete coincidence -- -- and I felt like this time were just a few too many moving parts.
These remain enjoyable, there are glimmers that Izzie will thaw slightly as a character -- her one-note standoffishness had worn a bit thing after three books of being surrounded by people who care for her and help her -- and these remain enjoyable-for-what-they-are so I'll probably pick up the next book as well.
Though I'd rather see the author return to the tighter plotted 250-page count style of the original book.
These remain enjoyable, there are glimmers that Izzie will thaw slightly as a character -- her one-note standoffishness had worn a bit thing after three books of being surrounded by people who care for her and help her -- and these remain enjoyable-for-what-they-are so I'll probably pick up the next book as well.
Though I'd rather see the author return to the tighter plotted 250-page count style of the original book.
July 21, 2024
July is absolutely crushing it with a top-tier TBR. This is one of the best sequels I've ever read, and it's also in the running for book of the year.
Where the previous two installments are focused on mysteries within closed circles and confined spaces, Murder on Hunter's Eve is a city-wide romp that adds some much appreciated depth to the world at large. I think it did a beautiful job weaving existing characters and plot threads into a much, much larger story, all while setting up infinite possibilities for future books. There are a few plot 'holes,' but given the author's ability to either tie up loose ends or make some incredibly fourth-wall-breaking jokes about them, I have full faith that everything will eventually be answered in a satisfying way.
I've said before that I'm a prime candidate for mystery plotlines, because I'm so easily misled, but that isn't the only reason I love this series so far. The plot doesn't come at the expense of entertaining and complex characters. The humor is blatant, but is balanced perfectly by a bleak and melancholy atmosphere. There are elements of horror, sci-fi, fantasy, romance, and mystery; yet none of them really overpower the others.
Usually my reviews are pretty heavy on critiques, and I'm sure I could come up with some if I really tried, but as of right now I have no complaints. I will be anxiously looking out for future additions to this series.
Where the previous two installments are focused on mysteries within closed circles and confined spaces, Murder on Hunter's Eve is a city-wide romp that adds some much appreciated depth to the world at large. I think it did a beautiful job weaving existing characters and plot threads into a much, much larger story, all while setting up infinite possibilities for future books. There are a few plot 'holes,' but given the author's ability to either tie up loose ends or make some incredibly fourth-wall-breaking jokes about them, I have full faith that everything will eventually be answered in a satisfying way.
I've said before that I'm a prime candidate for mystery plotlines, because I'm so easily misled, but that isn't the only reason I love this series so far. The plot doesn't come at the expense of entertaining and complex characters. The humor is blatant, but is balanced perfectly by a bleak and melancholy atmosphere. There are elements of horror, sci-fi, fantasy, romance, and mystery; yet none of them really overpower the others.
Usually my reviews are pretty heavy on critiques, and I'm sure I could come up with some if I really tried, but as of right now I have no complaints. I will be anxiously looking out for future additions to this series.
October 25, 2024
4.5/5
Man this series is just delightful. I have loved all the three books in the series. Isabeau and Evie and Penny are all just amazing, and I think Evie is the MVP of this book. This is as much her book as Isabeau's. Unlike the previous two books, this one happens in the lamplight city itself, not just a closed place. But the change didn't really affect the quality much and lamplight felt just as much as a character as the rest of the two locations. There are many plots to untangle here and it was a delight to read them. There's also several moments where I was just laughing out loud.
I think the first 75% or so of the book is 5/5. Its just a standard procedural set in a fantasy city, but it is so delightful I don't really need anything more. The remaning 25% I think is a bit inconsistent. It does end well, but also it has some plot conveniences and some things that could have been given more breathing roo, The ending wasn't bad, it just wasn't as good as the rest of the book.
Really, really need the next book ASAP.
Man this series is just delightful. I have loved all the three books in the series. Isabeau and Evie and Penny are all just amazing, and I think Evie is the MVP of this book. This is as much her book as Isabeau's. Unlike the previous two books, this one happens in the lamplight city itself, not just a closed place. But the change didn't really affect the quality much and lamplight felt just as much as a character as the rest of the two locations. There are many plots to untangle here and it was a delight to read them. There's also several moments where I was just laughing out loud.
I think the first 75% or so of the book is 5/5. Its just a standard procedural set in a fantasy city, but it is so delightful I don't really need anything more. The remaning 25% I think is a bit inconsistent. It does end well, but also it has some plot conveniences and some things that could have been given more breathing roo, The ending wasn't bad, it just wasn't as good as the rest of the book.
Really, really need the next book ASAP.
July 13, 2024
Another fabulous book in my favorite new series! This one is a little different than usual since it takes place in the city of Lamplight as opposed to a closed setting. I was a little worried about the change in formula, but I shouldn't have been. It was actually quite nice getting to know the city. As always, the plot was intriguing and all the reveals to the mysteries were utterly brilliant. My jaw dropped multiple times! There was one huge twist I'm not quite sure how I feel about though. It was nice to see previous characters make an appearance again and, of course, Penny is an absolute treasure. There is a bit of a cliffhanger at the end, and I can't wait to find out what happens next! Hopefully we don't have to wait too long for the next one!
If you are new to this series, don't start with this book because it would spoil the first two. Definitely read them in order!
If you are new to this series, don't start with this book because it would spoil the first two. Definitely read them in order!
September 4, 2024
Once again, Morgan Stang has crushed it. My favorite author and favorite series. I honestly felt so many emotions reading this and at one point had to set my kindle down and cry for a second. I hope there are more to this series and I can’t wait to see more books in general from this author. I hope one day there’s merch from them too 👀 🫶🏻
July 31, 2024
The latest story in the Lamplight Murder Mysteries really amped the volume! Our regular cast of characters are back (that's Isabeau, Evie , Penny and Mr. Homes) plus a few from previous books and some new faces! We got lots of new locations around Lamplight which I adored. It made the scope of the world bigger and had greater depth.
I love the authors writing style, the witty banter and how I never know 'who done it' till the end! You just can't guess at the intricacies of the mystery while you're in it.
Two words - CHAPTER 35! That is all.
I love the authors writing style, the witty banter and how I never know 'who done it' till the end! You just can't guess at the intricacies of the mystery while you're in it.
Two words - CHAPTER 35! That is all.
July 17, 2024
Easier to read on Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/Fantasy/comm...
Note:
This review is long, jump to where you want, I'm not Waxwick Yard.
Blog Post:
It's been 82 years...
r/Fantasy - Review: "Murder on Hunter's Eve" by Morgan Stang | That Werewolf Needs a Bigger Brush
_________________________________________
Spoiler-Free Summary:
A werewolf is seen on the streets of Lamplight. Our intrepid quartet team is on the job to catch the elusive werewolf and bring peace to the citizens.
Side effects include dark humor and thunder.
_________________________________________
Characters and Terms:
Isabeau: The MC of our story. Hunts monsters for a living.
Evie: A detective for Waxwick Yard (the equivalent of Scotland Yard)
Penny: A living doll that cannot express emotions and is undead until she cuts through her mouth and releases her soul and truly dies. What a lovely character!
Mr. Homes: A significantly better Sherlock Holmes/Herlock Sholmes that I would die for him in a heartbeat. But also not a detective but a carriage driver for our team.
_________________________________________
Real Thoughts:
I won’t lie.
I was 100% going to bash this book to high heaven and back.
Why?
The dude has multiple Golden Stick Awards (TM) and I wanted to see if he really deserved a nomination this year.
I was prepared to go into this book being jaded and feeling like it won’t meet my expectations.
I wanted to knock him down a peg because he might have Sequel Syndrome.
...He still drop kicked me to tell me he did deserve a spot, the book did meet my lofty expectations, and I meekly told him “Good day” before trying to lecture him about Sequel Syndrome.
(Based on a False Story)
As you may or may not know, this is the 3rd book in the Lamplight Murders series and it changes the structure and pace compared to the first two books. Because of that, I was like, “Why is it so slow and meandering?”
Yeah, I’ll tell you why.
Do not mistake the slow start and different pacing. Let’s just say:
I started yesterday morning at 10% of the book done.
It was 5 AM when I finished it today.
Stang somehow maintained my attention and finished the book in 2 days flat, 1 hour of sleep be damned.
The problem with the first two books I felt I predicted a LOT of what would happen so the plot wasn’t the best part for me, but the vibes and worldbuilding were the stars.
However, that is not the case with book 3. Nearly everything is a star. Worldbuilding, plot is unpredictable, prose, you name it. If you had problems with Stang’s work before, he somehow fixed it and smelted it into mithril.
One thing he did differently in this book is the setting is no longer a closed environment. At first I wasn’t crazy about it, but, by doing it this way, we see a lot of the world than in the previous books. He talks a little more about this in his author’s notes but yeah, I would be welcoming to the idea of more open environments if I get this much worldbuilding, fuck yes.
To say Stang did better than the previous books is an understatement. He shoved them down a sinkhole and proclaimed “Hunter’s Eve” as his new best friend on a pedestal.
Hello, “Hunter’s Eve,” my friendship with “Lamplight Express” is over.
_________________
Cover:
r/Fantasy - Review: "Murder on Hunter's Eve" by Morgan Stang | That Werewolf Needs a Bigger Brush
Elegant, but simple pattern of leaves and flowers, and reds and blacks. A similar coloring pattern can be found in his previous books.
_________________________________________
Prose:
A good prose should not jolt you out of the illusion that you are reading. Rather, it will streamline the words into your head where you forget you're even reading.
"Hunter's Eve" solves the problems of past books and improved immensely.
I want to say, at 5 AM reading this book, I may not be the best judge of this, but put an ill placed comma in between run on sentences and I just might go meditate in a bath of vinegar communing the spirits.
_________________________________________
Pacing:
Slow in the beginning, picks it up at XX%.
I'm not going to spoil the fun when you figure it out!
_________________________________________
Plot:
Without spoiling what will happen, the main premise is a werewolf on the loose and at least 3 people have already died.
As in regards of twists for a murder mystery...somehow Stang out does himself and makes it so unpredictable that a cynic like me would be surprised.
Go into it with the mindset of Isabeau, go out crying like Evie.
_________________________________________
Characters:
I do hope Stang does keep this page count as it does help balance the lack of worldbuilding and character development that we had problems in the previous books.
The characters are way fleshed out more, even the murder suspects, MCs, worldbuilding, nearly everything. For example, we get more info on Evie, not just her being a peppy character, but she's more than that. She's curious, actually gives a fuck, and can be seen walking around with a book if you just give her a chance, BRITTNEY.
Isabeau is...well, Isabeau, but we get more information on her backstory, how she was like as a kid and such.
So Stang, thank you for giving us more pages to explore these characters!
(SPOILER)
I'm just mad I have to wait probably like 5 books for Isabeau/Evie ship to set sail after the Annabel sunk faster than my future. I'm not a ship bitch, but the way Stang doesn't hyper focus on the romance and just leaves crumbs make it so refreshingly organic in development of feelings and relationship....Instead of "insta hump" in Study of Drowning...eugh.
_______________________
Vibe:
Think fantasy London, with fog and gaslamp.
Oh and a giant werewolf. Now with more thunder!
_________________________________________
Worldbuilding:
Thank Lady Constellation, we get more worldbuilding. Though it's more about Lamplight itself and the urban districts, but still, it's something. Hell, if Lady Constellation told me what she does in her free time, I'd be happy about that too.
But, we actually get FULL PAGES of a book about werewolves. You read this right.
ACTUAL PAGES OF A FAKE BOOK INSIDE A FANTASY BOOK.
Do you understand how long I've been waiting for an author to go past more than 1-2 pages on a fictional book?
Fuck, I haven't read many fantasy books about books that actually put pages of a fictional book in their novel. Baldree is the only other author I know that does at least a snippet of fictional books I'll never read in this dimension. (I still need to read "Library of the Unwritten" and "Ink and Bone" but still...)
That aside, our worldbuilding expands into info about werewolves, some info about the Ravaged Continent, the past, a little about philosophy of what happened in the past (oddly refreshing), and the urban underbelly of Lamplight. We also get a legend.
Though we don't get more info about other monsters, the Ravaged Continent, or the Nobles this time around, can't complain too much when the previous 2 books barely gave me a crumb to go off of. I'll take what I get.
_________________________________________
If you're on the fence whether to dive into Book 3, because Book 1 & 2 are so vastly different, I get it, but please, make the leap and get the book.
Yes, it's a little slow, but you will be rewarded with a ride I don't think anyone would have anticipated.
Well done, Stang. You made me fear of my own neck and fear snails again.
_________________________________________
Who should read this?
Read because this book is more satisfying to read than that $30 hardback book at B&N.
That book is probably shit, this book is $4 and has a living doll girl, murder, blood, and 100% less Twilight.
Ez.
Personal Rating:
5/5
Golden Stick Update:
As of writing this, I now have 4 unofficial nominees for Book of the Year for the Golden Stick Awards (TM)
This can (and most likely will) change at some point, but thought to give y'all an update.
Here are the nominees for the Book of the Year as of July:
r/Fantasy - Review: "Murder on Hunter's Eve" by Morgan Stang | That Werewolf Needs a Bigger Brush
None of it's in order of best to worse or vice versa.
Strange Beasts of China by Yan Ge
The Entire Witcher Series by Andrzej Sapkowski
Murder on Hunter's Eve by Morgan Stang
The Spear Cuts Through Water by Simon Jimenez
Don't expect this to be the final count but, this is what we have so far and no matter if I get more nominees or not, it will be extremely difficult to pick Book of the Year.
Note:
This review is long, jump to where you want, I'm not Waxwick Yard.
Blog Post:
It's been 82 years...
r/Fantasy - Review: "Murder on Hunter's Eve" by Morgan Stang | That Werewolf Needs a Bigger Brush
_________________________________________
Spoiler-Free Summary:
A werewolf is seen on the streets of Lamplight. Our intrepid quartet team is on the job to catch the elusive werewolf and bring peace to the citizens.
Side effects include dark humor and thunder.
_________________________________________
Characters and Terms:
Isabeau: The MC of our story. Hunts monsters for a living.
Evie: A detective for Waxwick Yard (the equivalent of Scotland Yard)
Penny: A living doll that cannot express emotions and is undead until she cuts through her mouth and releases her soul and truly dies. What a lovely character!
Mr. Homes: A significantly better Sherlock Holmes/Herlock Sholmes that I would die for him in a heartbeat. But also not a detective but a carriage driver for our team.
_________________________________________
Real Thoughts:
I won’t lie.
I was 100% going to bash this book to high heaven and back.
Why?
The dude has multiple Golden Stick Awards (TM) and I wanted to see if he really deserved a nomination this year.
I was prepared to go into this book being jaded and feeling like it won’t meet my expectations.
I wanted to knock him down a peg because he might have Sequel Syndrome.
...He still drop kicked me to tell me he did deserve a spot, the book did meet my lofty expectations, and I meekly told him “Good day” before trying to lecture him about Sequel Syndrome.
(Based on a False Story)
As you may or may not know, this is the 3rd book in the Lamplight Murders series and it changes the structure and pace compared to the first two books. Because of that, I was like, “Why is it so slow and meandering?”
Yeah, I’ll tell you why.
Do not mistake the slow start and different pacing. Let’s just say:
I started yesterday morning at 10% of the book done.
It was 5 AM when I finished it today.
Stang somehow maintained my attention and finished the book in 2 days flat, 1 hour of sleep be damned.
The problem with the first two books I felt I predicted a LOT of what would happen so the plot wasn’t the best part for me, but the vibes and worldbuilding were the stars.
However, that is not the case with book 3. Nearly everything is a star. Worldbuilding, plot is unpredictable, prose, you name it. If you had problems with Stang’s work before, he somehow fixed it and smelted it into mithril.
One thing he did differently in this book is the setting is no longer a closed environment. At first I wasn’t crazy about it, but, by doing it this way, we see a lot of the world than in the previous books. He talks a little more about this in his author’s notes but yeah, I would be welcoming to the idea of more open environments if I get this much worldbuilding, fuck yes.
To say Stang did better than the previous books is an understatement. He shoved them down a sinkhole and proclaimed “Hunter’s Eve” as his new best friend on a pedestal.
Hello, “Hunter’s Eve,” my friendship with “Lamplight Express” is over.
_________________
Cover:
r/Fantasy - Review: "Murder on Hunter's Eve" by Morgan Stang | That Werewolf Needs a Bigger Brush
Elegant, but simple pattern of leaves and flowers, and reds and blacks. A similar coloring pattern can be found in his previous books.
_________________________________________
Prose:
A good prose should not jolt you out of the illusion that you are reading. Rather, it will streamline the words into your head where you forget you're even reading.
"Hunter's Eve" solves the problems of past books and improved immensely.
I want to say, at 5 AM reading this book, I may not be the best judge of this, but put an ill placed comma in between run on sentences and I just might go meditate in a bath of vinegar communing the spirits.
_________________________________________
Pacing:
Slow in the beginning, picks it up at XX%.
I'm not going to spoil the fun when you figure it out!
_________________________________________
Plot:
Without spoiling what will happen, the main premise is a werewolf on the loose and at least 3 people have already died.
As in regards of twists for a murder mystery...somehow Stang out does himself and makes it so unpredictable that a cynic like me would be surprised.
Go into it with the mindset of Isabeau, go out crying like Evie.
_________________________________________
Characters:
I do hope Stang does keep this page count as it does help balance the lack of worldbuilding and character development that we had problems in the previous books.
The characters are way fleshed out more, even the murder suspects, MCs, worldbuilding, nearly everything. For example, we get more info on Evie, not just her being a peppy character, but she's more than that. She's curious, actually gives a fuck, and can be seen walking around with a book if you just give her a chance, BRITTNEY.
Isabeau is...well, Isabeau, but we get more information on her backstory, how she was like as a kid and such.
So Stang, thank you for giving us more pages to explore these characters!
(SPOILER)
I'm just mad I have to wait probably like 5 books for Isabeau/Evie ship to set sail after the Annabel sunk faster than my future. I'm not a ship bitch, but the way Stang doesn't hyper focus on the romance and just leaves crumbs make it so refreshingly organic in development of feelings and relationship....Instead of "insta hump" in Study of Drowning...eugh.
_______________________
Vibe:
Think fantasy London, with fog and gaslamp.
Oh and a giant werewolf. Now with more thunder!
_________________________________________
Worldbuilding:
Thank Lady Constellation, we get more worldbuilding. Though it's more about Lamplight itself and the urban districts, but still, it's something. Hell, if Lady Constellation told me what she does in her free time, I'd be happy about that too.
But, we actually get FULL PAGES of a book about werewolves. You read this right.
ACTUAL PAGES OF A FAKE BOOK INSIDE A FANTASY BOOK.
Do you understand how long I've been waiting for an author to go past more than 1-2 pages on a fictional book?
Fuck, I haven't read many fantasy books about books that actually put pages of a fictional book in their novel. Baldree is the only other author I know that does at least a snippet of fictional books I'll never read in this dimension. (I still need to read "Library of the Unwritten" and "Ink and Bone" but still...)
That aside, our worldbuilding expands into info about werewolves, some info about the Ravaged Continent, the past, a little about philosophy of what happened in the past (oddly refreshing), and the urban underbelly of Lamplight. We also get a legend.
Though we don't get more info about other monsters, the Ravaged Continent, or the Nobles this time around, can't complain too much when the previous 2 books barely gave me a crumb to go off of. I'll take what I get.
_________________________________________
If you're on the fence whether to dive into Book 3, because Book 1 & 2 are so vastly different, I get it, but please, make the leap and get the book.
Yes, it's a little slow, but you will be rewarded with a ride I don't think anyone would have anticipated.
Well done, Stang. You made me fear of my own neck and fear snails again.
_________________________________________
Who should read this?
Read because this book is more satisfying to read than that $30 hardback book at B&N.
That book is probably shit, this book is $4 and has a living doll girl, murder, blood, and 100% less Twilight.
Ez.
Personal Rating:
5/5
Golden Stick Update:
As of writing this, I now have 4 unofficial nominees for Book of the Year for the Golden Stick Awards (TM)
This can (and most likely will) change at some point, but thought to give y'all an update.
Here are the nominees for the Book of the Year as of July:
r/Fantasy - Review: "Murder on Hunter's Eve" by Morgan Stang | That Werewolf Needs a Bigger Brush
None of it's in order of best to worse or vice versa.
Strange Beasts of China by Yan Ge
The Entire Witcher Series by Andrzej Sapkowski
Murder on Hunter's Eve by Morgan Stang
The Spear Cuts Through Water by Simon Jimenez
Don't expect this to be the final count but, this is what we have so far and no matter if I get more nominees or not, it will be extremely difficult to pick Book of the Year.
July 26, 2024
This book got me out of a reading slump!
So good! Just as enjoyable as the previous two in the series, and I can't wait for the next installment!
So good! Just as enjoyable as the previous two in the series, and I can't wait for the next installment!
December 15, 2024
This is the third in a series of comic murder mysteries in which a monster hunter gets involved in solving murders, along with her partner, a police detective. One difference to the first two books in the series is that while they were set in very confined locations (an inn and an overnight train) this one is set across a city as the protagonists try to investigate a series of linked murders. Meanwhile the city is also obsessed by other killings and chaos caused by a werewolf. There is a lot going on in this book, including a lot more being revealed about the world in which it is set. At times I did think parts of the main mystery did seem a bit too obvious (particularly a homage to a classic work of literature), but then it did bring in some plot developments which surprised me. Overall, I thought it was another entertaining book in the series. The only negative I have is that this is self-published and while I think that writing is good the editing is sometimes lacking, particularly the proof-reading.
July 24, 2024
Mixed feelings
I have mixed feelings over this book, I had to pull myself through it. It is very different writing from the 1st 2 books. This felt more like a book 10 when the writer ran out of stories and had to go in a different direction to keep the series alive.
I have mixed feelings over this book, I had to pull myself through it. It is very different writing from the 1st 2 books. This felt more like a book 10 when the writer ran out of stories and had to go in a different direction to keep the series alive.
July 16, 2024
Fantastic entry in the Lamplight Murder Mysteries series
The third installment of Isabel Agarwal and Evie Turnstall’s adventures working as a Hunter/Detective duo (plus the ever-delightful Penny) in the city of Lamplight was glorious. The steampunk setting with its victorian flair populated by the eldritch and supernatural characters is excellent - I thoroughly enjoy the world-building. The intrigue and twists are top notch, and I did not see several of them coming - which makes the reveals even better. In addition to amazing structure and environment, the characters are richly colored and capable of deep pathos. If you love murder mysteries in the vein of Agatha Christie - if she wielded a sawn-off double barreled shotgun (in addition to an arsenal sufficient to outfit a small militia) and hunted the supernatural - and enjoy steampunk fantasy, you will love this book. I hope Stang continues to write in this universe and will be purchasing each subsequent entry. All the stars, highly recommend.
The third installment of Isabel Agarwal and Evie Turnstall’s adventures working as a Hunter/Detective duo (plus the ever-delightful Penny) in the city of Lamplight was glorious. The steampunk setting with its victorian flair populated by the eldritch and supernatural characters is excellent - I thoroughly enjoy the world-building. The intrigue and twists are top notch, and I did not see several of them coming - which makes the reveals even better. In addition to amazing structure and environment, the characters are richly colored and capable of deep pathos. If you love murder mysteries in the vein of Agatha Christie - if she wielded a sawn-off double barreled shotgun (in addition to an arsenal sufficient to outfit a small militia) and hunted the supernatural - and enjoy steampunk fantasy, you will love this book. I hope Stang continues to write in this universe and will be purchasing each subsequent entry. All the stars, highly recommend.
May 3, 2025
I admit that when I read series, it is rare for me to come across a book that I prefer more than the first. There's nothing like the first y'know? The introduction to the characters, the world, and the tone that made you feel all the things, and while the rest of the series can be great, it rarely lives up to the first moments.
The Lamplight Murder Mysteries has proven that later books can be so much better because this is by far my favorite with the most twists and turns that I didn't see coming when I should have. A major reveal in this book has to do with what happened in the previous and I kept wondering about something, if it would ever be addressed, then BAM. I was left shocked and simply must read more. Gimme 14 of 'em, thanks.
The Lamplight Murder Mysteries has proven that later books can be so much better because this is by far my favorite with the most twists and turns that I didn't see coming when I should have. A major reveal in this book has to do with what happened in the previous and I kept wondering about something, if it would ever be addressed, then BAM. I was left shocked and simply must read more. Gimme 14 of 'em, thanks.
October 21, 2025
Book 3 in the Lamplight Murders series and it was kind of a doozy. I loved this for the bigger world (it is not a closed-circle mystery but instead takes place across the streets of Lamplight), the dark setting and mood perfect for Halloween, and the insane twists Stang has set up for future books. There also seemed to be more vulnerability and depth in following along in the mind of Huntress Agarwal, but the tone is still fun and we get more found-family shenanigans from our recurring characters too.
August 7, 2024
By far the most fun I've had reading a mystery novel.
Murder on Hunter's Eve rehashes the tropes already explored thoroughly by the other Lamplight mysteries. What makes this work more compelling than its predecessors is the depth to which Stang explores character motivations and relationships. We get much more insight into Evie's attitude and mindset and see very clearly the ways Isabeau and her have changed one other. Penny and Mr. Homes have their best moments so far in the series in this book. The humor throughout this story is great. There is also an interesting layering of the plot elements, character choices, antagonist motives, and fantasy elements which reinforce one another in surprising directions.
At the plot level, this book delivers several different conundrums, all of which feel "fair" in the world Stang has developed. The intellectual and puzzle aspects of the story feel compelling -- even if the reader figures out four of the mysteries, it is likely that there will still be meaningful reveals for three more that had escaped the reader's deductions.
Murder on Hunter's Eve rehashes the tropes already explored thoroughly by the other Lamplight mysteries. What makes this work more compelling than its predecessors is the depth to which Stang explores character motivations and relationships. We get much more insight into Evie's attitude and mindset and see very clearly the ways Isabeau and her have changed one other. Penny and Mr. Homes have their best moments so far in the series in this book. The humor throughout this story is great. There is also an interesting layering of the plot elements, character choices, antagonist motives, and fantasy elements which reinforce one another in surprising directions.
At the plot level, this book delivers several different conundrums, all of which feel "fair" in the world Stang has developed. The intellectual and puzzle aspects of the story feel compelling -- even if the reader figures out four of the mysteries, it is likely that there will still be meaningful reveals for three more that had escaped the reader's deductions.
November 30, 2025
4.5 stars
It was a lucky coincident that I happened to line this one up with the Halloween weekend. A very happy happenstance, I must say, because the atmosphere as perfect 👌🏻✨ - especially in the haunted alley. That scene will live with me for quiet a while!
This 3rd book was the best one in the series, so far. I hope there will be many more! 💖
It was a lucky coincident that I happened to line this one up with the Halloween weekend. A very happy happenstance, I must say, because the atmosphere as perfect 👌🏻✨ - especially in the haunted alley. That scene will live with me for quiet a while!
This 3rd book was the best one in the series, so far. I hope there will be many more! 💖
July 13, 2024
Another fun adventure, this time set in the sprawling city of Lamplight. Full of more unexpected twists, turns and shocking revelations. Highly recommend checking out this if you were a fan of the previous two.
Was great to see some recurring characters and nods to previous events as well.
Was great to see some recurring characters and nods to previous events as well.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 113 reviews