Having read this author's "Her Little Flowers" and enjoyed it, I was excited to read another of her novels. I had high hopes for this new book but sadly, I was very disappointed..
A dual timeline ghost story that is set in a spooky Scottish castle. A modern gothic tale. Sounds exactly the type of read I like on chilly autumn nights. However... it was so 'hokey'! I loved the setting. The present day characters were easy to get to know. I loved the whole 'unexpected inheritance' trope. And an isolated Scottish castle on an island steeped in macabre history... what's not to like you might ask.
I like my ghost stories that allude to ghostly presences. Ones that evoke a sense of the supernatural without being overt about it. This book had ghosts galore and they announced themselves from the get-go. Ghostly writing on the walls, men standing over the characters beds at night, ghostly ships sailing on the loch, ghost rats that run on the half hour, evil witches in wells, familial curses. It was just all too much for me.
I preferred the older timeline and my favourite character was Mungo. A severely autistic young man who just happened to be one of the ghosts. He loved to be read to and even Edie and Neve gave into his demands of yet another story.
Present Day: Edwina Nunn is a widow with a fifteen year old daughter. They live in a small house in England. Edwina was a foundling, brought up in an orphanage run by nuns. When she learns that she has inherited a castle in Scotland, she and her daughter Neve travel north to claim their inheritance. Edwina, who is skeptical of ghosts and supernatural phenomenon, seems to embrace them wholeheartedly from the onset of their stay in the castle. Neve, who learns that there is a missing rare and cursed jewel, wants to stay at the castle until she finds it. Edie wants to find out the identity of her parents. In their research in the castle's library, the women learn that all members of Edwina's family who resided there, died on the same date, Samhain, October 31st...
Oh, and then there is Cameron, a microbiologist, staying illegally in the castle in order to carry out his research on the red coloured loch.
Early 1960s: the Maundrell family inhabit the castle. The grandmother, Lady Elizabeth (Bitsie) is an odious old woman who rules her family with an iron fist. She had three children. The eldest, Theo, her favourite, died in the war. The middle child was Alice, who hated her mother with very good reason. The youngest was Jasper who was a keen disappointment to his domineering mother.
Jasper's children were Percy, Charlotte and Mungo. Percy was a homosexual, much to the disgust of his grandmother, who thought it criminal and abnormal. Charlotte seemed to exist solely to look after her elder brother Mungo.
Mungo, born with severe autism, maintained the intellect of a four year old for his entire life. Mungo's grandmother had a doctor deliver ECT (Electroconvulsive Therapy) to Mungo in order to 'cure' him. As I said, she was an evil old b**ch. Sadly, that really did happen to autistic persons in the '60s.
Lady Elizabeth is obsessed with the family jewel, a unique red diamond culled from the diamond mines of South Africa. The diamond, named the Maundrell Red, went missing in 1965 and has never been seen since - not for want of searching.
For the reader who is game to suspend belief for the duration of the read, this novel might satisfy the need for a seasonal, spooky read. For me however, it was just too much. Too many ghosts, too many characters, too slow paced, too farcical and overdone.
If I was the type of reader who DNF a book, then I probably would have abandoned this one. However I soldiered on, hoping against hope for improvement. I struggled to remain invested in the outcome and found myself skimming a few times - that is never a good sign. For those readers who are truly invested in this book, the ending was satisfying.
I cannot in good conscience recommend this novel, though reading tastes are subjective and many readers have really enjoyed it. If you want to support this author, you should read her debut novel "Her Little Flowers". Still a spooky ghost story, yet much superior to this one in my personal opinion.