What do you think?
Rate this book
Lady of Letters #3
Murder in Season
Join Countess turned advice columnist Amelia Amesbury as she tries to juggle a new Season and a new murder in this charmingly deadly historical mystery.
"A beautiful debutante, a wealthy widow, and a dead would-be baron. What could be more exciting?"
Countess by day, secret advice columnist by night, Amelia Amesbury has life happily balanced on a quill's edge . . . until her sister Margaret shows up in London under a blanket of scandal and Amelia is catapulted out of mourning and into the ton's unforgiving Season.
However Madge's Season debut is marred by a rather inconvenient death at the dining table as the infamous Mr Radcliffe takes ill and is later confirmed dead by poisoning. With Madge being the last person to have cross words with the soon-to-be baron, the ton's gossip mill - and the police - are looking to pin the murder on her.
Adding to the ton's troubles is a jewellery thief targeting the most lavish of Society's houses. Is the murderer and the thief one in the same? It falls to Amelia once again to uncover the secrets buried deep within the pages before her sister goes down for the crimes.
Perfect for fans of witty historical mystery and Regency romances with a similar feel to Verity Bright and T.E. Kinsey
"A beautiful debutante, a wealthy widow, and a dead would-be baron. What could be more exciting?"
Countess by day, secret advice columnist by night, Amelia Amesbury has life happily balanced on a quill's edge . . . until her sister Margaret shows up in London under a blanket of scandal and Amelia is catapulted out of mourning and into the ton's unforgiving Season.
However Madge's Season debut is marred by a rather inconvenient death at the dining table as the infamous Mr Radcliffe takes ill and is later confirmed dead by poisoning. With Madge being the last person to have cross words with the soon-to-be baron, the ton's gossip mill - and the police - are looking to pin the murder on her.
Adding to the ton's troubles is a jewellery thief targeting the most lavish of Society's houses. Is the murderer and the thief one in the same? It falls to Amelia once again to uncover the secrets buried deep within the pages before her sister goes down for the crimes.
Perfect for fans of witty historical mystery and Regency romances with a similar feel to Verity Bright and T.E. Kinsey
227 pages, Hardcover
First published December 3, 2024
36 people are currently reading
596 people want to read
About the author
Mary Winters
4 books317 followersMary Winters is the Edgar-nominated author of the Lady of Letters historical mystery series. She also pens cozy mysteries under the name Mary Angela. A longtime reader and fan of historical fiction, Mary set her latest work in Victorian England after being inspired by a trip to London. Since then, she’s been busily planning her next mystery—and another trip! Find out more about Mary and her writing, reading, and teaching at marywintersauthor.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 134 reviews
August 24, 2024
*Many thanks to NetGalley for providing me an E-Arc in exchange for an honest review!*
3.75 out of 5 stars!
Historical murder mystery with pretty covers are my weakness.
Here we are on book 3 of the 'A Lady of Letters Mystery' series, as we follow yet again our main character Amelia Amesbury who is countess by day and a secret advice columnist by night. In this instalment she gets a visit from her mother and younger sister Margaret, and they're both, especially her younger sister is in dire need for her help.
I wish I could have found out about this series much sooner. There's mystery, adventure, high societies, romance that will make your heart flutter and swoon, family chaos and much more.
Murder in Season ended beautifully with no plot holes left. But of course I wouldn't mind at all if we get more books in this series, I've already grown attached to all of the characters.
P.S. I have to pick up the previous books much sooner. This is a perfect cozy-mystery series with a hint of a swoon worthy romance.
3.75 out of 5 stars!
Historical murder mystery with pretty covers are my weakness.
Here we are on book 3 of the 'A Lady of Letters Mystery' series, as we follow yet again our main character Amelia Amesbury who is countess by day and a secret advice columnist by night. In this instalment she gets a visit from her mother and younger sister Margaret, and they're both, especially her younger sister is in dire need for her help.
I wish I could have found out about this series much sooner. There's mystery, adventure, high societies, romance that will make your heart flutter and swoon, family chaos and much more.
Murder in Season ended beautifully with no plot holes left. But of course I wouldn't mind at all if we get more books in this series, I've already grown attached to all of the characters.
P.S. I have to pick up the previous books much sooner. This is a perfect cozy-mystery series with a hint of a swoon worthy romance.
September 6, 2024
MURDER IN SEASON by Mary Winters.
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Amelia Amesbury continues to enchant! And solve murder mysteries, of course.
Since this is the third book in the A LADY OF LETTERS MYSTERY, I’m just going to list what I loved:
1. The Agony Aunt letters at the beginning of every chapter have so much wit and wisdom.
2. Multiple mysteries at the same time: jewel thefts and murder, oh my!
3. Amelia’s (Lady Amesbury) love and close relationships with her niece and aunt-in-law.
4. The London season and coming-out balls.
5. Amelia’s sister, Madge, is a feisty new character that was easy to love.
6. Amelia is such an enjoyable heroine who isn’t afraid to investigate and go under cover. Or fall in love.
7. I guessed wrong on the whodunnit of one of the mysteries…which will remain a mystery.
8. A slow burn romance with two kisses that were worth the wait!
9. Simon. Everything about him! Or should I say Lord Bainbridge?
10. The Epilogue. You’ll know why when you read it!
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Amelia Amesbury continues to enchant! And solve murder mysteries, of course.
Since this is the third book in the A LADY OF LETTERS MYSTERY, I’m just going to list what I loved:
1. The Agony Aunt letters at the beginning of every chapter have so much wit and wisdom.
2. Multiple mysteries at the same time: jewel thefts and murder, oh my!
3. Amelia’s (Lady Amesbury) love and close relationships with her niece and aunt-in-law.
4. The London season and coming-out balls.
5. Amelia’s sister, Madge, is a feisty new character that was easy to love.
6. Amelia is such an enjoyable heroine who isn’t afraid to investigate and go under cover. Or fall in love.
7. I guessed wrong on the whodunnit of one of the mysteries…which will remain a mystery.
8. A slow burn romance with two kisses that were worth the wait!
9. Simon. Everything about him! Or should I say Lord Bainbridge?
10. The Epilogue. You’ll know why when you read it!
September 2, 2024
Book Three in the A Lady of Letters mystery series, set in the mid-1800s in England, is a fine addition, and can be enjoyed, too, as a standalone. Highly recommended for histfic fans who love mysteries they can't solve with historical details and beautiful prose that bring the era fully alive. Loved it!
December 8, 2024
This was such a charming and delightful cozy mystery! I thought the characters were very well developed, and the mystery kept me guessing to the very end. The romance between Amelia and Simon was wonderful, and I loved that it didn’t overshadow the mystery. The writing style was excellent, and the story kept me engaged the entire time. It was a great mix of historical mystery, wit, humor, and romance. Loved it!
This is the first book I’ve read in the A Lady Of Letters Mysteries series, but I’ll definitely be reading more!
Thanks to the author, publisher, and Austenprose for a gifted copy. All opinions expressed are my own.
This is the first book I’ve read in the A Lady Of Letters Mysteries series, but I’ll definitely be reading more!
Thanks to the author, publisher, and Austenprose for a gifted copy. All opinions expressed are my own.
December 18, 2024
4.5 stars
I have loved this series since the first book! I thought it was such a cute series especially with the Lady Agony parts at the beginning of each chapter. It has been a solid, well written, fun series so far. So naturally when this book came up for review it was an easy yes for me! This is a great series for fans of other ‘Lady Detective’ mysteries such as Veronica Speedwell, Lady Darby, or Lady Sherlock.
I know when the series came out, Bridgerton was super popular and I feel like every book that was historical fiction has the marketing pitch of ‘the next Bridgerton’, this book included! I was like how is a mystery novel going to be like Bridgerton? I anticipated this series being more about the romance than a mystery but I was pleasantly surprised that the book really was less about the romance and more about the mystery. The romance is cute and charming but nothing like Bridgerton. It really is more of a Lady Detective novel for me than romance at all!
If you enjoy historical mysteries and are looking for something new and fun, this is one you absolutely need on your radar! It is well written, funny, charming, and has a touch of romance. The mysteries are also equally engaging. Basically I am saying you don’t want to miss this one! I would say that the books should be read in order, while not wholly necessary, I felt like the story made more sense having read the other books first as well las the relationships between the characters as this book dives a bit more into the romantic interest. So reading the other books might be helpful
The one thing I was looking forward to in this book is the introduction of Amelia’s family. Up until now the focus has really been on Amelia and her life as a widow and navigating her ‘child’. Now in this book we get to really dive into her own family dynamics with the introduction of her sister. I really liked how Simon sort of took a back seat in this book with Amelia and her sister being the ones who really focus on solving the mystery. There was also another love interest introduced for Amelia which I loved how that dynamic moves the larger narrative forward. I have definitely felt frustrated by Simon’s reluctance to move forward with Amelia and I think this book helps move things along.
The mystery itself was enjoyable. I liked the jewel thief angle and I thought the mystery unfolded well with some twists along the way. The mystery wasn’t overly long or complicated but it held my interested and I loved watching Amelia and Madge work together to solve this. They are spunky, funny, and memorable which worked very well for two ‘lady detective’ in this mystery. It is a witty mystery and I think fans of those classic historical mysteries that are well written, smart, and quirky will enjoy this one.
The only criticism I had for this one was I wish it was a little longer. It’s only 240 pages, I would have liked to have seen a little more development either with the characters or a few more twists within the mystery to give readers a more complete reading. Most historical mysteries run about 320-350 pages so this one felt like it could have been a little longer to give us more of the things we love about this one! Overall though another enjoyable addition and probably my favorite in the series so far! Do not miss this series!
I have loved this series since the first book! I thought it was such a cute series especially with the Lady Agony parts at the beginning of each chapter. It has been a solid, well written, fun series so far. So naturally when this book came up for review it was an easy yes for me! This is a great series for fans of other ‘Lady Detective’ mysteries such as Veronica Speedwell, Lady Darby, or Lady Sherlock.
I know when the series came out, Bridgerton was super popular and I feel like every book that was historical fiction has the marketing pitch of ‘the next Bridgerton’, this book included! I was like how is a mystery novel going to be like Bridgerton? I anticipated this series being more about the romance than a mystery but I was pleasantly surprised that the book really was less about the romance and more about the mystery. The romance is cute and charming but nothing like Bridgerton. It really is more of a Lady Detective novel for me than romance at all!
If you enjoy historical mysteries and are looking for something new and fun, this is one you absolutely need on your radar! It is well written, funny, charming, and has a touch of romance. The mysteries are also equally engaging. Basically I am saying you don’t want to miss this one! I would say that the books should be read in order, while not wholly necessary, I felt like the story made more sense having read the other books first as well las the relationships between the characters as this book dives a bit more into the romantic interest. So reading the other books might be helpful
The one thing I was looking forward to in this book is the introduction of Amelia’s family. Up until now the focus has really been on Amelia and her life as a widow and navigating her ‘child’. Now in this book we get to really dive into her own family dynamics with the introduction of her sister. I really liked how Simon sort of took a back seat in this book with Amelia and her sister being the ones who really focus on solving the mystery. There was also another love interest introduced for Amelia which I loved how that dynamic moves the larger narrative forward. I have definitely felt frustrated by Simon’s reluctance to move forward with Amelia and I think this book helps move things along.
The mystery itself was enjoyable. I liked the jewel thief angle and I thought the mystery unfolded well with some twists along the way. The mystery wasn’t overly long or complicated but it held my interested and I loved watching Amelia and Madge work together to solve this. They are spunky, funny, and memorable which worked very well for two ‘lady detective’ in this mystery. It is a witty mystery and I think fans of those classic historical mysteries that are well written, smart, and quirky will enjoy this one.
The only criticism I had for this one was I wish it was a little longer. It’s only 240 pages, I would have liked to have seen a little more development either with the characters or a few more twists within the mystery to give readers a more complete reading. Most historical mysteries run about 320-350 pages so this one felt like it could have been a little longer to give us more of the things we love about this one! Overall though another enjoyable addition and probably my favorite in the series so far! Do not miss this series!
December 10, 2024
Mary Winters delivers another exciting installment in the A Lady of Letters cozy mystery series! Murder in Season begins with a surprise. Lady Amelia’s mother & sister Margaret have unexpectedly arrived for the Season under a hint of scandal. In the flurry of balls & parties, one man winds up dead & a notorious jewel thief stalks the wealthy aristocracy. Will Lady Amelia, the secret advice columnist & amateur sleuth, be able to clear her sister’s name when she’s accused of murder?
I’ve thoroughly enjoyed this series! After only a few months of marriage, Lady Amelia is widowed & takes up residence with her husband’s darling niece & curmudgeonly but lovable aunt. She pens a delightful advice column under the nom de plume of Lady Agony & I loved the way this witty, funny column begins every chapter. Though she loved her husband, she barely knew him before his death. Though still technically in mourning, she can’t resist the pull to the handsome Simon Bainbridge, a marquis & heir to a dukedom. I was delighted to see their romance progress as they investigate these mysteries together.
Margaret “Madge” is intelligent, strong willed, & spunky. Of course as Amelia’s sister, she has a mind of her own & gets herself into all sorts of trouble. She’s the prime suspect when she was the last person to argue with the notorious bachelor Mr. Radcliffe & he’s later found poisoned.
The mystery was interesting with several suspects & motives. Along with the murder are the thefts of priceless jewels. There’s also a dogged inspector with a former grudge against Amelia’s husband who’s determined to convict Madge. It all comes down to the wire as all the clues come together.
Historical mystery fans will definitely enjoy this quick witted whodunit with a bit of romance! Though part of a series, it can be read as a standalone. There are a few mild biblical swears including taking the Lord’s name in vain as well as brief violence. There’s also a brief reference to a character being gay as a possible motivation for murder. I received an advanced complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions are my own & voluntarily provided. 4-4.5 stars!
I’ve thoroughly enjoyed this series! After only a few months of marriage, Lady Amelia is widowed & takes up residence with her husband’s darling niece & curmudgeonly but lovable aunt. She pens a delightful advice column under the nom de plume of Lady Agony & I loved the way this witty, funny column begins every chapter. Though she loved her husband, she barely knew him before his death. Though still technically in mourning, she can’t resist the pull to the handsome Simon Bainbridge, a marquis & heir to a dukedom. I was delighted to see their romance progress as they investigate these mysteries together.
Margaret “Madge” is intelligent, strong willed, & spunky. Of course as Amelia’s sister, she has a mind of her own & gets herself into all sorts of trouble. She’s the prime suspect when she was the last person to argue with the notorious bachelor Mr. Radcliffe & he’s later found poisoned.
The mystery was interesting with several suspects & motives. Along with the murder are the thefts of priceless jewels. There’s also a dogged inspector with a former grudge against Amelia’s husband who’s determined to convict Madge. It all comes down to the wire as all the clues come together.
Historical mystery fans will definitely enjoy this quick witted whodunit with a bit of romance! Though part of a series, it can be read as a standalone. There are a few mild biblical swears including taking the Lord’s name in vain as well as brief violence. There’s also a brief reference to a character being gay as a possible motivation for murder. I received an advanced complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions are my own & voluntarily provided. 4-4.5 stars!
October 9, 2024
It's always nice to return to Amelia Amssbury's London! The format for these books is wonderful - each chapter starts with a letter to Lady Agony and Amelia's response. Her secret job helps her childhood friend who runs a paper and gives her something to do now that she's a widow with a title and fortune. This installment in the series introduces some family members, with Amelia's sister being a wonderful addition to the cast. We know about Amelia's childhood at the family inn in Somerset, but we haven't met any family members up until now.
This story's murder happens at a ball Amelia throws to introduce her sister to society. All of the regular characters attend, but there's a long list of guests who serve as suspects in the crime. At the same time, there's a jewel thief targeting homes in Mayfair and Amelia's house is one of the ones hit. Amelia and her sister do most of the sleuthing in this one with the Simon Bainbridge, the potential love interest, falling back to secondary character status. Amelia and Simon have some nice moments together, but Amelia is frustrated by his reluctance to move forward. A second love interest was introduced and that made things interesting for a bit!
These books are wonderfully cozy despite the body count! Amelia is a heroine you can root for!
This story's murder happens at a ball Amelia throws to introduce her sister to society. All of the regular characters attend, but there's a long list of guests who serve as suspects in the crime. At the same time, there's a jewel thief targeting homes in Mayfair and Amelia's house is one of the ones hit. Amelia and her sister do most of the sleuthing in this one with the Simon Bainbridge, the potential love interest, falling back to secondary character status. Amelia and Simon have some nice moments together, but Amelia is frustrated by his reluctance to move forward. A second love interest was introduced and that made things interesting for a bit!
These books are wonderfully cozy despite the body count! Amelia is a heroine you can root for!
November 19, 2024
This is a fantastic addition to the Lady of Letters mystery series. It’s a cozy, historical mystery with a dash of romance. The series is one of my favorites and this book might be my favorite one so far. I mean, Simon…finally! I hope there are many more books to come. This one releases 12/3/24. It can also be read as a standalone.
I received an eARC from the publisher via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
I received an eARC from the publisher via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
September 11, 2024
3.5/5.
A lot of charm and character. While interesting, the mystery unfortunately did fall flat for during the last chapters of the book, but that could possibly be due to how short it is. I would have appreciated a slightly longer ending to flesh out the aftermath of the mystery, as it left me with a lot of questions. However, I thought it was engaging and a good read. The characters were fantastic and the romance was a highlight.
I found myself encountering the Tiffany Problem, or a small version of that at times, where a real historical fact feels unrealistic, like referencing the smallpox vaccine and calling the houses “Edwardian”. Not a negative, but interesting.
A lot of charm and character. While interesting, the mystery unfortunately did fall flat for during the last chapters of the book, but that could possibly be due to how short it is. I would have appreciated a slightly longer ending to flesh out the aftermath of the mystery, as it left me with a lot of questions. However, I thought it was engaging and a good read. The characters were fantastic and the romance was a highlight.
I found myself encountering the Tiffany Problem, or a small version of that at times, where a real historical fact feels unrealistic, like referencing the smallpox vaccine and calling the houses “Edwardian”. Not a negative, but interesting.
December 11, 2024
The perfect historical cozy mystery! Amelia is a widow running her late husband's household along with her late husband's strict Aunt Tabitha. Amelia's mother and younger sister, Madge, show up unannounced saying that Madge wants to have a season. It's all very suspicious until Amelia learns that her tough sister hurt a man's arm in their small home town and now she's the talk of the town. What she needs is a new setting where no one knows of her transgressions. But during a debut ball for Madge, in Amelia's home, someone already knows and makes a spectacle of Madge.
Then everything kind of breaks loose from there with a deceased party guest and missing jewels from Aunt Tabitha's jewelry box. A perfect blend of who-dunnit feels in a historical setting. I love these kinds of stories where you're trying to figure out exactly who is the guilty party and how did everything transpire. Not to mention that Amelia is an astounding character. She's charming, witty, and while she's well behaved in company she also is a fiery one. Especially when it comes to her attraction to her late husband's best friend, Simon.
There are elements of romance within the story between Amelia and Simon as they try to navigate their confusing feelings for one another and attempt to avoid dishonoring Amelia's late husband. But the mystery elements are so fun to follow as well! It took me a while to figure out exactly where it was going and I enjoyed every minute of it!
Then everything kind of breaks loose from there with a deceased party guest and missing jewels from Aunt Tabitha's jewelry box. A perfect blend of who-dunnit feels in a historical setting. I love these kinds of stories where you're trying to figure out exactly who is the guilty party and how did everything transpire. Not to mention that Amelia is an astounding character. She's charming, witty, and while she's well behaved in company she also is a fiery one. Especially when it comes to her attraction to her late husband's best friend, Simon.
There are elements of romance within the story between Amelia and Simon as they try to navigate their confusing feelings for one another and attempt to avoid dishonoring Amelia's late husband. But the mystery elements are so fun to follow as well! It took me a while to figure out exactly where it was going and I enjoyed every minute of it!
November 8, 2024
This is a new series and author for me. I had thought this was the first in the series, but it was the third. This did not impact my enjoyment of the book and was caught up quite easily. Our heroine is a young widow, Lady Amelia Amesbury has her late husband's niece to raise as well as his aunt, the formidable Tabitha to add to her household. Because she has a lot of energy and interest in the world, as well as a friend from home that is an editor of a penny weekly, she also writes a Lady Agony column. When her mother drops her youngest sister Margaret on her for the Season, she knows she will have her hands full. As out spoken and willful as she is herself, Madge has been sent away because she broke the arm of a young man at home who got a little too forward. The sisters will indeed find their Season full when a young Lord dies at Madge's coming out party, then there are the missing jewels and the possibility of broken hearts. It is an entertaining Victorian romp with mysteries, beautiful clothes, jewelry theives, wonderful characters, and murder. I believe I will go back for books one and two! Thanks to #Netgally, #SevernBooks, and the author for a chance to read. #MurderinSeason #ALadyofLettersMystery #MaryWinters #bookreview #bookideas #retiredreader
April 6, 2025
I started this book as I was starting the most recent in the Lily Adler series and I couldn't help noticing the similarities... both widowed, both have feelings for their former husband's best friend (both of whom were former sailors), both relocate to London, both have a child (or are taking care of a child), both have a knack for investigation... I'm pretty sure both even lived in the same area of London. I had a bit of a difficult time keeping the characters on both book straight at one point. 😂🤦🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️
Once I finished them one at a time, I enjoyed each more for what it was. This book in the series centers around a mysterious death that happens at a ball at Lady Amesbury's house. When her sister is implicated in the crime, Lady Amesbury jumps into investigating to prove her sister's innocence.
Overall, I liked this cozy mystery. The resolution was a surprise that I didn't see coming, which is always good when reading the genre. I'll read the next in the series when it comes out!
Once I finished them one at a time, I enjoyed each more for what it was. This book in the series centers around a mysterious death that happens at a ball at Lady Amesbury's house. When her sister is implicated in the crime, Lady Amesbury jumps into investigating to prove her sister's innocence.
Overall, I liked this cozy mystery. The resolution was a surprise that I didn't see coming, which is always good when reading the genre. I'll read the next in the series when it comes out!
August 28, 2024
A good addition to this developing series. Amelia shines as she navigates her troublesome sister, a death at her first ball, and a series of jewelry thefts. I do wish clues to determine the killer had been laid earlier, as there were a lot of characters introduced in this one. I’m just as interested in how Amelia navigates love interest Simon. Amelia and I have both been impatient with him, but things look promising for book 4, which I’m already eager for.
I received an arc from NetGalley
I received an arc from NetGalley
February 12, 2025
I always get excited when a new installment in this series comes out because I truly love hanging out on the page with Lady Amelia Amesburg (aka secretly the advice columnist Lady Agony), her best friend Kitty, her late husband’s aunt Tabitha, and Amelia’s adopted daughter Winifred. In Murder in Season, we get the added treat of Amelia’s fiery sister Margaret (or ‘Madge’) who is foisted upon them in hopes of making a good match for the Season. Madge is just as spirited as Amelia, but without the learned control or maturity that a few more years down the road of life will earn her, and thus any scene she’s in has the potential to epitomize the words ‘oh dear’. As you may be getting ready to guess, when murder also enters the picture Madge is one of the prime suspects, making Amelia’s covert investigations all the more personal. This sleuthing is, as always, delightful to follow, given Amelia’s savvy instinct and the ability to (mostly) discreetly snoop around in locations that range from a dark market alley to a glittering ballroom and everywhere in between.
Enter the dashing Simon, whose feelings for Amelia are complicated but deep and whose kisses (once he gets around to them) left me all a’swoon after reading. He makes a wonderful co-investigator, a delicious love interest, and a steady friend, and here is where I confess that most of my excitement leading up to each new book is because of the chemistry he and Amelia share. Their banter, their teamwork, their dances, their longing gazes and spark-filled romantic tension… and their kisses (hallelujah!)… all of it is just so much fun. Without taking away from the mystery that we’re solving or the other characters’ delightful personalities (Tabitha’s cane is out in full force this book). Because I love the mysteries and the side characters too, and Mary Winters writes them all so well. But once you get me hooked on a simmering romance, that’s what keeps me coming back for more. (I am telling you nothing y’all don’t already know about me)
Bottom Line: Murder in Season by Mary Winters is delightfully charming from beginning to end! Amelia remains a layered and engaging protagonist, and the addition of her scapegrace sister in this book made her even more so. Jewel thefts and murder may complicate matters for Amelia and her inner circle but it’s to the reader’s benefit for the entertainment it provides & the clever twists that I didn’t see coming. Add a dash of swoony romance with the delicious Simon and I’m all in! The characters, the Victorian setting, the well-plotted mystery, and yes the romance all made me a very happy reader of Murder in Season!
Reviewer’s Note: Followers of my reviews may want to be aware that there is occasional mild cursing and one profane expletive in this book.
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower
Enter the dashing Simon, whose feelings for Amelia are complicated but deep and whose kisses (once he gets around to them) left me all a’swoon after reading. He makes a wonderful co-investigator, a delicious love interest, and a steady friend, and here is where I confess that most of my excitement leading up to each new book is because of the chemistry he and Amelia share. Their banter, their teamwork, their dances, their longing gazes and spark-filled romantic tension… and their kisses (hallelujah!)… all of it is just so much fun. Without taking away from the mystery that we’re solving or the other characters’ delightful personalities (Tabitha’s cane is out in full force this book). Because I love the mysteries and the side characters too, and Mary Winters writes them all so well. But once you get me hooked on a simmering romance, that’s what keeps me coming back for more. (I am telling you nothing y’all don’t already know about me)
Bottom Line: Murder in Season by Mary Winters is delightfully charming from beginning to end! Amelia remains a layered and engaging protagonist, and the addition of her scapegrace sister in this book made her even more so. Jewel thefts and murder may complicate matters for Amelia and her inner circle but it’s to the reader’s benefit for the entertainment it provides & the clever twists that I didn’t see coming. Add a dash of swoony romance with the delicious Simon and I’m all in! The characters, the Victorian setting, the well-plotted mystery, and yes the romance all made me a very happy reader of Murder in Season!
Reviewer’s Note: Followers of my reviews may want to be aware that there is occasional mild cursing and one profane expletive in this book.
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower
November 14, 2024
Thank you, NetGalley, for providing me with a free e-book copy!
“Murder in Season” is the third instalment of the “Lady of Letters Mystery” series. The author did a marvellous job of reintroducing the characters, and I had fun writing notes to get familiar with them faster. You can read it as a standalone, but of course, it’s better to read the whole series.
Aside from the new characters, I seemed to have learned a thing or two about the end of the 19th century customs and fashion.
Our main character, Lady Amelia Amesbury, has a lot on her plate, but there’s no murder she cannot solve, no thief she cannot catch, as she has the support of those who care for her deeply. She’s joggling multiple cases, both matters of the heart and of the sleuthing nature.
Amelia’s life has a routine and a comfort to it, but the adventures always find her. This book’s main adventure is her energetic younger sister, Miss Margaret (Madge) Scott. Now Amelia has to keep an eye on her younger sister, which is as Lady Tabitha had said a “full-time occupation”.
Besides, it’s time to decide between giving up the hope of ever being loved and following her heart and embracing her newly developed feelings for that “lonely curmudgeon”, Lord Simon Bainbridge.
And there's no murder mystery without a murder - the Countess has to catch a killer and a thief terrorizing Mayfair habitants.
One of my favourite moments was the reintroduction of Grady, or maybe I liked what he represents/means for Amelia. This passage told me everything I needed to know about him. I’m afraid I won’t be able to put it better than the author herself, so here it is: “His rough skin reminded her of their childhood days, when she had no worries about the smooth skin, good posture or fashionable dresses. Her greatest concern was whether they would catch a fish and who would keep it – she or Grady”.
What made me second guess:
Amelia didn’t stop the ball when she found out about the death of one of her guests. Our Ladyship is known for being brave and not afraid of other people opinions, so what stopped her?
When Amelia planned to visit the dangerous neighbourhood, she decided to bring her younger sister, because Margaret "was used to disguising herself and was not above the physical violence". And here I must agree with Lady Tabitha that for the very long time their parents and other sisters were indulging in this kind of behaviour. As a fellow reader and reviewer, I think I understand why the author wrote it this way. But as the eldest sister myself, I disapprove of risking your sister’s safety and reputation for the lead or an heirloom piece of jewellery, no matter how precious it might be.
I understand Amelia wants to solve the case by herself, but lying to Detective Collins about them appearing on Petticoat Lane is not a sensible thing to do.
When the party located Marge unconscious, why they didn’t call for the constables to comb through the park to find the perpetrator. This leaves Detective Collins even more incompetent than we thought. Or is it Amelia who should be held responsible?
Even so, I can’t forget that the Countess helped the young lady with her dress at the ball, how she didn’t betray the secrets she learnt, the way she didn’t judge a book by its cover. But what’s most important is that she loves a good stationery and a good story. A woman of my own heart.
I found the descriptions to be very poetic, and I might've been drawn more to the prose rather than the characters. Nevertheless, I would recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a cozy mystery in a historical setting.
P.S.
I hope Lady Agony continues her epistolary mission and stays true to herself.
#LadyOfLetters #NetGalley #MurderInSeason #SevernHouse
“Murder in Season” is the third instalment of the “Lady of Letters Mystery” series. The author did a marvellous job of reintroducing the characters, and I had fun writing notes to get familiar with them faster. You can read it as a standalone, but of course, it’s better to read the whole series.
Aside from the new characters, I seemed to have learned a thing or two about the end of the 19th century customs and fashion.
Our main character, Lady Amelia Amesbury, has a lot on her plate, but there’s no murder she cannot solve, no thief she cannot catch, as she has the support of those who care for her deeply. She’s joggling multiple cases, both matters of the heart and of the sleuthing nature.
Amelia’s life has a routine and a comfort to it, but the adventures always find her. This book’s main adventure is her energetic younger sister, Miss Margaret (Madge) Scott. Now Amelia has to keep an eye on her younger sister, which is as Lady Tabitha had said a “full-time occupation”.
Besides, it’s time to decide between giving up the hope of ever being loved and following her heart and embracing her newly developed feelings for that “lonely curmudgeon”, Lord Simon Bainbridge.
And there's no murder mystery without a murder - the Countess has to catch a killer and a thief terrorizing Mayfair habitants.
One of my favourite moments was the reintroduction of Grady, or maybe I liked what he represents/means for Amelia. This passage told me everything I needed to know about him. I’m afraid I won’t be able to put it better than the author herself, so here it is: “His rough skin reminded her of their childhood days, when she had no worries about the smooth skin, good posture or fashionable dresses. Her greatest concern was whether they would catch a fish and who would keep it – she or Grady”.
What made me second guess:
Amelia didn’t stop the ball when she found out about the death of one of her guests. Our Ladyship is known for being brave and not afraid of other people opinions, so what stopped her?
When Amelia planned to visit the dangerous neighbourhood, she decided to bring her younger sister, because Margaret "was used to disguising herself and was not above the physical violence". And here I must agree with Lady Tabitha that for the very long time their parents and other sisters were indulging in this kind of behaviour. As a fellow reader and reviewer, I think I understand why the author wrote it this way. But as the eldest sister myself, I disapprove of risking your sister’s safety and reputation for the lead or an heirloom piece of jewellery, no matter how precious it might be.
I understand Amelia wants to solve the case by herself, but lying to Detective Collins about them appearing on Petticoat Lane is not a sensible thing to do.
When the party located Marge unconscious, why they didn’t call for the constables to comb through the park to find the perpetrator. This leaves Detective Collins even more incompetent than we thought. Or is it Amelia who should be held responsible?
Even so, I can’t forget that the Countess helped the young lady with her dress at the ball, how she didn’t betray the secrets she learnt, the way she didn’t judge a book by its cover. But what’s most important is that she loves a good stationery and a good story. A woman of my own heart.
I found the descriptions to be very poetic, and I might've been drawn more to the prose rather than the characters. Nevertheless, I would recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a cozy mystery in a historical setting.
P.S.
I hope Lady Agony continues her epistolary mission and stays true to herself.
#LadyOfLetters #NetGalley #MurderInSeason #SevernHouse
November 9, 2024
*I received a copy via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review*
As a lady of the ton and the secret author of a popular advice column, Amelia Amesbury is used to juggling multiple things at once. But when her younger sister Margaret unexpectedly turns up for the London season, Amelia finds herself in a tizzy. It seems Margaret has caused quite a scandal in their hometown and hopes to make a fresh start for herself. However, when a young suitor dies after an incident with Margaret at a ball, society is quick to blame the hot-headed newcomer. As if murder wasn't enough, there is also a burglar prowling the streets of Mayfair, stealing precious jewels from well-to-do families. Amelia is sure these two events are connected, so she must again don her investigator hat to clear her sister's name and bring the real criminal to justice.
I loved the first two books in this series. They had everything I love in a historical mystery, including a plucky heroine you can't help but root for. Amelia is such a fun character to follow. She's whip-smart, witty, and determined when she sets her mind on something. I love following along while she ferrets out clues and pieces together mysteries. I also love her dynamic with Simon and how he's always willing to help with whatever scheme Amelia concocts. The tension between them is what keeps me coming back for more. As for the mystery aspect, it was okay. I was a little bored, but I still liked how everything wrapped up. While I don't think it's the best installment, it's still one of my favorite historical mystery series.
As a lady of the ton and the secret author of a popular advice column, Amelia Amesbury is used to juggling multiple things at once. But when her younger sister Margaret unexpectedly turns up for the London season, Amelia finds herself in a tizzy. It seems Margaret has caused quite a scandal in their hometown and hopes to make a fresh start for herself. However, when a young suitor dies after an incident with Margaret at a ball, society is quick to blame the hot-headed newcomer. As if murder wasn't enough, there is also a burglar prowling the streets of Mayfair, stealing precious jewels from well-to-do families. Amelia is sure these two events are connected, so she must again don her investigator hat to clear her sister's name and bring the real criminal to justice.
I loved the first two books in this series. They had everything I love in a historical mystery, including a plucky heroine you can't help but root for. Amelia is such a fun character to follow. She's whip-smart, witty, and determined when she sets her mind on something. I love following along while she ferrets out clues and pieces together mysteries. I also love her dynamic with Simon and how he's always willing to help with whatever scheme Amelia concocts. The tension between them is what keeps me coming back for more. As for the mystery aspect, it was okay. I was a little bored, but I still liked how everything wrapped up. While I don't think it's the best installment, it's still one of my favorite historical mystery series.
November 16, 2024
In the latest in the Lady of Letters series, Amelia's younger sister Margaret pays an unexpected visit. She was part of a minor scandal at home and their mother thinks a season in London is just what Madge needs. The beautiful young woman is a hit at the Ball Amelia hosts, but when a future Baron that Madge argued with is found poisoned at the supper table, she becomes the prime suspect. In addition, there is also a series of jewel thefts occurring in wealthy homes and Amelia's Aunt Tabitha is the latest victim.
Amelia is an unlikely but very capable amateur sleuth. I enjoy the Lady Agony letters and the way they tie in with the story. The letters, as well as the narrative, do a great job of informing the reader about various Victorian customs. The solution to the crime was surprising and the overall ending of the book was fantastic. This book works well for new readers as well as returning fans.
Thank you to NetGalley and Severn House for providing an advance copy of this ebook for review consideration. My review is voluntary and unbiased.
Amelia is an unlikely but very capable amateur sleuth. I enjoy the Lady Agony letters and the way they tie in with the story. The letters, as well as the narrative, do a great job of informing the reader about various Victorian customs. The solution to the crime was surprising and the overall ending of the book was fantastic. This book works well for new readers as well as returning fans.
Thank you to NetGalley and Severn House for providing an advance copy of this ebook for review consideration. My review is voluntary and unbiased.
September 4, 2024
This cozy-mystery novel follows Amelia Amesbury in a new adventure of the The Lady of Letters series. Amelia is an advice columinst who often stumbles upon something suspicious and can't stop investigating until she is able to uncover the truth. I have read the first novel of the series and I remember enjoying it a lot so I was really looking forward to this! Murder in Season was entertaining and it kept me wondering what had happened until I reached the last chapter. I really love Mary Winters's writing, it makes the plot easy to follow and it gets me invested in the whole story. I enjoyed seeing different sides of Amelia and Simon in this novel and I thought Madge's plot-line was quite interesting. I'm looking forward to the next installments of this series (if there are any), I will for sure continue reading as I am attached to Amelia's character and I loved all the side-characters (Kitty, Simon, etc). Murder in Season did not disappoint!
November 22, 2024
I’m going to start this by saying that when I requested this on NetGalley, I did not realize that it was third in a series. And I did not read the other two before starting this one. So it’s possible that there are some questions I have that were answered in other books. But overall, I felt like you could read this without needing to read the others.
This book gives more “murder for comedy” rather than a serious mystery novel, but I like it. It’s fun.
The letters at the beginning of each chapter were cute, and supported the storyline of Amelia being Lady Agony. But they felt disconnected from the story at large happening within the book.
I loved the relationship between the sisters. It showed how they can simultaneously be your biggest annoyance and best friend.
The ending did seem to come together a little quickly but was not given away too early and was enjoyable enough.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an ARC for my review.
This book gives more “murder for comedy” rather than a serious mystery novel, but I like it. It’s fun.
The letters at the beginning of each chapter were cute, and supported the storyline of Amelia being Lady Agony. But they felt disconnected from the story at large happening within the book.
I loved the relationship between the sisters. It showed how they can simultaneously be your biggest annoyance and best friend.
The ending did seem to come together a little quickly but was not given away too early and was enjoyable enough.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an ARC for my review.
December 16, 2024
This book was so fun. A cozy mystery with Bridgerton vibes. I loved the combination.
Meeting a countess who, in the sly, would write an advice column was a really fun new premise . I found it clever, and appreciated the addition of the column to the book.
Mbit added so much personality to the story.
The story itself was fantastic. A true cozy mystery. Fun and easy to follow, but not crazy. Definitely a cozy.
I thoroughly appreciated all of the characters and their wits. Following their interactions and dialogue in and of itself was entertaining, and there were so many personalities. They help make the story engaging.
It’s a perfect story for all historical fiction, mystery, and cozy fans out there. And don’t worry if you didn’t read the previous books in the series. I didn’t, and loved this one.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, received from @marywintersauthor @severnhouseimprint and @austenprose . However, all thoughts and views reflected are strictly my own opinions.
Meeting a countess who, in the sly, would write an advice column was a really fun new premise . I found it clever, and appreciated the addition of the column to the book.
Mbit added so much personality to the story.
The story itself was fantastic. A true cozy mystery. Fun and easy to follow, but not crazy. Definitely a cozy.
I thoroughly appreciated all of the characters and their wits. Following their interactions and dialogue in and of itself was entertaining, and there were so many personalities. They help make the story engaging.
It’s a perfect story for all historical fiction, mystery, and cozy fans out there. And don’t worry if you didn’t read the previous books in the series. I didn’t, and loved this one.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, received from @marywintersauthor @severnhouseimprint and @austenprose . However, all thoughts and views reflected are strictly my own opinions.
May 11, 2025
Murder in Season is another sparkling entry in Winters’ charming Victorian historical mystery series features an engaging mystery and irresistible characters, especially Amelia, a countess whose independence and intelligence make her a perfect advice columnist and sleuth. We get to meet Amelia’s mother and one of her sisters in this book, and we get to see how her relationships with friends, family members, and potential love interest Simon continue to develop. I love how every chapter starts with a letter written to Amelia in her secret job as an advice columnist. I find every aspect of this series and charming.
November 29, 2024
Thank you NetGalley for sending me this book!
This gives off the vibes of Bridgerton and my lady Jane! I enjoyed reading this book
This gives off the vibes of Bridgerton and my lady Jane! I enjoyed reading this book
July 10, 2025
Wonderful as always
January 9, 2025
Murder in season is the third in this historical cozy mystery series. It's setting is England during the Victorian era and follows ad such. We met Amelia Amesbury yet again with her usually crew like Simon and Kitty, but this time it's an introduction to the other side of her family. A major case of this is her sister Margaret also know as Madge. Madge is back in Season and adettonv a ball. When the man of high standing shd has words with drops dead, revealed to be poisoning. Therr I'd also a theft that plays into the plot making it more interesting for Amelia. It wad great.
January 3, 2025
I first wanted to say thank you for the opportunity to read the ARC. As someone who loves historical fiction, I was more than excited to give the book a try. Anything set in the Regency or Victorian eras would be immediately interesting to me.
Murder in Season would be a good fit for Bridgerton fans who are looking for romance with a whodunit plot. Even though I hadn't read the previous books in the series, it didn't present a blocker for me to dig into this book and catch up with what the characters are up to. The book makes sure to bring you up to speed pretty quickly.
I appreciated the fashion descriptions and the general aesthetic described in the scenes. All characters (almost) wear the most beautiful clothes and live in glorious, scenic houses. It's easy to find yourself imagining the spaces as you read.
Unfortunately, despite enjoying the aesthetic, I found myself really not enjoying the characters. I thought I'd be rooting for Amelia and her love interest. I thought I'd enjoy the side characters, but sadly that didn't happen. The characters often felt flat, and at times very obnoxious.
It's understandable of course with some of the side characters that are clearly meant to be disliked, but that unfortunately extended to Amelia and her sister, Madge. It isn't that I dislike characters with flaws, it's that the book seems treats them as if they can do no wrong.
The other problem I personally had was with historical inaccuracies. I don't necessarily expect everything to be perfect. I've enjoyed many books that had the occasional historical misstep. The problem here is I found myself feeling that the book often forgot the Regency setting until it was beneficial for the vibes.
Characters often enough acted in modern ways that really wouldn't make sense in the setting. Or at times, makes the story less powerful. I love strong, outspoken female leads. Especially in historical fiction. But for that to work, there needs to be consequences to acting against the norms. That's what makes them impressive, that despite facing great consequences they still did what they needed to do. In most cases in this story, the consequences were very vague and/or subdued. Someone may get their feelings hurt perhaps. A glare. That's it.
There are other glaring issues. Ignoring the fact that Amelia was the daughter of an inn keeper and married a titled gentleman (I am a romantic at heart so I appreciate the appeal and the fantasy every now and then), the book started pushing it even further by making Amelia's mother ask and expect for Madge, Amelia's daughter, to attend the season. That wouldn't happen. Amelia would barely be tolerated by society at that point. Especially when her husband is dead, even more so when they were married for a very short time.
Assuming that her husband's family were so enamoured by her, and were even progressive enough to accept her, the rest of the ton would not. Not even with all that wealth. I find it hard to believe they would then attend a ball thrown in her sister's honour. And even more so, that wealthy bachelors would show interest in her so quickly. So much so that someone would comment on how half the bachelors are after her? Everyone is gushing about Madge. Only ones that don't clearly have ulterior motives or are just plainly villainous.
The writing style itself was fine at times. Other times, I found myself skimming entire paragraphs, or pages, because it felt they were repeating things we've already read before. Sometimes they restated the same things the characters just said a few sentences ago with little to no additions.
While the characters and the historical inaccuracies were enough for me to find the read tedious, I still can see some readers enjoying this.
Read it for the fashion and aesthetic.
Murder in Season would be a good fit for Bridgerton fans who are looking for romance with a whodunit plot. Even though I hadn't read the previous books in the series, it didn't present a blocker for me to dig into this book and catch up with what the characters are up to. The book makes sure to bring you up to speed pretty quickly.
I appreciated the fashion descriptions and the general aesthetic described in the scenes. All characters (almost) wear the most beautiful clothes and live in glorious, scenic houses. It's easy to find yourself imagining the spaces as you read.
Unfortunately, despite enjoying the aesthetic, I found myself really not enjoying the characters. I thought I'd be rooting for Amelia and her love interest. I thought I'd enjoy the side characters, but sadly that didn't happen. The characters often felt flat, and at times very obnoxious.
It's understandable of course with some of the side characters that are clearly meant to be disliked, but that unfortunately extended to Amelia and her sister, Madge. It isn't that I dislike characters with flaws, it's that the book seems treats them as if they can do no wrong.
The other problem I personally had was with historical inaccuracies. I don't necessarily expect everything to be perfect. I've enjoyed many books that had the occasional historical misstep. The problem here is I found myself feeling that the book often forgot the Regency setting until it was beneficial for the vibes.
Characters often enough acted in modern ways that really wouldn't make sense in the setting. Or at times, makes the story less powerful. I love strong, outspoken female leads. Especially in historical fiction. But for that to work, there needs to be consequences to acting against the norms. That's what makes them impressive, that despite facing great consequences they still did what they needed to do. In most cases in this story, the consequences were very vague and/or subdued. Someone may get their feelings hurt perhaps. A glare. That's it.
There are other glaring issues. Ignoring the fact that Amelia was the daughter of an inn keeper and married a titled gentleman (I am a romantic at heart so I appreciate the appeal and the fantasy every now and then), the book started pushing it even further by making Amelia's mother ask and expect for Madge, Amelia's daughter, to attend the season. That wouldn't happen. Amelia would barely be tolerated by society at that point. Especially when her husband is dead, even more so when they were married for a very short time.
Assuming that her husband's family were so enamoured by her, and were even progressive enough to accept her, the rest of the ton would not. Not even with all that wealth. I find it hard to believe they would then attend a ball thrown in her sister's honour. And even more so, that wealthy bachelors would show interest in her so quickly. So much so that someone would comment on how half the bachelors are after her? Everyone is gushing about Madge. Only ones that don't clearly have ulterior motives or are just plainly villainous.
The writing style itself was fine at times. Other times, I found myself skimming entire paragraphs, or pages, because it felt they were repeating things we've already read before. Sometimes they restated the same things the characters just said a few sentences ago with little to no additions.
While the characters and the historical inaccuracies were enough for me to find the read tedious, I still can see some readers enjoying this.
Read it for the fashion and aesthetic.
September 5, 2024
4 stars
I've jumped in at book 3 of the series. Our heroine is a commoner who has married into the aristocracy. She is a widow and lives with her aunt by marriage and her husband's niece. (It did urk me that half way through she started to refer to Winifred as her daughter. A mistake or just showing how much she liked the child?) Amelia is also the agony aunt of a paper and at the start of each chapter there is a letter. She also likes Simon but not much is progressing with his romance. I wondered if I'm really the author's market as it seemed a good book for teenager.
We eventually find out who the thief and the murderer is but there's no messy hanging or transportation to upset the reader. Amelia seems a bit sexually frustrated but I doubt I'll continue with it....
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own
I've jumped in at book 3 of the series. Our heroine is a commoner who has married into the aristocracy. She is a widow and lives with her aunt by marriage and her husband's niece. (It did urk me that half way through she started to refer to Winifred as her daughter. A mistake or just showing how much she liked the child?) Amelia is also the agony aunt of a paper and at the start of each chapter there is a letter. She also likes Simon but not much is progressing with his romance. I wondered if I'm really the author's market as it seemed a good book for teenager.
We eventually find out who the thief and the murderer is but there's no messy hanging or transportation to upset the reader. Amelia seems a bit sexually frustrated but I doubt I'll continue with it....
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own
December 30, 2024
This is an enjoyable historical cozy mystery set in the Victorian Era. It is filled with wit, romance, and intrigue, this is the third book in an enchanting series that will keep you guessing until the very end. It can standalone. Thank you @netgalley
December 31, 2024
Countess Amelia Amesbury has her hands full running her Lady Agony column, trying to figure out the identity of a jewel thief, and her sister making her London debut. Things escalate when Madge argues with a gentleman at her debut and he dies during their dinner. But he didn't just die. He was murdered and Madge is the number one suspect.
I think this was a stronger entry than the first book in the series, but I don't think it had the consistent quality of the second book. For one thing, I was surprised that Madge being a murder suspect didn't have more of an impact on her reputation. The reason why Madge was in London in the first place was that she was in hiding after a man tried to kiss her and she broke his arm in self-defense. She was caught arguing with a gentleman and making a scene and yet no one gossips about this at all? She's not ostracized or excluded from the ton? Even stranger, she's the season's superstar who is beloved for her looks and singing. This newfound popularity among the British aristocrats and Madge's supposed rash behaviour and churlishness just didn't seem to make sense.
In order to discuss another gripe, I have to talk about the identity of the murderer and the thief. I wasn't disappointed by the reveal as much as I was confused. Considering the murderer's identity as someone in high society, I was curious to see how everyone reacted when the reveal was made. Especially when the detective on the case had a vendetta against the Amesburys and was determined to blame everything on Madge.
However, there was no resolution to these subplots. We never get to see everyone's reactions to the murderer and their accomplice. I also thought Amelia would have made more use of the informant from Petticoat Lane. He showed up once to confirm the thief had to be an aristocrat and that was it. Kind of a waste in my opinion. The ending felt unsatisfactory and unfinished as a result.
Things weren't all bad, of course. The letters from the column and Lady Agony's replies were always a delight. I'm also surprised to say that I enjoyed Amelia and Simon's romance in this book. Simon's presence was unusually scarce so the moments where he did show up felt more impactful and I believed Amelia's happiness whenever she interacted with him. The scene where Aunt Tabitha caught them canoodling was simultaneously amusing and cringe-worthy since Aunt Tabitha is so conservative and didn't approve of their extramarital affairs.
The touch of violence was also a welcomed surprise. I know this a murder mystery series, but it felt like this was the first instance where the characters weren't safe. Like there was impending violence and danger and they didn't know who or what to look out for.
A Murder in Season was a fun read and I can definitely see this as a conclusion to wrap the series up. If Mary Winters was to write another book or two, I would definitely check them out.
I think this was a stronger entry than the first book in the series, but I don't think it had the consistent quality of the second book. For one thing, I was surprised that Madge being a murder suspect didn't have more of an impact on her reputation. The reason why Madge was in London in the first place was that she was in hiding after a man tried to kiss her and she broke his arm in self-defense. She was caught arguing with a gentleman and making a scene and yet no one gossips about this at all? She's not ostracized or excluded from the ton? Even stranger, she's the season's superstar who is beloved for her looks and singing. This newfound popularity among the British aristocrats and Madge's supposed rash behaviour and churlishness just didn't seem to make sense.
In order to discuss another gripe, I have to talk about the identity of the murderer and the thief. I wasn't disappointed by the reveal as much as I was confused. Considering the murderer's identity as someone in high society, I was curious to see how everyone reacted when the reveal was made. Especially when the detective on the case had a vendetta against the Amesburys and was determined to blame everything on Madge.
However, there was no resolution to these subplots. We never get to see everyone's reactions to the murderer and their accomplice. I also thought Amelia would have made more use of the informant from Petticoat Lane. He showed up once to confirm the thief had to be an aristocrat and that was it. Kind of a waste in my opinion. The ending felt unsatisfactory and unfinished as a result.
Things weren't all bad, of course. The letters from the column and Lady Agony's replies were always a delight. I'm also surprised to say that I enjoyed Amelia and Simon's romance in this book. Simon's presence was unusually scarce so the moments where he did show up felt more impactful and I believed Amelia's happiness whenever she interacted with him. The scene where Aunt Tabitha caught them canoodling was simultaneously amusing and cringe-worthy since Aunt Tabitha is so conservative and didn't approve of their extramarital affairs.
The touch of violence was also a welcomed surprise. I know this a murder mystery series, but it felt like this was the first instance where the characters weren't safe. Like there was impending violence and danger and they didn't know who or what to look out for.
A Murder in Season was a fun read and I can definitely see this as a conclusion to wrap the series up. If Mary Winters was to write another book or two, I would definitely check them out.
November 1, 2024
In public, Amelia Amesbury is the proper English Lady of 1860 England. She has a secret, however. Well, perhaps more than one. The biggest secret is her identity as columnist Lady Agony. As such, she offers some frequently not-so-discreet advice to those who write in for advice. You know, hardly the thing a Lady of that time would think, let alone vocalize. She could use some advice herself this go-round, however. First, advice on how to handle her beautiful, unpredictable sister who arrives unannounced to be sponsored for the season. Seems Madge has run into a few problems back home, one of which involved leaving a not-so gentlemanly wannabe suitor with a broken arm. I'd say Madge is not to be trifled with. For that matter, Amelia could use some sage advice on her own romantic yearnings. Seems she just can't quite budge Simon from the friend zone into suitor material. Then there's the little matter of a male guest that becomes ill at the ball given for Madge and later dies. Toss in a jewel thief absconding with some valuable family jewels from various residences and Amelia's amateur sleuth persona is about to be very busy. And, oh, did I mention that the man that died had words with Madge just before coming ill? That only adds to the problems Amelia is trying to juggle.
I won't detail the plot further other than to say there are other, actually far more viable suspects than Madge. But, well, seems to Detective in charge has it in for the Amesbury family. Toss in what we'd consider quaint standards of behavior, what society members find proper and improper, and family pressures and Amelia can't seem to catch a break. Those used to somethings happening every second plot speed may find this one quite slow but it's actually quite nice to relax into the pace of the 1860s. I liked the characters, even stern, rigid Aunt Tabitha, who is a force to be reckoned with when she assumes her mantle as Lady Tabitha, that's for sure. Simon is solid, albeit could be the poster boy for slow burn romances. Madge, oh, boy, she is personality plus. Outgoing, far more physically able than the typical female of that era, and can't always seem to rein in her impetuous mouth. There are more, actually lots more, which does always seem to take me a bit to sort through them given the use of both titles and names. What can I say, I felt like I needed a cast of characters at times.
Bottom line, an enjoyable if slow read. The setting was well done and I felt like I was strolling the park with characters more than once, and the descriptions of both the clothing and physical appearances were well done. And, oh, some of the clothing. I'm the sort that doesn't much like dressing up but it'd sure be fun to see, wouldn't it? As to whodunit, I didn't really sort it out until the reveal for sure, so it kept me guessing. And, oh, do be sure to read the epilogue. Thanks #SevernHouse for letting me take an early time-travel trip back to 1860 London. It was fun and I found myself enjoying the characters and their lives/adventures, both of which gave me an idea of the difference between the haves and have not groups. The traces of humanity from all were well done and heartwarming at times.
I won't detail the plot further other than to say there are other, actually far more viable suspects than Madge. But, well, seems to Detective in charge has it in for the Amesbury family. Toss in what we'd consider quaint standards of behavior, what society members find proper and improper, and family pressures and Amelia can't seem to catch a break. Those used to somethings happening every second plot speed may find this one quite slow but it's actually quite nice to relax into the pace of the 1860s. I liked the characters, even stern, rigid Aunt Tabitha, who is a force to be reckoned with when she assumes her mantle as Lady Tabitha, that's for sure. Simon is solid, albeit could be the poster boy for slow burn romances. Madge, oh, boy, she is personality plus. Outgoing, far more physically able than the typical female of that era, and can't always seem to rein in her impetuous mouth. There are more, actually lots more, which does always seem to take me a bit to sort through them given the use of both titles and names. What can I say, I felt like I needed a cast of characters at times.
Bottom line, an enjoyable if slow read. The setting was well done and I felt like I was strolling the park with characters more than once, and the descriptions of both the clothing and physical appearances were well done. And, oh, some of the clothing. I'm the sort that doesn't much like dressing up but it'd sure be fun to see, wouldn't it? As to whodunit, I didn't really sort it out until the reveal for sure, so it kept me guessing. And, oh, do be sure to read the epilogue. Thanks #SevernHouse for letting me take an early time-travel trip back to 1860 London. It was fun and I found myself enjoying the characters and their lives/adventures, both of which gave me an idea of the difference between the haves and have not groups. The traces of humanity from all were well done and heartwarming at times.
December 2, 2024
Barbara’s rating: 4 out of 5 Stars
Series: A Lady of Letters Mystery #3
Publication Date: 12/3/24
Period: Victorian London
Number of Pages: 240
It was wonderful to have another visit with Amelia and Simon in this entertaining third book in the series. Amelia, Countess Amesbury, has a secret life as an Agony Aunt (advice columnist) and each chapter begins with the content of one of the letters and Amelia's pithy reply. The book would be entertaining if it contained nothing but the letters and answers, but when you add a couple of engrossing mysteries along with likable and relatable characters, you have a sure winner.
Amelia is delighting in her life as it is at the moment. Although she is widowed, her husband left her with a title, plenty of money, a ward that she adores, and an aunt-in-law who is both formidable and lovable. Her life could hardly get better! Then, to add to her delight, her mother and sister (Madge) come for a visit.
Madge is in London because she caused a tad-bit of a scandal at home. Not the lascivious kind of scandal, but – still. . . Madge is irrepressible! You will love her and despair of her. She has no filter and whatever she thinks seems to come out of her mouth and that isn’t a good way to endear one’s self to the ton. Therefore, when the would-be baron she had loud words with ends up dead, who is the logical suspect? Madge, of course. Proving Madge’s innocence won’t be easy – especially when the policeman investigating the murder has a grudge against the Amesbury’s.
There are hundreds of suspects since the murder happened at a ball. How will they narrow the list? Everyone speaks highly of the deceased, but Madge thinks he was a cad. Amelia and Simon have to scrape away at the layers of veneer on the deceased to get down to the real man. It seems Madge is correct and he wasn’t who he seemed to be. Now that they know his true nature, how will they find the real murderer and clear Madge’s name?
I enjoyed reading this story and getting to see further developments in Amelia and Simon’s relationship. The Epilogue is great! There were also two mysteries, but I have mentioned only one because the secondary mystery is more superfluous and easily solved for Amelia. If you are looking for a quick, entertaining mystery with delightful characters and a nice mystery, then you should give this book (and series) a try.
I voluntarily read an early copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Series: A Lady of Letters Mystery #3
Publication Date: 12/3/24
Period: Victorian London
Number of Pages: 240
It was wonderful to have another visit with Amelia and Simon in this entertaining third book in the series. Amelia, Countess Amesbury, has a secret life as an Agony Aunt (advice columnist) and each chapter begins with the content of one of the letters and Amelia's pithy reply. The book would be entertaining if it contained nothing but the letters and answers, but when you add a couple of engrossing mysteries along with likable and relatable characters, you have a sure winner.
Amelia is delighting in her life as it is at the moment. Although she is widowed, her husband left her with a title, plenty of money, a ward that she adores, and an aunt-in-law who is both formidable and lovable. Her life could hardly get better! Then, to add to her delight, her mother and sister (Madge) come for a visit.
Madge is in London because she caused a tad-bit of a scandal at home. Not the lascivious kind of scandal, but – still. . . Madge is irrepressible! You will love her and despair of her. She has no filter and whatever she thinks seems to come out of her mouth and that isn’t a good way to endear one’s self to the ton. Therefore, when the would-be baron she had loud words with ends up dead, who is the logical suspect? Madge, of course. Proving Madge’s innocence won’t be easy – especially when the policeman investigating the murder has a grudge against the Amesbury’s.
There are hundreds of suspects since the murder happened at a ball. How will they narrow the list? Everyone speaks highly of the deceased, but Madge thinks he was a cad. Amelia and Simon have to scrape away at the layers of veneer on the deceased to get down to the real man. It seems Madge is correct and he wasn’t who he seemed to be. Now that they know his true nature, how will they find the real murderer and clear Madge’s name?
I enjoyed reading this story and getting to see further developments in Amelia and Simon’s relationship. The Epilogue is great! There were also two mysteries, but I have mentioned only one because the secondary mystery is more superfluous and easily solved for Amelia. If you are looking for a quick, entertaining mystery with delightful characters and a nice mystery, then you should give this book (and series) a try.
I voluntarily read an early copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 134 reviews