What do you think?
Rate this book
The Dawnless Night Series #2
Requiem for a Star: A Dawnless Night Novella
Before the voices
Before vengeance and blood and lies
Nye was just a boy.
A curly haired boy, shy, and kinda cute.
Neoro was his name back then.
And he wasn’t alone.
He had me.
Hi, I’m Nova, pleased to meet you.
I’m not a fan of small talk, so here’s what you need to
I’m seventeen. I like books, and swimming, and jewelry, and asking weird questions that put people on the spot.
My biggest fear is having no one to talk to.
And my biggest dream is that people will listen to what I have to say.
“Requiem for a Star” is my story—how I met Neoro, what I learned from him, what I did, what I fought.
It’s a bitter-sweet love story, a tiny bit sexy, revolving around magic, loss, philosophy, beauty, and hugs.
Lots of hugs.
And it is also a memorial
For another girl, another face
One of many, in a better place.
Before vengeance and blood and lies
Nye was just a boy.
A curly haired boy, shy, and kinda cute.
Neoro was his name back then.
And he wasn’t alone.
He had me.
Hi, I’m Nova, pleased to meet you.
I’m not a fan of small talk, so here’s what you need to
I’m seventeen. I like books, and swimming, and jewelry, and asking weird questions that put people on the spot.
My biggest fear is having no one to talk to.
And my biggest dream is that people will listen to what I have to say.
“Requiem for a Star” is my story—how I met Neoro, what I learned from him, what I did, what I fought.
It’s a bitter-sweet love story, a tiny bit sexy, revolving around magic, loss, philosophy, beauty, and hugs.
Lots of hugs.
And it is also a memorial
For another girl, another face
One of many, in a better place.
- GenresFantasy
107 pages, Paperback
Published June 11, 2024
17 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 19 of 19 reviews
August 9, 2024
This review was originally published on Before We Go Blog
U.G. Gutman gives a tantalising glimpse into his Dawnless Night series in Requiem for a Star, a profound little prequel novella full of self-exploration, philosophical musings, dangerous magic, sweet romance, and soul-stirring emotion.
Through the eyes of the young and precocious girl Nova, we get to experience Nye, or Neoro, way before he became the fearsome witch hunter we have come to know and love (or hate?) in Winds of Strife. In an almost stream of consciousness way, Nova lays her soul bare and takes us along on their vulnerable coming of age journey and budding relationship; though this is not simply a story about romance, it’s more a brutally bittersweet story exploring grief, life, death, and love in all its devastating beauty.
“Neoro, even as a fourteen-year-old, refused to ‘flow’ with being sad. Even before he was Nye. Even before he learned Senspirity. He was the kind who acts, who tries to solve everything.”
Let’s just get this out of the way first: Requiem for a Star is one of my favourite novellas I have ever read. It completely sucked me in from page one and then had me tearing up from both joy and sorrow by the end; and all that in just 80 pages! From reading Winds of Strife back in 2021, I knew that Gutman was a skilled storyteller, but he just stepped up his game in every single way in this novella for me.
Though slightly less dark and disturbing than Winds of Strife, this novella just packs everything that is so amazing about The Dawnless Night series and offers it in a delicious bite-sized chunk. I hadn’t even realised how much I had missed being in this world, as brutal as it is, until I opened these pages and was awe-struck by the incredible imagination and rich atmosphere all over again.
With a story that is so vulnerably intimate and quietly introspective, I loved how the emotion-based Senspirity magic absolutely got to shine in Requiem for a Star. Nova is a very curious and inquisitive young girl, and I really enjoyed seeing her starting to discover the extent of her (feared) powers. Gutman does a remarkably fine job of introducing this complex magic system in just a few pages, filling both old and new readers of this series with excitement and wonder.
“Then I dove into the depths of my heart and gave myself up to Sadness. Not for any magic or self-studies, rather, just to be human. I’d earned it, this one time, the right to feel down for just the sake of feeling down. So, I dove into it, and I cracked.”
Though what I maybe appreciated most about this novella, is how deeply layered and emotionally resonant it is. In a way, Requiem for a Star almost reads like a lament, which makes so much sense when you read the incredibly moving dedication and author’s note. This entire story is just drenched in a deep sense of melancholy, and I loved how Nova’s philosophical musings and existential quandaries gave this simple tale such a surprising amount of nuance and depth.
Now, I can see how some readers might bounce off Nova’s quirky unfiltered narration, but for me it was honestly deeply immersive and engrossing, making all the emotional beats hurt so so so good. Moreover, her dynamic with Neoro (who is an absolute cinnamon roll) was so incredibly sweet and wholesome, which makes it only more tragic to reflect on the way that Neoro/Nye has changed when we meet him in Winds of Strife. Gutman just has an incredible gift for writing extremely complex and human characters who will creep under your skin, whether you like it or not.
“Why not both? You can be an old soul in a young body, and a kid, at the same time.”
Whether you treat this as a little appealing appetiser to The Dawnless Night series or come back to it as a delicious (and somewhat soothing) dessert after finishing book 1, I think Requiem for a Star is an absolute triumph of a prequel novella that you absolutely should not miss out on. It’s dark, it’s intriguing, it’s emotional, it’s thought-provoking, it’s heartwarming, but most of all, it’s absolutely unforgettable; this is simply everything a prequel novella should be, and then so much more.
Thank you to the author for providing me with an eARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own. Requiem for a Star is scheduled for release on August 2, 2024.
U.G. Gutman gives a tantalising glimpse into his Dawnless Night series in Requiem for a Star, a profound little prequel novella full of self-exploration, philosophical musings, dangerous magic, sweet romance, and soul-stirring emotion.
Through the eyes of the young and precocious girl Nova, we get to experience Nye, or Neoro, way before he became the fearsome witch hunter we have come to know and love (or hate?) in Winds of Strife. In an almost stream of consciousness way, Nova lays her soul bare and takes us along on their vulnerable coming of age journey and budding relationship; though this is not simply a story about romance, it’s more a brutally bittersweet story exploring grief, life, death, and love in all its devastating beauty.
“Neoro, even as a fourteen-year-old, refused to ‘flow’ with being sad. Even before he was Nye. Even before he learned Senspirity. He was the kind who acts, who tries to solve everything.”
Let’s just get this out of the way first: Requiem for a Star is one of my favourite novellas I have ever read. It completely sucked me in from page one and then had me tearing up from both joy and sorrow by the end; and all that in just 80 pages! From reading Winds of Strife back in 2021, I knew that Gutman was a skilled storyteller, but he just stepped up his game in every single way in this novella for me.
Though slightly less dark and disturbing than Winds of Strife, this novella just packs everything that is so amazing about The Dawnless Night series and offers it in a delicious bite-sized chunk. I hadn’t even realised how much I had missed being in this world, as brutal as it is, until I opened these pages and was awe-struck by the incredible imagination and rich atmosphere all over again.
With a story that is so vulnerably intimate and quietly introspective, I loved how the emotion-based Senspirity magic absolutely got to shine in Requiem for a Star. Nova is a very curious and inquisitive young girl, and I really enjoyed seeing her starting to discover the extent of her (feared) powers. Gutman does a remarkably fine job of introducing this complex magic system in just a few pages, filling both old and new readers of this series with excitement and wonder.
“Then I dove into the depths of my heart and gave myself up to Sadness. Not for any magic or self-studies, rather, just to be human. I’d earned it, this one time, the right to feel down for just the sake of feeling down. So, I dove into it, and I cracked.”
Though what I maybe appreciated most about this novella, is how deeply layered and emotionally resonant it is. In a way, Requiem for a Star almost reads like a lament, which makes so much sense when you read the incredibly moving dedication and author’s note. This entire story is just drenched in a deep sense of melancholy, and I loved how Nova’s philosophical musings and existential quandaries gave this simple tale such a surprising amount of nuance and depth.
Now, I can see how some readers might bounce off Nova’s quirky unfiltered narration, but for me it was honestly deeply immersive and engrossing, making all the emotional beats hurt so so so good. Moreover, her dynamic with Neoro (who is an absolute cinnamon roll) was so incredibly sweet and wholesome, which makes it only more tragic to reflect on the way that Neoro/Nye has changed when we meet him in Winds of Strife. Gutman just has an incredible gift for writing extremely complex and human characters who will creep under your skin, whether you like it or not.
“Why not both? You can be an old soul in a young body, and a kid, at the same time.”
Whether you treat this as a little appealing appetiser to The Dawnless Night series or come back to it as a delicious (and somewhat soothing) dessert after finishing book 1, I think Requiem for a Star is an absolute triumph of a prequel novella that you absolutely should not miss out on. It’s dark, it’s intriguing, it’s emotional, it’s thought-provoking, it’s heartwarming, but most of all, it’s absolutely unforgettable; this is simply everything a prequel novella should be, and then so much more.
Thank you to the author for providing me with an eARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own. Requiem for a Star is scheduled for release on August 2, 2024.
July 20, 2024
FULL REVIEW HERE:
https://youtu.be/8hDDIi6EsM8?si=6s22Y...
I don’t have words right now to explain how I feel about this. I’ll do a full review in a few days.
https://youtu.be/8hDDIi6EsM8?si=6s22Y...
I don’t have words right now to explain how I feel about this. I’ll do a full review in a few days.
July 7, 2024
This novella is a prequel story to Winds of Strife following Nova, Nye's first love.
The story is romantic, but mostly, it is coming-of-age, focusing on dealing with grief and getting to know yourself and your feelings.
This story can be read before or after the Winds of Strife. The story is different from the first - so to readers expecting more of the same might be a jarring experience. While Winds of Strife is an epic fantasy following multiple characters and political events, Requiem for a Star is a quiet, contemplative story written in the first person.
Themes of dealing with grief, comparing yourself to an older sibling, and getting to know yourself are the most prevalent, and while romance plays a part in it, it isn't overwhelming the narrative.
I liked it. I found that it is a balanced story, with enough worldbuilding not to feel lost if this is your first entry in the world, but focusing on the main story of this novella and what's important to the characters it follows.
I'm not a fan of philosophy and philosophical musings in books I'm reading. In this book, philosophy was part of the characterization. It didn't feel out of place and just thrown in, but I can't help my personal preference playing a part in my enjoyment.
Overall, I liked this novella and would recommend it. If you enjoy coming-of-age tales or want to learn more about the world of the Dawnless Night series, give it a read.
The story is romantic, but mostly, it is coming-of-age, focusing on dealing with grief and getting to know yourself and your feelings.
This story can be read before or after the Winds of Strife. The story is different from the first - so to readers expecting more of the same might be a jarring experience. While Winds of Strife is an epic fantasy following multiple characters and political events, Requiem for a Star is a quiet, contemplative story written in the first person.
Themes of dealing with grief, comparing yourself to an older sibling, and getting to know yourself are the most prevalent, and while romance plays a part in it, it isn't overwhelming the narrative.
I liked it. I found that it is a balanced story, with enough worldbuilding not to feel lost if this is your first entry in the world, but focusing on the main story of this novella and what's important to the characters it follows.
I'm not a fan of philosophy and philosophical musings in books I'm reading. In this book, philosophy was part of the characterization. It didn't feel out of place and just thrown in, but I can't help my personal preference playing a part in my enjoyment.
Overall, I liked this novella and would recommend it. If you enjoy coming-of-age tales or want to learn more about the world of the Dawnless Night series, give it a read.
Read
July 2, 2024I’m not giving this a star rating because I don’t know how to rate this story. It is a well written, beautiful story that expands on the magic system from Winds of Strife. As a fan of Winds of Strife, I loved learning more about the magic.
But more than anything else, this felt like a romance story to me. I don’t read romance and don’t care for romance within the books I do read, so this was well outside my preferred genre. I’m sure people who like romance will really enjoy this story, but ultimately it wasn’t for me.
But more than anything else, this felt like a romance story to me. I don’t read romance and don’t care for romance within the books I do read, so this was well outside my preferred genre. I’m sure people who like romance will really enjoy this story, but ultimately it wasn’t for me.
July 31, 2024
A moving philosophical piece celebrating the loss of a dear friend.
Uni has put his heart and soul into this piece of literary art and it shows.
A beautiful showcase of how people can turn up in our lives when we least expect it, and keep a piece of our hearts for themselves.
In memory of Olga Romashkin, while I may never have known you, but I know you were loved.
Uni has put his heart and soul into this piece of literary art and it shows.
A beautiful showcase of how people can turn up in our lives when we least expect it, and keep a piece of our hearts for themselves.
In memory of Olga Romashkin, while I may never have known you, but I know you were loved.
December 30, 2024
4.5 Stars
Requiem for a Star is a profound and thought provoking character focused coming of age story that follows Nova as she is exposed to a variety of life experiences for the first time. As a young independent thinker who is following in the footsteps of her older sister but who is also intrigued by philosophy and not afraid to break the mould, Nova in some ways displays great emotional maturity as she questions her experiences and explains her reactions making her especially endearing, interesting and at times relatable.
This novella is perfect for readers new to the Dawnless Night series and existing fans alike. UG Gutman takes care to subtly weave in important contextual information so that new readers are not left behind or confused but also takes time to connect to or hint at things that occur within Winds of Strife. As someone new to this world, I never once felt confused and am now more intrigued about the world and political climate of his novel. This story definitely left me wanting more! I think there was only one passing reference that I didn't fully understand (but that I have some idea of the meaning behind). I'm really curious to read on in the series and gain more intricate understanding surrounding the plot!
This is one of those stories where I'm awed at just how much meaning and emotional depth was able to be conveyed in so few words. There were moments as I was reading where I would read a sentence and suddenly feel like I had a full understanding of something going on or someone's character which I really appreciated. I also enjoyed that there were some more ominous statements woven into the narrative to build more tension and allow for predictions for both this novella and for the series!
I suspect that the most polarizing aspect of this story will be the prose as there were some more modern expressions woven in with vivid descriptions and world specific fantasy lingo. Personally this aspect didn't bother me and actually led to the story feeling a little more relatable so I appreciated it even though it might not normally be my cup of tea.
I cannot quite convey the emotional impact of this story or how special it is in my review and I don't feel that I can fully do it justice so I would definitely recommend giving this a go on your own; it's sure to impact you and get you thinking! I would also recommend reading the author's note and extra content at the end as it will enrich the meaning of the story for you if you do.
Many thanks to the author for providing me with an ARC in exchange for my honest review!
Merged review:
4.5 Stars
Requiem for a Star is a profound and thought provoking character focused coming of age story that follows Nova as she is exposed to a variety of life experiences for the first time. As a young independent thinker who is following in the footsteps of her older sister but who is also intrigued by philosophy and not afraid to break the mould, Nova in some ways displays great emotional maturity as she questions her experiences and explains her reactions making her especially endearing, interesting and at times relatable.
This novella is perfect for readers new to the Dawnless Night series and existing fans alike. UG Gutman takes care to subtly weave in important contextual information so that new readers are not left behind or confused but also takes time to connect to or hint at things that occur within Winds of Strife. As someone new to this world, I never once felt confused and am now more intrigued about the world and political climate of his novel. This story definitely left me wanting more! I think there was only one passing reference that I didn't fully understand (but that I have some idea of the meaning behind). I'm really curious to read on in the series and gain more intricate understanding surrounding the plot!
This is one of those stories where I'm awed at just how much meaning and emotional depth was able to be conveyed in so few words. There were moments as I was reading where I would read a sentence and suddenly feel like I had a full understanding of something going on or someone's character which I really appreciated. I also enjoyed that there were some more ominous statements woven into the narrative to build more tension and allow for predictions for both this novella and for the series!
I suspect that the most polarizing aspect of this story will be the prose as there were some more modern expressions woven in with vivid descriptions and world specific fantasy lingo. Personally this aspect didn't bother me and actually led to the story feeling a little more relatable so I appreciated it even though it might not normally be my cup of tea.
I cannot quite convey the emotional impact of this story or how special it is in my review and I don't feel that I can fully do it justice so I would definitely recommend giving this a go on your own; it's sure to impact you and get you thinking! I would also recommend reading the author's note and extra content at the end as it will enrich the meaning of the story for you if you do.
Many thanks to the author for providing me with an ARC in exchange for my honest review!
Requiem for a Star is a profound and thought provoking character focused coming of age story that follows Nova as she is exposed to a variety of life experiences for the first time. As a young independent thinker who is following in the footsteps of her older sister but who is also intrigued by philosophy and not afraid to break the mould, Nova in some ways displays great emotional maturity as she questions her experiences and explains her reactions making her especially endearing, interesting and at times relatable.
This novella is perfect for readers new to the Dawnless Night series and existing fans alike. UG Gutman takes care to subtly weave in important contextual information so that new readers are not left behind or confused but also takes time to connect to or hint at things that occur within Winds of Strife. As someone new to this world, I never once felt confused and am now more intrigued about the world and political climate of his novel. This story definitely left me wanting more! I think there was only one passing reference that I didn't fully understand (but that I have some idea of the meaning behind). I'm really curious to read on in the series and gain more intricate understanding surrounding the plot!
This is one of those stories where I'm awed at just how much meaning and emotional depth was able to be conveyed in so few words. There were moments as I was reading where I would read a sentence and suddenly feel like I had a full understanding of something going on or someone's character which I really appreciated. I also enjoyed that there were some more ominous statements woven into the narrative to build more tension and allow for predictions for both this novella and for the series!
I suspect that the most polarizing aspect of this story will be the prose as there were some more modern expressions woven in with vivid descriptions and world specific fantasy lingo. Personally this aspect didn't bother me and actually led to the story feeling a little more relatable so I appreciated it even though it might not normally be my cup of tea.
I cannot quite convey the emotional impact of this story or how special it is in my review and I don't feel that I can fully do it justice so I would definitely recommend giving this a go on your own; it's sure to impact you and get you thinking! I would also recommend reading the author's note and extra content at the end as it will enrich the meaning of the story for you if you do.
Many thanks to the author for providing me with an ARC in exchange for my honest review!
Merged review:
4.5 Stars
Requiem for a Star is a profound and thought provoking character focused coming of age story that follows Nova as she is exposed to a variety of life experiences for the first time. As a young independent thinker who is following in the footsteps of her older sister but who is also intrigued by philosophy and not afraid to break the mould, Nova in some ways displays great emotional maturity as she questions her experiences and explains her reactions making her especially endearing, interesting and at times relatable.
This novella is perfect for readers new to the Dawnless Night series and existing fans alike. UG Gutman takes care to subtly weave in important contextual information so that new readers are not left behind or confused but also takes time to connect to or hint at things that occur within Winds of Strife. As someone new to this world, I never once felt confused and am now more intrigued about the world and political climate of his novel. This story definitely left me wanting more! I think there was only one passing reference that I didn't fully understand (but that I have some idea of the meaning behind). I'm really curious to read on in the series and gain more intricate understanding surrounding the plot!
This is one of those stories where I'm awed at just how much meaning and emotional depth was able to be conveyed in so few words. There were moments as I was reading where I would read a sentence and suddenly feel like I had a full understanding of something going on or someone's character which I really appreciated. I also enjoyed that there were some more ominous statements woven into the narrative to build more tension and allow for predictions for both this novella and for the series!
I suspect that the most polarizing aspect of this story will be the prose as there were some more modern expressions woven in with vivid descriptions and world specific fantasy lingo. Personally this aspect didn't bother me and actually led to the story feeling a little more relatable so I appreciated it even though it might not normally be my cup of tea.
I cannot quite convey the emotional impact of this story or how special it is in my review and I don't feel that I can fully do it justice so I would definitely recommend giving this a go on your own; it's sure to impact you and get you thinking! I would also recommend reading the author's note and extra content at the end as it will enrich the meaning of the story for you if you do.
Many thanks to the author for providing me with an ARC in exchange for my honest review!
December 21, 2024
This was read as part of SFINCS2 round one!
This review is also featured on Behind the Pages: Requiem for a Star
Requiem for a Star takes readers on a journey of love and loss with immense emotional depth.. Novella, or as we come to know her as Nova, endures a devastating loss at a young age. Yet through her grief she is able to harness magic, and carry on with her dearly departed’s hope to speak out against the king.
It is not an easy world Nova lives in. Women are persecuted for having powers, and Nova is no exception. Yet Nova is able to process her grief and emotional state through magic. Keyed into specific emotions, by harnessing them and pulling forth emotional understanding, Nova is able to wield power.
As the reader uncovers how magic works in this world, Nova also shares a coming of age story. A story of her first love and their slowly kindled romance through the years. And the risk her wielding power has for not only them, but their families as well.
Requiem for a Star is a brief glimpse into the world Nova inhabits, and it is a brilliant spark. There is much left to be uncovered by the end of this novella and leaves the reader craving more.
This review is also featured on Behind the Pages: Requiem for a Star
Requiem for a Star takes readers on a journey of love and loss with immense emotional depth.. Novella, or as we come to know her as Nova, endures a devastating loss at a young age. Yet through her grief she is able to harness magic, and carry on with her dearly departed’s hope to speak out against the king.
It is not an easy world Nova lives in. Women are persecuted for having powers, and Nova is no exception. Yet Nova is able to process her grief and emotional state through magic. Keyed into specific emotions, by harnessing them and pulling forth emotional understanding, Nova is able to wield power.
As the reader uncovers how magic works in this world, Nova also shares a coming of age story. A story of her first love and their slowly kindled romance through the years. And the risk her wielding power has for not only them, but their families as well.
Requiem for a Star is a brief glimpse into the world Nova inhabits, and it is a brilliant spark. There is much left to be uncovered by the end of this novella and leaves the reader craving more.
December 26, 2024
Read on behalf of Team Behind the Musings for the SFINCS2 contest: 8.5/10
Requiem for a Star packs a lot into a relatively short novella with a coming of age story for its main character, teenager Nova, the acceptance of loss and grief for her older sister, a sweet, heartwarming romance with a local boy, philosophical discussions around the fundamental basics of magic in this world and the secondary place women have in its society during a time of barbaric witch-hunts.
Told in first person from Nova’s perspective there are deep emotions laid bare on the page. Her grief after finding her seventeen-year-old sister, Star had died in her sleep is palpable. As is the burgeoning love she feels for the ever-supportive boy, Neoro, who helped her family bury Star. Her determination to enhance her magical powers and practise until she is as powerful as possible stems from her beloved sister’s beliefs. She hopes to honour Star by following all of her sisters’ dreams and wishes for a future without the persecution of witches, and without their cruel king.
I was sucked into Nova’s story right away and connected with her character well, making this an unputdownable story for me. I really loved the way the sweet relationship between Nova and Neoro was written, beginning coyly and developing into a mutual support system neither could do without.
I believe this novella is a prequel to other works by the author but I found it stood alone well. It has definitely piqued my interest in those other stories.
Requiem for a Star packs a lot into a relatively short novella with a coming of age story for its main character, teenager Nova, the acceptance of loss and grief for her older sister, a sweet, heartwarming romance with a local boy, philosophical discussions around the fundamental basics of magic in this world and the secondary place women have in its society during a time of barbaric witch-hunts.
Told in first person from Nova’s perspective there are deep emotions laid bare on the page. Her grief after finding her seventeen-year-old sister, Star had died in her sleep is palpable. As is the burgeoning love she feels for the ever-supportive boy, Neoro, who helped her family bury Star. Her determination to enhance her magical powers and practise until she is as powerful as possible stems from her beloved sister’s beliefs. She hopes to honour Star by following all of her sisters’ dreams and wishes for a future without the persecution of witches, and without their cruel king.
I was sucked into Nova’s story right away and connected with her character well, making this an unputdownable story for me. I really loved the way the sweet relationship between Nova and Neoro was written, beginning coyly and developing into a mutual support system neither could do without.
I believe this novella is a prequel to other works by the author but I found it stood alone well. It has definitely piqued my interest in those other stories.
October 1, 2024
I read “Requiem for a Star” quickly; the book isn’t all that long, but it is full — full of emotionality and characterization. The imagery and thematic throughline are consistent; they don’t stray from the mark Gutman has set. However, now that I’ve arrived at the point of rating and reviewing it, I’m finding it difficult to ascribe a numerical value to this novella. But why?
I have to start answering this question with another: what five-star rating could one possibly place on an expression of grief? Can the reader measure it solely on its aesthetics, the aerodynamism of the vehicle delivering it? Or, should the author’s attempts at expressing his individual experience of this universal emotion tip the scales in either direction? Honestly, I don’t know.
A couple of years ago, I read Gutman’s debut novel in the Dawnless Night series — Winds of Strife — and, although it also dealt with heavy subject matter, it was easier to understand if not digest. Nye, the main character, is revealed in bits and pieces to be a troubled, abusive reactionary who is (arguably) *just this side* of monstrousness. It’s a story of revenge and transcending revenge to aim for something greater (depending on the POV character you most identify with, of course). The viciousness of the principal protagonist is inextricably bound with the volatility of the emotion-based magic system. Whether or not you can stomach Nye’s choices, you come to understand them — and him.
In “Requiem for a Star,” interestingly, we see a younger Nye (14-15 years old, called “Neoro” at the time), a narrative choice reflective of the Star Wars’ prequels’ highlighting of Anakin’s tragedy. The point of view character in Requiem, however, is Nova. I was excited by this at the start because, in my opinion, Nova has always been an easier character to relate to: existing inside her headspace, especially in first person, did not make my skin crawl in the same way that Nye’s thoughts and actions in Winds of Strife did. Through Nova’s eyes and descriptions, we learn of the terrible loss she suffers, an incident that occurs near the very start of the narrative, suddenly as an axe-blow. We see very little of this doomed character before they’re gone, and we don’t know why or even how, exactly, they died; maybe that is meant to comment on the unexpected, often anti-climactic nature of loss. Perhaps Gutman means to imply that it isn’t like the movies, when someone dies in real life.
I found this to be a compelling idea, one that was rewarding to roll around my mind.
So, that’s the start. Then we meet Neoro, who is a chrysalis of his future Nye-self: shy, quiet, socially awkward. He has yet to experience the trauma that will eventually transform him into the bitter, violent abuser he becomes. Yet, we can already catalog the seeds of those tendencies; we can see coming the ill luck, bad choices, and self-pity that will water and eventually give rise to the gnarled tree of his brutality.
However, during the time of Requiem, he is still capable of relating to other human beings in a somewhat healthier way. And I did feel sorry for him, as I believe I was supposed to. Sorry for who he is going to become but also sorry for who he is now. Between the two books, his characterization put to mind a boy or young man in our modern day who is one handful of 4-Chan posts or Andrew Tate videos away from becoming a full-blown incel. The key difference being that Neoro->Nye will unfortunately develop superpowers. (I’m sure his character arc is headed other places over the course of the trilogy, but this is what we know of him so far.)
The points I’ve described above caused me discomfort, but it was discomfort that served the narration and the author’s intention. It made sense, and I enjoyed making these connections as I read.
This idea of discomfort, though, brings me to the central romance. To quote the synopsis, this book is meant to be “a tiny bit sexy,” which I wasn’t expecting before getting into the story. (I read the full synopsis only after finishing the story.)
I have to say, as an adult man reading a book written by another adult man, I was made uncomfortable by the sexual interactions of two 14/15-year-olds—even though only implied, for the most part. I was put off by that subject matter, but I also felt that these scenes were tonally at odds with the rest of the story.
I found myself asking, who is the target audience? Between Winds of Strife and Requiem, the overall story is decidedly grim dark — not your typical YA+ fare; and, if this is a story geared primarily toward adults, the decision to have *quite a few* implied sex scenes between minors is one I couldn’t wrap my head around. Maybe I overthought it; maybe others’ preferences are at odds with mine; I decided not to alter my rating based on this narrative decision.
There are two areas I feel more at ease discussing:
1. The middle 30-40% of the book (I was reading on Kindle) becomes *intensely* philosophical, involving a series of discussions between the two teen main characters about, among a plethora of other ideas, the meaning of life and how it intersects with the magic system. These frequent conversations ultimately serve a purpose in the narrative, but I feel they could’ve been trimmed somewhat — or, interspersed between a few more bursts of action or outside influences. I enjoy the weaving of philosophy into a narrative; it adds depth and import and so much else to the story. The sheer amount and continuous stream of in Requiem, however, overwhelmed.
2. Writing a younger protagonist while balancing their youth/inexperience with the complexities of plot can be difficult. Maintaining the equilibrium between believability and relatability is a challenge, to be sure — especially in a first-person narrative. At times, the immaturity evident in Nova and Neoro’s words and actions was at odds with the more somber, narratively necessary moments of wisdom they evinced. There were some passages that took me out of the story because of the disconnect between the first-person narration and the more immature language/dialogue into which the characters habitually lapsed.
Now that I've had time to categorize and ruminate...
Clearly I had a lot to say about this book, so it has succeeded in eliciting a strong emotional response. And, clearly, a complicated one. I read Requiem both as a reader and a writer. I’ve given my writerly response. Now, finally, here’s what I would tell prospective readers out there:
If you are looking for a short, honest, ambitious navigation of the choppy seas of grief in an attempt to reach the sunnier shores of catharsis, Requiem could be just what you seek. Dive into its depths for yourself, plumb its recesses and see if it will succor you. Suffering is universal, so we can all potentially relate to the themes explored by this work. And many of us have lost someone far too soon, so we —and I — could imagine the scope of Gutman’s sorrow on behalf of the young woman to whom this book is dedicated.
It is genuinely terrible, the number of souls sacrificed to the machines of war and terrorism. Our drive to kill each other is our most odious weakness as a species. I hope that the author will continue to be a voice for reason and peace. Accordingly, I’m giving this book an aspirational 4/5 stars.
From the murkiness of the seafloor, the muck-like chaos of this life, dear reader, I hope you may find — through a sympathetic link to the characters and world of Gutman’s creation — a salve for your sorrows.
I have to start answering this question with another: what five-star rating could one possibly place on an expression of grief? Can the reader measure it solely on its aesthetics, the aerodynamism of the vehicle delivering it? Or, should the author’s attempts at expressing his individual experience of this universal emotion tip the scales in either direction? Honestly, I don’t know.
A couple of years ago, I read Gutman’s debut novel in the Dawnless Night series — Winds of Strife — and, although it also dealt with heavy subject matter, it was easier to understand if not digest. Nye, the main character, is revealed in bits and pieces to be a troubled, abusive reactionary who is (arguably) *just this side* of monstrousness. It’s a story of revenge and transcending revenge to aim for something greater (depending on the POV character you most identify with, of course). The viciousness of the principal protagonist is inextricably bound with the volatility of the emotion-based magic system. Whether or not you can stomach Nye’s choices, you come to understand them — and him.
In “Requiem for a Star,” interestingly, we see a younger Nye (14-15 years old, called “Neoro” at the time), a narrative choice reflective of the Star Wars’ prequels’ highlighting of Anakin’s tragedy. The point of view character in Requiem, however, is Nova. I was excited by this at the start because, in my opinion, Nova has always been an easier character to relate to: existing inside her headspace, especially in first person, did not make my skin crawl in the same way that Nye’s thoughts and actions in Winds of Strife did. Through Nova’s eyes and descriptions, we learn of the terrible loss she suffers, an incident that occurs near the very start of the narrative, suddenly as an axe-blow. We see very little of this doomed character before they’re gone, and we don’t know why or even how, exactly, they died; maybe that is meant to comment on the unexpected, often anti-climactic nature of loss. Perhaps Gutman means to imply that it isn’t like the movies, when someone dies in real life.
I found this to be a compelling idea, one that was rewarding to roll around my mind.
So, that’s the start. Then we meet Neoro, who is a chrysalis of his future Nye-self: shy, quiet, socially awkward. He has yet to experience the trauma that will eventually transform him into the bitter, violent abuser he becomes. Yet, we can already catalog the seeds of those tendencies; we can see coming the ill luck, bad choices, and self-pity that will water and eventually give rise to the gnarled tree of his brutality.
However, during the time of Requiem, he is still capable of relating to other human beings in a somewhat healthier way. And I did feel sorry for him, as I believe I was supposed to. Sorry for who he is going to become but also sorry for who he is now. Between the two books, his characterization put to mind a boy or young man in our modern day who is one handful of 4-Chan posts or Andrew Tate videos away from becoming a full-blown incel. The key difference being that Neoro->Nye will unfortunately develop superpowers. (I’m sure his character arc is headed other places over the course of the trilogy, but this is what we know of him so far.)
The points I’ve described above caused me discomfort, but it was discomfort that served the narration and the author’s intention. It made sense, and I enjoyed making these connections as I read.
This idea of discomfort, though, brings me to the central romance. To quote the synopsis, this book is meant to be “a tiny bit sexy,” which I wasn’t expecting before getting into the story. (I read the full synopsis only after finishing the story.)
I have to say, as an adult man reading a book written by another adult man, I was made uncomfortable by the sexual interactions of two 14/15-year-olds—even though only implied, for the most part. I was put off by that subject matter, but I also felt that these scenes were tonally at odds with the rest of the story.
I found myself asking, who is the target audience? Between Winds of Strife and Requiem, the overall story is decidedly grim dark — not your typical YA+ fare; and, if this is a story geared primarily toward adults, the decision to have *quite a few* implied sex scenes between minors is one I couldn’t wrap my head around. Maybe I overthought it; maybe others’ preferences are at odds with mine; I decided not to alter my rating based on this narrative decision.
There are two areas I feel more at ease discussing:
1. The middle 30-40% of the book (I was reading on Kindle) becomes *intensely* philosophical, involving a series of discussions between the two teen main characters about, among a plethora of other ideas, the meaning of life and how it intersects with the magic system. These frequent conversations ultimately serve a purpose in the narrative, but I feel they could’ve been trimmed somewhat — or, interspersed between a few more bursts of action or outside influences. I enjoy the weaving of philosophy into a narrative; it adds depth and import and so much else to the story. The sheer amount and continuous stream of in Requiem, however, overwhelmed.
2. Writing a younger protagonist while balancing their youth/inexperience with the complexities of plot can be difficult. Maintaining the equilibrium between believability and relatability is a challenge, to be sure — especially in a first-person narrative. At times, the immaturity evident in Nova and Neoro’s words and actions was at odds with the more somber, narratively necessary moments of wisdom they evinced. There were some passages that took me out of the story because of the disconnect between the first-person narration and the more immature language/dialogue into which the characters habitually lapsed.
Now that I've had time to categorize and ruminate...
Clearly I had a lot to say about this book, so it has succeeded in eliciting a strong emotional response. And, clearly, a complicated one. I read Requiem both as a reader and a writer. I’ve given my writerly response. Now, finally, here’s what I would tell prospective readers out there:
If you are looking for a short, honest, ambitious navigation of the choppy seas of grief in an attempt to reach the sunnier shores of catharsis, Requiem could be just what you seek. Dive into its depths for yourself, plumb its recesses and see if it will succor you. Suffering is universal, so we can all potentially relate to the themes explored by this work. And many of us have lost someone far too soon, so we —and I — could imagine the scope of Gutman’s sorrow on behalf of the young woman to whom this book is dedicated.
It is genuinely terrible, the number of souls sacrificed to the machines of war and terrorism. Our drive to kill each other is our most odious weakness as a species. I hope that the author will continue to be a voice for reason and peace. Accordingly, I’m giving this book an aspirational 4/5 stars.
From the murkiness of the seafloor, the muck-like chaos of this life, dear reader, I hope you may find — through a sympathetic link to the characters and world of Gutman’s creation — a salve for your sorrows.
July 1, 2024
"This is my quest to follow that star
No matter how hopeless, no matter how far"
These immortal lines from "The Impossible Dream" came to my mind as I read "Requiem for a Star."
A young girl follows a star she knows is impossible to reach. And yet she tries and strives. The child grows, and we grow with her, with all the implications of life. Loss, love, pain, and happiness—it's all there. She sets on a course to become a witch—and becomes a powerful one—not because life is perfect but because she learns to harness the hardship and the good. It is a story about growth as much as it is about love.
The line from the song "To Bear with unbearable sorrow" fits right in there. The melancholy throughout the book is not there to smack the reader down with sadness. No, it's there to show the strength a person can have when confronting one's emotions.
It's hard to ignore the context in which the book was written and the personal - and even more than personal - pain the author and his surroundings experienced. This turmoil of emotion is expressed in a tapestry of emotions, relationships, and the philosophy of "the world is bad, but we will make it better!".
As a "Winds of Strife" fan, I've been eagerly waiting for another glimpse of this amazing world with its emotional magic (Senspirity). "Requiem for a Star" delivers that and more in a well-written novella.
No matter how hopeless, no matter how far"
These immortal lines from "The Impossible Dream" came to my mind as I read "Requiem for a Star."
A young girl follows a star she knows is impossible to reach. And yet she tries and strives. The child grows, and we grow with her, with all the implications of life. Loss, love, pain, and happiness—it's all there. She sets on a course to become a witch—and becomes a powerful one—not because life is perfect but because she learns to harness the hardship and the good. It is a story about growth as much as it is about love.
The line from the song "To Bear with unbearable sorrow" fits right in there. The melancholy throughout the book is not there to smack the reader down with sadness. No, it's there to show the strength a person can have when confronting one's emotions.
It's hard to ignore the context in which the book was written and the personal - and even more than personal - pain the author and his surroundings experienced. This turmoil of emotion is expressed in a tapestry of emotions, relationships, and the philosophy of "the world is bad, but we will make it better!".
As a "Winds of Strife" fan, I've been eagerly waiting for another glimpse of this amazing world with its emotional magic (Senspirity). "Requiem for a Star" delivers that and more in a well-written novella.
July 25, 2024
There is much I could say about this novella and its place within the Dawless Night series. It expands nicely on the world, the characters, and the magic system. It shows the author's growth with the written word from their previous novel. And it is a pleasant romance and coming-of-age piece, even for someone like myself who reads few of these stories.
But first and foremost, this is a tale of grief and growing alongside it. Woven through the worldbuilding and the love and the magic is a story of someone trying to figure out who they are after loss. Nova is a masterwork of characterisation in this regard, and I think anyone going through loss will find strength and comfort from her story. It is a universal tale, even if it may not feel like it in the moment, and for readers, knowing that they are not alone in their struggle is incredibly important.
I look forward to seeing where this series goes next, and thank you once again to the author for sending me an eARC.
But first and foremost, this is a tale of grief and growing alongside it. Woven through the worldbuilding and the love and the magic is a story of someone trying to figure out who they are after loss. Nova is a masterwork of characterisation in this regard, and I think anyone going through loss will find strength and comfort from her story. It is a universal tale, even if it may not feel like it in the moment, and for readers, knowing that they are not alone in their struggle is incredibly important.
I look forward to seeing where this series goes next, and thank you once again to the author for sending me an eARC.
July 10, 2024
I liked this book a lot even thought I am not much of a romance reader. It had great balance between Nova studying and her realationship with Neoro.
I always enjoy books that give you backstory of the character you alteady know and love.
This book was great it had romance, it had sadness and grief.
I liked Nova a lot and her passion to learn more and do good by her sister is great.
Quick and easy read so if you want to read something short and bittersweet grab it!
I always enjoy books that give you backstory of the character you alteady know and love.
This book was great it had romance, it had sadness and grief.
I liked Nova a lot and her passion to learn more and do good by her sister is great.
Quick and easy read so if you want to read something short and bittersweet grab it!
August 8, 2024
Requiem for a Star is a very good novella that is set in the world of Winds of Strife, a world in which the nights are getting longer and no one knows why.
It’s a prequel story that happens 15 years prior to the events in Winds of Strife.
The story focuses on Nova when she was still a teenager, but also on Neoro (who will later be known as Nye).
While it's nice to go back and learn about the life events that shaped Nova and Nye if you've read Winds of Strife, having any prior knowledge from "Winds of Strife" is just a bonus, but definitely not required.
Actually, I think it serves as a good introduction to the world.
Writing style: Good and flows well. A few times I felt that a more "powerful" style could have
done a good service to the book. 4/5
Characterization: The story focuses on two characters, Nova and Neoro (Nye). We see how they develop over the years and the impact they have on one another. They are well-developed and rounded characters. The villains are also well-portrayed and interesting. 4.25/5
World-building and Magic-system: We are introduced to the world of "The Dawnless Night," where the nights are getting longer. In this world, females who use Senspirit powers are considered witches and are persecuted by the king and his men, who use the same powers.
We learn about the innovative, feelings-related magic system, which will make Sanderson fans feel at home.
4.25/5
Plot:
To be continued
4.25/5
It’s a prequel story that happens 15 years prior to the events in Winds of Strife.
The story focuses on Nova when she was still a teenager, but also on Neoro (who will later be known as Nye).
While it's nice to go back and learn about the life events that shaped Nova and Nye if you've read Winds of Strife, having any prior knowledge from "Winds of Strife" is just a bonus, but definitely not required.
Actually, I think it serves as a good introduction to the world.
Writing style: Good and flows well. A few times I felt that a more "powerful" style could have
done a good service to the book. 4/5
Characterization: The story focuses on two characters, Nova and Neoro (Nye). We see how they develop over the years and the impact they have on one another. They are well-developed and rounded characters. The villains are also well-portrayed and interesting. 4.25/5
World-building and Magic-system: We are introduced to the world of "The Dawnless Night," where the nights are getting longer. In this world, females who use Senspirit powers are considered witches and are persecuted by the king and his men, who use the same powers.
We learn about the innovative, feelings-related magic system, which will make Sanderson fans feel at home.
4.25/5
Plot:
To be continued
4.25/5
July 14, 2024
Firstly, I'd like to thank the author for sending me an eARC - much appreciated.
I found this book incredibly beautiful. The imagery is just *chef's kiss*. The romance elements are touching and sweet and the climax is thrilling and powerful.
The book is about a character named Novella (Nova) who loses her sister and afterwards falls in love with a boy named Neoro, who is Nye in Winds of Strife, the book to which this is a prequel. Requiem gives a ton of world building and background to Winds of Strife, and all using beautiful prose. I found it incredibly touching and heartfelt. I particularly enjoyed the new perspectives of the magic system. Overall, 5/5 for imagery, world building, and emotional impact
The eulogy at the end made me cry. I have no words for it.
I found this book incredibly beautiful. The imagery is just *chef's kiss*. The romance elements are touching and sweet and the climax is thrilling and powerful.
The book is about a character named Novella (Nova) who loses her sister and afterwards falls in love with a boy named Neoro, who is Nye in Winds of Strife, the book to which this is a prequel. Requiem gives a ton of world building and background to Winds of Strife, and all using beautiful prose. I found it incredibly touching and heartfelt. I particularly enjoyed the new perspectives of the magic system. Overall, 5/5 for imagery, world building, and emotional impact
The eulogy at the end made me cry. I have no words for it.
July 5, 2024
Wonderful , sensitive, story, about a girl who experienced terrible loss, and through that pain, finds her power and womanhood. This book is taking place in the Winds Of Strife world, which is the the author first book, and also contains detailed explanation about the magic system.
The tone of the book is quite, gentle and sad.
Highly recommend
The tone of the book is quite, gentle and sad.
Highly recommend
March 30, 2025
Short fantasy Novella featuring Nova. It was fine, but I was a bit disappointed to learn all about different magical abilities only to see them barely touched on in the novella. Maybe they’re more relevant in the affiliated series? I didn’t think this was terribly satisfying as a standalone read. I read the ebook on Kindle unlimited.
August 20, 2024
4.5/5
A beautiful exploration of grief, love, and growing up. I thoroughly enjoyed this short read! Some of the magic stuff was a bit tricky to understand, but I was fully immersed in Nova's narrative. What a great character.
A beautiful exploration of grief, love, and growing up. I thoroughly enjoyed this short read! Some of the magic stuff was a bit tricky to understand, but I was fully immersed in Nova's narrative. What a great character.
August 19, 2024
I felt so much sadness and grief through out the whole of this book. But I also felt discovery of one’s strength.
So much about this story resonates with me! The description of grief and what it does to Nova is beautiful written. It unpacks the processes one goes through in grief but also in how Nova uses this to her advantage in finding her powers. It’s a coming of age story that has a side of romance. The romance is brief but also beautiful. It shows true resilience in young love and discovery.
There is a magic world where powers are connected to feelings.
I love story’s that have so much feeling in them and this is definitely one high on my list and will be put into a favourite category.
So much about this story resonates with me! The description of grief and what it does to Nova is beautiful written. It unpacks the processes one goes through in grief but also in how Nova uses this to her advantage in finding her powers. It’s a coming of age story that has a side of romance. The romance is brief but also beautiful. It shows true resilience in young love and discovery.
There is a magic world where powers are connected to feelings.
I love story’s that have so much feeling in them and this is definitely one high on my list and will be put into a favourite category.
May 30, 2024
4.5 stars
I was kindly given an ARC to read by the author. And I'm very glad he did because I really enjoyed it!
This is the same author as Winds of Strife, which I really enjoyed as well when it came out (eagerly awaiting the sequel). This is actually a prequel novella that can be read without having read Winds of Strife, but also works very well for the people who have already read it.
I liked the main character, Nova. She was great; her story was interesting. The dialogue was really good and there was some very cool magic moments towards the end. And I really appreciate the dedication at the end, it was very lovely.
The only thing i wanted more of in the story was the parents; I would have liked to get more of how they felt about everything that was going on.
I definitely enjoyed it, I think people can definitely read this before they read Winds of Strife and have a good time with it. And for the fans who are waiting patiently for book 2 to drop, this is a very cool addition to the world, and overall a really cool character study.
I was kindly given an ARC to read by the author. And I'm very glad he did because I really enjoyed it!
This is the same author as Winds of Strife, which I really enjoyed as well when it came out (eagerly awaiting the sequel). This is actually a prequel novella that can be read without having read Winds of Strife, but also works very well for the people who have already read it.
I liked the main character, Nova. She was great; her story was interesting. The dialogue was really good and there was some very cool magic moments towards the end. And I really appreciate the dedication at the end, it was very lovely.
The only thing i wanted more of in the story was the parents; I would have liked to get more of how they felt about everything that was going on.
I definitely enjoyed it, I think people can definitely read this before they read Winds of Strife and have a good time with it. And for the fans who are waiting patiently for book 2 to drop, this is a very cool addition to the world, and overall a really cool character study.
Displaying 1 - 19 of 19 reviews