What do you think?
Rate this book
花君と恋する私 [Hana-kun to Koisuru Watashi] #8
花君と恋する私 8 [Hana-kun to Koisuru Watashi 8]
やっと、停学から戻ってきた花君。嬉しいハズの七世なのに、ちょっとの間にすれ違ってできた心の距離が取り戻せず、なんだかぎこちなくなってしまう二人。そしてついに、花君の口から「離れよう」という一言が…!! 花君の言葉に七世が選んだ答えは――!? そしてふたりの気持ちはこのまま本当に離れていってしまうのか? 超ヒット・学園きゅん恋、急展開の第8巻。
192 pages, Paperback
First published March 13, 2014
5 people are currently reading
30 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 11 of 11 reviews
May 27, 2021
Hana is back from suspension, but that hasn’t prompted the resumption of romance between himself and Nanase. As the two drift ever further apart, it feels like things are absolutely hopeless, and, well, they are when two dummies are involved.
Imagine one of those sci-if tropes where the ship is trapped in a decaying orbit or runs out of fuel and disaster is looming. Now imagine this scenario, but the ship has full power and fuel, it’s just that nobody can be bothered to take charge and they simply let disaster happen. That’s this book.
Hana and Nanase break up and for seemingly no reason whatsoever. There’s some nonsense later on where Hana comments that he was letting Nanase fill too much of a mother role for him, which is very out of nowhere. This is, in turn, countered by somebody giving him advice that is such howlingly bad psychology that I had to put the book down to collect myself.
But the crux of this is that it happens and even though it is blatantly obvious nobody wants this, they let it happen anyway. There was a minimal fight, if it could even be called that, and they were separated for A WEEK while Hana was suspended and that’s all it takes for their entire relationship to implode? Really!?
Look, I get it, fumbled, awkward words hurt bad (trust me, been there as both giver and receiver). But they shouldn’t cause this much damage when these two were doing amazing up to that point. It doesn’t have any logic behind it and, while I like the idea of exploring a break in a relationship, nothing here makes narrative sense.
And again, it’s not like situations don’t spiral out of control for no good reason, but I cannot for the life of me get my head around the way the story tries to justify the events of this volume and it turns into a lot of moping that shouldn’t have happened and nothing that a five minute conversation wouldn’t fix.
Is there some good stuff? Yes, yes there is. I love the burgeoning friendship between Nanase and Asaki, who is one of Hana’s female friends. Asaki’s freewheeling nature makes her a fun counterpart to Nanase and having a male lead with an actual female friend is a nice touch (it can be done!).
Nanase’s friend Kouko gets a boyfriend this volume and the story of how is the bonus manga and it’s better than the actual main narrative this time around. A simple tale of two people who form a connection out of nowhere, it really ends this book on a far better note than it might deserve.
2.5 stars and my lingering affection for the series rounds it up, just barely. Make no mistake though, I think this is one of the dumbest manga breakups I have ever read and some of the silliest baloney drama in recent memory.
Imagine one of those sci-if tropes where the ship is trapped in a decaying orbit or runs out of fuel and disaster is looming. Now imagine this scenario, but the ship has full power and fuel, it’s just that nobody can be bothered to take charge and they simply let disaster happen. That’s this book.
Hana and Nanase break up and for seemingly no reason whatsoever. There’s some nonsense later on where Hana comments that he was letting Nanase fill too much of a mother role for him, which is very out of nowhere. This is, in turn, countered by somebody giving him advice that is such howlingly bad psychology that I had to put the book down to collect myself.
But the crux of this is that it happens and even though it is blatantly obvious nobody wants this, they let it happen anyway. There was a minimal fight, if it could even be called that, and they were separated for A WEEK while Hana was suspended and that’s all it takes for their entire relationship to implode? Really!?
Look, I get it, fumbled, awkward words hurt bad (trust me, been there as both giver and receiver). But they shouldn’t cause this much damage when these two were doing amazing up to that point. It doesn’t have any logic behind it and, while I like the idea of exploring a break in a relationship, nothing here makes narrative sense.
And again, it’s not like situations don’t spiral out of control for no good reason, but I cannot for the life of me get my head around the way the story tries to justify the events of this volume and it turns into a lot of moping that shouldn’t have happened and nothing that a five minute conversation wouldn’t fix.
Is there some good stuff? Yes, yes there is. I love the burgeoning friendship between Nanase and Asaki, who is one of Hana’s female friends. Asaki’s freewheeling nature makes her a fun counterpart to Nanase and having a male lead with an actual female friend is a nice touch (it can be done!).
Nanase’s friend Kouko gets a boyfriend this volume and the story of how is the bonus manga and it’s better than the actual main narrative this time around. A simple tale of two people who form a connection out of nowhere, it really ends this book on a far better note than it might deserve.
2.5 stars and my lingering affection for the series rounds it up, just barely. Make no mistake though, I think this is one of the dumbest manga breakups I have ever read and some of the silliest baloney drama in recent memory.
July 7, 2017
Setelah skors selesai, Hana-kun malah ngajak putus...huhu. Alasannya konyol. Dia tidak mau tergantung sama Nanase. Udah gitu Nanase iya-iya aja... padahal masih sama-sama suka.
February 24, 2023
I really appreciate how quiet the characters' pain is. Not all relationships cause drama, even with teenagers.
July 5, 2017
Tulis review lengkap nanti klo sempat, sudah keburu ter-Bakuman...
Ya ampun, aku jadi pengen baca [Reversi] serial baru Ashirogi Muto sensei yang baru...
Ya ampun, aku jadi pengen baca [Reversi] serial baru Ashirogi Muto sensei yang baru...
Read
December 30, 2021The drama, the angst. Sigh. I want to give both of them a kick.
February 26, 2022
Part 29: From Tomorrow
Part 30: Right Now, It's Still
Part 31: I Want to Be Involved
Part 32: The Time I Loved Hana-kun
*Special Short* When We're in Love (Extra) ～Kouko～
Part 30: Right Now, It's Still
Part 31: I Want to Be Involved
Part 32: The Time I Loved Hana-kun
*Special Short* When We're in Love (Extra) ～Kouko～
August 27, 2022
Akhirnya ada titik terang dari permasalahan mereka. Untung aja ada sahabat yang menasehati Hana. Rasanya terharu sekali.
June 13, 2023
Nota real: 3,5⭐️
7/10⭐️
7/10⭐️
September 11, 2019
Ma è questa storia delle due settimana di separazione che non mi torna... Davvero son necessarie solo due settimane affinché una storia si raffreddi.
Le scene preferite: quando Nanase toglie la maschera nei confronti delle amiche e quando Hana va a riprendersi Nanase. L'ho sempre scritto che l'autrice è un drago a concludere i volumetti!
Le scene preferite: quando Nanase toglie la maschera nei confronti delle amiche e quando Hana va a riprendersi Nanase. L'ho sempre scritto che l'autrice è un drago a concludere i volumetti!
August 26, 2024
HAHAHAHAHHA BALIKAN??
Displaying 1 - 11 of 11 reviews