Review: Act Like a Man
I felt that Act Like a Man was pretty bad. The scripture references were at times taken out of context, and the overall tone sounded more like a complainer—which is the antithesis of “acting like a man.” The book leaned heavily on the lion and lamb imagery. While I understand the metaphor, it felt overbearing on the lion side, giving the impression of aggression without the balance of grace.
If the author wants to critique the church, I’m actually fine with that. The church should be its own harshest critic. Jesus himself was extremely direct with the Jewish leaders of his day, but toward those outside the faith he showed grace, reason, and a measured urgency. This book, however, showed little of that grace for the lost.
I had no idea who Mark Driscoll was before reading this. As I went through the book, I found myself thinking: “This guy seems pretty aggressive.” Out of curiosity, I looked him up and discovered he was a pastor with a checkered past and other very lets just say "creative" writing—uh oh. Then I read more about Mars Hill, and suddenly the tone of the book made complete sense. I’m not one to go hunting for controversies in people. However, when it comes to spiritual authors, it is critical to know who you’ve decided to read and be influenced by.
By contrast, I’ve been reading Tim Keller. My reaction was the exact opposite. His writing struck me as thoughtful and measured, so I looked him up and wasn't surprised when I found that he lived a measured and Godly life through and through. His literature I can wholeheartedly recommend.
Bottom line: This book fails to model the kind of servant-hearted strength men—particularly those in marriage or considering marriage—are called to. It reads more like frustration than formation. If you want a biblically faithful, grace-filled picture of manhood, skip this book and reach for Keller instead.