Does any picture of Jesus violate the Second Commandment?
The answer is, "No." That's what Pastor Jeffrey J. Meyers contends in response to Peter Barnes's booklet, "Seeing The Case Against Pictures of Our Lord Jesus Christ."
Any attempt to mediate the divine presence through an image is, indeed, a violation of the Second Commandment, but in this book Meyers lays out a biblical and theological argument for a limited use of pictures of Jesus.
Specifically, Meyers argues the historical Christ, if shown within a historical setting as detailed in Scriptures, does not violate the Second Commandment and may be of great value, both educationally and artistically.
Beyond the question of when we may use or enjoy pictures of Jesus, Meyers' book also sketches out a theology of art and the Christian imagination.
The "Answers in an Hour" series is an ongoing collection of short and easily digestible books written with the inquirer in mind. These little books provide brief studies of various topics of interest to Christians who seek instruction that is grounded in biblical theology.
This one was just plain helpful. I had always had a simple interpretation of the second commandment when it came to pictures of Jesus which was "you know it when you see it." I knew the Mormon Jesus portrait was bad, but the Ghent Altarpiece was good. Meyers really helped me flesh out the biblical reasons for why that's the case. I was a little caught off guard by how polemical and sarcastic he was at times, but his arguments were sound. Recommend.
2.5 for the historical section, some interesting comments there.
I would like to write out a fuller review but one of my main complaints that I will likely forget if I don’t put it down now is that he is perfectly willing to insist that any prohibitions against worshipping images do not undermine his position while unwilling to acknowledge that sources that explicitly prohibit “making” of images without distinction do undermine his position.
For example, if someone or a confessional document argues that second commandment prohibits the MAKING of images of God, I do not think it is reasonable to assert that that person or document is only prohibiting making images for worship unless the person or document actually makes that distinction. Similarly if the person or confession prohibits making images of GOD, I also don’t think it is reasonable to assert that it only means the divine essence and doesn’t prohibit making images of the Incarnate Son unless there is something in the document or discussion surrounding the formation of the document to suggest otherwise.
Bullinger’s presence was noticeably absent from this booklet. He has a pretty explicit argument against making images of God in Decades and the Second Helvetic has a whole section against the making images of Jesus. Granted this is only 89 pages but given Bullinger’s influence on Protestant England, the absence is noteworthy.
The lack of engagement with the stream of iconoclasm in Anglicanism was also noteworthy to me. An offhanded mention of Anglicans removing certain stained glass is mentioned but not dug into beyond that. The Homily Against the Peril of Idolatry that calls images of Jesus “lying images” would have been important context for the Westminster assembly but this also goes unmentioned.