Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
Gavin Wilkes is rugby’s biggest star and my older brother’s best friend.
He’s tall, dark, handsome… and a notorious player—not just in the sportsball way.
For years he’s teased me—flirted with me as a joke—and I’m tired of it. So the night of my parents’ annual Christmas party, I call his bluff, never expecting him to take me up on it.
He does. Many times.
At my place. At his place. In my mom’s she shed and the back of a bar.
Not once does it cross my mind that our little meet-ups might lead to more. That I might be the woman who makes Gavin want to settle down.
Especially since he’d have to risk everything to make me his.
Maybe I’ll just make him mine.

258 pages, Kindle Edition

First published October 25, 2024

338 people are currently reading
489 people want to read

About the author

Josie Watts

8 books81 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
455 (37%)
4 stars
457 (37%)
3 stars
254 (20%)
2 stars
47 (3%)
1 star
4 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 96 reviews
Profile Image for niki_reads_romance.
883 reviews9 followers
November 4, 2024
perfect

Gah! This story was fantastic! Funny, tense, sexy and interesting, I could not set it down. Scary Terry and Cilantro were excellent additions to a completely lovable cast of characters. What is it about pets that makes books even better? Also, the cameos to previous stories were fabulous. I appreciated that they weren’t really in depth, so any new reader could read this without feeling lost or confused. Gavin and Alexis had a whole bunch of personal and family issues to overcome and “watching” them discover each others truth was *chefs kiss*
Profile Image for Stephanie Mellott.
27 reviews
December 28, 2025
3.75⭐️

I found Alexis a little hard to read and felt like I was waiting for her to flip a switch for most of the book. However, I loved Gavin and the girlfriend group! There were definitely some relatable moments, like never having enough sushi, and the use of unexpected pets was great.
Profile Image for Lisa MK.
119 reviews4 followers
November 24, 2024
Cute, Fun Holiday Read

This book was wonderfully adorable with a MMC that is all waving green flags. It’s a quick and fun read that I adored. I will absolutely be reading more from this author!
Profile Image for Meredith Richardson.
440 reviews11 followers
November 5, 2024
This was such a fun little read! The brother's best friend trope was well played throughout. I also found it really refreshing that Alexis had a strong backbone and RBF.
Profile Image for Margaret.
79 reviews
November 7, 2024
Cute

Just the book I needed to get me in the holiday spirit. Loved it. Alexis is the MFC I strive to be in life.
Profile Image for Angie.
5 reviews
May 20, 2025
Very cute fun read that isn’t as christmas-y as I thought so it’s totally fine that I read it in May 🙃
10 reviews1 follower
December 14, 2024
Mistle-Ho - Josie Watts

A brother’s best friend rugby romance.

4 STARS & 3 CHILIS
A quick and enjoyable Christmas read with the perfect amount of spice that made me laugh out loud on multiple occasions.

Note
I personally don’t read any trigger warnings before starting a book. For me, it spoils the story if I know to expect specific triggering content. I also don’t make note of possible triggers in my review. If you have triggers, check them.

My rating system
1 star - DNF/bad writing and poor plot, not interesting
2 stars - below average, bad writing/plot, sometimes interesting, wouldn’t recommend
3 stars - Good book, worth reading, wouldn’t read again, might recommend
4 stars - Mostly great book, would read again and would recommend
5 stars - Excellent book.
Soul book - Rare, books that touch my soul, they stay with me long after I read them, often I re-read these books multiple times.
Spice
1 chilli - PG, no spice/fade to black romance
2 chilis - a couple of spicy scenes
3 chilis - spicy romance scenes that are appropriate in the plot of the book. spice and plot equally good
4 chilis - plentiful spicy scenes, descriptive and possibly kinky, spicy scenes every chance the characters get
5 chilis - mostly smut, not much plot

***Possible Spoilers Ahead***

Opening Line

As I climb the stairs leading to the porch of my parents’ stucco two-story, my already bad mood sours further.


Review

Alexis is the introvert of her family. She’s not happy and bubbly and suffers a case of resting bitch face. Gavin, her brothers best friend, is the sexy rugby superstar that’s been part of the family since they were all kids. Alexis tries to deny her feelings for her long time crush, acting irritable when Gavin is exceptionally thoughtful by gifting her a new scarf after noticing her favourite one is falling apart

I don’t know why he would remember something like that, or what in the hell would possess him to get this for me, but I don’t want it. Even though I kinda want it.


Their flirtation turns physical the night of her parents Christmas party with Gavin unable to hold back…
Alexis tells her friends about Gavins ‘speed’ which he suspects when he saves Alexis from her creepy colleague at the bar
Well, isn’t that interesting. I’m feeling a little cocky over Al telling them about my skill as a player, but then it occurs to me that might not be the sort of speed she’s told these women about. We might actually be discussing the events of her parents’ Christmas party, and my dumb ass is too stupid to know it.


Not without hiccups, their relationship starts as friends with benefits as Gavin doesn’t want anything serious, until he does.
We’re not more than a situation. I don’t like the way she said it. So easily. As if it never crossed her mind to want more. It’s not like I want her to want more, but she could’ve at least considered it.


Best

Gavin nicknames Alexis; Al. Man I love it when guys have a unique name for their girl. He also has some affectionate names for the guys of Alexis’ history, Hugo aka Huge-Nose and Dillon aka Dill-hole.
He also notices Alexis in ways her own family don’t.
He asked where Leo was, but not Alexis. It digs under my skin because that’s the kind of shit that makes her think no one cares when she’s gone. She’s still wrong though. Someone does notice when she leaves. Always.

There are displays of jealousy from Gavin, as well as a few saviour moments where he stops Alexis from being assaulted. For those who love a hero.

Alexis is an imperfect main character and i love that she isn’t the happy bubbly girl.
To be fair, I’m starting to think going out with any guy is a terrible fucking idea.

Her character stays authentic throughout the book too, which is a huge plus for me. there’s nothing worse than the main character having a personality transplant for the sake of the plot.

Worst

This book has the 'brothers best friend' trope which I don’t love. This trope bothers me because If the thought of your best friend with your sister is upsetting, maybe you should pick better friends, or speak up when they behave poorly to women. And if they don’t behave poorly towards women (which Gavin doesn’t), then why have an issue with your sister doing what she wants. If both parties are fully informed and fully willing then why have an issue with it?
Before getting with Alexis, Gavin sleeps around, sure, but he is always honest with his partners. And those partners are never forced or coerced so whats the problem?

Overall this one was cute and fun, a couple serious moments and a few quirky ones.
Profile Image for Betty.
498 reviews36 followers
December 1, 2024
This was such a cute story!! Don’t let the cover fool you! Read this lovely little story!

- no third act breakup
- smart, mature characters
- good character growth/communication
- dual POV/HEA
- curvy FMC and cinnamon roll MMC (“the wall”)
- also anxiety rep w the FMC being an introvert in an extroverted world
- cute side kick animals
- no OM/OW
- good spice

Gavin is a rugby player who is a giant sweetie but afraid to love/care for someone bc of his terrible parents. Alexis is his best friend’s sister; she thinks he’s been teasing her when he’s nice, but in reality he genuinely likes her and her sassy/snarky attitude.

This is the story of them growing together, trusting each other, communicating throughout, holding each other accountable and supporting each other as they grow and deal w family issues.

Love love love how protective they were of each other.

Low angst but also lots of lovely emotions. A little hug of a book.

Best moments - in no order - spoilers ✋)
- all the teasing about how long he would last after their first encounter in the tree house.
- when he explained about his jealousy after finding her w Dillon ( he was attacking her in the office after she rebuffed his advances); how understanding she was w him
- how when she made a small comment he held her accountable and made her tell him what was on her mind. All the open communication about their feelings
- how he learned to knit so he could make her a scarf like her grandma. In the epilogue, how she wore it even when it was hot outside
- how her grandma loved him and gave him her recipe book and he cooked her those meals and worried that it would be “too much”
- how she stood up to his dad when he came to visit at the end and told him “you’re not allowed to hurt him”
- when she went home w him and dealt w the lizard and cat situation
Profile Image for Brayzen Bookwyrm.
379 reviews51 followers
October 21, 2024
Y’all, you need to read this book. Looking for something fun, engaging, entertaining, snortlaugh funny with really beautiful reflections of real life emotions and feelings within larger-than-life hilarity? This is your book. It is my favorite Josie Watts story to-date. (Dare I say even one of my favorite Janice Whiteaker books? Yes, yes I dare.) If you are a fan of Pippa Grant and Kayley Loring, you’ve got to read this book.

What I love about it:

On-point humor, all the way through

So much delightful & fun banter

Down-to-earth characters in hilarious situations I can almost imagine happening

A confident, curvy realistic heroine I absolutely adore!

Rubgy thighs. Enough said.

Chapter 14! New pet, anyone?

Fully standalone readable.

My margin notes included:

DED! I. Am. F*cking. DED!

I just laughed so hard I think I peed a little!

...aaand, I just cackled.

Bahahahahaha! (too many to count)

NICE! (also too many to count)

OMD, I freaking love this!!! (several times)

F*cking hell! Tea! Everyf*ckingwhere!

Mistle-Ho is the first novel in the Cape Coral Swamp Cats: Rugby and Romance series, is 100% standalone readable, but takes place in Josie Watts’s Sweet Side community. And the hilarity there is pretty fantastic, so I definitely recommend diving into those, too. You’ll meet several Sweet Side characters in Mistle-Ho, and yeah, you’re gonna want their stories too. But, you can read Mistle-Ho first and then dive into the Sweet Side Series.
Profile Image for Sara Jane.
523 reviews4 followers
December 23, 2024
FMC is grumpy, which is fine
MMC is sunshine, which is great
He was so amazing, and she shit on him throughout the book. I refuse to believe she got an HEA.

There were a few things unresolved/unaddressed in the book.

She loved MMC all through high school, and they flirted all the time. She overheard him saying something that caused her to think it was all fake flirting on his part. For 5 years, she held a grudge, and the author never told us exactly what was said.
The whole book was centered around her hating him because of it. She was even hateful and aggressive about it, but the MCs didn't discuss it. We didn't even get a flashback or anything?

MMC decided, 6 months ago, that he was tired of one night stands and decided to remain celibate. (MCs never discussed)
The MCs ran into each other at the family Christmas party, and MMC gifts her with a beautiful scarf, which she decides she wants to throw away after she leaves.
They end up talking, and he tells he flirting is real, and she says to prove it. He responds, "Meet me in the treehouse 15 minutes."
They get to the treehouse, and 2 secs after she grabs his dick he blows on her dress. She runs away pissed because he got it on her new dress. 🙄🙄🙄
SHE TOLDS ALL HER FRIENDS, AND HE IS A LAUGHING STOCK THE REST OF THE BOOK.

FMC friends even laughed in his face at the bar, mentioning that FMC told them how quick he was. When he walks away from them, he ending up saving her from a drunk guy who cornered her at the bathroom..
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Just a Reader.
109 reviews3 followers
October 25, 2024

She's a whole pile of attitude packed into a tiny package, and I love it.
The attitude, and the package.


This is an ARC review!
Mistle-Ho releases October 25th 🖤

Alexis always had a crush on her brother's best friend Gavin, but it never was reciprocated. Or so she thought. Gavin's feelings change with time and his infatuation for Al only grew. Can this frenemies became lovers?
In fact he was at lovers from the start!

Christmas arrived early this year 🤣

I read this story in a heartbeat ❤️
We knew Gavin from Filthy Liar (he's Fynn's neighbour), and I was excited to read this man falling in love. And I loved every line in this book. Gavin is a huge teddy bear with the dirtiest mouth you can imagine. The perfect ballance between hot and caring.
Alexis is the kind of girl that has a resting bitch face and nobody knows when she's joking. But in fact she's just an introspective person that needs to be confortable to shine. And Gavin is her safe place. A man that can handle his woman is a big turn on.
✨ This match? HEAVEN! ✨
And I need to mention their size diference - It was the ice in the cake for me 🥵 🔥
This story is funny, sweet, sexy, hot, and all the best things you can come up with in a book!
And I also knew more about iguannas as pets, so this story has lots of information too 🦎🤣

This book is the first in Rugby and Romance series.

P.S. I already read the blurb of the next book (because I'm a curious little thing) and you abso-fucking-lutely won me with the suprise pregnancy trope! 💎
Profile Image for LadyJane.
76 reviews2 followers
November 10, 2024
Once again, Janice Whiteaker, writing as Josie Watts, has tapped into her first-rate sense of humor and given us a fun book with yummy spice added in!

I liked Gavin in the previous book, Filthy Liar, but I love him in Mistle-Ho! He’s a genuinely nice guy who has decided to finally give in to his feelings for his best friend’s little sister. Gavin appreciates her for who she is and respects what she is able to do for herself. And he’s a cuddler. Who doesn’t appreciate a big, rugby-playing cuddler?

Alexis is an introvert with great snarky lines that she throws out when she's done with people. She has a fashion sense that highlights her comfort with her beautiful, curvy body. Her gang of friends is supportive and quirky. At first, she can't believe Gavin's flirting is for real. Oh, he's interested, and things get good between them!

The banter is perfect and well-written. Even though it’s a rom-com, the story wasn’t short on background for the main characters. Both characters explored their past feelings and insecurities. To top it off, a five-foot-long iguana and a cat named Cilantro are cute side characters that added to the mix of different personalities.

I enjoyed having a quick read that made me laugh. I wasn’t interested in rugby players before, but I am now!
Profile Image for Destany.
454 reviews18 followers
November 8, 2024
I rcvd an ARC of this book. All thoughts are my own.

Holy cow, Gavin Wilkes is a god among men. He knows what he wants, and what he wants, what he's always wanted, is his best friend's sister, Alexis. But Gavin's smart enough not to betray his best friend, right? haha yeah right. He unwittingly falls into situation after situation where he's alone with Al, and things start to heat up.

With a side plot featuring Al's brother and his girlfriend, the stories are told in tandem. This means we'll get that story next, and I'm super excited! Ok, but wait, back to Gavin and Al. They've been in each other's orbit for a while, and Gavin has even spent holidays with Al's family. She, of course, had a massive crush on him. When their worlds finally collide, *fans self* Gavin treats Al like she deserves to be treated, and as they start to fall for each other, they both fall hard and fast.

I love the attention to small details that Janice/Josie puts in her stories. Small details like quirky pets and sweet friends. I can't wait to see what's next!
Profile Image for Jessica Lynne.
267 reviews10 followers
October 28, 2024
TITLE: Mistle Ho
AUTHOR: Josie Watts
SERIES: Cape Coral Swamp Cats
SERIES ORDER: 1 of ???
RELEASE DATE: 10/25/2024
GENRE: Holiday Romance
RATING: ❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥
------------------
DISCLAIMER: I voluntarily read and reviewed an advance copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

I absolutely loved this story! I think this might be my favorite Josie Watts story so far! She made these characters, this story, come to life so vibrantly!

I loved Gavin and Alexis! I loved how they treated and respected each other! Gavin might be my favorite Janice/Josie hero yet!

I am so looking forward to The Ruckup, the next book in the Cape Coral Swamp Cats series! Outside of Gavin and Alexis, I absolutely loved the glimpses of Leo and Maddie in this, and can’t wait to learn more about their story!

Thank you Janice and Julie for the advance copy!
Profile Image for Kelley Perrin.
19 reviews
October 24, 2024
Looking for a feel good, snarky holiday rom-com? Then this book is for you! This book brings us back to Sweet Side with a new series (Cape Coral Swamp Cats: Rugby and Romance) so you see a few glimpses of some beloved characters from Sweet Side, but we get introduced to Alexis and Gavin (Gavin just happens to be neighbors with Fynn from Ms. Watts most recent Sweet Side book).

Alexis has crushed on Gavin since high school, but he is oblivious to that until his feelings for her changed. He has always teased her since he was her brother’s best friend, and she doesn’t know that he has changed and that his teasing now is a form of his affection. This is a slow burn romance but once it ignites, it is fire.

Once I got started on this book, I didn’t want to put it down! It was a quick fun read, and I highly recommend it!
Profile Image for Erica.
44 reviews
October 25, 2024
Another fun and spicy book set in Sweet Side! Alexis has had a crush on Gavin since they were teens but she’s done with his teasing so she calls his bluff at her parents Christmas party. Gavin hasn’t been teasing, more like flirting and he’s set on showing Alexis how he really feels. Of course there are issues and bumps along the way and Alexis helps Gavin realize that he absolutely can have a real relationship. Alexis is an amazing character, sarcastic, introverted and curvy. She doesn’t fawn all over Gavin who plays professional rugby which makes him just want her more! Gavin a sweet and protective and wants to prove how much Alexis really means to him. There’s family drama on both sides which adds to the drama but a happily ever after is guaranteed! You can read this as a stand alone, but the other Sweet Side books are wonderful too! Grab this funny & sexy holiday read!
Profile Image for Gemjar.Reads.
190 reviews
December 5, 2024
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶🌶

This was such a fun read. Well written and easy to follow. There is no stupid fall out between the MMC and MFC. They discuss their worries like actually adults. The drama is more around their families.

It was just an entertaining read. It was a fast but also slow burn in a way. I definitely got a crush on the MMC, and tbh a bit of the MFC. I really related to the MFC. The sarcasm and wit were there. Her friendship group is definitely ride or die, but also understanding she's an introvert. The part where she's trying to find a parking space to meet them in a bar and considers leaving but it's too hard work finding new friends cracked me up. I would so think that.

I'm a dark romance type of girl, so this was a nice change of pace and palate cleanser.

Cannot wait for Leo and Miss Millers book
Profile Image for Elizabeth.
748 reviews9 followers
October 25, 2024
I’m still laughing.

I love this delightful, fun, charming, and hilarious story. Gavin and Alexis may seem like opposites, but they are more alike than you think. Alexis has had a crush on Gavin for years, yet he’s been clueless. When he realizes how much his feelings for her changed and he approaches her, the hilarity ensues. He’s a cinnamon roll and I melted at the way he treated Alexis, his cat Cilantro “because she’s not for everyone”, and a poor lost Iguana. Alexis is sassy and snarky and I loved her! The connection between them is hot and steamy. I enjoyed the supporting characters I met and am looking forward to the next Swamp Cats book. I’m still laughing at this enchanting story and these likable characters. Don’t miss out on a great book!
Profile Image for Wren.
515 reviews46 followers
November 2, 2024
A fastburn swoony romance!

Black cat x golden retriever supremacy!!!

I love a mean FMC and Alexis was queen of mean, and Gavin absolutely ate it up!

Even though the title is holiday romance like, really the holidays only take place 7ish chapters of the book.

I loved how Gavin learned all he could about Alexis and worked to love her the best way possible. For example, he bought her a beautiful cashmere scarf for Christmas because he noticed hers was wearing thin. When he learned the reason hers was wearing this was because her deceased grandmother made it for her, and she couldn’t part with it because it was a labour of love, he decided to teach himself how to crochet so he could make her a scarf, just like her grandma did. So cute!
Profile Image for 3v4nny.
194 reviews
Read
November 12, 2024
when i tell you gavin had me screaming im not lying one bit, he was everything and im so glad that his insecurities didn’t make him pull away from alexis but he saw through them and grew🥹. i saw so much of myself in alexis, like she constantly said she was a very straight forward girl who was also kinda boring, keeps to herself and also hates crowded/ loud spaces? like she kinda is me to a fucking T. and the way she described herself wasn’t in a self deprecating way she just told it how it is. also the fact that gavin thought his jealousy and possessiveness would make alexis run was insane to me cause if i were her my clothes would have flew off in a second! omg one last thing gavin was such a sweetheart and was just the nicest guy, like it’s no surprise i loved him sm
Profile Image for Zoë Braycotton.
743 reviews9 followers
February 21, 2025
Romcom with a twist.

Loved this first in the Rugby and Romance series.

Gavin and Alexis are a wild ride from the off.

Alexis definitely takes no prisoners in life, her straight talking attitude made me laugh.

Gavin got a problem and that’s his pint size best friends sister, he’s slightly obsessed, but not prepared to rock the boat with her brother and his family, they’ve been the only family he’s really had. Rock and hard place!

Little did he know that Alexis had that crush on him as a teen!

This was a fun story in the most part, but with an added darker twist with a touch of domestic abused and unwanted man handling!

Looking forward to getting Leo and Maddie next.
Profile Image for Laura Spinnett.
205 reviews8 followers
October 23, 2024
A fun, snarky and emotional Holiday story that will keep you wondering if anyone will be getting their holiday gifts! Alexis doesn't seem to have a lot of luck in the dating scene, and Gavin has a reputation for being a bit of a player. But when he finally sets his sights on Alexis, she isn't quite sure if he's still teasing her (as he always had been) or if there's an off chance that he might actually WANT to be with her! Only kisses will tell, and his leave her coming back for more! Of course, this story has an HEA, however, it has some surprising twists getting there! You'll enjoy this holiday romance.
Profile Image for Curvy Girls Read Romance.
601 reviews71 followers
November 12, 2024
Absolutely hilarious, rugby, Christmas, rom-com!

Gavin has wanted Alexis for years. The problems? She's his best friend's little sister and she thinks he only flirts with her as a game. When Alexis calls his bluff though, Gavin jumps the gun in a she-shed and stains her dress. "Did you just Bill Clinton me?"

This sweet dummy is so in love with Alexis but too afraid to act on it because he doesn't want to be his father. Little does he know, his animal loving, protective self could never.

Alexis is a super fierce heroine who can take care of herself and who takes no shit from anyone. Her handling of Gavin's father was such a perfect takedown.

Seriously though, I laughed out loud so many times during this one. A great holiday read!
Profile Image for Liz Matzen.
150 reviews3 followers
December 13, 2024
This was my first book by this author but it's not going to be my last. I need to find out what happens to Gavin and Alexis's friends!

Gavin is Alexis's brother's best friend and rugby teammate. Alexis has had a crush on him since she was a teenager, but he always teased her and treated her like a little sister. Until one Christmas Eve in her mom's she shack treehouse. The laughs start there and keep on going.

This is a funny, spicy book that will keep you entertained. If you like brother's best friend, a one-eyed iguana, and a feral cat as pets, this is the book for you! A cute holiday read that I recommend.
Profile Image for Always Looking For My... Next Book Boyfriend..
148 reviews1 follower
December 15, 2024
Kinda love Gavin!

Really liked it. The writing was good the characters were likable, well developed, and a great fit for one another. Alexis is a bit prickly and tells it like it is but seems to melt a bit for Gavin who is pretty easy going and is so sweet to her. This is my first book by this author but I love it when they tie in couples from other books so I’m excited to read about Flynn and Val and Grant and Julia in their stories. Alexis’ friend group is super interesting and supportive, I hope there will be books about them in the future too. Can’t wait until a Leo’s book comes out.
1,197 reviews
October 25, 2024
Alexis is Leo’s sister.
Leo is Alexis brother.
Gavin is Leo’s rugby teammate.

Alexis and Gavin new each other ( because he is her brother’s friend and teammate)Alexis has had a teenager girl’s crush on Gavin , besides the attraction and chemistry ( love/hate relationship and personnel issues too overcome).
Can they work through their issues and have a Happily Ever After?
You will have to read the book to find out what happens.

This book is funny, has snarky humor and entertaining.

Great Job Josie Watts !!!
Profile Image for Carolyn.
1,798 reviews7 followers
October 26, 2024
Gavin and Al

This is such a great read! It’s full of snark, attitude, angst, insecurity, giggles and belly laughs. I love Al. She’s a lot like me well except for the dressing up and fashion sense. I understood a lot of her mindset. I love how she loves her body even if she has lots of curves and boobs. Plus a group of friends that keep her from being a hermit. I’ve been in a book funk for a while and this book definitely helped giving me a reason to laugh and enjoy a book again.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 96 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.