I received this book from First Reads on Goodreads.com. As always this is my completely honest review.
I thought it had an interesting premise. I've always enjoyed the motif of creepy mirrors. It has elements of scifi, romance, paranormal and historical fiction, all great genres. Even though it is described in a way that you might expect horror, I don't think it fits.
As I said the premise I was up for, but the execution left a lot to be desired for me. The biggest problem I had was all the characters seem to be just negative and unlikable. All of them. A lot of racist, homophobic and mysoginist thoughts come from these characters. I didn't like or relate to any of them and they were very one dimensional. There wasn't much character development across the board. Not interesting to me at all. The love built between the two main characters wasn't really shown. They are suddenly life or death in love with each other and I didn't feel it or care. There needed to be more development in these areas. I also thought the Salem witch trials were treated a bit silly.
There were also a lot of typos. I thought it was a review copy, so I wasn't really worried about them until I came on to write this review and saw it was published last year. Like many people, I wasn't sure about the gender of the main character Quinn Channing. I like the idea of that being a mystery and not the most important thing, but again the execution didn't come through. I'm not convinced that the character was referred to as he as well as she on purpose. The way it is handled I think it may have just been more typos.
To wrap it up, I think it was a great idea and premise that could be successful with rewrites and editing, but I can't recommend it as is.