Dust is a YA speculative fiction novel about a young half deaf girl who is uprooted from her home in Ohio to a desolate, dry, hot, and seemingly dying town in Colorado by her parents. Her parents refuse to acknowledge she struggles with hearing. They have become fearful of progress and have chosen to pull their children from school, deciding to live without help from the outside world, wanting to go back to “simpler” times. All the while, ignoring the strain that it’s putting on their family, on their daughters.
This is a very interesting story, I haven’t read one quite like it before. It was interesting to see parents refusing to acknowledge their daughters disability and to examine how that affected the main character and those around her. It was incredibly heartbreaking to watch the parents slowly break the spirits of their daughters because of the fear that they had. Fear had such a prominent role in this story and controlled the decisions the parents made throughout. It also caused the parents to technically abuse their children by denying them education and socialization. It definitely was difficult to read at times, but that did lead to some heartwarming moments when the main character was able to establish meaningful connections.
I really did struggle with the unschooling part of the story. To be clear, homeschooling, and unschooling are two incredibly different things, and to confuse the two, especially in this kind of format can be detrimental. I understand the point the author was trying to make with regards to fear, misinformation, and unschooling (which has become a trend recently) but several times throughout the story she used homeschooling and unschooling interchangeably, which is inaccurate and can cause a lot of confusion and spreads misinformation. And to be fair, what happened in this story couldn’t even be considered unschooling or homeschooling. It was a complete absence of schooling. Although at times, it was stated that the youngest daughter was getting taught, it was very obvious the oldest one wasn’t getting any education at all. What the author did was absolute misrepresentation and ruined the entire entire story for me as I was angry with the author for portraying both of these potentially legitimate, benign, and useful ways of teaching children in such an inaccurate and damaging light. What would’ve been more accurate and what would’ve been more beneficial to the story would’ve been to show how maybe the parents started off with wanting to homeschool or unschool and due to their fears decided to focus on no schooling. The author could have allowed the obviously intelligent main character to realize that her parents weren’t doing what they originally set out to do. The main character could have pointed out that if she wasn’t going to get homeschooled or unschooled properly, she would prefer to be in public school. Instead, the author chose, in a YA novel that will be read by a younger audience who is more likely less knowledgeable about other forms of schooling, to portray it is something abusive and terrifying.
***Thank you NetGalley, St. Martin’s Press, and Alison Stine for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.***