Green Pastures

The Amish of Shepherd's Hill #1

by Patricia Johns

Tabitha Schrock's return to Lancaster County shakes the foundations of her family and community. After her departure during rumspringa and a recent divorce, Tabitha faces the challenge of reintegrating into Amish society while pursuing her dream of working as a veterinarian. Meanwhile, her sister Amanda, whose own prospects were dimmed by Tabitha's leaving Shepherd's Hill, decides to seize her chance at love by pursuing a man with a shadowed past. And their youngest sister, Rose, despite her beauty and romantic hopes, faces the harsh realities of matrimony, grappling with the weight of vows made before Gott and her community.

As the sisters navigate the intricacies of love, faith, and tradition, they are bound by their commitment to uphold their Amish way of life. But as they strive to keep their promises, how much are they willing to sacrifice to remain true to themselves and their community?

Genres: Amish, Amish Fiction, Christian, Romance, Inspirational, Christian Fiction, Contemporary

336 pages, Paperback

Published March 18, 2025

About the author

Publishers Weekly bestselling author Patricia Johns writes sweet romance. She lives in Alberta, Canada with her husband and son.

Sign up for her newsletter: https://bit.ly/35kj3Rn

Reviews

[Jeanette Durkin · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is a fantastic book! It was very thought-provoking. So many issues were brought up. Infidelity, alcoholism, and abandonment. There's also a sweet and tender love story!

I really connected with all of the sisters. As their relationship is stretched and pulled in different directions, they must learn to really listen, not just with their ears but also their hearts. It's awesome that Tabitha is able to continue in her vocation as a vet. Her knowledge and patience are extraordinary. Menno really touched my heart. He's trying so hard to turn his life around. He finds security when his community offers him help.

It was interesting to me that the author didn't paint the Amish as the all perfect people like they usually are. The characters chose to forgive and even get help when needed. I know that I'm going to love this series, and I eagerly look forward to the next book!

I was provided a complimentary copy of the book from Bethany House through Interviews and Reviews. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

[Carla Bruns · Rating 5 out of 5]

This story is about the love of three sisters who lead very different lives in their Amish community. It’s primarily from the point of view of the oldest sister, Tabitha, and the middle sister, Amanda.

Tabitha leaves the Amish community for ten years, living in the English world, getting married, and divorcing. When she returns, the Amish community is forgiving and welcomes her back, allowing her to continue working as a veterinarian, even though it’s considered men’s work. Since she is divorced, she cannot marry an Amish man, which brings a different type of heartbreak but Tabitha is content with her decision. I admire her bravery in returning and building a new type of Amish life for herself.

Amanda, is left unmarried partly because of her sister‘s decision to become English but longs for a family of her own. She learns that Menno Weaver is looking for a wife. His reputation isn’t the best because of his family’s choices and his own troubled past, but he is working hard to change. I feel connected to Amanda because choosing to love someone who fights an addiction daily is not an easy choice, but it can be worth the risk. And I absolutely fell in love with Menno myself!

This book is beautifully written. There were moments that made me laugh, times when I had tears in my eyes, and times when I couldn’t help but smile. Every part has meaning and depth, full of love for people of all types of backgrounds and God. There are hints of a possible love story for Tabitha in future books, and I can’t wait to see how that unfolds given her circumstances.

This is a great read for anyone who loves Amish romance, real-life marriage struggles (Amish or not), and stories that show what the power of family, community, and God can do.

𝘐 𝘷𝘰𝘭𝘶𝘯𝘵𝘢𝘳𝘪𝘭𝘺 𝘳𝘦𝘷𝘪𝘦𝘸𝘦𝘥 𝘢 𝘤𝘰𝘮𝘱𝘭𝘪𝘮𝘦𝘯𝘵𝘢𝘳𝘺 𝘤𝘰𝘱𝘺 𝘰𝘧 𝘵𝘩𝘪𝘴 𝘣𝘰𝘰𝘬, 𝘸𝘩𝘪𝘤𝘩 𝘐 𝘳𝘦𝘤𝘦𝘪𝘷𝘦𝘥 𝘧𝘳𝘰𝘮 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘱𝘶𝘣𝘭𝘪𝘴𝘩𝘦𝘳. 𝘈𝘭𝘭 𝘰𝘱𝘪𝘯𝘪𝘰𝘯𝘴 𝘢𝘳𝘦 𝘮𝘺 𝘰𝘸𝘯.

[J.E. Grace · Rating 5 out of 5]

Green Pastures is a very exciting Amish story. The plot unfolds with Tabitha returning to Shepherd's Hill to the family farm. Divorced from an Englisher, she hopes to fit back into the Amish community while working as a licensed Veterinarian in Sheperd's Hill Amish country.

The novel has well-developed characters with many layers. The characters deal with everyday issues but in the Amish way. The descriptions of Amish life were somewhat different because of Tabitha's occupation, but each order had its own rules to follow. I was drawn to Tabitha's courage and determination to fit in. The whole family dealt with heartbreak, forgiveness, and second chances.

There were biblical references, which gave the story more substance but did create some tension. I enjoyed the budding romance. Overall, a very enjoyable story. I hated to see it end.

I received a complimentary ARC from the author; a positive review is not required. All opinions are my own.

[Sarah ⚘ · Rating 3 out of 5]

3.5 stars. Full review to (hopefully) come sometime soon.

[Elly · Rating 5 out of 5]

Patricia Johns' "Green Pastures" is a captivating, heartfelt novel that immerses readers in the rich traditions of the Amish community of Shepherd's Hill. With remarkable sensitivity and insight, Johns weaves together the compelling stories of the three Schrock sisters as they navigate the delicate balance between personal desires and community expectations.

Tabitha Schrock's return to her Amish roots after her rumspringa departure and subsequent divorce creates ripples throughout Shepherd's Hill. Her determination to pursue her veterinary ambitions while reintegrating into Amish society showcases the novel's central theme of reconciling individual dreams with communal responsibilities. Johns portrays Tabitha's struggles with such nuance that readers can't help but root for her journey toward healing and belonging.

Meanwhile, Amanda Schrock's character arc is equally engaging as she boldly pursues romance with a man carrying a complicated past. Her willingness to seek love after years of dimmed prospects (following Tabitha's departure) speaks to the resilience and hope that permeates this story. The youngest sister, Rose, despite her beauty and romantic hopes, provides a poignant counterpoint as she grapples with the harsh realities of matrimony and the weight of vows made before Gott and community, creating some of the book's most reflective and emotionally resonant moments.

What makes "Green Pastures" truly exceptional is Johns' ability to portray the Amish way of life with authenticity and respect while still examining the universal human struggles within this specific context. The lush descriptions of Lancaster County create a vivid backdrop for this tale of sisters bound by blood, faith, and their promises to both themselves and their community.

This novel will resonate deeply with readers who appreciate stories of family bonds, spiritual journeys, and the courage it takes to remain true to oneself while honoring traditions. Patricia Johns has crafted a warm, thought-provoking tale that lingers in the heart long after the final page is turned.

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are only my honest opinion

[Jo|Ruth Reads · Rating 5 out of 5]

Five stars all the way! I've never read anything like it!

This story offers a heartfelt glimpse into the lives of three sisters as they each navigate very different paths within their Amish community.

For Tabitha, it's about returning home after a divorce and trying to find her place again. She’s not the same woman who left years ago she’s now a trained veterinarian, a divorced woman, and fiercely independent. But can a female vet really be accepted in the Amish world? And is she truly happy giving up marriage and choosing a single life to stay in her community?

Amanda is on a very different journey she knows she wants marriage and has set her sights on Menno. But not everyone supports her choice. Will she follow her heart even as those around her urge her to walk away?

And then there’s Rose, the sister who followed the traditional Amish path. She’s married, doing what was expected but finding out that marriage isn't quite as easy as she imagined.

I absolutely loved this story. Tabitha’s return and how she slowly rebuilt the friendships she once left behind was so moving. Rose and Aaron’s marriage struggles felt honest and real, especially the way family tried to help sometimes succeeding, sometimes falling short. But my favorite was Amanda and Menno’s love story. Menno worked so hard to rebuild his life for himself, for Amanda, and for their community. It was beautiful to watch that journey unfold. I am still hoping for a romance for Tabitha... hopeful somehow she can have a happily ever after, she deserves it. I am SO ready for book 2 in the series!

[June Jacobs · Rating 5 out of 5]

A moving and inspirational story about an Amish community filled with flawed, scarred individuals and families and their quest to move past their painful pasts to discover the blessings God has in store for them . . .

This story centers on the three sisters in the Schrock Family of Shepherd's Hill in Lancaster County. The oldest sister, Tabitha, is a licensed large-animal veterinarian who is returning to the family after ten years of living as an Englischer. She is divorced, so she is facing a life as a single woman as she will not be allowed to remarry according to the Amish ordnung. Tabitha's return to the family home has been an adjustment for everyone—especially Amanda.

Amanda, age twenty-seven is the middle sister. She still lives at the family home with her very strict widowed father. She is currently single, but has made a goal for herself to marry someone from the community when she finds him and falls in love. I thoroughly enjoyed this thread from the story because this strong-willed young woman has an untraditional approach to finding her future mate.

Rose is the youngest sister and has been married to a man from their community for two years. She works hard to keep a fine Amish home for him, but something seems to be missing in their relationship.

Reading about the veterinary work Tabitha does with the assistance of Amanda and Rose captured my interest because I'm a big fan of the 'All Creatures Great and Small' series by James Herriot. This is the first Amish fiction I've read where there was a female veterinarian.

Since I don't want to share any more of the wealth of hidden treasures in this book, I will end my review by saying that the faith thread woven throughout the story is strong and inspiring.

The book is completely clean in language and content. I received a copy of the book from the publisher through JustRead Publicity Tours. All of my thoughts and opinions shared here are solely my own.

######################################

[Cindy Davis- Cindy's Book Corner · Rating 4 out of 5]

I enjoyed Green Pastures by Patricia Johns.

Animals were like people that way-put them under enough pressure and you got the worst out of them, never the best.

Read for:

🩺female Amish vet (divorced)

🩺spinster sister wanting a marriage of her own

🩺struggling marriage

🩺complicated family dynamics

🩺second chances

🩺looking for belonging

🩺long-time feud

This is a sweet story about a family, each struggling in their own way. There was a lot going on in the story, with a lot of characters. The story has themes of abandonment, unmet expectations, alcoholism, forgiveness, and reconciliation. In the end, not everything is wrapped up in a pretty bow, and you are left wanting more. I hope the second book continues the sister's storyline.

Thank you to the author and Bethany House for the opportunity to read this book. I was not required to provide a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

[Laura (kroosreadsandreviews) · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book was filled with relationships and faith, the best combination!

The relationship between the three sisters was so special! Sisters don't always get along but will always be on your side.

It was interesting to me how the community responded to Tabitha returning to the Amish faith. This was a different spin on the story, which I really enjoyed.

The idea of green pastures was intriguing and gave me a lot to think about. The theme of second chances amidst addictions added to the story as well.

Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for the arc. The opinions are my own.

[Helen · Rating 5 out of 5]

Green Pastures, by Patricia Johns, is the first book in The Amish of Shepherd’s Hill series. This is a well written story that is easy to read with nice characters. The story focuses on the Schrock family, which include the father and three grown sister. This story gives a look into each of the sister’s lives and their struggles. It also shows how the father feels about certain things based on his past experiences.

This is an enjoyable story to read. It mainly focuses on family, faith, honesty and communication while it gives a look into some of the rules of the Amish faith. One of the things I enjoyed about this story is how it shows that women are capable of earning a degree and working in a field traditionally held by men. I enjoyed how the sisters worked together to held Tabitha care for the animals in the community and how they care for each other. I also enjoyed how accepting the community was of how she cared for them. One of the things that stands out for me in this story is when Tabitha explains to Amanda that their father is visiting with her boyfriends is not to make choices for her but for her father to get to know the man she has chosen and making peace with it.

I voluntarily received a complimentary copy of this book, this is my honest review.

[Hallie (Hallie Reads)]

a sweet amish story!

having been betrayed by the man for whom she gave up her community, tabitha schrock has returned to lancaster county a divorced woman. she's taken over the veterinary work in the community, as she readjusts to amish life, and navigates the challenges of second chances and family relationships.

green pastures has a little romance, but truly focuses more on tabitha, her sisters, amanda and rose, and her father. they deal with questions of forgiveness and reconciliation, growing up and changing, and putting it all into perspective. it's a sweet, hopeful story of second chances that i'm sure readers of amish fiction will enjoy.

(i received a complimentary copy from the author. i was not required to write a positive review, and all the opinions i have expressed are my own.)
 
 
considerations: 
—language: none
—spice: kisses only
—faith: amish community and traditions
—content: drunkenness, mentions of abusive parent and parental abandonment

[Emily · Rating 5 out of 5]

Green Pastures is the first book I have read by Patricia Johns and it did not disappoint. Having ties to the Mennonite faith personally I can relate to the Amish on some level.

The character development in this story was great. There was a lot of characters that we see evolve throughout the book. The three sisters-Tabitha, Amanda and Rose are all in the middle of life changing experiences. I loved seeing Tabitha navigate her life after divorce and the Amish community while also trying to support herself through being a veterinarian. Amanda is trying to navigate courting Menno. Which Menno in himself goes through some amazing development battling alcoholism, abandonment, and the return of his mother. Rose going through a lot as a newlywed and navigating what it means to be a wife. There were so many layers to each character.

The setting was enjoyable. Who doesn’t love a good Amish story set on rolling farmlands in Lancaster County. The storyline was fun. It has been a while since I have read a story with so many main characters and intertwining stories.

The romance was sweet, a low spice. Just the way I appreciate it. It was a slow build and courtship style.

Patricia Johns did a great job intertwining faith throughout the book.

*I received a complimentary copy from the author and voluntarily chose to review it. All opinions are my own.

[Hannah Ruth · Rating 4 out of 5]

Green Pastures wasn’t what I expected from Amish fiction, but it was quite good.

I’ve read a lot of Amish fiction—it was actually pretty much the only thing I read for a LONG time, primarily in middle school, although I do pick one up now and then. I read primarily Amish romances, though, and while this book does incorporate some romance, it almost feels more like literary fiction to me.

I love that this book follows three sisters through their struggles—although Rose never got POV portions, which was interesting. I was a bit confused as to why Jonas got to have POV scenes, but maybe that’s something to do with a book that will come out later?

The big theme of Green Pastures was faithfulness and marriage, and how it’s a risk, but it’s a worthy risk… it can go so desperately wrong, but that doesn’t mean we should refuse it. The way this played into all three sisters’ lives… chef’s kiss. It was beautiful. It didn’t sugarcoat anything, but it was still so bright and hopeful.

I love Tabitha and her determination to find her place in the Amish community again. I love Amanda and her sweet heart and desire to be a wife and mama. I love the way this family was portrayed—they all have issues, but they all want to honor God and their community.

Overall, definitely a book worth reading.

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.

[Heather Pickett · Rating 5 out of 5]

A standout introduction to her new series, author Patricia Johns gives us Green Pastures. This is not only a love story, it's a tender and thoughtful examination of the relationship of the Schrock family; sisters Tabitha, Amanda (the subject of this book's love story), and Rose, along with their widowed father.
The author touches on some hard-hitting subjects in this book, but also shows the light and hope that shines through trials and tribulations. While there is unwavering faith in "Gott", it's refreshing to read about the doubts, questions, and worries, and how they are addressed. I absolutely loved this story, and am already looking forward to the next in the series!
I received a complimentary copy of this book, but my opinion is entirely my own.

[Camille Dayton Fostering.literacy · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is probably one of the most intriguing Amish fiction books that I’ve read. The main character, Tabitha, is a prodigal daughter to the Amish way of life, and this book tells her story of choosing to come back to the Amish people. She is anything but a conventional Amish woman: divorced, a trained veterinarian, and willing to have a career instead of marriage and family.

The book tells her story of reintegration and also her sister’s story of her last attempt to avoid becoming an old maid.

All of the book points to finding meaning and purpose through your story and the people you surround yourself with:
“The foundational truth stood solid: There was strength in community.”

Overall, it’s a great book. I recommend it to anyone who enjoys reading about the Amish culture, and anyone who is looking for a squeaky clean romance. Thank you to the publisher for the advance copy. A review was not required.

[Kathy Wallen · Rating 5 out of 5]

November 22, 2025

Is it possible? Have I truly found an actually well-written Amish romance with lifelike characters, a believable setting, and near-perfect pacing? Why yes, yes I have indeed.

This book is told from the point of view of four people: Tabitha Schrock, who left the Amish at nineteen to marry her boyfriend and has returned divorced after he cheated on her; Tabitha's sister Amanda, who has dutifully taken care of her father and other such chores and longs for a husband and children of her own; Jonas Peachy, the son of Nathaniel Peachy with whom Tabitha and Amanda's father has had a feud for many years; and Menno Weaver, a young man who was abandoned by his mother, abused by his alcoholic father, and is a former alcoholic himself but has maintained his sobriety for quite some time now and is looking for a wife despite having closed himself off from the community. (Try saying all that in one breath!) Tabitha and Amanda also have a younger sister, Rose, who is not given a role as a narrator but has marital troubles of her own.

If I had to pick the best thing about this book, it would absolutely be the characters. They felt real. They felt alive. They felt like actual human beings instead of names on a page. The last book that I read was Thankful by Shelley Shepard Gray, and I really did not like it for a multitude of reasons, the main one being that the characters were... Hmm. Well, "un-care-about-able" isn't a word, but that pretty well describes them. I did not care about them because they did not act nor feel like actual people. The narrative was telling me that Aden and Christina loved each other and yet the story showed them barely even tolerating each other except for when it was convenient for the plot. Here, though, whenever the narrative described a character as this or that, it was accurate. For example, Tabitha and Rose and their father repeatedly describe Amanda as a good woman who is good marriage material, and that is shown in the way that she cares about other people, stands up for herself and others, and takes care of baking, cooking, cleaning, and gardening. Amanda describes Tabitha as a direct person, and Tabitha is repeatedly shown as being blunt and direct in her conversations where a conventional Amish woman would not have been. The short version is that the narrative isn't lying to me, and I like that.

I also liked how realistically the issues in this book were handled. Tabitha wasn't all "woe is me" because of her divorce. I liked that she didn't hate herself because of the divorce and that she also didn't take the blame for it when it wasn't her fault. She gave everything that she had to offer and it wasn't enough for her husband who cheated on her. I really liked that she gave her advice as she saw fit and recognized her mistakes when it sometimes made things worse. There were things that she knew and things that she didn't.

I loved how Amanda heard about Menno looking for a wife and decided to take the first step herself. Her whole adult life, she'd been waiting for a man to look in her direction, and most wouldn't because of her sister's reputation. So when she saw an opportunity, she didn't let it pass her up. Mrs. Johns did a wonderful job capturing Menno's social awkwardness, especially the bits where he and Amanda were just staring at each other, each knowing full well that the conversation was over and yet they were unsure of how to leave. That was so funny to me because it was relatable. Maybe it's just me, but it was so cute how Menno was seen as a lost cause and an outsider by the rest of the community, and then Amanda went to visit him with some cinnamon rolls and she found that his house was a bit cluttered but clean... and he had a baby pig in the living room which he was nursing back to health. It melted my heart and I was so happy that Menno and Amanda ended up getting married. Side note, Amanda was a real one for all her thoughts and fears about marriage. Both of her sisters' stories are excellent examples of thinking that you've found "the one" only to discover that marriage is really hard work and sometimes it's not all sunshine and rainbows. Marriage may be fun and games at first, but all the little problems add up until it's a volcano waiting to explode. Nobody tells you that when you're in your early twenties and think that you know everything.

I know that this is a series, so I'm not sure if Tabitha and Jonas are going to get together at all, but to be frank, I'm satisfied with them being just friends at the moment. They got along well and it was enjoyable to watch them build up their friendship even though their fathers did not like each other. (Technically, Tabitha isn't allowed to remarry unless her husband Michael is dead, which is unlikely... so...)

I do not know literally anything about veterinary practices and animal care, so I couldn't tell you if Mrs. Johns's depiction of Tabitha's care was accurate or not, but it seemed to me that it was well-researched and that she knew what she was talking about. The same goes for the general Amish way of life. I liked that chores were integrated into characters' lives because in some Amish books that I read, it's like the characters have all the free time in the world and never have any chores to do.

There's probably some stuff that I've forgotten to mention, but oh well. I was very pleased with this book and highly recommend it. I should also check out the sequel!

[Carrie Schmidt · Rating 4 out of 5]

If you’ve been around here for a minute, you know that I’m pretty picky about the Amish fiction I choose to read. I’m not super interested in the ones that make Amish communities into some type of utopia, but I do love the stories that feature characters with real flaws and strengths and dreams and hurts and faith and all the things that make us human. Green Pastures by Patricia Johns is exactly the kind of Amish fiction I enjoy, and I so appreciated all the multidimensional characters she introduced to us in this first book of her new series.

We meet Tabitha Schrock right away… as she sets a bull’s broken leg. Yeah, definitely not a typical scenario for an Amish female lead, right? But Tabitha isn’t a typical Amish female lead. After all, she jumped the fence during rumspringa to marry an Englischer and become a veterinarian, but she’s now back home and Amish once more after a heartbreaking divorce. I loved that she still gets to be the community’s veterinarian, in spite of all of the above, and I enjoyed watching her blaze a trail in proving herself and her work to longtime friends & family. It’s not an easy environment to come back to, especially as the consequences of her leaving carry forward with some lonely ramifications, but these are such intriguing layers to explore. And I’m really hoping that this book isn’t the last we’ll see of her story because I have a feeling her future isn’t quite as set as she thinks it is (looking at you, Jonas Peachy).

Tabitha isn’t the only complexly-layered character in Green Pastures, though. Not only are her younger sisters each dealing with complicated relationship plot twists in their own lives, but their father is a mass of contradictions himself. He mostly drove me crazy with his stubbornness (lol) but every once in a while he would show his heart as a tender dad who just wants to protect his girls. There’s also one unexpected scene that had me cheering out loud for him, and it endeared him to me henceforth and forevermore, general orneriness notwithstanding. As for Tabitha’s sisters, I so related to both Amanda and Rose, albeit in different ways and in different stages of my life. And then there’s the young man who’s dared to break some generational chains (oh his family is a heap of flaws and heartbreak), and he’s dared to do so in ways that are unconventional for the Amish. I absolutely adored Menno in every way and spent most of the book just wanting to give him a big hug.

Bottom Line: Green Pastures by Patricia Johns is a compelling combination of storylines that follow several different characters connected to the Schrock family of Shepherd’s Hill. Tabitha, Amanda, and Menno were particularly well-developed with growth arcs that aren’t quite as common in Amish fiction and layers that immediately drew my attention and kept me invested. I enjoyed the author’s engaging writing voice, the gently meaningful faith threads, and the seamless switch between the different character POVs. If you enjoy the storytelling styles of authors like Suzanne Woods Fisher & Shelley Shepard Gray, then you’ll definitely enjoy Green Pastures too. I am eager for more books in this series!

(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)

first reviewed at Reading Is My SuperPower

[Emily · Rating 5 out of 5]

I truly enjoyed reading Green Pastures. I expected it to be a typical Amish romance and, while it DID have a romantic storyline, it was also focused on the relationships among three sisters, Tabitha, Amanda, and Rose. Each of the women was at a different point in her life: Rose (the youngest) is married, Amanda is a "spinster" wishing for a husband and family, and Tabitha (the oldest) left the Amish community, married, divorced, and has returned. Luckily, she has been granted special permission to continue her work as a veterinarian. Unluckily, since she's already been married, she's not allowed to marry again within her Amish community.

Each sister was realistically portrayed, and each had her own unique dreams and goals. I liked them all as individuals, and enjoyed their dynamic when they were together. Their conversations and motivations rang true, and I appreciated this attention to relationships beyond romance.

Another big upside to this book was that the Amish people weren't portrayed as perfect, and perfectly Godly. Of course, their faith is at the center of their lives, and they try their best to be obedient to God and the Amish church, but sometimes they struggle with willfulness, self-interest, and other all-too-human motives. To be clear, the book NEVER demeans the Amish faith in any way. It does, however, portray Amish people as real humans, not as absolutely perfect examples of religious purity.

I liked the way I gradually learned more about each of the sisters as parts of the story focused on each of their lives. I also enjoyed learning more about the Amish people, their faith, and their customs.

Christianity plays an important role in the lives of all of the characters, and they regularly pray and turn to God for help in doing the right thing and making decisions. It was nice to see true faith in action in the lives of the characters throughout the book.

The story was interesting and multi-faceted. The main romantic plot was resolved, but there is plenty of room in the lives of other characters for future books in this series. I look forward to the next one!

5 stars!

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.

[Emma · Rating 5 out of 5]

Green Pastures by Patricia Johns
(The Amish of Shepherd's Hill Book #1):
(An Amish Christian Fiction Book about Sisters, Love, and Redemption)
Tabitha Schrock's return to Lancaster County shakes the foundations of her family and community. After her departure during rumspringa and a recent divorce, Tabitha faces the challenge of reintegrating into Amish society while pursuing her dream of working as a veterinarian. Meanwhile, her sister Amanda, whose own prospects were dimmed by Tabitha's leaving Shepherd's Hill, decides to seize her chance at love by pursuing a man with a shadowed past. And their youngest sister, Rose, despite her beauty and romantic hopes, faces the harsh realities of matrimony, grappling with the weight of vows made before Gott and her community.
As the sisters navigate the intricacies of love, faith, and tradition, they are bound by their commitment to uphold their Amish way of life. But as they strive to keep their promises, how much are they willing to sacrifice to remain true to themselves and their community?
This is Tabitha Schrock's story. A licensed Veterinarian. And recent divorce. When she’d received her father’s invitation, Tabitha had been ready to come home.
This is Amanda Schrock's story. Sister of Tabitha and Rose.
This is Rose and husband Aaron's story. Sister of Tabitha and Amanda.
This is Abram Schrock's story. Father of Tabitha, Amanda and Rose.
This is Menno Weaver's story. Mother Linda Weaver.
I recommend this book.
Green Pastures by Patricia Johns is a wonderful well written 5 star book.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced readers copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions shared here in this review are my own.
I am looking forward to reading more books by Patricia Johns.
Grave Amish Secrets by Patricia Johns
Her Pretend Amish Beau by Patricia Johns
Amish Sleigh Bells by Patricia Johns
Murder of an Amish Bridegroom (An Amish Seamstress Mystery)
by Patricia Johns .
Green Pastures by Patricia Johns
(The Amish of Shepherd's Hill Book #1)
Still Waters (The Amish of Shepherd's Hill Book # 2))
by Patricia Johns
and more books by Patricia Johns.

[H. · Rating 5 out of 5]

Green Pastures, by Patricia Johns, is a story of the three Schrock
sisters and their lives within the Amish community. Tabitha Schrock, a
veterinarian, has returned to her home after ten years, having left the
community - known as "Jumping the fence". Tabitha fell in love with and
married an Englisher, only for him to leave her for another woman and
causing Tabitha to divorce. As a consequence of returning to the Amish
community, she will never be able to remarry, and will have to regain
the trust of her people. Tabitha brings her wonderful ability in taking
care of the animals, be it her family's and her neighbors. She also has
a soft spot for one of the family horses, who suffers from digestive
issues. Rose is married to Aaron, and takes great care as a homemaker
and gardener. Unfortunately, all is not what it seems to be and the
couple is very unhappy. However, Rose is concerned about their troubles
reaching the community. Amanda is single, and longs for a home and
family of her own. Unfortunately, Tabitha's departure left a cloud over
Amanda's chances and as she is in her late twenties, Amanda is all but
resigned to a life of spinsterhood.

Their father, Abram, is a kind and caring father, who also nurses a
long-held grudge against a community member. Menno is a sweet natured
young man who is a recovering alcoholic, and works hard on his home and
farm. He hopes to marry one day, but feels the stigma of his past, as
his brothers and their late father have also dealt with alcoholism which
caused their mother to run away. The most important thing of all is
that they trust Gott (God) in all they do.

I truly enjoyed this book, and learning a bit about the Amish. It's
a wonderful story, and I look forward to a sequel! I highly recommend
this book, and give it five stars!

I received a complimentary copy courtesy of Bethany House Publishers through Interviews & Reviews for my honest opinion.

[Kathy · Rating 4 out of 5]

4.5 stars.

Green Pastures by Patricia Johns is a marvelous Amish novel of forgiveness, acceptance, and love.

Tabitha Schrock’s return to her family and her Amish faith has not been without its complications. She is unable to remarry so she needs to support herself. Her Bishop has approved her to work as a veterinarian but a woman working in a man’s job is complex. Tabitha is also hoping to renew her lost friendships and her relationships with her sisters, Rachel and Rose. While she has unique insight into certain issues, does anyone want to hear her advice?

Rachel was the most affected by Tabitha leaving the Amish to marry an Englischer. The scandal arrived at the time she should have been courting, but her few prospects fizzled out. Although Rachel has resigned herself to spinsterhood, information that Menno Weaver is hunting for a wife gives her renewed hope. She is well aware of his and his family’s reputation but Rachel does not want to let this opportunity pass her by. Will Rachel and Menno find their path to a future together?

Rose and her husband Aaron have married for two years. Their marriage is currently in a fragile state and she is unsure how fix their relationship. Despite some sensible advice, will the couple find a way to reconnect and find their way back to happiness?

Green Pastures is a riveting Amish novel with a beautiful undercurrent of faith. Each of characters is well-developed with relatable foibles and strengths. The various story arcs are interesting and easy to follow. The storyline is well-written and features real life issues to overcome. Patricia Johns brings this first installment in The Amish of Sheperd’s Hill season to a heartwarming conclusion.

[Michelle C · Rating 5 out of 5]

I really enjoyed this book. It’s not the typical Amish romance I’m used to reading. It tells the story of three Amish sisters as they all struggle with different chapters in their lives. This story had a lot of layers about deep subjects like infidelity, alcoholism, abandonment, marital problems, forgiveness and second chances.

Tabitha is an Amish veterinarian. She divorced her Englischer husband due to his infidelity, and returned home to join the church and way of life she had left behind. She deals with trying to prove she is a competent vet, find her place in the family she has been absent from, and overcome the doubts the community has that she will jump the fence and leave again. She has had an unhappy marriage, gone through a painful divorce and now has to accept she can’t remarry.

Amanda is the middle sister. When Tabitha left the community it was a scandal that affected her marriage prospects. She was passed over. Now she is struggling to accept she might never have a family of her own. She finds the courage to take a chance on love with someone who like her has had scandal from his family affect his prospects as well.

The youngest sister, Rose, was pretty and popular. She married easily, but now the reality of marriage isn’t what she had expected. Her husband and her are having problems. She is trying to keep up appearances while hiding her problems. As everything crumbles she must work to save her marriage.

I highly recommend this book. I’m already looking forward to reading more in this series. I received a complimentary book, but the opinions expressed are my own.

[Beverly Laude · Rating 5 out of 5]

I am a retired Veterinarian and I also enjoy reading books set in the Amish community. So, I jumped at the chance to read this book. Tabitha Schrock has returned to her Amish community after "jumping the fence" and marrying an Englisher. Unfortunately, her husband cheats on their marriage and she is now returning to her Amish community as a fully trained Veterinarian. But, the road to being able to fit in will be a long one and she is determined to work hard at being accepted, both as an unwed Amish woman and a Veterinarian.

Her younger sister, Amanda, has felt the effects of Tabitha's choice and now longs to be a wife and mother. But, she is having difficulty in finding a suitable man to fulfill her dreams. Then, there is the other Schrock sister, Rose, who is supposedly happily married. But, it soon becomes apparent that looks can be deceiving!

I especially enjoyed reading about Tabitha's veterinary cases and how her community comes to accept her expertise. It is wonderful to see the budding romance between Amanda and former wild boy Menno evolve into something truly special.

Throughout the book, the ideas of faith, community and relationships are explored and provide some emotional and uplifting scenes. As the characters discover:

"There was strength in community.
Gott was the Gott of second chances.
The treasures - it's us. Relationships. People."

This is a well-written book, with great characters, a touch of romance and wonderful reminders of what a deep faith in God will do for anyone who asks.

I received a complimentary copy courtesy of Bethany House Publishers through Interviews & Reviews for my honest opinion.

[Christi · Rating 4 out of 5]

“The Lord is my shepherd; I shall not want. He maketh me to lie down in green pastures; he leadeth me beside the still waters. He restoreth my soul.”

This has always been one of my favorite Psalms, and restoration and reconciliation is such a beautiful message that was incredibly powerful and prevalent in Green Pastures.

I appreciate the premise of three sisters banding together to help one another navigate through life during a time of transition. There is a lot of introspection as everyone is trying to navigate the next step in their lives while also reconciling choices of the past. This is something we all do at one time or another in our lives and felt very real to me. This is a novel that has a slower pace, which fits well with the feel of the Amish lifestyle while also giving time for the reader to absorb the characters and conflicts.

Second chances and giving people the opportunity to show that they’ve changed is a huge theme in this novel, which I think is a timely message and something that echoed with me long after I put down the book. I enjoyed the pace and conflicts, but what I adored most of all was the support and love that were clearly highlighted. Marriage is a major theme in this novel, but it’s more the love of family than romantic love that spoke to me the most and made this narrative feel even more special.

*I have voluntarily reviewed a copy of this book which I received from the author/publisher through JustRead Tours. All views and opinions expressed are completely honest, and my own.

[Kendra Neal · Rating 5 out of 5]

Amish Romance is my favorite genre to read. I also enjoy books by new to me authors. Green Pastures by Patricia Johns fits both of those situations. It is Book 1 in The Amish of Shepherds Hill series.

WOW, this storyline was absolutely intriguing and wonderful. The main characters in this book are Tabitha Schrock and her sisters, Amanda and Rose. One of the main things about the Amish that really intrigues me is Rumspringa, when they can have "Freedom" from the Amish ways. Tabitha has returned to Shepherd's Hill in Lancaster County after being going since her rumspringa and being married to an Englischer. She has divorced and wants to settle back into the Amish Community and be a veterinarian. Amanda has always wanted to marry but has not found the perfect suitor. Menno, who has a questionable past, starts courting Amanda and her family is worried for her. Rose has been married for 2 years and her marriage her struggling. I really LOVE how the Sisters LOVE and Support each other throughout their struggles. Tabitha has received the blessing from the Bishop to be a Female Veterinarian, which is uncommon. The doubts about Amanda and Menno courting are from the community, the sisters love Amanda and help her navigate the situation. The book is one of Faith, LOVE and Family. The author really made the characters bring their story together to help one another. I HIGHLY recommend this book to anyone who enjoys Amish Romance. FANTASIC BOOK!

[Rachel DeVaughn]

This Christian fiction book follows the story of 3 Amish sisters and their father Abram. Tabitha leaves the Amish faith and community to get married, becomes a vet, but then returns home after her divorce. Rose is married and lives close by the family farm but is having a hard time adjusting to her marriage after only two years. Amanda cooks, cleans and looks after this father and is considered old in her late 20's by not being married.

I liked the different Amish and English perspectives of the sisters on different topics like marriage, dating, communicating and every day life. I also liked reading Tabitha's and Amanda's experiences with providing medical care to the local animals and Tabitha trying to make a name for herself again in the Amish community where she grew up.

Relationships and friendships are introduced in this story and I wish all three girls received a "happily ever after" story to their lives because they all deserved it. I hope we will hear more about the sisters in future Amish of Shepherd's Hill books.

This story addresses hard things that unfortunately also happen in an Amish community like addictions, abuse, marriage problems, etc. I liked how the characters made these situations relatable and how God can help strengthen and direct his children.

I really enjoyed this sweet family Amish book about love, faith and second chances. I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions and views expressed are my own.

[Erin · Rating 5 out of 5]

Green Pastures is a wonderful Amish romantic fiction novel and the start of a new series that you won’t want to miss out on. This book follows one of a set of three Amish sisters. She left the Amish life behind. And now after a divorce, she’s back and returning to her faith. It’s a time of adjustment. It’s a time of reintegrating herself into her old life. But it’s also a totally different life because she is different.

This is a bit different than your normal Amish novel. They’re breaking stigmas and working in jobs that you don’t think are Amish. For instance, Tabitha is working as a vet.

These sisters have to learn to listen to each other. Not just listen with their ears but listen with their being, their heart, to what is really being said.

I really enjoyed the characters in this book. They were real and truly felt like real people that I was getting to know. I can’t wait to come back to this place in the next novel in the series. Nobody has a truly perfect life and I think we see that in this series. Each of the sisters has something they struggle with, a burden if you will, that they must overcome.

I have voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from JustRead Publicity Tours. All views expressed are only my honest opinion. I was not required to write a positive review nor was I compensated in any other way. All opinions expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the FTC regulations.

[Kristina Anderson · Rating 4 out of 5]

Green Pastures by Patricia Johns revolves around the three Schrock sisters: Tabitha, Amanda, and Rose. The characters are developed and realistic. I appreciate seeing that Amish people are not perfect. The Amish struggle with the same issues as Englischers (alcoholism, stubborn fathers, gossipy relatives, negative thoughts, infertility, yearning for love, and more) and some problems that are unique to the Amish. The story is well-written and engaging. I liked that the story had a female Amish veterinarian (a rarity). I do not know how she performed her duties in a dress with an apron and a kapp (I would not have lasted a day in a dress). I liked the different story arcs and how they all tied together into one satisfying story. I wish, though, that one sister’s storyline had a better resolution (I cannot tell you because that would be a spoiler). I hope that this sister will be featured in an upcoming book and get the happy ending that she deserves. I like how faith was threaded throughout the book. I finished the story with a smile on my face. Green Pastures is the first installment in The Amish of Shepherd’s Hill series, and I cannot wait for Still Waters to come out at the beginning of November. Green Pastures is a heartwarming tale with a veterinarian sister, marital miseries, a suffering horse, an endearing runt, a bothersome brother, and learning that God is our friend.

[C Allen · Rating 5 out of 5]

Green Pastures: The Amish of Shepherd’s Hill by Patricia Johns is simply amazing. Ms. Johns tells an excellent story in all her books, but this one is uniquely written.

Tabitha Schrock has returned to her Amish community after a 10 year absence. During that time, she married an Englisher, got divorced and became a veterinarian. Her Bishop allows her to practice as a vet. Her sisters Amanda and Rose help her. Each of the daughter’s stories are revealed throughout the book.

Amanda has reached the time in her life when she wants a home of her own and a husband. No easy task with picking slim to none in her community. Along comes Menno. Amanda must decide if love is worth the risk for a chance for happiness.

The story examines hard issues of marriage troubles, divorce, and alcoholism. These are Topics that are usually not discussed in Amish stories, nevertheless, they are real in all communities.

The characters are realistic and very believable. I think they come across as being human with human faults.

The storyline is interesting and the story moves along well.

I highly suggest you order your copy of the 5-star book today.

I was given a copy by the author and publisher, but was not required to give a positive review. All opinions are my own. By the way, the cover is beautiful with embossed letters.

[Dana McNeely · Rating 5 out of 5]

A MOST SURPRISING STORY

First off, you’ll notice that, although I write Biblical Fiction, I’m reviewing an Amish book. Many years ago, I read two or three in the genre and decided I didn’t need to read any more. That changed when I came across a Facebook post by Patricia Johns with photos of crocheted frogs dressed in Amish clothing. I watched for more posts about the funny, intriguing frog family and their baby tadpole. I decided to read one of Ms. John’s novels. I think JEB’S WIFE, which I also recommend, may have been my first.
Then I preordered GREEN PASTURES, about Tabitha Shrock, a strong young woman who “jumped the fence” of Amish-ness, married an “Englisher,” and trained to become a veterinarian. All problematic.
Years later, now husbandless, she has come home at her father’s request. The first scene shows her trying to capture and treat a dangerous bull, enraged by the pain of a broken leg. Her aged father complicates everything by threating to jump in the pen and help. She attempts to block those unwise attempts without wounding his male ego. It made me smile. If you have an old father or grandfather in your life, you’ll smile, too.
This is what Patrica Johns does. She makes every scene surprising, and sometimes smile-worthy, but never sickly sweet. There’s plenty of tension throughout, especially when you factor in her two sisters. Amanda, an “old maid” plain of face and speech, decides to set her “kopp” at a man with a shadowed past. Rose, the beautiful youngest daughter, is beautiful and has a perfect marriage. But is it perfect?
I loved this book. How much? After I started reading my preordered paperback, I bought the audio version so I could keep reading on the treadmill and at bedtime. I listened to it three times. I heartily recommend GREEN PASTURES to lovers of Amish Fiction and general fiction. Be warned, however. Books by Patricia Johns are unputdownable and may be addictive.