The book demonstrates the deep connections between how we think about animals and how we think about ourselves and our cultures in different times and places. The collection brings together scholars from a wide variety of disciplines—including history, literary studies, anthropology, cultural studies, and art and art history—and marks a formative moment in the emerging field of "animal studies." Author Nigel Rothfels is Director of the Edison Initiative and teaches in the history department at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee. His book, Brought Back An Unnatural History of Exhibiting Animals and People, is forthcoming from The Johns Hopkins University Press (2002). Rothfels is currently writing a cultural history of the elephant. Steve Baker, Senior Lecturer in Historical and Critical Studies at the University of Central Lancashire, UK, is the author of The Postmodern Animal (2000) and Picturing the Animals, Identity and Representation (1993). He is also guest editor of a special issue of Society and Animals (2001) on "The Representation of Animals." Marcus Bullock is Professor of English at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee. He is the author of The Violent Ernst Jünger's Visions and Revisions on the European Right (1992) and the editor, with Michael Jennings, of Walter Selected Writings, Vol. I (1996). Jane Desmond is Associate Professor of American Studies and Co-Director of the International Forum for US Studies at the University of Iowa. She is the author of Staging Bodies on Display from Waikiki to Sea World (1999). She is the editor ofDancing Choreographing Sexuality (2001) and Meaning in New Cultural Studies of Dance (1997). Erica Fudge is Lecturer in the School of Humanities and Cultural Studies at Middlesex University. She is the author of Perceiving Humans and Beasts in Early Modern English Culture (1999) and a coeditor, with Ruth Gilbert and S. J. Wiseman, of At the Borders of the Beasts, Bodies and Natural Philosophy in the Early Modern Period (1999). She is currently editing a collection of essays, Renaissance Beasts, that will be published by Illinois University Press in 2002. Andrew Isenberg is Assistant Professor of History at Princeton University. He is the author of The Destruction of the An Environmental History, 1750-1920 (2000), in addition to articles in Environmental History and Great Plains Quarterly. Kathleen Kete, Associate Professor of History at Trinity College, is the author of The Beast in the Petkeeping in Nineteenth-Century Paris (1994). Her essays and reviews have appeared in Representations, Signs, and The Journal of Modern History. Kete is currently writing a book on ambition in postrevolutionary France. Akira Mizuta Lippit is Associate Professor of Film Studies and Critical Theory in the Program in Film and Visual Studies at the University of California, Irvine. He is the author of Electric Toward a Rhetoric of Wildlife (2000). Lippit's work has appeared in Afterimage, Assemblage, MLN, Qui Parle, and Women and Performance. Teresa Mangum is Associate Professor of English at the University of Iowa and the author of Married, Middlebrow, and Sarah Grand and the New Woman Novel (1998). Her recent publications include essays in Figuring Women, Bodies, Generations (1999), and A Companion to Victorian Literature and Culture (1999). She is currently at work on a book to be titled "The Victorian Invention of Old Age." Garry Marvin is Senior Lecturer in Social Anthropology at the University of Surrey Roehampton. He is the author, with Bob Mullan, of Zoo Culture (1999) and Bullfight (1994), and is at present writing a book on English foxhunting. The film The Hunt, based on his research, received the Prix d'Italia for the best cultural documentary on European television in 1998. Susan Bridget McHugh is Marion L. Brittain Fellow of Writing in the School of Literature, Communication, and Culture at the Georgia Institute of Technology. She is the author of essays in Critical Inquiry and South Atlantic Review, as well as reviews in Modern Fiction Studies. She is currently working on a book to be titled "Animal Domesticated Animals and Visual Narrative."
More like a 2.5 than a 2. The better essays are Teresa Mangum's "Dog Years, Humans Fears," which opened me up to the proliferation of 19th-c. English works told from a dogs'-eye view; Steve Baker's Deleuzo-Guattarian reading of several contemporary animal art projects (although he seems not to have exploited the idea of the 'Pack' sufficiently); and Susan McHugh's piece on the Missyplicity project, which convincingly identifies the human refusal to grant dogs their *own* erotic and aesthetic lives. Several of the other essays are okay.
It goes without saying that, overall, they know little about the Middle Ages. Thus, all the great historical breaks they identify as leading to the 19th c. sentimentalization of animals and the desire for nature requires knowledge of Ambrose's admiration for animal society in his Hexaemeron (and knowledge of his sources in turn). Likewise, despite all the work on English hunting, despite the requisite gestures to Matt Cartmill and John Cummins and even, at one point, Gaston Phoebus, there's *nothing* by Jean Birrell, which means their (of course) E.P. Thompson-inspired narratives of poaching look only half-historicized (e.g., none of them seems to know that the late medieval urban gentry had hunting monopolies and thus the restriction of hunting to *rural* gentry in the 1671 game law did much--I imagine--to delineate the urban gentry as bourgeoisie). Sadly, there's virtually no knowledge of the French work on nature and animals in evidence (there's one reference to Robert Delort's Les Animaux ont une histoire, but strangly enough, not in the English-only historiography essay, and Claudine Fabre-Vassas's work on pigs doesn't appear at all, nor, for that matter, Noëlie Vialles's sociology of slaughterhouses); anthropology, sociology, and archaeology are virtually nowhere in evidence.
Worst of all, several of the 'theory' articles are, sorry to say, complete catastrophes, either because they repeat received wisdom in new packaging (one essay seems as convinced as Lacan that animals 'lack the lack' and, in its conviction of the wholeness of animals, is completely innocent of Roger Caillois's work on the excess of animal camouflage, let alone *science* [e.g., Gould's The Panda's Thumb) or because they just don't understand what the theory does (e.g., one, clearly name dropping the Deleuzo-Guattarian terminology of the rhizome, explains that "identification is a mode of becoming": identification!!?? [to explain: becoming DISIDENTIFIES, in the sense of putting things in motion and thus enabling relational modes far more mobile than those allowed for by the handshaking and *mere mimesis* of identification. Sheesh!).
Ultimately, the anthology has more historiographic than interpretative value: reference it in your long footnote on previous cultural studies work on animals. Better anthologies include Cary Wolfe's Zoontologies, Jeffery Ham and Matthew Senior's Animal Acts, and Lorraine Daston and Gregg Mitman's Thinking with Animals.