Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
A 1920s Historical Mystery

First Class train travel never looked so deadly….

France 1926

Penelope “Pen” Banks and friends are finally headed to Paris aboard the famous Blue Train. No sooner has the train left the station than one of their group is accused of theft by another First Class passenger. The situation is quickly resolved thanks to the timely (yet rather suspicious) intervention of a fellow female passenger.

When the victim of the supposed theft is found dead later that evening, a surprising number of suspects are uncovered. There may have been more to the victim’s travel plans than a simple tryst along the French Riviera with his young female companion.

Unfortunately, the accusation of theft has Penelope’s friend Lulu accused as one of the suspects. Can Pen find the real culprit before the cuffs are placed when they reach the next station?



A Murder in Blue is the thirteenth book in the Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries series set in the 1920s. Join her and her friends as they continue their European adventure.

278 pages, Kindle Edition

First published July 30, 2024

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Colette Clark

43 books115 followers
Colette Clark lives in New York and has always enjoyed learning more about the history of her amazing city. She decided to combine that curiosity and love of learning with her addiction to reading and watching mysteries. Her first series, Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries is the result of those passions. When she’s not writing she can be found doing Sudoku puzzles, drawing, eating tacos, visiting museums dedicated to unusual/weird/wacky things, and, of course, reading mysteries by other great authors.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
393 (50%)
4 stars
235 (30%)
3 stars
112 (14%)
2 stars
24 (3%)
1 star
7 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 20 of 20 reviews
Profile Image for Noah.
604 reviews578 followers
August 8, 2025
Life is dull, it's nothing but one big lull / Then presto you do a skull, and find that you're reeling / She sighs and you're feeling... like a toy on a string (Ring-A-Ding Ding – Frank Sinatra).

Hey, I did it! I read another Penelope Banks murder mystery and came out the other end a more fulfilled and realized person. Okay, maybe that’s a little dramatic, but I’m not kidding when I tell you that somewhere along the way, this book series has become a great source of comfort for me, and just knowing that there will always be a couple new installments to check out when I get bored always changes my mood for the better. Besides, I think at this point the real miracle is the fact that this very long running series has been this consistently good for thirteen whole books! Full novels, all good! Because if I were a writer, I’d totally be running on empty and throwing out any terrible idea that comes to my brain. Like, I'd write “Love Island Murder Mystery?” on a white board, circle it in red, and then call it a day. So yeah, as for the story, we’re still in the middle of Pen and her crew’s vacay around Europe and A Murder in Blue finds them situated right in the middle of a murder scene on a first class train to Paris. Things quickly take a turn for the worst and it becomes a race to find a priceless artifact that most definitely has some cultural significance, but more importantly for the passengers, it's very valuable. The story has clear shades of Murder on the Orient Express (and even though I wasn’t the biggest fan of that book, I can still appreciate its impact), but for some reason the fact that a lot of this story revolves around the pitfalls of greed and people going to any lengths to find some kind of Indiana Jones type treasure kept reminding me of that scene in Aladdin in The Cave of Wonders where they come across that room full of treasure, and the whole thing is supposed to be a test of character to find “the real treasure” or whatever, but I always related to Abu wanting to shove everything he could carry in his pockets on the way out. Shiny things have always enticed me! But yeah, I guess I’d totally fail the “Diamond in the Rough” challenge, and if I were somehow transported into this book Magic Tree House style, I think it’s safe to say that I’d be one of the unpleasant suspects who would do anything to get my hands on a piece of gold. Anyway, moral failings aside, I know it’s probably a cliché at this point to set a murder mystery on a train, but I’m not lying when I tell you that the excitement of having a bunch of people stuck in one place where one of them is a killer hasn't worn off on me yet. You could call me boring, but how about we just pretend like I have a thing for the classics instead. Seriously though, I just really love stories that force the characters in a place where the tensions are at their highest, because it’s an opportunity for an author to really flex their writing ability. Can they write a mystery where all the suspects are in one place over one night and still keep things interesting? Sometimes the best stories are the ones where the writers realize they don't have to escalate, but rather dial things back to the basics of what made us fall in love with characters like Penelope Banks in the first place. And to that point, I can say with all my heart that A Murder in Blue works not only as a wonderful mystery, but also Colette Clark's victory lap saying that the Penelope Banks Murder Mysteries can be just as fun and entertaining even if there’s nothing more to it other than just Pen and her wits about her.

Speaking of suspects, this time around we’ve got a racist lady, a newlywed couple who doesn’t act all that newly… wed, an unfazed Irene Adler type, a weirdo who’s always carrying around a Necronomicon looking ass book, the lecherous creep who goes by the name of Mr. “Step back, you're dancin' kinda close, I feel a little poke comin' through on you,” and finally, Pen’s own bestie, Lulu. Now, this is the first book in the series that actually touched upon real issues like racially motivated undertones of false police accusations, and even though I enjoy the doo-wop-Jason-Mraz-feel-good-easy-breezy-cozy-wozy feeling that these books usually evoke, I appreciated this installment's dose of realism. We’re in the 1920’s, so let’s be real, not everything is going to have that golden Great Gatsby sheen to it. I mean, this harsher narrative is made easier to stomach by the fact that (spoilers) it's the racist jerk who dies (end of spoilers). One of my biggest pet peeves is when an author tries to be unique by writing an “anyone can die” narrative, yet always ignores killing off the most awful character because their death wouldn’t carry any emotional weight with the audience. You’d think it’d be a rather niche trope, but I’ve noticed it with Eugene from The Walking Dead, Euron Greyjoy in Game of Thrones, Paul in the newer Spider-Man comics, Hawkeye in Avengers: Age of Ultron, and Hawkeye in Avengers: Endgame, and Hawkeye in Hawkeye. Nobody would give a shit if they died and the author doesn't have the writing chops to get people to give a shit, so as a result, they start getting weirdly defensive over the character and end up keeping them around out of spite more than anything. Sure, it’s not like this book is the reigning champion of discussions around race relations, but at least it’s not Bioshock Infinite, a historical game that tries to “both sides” racism. Otherwise, killing off this person was just as well, because I really don’t care about whether or not a racist person can or will become a better person. At the end of the day, I’d rather just not have to deal with these people in real life or in fiction, and trying to give them a little Finding Forester redemption arc always grinds my gears. "Can people change?" I don't know, not my problem. Anyway, I think it’s funny how this will have been the fourteenth dead body Penelope has stumbled across because I’m starting to think she was cursed after forgetting to carry Madame Zeroni up the thumb shaped mountain or something. Nonetheless, I still marvel at Colette Clark's ability to make every mystery not only wholly unique, but also plausible within the narrative. Whenever I’m reading one of these books an come across a popular highlight that’s a clue, I always have a “should I have been taking notes!?” moment and panic something awful… but that’s just the thing, I read these books the same way I listen to music; I’m just along for the ride. I think that’s why I have such an aversion to Anthony Fantano types, because they're always cutting songs down to bits and analyzing every single line and it’s frustrating because he forgot to ask the most important question: does it sound good? So, that’s why I love these books, not because they’re the most transgressive works of literature, but because they have a nice groove.

“Not all devils are bad, of course,” Benny said, waggling his eyebrows. “Wicked perhaps, but hardly evil.”
30 reviews3 followers
August 12, 2024
All these people giving this book must have read a different version than mine. I found it to be boring, confusing, and I didn't think it would ever end.
Profile Image for Lady Tea.
1,947 reviews133 followers
August 2, 2024
Rating: 4.5 / 5

After a derailment two books long, I'm happy to say that this series is finally back on track! (Cause...it's a train, get it? Haha...)

Ahem, anyways, the story picks up where it left off, with our characters on their European tour. Having sampled the delights (and murders) of the Cote D'Azur, Pen and her gang are on their way to Paris via train. Things are going smoothly and romantically until, of course, they're not as a murder occurs.--of course, obvious reference to and inspiration by Murder on the Orient Express fully applies.

Naturally, as the characters are all confined on the journey until the murderer is found, Penelope can't help but investigate, especially since she and her friends are all suspects as well.

______

Now, first off, I'm glad that I decided to stick with this series, as some previous books--*glares at Murder on the Atlantic: A 1920s Historical Mystery*--almost turned me off earlier. Still, the author's gotten in better shape and is steadily moving back up to the regard with which I hold this series, and Penelope herself.

This book just has...well, a little bit of everything that I like in a good murder mystery. The train as a setting is essential, as it's the equivalent of a 'locked room murder', where everyone is stuck with the murderer and everyone is a suspect until proven otherwise. This is, of course, especially hard to do since almost everyone is lying about their purpose for being there (and some, their identities), and therefore everyone is suspicious in one way or another and nothing is as it seems.

From start to finish, while this wasn't the most action-packed or exciting book of the series, one thing it does really well is keeping the plot nevertheless fast-paced, just through discussion. Because...yes, there's not really much that Penelope can do apart from discuss things and ask questions, as even her eidetic memory is only so relevant within the confines of a train. She works much like Poirot does on the Orient Express, needing to zone in on what questions to ask, and essentially put together a narrative about people that she doesn't know, any of whom may have done it, in a way that makes sense.

Also, every chapter, though mostly on the shorter side, has some new revelation or other to toss at the reader, and it really shows that the author put thought into how to make this compelling and invite readers back into Penelope's world. It also shows how an interesting story doesn't HAVE to have a lot going on or be fast-paced or action-packed; it just has to be clever, and both the reader and Penelope certainly need to get their brain and gears grinding to figure this one out!

If I had one thing to mention about it that I felt lacking, and which accounts for the .5 stars that I'm taking off, it's that I was disappointed by how little of a role the rest of Penelope's group really plays in this story. I mean, Benny, Lulu, Cousin Cordelia, and Richard are all present and there, but considering that Richard is a key police presence and detective, he doesn't do much, and the rest of the gang has even LESS to do. Their roles are pretty much just Cousin Cordelia being distressed and/or scandalized at what's happening and what some people are saying, Benny making some snarky comments and loving every juicy tidbit that they find out, and Lulu...honestly doing precisely nothing--just standing there looking pretty, I guess. (Like, seriously, these three hardly get any speaking roles in this, which makes them seem almost like an afterthought, there just to complete Penelope's entourage, but...not for any real reason.)

Let me reach out directly to the author about this faux pas: you've built up a great SET of characters in this series, and you should really treat them as such. It shouldn't be just Penelope going at it alone, especially not when everyone has their own set of skills to contribute and have already proven themselves resourceful, again and again in previous mysteries. I'm okay with overlooking it for one book, but if the pattern in the future insists on being Penelope-centric, personally that dims the level of enjoyment for this series for me, as it's the characters that really drive readers to care about this genre, especially from one book to the next in a series that can potentially go on and on and on. Ahem, just saying.

As for the mystery and solution itself...eh, it wasn't the most "twisty-turny" thing I've ever read, but it's not immediately obvious either, so it's fine. I mean, I guess I wasn't blown away by it, but that's not why I read this series in the first place, so I can't count that as a disappointment.

Anyway, all in all, I remain therefore optimistic about things moving forward, and hope that we have only good things planned ahead for this series. I believe that next time they will find themselves in Paris?
Profile Image for Michelle.
1,965 reviews23 followers
August 1, 2024
Crazy train!

What a crazy ride! Pen and her group have left the French Riviera and are off to Paris. They take the famous Blue Train and expect to spend a night in luxury and that’s far from what they got. While their surroundings were fabulous the journey is marred by murder and a missing artifact. Now there is but a few hours for the case to be unraveled before they end up at the next station and possibly under arrest!
What a fabulous adventure this vacation is turning out to be. Not quite the relaxing haunt they all expected but I think Pen and her friends would’ve been bored by a sedate vacation by the sea. I was amazed at how this case was solved and just who and how they almost pulled it off. I absolutely loved Honorine she was a hoot! I hope she spends some time with the group once they get to Paris. And omg what a cliffhanger to end on! I cannot wait to see what’s next!!
128 reviews3 followers
June 2, 2025
My Favorite Setting for Murder

A train…and not just any train a first class luxury train in the golden age of rail travel. A concierge in every first class car…a private dining car for first class passengers only…a 24 hour cocktail bar in the lounge car. Truly living large for Penelope and her band of friends. They are traveling from the south of France to Paris in the most luxurious way. So why does something seem off to Pen. There are passengers who just don’t seem to rate First Class, a honeymoon couple that don’t seem to be at all in love, a rich businessman traveling with his beautiful girlfriend but doesn’t book connecting rooms. I won’t be a spoiler but soon murder gives Pen a lot to think about. This another beautifully crafted page turner from Colette Clark…lucky 13 for we devoted readers,
Profile Image for KathleenWH.
190 reviews4 followers
August 4, 2024
Another fine mystery from Colette Clark

I always look forward to Colette Clark’s books.

In the course of her Penelope Banks works, she has helped Penelope mature
from hustling as a card shark in order to survive to being an international
traveler fluent in French.

I hope Ms Clark will continue the Penelope Banks series, or, if not, take her
readers on equally exciting adventures.
Profile Image for Maryann.
320 reviews4 followers
August 13, 2024
A Train Full of Suspects Speeding to Paris

Pen and her friends are, as always, fun. In this homage to Christie’s Orient Express, Pen and company need to solve a murder and find a stolen treasure. Everyone in first class has a motive and most seem to have the opportunity at least until Pen figures it out. I recommend curling up with this book if you’re up for a lovely escape from the real world.
Profile Image for Lonny Johnson.
509 reviews12 followers
January 15, 2025
I really love the Penelope Banks series. This is a fine addition to it. Pen and her fiance, Detective Richard Prescott have just a few hours to discover who killed Mssr. Barbier, a most unpleasent businessman travelling with his mistress and a number of secrets. It all comes together with 2 twists at the end. As I am approaching the end of the series as it stands, I sincerely hope Ms. Clark has many more ideas up her sleeve for the further adventures of Penelope Banks.
Profile Image for Richard.
536 reviews5 followers
August 1, 2024
Worth the wait to read

Combine Murder on the Orient Express, The Maltese Falcon, and all the reveal scenes from the movie Clue and you have this story, only better! " It's the stuff dreams are made of, sweetheart! "
39 reviews
August 3, 2024
What a great read!!

Colette really outdid herself this time!! I really liked this book. It truly was a complex case.

I'm also happy to hear that there will be a spinoff series with one of these characters. I can't wait to read!!
Profile Image for Cathie Murphy.
1,177 reviews
September 6, 2026
Not a big fan of this book. The plot and storyline were interesting, but I just couldn't get into the book. It was largely just a lot of dialogue that seemed to go on and on. I normally love her books, but not this one. Despite being a police detective, her boyfriend seemed to remain clueless, which doesn't make sense. This book needed some action to keep it interesting. Most of the dialogue was repetitive. Recommend.
Profile Image for Larry.
3,325 reviews20 followers
December 22, 2024
This has been quite a fun series! The characters have become beloved to me and the supporting characters in this story has provided quite the fun story on a train headed for Paris. The plot is easily followed and the premise is finding out who killed the obnoxious fellow passenger and why. The answers were quite surprising to me, at least. I definitely recommend this book.
Profile Image for Rachel.
643 reviews4 followers
August 2, 2026
I enjoyed this Agatha Christie type story. The writing style was a little different for me and I do enjoy the books set between the world wars. It was a complicated murder and the ensuing hunt for the killer had many ups and downs and was also a little unorthodox with the DI taking the narrator, Rutherford, into his confidence. A great listen on Audio.
Profile Image for Leona.
526 reviews7 followers
August 20, 2024
Wasn't crazy about this one although I've liked the author's other books. Far too many characters and name changes but I can appreciate how difficult it must've been to write. Looking forward to the next one though.
265 reviews1 follower
August 14, 2024
This one didn’t grab me at all. Too convoluted and I just wasn’t interested in the murder or the stolen artifacts.
Profile Image for Jeannine.
68 reviews
August 20, 2024
It s a nice homage to Agatha Christie’s Orient Express, but it's too slow for me. They mostly just sit around talking. 2.5 stars
100 reviews
February 8, 2025
Another great addition to the series and homage to Agatha Christie. The story was well written and had a number of twists and turns. I thought the monkey was going to be in the book (pages hollowed out) so the champagne bottle was a twist I missed.

Some of the reviews complained it was boring and had too many characters. It lacked physical activity and locations because it took place on a train. There is only so much you can do and the time frame was only overnight. You needed a cast of characters to divert suspicion. I think it was very well played by the author.


I love way the series is progressing with a mystery at each location along the journey of their holiday.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Dianna.
32 reviews
March 31, 2026
I Enjoy her books and would recommend them to anyone. try one and you'll see how good they are 😊
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Lass Loda.
70 reviews
November 12, 2025
This one was hard to follow despite the small setting. Too many main characters and a bit of a slog to get through. 'Locked room mystery' too quickly dispensed with, final motive/ culprit ended up a bit meh. And I say this as a train murder mystery enjoyer.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Displaying 1 - 20 of 20 reviews