I read this as an audiobook, narrated by the author.
I’ll break this review down by each section.
Dopamine - by far the most engaging chapter. Not only the neuroscience being the most interesting but also the advice seemed best thought out. I feel that the inception of this book was a premise that was all about dopamine, but that would have lacked a catchy anagram. That isn’t to say all his suggestions hit the mark. Power suggests a good way to build dopamine is this modern concept of ‘flow state’ - the magical engagement ‘zone’ that lies between enjoyment and challenge. While I’m sure it builds dopamine, building a scenario that will put you in a flow state (at work, while exercising, while hobbying) is immensely difficult. Slow days at work, hard days at the gym, or a book you just cannot get lost in (naming no names), would make this, at best, an unreliable dopamine building activity. However some of his advice, such as “phone fasting” (if you can look past the needless new-age terminology) is quite worthwhile.
Oxytocin - this, for me, is where the wheels started falling off. Oxytocin is the “love” hormone. This means it’s generated by us doing loving acts. It seems painfully tone deaf to consider that this is a hormone which should be “boosted” by hugging your family more, or engaging intimately with a partner. Surely, if this is something you’re not doing enough because of not having loved ones nearby or simply being single, it’s not like you can go out and fix it by hugging (or engaging intimately with) a stranger. I also felt the neuroscience started to fall down here. Power recommends displays of gratitude for boosting your Oxy levels. Why? With so much explained about how dopamine works - with our ancestors needing a hormone that makes hard work attractive to repeat - we are told oxytocin drives relationship development and procreation. Okay, so why would having an attitude of gratitude help that? I’m not saying it’s wrong, I’m saying it’s not clear. For an audiobook purporting to explain hormones and how to improve their balance, knowing exactly how it works and why it rises or falls would have been good content.
Serotonin - in an age where more people than ever are turning to pharmacology to bat away the darkness, and using things like SSRIs, will Power be able to provide novel and insightful ways in which might improve our mood and boost our “happiness hormone”? Yes: get outside, preferably in the sun, eat well, sleep deeply and don’t overthink. Well, it’s a wonder pharmacies aren’t already boarding up their windows. The serotonin section of this book reaches a peak of ignorance. Those who suffer from a lack of, or clinically low levels of happiness hormone are not going to feel supported by being told all the things in which is rammed down our throats by Instagram Influencers and Health Mags. I don’t know anyone who is unaware of the benefits of getting outside on a sunny day, reducing processed sugar and alcohol from their diet or getting the clinically recommended eight hours per night.
Endorphins - an ugly problem now rears its head by the time we roll around to part 4. The very first suggestion to improve your endorphin levels is exercise. Exercise which overlaps with methods to boost serotonin and dopamine. So maybe a better approach would have been to pick some novel and typical recommendations at improving well being (like exercise) and like the ways in which this neurochemically affects us. For example “exercise is good. You may not like it because of ‘x’, but when you do it, you experience ‘y’, the long term benefit of exercise being ‘z’.” Obviously then you would just be writing a boring thesis paper on the benefits of exercise and diet and getting outdoors. But the neuro chemistry would be more engaging. There is one 5-minute section at the end of the book, “DOSE Stacking” which deals with the intersectionality of these chemicals, but it is astoundingly basic and feels like a natural place for this book to have culminated in, but like, an hour, not five minutes.
The parts of the chapter which refer to challenges and strategies are interesting, adding a practical layer to what would otherwise be a fairly by-the-numbers read. However, the separation of the paragraphs into segments which can be referred to and looked back at when you need a method to increase hormones seems more like a handbook / cheat sheet than an actual learning process. I feel like I’m in a lesson in school. Instead of learning what builds my hormones, what tanks my hormones, why my hormones work that way, and ideas to go away with that work with my life, I’m given 5 strategies ranging from things I already do, to things that are wildly incongruent with my current lifestyle. I already sing in the car, so that section is useless, and my gym doesn’t have a sauna, and I’m not going to change my membership anytime soon.
The audio bonus section genuinely made me think why is this a book (and wonder how it was put to page). In the interests of full disclosure, I did not read this through all the way through - there are 20 and 30 minute sections at the end of the book which is sleep sounds and body scans which I do not feel motivated to engage with. I cannot comment on whether they are effective but I would instead seek out an application that is focused on those things (Headspace), similarly with the exercises or stretches, I don’t consider the ones in this book to be definitive - speak to a personal trainer or at least look into what stretches work for you on instagram. It’s a last ditch attempt at adding value in a book which so desperately does not want to be a book.
This is so podcast-coded, trying to throw out a plethora of ideas so I feel like I’m getting use out of it but on reflection the science is shallow, I’m being overly sold on “what my life can be like”.
I was ultimately disappointed with this book. The premise was very interesting but it just fell foul of the usual pitfalls of someone with 750k Instagram followers thinking that even more people need to hear about things you learned on your Masters degree.
One star for the suggestion of getting off my phone, the aMCC stuff and for the fact that serotonin is produced in the gut; so, if you eat crap you feel like crap. Go figure. But at least that’s some reasoning.