In June 2017, John Grisham published an offbeat novel – “Camino Island” - that wasn’t a legal thriller focusing on lawyers. Instead, he took aim at the world of bookstores, publishing, and writers. It began with a skillful heist of five John F. Fitzgerald manuscripts from a secure vault below Princeton’s Firestone Library. The manuscripts end up in a secondary black market and a young female writer, Mercer Mann, is hired to go undercover an investigate Bruce Cable, the popular independent bookstore owner of Bay Books on Camino Island and prominent dealer in rare books that is thought to have or know who is in possession of the manuscripts.
I thought the book was interesting and well worth the read. However, there were many other readers who just didn’t get into it the way I did.
In April 2020, Grisham published a follow-up novel – “Camino Winds” - that was focused on a murder mystery occurring during a destructive storm. This time Hurricane Leo tears through the island, leaving devastation, ruin, and flooding in its wake. Following the hurricane, Bruce and his buddies discover that their fellow thriller writing friend, Nelson Kerr, appears to be an apparent victim of murder after suffering several suspicious strikes to the head from a blunt instrument.
I thought the second book was a leisurely read but thin, slow and drawn out in almost casual manner. There was no real drama or tension in solving Kerr’s murder, which mostly takes place away from the island, a bit poorly developed, and several key plot points occur offscreen (which was fairly frustrating at times).
Now, in May 2024, Grisham returns to the island for a third novel – “Camino Ghosts” – focusing on a legal battle for ownership of a nearby deserted island called Dark Isle. The first combatant is a giant resort developer, Tidal Breeze, trying to build a resort and casino complex by flexing its political connections, deep pockets, and a relentless willingness to play dirty. The second combatant is eighty-year-old Lovely Jackson, the last living survivor that lived on the island, and carrying the entire history and legacy of previously escaped slaves.
Even though Lovely has written a book about the history of her people and openly laid claim to Dark Isle, she is just an obstacle to be removed by Tidal breeze one way or another. Even the belief that the locals have in the island being cursed is not enough to turn back the powerful corporation, its team of lawyer, lobbyists, and state politicians. This time, Mercer, Thomas, Bruce, and the rest of their team are facing impossible odds, ultimate power, and insatiable greed…
Let me start off by saying that I have rarely read a bad Grisham novel. He is such an excellent writer that he makes everything sound good, and this is a decent book. However, as much as I like the Camino Island characters, this book is more interesting than compelling. Rather than being a thriller, it’s more like a cross between Grisham-lite and a Grisham cozy mystery. I don’t mean to sound critical, but this is a quick 292-page Spring/Summer read that comes across more casual and formula-Matic than is intended. It is an easy two or three-evening read that feels causal and lacks much of the intensity that comes with most of Grisham’s legal thrillers.
As you can tell by those comments, the good news is that this one is much better than the last one – “Camino Winds” by far. The story is tighter, more focused, and key moments take place onstage rather than offstage. For me, Grisham’s flashback stories of the runaway slaves living and surviving on the island were some of my favorite parts of the book, even more so than the legal fighting and maneuvering between the good guys and the bad guys.
On the other hand, there is also some real constructive criticism too. I found that the strength and heart of this book. Without that history intertwined with the current day legal battle, the first two-thirds of the book felt more like a leisurely small-town cozy mystery than a legal drama. More style than substance at times.
There’s no doubt that Grisham knows how to tell a story that readers enjoy. He is a master storyteller that has written more winners than I can name off the top of my head. However, with this one the outcome never really felt like it was in doubt, nor were the twists and turns as tension filled as his earlier legal thrillers. I also think that he could have done more with this, including more depth and removing some of the mechanical plotting.
That is until the last 30 – 40 pages, when Grisham finds a way to kick into a higher gear and up the emotional ante. He finds a way to bring everything home in the end with a bittersweet and melancholy ending that is the right one. For me, this improved my overall thoughts on the book in a material way. My heart strings were tugged in a sentimental and reflective way that few writers can pull off, and Grisham is one of those who can.
Overall, Grisham’s better than average is equivalent to most everyone else’s good. That was the case for me with “Camino Ghosts”. The first two thirds were 3 stars, and the last third improved to four stars, giving it an overall rating of a little more than 3 out of 5 stars. That’s my story and I am sticking to it…