Forever to Fall

Buckeye Falls #5

by Libby Kay

Welcome to Buckeye Falls, where second chances mend broken hearts for these childhood sweethearts. Wedding bells are ringing, but the sister of the groom is conflicted.

Fifteen years ago, Mallory Lawson “married” her childhood sweetheart, Beckett, in a pretend wedding on his family’s apple farm. She treasures not only the memories, but the ring he put on her finger. The trouble now, her brother, Evan, wants to put that family heirloom on his fiancée’s finger. Mallory adores CeCe, but she struggles to get past her girlhood fantasies of Beckett swooping back into her life with a certain ruby ring…

Beckett Fox is at a crossroads. After losing his grandfather, he’s listless and fearful of coming back to the family farm. There are too many memories, and most of them are tied to the love of his life, Mallory. He doesn’t even know if she remembers that fateful day when they were kids, playing make-believe under the apple trees, but he does. Now he’s back to help his buddy get married, and he hopes to find peace on the family farm, with Mallory by his side…

When the wedding planning kicks into high gear, Beckett and Mallory are thrust together as maid of honor and best man. The more time they spend together, the harder it is to ignore the sparks between them. Beckett fears Evan won’t support him dating Mallory, so the pair date in secret. But true love won’t stay hidden forever…

Best-selling author Libby Kay’s Buckeye Falls Series reminds readers of small-town life where everyone knows each other. Fans of Sharon Sala’s Blessings, Georgia series and Susan Mallery’s Fool’s Gold series will fall in love with Buckeye Falls and the childhood sweethearts who are tired of hiding their feelings. Come for the wedding and stay for the whole series.

Genres: Romance, Fiction, Contemporary Romance

312 pages, Kindle Edition

Published August 20, 2024

About the author

Libby Kay lives in the city in the heart of the Midwest with her husband. When she’s not writing, Libby loves reading romance novels of any kind. Stories of people falling in love nourish her soul. Contemporary or Regency, sweet or hot, as long as there is a happily ever after—she’s in love!

When not surrounded by books, Libby can be found baking in her kitchen, binging true crime shows, or on the road with her husband—traveling as far as their bank account will allow.

Writing is a solitary job, and Libby loves to hear from readers. Reach out, ask questions, and review her stories anytime. She’d love to hear from you.
Website: https://www.libbykayauthor.com/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/libbykayaut...
Facebook: @LibbyKayAuthor

Reviews

[Liz Donatelli · Rating 5 out of 5]

Forever to Fall is Libby Kay's most emotionally compelling romance in the Buckeye Falls series.

Mallory and Beckett's heartfelt "childhood friends-to-lovers"/"brother's best friend"/"best friend's sister" romance journey is brilliantly crafted with hearty doses of small-town charm, food-inspired nostalgia, and swoony romantic gestures.
Kay's exploration of grief and abandonment adds layers of depth that culminate in a deeply satisfying HEA.

Warning: Reading Forever to Fall WILL cause intense cravings for apple cupcakes and French bread pizza.

[Jenni · Rating 4 out of 5]

Buckeye Falls is a magical place, full of lovely couples who have found their way to each other, as well as those who are yet to get it together. This small town is a charming place where everyone knows you and knows your business. It is filled with sassy, sweet, nosy, quirky, and colourful characters.
"Forever to Fall" is the fifth book in the Buckeye Falls series. It tells a friends-to-lovers story of childhood friends who finally reveal their feelings to each other. However, sharing what they have may not make everyone happy.
Libby Kay writes magical stories of love, hopes, wants, needs, and dreams. The journey the characters take to get there is part of the adventure Libby presents.
"Forever to Fall" is a charming tale that has it all to make your heart sigh with happiness - a little angst, lots of sexual tension, spice, wit, and banter that had me laughing. Oh, and there is a wedding and delicious food to make you drool.
Grab a drink and escape reality for some "me time" with this delightful tale.
I wonder who is next to arrive in Buckeye Falls.

[Emily · Rating 4 out of 5]

Mallory Lawson "married" her friend Beckett in a pretend wedding fifteen years ago. Beckett was her brothers best friend. As they grew older, they grew apart and life happened. Now Beckett Fox is back dealing with what to now do with his life, but he knows one thing, he wants Mallory back in it. Beckett is certain Mallory is his one, but there is a hurdle, is best friend. Can Mallory and Beckett have their second chance and find their happily after?

The one thing I really appreciate with the Buckeye Falls series is the characters are down to earth. Reading the faux wedding of sweet youth was delightful. Mallory has been so busy with her career life has gone by, perfectly paired with Beckett. Another great read from this author.

[Marissa · Rating 4 out of 5]

Mallory got her own book!! Okay, so Mallory has been in love with one boy since forever. She can’t remember a time when she didn’t love him in some way. At first, when they were kids, it was in a friend/brother way. Then somewhere along the way, it became more. Her favorite childhood memory is fake marrying Beckett Fox when she was 13. This memory has everything. Her brother, Beckett, her grandma’s ring, and her first kiss after they said “I do”.

Beckett just lost his grandfather. Two years before that, his grandmother. They have been everything to him since his parent’s divorce when he was 8. His mom went to Boston to start a new life with her new husband, and eventually new family. His dad went west to California. Beckett’s grandparents were everything. Now, he is kinda lost. There are two things he is thankful for in this world, that his job is remote which allows him to travel and find what he is looking for, and the Lawsons. Evan Lawson has been his best friend since practically the crib. Then there is Mallory.

Beckett and Mallory have been friends. They have tried to be more than friends. Beckett can’t work up the nerve to tell Evan that he loves Mallory. Everytime Evan thinks Beckett needs to go to the city to meet some girls, Beckett follows along because he can’t hurt his best friend, leaving Mallory hurt in the wake. Beckett has moved to Buckeye Falls to be close to Evan and because it hurts too much to be out at the family farm without his grandfather. That means that he will see Mallory, be around Mallory, have to interact with Mallory. Neither Beckett or Mallory is ready for that.

The only roadblock standing in their way is Beckett’s inability to tell Evan. Evan is so blissfully in love with CeCe and doesn’t see what everyone else sees, that Mallory and Beckett are in love. Evan is focused on his proposal and then engagement and wedding. Beckett fights himself to keep his found family while fighting for the love of his life. Will Evan ever be able to accept Beckett and Mallory together?

I still love these characters. The sibling banter between Evan, Mallory and Emily is sooooo very true to life. I swear I have said something similar to my sisters at some point, especially when I am right. 😂 I don’t know who else in the town needs to find love, but I hope there is someone because I don’t know if I am ready to say goodbye to these characters. They are just wonderful and awesome. You don’t have to read the entire series, but read about Mallory and Beckett. I totally encourage you to read the series. It rocks.

[Beverly Finnie · Rating 5 out of 5]

Welcome back to Buckeye Falls! In Forever to Fall the next one to fall is Mallory. Well actually she may have fallen years ago but never had her chance. The author tells her story in a way that shows wonderful character growth but also the main characters need to self-sacrifice even when it hurts.
Beckett is back. Well he just moved to Buckeye Falls and he knows this is where the one who got away lives. His grandfather’s dying wish was for him to get his girl. Easier said than done. 1st step: move to where she is. 2nd step: he hasn’t figured that out yet. Evan is the issue, he’s his best friend but also the brother of the woman he’s been pinning for, for years.
How can he go for what he wants?
Mallory is in a frenzy knowing Beckett just moved to her town. He’s the one he always has been, but he doesn’t feel the same way. Or so she thought. And then there’s the matter of Nana’s ring. A ring she always thought would be hers, but Evan wants it. Downside she takes the pain and says congratulations it’ll be perfect for Cece, all the while she’s emotionally destroyed inside. Not only does Beckett see it but her sister does too! Evan seems to be oblivious to notice. Just like he’s too oblivious to notice how she feels about his best friend.
Can her and Beckett coexist for those around them?
Will they always be awkward with one another?
Or will they finally take the chance they’ve always wanted?
It’s a wonderful addition to the series. A series of books that are great to read in succession. However each one works as a standalone novel as well. I will say this though, once you read one you’ll want to read them all!

[Angela · Rating 4 out of 5]

4 Stars

Forever to Fall is the fifth and final instalment in the Buckeye Falls series by Libby Kay. This was a bit of a bittersweet read, as I really wanted Mallory and Beckett’s story, but wasn’t ready to leave Buckeye Falls yet.
This is a second chance, small town contemporary romance- with childhood sweethearts reunited, secret dating, sparks, drama, a wonderful cast of endearing characters, connection, emotion, family, friendship, and a bit of a forced proximity situation. It is a ‘clean’ romance- suitable for those who prefer their romances on the sweet and less spicy side.
This has a few different tropes happening in it, but they all blend together into a wonderful story. From brother’s best friend/best friends little sister to a secret relationship, with forced proximity (and more)- this story has all the ingredients to keep you turning the pages
Even though this is the fifth and final book in the series, it can be read as a standalone if you wanted, as each instalment focuses on its own particular couple. But, having said that, there is a cast of recurring characters who really add to the overall reading experience, and are really worth getting to know. So, I recommend starting at the beginning, if you haven’t already- because all the books together equals lots of fun!
As expected, Ms. Kay knows how to weave a heart-warming story – and even though I’m sad to be leaving Buckeye Falls, I am excited to see what she has in store for us next.
Happy Reading…

Thank you, Libby Kay!

[Jennie · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book is the fifth, and final, in the “Buckeye Falls” series. Earlier in the series we were introduced to Mallory, sister to Evan, who works for Max in the town diner. This book tells Mallory’s story. Mallory and Beckett were childhood sweethearts who reconnect in adulthood. They struggle to find a way to be together as adults and often wonder if their relationship is even possible.
I read the previous four books in this series. I think readers could enjoy this book without reading the rest of the series, but I found it more enjoyable and easier to follow the characters’ story lines since I read the previous books. I absolutely love this series! I am so happy we have a story for Mallory now. The characters of Buckeye Falls (a fictional Ohio town), are absolutely endearing. The families are warm and loving, though they also sometimes pick on one another. The friendships are heartfelt and genuine.
Mallory is such a sweetheart, and often indecisive. It seems like her to be unsure of how to proceed with Beckett. I found the ups and downs of their relationship sometimes frustrating. I couldn’t put this book down, though. I couldn’t wait to find out if they made it work. I love the romantic gestures between the characters. This book focuses more on the relationship building than sex scenes, and I appreciate that. I would definitely recommend this book to anyone who loves a sweet romantic tale, especially one with twists and turns.

[Francis · Rating 5 out of 5]

Forever to Fall is the fifth book in the Buckeye Falls series. Each book in this series is a romance focusing on a different pair of people in the Buckeye Falls community. With her brother Evan’s wedding approaching, Mallory is worried about the lifetime of spinsterhood that seems to lie ahead of her. Her childhood sweetheart coming back to town, and preparing to be her brother’s best man, complicates her feelings further.

Each book in this series can be read as a standalone, but reading them in order will let you get to know the characters as they are introduced. I like seeing the couples from previous books enjoying their lives together further down the line!

Although the romance is at the centre of this book, I love all the friendships around the sides. Mallory, Evan and Beckett have a friendship going back decades with lots of fun traditions. As she struggles with her feelings, Mallory leans on friends like Alice and CeCe.

Beckett’s family farm provides a lovely setting for much of the story, including the childhood memories he shares with Mallory and Evan. It’s also a space that holds a lot of grief for him after losing his grandparents, so part of the story is him learning how to navigate his changing relationship with the place.

This is a comforting and fun read. I’d recommend it to fans of romances built on foundations of strong friendships. It gets five stars from me!

[Jaimie · Rating 5 out of 5]

I love this whole series! It's super cute. It deals with different "couples" in each book. They all live in and/or move to a small town named Buckeye Falls in Ohio. Everyone knows everyone and the town is so sweet! This book is about Mallory and Beckett. Mallory has been dreaming of her wedding her whole life. Playing make believe and getting married to her brother's best friend and their childhood neighbor has been in her head for 15 years! Even the family heirloom ring is in those dreams. Finding out her brother plans to give it to his girlfriend CeCe has her speechless and watching that dream float away. What she doesn't know is that her brother's best man of course is going to be his best friend Beckett! He's moved back to town and the family farm. He can't forget that marriage under the apple trees was back when either and he wants her by his side. Both of them dream to be with each other and it's hard to hide it. As wedding plans get sorted, because they are best man and maid of honor, they are both thrown together more and more. Of course huge sparks fly!!! Fearful of her brother's opinion they start to date in secret. But as we all know those can't stay hidden! Will it all blow up in their face? Can childhood love last through the ages? And what about the brother and the ring!! If you haven't read any of this series you will not be disappointed! Grab them all! I love the characters and the world that the author spins. I can see this as a movie series so easily!

[Jennifer · Rating 5 out of 5]

Having read and enjoyed the previous books in this series I was looking forward to this latest instalment, and I was not disappointed. Childhood sweethearts Mallory and Beckett married in a pretend wedding on Beckett’s family Apple farm. Mallory still treasures those memories fifteen years later, but now it’s her brother Evan and fiancé CeCe who are getting married. Beckett is returning to his family’s farm having lost his grandfather. He has many memories surrounding his childhood home and they tend to involve Mallory, the love of his life.
As maid of honour and best man Mallory and Beckett are spending a lot of time together which is making it hard to deny their feelings for one another and their obvious chemistry. Fearing that Evan won’t support them dating the couple decide to date in secret. However, as their relationship develops they can’t keep it a secret for ever. This is a heartwarming and sweet romance which kept me happily turning the pages. Once again the small town of Buckeye Falls, where everyone knows each other was brought vividly to life by the descriptive narrative. Mallory and Beckett are both likeable and relatable characters and their chemistry came across in the story. I loved being back in Buckeye Falls and I have been hooked by each story in this enjoyable and engaging series.

[Lorralei Hoerner · Rating 5 out of 5]

5 Stars 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

Forever to Fall is Book 5 in the Buckeye Falls Series...I love how I fell like I am part of the Buckeye Falls family. Libby has created this wonderful sense of small town community that I want to be part of....seeing each character develop in this series, you become invested from the beginning of the first book to the end of this book. I love the heartwarming, small town romance full of family, love, friendships, trust and a little bit of secrets.

Mallory and Beckett knew each other since childhood and there has always been this spark between them...but nothing came about since Mallory's brother, Evan is Beckett's best friend. Mixing friendship and romance was off the table and feelings were suppressed between Mallory and Beckett. When Beckett moves back to Buckeye Falls...so many things are happening between family memories, being the best man in a wedding but also the feelings of Mallory coming back into his life....will Beckett and Mallory get their HEA that they deserve.....

Definitely read and find out...I very highly recommend reading this entire series in order..I have loved every book in this series. This may well be the last book but I always look forward to seeing what Libby may have in store for me next to enjoy!!

[Kerry carr · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is the fifth book in the Buckeye Falls series. Even though it is part of a series it can be read as a standalone, however once you've read one you will love the small town feel, the emotion and romance that you will want to read more.
This is a sweet second chance romance filled with sweet moments, secret dating, brother best friend, and childhood sweethearts.

Mallory Lawson has always loved Beckett Fox even when they were children playing together she always knew he was the one for her. The only problem is that he is her brother's best friend. Little does Mallory know that Beckett felt the same way about her but was held back by the same thing worries about what Mallory's brother would say.
Times moves on and Mallory and Beckett move on with their lives and Beckett moves away. But the feelings they feel for each other never leave.
Now Beckett is back in Buckeye Falls, after losing his grandad he is returning to claim the woman he loves.
But will Mallory feel the same? And what will happen when her brother finds out about them? Will they get their happy ever after, after all the years they have fought against their feelings?
This is a really sweet and romantic story that you can't help but fall in love with the characters and with Buckeye Falls.

[Heidi Sturgess · Rating 5 out of 5]

Oh how I missed Buckeye Falls and it’s people ! It’s good to be back 🥰

This was almost too much for my heart to handle but in a good way 😉 Mallory “married “ Beckett in their family orchard 15 years ago and the Ruby ring , which was a family heirloom was on her finger and she’s always dreamed that their childhood wedding would become a reality , Beckett had always owned her heart ❤️ now reality has come to shake things up when her brother Evan wants to propose to CeCe with “ her ring” …., do you feel my anxiety !?

Beckett left Buckeye Falls but his memories never left him and as he heads back home after his grandpas passing he wonders if Mallory also remembers but the heart always will remember my dear 🥰 and he feels what Mallory’s feeling as they prepare for the wedding of friend and family 🥰🙈

So she’s maid of honour and he’s best man so there’s no way they can avoid each other and poor Beckett is fraught that his friend won’t approve his relationship with his sister 🙈

I know I could’ve read this in a shorter time span but I really dragged it out to make it last 🤣❣️📚
I loved each page and being around these characters that just make you feel like you’re home ! I can’t wait to come back again to Buckeye Falls🥰

[Sheri · Rating 5 out of 5]

Forever to Fall is the fifth book in the Buckeye Falls series. The book can be enjoyed as a standalone, but I recommend reading the other books in the series. This book focuses on the Mallory and Beckett who "married" as childhood sweethearts with her family's heirloom ring. Mallory's memories are soon squashed as her brother wants to use the ring to propose to his girlfriend. Will Beckett return to town to sweep her off her feet?
The story is well written with lots of emotion. Mallory's brother is oblivious to his sister's feelings and memories of Beckett as he plans his own wedding. Mallory and Beckett get their reunion as they are both in the wedding party. I was hoping for a happy ending, but at moments I was unsure if everything would work out for the two of them. I like there is a bit of complexity to their reunion and it wasn't just handed the easiest of solutions. Everyone is relatable and Mallory's brother reminded me of my own.
I enjoyed the romance, but also the drama that surrounds events involving family. I hope more books are written centered in the small town of Buckeye Falls.

[Rosanna Ingram · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is such a sweet and romantic story that will make you believe in lifetime love. Mallory has loved Beckett for as long as she can remember. One memory that has stuck with her is when her brother, Evan, married her and Beckett in a wedding ceremony when they were just children. When Evan gets engaged, Mallory and Beckett find themselves thrown together for wedding festivities. The feelings of the past still remain, but the two decide to date in secret because they don't think Evan will approve. However, like in any small town, nothing stays a secret forever. Will these two, who loved each other when they were young, be able to make their forever dreams come true?

This is a cute story that I devoured in one sitting. While it is the 5th book in the series, it can definitely be read as a standalone. I enjoyed the small town atmosphere and the belief that you can find your true love before you really know what love is. I have enjoyed the other books in this series and this one was just as good.

[Maisie Camille · Rating 4 out of 5]

Forever to Fall is the fifth instalment of Libby Kay’s Buckeye Falls series, and it follows childhood friends Beckett and Mallory, who reunite after the tragic loss of Beckett’s grandfather. I loved the previous book so I was really excited to read this one. The prologue was adorable, so well written and gripping. Beckett and Mallory are clearly soulmates, as are Beckett’s grandparents whose love story was beautiful. I loved seeing Alice and James again, and how the childhood best friends to lovers/will they won’t they was executed. It was hard to read the part where Beckett goes out with Cece’s friend, despite understanding why he wanted to keep his feelings from Evan. I also think it would’ve hit harder if Cece’s friend was a pleasure to be around and we could see how he still preferred to be with Mallory. But either way, it’s clear they are the only person for each other. My favourite character was Mallory. I recommend this book because it is a beautiful friends to lovers story. ‘Trying—six little letters strung together for maximum impact.’

[Tausha Treadway · Rating 5 out of 5]

Forever to Fall (Buckeye Falls Book 5) by Libby Kay. This is such a sweet, romantic series. Each book in this series focuses on a couple in the Buckeye community. This is Mallory and Beckett's story and its so good. Mallory is helping her brother Evan with his upcoming wedding and its leaving her feeling a little like a spinster. Evan is Mallory's brother and along with Beckett they were inseparable growing up. Beckett and Mallory always had a attraction to each other but because he was Evan's sister, Beckett felt she was off limits. When he comes back to town after the loss of his Grandfather and he is the best man and Mallory is the Maid of Honor they are spending a lot of time together and the spark is still there. Fresh on both their minds is the pretend wedding they had when they were younger. When they finally give in to dating they are scared others will not be happy and cause them grief. Will they finally have their happily ever after. Read this sweet small town, second chance romance to find out.

[Tara Johnson · Rating 5 out of 5]

Forever to fall is Book 5 in the Buckeye Falls Series. Mallory and Beckett have not seen each other in fifteen years. They were once childhood sweethearts who shared one unforgettable day playing make-believe where they kissed under the apple tree. Then time and distance separated them and each think that the other has forgotten about that moment so many years ago. When Mallory and Beckett are named as Best Man and Maid of Honor for Malory’s brother, Evan, the two spend time together and it reignites the spark between them. Fearing Evan will be unsupportive of their relationship, they choose to keep the relationship a secret which proves to be harder and harder to hide. This was a cute small town second chance romance between childhood sweethearts Mallory and Beckett complete with hope, dreams, love, laughter, and witty banter. I loved the backdrop of small-town Buckeye Falls with its small-town charm and cast of quirky characters. This was another great installment to this amazing series.

[Shannen · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is book five in the Buckeye Falls series, and it’s my favorite one yet! You can absolutely read each one as a standalone but since the characters appear in each one, you’ll want to get more familiar with them and their background. The author steals your attention in the very beginning with such a spectacularly crafted plot and characters that are even further developed than previous books. Mallory is incredibly relatable and has some lingering feeling from her childhood sweetheart, Beckett. Her little brother, Evan, is about to get married and wants to give a family heirloom to his future wife…but it holds special meaning for Mallory. Beckett is such a dreamy book boyfriend! His grandpa had beautiful words of wisdom before he passed, and Beckett is trying to live up to them. This second-chance romance in a small town is a delightful read with the author’s skillful storytelling and vivid depiction of Buckeye Falls. Whether you’re drawn to the allure of rekindled love or the charm of small-town life, this book is sure to capture your heart. I highly recommend it!

[Rebecca Hill · Rating 4 out of 5]

This book is number 5 in the Buckeye Falls series. This book can completely be read as a stand alone. I have read all the other books in the series, and I really enjoyed the continuation of characters. For the most part, books in this series have centered around a set of two main characters with characters from previous books set as supporting cast. I love reading more about all them! This book is the story about Mallory Dawson and Beckett Fox. Mallory has loved Beckett for as long as she can remember. She has learned to live without him. When he moves back to Buckeye Falls, she doesn’t know if she can continue to live without him. Unbeknownst to her, Beckett is also in love with her. It was a sweet story about the two of them finding their way to each other. I’m not sure that I believe in love at first sight at all, much less in kids, but I still enjoyed the book. Worth the time to read as a story and as a series.

[Jennifer P Ramos · Rating 5 out of 5]

I’ve been eyeing this series for quite some time and finally decided to give it a try on the last one in the series. I will admit I was a bit nervous jumping into the series at the final but honestly I do not regret it! I definitely plan on reading the entire series now from the beginning. This story centers on Mallory and Beckett, who were once childhood sweethearts but with time and distance, move on with their lives but somehow emotions were deeply buried. Now into adulthood, Mallory’s brother has just announced he is marrying Cece and she ends up being the Maid of Honor along with the Best Man, Beckett. The close union brings them together along with the memories of what they once were. I absolutely love how the admiration is focused in this story but seeing how all of these characters are intertwined and their involvement and love within this small town of Buckeye Falls. Great and very entertaining read!

[Audrie Harrington · Rating 5 out of 5]

I have loved every book that I have read set in Buckeye Falls. The characters are relatable and the plot lines and conflicts are so true to life and families and love. This book followed Mallory, one of the Lawson kids and Beckett, one of her and Evan’s best friends growing up. Mallory is a nurse in the ER and living an ok life. She has friends and loves her family but she has been pining over Beckett since they got “married” at 12 years old. Beckett just lost his grandpa from cancer and is moving home. He broke Mallory’s heart unintentionally a few years before and then just traveled the country. They keep running into each other and with Evan planning to propose they are thrown into the planning. They are having a hard time keeping their feelings from showing and they really don’t want Evan to know. Mallory needs to make it through the engagement and maybe something can happen with Beckett. I hope there is more to come because I just can’t put these books down!

[Laura · Rating 5 out of 5]

Forever to Fall is book 5 of the Buckeye Falls series by Libby Kay. I regretfully have not read the previous 4 books. Despite this fact, I was able to completely enjoy this story. It focuses on Mallory and Beckett. Mallory has been in love with Beckett for years, and he JUST moved back to town! He's going to be her brother Evan's best man in his wedding to Cece. Mallory is upset to find out that Evan plans to give Cece Nana's ring, which she had wanted for herself. Evan is too self-absorbed to see her devastation, though. Mallory is maid of honor and Beckett is best man, so they end up spending a lot of time together. They end up trying to have a secret relationship, but we all know how that ends up working out. This is a sweet book based in a sweet town and I enjoyed reading it. I'll happily be going back to read the previous books in the series, and I look forward to more from this author.

[Kristan Anderson · Rating 4 out of 5]

Forever to Fall by Libby Kay is book five of the Buckeye Falls series. I have not read any of the others in this series and did not find it difficult to catch up, although I know the books are intertwined. I would definitely go back and read the others because this was a cute story and I enjoyed it overall. Mallory and Beckett “married” each other when they were kids, the cutest childhood sweethearts. Both have grown up and lead separate lives until now. Mallory’s brother is getting married and both she and Beckett have been thrown together as maid of honor and best man. When you know someone is the one, you just KNOW. And these two have to hide the fact that they have finally figured it out. This second chance story is definitely one of those quick read feel gooders. Everything about it was sweet and charming.

[Dawn Daughenbaugh · Rating 5 out of 5]

5 Stars
Forever to Fall (Buckeye Falls Book 5) by Libby Kay

Forever to Fall is the fifth book in the Buckeye Falls series. This is a Second chance romance that I absolutely loved reading. I’ve truly enjoyed reading this series and this might be my favorite yet. Oh Mallory and Beckett these two know how to pull the heartstrings. These two when they were much younger had a pretend wedding that neither one ever forgot. Fast forward a bit and now that they are adults it’s seems they both have the same thoughts. With an upcoming wedding these two are thrown into maid of honor and best man duties that brings them closer together. They find themselves dating in secret. What happens next you must read to find out. I can’t recommend this book enough. I’m looking forward to reading more from this Author.

[Lisa · Rating 4 out of 5]

This isn’t my favorite of the series but it is still good. Mainly because I keep getting the feeling this isnt the first time they have danced this secret dance. But yet no mention of it. Just guesses they have been together multiple times in the past 10 yrs. They both are just waiting for it to magically be okay with the brother but no one wants to tell him until after his engagement. Now the whole idea of them getting “married” when they were kids by the brother is great. Add in years gone by and each would love to do it for real but there is on giant obstacle. Evan. Beckett worries of losing friendship or never seeing Mal again. He figures either way he loses so why try. Overall this is cute and delightful with the bumps and bruises that come with close family and friends. These two really took Forever

[Bobbi Wagner · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is an author that I have enjoyed reading from the first book I picked up by this author. I enjoy their creative writing style as well as their attention to details that made the characters pop. This is a well written story about Beckett and Mallory. When they were younger they had a pretend wedding. Now that they are adults and have been dating in secret. What will happen when their romance comes out? Will she be the one to wear the family heirloom or will her brother’s fiance? I enjoyed both these characters. They are connectable and bring the story to life. They have great growth and chemistry throughout the story. Their story is fast paced and hard to put down. An engaging story that is easy to read and entertaining. I highly recommend this book.

[Stephen Rymer · Rating 4 out of 5]

Forever To Fall by Libby Kay is like a roller coaster of emotions. It follows the storyline of two people who have been best friends ever since they were children. Beckett is in love with Mallory. Mallory's brother Evan is getting married to CeCe and invites Mallory to the wedding. Beckett wants to marry Mallory but doesn't know how to tell her. It is a cheesy romance where one loves the other but the other is focused on something else. I enjoyed reading the book from the prologue to the end. With 30 characters of excitement, Sad scenes, and Love, you will be reading till the end wondering if he will ever get to marry her. Find out in Libby Kay's Newest book in the Buckeye Falls Series.
@Stephen Rymer
08/2024

[Kat Mellon · Rating 5 out of 5]

Forever to Fall was such a cute read! It is the 5th in the Buckeye Falls series but is totally fine as a standalone. This was my first read by this author and the first books are not necessary to be able to follow and enjoy this one. Although I am totally going to go back and read the others because it was such a fun story. It does get a little frustrating when the MMC can't get past what is seemingly his own cowardice to tell Mal how he truly feels, and then in turn to be able to tell her brother/his best friend the truth of it as well. I get why he was hesitant, but think he was really selling his best friend short.
All in all, was really well written, wonderful characters and a happy ever after that wasn't cheesy and cliche to get to. Easy to read and fun.

[Ella Gleason · Rating 5 out of 5]

Forever to Fall by Libby Kay, is the 5th book in the buckeye fall series. This is an Amazing book, Beckett is a funny relatable guy who is messy, clumsy, funny, and very relatable. Mallory is very much a homebody and is very much obsessed with French bread pizzas. Together I got to deep dive into their friendship and story on how they met each other and became friends. Their relationship that had some bumps. Libby masterfully weaves this story together and created an amazing story making me laugh out loud on multiple occasions and I may have kicked my feet, it’s so cute. And as cute as it was sometimes I wanted to shake them, Libby got me so engrossed in the story I found it very difficult to put down and I would read it again.