Well ... having been hooked on this series from the beginning, I have to say that this is perhaps the most emotional and tense book yet. There are two very different threads in this story but both will have you completely on tenterhooks from start to finish. On the one hand we have our old friend Áróra, who is knocked for six after getting a call from someone who says their child is claiming to be the reincarnation of her long lost sister, Ísafold. On the other, Áróra's partner, Daníel, has his own mystery to solve, the disappearance of his tenant and friend, Lady Gúgúlú. Now the latter disappearance, whilst still unexpected, is not wholly unexplained as Lady G leaves Daníel a note, which would be fine if not for the fact that he left behind all of his belongings, and now there are a trio to very shady, very dangerous, characters trying to track him down. All of which combines to get the tension heaving and the intrigue off the scale and had me tearing through the book at a great rate of knots.
I do love the character of Áróra. She is a very focused and strong woman, quite imposingly so from a physical perspective, but it is fair to say that not knowing what has happened to her sister does have an impact upon her. She seems to try to make up for the loss of her sister by pushing herself to the very limit physically, a fact that is starting to impact upon her not only strength wise, but personality wise, for reasons that become very clear in the reading. You don't need to have read the other books in the series to realise the impact that being told a three year old girl claims to be the reincarnation of Ísafold may have on Áróra, who has long believed her sister to be dead, from around the same time as young Ester Lóa was born as it happens.
I like how the author has played these scenes out, always providing some element of doubt about the veracity of the child's claims, from her parent's 'hobby' to the simple unwillingness of Áróra's friends to believe them. But there are those moments when you do just sit back and wonder. Maybe, just maybe ... There are too many moments, too many times when things cannot be simply explained away, so much so that it pushes the police to follow a new lead that may just give them all some of the answers they crave.
As for the disappearance of Lady G, or Haraldur as Daníel knows him, this adds a real quota or tension and pace to the story. Just who are these mysterious men who are chasing him and what do they want? It's hard to imagine that someone who has lived such a seemingly ostentatious life could actually be on the run, but the more we learn about his past, the more drawn into the story I became. I loved this kind of distraction, and as much as it felt as though it had come from almost nowhere, it actually totally made sense too. I loved exploring Lady G's past, and finding out the answer to a big mystery that had been plaguing Daníel for as long as we have known him. For that part of the book to make sense, you really do need to have read all of the previous books, and why would you not want to? In fact, to get the most out of this book in particular, to understand why Ester Lóa's story makes such an impact, you really need to have read book one at the very least.
I am really drawn to the characters in this series, from Àróra, with her sometimes suspect methods of investigation, to her partner Daníel, who seems incredibly patient with her all the times she is a t her lowest. He understands Àróra so well, as becomes very clear in this book, and is as determined and focused as she is in his quest to understand what happened to Hardaldur, one that is set to be quite painful. Then there is Daníel's work partner, Helena, who is as in tune Daníel professionally, as Daníel is with Àróra emotionally. Add in all of the othe r characters on the periphery of theirs, and Haraldur's lives, and you have a wonderfully diverse array of personalities that add real dimension and authenticity to to story.
There is a real mixture of tension and emotion in this book that kept me captivated from start to finish. The ending is particularly poignant and left me with something of a smile on my face. I love coming back to these characters and I am almost sad to have finished this book as I know it means we are drawing close to the end of the series. Do not fear though. As much as many questions are answered in this fourth instalment, some new ones are asked and I cannot wait to see what Lilja Sigurðardóttir has left in store for us and Àróra. My thanks to translator Lorenza García for bringing the book to life in English for us and capturing all of the energy, tension, angst and emotion of this wonderful range of characters. Definitely recommended for fans of the series. For newcomers, start at the beginning. You won't regret it.