Puck Me Baby One More Time

Playing the Puck #2

by Wynter Ryan

Britt

Being wild and crazy isn’t in my DNA. I’m the quiet best friend. The one who gets straight A’s and hides behind her glasses. But after a breakup with my long-time boyfriend, I need to feed my wild side.

Having a birthday on the same day as Halloween has always felt like a curse until I decide to embrace the magic of the holiday and dress like Brittney Spears for my best friend’s family Halloween party. I’m dressed in a schoolgirl uniform, complete with a blonde pigtail wig and foregoing my glasses for my contacts to hide behind the eye mask to keep my identity a secret, and ready for the night of my life.

I have one mission, and that is to seduce my crush. The problem is I don’t have a crush on just one guy; I have a crush on three my best friend’s triplet brothers, Torin, Talen, and Tarek. All three are professional hockey players who can have any woman they want, but tonight, I want them to want me, and I’ll do anything to make that happen.

I was wrong to think being with them once would be enough to get them out of my mind. Instead, I have to stop myself from begging them to Puck me baby one more time.

Torin, Talen, Tarek

We knew it was Britt hiding behind the mask and wearing the Brittney Spears costume that fateful night, but we decided to play along when she refused to give us her name in that adorable fake British accent that fooled no one. Each one of us gave in to the temptation we swore to stay away from. A brotherly pact we decided on long ago. But when she approached each of us individually, all bets were off.

Once we found out we had each been with our dream girl on the same night, we should have been horrified, but instead, it felt right. Being identical triplets, we have shared everything from the moment we were conceived. Why not Britt? And why not all of us at the same time?

Stepping back and giving her time to come to us was the hardest thing we’ve ever done. Waiting almost two years to make her ours again has been almost impossible. But no other woman will do now that we’ve had a taste of our Britt.

So, when the opportunity arises to be her new roommates, we jump at the chance, hoping to make her moan, oh, baby, baby, baby, one more time.

Genres: Hockey, Why Choose, Contemporary, Hockey Romance

162 pages, Kindle Edition

Published July 4, 2024

Reviews

[Natalie H · Rating 2 out of 5]

July 2024
Kindle edition

They’re short and RH so tick challenge boxes. I’ll probably keep on going just for that. My Why choose count is dismal. This was triplets with similar names and appearances, which made them pretty forgettable. Miscommunication, jealousy and a cheerleader mean girl liar there for the third act almost breakup. The beginning was good and I liked the hot tub, but after a point I was more focused on Gemma.

[Colbygirl13reads · Rating 5 out of 5]

Who doesn't love triplets? Hockey player triplets? Brittany, FMC is best friends with Teagan, who happens to be the sister of Talon, Toren, and Tarek! These incredible triplets and Teagan are some of the best hockey players around. This why choose, best friends brothers sports romance is such a great read. I felt so many emotions, laughing, smiling, frustration and crying all while rooting for Brittany and the triplets. I loved seeing Britt become such a strong, sassy woman who finally sees her worth. And what can we say about Talon, Toren, and Tarek except they are the best book boyfriends ever!! Wynter did it again and I can't wait for the next one. Thank you for the ARC.

[book_lover_jess · Rating 4 out of 5]

Love a best friend brother romance that is a why choose.

And also spicy 🤭🤭

Stars: 4.1/5
Smut: 3.9/5

[Marni Ortiz · Rating 5 out of 5]

Seriously !! What’s not to love about a steamy why choose hockey romance the centers around 3 oh so swoon worthy identical brothers and their sisters best friend!!! This was such a fun read and just the change I so desperately needed . I say this because I’ve been on quite the dark romance binge lately, so it’s not often I get to pick up a story that literally put a smile on my face from the very first page , made me laugh out loud , had me yelling outta pure frustration, made me sob like a baby and kept me rooting so freaking hard . Toren , Talon , and Tarek ( well I just might be a bit in love with all 3 guys - and our heroine Britt ( I just loved everything about her ) she’s not only the the super smart introverted best friend of Teagan ( who is also Toren , Tarek and Talons sister ) but there’s just so much more to her then meets the eye . A.Breakuo with her ex is what encourages her to venture out of her comfort zone and act on the feelings she has been harboring to all 3 guys . A fling was what it was supposed to be . But oh boy does it end up being so much more . I absolutely loved seeing her come into her own . 💜RH 💜Secret Identity 💜childhood/ friends to lovers 💜forced proximity 💜 why choose💜hockey romance 💜forbidden and well all the feels . WYNTER nailed it once again and delivered another unforgettable and unputdownable addition to what I can already tell will be a new favorite series of mine
3 minutes ago

[Kaitlyn · Rating 4 out of 5]

While I'm usually not into the brothers' "why choose" trope, I found this book to be a delightful exception. Wynter Ryan has crafted a quick, steamy rom-com that kept me entertained from start to finish.

The hot tub scene, where the triplets suggest the spin-around-with-your-eyes-closed game, had me laughing out loud. The humor and playful moments added a refreshing touch to the story. Despite the unconventional romance, the chemistry between Britt and the triplets, Torin, Talen, and Tarek, was palpable. I’m here for it and loved all four of them together.

Britt, the quiet best friend who hides behind her glasses, steps out of her comfort zone and embraces her wild side, leading to a night of passion and self-discovery. The triplets, professional hockey players who have shared everything since birth, find themselves irresistibly drawn to Britt, and their connection feels surprisingly natural.

Overall, "Puck Me Baby One More Time" is a well-written, fun, and steamy read that I thoroughly enjoyed. If you're looking for a lighthearted, why choose romance with a good dose of humor, this book is worth checking out!

[Nicole Henderson · Rating 5 out of 5]

Brittany, Teagan’s best friend, has a crush. Not just a crush. A huge crush on Teagan's older brothers. Brit has been in love with the Hayes triplets for as long as she can remember. She decides to take matters into her own hands one Halloween night while in costume. Brit spends time with each triplet. That should be it, right? All she needed to let her crush and feelings go. Unfortunately, that was not the case. That night was never far from her thoughts and no one ever measured up to the men of her dreams.

These novellas give readers exactly what they need. The stories are not long and drawn out and readers will feel like they get a complete story. A story that will have them begging for more. Almost two years after that faithful night, Britt finds herself unable to avoid the triplets any longer. They all find themselves working for the Minnesota Norse Hockey team. Brittany is in need of some roommates after being abandoned by Teagan. Teagan figures the triplets will be the perfect replacement. Can Britt deal with being in close proximity to Torin, Talen and Tarek after keeping her distance for so long?

[Becky Dreyer · Rating 5 out of 5]

Puck Me Baby One More Time is the 2nd book in the Playing the Puck series. This is a why choose hockey romance series. Puck Me Baby One More Time is the story of Brittany, Torin, Talen and Tarek Brittany has always had a crush on her best friend’s triplet brothers - Torin, Talen and Tarek, even though she is certain they only see her as their little sister’s best friend and nothing more. Although she has been avoiding them since one fateful night 2 years ago, she is now forced to be around them when she is informed they brother’s not only got traded to the hockey team she just got hired on with but they will also be her new roommates. Can Brittany survive working alongside and living with her crushes or will she break even more than she already has? Fantastic addition to the series and I can’t wait to see what comes next.

[Meg · Rating 5 out of 5]

I could not put this book down. Between the steamy chapters and the lovable characters, I was hooked from the first page. This Why Choose is written beautifully and the story behind the steam shows a world that is uplifting women in their careers and personal lives - not to mention the consensual very not-safe-for-work scenes that left me begging for more of the brothers.

If you have not read Why Choose romance yet, this is an incredible series to have your introduction. The author Wynter creates amazing characters who connect with one another like pieces of a very sexy puzzle. I am in love with this universe and cannot wait for the next book in the series, until then I will be re-reading this one until my Kindle screen gives out.

[Jenna · Rating 1 out of 5]

This one wasn’t for me. I expected the plot to be more developed but it was superficial and rushed. I couldn’t keep track of which triplet was who. The writing was a little less than average and felt like more of a quick porno rather than a smutty why choose romance.

Also potentially some editing needed: The third rule isn’t a rule formally stated. She starts her sentence but doesn’t give a rule but says a bland statement. I think there needs to be some rewording or a follow up sentence saying maybe to take the puck bunnies somewhere else bc two paragraphs later she says are they really that upset I asked them not to bring their puck bunnies into my home… but she never did ask that (pg 48-49 for me)

[ReadIntoWonderland · Rating 4 out of 5]

I knew this book was coming but I was definitely excited to see the new insights for Britt's POV. This was a short and simple adult read. It was nice to take a pause with a shorter story. I will admit I did know in advance basically all that was happening in this story due to Britt's prominence in book one. As was the case in the first book, I appreciate that each of the boys has an opportunity to get Britt to themselves and then have her as a group. My favorite part of the story by far was the epilogue. It was so so cute! I am intrigued to see book three as I know way less about it.

This story has a lot of spicy scenes so do not read this one if spice isn't for you

I received this book as an arc from the author. My review is honest and voluntary

[Theresa Lambe · Rating 4 out of 5]

She has done it again, giving us another hot couple to fall in love with. And believe me, they are hot. I mean, we all love the Hayes boys, and so does Brit.

It's nice that she thought she could fool them and take what she wanted. Oh, she took, she just didn't fool. And to think how much more fun she could have had if she had spoken up ages prior. But loving your best friends triplet brothers is hard. Sleeping with them and not causing jealousy is even worse. So, why choose right? Which makes it so much dang hotter when it all goes down!

Naked hot tub time anyone? Really, don't miss this spicy, sweet, why choose romance? Makes you want your selection of men.

[Hazel Haze · Rating 5 out of 5]

I LOVE THIS SERIES!!!!!!! Puck Me Baby One More Time takes place around Halloween(My favorite holiday) so naturally I needed to read this!! The FMC dresses up like Brittney Spears for her best friend’s Halloween Party and decides to take a chance and get with her crush, except its not one guy it is 3 who are the triplet brothers to her best friend! I freaking love this trope and everything about this book! Wynter did another fantastic job with this one. This is the second book in the series and I don't think I ever want the series to stop cause they are so cute and short I just can’t get enough!!

[Katy · Rating 4 out of 5]

ARC REVIEW

5/5 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
4.75 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Wynter did it again leaving you wanting so much more in this story you meet Brittany who has had a crush on her best friends triplet brothers for years so one Halloween Brittany decides to dress up and have one night with the triplets you have forced proximity best friends brothers secret identity and so much more when the spice hits it hits 🥵🥵

The only reason I didn’t give it a full 5 stars is because i wanted to see more of Brittany and her boys as a couple

[ChristiLovesBooks_smut · Rating 4 out of 5]

Puck Me Baby One More Time, book 2 in the series Playing The Puck, by Wynter Ryan @authorsynterryan. I don't think this was as good as the first book in the series, HOWEVER, Wynter, lost her Mom while writing the book. 😭

I liked this book about Britt, Torin, Talen, & Tarek. It checked a lot of trope boxes for me. Professional Hockey, RH, Triplets, childhood friends to lovers & best friends brothers.

[Sarah · Rating 5 out of 5]

Puck Me Baby One More Time is a good fast-paced why choose romance story!
What you get...
♡Hockey Players
♡RH
♡She's the Social Media Manager for Their Team
♡Best Friend's Brothers
♡Secret Identity
♡Childhood Friends to Lovers
♡Identical Triplet Brothers
♡Forced Proximity
♡Why Choose
♡Spicy🥵🔥🥵🔥🥵🔥

Brit, Torin, Talen, and Tarek have amazing chemistry, and their story was so good!! I couldn't put it down and can't wait to read the next book!

[Clary · Rating 4 out of 5]

Britt and the triplets are just hot, hot, hot. The steam in this story is pure fire and I loved it. I missed a little bit of the relationship development that was present in book 1 but the spice more than made up for it, and with hot, hockey triplets... yes please! I wouldn't want to choose either. Another very entertaining great read from this author.

[Toni Amey · Rating 4 out of 5]

This was a very cute and hot short story. You have the guys who are 3 identical brothers and then their sister’s best friend Britt. They have always loved each other but never told one another. I do wish the scenes in this book were more detailed, they would be soooo good especially the ones with all 4 of them together. Overall this story was cute but I do wish for more.

[Donna Williams · Rating 5 out of 5]

Oh my god Willow you are just sinking me down the hockey romance hole even further and I absolutely love it. I literally could not put this book down. Between the steamy chapters and the lovable characters, I was hooked from the first page. This Why Choose is written beautifully and the story behind the steam shows a world that is uplifting women in their careers and personal lives - not to mention the consensual very not-safe-for-work scenes that left me begging for more of the brothers. I literally can’t wait to read more and I hope you write more of these books. Now I wanna go watch some hockey lol.

[Rebecca · Rating 4 out of 5]

good book

I don’t like Tiffany she’s only out for herself and will take anyone down so that she’s on top. can’t believe those three kept avoiding saying something for three years and I can’t believe she didn’t say anything to her best friend especially when they sent every holiday together.

[Brandy Rice · Rating 4 out of 5]

Puck Me Baby One More Time is a fun why choose hockey romance. Britt and the triplets Talen, Toren and Tarek definitely steam up the pages with some very spicy scenes. The storyline is entertaining with some great banter, angst and a little drama. I really enjoyed this quick read and can't wait for Gemma's story!!

[Ashly · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is the next book in this series of hockey romance. I really liked it and found all the characters really likable as well. The stakes were low and it was an easy read that will leave you feeling happy. This is also a pretty spicy book considering the length of the story.
Overall it was fun and I am looking forward to the next one in the series.
4⭐️ 3.5🌶

[Krissy Brinn · Rating 5 out of 5]

Loved it

I loved Britt and the triplet T's got their own book. I wish it was longer I hated to see it end. But on the bright side they will return as side characters in future books that revolve around this hockey team.

The next book looks like it will be even better. I can't wait to read it next.

[Vivien Richards · Rating 5 out of 5]

What is it about hockey books that are so hot! This is a super cute, fun romance also with plenty of spice. Britt is best friends with Teagan. And Britt has a crush on Teagan's triplet brothers. This is a why choose romance. Why have just one brother when you can have all three? I felt so happy for Britt for getting her dream guys. This is a short read packed with spice. I recommend it!

[Danielle Coon-Davis · Rating 5 out of 5]

Holy Triplets???

Ok, so who doesn't love the idea of three hot triplets? Wynter has created a masterpiece of a short, spicy read that will have you begging for more. Torin, Talen, and Tarek give you all the spice, and the relationship they develop with Brittany is a dream. I loved the hockey also! My only complaint was that it wasn't longer.

Thanks for the early read!

[Melissa R · Rating 2 out of 5]

Why choose hockey romance. 3 identical triplet brothers fall in love with their sister’s best friend. She has been avoiding them because she secretly loves all three of them and is afraid of the stigma. Quick read (finished in about an hour), alpha men who stand up for her, good palette cleanser book.

[Kira · Rating 5 out of 5]

Man Wynter did it again! Britt's story was just as good as Teagans! I absolutely loved every second of it! Talen Torin and Tarken are ughh the most perfect triplets ! Spice was great just like the story! 5 stars. I can't wait to see Gemmas story!

[Heidi LaGrone · Rating 4 out of 5]

This was a yummy sports romance with plenty of heat! Fantastic characters and storyline that weaves in characters old and new! Britt and the trips are magical together and fulfill all my nerdy girl fantasies! Turn up the fan - the heat level gets HOT!

[Michelle C · Rating 5 out of 5]

Britt’s best friends brothers are triplets that she has had her eye on for years. Little does she know they also want her. This book is HOT. Britt has a night with all three separately while disguised. Again she has no idea they knew who she was and want more. Jump ahead about two,years and turns out she will be working for,the same team they play for and they are going to be roommates courtesy of their sister. You have to read to find out the rest. Have fun and enjoy this short read.

[Mandi Howard · Rating 4 out of 5]

4.5 stars!! I could not put this book down!! The only reason I gave it less than a 5 is because I feel like it was too short. In my opinion a lot of story was skipped. Seriously anticipating the next book in the series!

[Rachel Stephens · Rating 5 out of 5]

Britt's Story
RH, best friend's brothers, triplets, and 🏒
This was a quick and fun read!
Filled with spicy scenes, drama, a little humor, and some feels.

Torin, Talen, and Tarek are triplets and have eyes for only one woman. Britt gets to be that woman.
I loved it!