A few problems and weaknesses -
- The revisions read clumsily in some places, as if they were cut/pasted in rather than rewriting the section. For example, I don't think there's anyone with access to a computer who needs to have email explained to them at this point in the game. There are quite a few places in the book where it feels like we've time-traveled back to 2000.
- As is the case anytime a book contains website information, a lot of the URL's are no longer accurate and a lot of the information on sites is already outdated. I don't know how this could be avoided by nature of the material, but it's still a big problem for this sort of book.
- Since the focus of the book in on-line activity, I don't think nearly enough emphasis was putting on virus protection, avoiding malware, and not putting unproven information on line as fact. While the author does touch on respecting the privacy of living people or not posting other people's contact information without permission, it wasn't nearly enough.
- Software recommendations are Ancestry.com heavy. For example, Legacy, which is a very good software program (and offers a free version that is more robust than most people need) is mentioned only by name in passing.
Some strengths --
- Contains good overviews of sources for genealogy classes, workshops and conferences.
- Good explanation of social media use in genealogy, including one of the ore lucid descriptions of how to use Twitter I've seen.
- Strong sections on using local and regional databases and libraries, Ellis Island Online, Library on-line catalogs, obituary databases, etc.
- Good sections on ethnic resources (including the first time I've ever seen Romani, Arab or Hmong sources listed.)
The author evangelizes hard about DNA use in genealogy. I know it's popular, but I'm not convinced the matches it claims to provide are worthwhile. Admittedly, I'm biased against it, so I thought she should have been forthright about the business model of DNA sites and how they really make their money (Let's face it, you're the product, not the customer to them.)
Much of the material was too basic for my use--I've been at this crazy hobby for over a decade--but I think it's a good book for someone who is just getting into the hobby as long as they realize that anything having to to with the Internet's fine deatils will be obsolete before its published.