Settling on 3.5, because the beginning was a little slow but the second half picked up, and the spice was nice. And I just generally liked Violet and Thorne.
Violet and Thorne each spend the first half of the book confused about their feelings for the other. I love mutual pining. They each feel attraction with equal parts "nope can't like them." Violet wants to go home (for reasons unclear, aside from its where she's from) and Throne has responsibilities as King to keep his people safe and how can he fall for or trust this unknown human???
There are some Christmas things thrown in here and there, but it definitely not a Christmas themed story.
I trusted that it's a standalone, so I have not read the first book, unclear if some of my questions would be better understood if I had.
Things I didn't like so much:
I think the lead up to her going through the portal was a touch too long, for me. It seemed weirdly out of character (despite just meeting her) for Violet to go into the forest, that she does not trust, because she's never heard of the monsters mimicking a baby before, so that clearly meant there was an actual baby. Which didn't make sense to me. Like yes, there was a baby, but why was she so sure of it?? Like it works out and that's part of what Thorn loves about her, but it was still confusing at the start.
Violet being black felt like a side note, rather than part of her character. Like race doesn't have to be this huge part of who a character is, but it felt minimally touched on. There's one comment at the beginning about liking her small town-- except for the racists. And then it's not elaborated on or discussed again for a while. Later, she mentions the people in town treated her like an outsider because she's black. And then she references what I assume happened in the first book. (Oh and she's twerking at one point? I'm not sure if that was an attempt to make her seem more black? Idk felt weird.) We need more POC in monster romances, and I think that's what the author was going for, it just fell a little flat in my opinion.
Also, personally, don't like when windy boys are mentioned by name.
TL/DR:
Violet and Thorn are very cute together. Some elements fell flat and could be better developed. Slightly confusing if read as a standalone.