Good, but I expected more
First things first, I love pretty much everything Philip C. Quaintrell has written, and recommend his work more often than anything else.
That said, this one let me down. Was it well written? Absolutely. Was it entertaining? Definitely. Was it original? Eh, parts of it.
To be fair, I enjoyed most of the of the book, especially everything with Yamnomora and Grarfath. I think they are perhaps my two favorite characters in all of the Verda books. I adored Joran, he’s a good kid and wants to make the world a better place. Daijen and Ilithranda were great, Ilithranda’s past is heartbreaking, and the big battle they take part in was one of my favorites.
(Spoilers ahead)
But I feel like all those awesome parts have been tarnished by the part of the story I felt was most lacking, Skara, the villain who is introduced. We are given no insight into why he changes so drastically from the prologue to what Daijen sees of the past, which is fine, I imagine that will come in later books. But what really bothered me most was the implication that he created the Andarans for some as of now unrevealed purpose.
I mean, again? We’re really doing that again? It was bad enough that Elves in the Echoes Saga were created by an evil sorcerer, but to do that again, especially with such a similar people, just smacks of lack of creativity.
I really wanted to love this book, I have been eagerly awaiting it, but that one reveal really ruined it for me. It took me out of the story completely. Though not nearly as much as the inclusion of Malliath, however brief his inclusion was, as Shara’s dragon. The Echoes Saga made it seem as if Malliath was always a loner, and certainly never had a previous rider. I’m sure that Quaintrell has a plan to explain that bit away, but it just seems messy and rather than being a cool Easter egg, it drew me out of the immersive experience of the book.
Anyhow, I wanted to give the book three stars, but instead went with four because it really is good, aside from the couple of things that bug me, and I think a lot of people would enjoy those facets, I’m just a grouchy old curmudgeon.