Northern Appalachia has a fascinating economic history. Pennsylvania, Ohio, Upstate New York, West Virginia, and Maryland were the early leaders of American cottage industry. The coal-rich hills and rushing rivers were a fertile birthplace for America's industrial revolution. Canals and railroads flourished. Many of America's great companies would call the region U.S. Steel, Standard Oil, Alcoa, and many more. The region powered America's war machine from colonial times, through the Civil War, and well into the 20th century. In the 20th century, triumphant history turned tragic. After World War II, many countries copied the success of America's heavy industry. America's modern workers couldn't compete with global producers. Northern Appalachian companies died slowly but decisively, leaving many people without work. The negative effects still linger in Northern Appalachia's industrial cities and factory towns. People are poor, unhealthy, and unhappy. To help, both America and Northern Appalachia need to get real. Everybody can move forward with wisdom and legitimacy. "Hammer to Hypertext" focuses on West Virginia's coal, Pennsylvania's natural gas, and New York's microchip manufacturing. More How can communities help themselves? And how can Northern Appalachian moxie help a dispirited America?
"The hills and rocky plateaus of Southern Appalachia didn’t directly benefit from cash crops or slave agriculture …………."
Research writing with strong non-fiction vibes is always difficult. It becomes much more difficult when the author is arranging the data chronologically without harming the reader's engagement quotient.
"……………… Yet the wider industry of slave-based agriculture played an important part in Appalachia’s evolution, especially in the early 19th century".
In that context, the author has never missed his direction. The historical perspectives have smoothly mixed with the geographical and socio-economic perspectives. Moreover, those interesting keywords (sharecropping, Mississippi Valley culture, Appalachian Fiction, snowball effect, rootless vagrants) with tiny briefs make the reading more engaging. I love how the post-civil war requirements introduced railroads, canalboats and industrial efficiency-based statistics. The miners to "resolute laborer" transformation, sea power development, attractive skyscrapers and effortless transition to 20th century are great.
The author has not concealed the mass media and pop culture elements as well as the components of international politics. So, Dreamland's opioid connection and relevant "black tar", "opioid epidemic" seem the burning highlight of a specific time and place. Similarly, aftermath of Korean war is not missed. So, highway, "“suburban sprawl" and racial politics become various important nodes of rapid industrialization (or impacts of industrialization). With baby boomers, the substance abuse, war-based PTSD and opioid epidemic are highlighted appropriately. However, a little more specification is required for the knowledge-based services. The information on domestic "buy local movement", two sides of coal, iron-air batteries, and challenges of green infrastructure are great. Contextually, the recycling plastic's marketing strategy seems harmful (a new information for me). I like the way "Tech Valley campaigns" and related white suite romantic image is analyzed. The microchip explanation with data is great too.
Overall, an informative book to learn the multidimensional transitions of the Appalachian region. But the hypertext point needed more explanations.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Disclaimer: I am from and currently in WV, so I judge that part of the book the harshest. :)
This is a narrow focused book. It really starts at hammers - not who was on the land before or how the hammer-wielders got here or got their land or any of that. It starts with the Steel boom with very little exposition on how / why America went all in on resource extractive industries.
The author does a nice job of explaining the boom of the east coast and how similar it was to the west coast tech industry of today. Obviously, with such a narrow focused topic, there are lots of nuances missed. For example, only a handful of counties in WV have access to coal seams or have any type of mining operations or income.
The book does not fully make it to the 'Hypertext' portion of the title. While he does go into depth on the Silicon industry boom in upstate NY, he does not mention the many attempts and failures to provide broadband access to these states in Appalachia. He barely mentions the data center boom adjacent to Appalachia to draw power cheaply. He also doesn't discuss the programs by many Appalachia states to entice tech entrepreneurs and tech workers to move to this region for low-cost of living and outdoorsy lifestyle.
More books need to be written about the economics of Appalachia. This is a good start. I hope others will be interested in this read and do more research of their own.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
James Penn’s "Hammer to Hypertext" is a well-researched and thought-provoking look at the economic landscape of Northern Appalachia. Through a detailed exploration of the region's history—from its industrial roots in coal and steel to its ongoing transitions in energy and technology—Penn provides a comprehensive overview that is informative and engaging.
The author does an excellent job connecting the past with the present, highlighting how historical economic trends continue to influence current and future developments. The author also weaves in current references such as JD Vance’s Hillbilly Elegy to highlight the role of Appalachian culture in popular culture.
Overall, "Hammer to Hypertext" is a valuable resource for anyone interested in understanding Northern Appalachia’s economic journey and future prospects. It's a well-rounded work that balances historical context with forward-looking insights, making it a must-read for scholars, policymakers, and anyone invested in the region’s future.