What do you think?
Rate this book
No Greater Valor: The Siege of Bastogne and the Miracle That Sealed Allied Victory
Jerome Corsi’s newest opus, No Greater Valor , examines the Siege of Bastogne—one of the most heroic victories of WWII—with a focus on the surprising faith of the Americans who fought there. In December of 1944, an outmanned, outgunned, and surrounded US force fought Hitler’s overwhelming Panzer divisions to a miraculous standstill at Bastogne. The underdogs had saved the war for the Allies. It was nothing short of miraculous. Corsi’s analysis is based on a record of oral histories along with original field maps used by field commanders, battle orders, and other documentation made at the time of the military command. With a perspective gleaned from newspapers, periodicals, and newsreels of the day, Corsi paints a riveting portrait of one of the most important battles in world history.
384 pages, Hardcover
First published October 28, 2014
125 people are currently reading
271 people want to read
About the author
Jerome R. Corsi
58 books75 followersAmerican author and political commentator.
Corsi is mostly known for his books against Democratic presidential candidates John Kerry and Barack Obama, that were published in the years of presidential elections.
Corsi has discussed topics that are considered conspiracy theories, such as the alleged plans for a North American Government, the theory that President Barack Obama is not an American citizen.
Corsi is mostly known for his books against Democratic presidential candidates John Kerry and Barack Obama, that were published in the years of presidential elections.
Corsi has discussed topics that are considered conspiracy theories, such as the alleged plans for a North American Government, the theory that President Barack Obama is not an American citizen.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 34 reviews
February 6, 2023
Incredible story of the Battle of the Bulge and how faith and moral strength played a part. Amazing. What hero’s in so many roles saved us. This should be mandatory reading in our schools.
January 28, 2015
No Greater Valor written by Jerome Corsi, a conservative pundit and journalist, is about the Battle of the Bulge that occurred during the Second World War in December of 1944.
The book is well written and recounts events of the battle from a variety of other books written about the Battle of the Bulge. Corsi follows the major players, McAuliffe, Patton, Middleton, Bradley as well as other regimental and battalion level commanders. A small amount of the battle is seen from the German side of the offensive, known to them as the Wacht am Rhein offensive.
Despite a large amount of the material coming from previous Battle of the Bulge texts, Corsi did use some newly found transcripts of interviews or what are today commonly known as after action reports, conducted by then Army historians with much of the involved U.S. leadership.
Corsi also recounts some of the lesser known events of the battle such as the capture of the 101st Division's medical and surgical team and he also devotes some time to the military chaplains that were present.
His inclusion of the chaplain's stories are part of Corsi's thesis that the battle was won by the U.S. because of divine intervention. I wonder if he included this premise as a way to further his conservative credentials or put a modern day evangelical spin to the history of the battle. In any case he does not execute or follow through very well on his hypothesis and it made for a much better book, sticking to the historical facts as opposed to a faith based reasoning or explanation for events.
I wish the maps included in the book were larger as they were all but impossible to read because of their smallness in size.
Another small complaint, when the author quotes from interview transcripts and other books whenever a cuss word was part of the original text Corsi inserts [expletive] as opposed to the actual word which in all cases in this book would have been the word "hell." I think this was an appeasement to the intended conservative audience of this book for I can think of no other reason. It is a story of war after all and of soldiers and if you are going to quote them then use what they said, no need to sugar coat it.
The book does end somewhat abruptly as soon as Patton's 4th Armored makes their breakthrough to Bastogne. I wish there were a few more chapters dealing with the withdrawal of the Germans and the wrap up of the battle.
Overall a good book and I would recommend it for someone interested in reading more about the Battle of the Bulge.
The book is well written and recounts events of the battle from a variety of other books written about the Battle of the Bulge. Corsi follows the major players, McAuliffe, Patton, Middleton, Bradley as well as other regimental and battalion level commanders. A small amount of the battle is seen from the German side of the offensive, known to them as the Wacht am Rhein offensive.
Despite a large amount of the material coming from previous Battle of the Bulge texts, Corsi did use some newly found transcripts of interviews or what are today commonly known as after action reports, conducted by then Army historians with much of the involved U.S. leadership.
Corsi also recounts some of the lesser known events of the battle such as the capture of the 101st Division's medical and surgical team and he also devotes some time to the military chaplains that were present.
His inclusion of the chaplain's stories are part of Corsi's thesis that the battle was won by the U.S. because of divine intervention. I wonder if he included this premise as a way to further his conservative credentials or put a modern day evangelical spin to the history of the battle. In any case he does not execute or follow through very well on his hypothesis and it made for a much better book, sticking to the historical facts as opposed to a faith based reasoning or explanation for events.
I wish the maps included in the book were larger as they were all but impossible to read because of their smallness in size.
Another small complaint, when the author quotes from interview transcripts and other books whenever a cuss word was part of the original text Corsi inserts [expletive] as opposed to the actual word which in all cases in this book would have been the word "hell." I think this was an appeasement to the intended conservative audience of this book for I can think of no other reason. It is a story of war after all and of soldiers and if you are going to quote them then use what they said, no need to sugar coat it.
The book does end somewhat abruptly as soon as Patton's 4th Armored makes their breakthrough to Bastogne. I wish there were a few more chapters dealing with the withdrawal of the Germans and the wrap up of the battle.
Overall a good book and I would recommend it for someone interested in reading more about the Battle of the Bulge.
September 6, 2022
This review is certainly not intended to reflect on the courage of those involved in the siege of Bastogne and the Battle of the Bulge in general, but I found the author's writing extremely tedious. Although he seems to have written many books, one thing that he is not is a professional historian / storyteller. The facts were not laid out in a fashion that kept one's interest. I was thrilled that I was able to make it to the end. I enjoy history and read quite a bit of it, but this was difficult. Compounding the issue was the author's attempt to prove the sovereignty of God over the events of the siege by using the prayers of non-believers, such as George Patton, which seemed to be more superstition than genuine prayers to the living God. I found that to be beyond the pale. I say that as an one who strongly believers in the power of the prayers of the child of God.
I have noticed in looking through Amazon that the author has written many politically-oriented books. I have not read any of them, but perhaps the author's style is better suited to that genre or audience.
I have noticed in looking through Amazon that the author has written many politically-oriented books. I have not read any of them, but perhaps the author's style is better suited to that genre or audience.
May 13, 2017
Thank goodness for McAuliffe's 101st Airborne, Roberts's Combat Command B of the 10th Armored Division, Abrams's 37th Tank Battalion of the 4th Armored Division, and Patton's 3rd Army! No Greater Valor provides a wonderful up close and personal look at such a pivotal part of the war!
June 23, 2018
Action packed
A short action packed history of the siege of Bastogne in the Battle of the Bulge. This book covers the units that were critical to the defense of Hastings and the destruction of the German's timetable.
A short action packed history of the siege of Bastogne in the Battle of the Bulge. This book covers the units that were critical to the defense of Hastings and the destruction of the German's timetable.
October 26, 2018
I put this book down after just a few pages. The reason? The author seemed so determined to prove that divine intervention won the Battle of the Bulge that I wondered how dispassionate his reporting was.
September 4, 2020
Great Battle of the Bulge facts
While there are many determining battles in WWII, none is greater than the resistance, resolve, and victory of the US armies at the Battle of the Bulge.
While there are many determining battles in WWII, none is greater than the resistance, resolve, and victory of the US armies at the Battle of the Bulge.
June 30, 2020
pretty good.
September 15, 2022
The introduction was enough to tell me that I don't need to read this. I want a history book. Not the author telling me about how the ACLU is trying to remove God from all public life in America.
July 15, 2024
Very detailed account
July 16, 2020
If you have a love for World War 2 as well as have watched the Battle of Bastogne on the HBO series Band of Brothers then this is a good book to check out. Although his focus is not on Easy Company you get a great picture of what this battle was like in real life. His focus is to show how the victory of this battle was not just luck, circumstances, and the genius of the American leaders led by general McAuiliffe and Patton. The author wants the reader to consider God’s divine hand in this battle and how he believes is the cause of the victory when considering His sovereignty and providence. One of the chaplains he follows is Father Samson also known as Parachute Padre as he was with the 101st Parachute division. In his account is where they found the inspiration and true story of Saving Private Ryan. Overall it was a good account of the Battle of Bastogne and I especially enjoyed the prayer Patton made one of the chaplains write that was answered by God’s divine hand for good weather in order to advance quicker towards Bastogne.
December 11, 2014
“No Greater Valor, The Siege of Bastogne and the Miracle that Sealed Allied Victory,” by Jerome Corsi, Ph.D., focuses on how the faith of the men involved in this key battle of World War II factored into their fight for survival and ultimate victory. This key nexus point became the center of attention for the Allies and the Nazis during the Battle of the Bulge, resulting in the 101st Airborne Division and others being completely cut off and surrounded by enemy troops.
Soldiers in the battle became known as the “Battered Bastards of Bastogne,” and are admired for their resolve in harsh conditions with long odds. When the Germans sent a group under the white flag of truce to negotiate terms of surrender for the U.S. troops, Acting Division Commander General McAuliffe gave his famous one word response to the German military commander: “Nuts!”
What makes this a fascinating read, is Corsi’s exploration of the faith backgrounds of famous commanders and key leaders. The fact that McAuliffe became the acting division commander could be chalked up to fortunate chance, or as some believe, to Providence. In accounts of the battle following the war, McAuliffe himself attributes the hand of God to the successful placement of units around the town. When they were emplaced, McAuliffe did not even have the guidance of a map when making initial decisions on where to place his assets.
Patton’s Third Army eventually broke through the German siege, and the author describes the military and spiritual components of that side of the action as well. Patton’s chaplain was awarded the Bronze Star medal for offering what the general deemed to be a successfully written prayer.
Prayer for Good Weather to Kill More Germans
General Patton ordered his chaplain to produce a prayer in December 1944, just as the Third Army began its turn North to rescue the beleaguered men in Bastogne. 250,000 copies were distributed to soldiers, with the prayer on one side and a Christmas greeting on the other.
“Almighty and most merciful Father, we humbly beseech Thee, of Thy great goodness, to restrain these immoderate rains with which we have had to contend. Grant us fair weather for Battle. Graciously hearken to us as soldiers who call upon thee that, armed with Thy power, we may advance from victory to victory, and crush the oppression and wickedness of our enemies and establish Thy justice among men and nations. Amen.”
On the reverse, Patton’s Christmas greeting:
“To each officer and soldier in the Third United States Army, I wish a Merry Christmas. I have full confidence in your courage, devotion to duty, and skill in battle. We march in our might to complete victory. May God’s blessings rest upon each of you on this Christmas Day.
G.S. Patton
Lieutenant General
Commanding, Third United States Army
The story behind these developments makes for a great read, and honors the memories of America’s brave heroes who sacrificed so much to defeat the Nazis.
This book earns a solid four stars.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from the publisher through the BookLook Bloggers book review bloggers program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
Soldiers in the battle became known as the “Battered Bastards of Bastogne,” and are admired for their resolve in harsh conditions with long odds. When the Germans sent a group under the white flag of truce to negotiate terms of surrender for the U.S. troops, Acting Division Commander General McAuliffe gave his famous one word response to the German military commander: “Nuts!”
What makes this a fascinating read, is Corsi’s exploration of the faith backgrounds of famous commanders and key leaders. The fact that McAuliffe became the acting division commander could be chalked up to fortunate chance, or as some believe, to Providence. In accounts of the battle following the war, McAuliffe himself attributes the hand of God to the successful placement of units around the town. When they were emplaced, McAuliffe did not even have the guidance of a map when making initial decisions on where to place his assets.
Patton’s Third Army eventually broke through the German siege, and the author describes the military and spiritual components of that side of the action as well. Patton’s chaplain was awarded the Bronze Star medal for offering what the general deemed to be a successfully written prayer.
Prayer for Good Weather to Kill More Germans
General Patton ordered his chaplain to produce a prayer in December 1944, just as the Third Army began its turn North to rescue the beleaguered men in Bastogne. 250,000 copies were distributed to soldiers, with the prayer on one side and a Christmas greeting on the other.
“Almighty and most merciful Father, we humbly beseech Thee, of Thy great goodness, to restrain these immoderate rains with which we have had to contend. Grant us fair weather for Battle. Graciously hearken to us as soldiers who call upon thee that, armed with Thy power, we may advance from victory to victory, and crush the oppression and wickedness of our enemies and establish Thy justice among men and nations. Amen.”
On the reverse, Patton’s Christmas greeting:
“To each officer and soldier in the Third United States Army, I wish a Merry Christmas. I have full confidence in your courage, devotion to duty, and skill in battle. We march in our might to complete victory. May God’s blessings rest upon each of you on this Christmas Day.
G.S. Patton
Lieutenant General
Commanding, Third United States Army
The story behind these developments makes for a great read, and honors the memories of America’s brave heroes who sacrificed so much to defeat the Nazis.
This book earns a solid four stars.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from the publisher through the BookLook Bloggers book review bloggers program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
February 13, 2015
No Greater Valor: The Siege of Bastogne And the Miracle That Sealed Allied Victory by Jerome Corsi deals with the surprise attack by Nazi forces against the Americans in Belgium that hinged upon the capturing/holding the town of Bastogne. It is a very detailed account, almost too detailed for my taste, for instance, there are intricate accounts of the weapons used, what kinds they were, how many…etc. Which just didn't capture my interest, but it makes absolute sense to have that type of info in a book about war. And many probably prefer such attention to detail. There are many maps in the book as well, illustrating what was happening, and many photographs from that time too.
The thing I really didn’t like about this book was that, though trying to have a Christian aspect to it, it didn't really succeed in anything but showing that many of the allied forces were theists. One of the main persons focused upon is a Catholic Priest rather than a protestant pastor. I found the parts that dealt with him and his actions during the war, though obviously meant to be inspiring, were actually quite disheartening because the man was not teaching or promoting the Gospel of Christ but rather a works based salvation which will not save. Corsi also tries to demonstrate that Patton was a devout Christian, but I didn't get that impression from all of Corsi's arguments, rather it seemed that Patton viewed God as more of a tool to be utilized rather than a God to be worshiped because He is what life is all about. I just didn't get the idea that Patton was a very godly man. Also, as this book was published by Thomas Nelson and supposed to be from a more Christian perspective(and is in Christian bookstores), I was quite shocked that there is a quotation with Christ's name being taken in vain while swear words are cut out and replaced with: [expletive]. Why didn't they take out the vain reference to Christ's name and put: [blasphemy] instead? I mean, I find Christ's name being taken in vain more offensive than references to Hell, especially as it goes against the third commandment.
Anyway, the book seemed to be written with more of a theistic perspective than a Christian one. But again, if you like detailed books about war/battles, you'd probably like this one. There are a lot of references to other books about the siege of Bastogne and personal accounts of various people who were involved, so if you just want more of the history, overview/summary, this would probably be a good one to get. I just wasn't thrilled personally.
I received a free review copy of this book from the Booklook blogger program in exchange for my review which did not have to be favorable.
The thing I really didn’t like about this book was that, though trying to have a Christian aspect to it, it didn't really succeed in anything but showing that many of the allied forces were theists. One of the main persons focused upon is a Catholic Priest rather than a protestant pastor. I found the parts that dealt with him and his actions during the war, though obviously meant to be inspiring, were actually quite disheartening because the man was not teaching or promoting the Gospel of Christ but rather a works based salvation which will not save. Corsi also tries to demonstrate that Patton was a devout Christian, but I didn't get that impression from all of Corsi's arguments, rather it seemed that Patton viewed God as more of a tool to be utilized rather than a God to be worshiped because He is what life is all about. I just didn't get the idea that Patton was a very godly man. Also, as this book was published by Thomas Nelson and supposed to be from a more Christian perspective(and is in Christian bookstores), I was quite shocked that there is a quotation with Christ's name being taken in vain while swear words are cut out and replaced with: [expletive]. Why didn't they take out the vain reference to Christ's name and put: [blasphemy] instead? I mean, I find Christ's name being taken in vain more offensive than references to Hell, especially as it goes against the third commandment.
Anyway, the book seemed to be written with more of a theistic perspective than a Christian one. But again, if you like detailed books about war/battles, you'd probably like this one. There are a lot of references to other books about the siege of Bastogne and personal accounts of various people who were involved, so if you just want more of the history, overview/summary, this would probably be a good one to get. I just wasn't thrilled personally.
I received a free review copy of this book from the Booklook blogger program in exchange for my review which did not have to be favorable.
February 23, 2015
Jerome Corsi’s No Greater Valor tells the story of the Siege off Bastogne in World War II. I find the work worthwhile for the personal reflections on the war alone, without delving any further than that into the work. World War II is moving from memory to history, and efforts to secure as much memory into a recorded form are worth commending.
Knowing that I favor the overall effort of getting history in print, I am predisposed to like No Greater Valor. I have not read any of Dr. Corsi’s other books, so I cannot tell you if this fits his typical style. I will first highlight my chagrin that, once again, a nonfiction book has been saddled with endnotes rather than footnotes. I like references, and I like them on the page they are noted.
Overall, the writing here does feel a bit disjointed. Corsi presents the various Allied units involved in the Battle of the Bulge, but of necessity there is a great deal of chronological shifting. Some events are grouped by people involved, requiring a flashback to an earlier time to catch up on what is happening outside of the earlier chapter.
Having read various history books, I have seen some that follow this method and others that follow a strict chronological method. Either works, though strict chronology appeals to me when trying to learn. The harder to trace narrative of No Greater Valor makes for a better casual read.
All in all, Corsi has mixed his analysis with both first-person quotes and information from the official records. There are the accounts of both generals and corporals, observations from those inside Bastogne and those outside.
I like this book. There are a few typos, and a few events could be narrated more clearly. If you have a textbook-type knowledge of the Battle of the Bulge, and specifically of the Bastogne events, this definitely puts more detail into that knowledge.
Various people rotate through the spotlight. Patton takes several turns in it, as does McAuliffe. So do chaplains like Father Sampson and Chaplain O’Neill. There is a photo section in the middle of the book which broadens the understanding, but it is not specifically tied to the writing.
The one concept that causes me hesitance about this book is made clealry in the concluding pages. Corsi broadens the historical lesson from Bastogne to include the need for America to retain strong moral character and Judeo-Christian values. While I agree with the need for these, I am unconvinced that the book strongly supports this as the conclusion. It feels tacked-on as a conclusion.
Is it worth reading? Absolutely.
Free book from BookLook Bloggers in exchange for the review.
Knowing that I favor the overall effort of getting history in print, I am predisposed to like No Greater Valor. I have not read any of Dr. Corsi’s other books, so I cannot tell you if this fits his typical style. I will first highlight my chagrin that, once again, a nonfiction book has been saddled with endnotes rather than footnotes. I like references, and I like them on the page they are noted.
Overall, the writing here does feel a bit disjointed. Corsi presents the various Allied units involved in the Battle of the Bulge, but of necessity there is a great deal of chronological shifting. Some events are grouped by people involved, requiring a flashback to an earlier time to catch up on what is happening outside of the earlier chapter.
Having read various history books, I have seen some that follow this method and others that follow a strict chronological method. Either works, though strict chronology appeals to me when trying to learn. The harder to trace narrative of No Greater Valor makes for a better casual read.
All in all, Corsi has mixed his analysis with both first-person quotes and information from the official records. There are the accounts of both generals and corporals, observations from those inside Bastogne and those outside.
I like this book. There are a few typos, and a few events could be narrated more clearly. If you have a textbook-type knowledge of the Battle of the Bulge, and specifically of the Bastogne events, this definitely puts more detail into that knowledge.
Various people rotate through the spotlight. Patton takes several turns in it, as does McAuliffe. So do chaplains like Father Sampson and Chaplain O’Neill. There is a photo section in the middle of the book which broadens the understanding, but it is not specifically tied to the writing.
The one concept that causes me hesitance about this book is made clealry in the concluding pages. Corsi broadens the historical lesson from Bastogne to include the need for America to retain strong moral character and Judeo-Christian values. While I agree with the need for these, I am unconvinced that the book strongly supports this as the conclusion. It feels tacked-on as a conclusion.
Is it worth reading? Absolutely.
Free book from BookLook Bloggers in exchange for the review.
January 1, 2015
This is a (mostly) readable account of the American defense of Bastogne during the Battle of the Bulge. American forces tenaciously held this important crossroads against numerically superior forces and in spite of harsh weather and shortage of both food and ammunition. Because of the weather and the fact that the Bastogne defenders were surrounded by German forces, fresh supplies could not be brought in until the weather broke on 23 December.
I'm not competent to declare whether or not this battle is the most courageous ever fought by American troops, but this certainly is a story of courage and determination. The defenders on the ground, the airmen who flew supply drop runs, medics who volunteered to fly into Bastogne in gliders, and Patton and his 3rd Army all demonstrated courage.
I have no military background — missed the Vietnam draft by on graduating class, though my draft number was #169. I also don't generally like books about specific battles. Consequently, I struggled a bit with the military organizational vocabulary. Mostly, I just ignored those kinds of details and read for the bigger picture and that was what I found appealing.
Corsi says that his primary purpose in writing this book was "to reexamine the importance of God in our Judeo-Christian historical tradition in a world certain again to be…'nasty, cruel, brutish, and short' once again in the future." I don't believe he accomplished his purpose. Note — that's not the same thing as saying that I don't believe the premise. I just don't think Corsi presented the kind of compelling evidence that he intended. There are certainly examples of faith in action — Patton's distribution of leaflet encouraging the troops to pray, the attendance of both troops and leaders in Mass and Protestant services during lulls in the action, the statements of belief that God had favoured the American. Did God give the generals and other officers extraordinary wisdom in making decisions that seem to be merely fortuitous? I think so. Were the personnel involved motivated and emboldened by a belief that they were fighting to defeat an evil in the Nazis that was built on a Satanic foundation? I think so.
Someone who believes that God does not intervene in human affairs or, certainly, a non-Christian may well find the references to God's help obnoxious. But, if that focus doesn't bother you, this is a really good story of courage and great strategy.
I'm not competent to declare whether or not this battle is the most courageous ever fought by American troops, but this certainly is a story of courage and determination. The defenders on the ground, the airmen who flew supply drop runs, medics who volunteered to fly into Bastogne in gliders, and Patton and his 3rd Army all demonstrated courage.
I have no military background — missed the Vietnam draft by on graduating class, though my draft number was #169. I also don't generally like books about specific battles. Consequently, I struggled a bit with the military organizational vocabulary. Mostly, I just ignored those kinds of details and read for the bigger picture and that was what I found appealing.
Corsi says that his primary purpose in writing this book was "to reexamine the importance of God in our Judeo-Christian historical tradition in a world certain again to be…'nasty, cruel, brutish, and short' once again in the future." I don't believe he accomplished his purpose. Note — that's not the same thing as saying that I don't believe the premise. I just don't think Corsi presented the kind of compelling evidence that he intended. There are certainly examples of faith in action — Patton's distribution of leaflet encouraging the troops to pray, the attendance of both troops and leaders in Mass and Protestant services during lulls in the action, the statements of belief that God had favoured the American. Did God give the generals and other officers extraordinary wisdom in making decisions that seem to be merely fortuitous? I think so. Were the personnel involved motivated and emboldened by a belief that they were fighting to defeat an evil in the Nazis that was built on a Satanic foundation? I think so.
Someone who believes that God does not intervene in human affairs or, certainly, a non-Christian may well find the references to God's help obnoxious. But, if that focus doesn't bother you, this is a really good story of courage and great strategy.
January 29, 2015
Corsi takes you to the battlefield around Bastogne during Christmas of 1944 to understand the unlikely fate of the 101st airborne division mixed with an unexpected miracle that helped turn the battle in the Allies favor.
On December 15, 1944 in a desperate last attempt to gain control of Europe, Adolf Hitler launched his Wacht am Rhine offensive against the town of Bastogne. The purpose of the offensive was not to win the war, but to force the Allies to come to more of a German favorable treaty. Hitler based his decision to attack on a weather pattern that developed a large snow storm over the area so that the Allies at Bastogne could not be resupplied by air nor could the air corps join in the defensive. The courageous 101st Airborne division were called in from biovac to defend the town of Bastogne. The battle continued for eleven days and at one point the Allies were completely surrounded by German troops and tanks. If not for a strong belief in God and a weather related miracle, the Battle of Bulge may have had a different ending.
I rarely read historical accounts, but this one really caught my attention. I had always heard about the battle of the bulge, but not about the miracle that the author references in the title. Jerome Corsi has done an amazing amount of research to bring this event to life on paper. He does a great job showing the chain of events that lead to the development of the battle as well as the outcome of the battle. The way he words the book takes the reader into the trenches with the front lines, into General McAuliffe’s command center, and marching alongside the troops of Patton’s 3rd army as they work to relieve Bastogne.
Parts of the book are very detailed. So if you are more of a story person, it may take you away from the overall big picture. At times Corsi has short snippets of someone that seems unrelated to the events in the book, but he does a good job of tying the event back in so that the reader sees the correlation. One example is Father Sampson, also known as Parachute Padre, and his involvement in the events that led to the movie Saving Private Ryan.
If you love World War II history, this is a great book to add to you collection.
On December 15, 1944 in a desperate last attempt to gain control of Europe, Adolf Hitler launched his Wacht am Rhine offensive against the town of Bastogne. The purpose of the offensive was not to win the war, but to force the Allies to come to more of a German favorable treaty. Hitler based his decision to attack on a weather pattern that developed a large snow storm over the area so that the Allies at Bastogne could not be resupplied by air nor could the air corps join in the defensive. The courageous 101st Airborne division were called in from biovac to defend the town of Bastogne. The battle continued for eleven days and at one point the Allies were completely surrounded by German troops and tanks. If not for a strong belief in God and a weather related miracle, the Battle of Bulge may have had a different ending.
I rarely read historical accounts, but this one really caught my attention. I had always heard about the battle of the bulge, but not about the miracle that the author references in the title. Jerome Corsi has done an amazing amount of research to bring this event to life on paper. He does a great job showing the chain of events that lead to the development of the battle as well as the outcome of the battle. The way he words the book takes the reader into the trenches with the front lines, into General McAuliffe’s command center, and marching alongside the troops of Patton’s 3rd army as they work to relieve Bastogne.
Parts of the book are very detailed. So if you are more of a story person, it may take you away from the overall big picture. At times Corsi has short snippets of someone that seems unrelated to the events in the book, but he does a good job of tying the event back in so that the reader sees the correlation. One example is Father Sampson, also known as Parachute Padre, and his involvement in the events that led to the movie Saving Private Ryan.
If you love World War II history, this is a great book to add to you collection.
December 6, 2014
REVIEW
I've found that not every book can be graded the same. It depends on how the reader perceives the book or how much content about the events the reader takes into account. A review is the reader's viewpoint and not every reader has the same viewpoint. Some readers can point out the positive clear facts of nonfiction historical writing. Of course the reader must take in to account that the ending of one book in not the last writing on a particular event. There are always little historical tidbits that someone may find elsewhere that should fit into the historical book you are reading about.
This book should be a keeper on the shelf of anyone who is a history, military or WWII book lover.The author wrote this book to show that our forefathers that served during this time had immense strength, faith and courage as they fought and suffered the battles, the weather elements, the loss of their comrades and being away from their family. As now in today's world,we owe such a debt to those men and women who serve in the war in many ways to protect us. To lay down their lives to keep us safe.
Hitler and his followers were evil and cruel. Mr. Corsi points out what various leaders brought to the war along with the history that was penned for future generations to read. Today's life is"instant" as life during the war wasn't. People took time to write down what they saw and shared so that it could be remembered by the future generations.
This is a trip that everyone who loves history should take with the author during this battle in December 1944 and the results. As are the battles being fought in modern day be not forgotten, neither should those back then.The author gave all of us readers much to reflect on. He gave us a book to keep for our children to pass to their children to remember those who gave up their lives for all of those living, dying and those not yet to be born into this world.
I was given a complimentary copy of NO GREATER VALOR from the author, Jerome Corsi and BookLookBloggers for my view of the book. No other compensation took place.
I've found that not every book can be graded the same. It depends on how the reader perceives the book or how much content about the events the reader takes into account. A review is the reader's viewpoint and not every reader has the same viewpoint. Some readers can point out the positive clear facts of nonfiction historical writing. Of course the reader must take in to account that the ending of one book in not the last writing on a particular event. There are always little historical tidbits that someone may find elsewhere that should fit into the historical book you are reading about.
This book should be a keeper on the shelf of anyone who is a history, military or WWII book lover.The author wrote this book to show that our forefathers that served during this time had immense strength, faith and courage as they fought and suffered the battles, the weather elements, the loss of their comrades and being away from their family. As now in today's world,we owe such a debt to those men and women who serve in the war in many ways to protect us. To lay down their lives to keep us safe.
Hitler and his followers were evil and cruel. Mr. Corsi points out what various leaders brought to the war along with the history that was penned for future generations to read. Today's life is"instant" as life during the war wasn't. People took time to write down what they saw and shared so that it could be remembered by the future generations.
This is a trip that everyone who loves history should take with the author during this battle in December 1944 and the results. As are the battles being fought in modern day be not forgotten, neither should those back then.The author gave all of us readers much to reflect on. He gave us a book to keep for our children to pass to their children to remember those who gave up their lives for all of those living, dying and those not yet to be born into this world.
I was given a complimentary copy of NO GREATER VALOR from the author, Jerome Corsi and BookLookBloggers for my view of the book. No other compensation took place.
January 31, 2015
Looking for an exciting historical read that at least acknowledges that the Lord works in the affairs of men? You will love the fast-moving story given by Jerome Corsi on the Siege of Bastogne. The action vivid, the characters real, this story comes alive in its 300 pages.
It is not, in my opinion, a Christian book. It is respectful of Christianity, though it even makes no theological distinctions between, for example, Protestant Christians and Catholics. The heroes from both (particularly chaplains) are presented glowingly, just as they should be, though the differences that will always divide are never mentioned.
What makes this volume be published by a Christian publisher (Nelson) is its recognition that God made the greatest move and the heroes of the battle are the first to admit it. Most importantly the weather, followed by fortuitous developments that were clearly beyond just good planning, and finally some smaller unexplainable events, worked together to show God’s favor.
Much is made of the prayer that Patton pushed out among the men, who clearly embraced it, and that thankfulness to God that followed the results.
The story of the incredible soldiers involved was well told too. Eisenhower listened to all sides and made the big decision. He was moved by the sometimes reckless Patton, whose unorthodox ways were made for this battle. Patton, a living paradox who was obsessed with God’s favor and prayer and yet cursed often and worked reincarnation into his Christianity, was the man of massive ego who yet pulled off the most amazing pivot northward of an army on record. General McAuliffe, the understated commander in besieged Bastogne, was a model of courageous leadership. There seemed to amazing courage, and as the title suggests, no greater valor, in every group involved.
I think you will enjoy this book. I recommend it.
I received this book free from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
It is not, in my opinion, a Christian book. It is respectful of Christianity, though it even makes no theological distinctions between, for example, Protestant Christians and Catholics. The heroes from both (particularly chaplains) are presented glowingly, just as they should be, though the differences that will always divide are never mentioned.
What makes this volume be published by a Christian publisher (Nelson) is its recognition that God made the greatest move and the heroes of the battle are the first to admit it. Most importantly the weather, followed by fortuitous developments that were clearly beyond just good planning, and finally some smaller unexplainable events, worked together to show God’s favor.
Much is made of the prayer that Patton pushed out among the men, who clearly embraced it, and that thankfulness to God that followed the results.
The story of the incredible soldiers involved was well told too. Eisenhower listened to all sides and made the big decision. He was moved by the sometimes reckless Patton, whose unorthodox ways were made for this battle. Patton, a living paradox who was obsessed with God’s favor and prayer and yet cursed often and worked reincarnation into his Christianity, was the man of massive ego who yet pulled off the most amazing pivot northward of an army on record. General McAuliffe, the understated commander in besieged Bastogne, was a model of courageous leadership. There seemed to amazing courage, and as the title suggests, no greater valor, in every group involved.
I think you will enjoy this book. I recommend it.
I received this book free from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
December 9, 2014
Source: Free copy from Book Look Bloggers, HarperCollins Christian Publishing in exchange for a review.
Summary:
The Battle of the Bulge began on Saturday, December 16, 1944. The word bulge is defined as the bulging of the German offense against the Allies. On a map it looked as if there was a bulging pattern in the German offense line. The battle ended in late January 1945. The area where the battle took place was in eastern Belgium.
No Greater Valor is a study of military faith during the defining battle. The 101st Airborne is a principle focus in the book. Brief historical sketches are given to: Major General Troy H. Middleton, Major General James M. Gavin, Father Francis L. Sampson, General George S. Patton, and General Dwight David Eisenhower.
My Thoughts:
My dad was a veteran of the Battle of the Bulge. He was captured on December 17, 1944. He and two other soldiers were able to escape. Daddy had often remarked through the years, "Annette, I am so glad I don't have to sleep outside in the cold and the snow again." He was remembering the winter of 1944-1945.
I'm more than pleased to have been able to read and review a book with the subject of the Battle of the Bulge.
No Greater Valor is a over-all picture of the battle, with its focus and intent on the faith of the American soldiers who fought during the Battle of the Bulge.
There are several interesting points brought out in the book.
How Hitler gathered the forces that were needed to launch the Battle of the Bulge offense.
The terrain of the land.
An allied field hospital taken capture.
Living conditions during the battle.
The bombings on Christmas Eve and Christmas Day.
The Bastogne mystery ghosts.
No Greater Valor is an over-all great book. I enjoyed reading a broad view of the battle, but at times I wanted a thorough study of individuals who'd had decisive roles in the war. I'm also interested in reading a book from the German viewpoint.
Summary:
The Battle of the Bulge began on Saturday, December 16, 1944. The word bulge is defined as the bulging of the German offense against the Allies. On a map it looked as if there was a bulging pattern in the German offense line. The battle ended in late January 1945. The area where the battle took place was in eastern Belgium.
No Greater Valor is a study of military faith during the defining battle. The 101st Airborne is a principle focus in the book. Brief historical sketches are given to: Major General Troy H. Middleton, Major General James M. Gavin, Father Francis L. Sampson, General George S. Patton, and General Dwight David Eisenhower.
My Thoughts:
My dad was a veteran of the Battle of the Bulge. He was captured on December 17, 1944. He and two other soldiers were able to escape. Daddy had often remarked through the years, "Annette, I am so glad I don't have to sleep outside in the cold and the snow again." He was remembering the winter of 1944-1945.
I'm more than pleased to have been able to read and review a book with the subject of the Battle of the Bulge.
No Greater Valor is a over-all picture of the battle, with its focus and intent on the faith of the American soldiers who fought during the Battle of the Bulge.
There are several interesting points brought out in the book.
How Hitler gathered the forces that were needed to launch the Battle of the Bulge offense.
The terrain of the land.
An allied field hospital taken capture.
Living conditions during the battle.
The bombings on Christmas Eve and Christmas Day.
The Bastogne mystery ghosts.
No Greater Valor is an over-all great book. I enjoyed reading a broad view of the battle, but at times I wanted a thorough study of individuals who'd had decisive roles in the war. I'm also interested in reading a book from the German viewpoint.
January 29, 2015
When the Germans wanted the American troops who were surrounded and fighting the battle of their lives to surrender, General McAuliffe had one word for them. The word was 'Nuts!' This was easily 'the most famous single word uttered by any American commander during World War 11,' according to Jerome Corsi.
General McAuliffe summarized the way that most of the Americans who fought in the famous Battle of Bastogne felt even though they were fighting in dreadful weather, suffering from lack of provisions, arms and clothes, and needed reinforcements. They had also been surprised by the several forces that Hitler had amassed - this lack of knowledge was a massive intelligence failure. Hitler's famous Wehrmacht approached the little Belgian town of Bastogne from four directions, so the Americans had their backs to the wall.
Corsi relates the story of this miracle battle in this well-researched and detailed book, using quotes from interviews and biographies to illustrate his main argument that they won primarily because of their great faith. I found the book a bit dry and heavy at times, but I don't usually read books about battles. However, it was full of interesting stories and anecdotes, such as the tales about the adventurous priest, how Patton's prayer assisted the weather, and mysterious angels.
If you like reading about the history of the Second World War, this is highly recommended.
General McAuliffe summarized the way that most of the Americans who fought in the famous Battle of Bastogne felt even though they were fighting in dreadful weather, suffering from lack of provisions, arms and clothes, and needed reinforcements. They had also been surprised by the several forces that Hitler had amassed - this lack of knowledge was a massive intelligence failure. Hitler's famous Wehrmacht approached the little Belgian town of Bastogne from four directions, so the Americans had their backs to the wall.
Corsi relates the story of this miracle battle in this well-researched and detailed book, using quotes from interviews and biographies to illustrate his main argument that they won primarily because of their great faith. I found the book a bit dry and heavy at times, but I don't usually read books about battles. However, it was full of interesting stories and anecdotes, such as the tales about the adventurous priest, how Patton's prayer assisted the weather, and mysterious angels.
If you like reading about the history of the Second World War, this is highly recommended.
January 30, 2015
How Faith and Determination Won the Battle of Bastogne
By Christmas 1944, the Allies hoped and believed that Hitler was beaten, and the war would soon be over. Then in a surprise attack in the Ardennes, Hitler amassed a large force with the intention to move through to Antwerp and cut the Allies off from their main supply lines. The Allies were unprepared, but the 101st and 82nd Airborne Corps were close by and were immediately ordered to the area to stop the advance. The heart of the battle took place around the little town of Bastogne.
Corsi recounts the battle at Bastogne that was the final turning point in the war. The Americans were rushed to the area without complete provisions, or winter clothing. However, they were determined and had faith that they would hold the line. This is best illustrated by General McAuliffe's, quote. When asked to surrender, he sent back the answer, “Nuts.”
This is a well researched book that is accessible to the average reader. I liked the inclusion of quotes and stories from the men who fought the battle and later reported on their impressions. These glimpses of the battle from a personal point of view made it come alive for me.
I highly recommend this book if you enjoy history, or if you have heard about the Battle of the Bulge and want to know more about it.
I reviewed this book for BookLook Bloggers.
By Christmas 1944, the Allies hoped and believed that Hitler was beaten, and the war would soon be over. Then in a surprise attack in the Ardennes, Hitler amassed a large force with the intention to move through to Antwerp and cut the Allies off from their main supply lines. The Allies were unprepared, but the 101st and 82nd Airborne Corps were close by and were immediately ordered to the area to stop the advance. The heart of the battle took place around the little town of Bastogne.
Corsi recounts the battle at Bastogne that was the final turning point in the war. The Americans were rushed to the area without complete provisions, or winter clothing. However, they were determined and had faith that they would hold the line. This is best illustrated by General McAuliffe's, quote. When asked to surrender, he sent back the answer, “Nuts.”
This is a well researched book that is accessible to the average reader. I liked the inclusion of quotes and stories from the men who fought the battle and later reported on their impressions. These glimpses of the battle from a personal point of view made it come alive for me.
I highly recommend this book if you enjoy history, or if you have heard about the Battle of the Bulge and want to know more about it.
I reviewed this book for BookLook Bloggers.
March 19, 2015
Imagine my excitement when I discovered a new book devoted to that most interesting topic, the Siege of Bastogne!
This new hardback by Jerome Corsi is an in-depth picture of the entire situation. Although full of details, this book is not difficult to understand. It is perfect for all interested readers, from amateur history buffs to the history professor himself!
Although I haven't read any other books on this topic, I feel that I can honestly say, this book has everything you need to know about the siege of Bastogne! I learnt so much as I read through the many chapters. I especially appreciated how this book focused on the faith of the fighting Americans during the battle. Not many books about the battles will do this, yet it is so crucial. I believe some of the best soldiers were those who had a spiritual reason to fight. And some of the bravest had to be those who put their trust in God!
This new hardback by Jerome Corsi is an in-depth picture of the entire situation. Although full of details, this book is not difficult to understand. It is perfect for all interested readers, from amateur history buffs to the history professor himself!
Although I haven't read any other books on this topic, I feel that I can honestly say, this book has everything you need to know about the siege of Bastogne! I learnt so much as I read through the many chapters. I especially appreciated how this book focused on the faith of the fighting Americans during the battle. Not many books about the battles will do this, yet it is so crucial. I believe some of the best soldiers were those who had a spiritual reason to fight. And some of the bravest had to be those who put their trust in God!
June 5, 2015
Great insight into a pivotal battle
Often we hear of people telling of exploits or heroics in battle, usually it's left to the listeners to discern for themselves how or why it turned out that way. This story is different, in that the historical facts coincide with faith of the commanders and events that led to victory. Excellent insight from a standpoint of faith.
Often we hear of people telling of exploits or heroics in battle, usually it's left to the listeners to discern for themselves how or why it turned out that way. This story is different, in that the historical facts coincide with faith of the commanders and events that led to victory. Excellent insight from a standpoint of faith.
August 24, 2021
The strength of this book is its diversity. Weaving first hand accounts with historical assessments, the author delivers a fluid narrative balanced between the command view and foxholes. He addresses health and religious beliefs along with the tactical details. The display of faith is particularly well accounted for the events leading up to the Christmas Day attack.
June 10, 2016
Very good, but the author did not need to repeat again and again several of the stories from different participants' viewpoints - at least when the basic stories were exactly the same. That was too redundant. That was too redundant.
September 11, 2016
A lesson to all Americans
For those of us who already know the relationship of this country with God, this book serves as a second witness. The lesson here must be heeded by all if we expect to survive as a nation. What a great bunch of guys at Bastogne. What a great story.
For those of us who already know the relationship of this country with God, this book serves as a second witness. The lesson here must be heeded by all if we expect to survive as a nation. What a great bunch of guys at Bastogne. What a great story.
April 25, 2016
Fascinating account showing the courage, faith and resolve of our soldiers during the Siege of Bastogne in December 1944. Well-referenced.
May 4, 2016
A well-documented and engaging account of the siege of Bastogne. An engaging book for anyone, but especially for Christians interested in World War II.
June 8, 2016
Wow! What those men endured. Outnumbered, out artilleried, out everything. And out of food, clothing, medical supplies, ammunition. Just amazing.
November 10, 2019
I love history but it is very easy to get lost in this book, unless you know a lot about military / WW2 history.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 34 reviews