✰ 3.5 stars ✰
“But you are strong, Grace O’Connell, maybe more so than any of us. And you will find a way to pick up that pain and carry it with you.”
Grace of the Empire State takes place in 1930 during the time of the Great Depression and Prohibition, when construction of the Empire State Building was underway. Amongst some of the construction workers is twenty-year-old Irish Patrick, one of their key riveters, who breaks his arm in an unfortunate accident. Unable to bear the thought that he won't be able to receive his weekly payment that is needed for his mother and sisters, he enlists the help of his twin sister, 'Life is for living' Grace, to take his place as himself, so that they won't lose the finances that their family desperately needs. 🥺
“I think what you’re doing is incredibly stupid and dangerous. And it is also the greatest act of love I’ve ever heard of.”
The protagonist, Grace, was a very resilient and kindhearted protagonist. From her movements and her talents, her love for dancing was evident; one which did help her in her fears of impersonating her brother on a job that is quite dangerous and hazardous. 'Yesterday I was scared, but I didn’t really know what I was scared of. Now I do.' 😔 But, with desperate times comes desperate measures. And knowing that if she doesn't take his place on those high beams would hurt not only her family, but impact those of her cousin and the Gagliardis, two Italian brothers that assist her and her brother in their guise, is a heavy and taxing burden.
I was a bit upset when they did emotionally manipulate her, well, coerce her into doing the job, but she rose above that burden. I liked how she matured as the story progressed - physically and emotionally and mentally. How she proved that a woman could as easily do a man's job, if not better, with her determination and faith in herself. 🙂↕️🙂↕️ She always viewed life with a carefree spirit, but seeing her slowly accept the changes in herself was cathartic and welcoming - a healing process for her, too. She learned the job and she came to do it; even with the risks and the fear of being discovered, for a lack of a choosier word - she handled it with Grace.
The author captured her emotions on stage and on the construction site vividly in a descriptive manner that it was easy to envision. I liked the variety of the job; from making mistakes to bonding with the men, to even helping out when tragedy struck. With a believable supporting cast, the dialogue, the interactions, the nature of the hard-working men and the prevalent danger of the job was captured well. 👌🏻👌🏻 I liked that Grace wasn't perfect immediately, but slowly built her strength and improved in being a valuable fill-in for Patrick. I especially liked the climax - a moment that had both her worlds collide in a way that demanded her utmost patience and courage. It was an impactful scene that was both exhilarating and intense. 😦
“What am I meant to do?” she asked the universe...”
I also appreciated how the author touched upon the class difference between men and women and the social discrimination that prevented women who were in financial struggles to find feasible, if not beneficial opportunities to earn their keep, thus, leading to having them subject their bodies to cruel injustice with tragic results. 💔💔 'You worry for everyone all the time and you still think you should have done more?' It is unique in the way we do get two sides of the fence - marrying for money, or having family money, to those destitute and alone who have to rely on themselves to make ends meet. Her former fellow dancers were depicted in a way that shed light on how they made decisions based on necessity, in whatever capacity they sought fit.
It was heart-wrenching, but sadly quite true of the time. Grace's kindness for her friends was both her strength and her weakness; how she took it upon herself to be as gracious and helpful was heartbreaking, especially when she failed to help those she truly cared about. ❤️🩹❤️🩹 'The Lord never gives you more than you can manage.' It is that stark reminder that was mirrored in the way she felt grateful to work under the false guise of being a man that made her realize how important it was for her to find a place - for herself, as herself. 💃🏻
“The weight is your love for them that has nowhere else to go.”
I liked how Grace and Joe's budding romance developed. It was nice to see how he warmed up to her and how she behaved with him on the work site - even when it drew unwarranted attention - she was posing as a guy, after all! - but still grew to respect and care for him. 🥰 "It is a difficult thing to ask of someone, to understand and to accept.' I did feel though that the Patrick perspectives affected the storyline in a negative way, with a romance that could have done without, but, oh well. I understand how it was necessary to show how his own life was impacted by his accident, but it did not hold much weight to it and drew me out of Grace's own self-growth. I also felt that there was a certain moment in the middle of the story that entered a slight lull; as in the plot seemed to be at a standstill with then suddenly an onslaught of crisis happening on top of the other. 😕
Despite these few hindrances it was still a promising, and heartfelt debut. I do love the cover that perfectly captures the high-rise at which Grace found herself working for nearly a month, as well as how at ease she is at taking risks. 😟 She learned and grew from her experiences, thus making the ending feel that more realistic in teaching her the ways to be better and treat herself better, too. 'The mixture of her new strength and the adrenaline coursing through her made her steps effortless.' The writing had a wholesome yet informative vibe to it and a heartfelt familial feel to it that made me appreciate how Grace's story concluded.
I also felt good reading about how much care and hard work was taken into building a structure that has withstood the test of time, especially when written with this slight twist of a woman supposedly doing a man's job. The Empire State Building, 'a beacon of hope for the struggling city' has a history of its own that reminds you that it was not as easy to construct buildings as it is now to 'gift this view to the world'; dedication and craftsmanship, as well as the combined effort of hearts and souls went into it that as the author reminded should not be forgotten. 🏗️🙏🏻
*Thank you to Edelweiss for a DRC in exchange for an honest review.