This is a spoiler free review aimed at you, a person who stumbled across this by chance and is eyeballing reviews trying to decide whether or not to make a purchase. As you can guess from my five star review, I am a fan. But that doesn’t mean I think this book is for you. I mean, it could be REALLY REALLY for you, but it also might be not for you at all, and I would like to help you figure out where you might fall on this.
This is definitely a horror book, but I’m going to try to narrow down what that means. There is variety in the stories, some are science fiction, some feel like lost Tales from the Crypt episodes, some are essentially tragedies, etc, but Mendoza largely likes to operate within a gothic atmospheric sphere. I’ve observed recently a growing trend of associating the gothic with ideas like “safe” and “cozy” horror (which I think is a consequence of people who aren’t actually familiar with these texts beyond a vague misconcept of their aesthetic and readers who don’t grasp the full implications of these texts but that’s beside the point), so it necessary to note that this book regularly crosses lines that horror marketed as extreme ultraviolent schlock will not dare touch. See, if your whole thing is being super edgy, then you end up having to walk a tightrope where you break a lot of pseudo-boundaries so that your fanbase will think you are the most extreme person on the planet, while also making sure not to write anything that could actually lose people in your demographic. Mendoza is not playing that game. She does not write so that we will be in awe of how hardcore she is, which means that when she comes up with a story that crosses a line she weirdly has more freedom to just cross it. And she does.
This is the author’s second short story collection. The first is Salivation, the theme tying it together is hunger/loneliness. Worth a read, but if female centric horror is more directly aligned with your interests, I would recommend picking up Yellow Wallpapering first. This book is entirely about women. My favorite two stories are Wet Dog and Snakegirl and BangBang. I’m having a hard time picking a third favorite because it turns into trying to pick between my ladies. I feel these women, I am running my hands all over their faces. You may think to yourself “oh god, I’ve met her,” or even “oh god, I am her,” when you meet these characters. They’re all so specific and so real.
Reading this book is at times a physical experience. Snakegirl and BangBang in particular messed with my breathing, and if you do ultimately read this, you’ll find that thematically appropriate. Which is why I am so into this book. I have a very strong stomach, it is hard to get to me, so I see anything that forces a physical reaction from me as indicative of great skill.
So yeah, I hope this was even slightly helpful in your attempt to figure out if this book is your thing. Have a nice day!